tv Velshi MSNBC August 14, 2022 5:00am-6:00am PDT
5:00 am
thanks for watching the katie phang show. you can watch original episodes on msnbc on peacock, every thursday and friday. don't forget to follow the show on twitter instagram and tiktok. adam velshi is next. how >> good morning, it is sunday august 14th. on adam velshi, another new day and detail in the anti-democratic story of donald trump. like so much of his story, this part is littered with lies. let's circle back to last summer, where the national archives records administration relied, left office an improperly took scores of documents and items, all of which of the property of the united states. federal agents descended in mar-a-lago, and collect with the former president and he people said, was all he had.
5:01 am
15 boxes worth of documents and other boxes, in those documents, there were love letters, that he would exchange with north korea's jim kong own. turns out the former president and the people were less than forthcoming about that being all the classified documents with which he absconded to his tropical golf resort. we know this because nbc news has learned, somewhat familiar with the materials inside mar-a-lago, told investigators that there were more classified documents, squirrel the way at the golf resort. and the spring, trump received a federal grand jury subpoena to turn over the rest of what he had in his mar-a-lago forward. on june 3rd, a team of federal investigators including top counter intelligence officials from the justice department, met with trump and two of his lawyers at mar-a-lago. people briefed on that meeting,
5:02 am
and tells new york times, they show the investigators, a storage area with boxes containing more of the material that trump took. two people briefed on that visit, tell the new york times that investigators left with some of material marked classified, also importantly, around this time, one of trump's lawyers signed a written document asserting that all the material marked as classified and held in mar-a-lago, had been turned over to the government. that's according to four people, with knowledge of that document. as of last monday, search mar-a-lago revealed, that apparently was not true. the search notably included trump's office and residence, in addition to that apparent storage area. in total, the monday cash included 11 sets of classified documents, three sets labeled secret, for labeled top secret, and three sets designated as confidential. some documents are marked, highly classified, with ts
5:03 am
slash as c i. that means top secret sensitive compartmented information, meaning the information there is not meant to be viewed outside of a secure government facility. two sources briefed on the classified documents sought and the original subpoena tell the new york times that federal officials were prompted to search mar-a-lago, because some of the material trump took was particularly sensitive to national security. the unsealed search warrant science three criminal statutes as a legal basis for the raid including, potential violations of the espionage act. and violations of the obstruction statute. like yesterday, representatives adam schiff and caramel lonely, they are the respective chairs of the intel committee, have the oversight reform committee, they sent a letter to avril haines, a director of national intelligence, demanding an immediate review and damage assessment, on this situation as it relates to america's national security. joining me now is jane hartman,
5:04 am
-- a former nine term member of congress for the state of california, the author of insanity defense, why our failure to confront a hard national security problems makes us less safe. jane, in your career, good morning to you, you have dealt frequently with classified and top secret information. it seems to be, anyone who has had any interaction with the stuff, knows exactly what they're supposed to do, and what they are not supposed to do. taking into mar-a-lago is in the latter category. >> you bet. the people around trump had to know what to do, what not to do. trump is apparently known for not following rules. but they had to know how important these classifications are. i served on the housing intelligence community for eight years. four of them as a ranking democrat. after 9/11.
5:05 am
in that role, i was entitled to be in so came -- so called -- senior members of the intel committee, plus the leaders of both houses of congress. those briefings were a lot of -- not only did i never take a piece of paper out of the room, if i had taken any notes, they would've had to have stayed in the room. i never talked to anybody about the content and the briefings. it was important, coming back to nuclear, why would you take any materials, we don't know they, are relating to nuclear weapons, or nuclear facilities, or designs, whatever. out of the white house out of secure facility and put them in secure facility, which mar-a-lago is, let's remember, two chinese spies, who are trying to get in the last, year or a couple years ago, they were apprehended by security. why would you do that? would your purpose possibly be? and who would around you, you would think that is a good idea?
5:06 am
>> let's talk about that. donald trump was not sentimental about these things, he was known to destroy, burn, rub things up, thumb in the toilet. the idea that something has been kept, is notable. what could it be for? i'm not trying to cast aspersions, but why would you keep that information? >> we have no information. i don't think, he was notorious for not reading. you have to think, if it was there, again, let's wait, we see what's the justice department has said they are being meticulous about this investigation. there's absolutely no chance, this would have gotten this far, if it was not deadly serious. timeline you gave us shows us all the chances, the trump crowd had to turn over the material, and did not. and any rate, what would you do with it? you would not write a book with classified information, i don't think you would do that. it seems to me, you might consider transferring it somewhere. i have no idea where, i don't
5:07 am
know what it is. speculation is, russia, saudi arabia, something like that. but we have no information yet. bottom line is this is deadly serious, literally deadly serious. just like the russian bombing by the way, which is going on, the civil nuclear facility in ukraine, that whole area is now evacuated. you don't play with stuff like this. russia not be doing, it certainly, ex presidents should not be doing this. >> good to see this morning, thank you for joining us. you have a great deal of experience in this particular area. jane heiman, is a distinguished fellow -- at the joining me now is doctor david priess. former cia officer, and daily intelligence briefing, to then fbi director and former -- he's also the publisher and chief operating officer of lawfare, he's the author of the
5:08 am
presidents book of secrets and how to get rid of a president. david good to see you, thank you for joining us. i want to read something to you, hopefