he floated the idea of getting us out of that group. but tonight, a reassuring message. if we stand together, we are safe. a show of unity from nato leaders, that is what takes us off the air this evening. and on that good note, i wish you a good night. from all of our colleagues across the networks of nbc news thank you for staying up late with us. i will see you at the end of tomorrow. tomorrow you tonight from warsaw, poland where president biden will be arriving tomorrow after attending nato summit in brussels. now the very first nato summit was a 1957. nato had been formed eight years earlier but there had never been a nato summit. a meeting of all the leaders of the nato countries.

that is going to be a major world event. it was a dozen years after world war ii, amid the increasing competition between the west and the soviet union. nato countries were gathered in paris to reaffirm their unity. the undisputed leader of the alliance was president dwight eisenhower, not because he was the american president, after being the commander of allied forces in europe during world war ii, but before he was elected president, eisenhower became the first supreme allied commander of nato. when president eisenhower almost didn't make it to the summit, because just a few weeks before the summit was due to start, this happened. >> illness stocks the chief executive as he stands in the chill autumn air. a chill sensitive to bed. a bear aboard serious news. the following deer that, america hears the -- physician, learns that the

president has suffered a mild stroke, resulting in a speech impairment. secretary dallas and other government leaders including defense terry mcelroy, hundreds of the white house. the press secretary issues bulletins. vice president nixon sums up the situation. >> we expect that the president, after a period of recuperation, will be able to return to his desk in the white house. and that he will, as the factors indicated, fully recover. >> president eisenhower had already had a heart attack in office two years earlier. now, this mini stroke. there were concerns that he might not be up to the regular duties of office, let alone a grueling transatlantic trip to meet with 14 other world leaders. the new york times published this cartoon depicting eisenhower as atlas, carrying both the problems of his office, and, questionable health on his back, while trudging uphill

marked, course of world events. the times worried that going to the nato summit would be, quote, a two gallant gesture that may bring on another siege of illness. but i did go to pairs, arriving at the nato summit all smiles, just three weeks after his health scare. and the other nato leaders were so demonstrably relieved that he made, and that eisenhower started his opening remarks at the summit thanking them all for their well wishes. >> mister president, my nato friends, before i begin my i would like to express my appreciation of the overgenerosity meant that has been expressed by president belt and by the prime minister of france, respecting my health. and particularly, i appreciate your wishes for my good health.

>> and so the very first nato summit ever began. the first of nearly 30 nato summits that have taken place in the decades since. and nato's membership at that time has doubled. in 1957, there were 15 nato countries. now, there are 30. so, at today's nato summit in brussels, they needed a much bigger table the further meeting than they did before. but the central mission of today's summit is basically the same as that very first one 65 years ago. reaffirming nato's unity and solidarity. but this time, in the face of the biggest crisis nato has faced in decades. today, the u.s. and its european partners continue to increase the pressure on russia over its invasion of ukraine. announcing new sanctions on russian political leaders and defense companies. but biden told reporters today that it's not any particular new sanctions that is going to stop vladimir putin. he said it's the u.s., and its

allies, maintaining the pressure for as long as it takes. >> i'll say the most important fading, it's for us to stay unified, and the world continue to focus on water brooch this guy is and of all the innocent lives being lost and ruined, and what's going on. that's the important thing. but look, if you are putin, and you think that europe is going to crack in the months or six weeks, for two months, why not -- they can take anything for another month, but we have to demonstrate, the reason i asked for the meeting, we have to stay fully totally, thoroughly united. tomorrow, biden will come here to poland on nato's eastern edge on the front line of the ukraine crisis. over 2 million ukrainian refugees have fled here, to pull in, since russia's invasion began, before coming to warsaw, president biden will

meet the polish president in a town just 15 miles away from the ukrainian border while he will receive a briefing on the humanitarian response. biden hinted in his remarks today that he may personally meet with some ukrainian refugees. the u.s. also announced today that it will accept 100,000 ukrainian refugees. though that obviously pales in comparison to the numbers that poland and its neighbors are taking in. and what those refugees are fleeing remains truly hellish. a month into this invasion, this new footage from the eastern city of mariupol's shows seemingly endless lines of representatives lined up for humanitarian aid with the bombed-out cityscape behind them. ukrainian officials say 100,000 people remain in mariupol, cut off. no food, no water. as nbc news chief course pond it richard angles reports tonight, the brutality on display in places like measurable maybe partly a

result of increasing russian desperation. >> russia has by now all but flattened mariupol. new images released by officials in mariupol show the once thriving port city has been devastated by russian bombs. u.s. military officials say russia is now concentrating its assault on the east and ukraine, around mary-able, close to the russian border. russia has began to resupply its troops there. russian television showing the arrival of a landing ship in a port on the sea of azov, with fighting vehicles and loaded and ready for battle. today, russia's plans took a turn. the ship was in flames. ukrainian forces claim they destroyed it this morning, and damage to other russian vessels. russia's new focus on the east maybe out of duress. ukrainian forces are making advances around kyiv, pushing back russian troops from the capital.

>> we will have more in just a few minutes on those reports of ukrainian forces who are gaining ground, particularly around kyiv. but whatever the reason, there is no doubt that vladimir putin's tactics and ukraine are getting more brutal, and more deadly. addressing today's nato summit remotely, ukrainian president zelenskyy claim that russia has dropped phosphorus bombs on civilians, killing children. wide force versus highly toxic, and causes severe burns if it comes in contact with human flesh. there was no way to verify zelenskyy's claim, but hanging over two days nato summit was the fear of what putin might do next. particularly if he feels like he's losing this. for president biden and european leaders warned russia sharply against using chemical weapons, though they did not specify what their response would be if it does. joining us live now from lviv is nbc news correspondent cal perry. good evening, kyle. president zelenskyy's been asking western countries for military aid, he's been asking

for a fighter jets, he's been asking for a no-fly zone. he's renewed those calls today in an address to nato. what kind of response is he hoping to get from them? >> so, in the way he framed this was he approached from the russian point of view. he said to the nato countries, russia is attacking us, especially in the east, with unlimited firepower. so when i ask of you, he said, is unlimited response. unlimited military assistance. and that phrase, unlimited to military assistance, is code for what you said, no-fly zone and jets. the jets are a logistical nightmare to begin. with the jets in poland, we've heard recently the polish government saying that they will transfer them to the united states, in ramstein, germany, and then they will make it. here at the bottom line is, no nato country wants to be seen directly supporting the war effort. directly transferring things like jets. so they are looking for a

middleman, a way to do. that the problem, is no country wants to step. of the u.s. doesn't want to transfer these debts. maxlength=32> problem is the pilots. the same goes for the no-fly zone. according to the secretary general of nato, -- that's kind of the sticking point right now, ali. >> let's talk about people not wanting to do things directly, or at least some of the governments not wanting to do things directly that would seem like they're getting involved in a war with ukraine. you saw some folks today in the v, who you and i talked to on the show, the volunteers called the blue and yellow. they transfer critical supplies from supportive neighboring country to ukraine. they've been doing what they have been doing for since 2014, since the syrian refugee crisis. but did you hear? >> this is a group that was put together by a man named jonas and his friends. they're kind of a ragtag group of friends who have been doing this, as you, said since the

invasion of crimea, in 2014. it is only since this recent invasion, a month ago, where they have seen an influx of money. 16 million euros that they got in just a month. and there you see it on the left side of the screen, this was this morning that even the parking lot, just right behind me outside of a church in broad daylight. hundreds of flat jackets, scopes for sniper rifles, drones that they say they're going to, quote, used to draw presence on the russians. that's code for explosives. as well as anti-joan jamming equipment. especially here in the eastern part of the country, i was a unaware that yet russians are using drones in the western part of the country, and these anti-drones are what is needed. there's also an american -- there he is. there is an american among the group who came over because he saw that there was some action from nbc, and he wanted to be a part of. and i asked him how did he get, there how did that process work. here's a little bit of that exchange. >> how did you get linked up with this group?

>> i just flew from the throughway nia, the first, thing i just went through the ukrainian embassy. >> embassy? >> lithuania. my parents live there, so -- i just asked, which organization they trust most. because i brought some money here. i said -- they said blue and yellow. so the first, day first day i was working in the warehouse, next day -- here i am. there you are. three days later, i'm here. that's my second trip here now. yeah. >> so for countries like lithuania who, very much live in fear of some kind of russian response to their support, they are using these middlemen, these middle groups, these ngos, to get this here in the country. they took the stuff right out of lithuania, ali. they put it in vents, they drove it across poland, they got here this morning. that stuff is all headed to the east where we see these horrendous, horrendous videos,

ali. >> i had a chance to meet joe not. thanks kelly, for clarifying, i mentioned that they started because of the syrian refugee crisis. you're, right it's because of the russian invasion of crimea. i appreciate that. it's late for you in lviv, my friend, stay safe. as always, my friend cal perry, stay safe. michael mcfaul, he served as the u.s. ambassador for russia under president obama, ambassador mcfaul, thank you for joining us tonight. it is unbelievable, because we speak so regularly about this, russia is one month into this war. at this point, ukraine has reclaimed some important ground that russia had taken. you had said that you expected a robust response from ukrainian military. but it is impressive with the military, along with the civil defense, the territorial defense, has been able to do in a month despite what we are seeing from russia.

>> yes, ali. i did. but never did i expect that they would be this far along a month into the war. it is incredible, it's heroic what they've done. they are being -- they are using unconventional tactics to do what they can, with the limited weapons that they have. and i think it's fantastic what they have done. the fight putin's army to the stands that they have been lots of the country. and at the same time, i think our viewers need to understand, this war is only one month into it. wars can go on for years. the russians still have 90% of their forces available. but they are doing, barbaric, lee against mary opal is atrocious to watch, but that city is about to fall. as a looks like to me. and that's what the ukrainians are worried about as well. so i think we really need to listen to president zelenskyy today, when he said, to the nato allies, thank you for what you've done in the past, and now you have to do more to help

us fight this putin's army. that has invaded our country. this war is far from being over. >> so there are few elements to what the world can do to help ukraine. but in that address you just referred to, to nato, of a lot of mayor zelenskyy asked the allies for planes. he said, you can give us 1% of all your planes, 1% of all your tanks, 1%. and then he continued to say, quote, you have thousands of fighter jets, but we have not been given one yet. you've advocated -- you yourself, ambassador, have advocated for giving ukrainians more weaponry. so what considerations are they taking into consideration with they're making that decision at nato? >> they're worried about escalation, particularly about the plains, there was an intelligence assessment by the u.s. that it would be escalatory to transfer the make 29, from where you are now. and ali, don't forget, there are 27 make 20 nines in poland,

according to ukrainian government, there's 70 in the nato alliance three different countries. so they desperately want those planes. and they are worried about the fall of kyiv. they're worried that while we are watching with mariupol today will be kyiv tomorrow. that's why zelenskyy singled out those planes. and, you know, i know these he says, we cannot enforce a no fly zone. that is a declaration of war against russia. the ukrainians desperately need i think he's right about that. more of to defend the skies. it's a distinction without a i have a harder time understanding what's the difference between a javelin and a mig 29. or an s-300s system, that's a surface to air missile system, a russian-made system, that the ukrainians desperately need more of to defend the skies.

it's a distinction without a difference. but of course, the pentagon has a different view, and so far they steadfast with that. they do want to send the planes into ukraine. >> ambassador thank you again he is the former united states ambassador to russia. we appreciate your time as always. well u.s. officials now say that some of russia's persuasion missiles are failing. 60% of the time ukrainian forces push forward to take back some of the territory they lost. it might not be that. simple one of the reporters who just back from the frontlines joins me after this. ♪ ♪ ♪ ♪ ♪ ♪ ♪ ♪ ♪ ♪

how not to be a hero: because that's the last thing they need you to be. you don't have to save the day. you just have to navigate the world so that a foster child isn't doing it solo. you just have to stand up for a kid who isn't fluent in bureaucracy, or maybe not in their own emotions. so show up, however you can, peoples lives as much as for the foster kids who need it most— at helpfosterchildren.com

possible. their houses, roads, bridges factories. end quote. hours after that interview was published russia bombed one of the main bridges between kyiv and the city to its northeast. over the weekend, russian bombed one of europe's largest iron and steel factories in the ukrainian port city of mariupol. as for the rest of mary opal russian forces there have stopped advancing traditionally. instead they are leveling the city from afar.

they're starving out the civilian population, denying them access to medical, and humanitarian supplies. russia is quite literally destroying ukrainian, quote, houses, roads, bridges and factories. end quote. on monday, the same russian tabloid newspaper around an article saying that nearly 10,000 russian troops had been killed in ukraine. within hours the article had been taken down the site published an advisory saying it had been hacked. and the story was a fake. but keep in mind. 10,000 soldiers as much higher than the russian government's last public announcements three weeks ago. which only mention the loss of 498 troops. nato's estimate is even higher than america's. it says up to 40,000 russian troops are killed, wounded, captured or missing an action. if any of these non russian estimates are correct.

it's gonna be hard to continue to keep that for the russian people given the images like this one. this is a funeral. for the deputy commander of russia's black sea fleet yesterday in crimea. the funeral is for just one of the dozens of high-level russian officers that ukraine claims they have killed so far. ukraine also claims to have killed six russian generals. which is basically unheard of in modern warfare. at some point no matter how much the russian government tries to control the narrative. the russian people are gonna start noticing just how many military funerals of their are. how many people they know who've lost loved ones especially given the victories that are continuing to see from ukrainian forces. meanwhile the war also veers to be taking a toll on those and putin's government. yesterday we saw the highest level resignation from the russian government so far in the war in ukraine. putin's climate adviser resigned and fled the country.

officials had been a prime in economic reform are in the country had been serving in top assistance for decades. now the russian press in the russian press, he was expected in the spirit very quickly. the russian foreign minister spokeswoman saying that the climate adviser left it would be lucky. and today the russian defense minister made his first public appearance in 12 days. for a total of 11 seconds you can see him in the corner of this video call with putin and his security council. there was a widely publicized 11 seconds hoping to quell mounting rumors about his conspicuous absence in the aftermath of this failed invasion of ukraine. russia has shuttered the last of their independent press. it is crime down on people trying to spread the truth by a social media. and is jailing people who are protesting the war. heck, it's jailing people who use the word war to describe. jailing people for telling the

truth. the truth is playing catch-up. joining us now is joshua yaffa correspondent for the new yorker. based primarily in moscow. he wasn't ukraine the moment russia bonn started dropping. he's on some incredibly reporting from their sense. he's also the author between two fires, truth, ambition and compromise in putin's russia. joshua, thanks for joining us. we appreciate it. i want to get a sense of, given you've been inside ukraine and then to russia. jim has a very tight grip on power in russia. does it matter if russia's in the learn the truth and turn against him? would actually change something for vladimir putin's reality? >> i think it certainly would change something for vladimir putin's reality. if as you say russian citizens on matt -- were to learn the truth of this war. whether the degree of description of ukrainian cities -- that something not talked about in russia intelligent.

it continues to be called a special military operations in official channels. if you look at polling, many russians believe that this is a limited military engagement to the east of the country. the donbas region. and people aren't aware that kyiv is being bombed. kharkiv is being. bombed -- terrible pictures of how city that is. many people don't know that. so, if russians were to learn indeed the war that's being -- what it looks. like the ugliness of war. i think many of them would be surprised if not shocked at how widespread the violence is against ukrainian citizen. and i think of course equally impactful could be the knowledge of how many russian soldiers are being killed in this war. this estimate of 10,000 that we saw published in the moscow paper. the other day before it was quickly retracted. the question is will they. now what the effect will be. but will they even learn of that information. and that is a bigger question. so far since the beginning of the war in the month.

since the war began. a month. today i'm number -- nearly all of the nearly independent opposition minded but any independent non state run, non state controlled sources of information in russia have been blocked. shuttered. it's journalist forced to leave the country. websites taken down or blocked access them. even social media, facebook blocked, instagram blocked, so where will russian get that information from. that's a tricky question. there are of course vpns people using them but not everyone has that kind of technical ability. russia government regulators are also trying to go after vpn operators. it's a cat-and-mouse game. but people left with not that many sources where they can find out that sort of information. and i think the reason that the kremlin is being so diligent and going after the sources of information and making sure that russians don't have access to them is because they know

that if en masse, if russians were to learn the truth of the it could be very destabilizing. i'm not sure that that turn of events will come anytime soon given the kremlin's control over the social, critical, and medias fears. they may well succeed from preventing misinformation from spreading worldwide. >> you mentioned the vpn. i was gonna ask you about that? can people get around the information in russia? for the last month or so you've been driving around ukraine. place to place and getting a sense of how this has evolved. you've really seen it evolve. in realtime. what's your take away? >> well i was shocked as anyone on the morning of february 24th when i woke up in my hotel room in -- in eastern ukraine in the donbas to the sound of explosions the first missiles hit -- kyiv, kharkiv and so many other

cities across ukraine. and from the very first moments we saw the scale and scope of this war. and it was clear that putin was going for regime change. you look in a strike the capital change of kyiv. -- remove president zelenskyy from power. and install pro russian government. it was the aim in the first hours and days of the war. and what we've seen since then is how the war plans clearly did not go as putin and his top officials you mentioned defense minister sergei shoigu who's been missing for sometime. in from the russian scene for some days now. clearly this plan that putin and other officials hooked up to, according to their initial estimation. kyiv didn't fall. zelenskyy himself didn't flee the capitol. military put up a great heroic fight. continues to. and ukrainian society really galvanized together. and that ultimately is the biggest takeaway. >> joshua thank you for your great reporting on this.

joshua yaffa moscow correspondent for the new yorker. thank you for your time tonight. >> thank you. >> of course josh was an outside of ukraine right now. when we come back when i speak to someone inside ukraine who's literally on the front lines of the battle.

>> it's been a grueling month since russia began its invasion of ukraine, but it's failed to take the capital kyiv, or building among tim across the country.

that's because ukraine has launched a ferocious counter offensive like this one today at a seaport in berdyansk. ukrainian forces say it's sunk a russian warship in the occupied port. you can see the flames and smoke. an attack like this can be even harder for russia to get supplies and troops to critical areas. kharkiv, ukraine's second largest city, has been under attack by russian forces for weeks, but so, far they have repelled their bets. the city of mykolaiv has also taken heavy losses as it holds off russia's attempt to seize it. but a senior u.s. official says that ukrainian forces have not only kept russian ships were making progress, they force them to reposition around the city. and because of stories like this, it was hard not to be encouraged when the mayor of kyiv told reporters that ukrainian forces had retaken in the suburb of makariv. my next guest, a correspondent at large for the washington post, learned that the

situation on the ground is not as clear as with the mayor stated. here's what he wrote in a piece for the washington post. quote, as a team of washington post journalist passed through the checkpoint on wednesday, ukrainian soldiers ordered them to quickly leave the town, warning of incoming russian rockets or artillery. minutes later, reporters heard the sound of shells falling. black plumes of smoke rose over the houses. soon, more blasts followed. mccarthy remains a contested front line, and quote. joining us now is the author of that story, said rug up. devoun thank you for being with us tonight. give us the nuance of this because for those who have not spent time in a city that's under conflict or war zone, how do these things look when the russians say they've taken, it then the ukrainians say they've taken it back -- it's blurry. it's not like an old-fashioned frontline. >> not at all, especially in

disinformation age. but we really see here is two different wars happening. they're intertwined wars happening in ukraine. one is on the battlefield, one is an information war and would happened there exemplifies these two different wars. but you have his, the fog of war, known as a propaganda campaign, both sides have made information hard to come by. journalists are finding it increasingly difficult to reach areas outside the capital, to verify facts, bombardments, shifting front lines, a lack of clarity over the russian military positions. so oftentimes, you're relying on statements from ukrainian officials as what happened with makariv in tuesday. the defense ministry claimed the town had been liberated from russian forces, and ukrainian forces planted of, a ukrainian flag, on top of the town. we went next day to check it out, and as you read in the article, we found that it was

anything but liberated. in fact, the mayor himself told us that this was just a bunch of nonsense. and in fact, the russians were still in control of nearly 15% of the town. and it's been like that for the past three weeks. so there are tit-for-tat battles just like what you are seeing in other parts of ukraine, especially the north of here, but the russians definitely have not liberated by any means in this town. >> when you talk about irpin, or places like that, what does taken or liberated even mean? how does that get determined? we definitely hear about flags being flown. that of course is the age-old way in which you claim a land that wasn't otherwise under your control. but what does it mean in these towns? do things keep working? does the city council changed allegiances? what happens when the russians take territory? >> it's a very chaotic

situation, still. there are people -- even less -- people are still evacuating from these areas, even as these claims of liberation take place. they're still fighting, they're still shelling going on. and mockery, the russian tanks positioned right outside of the town shelling it. so it's a very chaotic situation. the mayor of this town, his main job is to go around, today, and try to feed people, try to deal with people who are -- who have lost their homes from shelling. many of which, we are told, are held in a hospital, inside the town, and that hospital is being shelled as well. the mayor has to deal with all these extremely chaotic situations through -- wants to preserve the lives of his residents, in some cases try to get them out. and for those who don't want to leave, and stick it, out he has to find ways to help them deal with electricity shortages, water shortages, gas, and all the other necessities of life.

>> what sudarsan raghavan, we are grateful for people like you who are there to report so that the rest of us can see. this sudarsan raghavan is a reporter at large for the washington post. thank you, as always, for your time, sir. >> thank you, ali. >> pat zidane biden said that the united states and nato would absolutely respond if russia used chemical weapons in ukraine. that response has likely been drawn up of -- national security experts called the tiger team. one of the reporters who broke that story joins us live next. at liberty butchemel— cut. liberty biberty— cut. liberty mutual customizes your car insurance so you only pay for whatchya... line? need. action. cut. you can't say that. [phone rings] sorry. is this where they're gonna put the statue of liberty? liberty... are we married to mutual?

cut. only pay for what you need. ♪ liberty. liberty. liberty. liberty. ♪ why do people who live with generalized myasthenia gravis want a new treatment option? because we want to be able to get up and get ready for work. because the animals need to be cared for, and we like taking care of them. because we want to go out to dinner with our friends. because, in family photos, we want to be able to smile. a new fda-approved treatment for adults with generalized myasthenia gravis could help them do more of the daily activities they care about. to learn more, go to now4gmg.com and talk to your neurologist. [yawn] bro trip! if you book with priceline, you'll save more, so you can “broooo” more. [impressed] broooooo. broooo!!!! broooo!!!! broooo!!!! [in unison] brooooooooo!!!!

[splash] [disappointed] broooo... good thing you saved on the trip! priceline. every trip is a big deal. we want to survive.

just survive. as any nation, i believe we have the right to live. today, they use phosphorus bombs.

russian force for his bonds. they killed more adults and more children. [end of translation] >> that was ukrainian president volodymyr zelenskyy in an address to nato today accusing the russians of using phosphorus bombs against ukrainians. nbc news has not independently verified this claim, and the pentagon says it's not verified it either, but when used against people, phosphorus bombs are a horrific weapon. they can reach temperatures high enough to melt metal. you can imagine the devastating effect phosphorus bombs would have on the human body. international chemical weapons treaties do not ban all uses of phosphorus on the battlefield, they can be used, for instance, to create smokescreens. and it has been used by many countries, including the united states, and iraq. however, it is illegal when used against human targets. as it, is russia's attacks on civilians and ukraine have already proved to be devastating, but if zelenskyy's accusation about phosphorus

bombs proves to be true, it will represent an escalation in the types of deadly weapons that russia is willing to use and it's brutal invasion of ukraine. and the new york times is now reporting that the biden administration is preparing contingency plans for what to do if russia decides to draw upon some of the most deadly weapons in its arsenal. a special group of experts known as the tiger team have reportedly been assembled in the white house, mapping out how the united states and its allies should respond to a chemical, biological, or nuclear attack by russia inside of ukraine. a senior administration official confirmed the existence of the tiger team to nbc news and says that the team is preparing contingencies of various scenarios. including russia's use of chemical weapons. all of that is increasing concern, as many fear vladimir putin may take more reckless and drastic actions as this invasion drags on more slowly than he expected.

as the new york times notes, quote, just a month ago, such scenario seemed more theoretical. but today, from the white house to nato's headquarters in brussels, a recognition has it in a russia has turned may turn the most powerful weapons in his arsenal to bail itself out of a military stalemate. today, president biden was asked, directly, about what a u.s. response to a russian chemical weapons attack would look like. >> if chemical weapons were used in ukraine, would that trigger a military response from nato? >> it would trigger a response and kind. whether or not you're asking whether nato would cross -- would make that decision at the time. >> joining us now is one of the reporters who broke the story of the white house tiger team. eric schmidt is a senior writer covering terrorism and national security for the new york times. eric, thanks for joining us. we are talking about the use of

chemical weapons, let's put aside nuclear weapons per second, because there is a long established thinking on what to do in that instance. but we are talking about chemical weapons as if it's a red line. the u.s. seems to not be drawing red lines at the moment because once you say there is a red line and someone crosses, it you're compelled to do something about it. but isn't your sense that their use in chemical or biological weapons against the ukrainian people will constitute a red line to which the united states and nato would have to respond? >> certainly, ali, that was the warning that president biden seemed to indicate today in brussels, that there were weapons used like that against civilians in the campaign, there would be some sort of consequences. the president obviously was deliberately vague and what those consequences would be since he's already vowed that u.s. military would not be directly involved in the ukraine crisis. but as you said, the tiger team, this group of specialists, have

been looking at scenarios, it could possibly draw american forces in under certain scenarios. >> eric, what's different about the tiger team compared to what is already in effect with respect to countries that are in a conflict that have non conventional weapons or weapons that would perhaps be unduly adverse to civilian populations and non-combatants? >> the tiger team is basically a team of specialists, and this goes many different national security crisis, when you pull together a group of specialists across the government who can look at a range of options from the president, so not having to deal in a crisis situation, and you haven't thought of some of these things in advance. so these individuals are looking at various scenarios, looking at a range of different chemical weapons. what happens if one of them is logged in not only inside ukraine but something goes awry

in the neighboring coal trees, is that an accidental or deliberate strike? those are important questions to think about in advance and think about those options and discuss them with allies. president putin, of course, has threatened to use chemical weapons and, while the united states hasn't seen any indications yet that that's being played anytime soon, russia has been operating in syria been using chemical weapons there. sometimes using chlorine, so you have to take these kinds of threats seriously in the u.s. government. >> >> of course this becomes real to countries like poland, where if there was a russian attack on a military base 15 miles from the polish border, what it was conventional met rapidly. it was not military based, that becomes very real. i want to get your response to volodymyr zelenskyy talking about phosphorus bombs.

not something that people think about a, lot they are used for military purposes, but if used against civilian populations, or non combatants. that of course becomes in illegal thing. what are you hearing about the use of phosphorus bombs? >> clearly as you indicated, this would be an escalation of the kind of weaponry that is already being used. the horrific weaponry that russia has used in ukraine. the pentagon has not been able to confirm that used yet. clearly, if this were to be something that the military was able to confirm, i would think that at the very least, the u. s. would help to guide intelligence to ukrainian forces, so that they can, on their own perhaps, attack the source of this weaponry. whatever kind of bombs, or artillery shells, or other delivery systems that they are. using after, that if they were to escalate beyond, that that is again, what's the scenarios that the team of specialists is looking. at the kind of weapons that are being described. >> eric, thank you for your great reporting on you. he is a senior writer covering terrorism and national security for the new york times.

coming up, next we're going to take you inside of a convention center here in warsaw, that has been converted to house thousands of refugees that have fled ukraine. right after this break. ...so that no one knows i'm secretly terrified inside. inner voice (sneaker shop owner): i'm using hand gestures and pointing... ...so no one can tell i'm unsure about my business finances. inner voice (furniture maker): i'm constantly nodding... ...because i know everything about furniture... ...but with the business side... ...i'm feeling a little lost. quickbooks can help. an easy way to get paid, pay your staff and know new business? no problem. yeah. success starts with intuit quickbooks.

yeah. when you're driving a lincoln, stress seems to evaporate into thin air. which leaves us to wonder, where does it go? does it shoot off like a rocket? or float off into the clouds? daddy! more than 3.6 million refugees

or maybe it takes on a life all its own. perhaps you'll come up with your own theory of where the stress goes. behind the wheel of a lincoln is a mighty fine place to start.

have fled ukraine. the number includes more than 2. 1 million refugees who have fled here to poland. today, we got a somber assessment about the number of children in ukraine, who have had to flee their homes. unicef announced today that more than half of ukraine's children, a staggering 4. 3 million children, have been displaced. one month into the war. with that humanitarian crisis worsening by the minute, president biden today in brussels announced the u.s. will accept up to 100,000 refugees from ukraine, with a focus on reuniting displaced ukrainians with family in the

united states. he also announced that the u. s. will donate almost 1 million dollars to help european countries, hit -- a city that has already accepted about three times more refugees than the u.s. is a planning to take. the regional government has staked up to take care of its share of these huge rush of people. >> the sea of cots at the warsaw convention center may look familiar, but the scenes that follow hurricanes, floods, and fires. this disaster is entirely man-made, and the people sheltering here may not have the chance to rebuild their homes. >> we came here two days ago, because we need help. we didn't know what to do, and how to -- we are trying to find a house in the uk. we don't have anything in the uk. just people that are willing to help. us >> she is just 15. she is here with her mother, alongside 6000 other refugees

here on this day. most don't have a plan. to help, the regional government has turned this massive convention center into a safe haven for up to 20,000 people. many arrive sick, so there is megan medical care on-site. >> obviously, that most of the people coming here, our women and children, then we have a gynecologist office. for pregnant women, we can do diagnostics. and we can even give birth here. which we have already done a couple of times. >> despite warsaw being the biggest center that receives refugees from ukraine, where you won't see anywhere around the city are tense, or temporary housing. a number of refugees are going to a stadium where they can spend some time. they're generally then sent to a hospital, or some sort of temporary accommodation. after a few, days they end up in private accommodation hosted by polls. or they leave for other european cities. many of the cities can be

reached with the help of a temporary bus tournament set up outside of the convention hall. about 1000 people leave every day, as thousands more pour in. some who arrive here, like event herman. they hope to get as far away as possible. >> even russia wants to invade poland. that is horrifying. we are right here. we see a lot of buses, people are going in very different countries in europe, like italy, everywhere. anywhere that they can get, just to escape all of. this >> that is just one center in one city in poland, which has shouldered more of the refugee borden than any country so far. that does it for us tonight, we'll see you here again tomorrow. >> tonight, one month of war.

president biden in brussels with nato allies. warning of chemical weapons are deployed, the west will respond. the evidence of widespread destruction grows. images of ukraine attacking a russian warship, and the city of mariupol flattened by putin 's military. plus, the stunning new reporting tonight, texts between justice clarence thomas 's wife and mark meadows. she was pushing to overturn the election while trump vowed to take his fight to the supreme court. as the 11th hour gets underway on this thursday night. good evening, once again, i am stephanie ruhle. the russian invasion of ukraine's entering its 30th day, marking the beginning of a second month of war. today, as russia continued attacking ukraine cities, and ukrainian forces fought back, president biden was at an emergency summit in brussels,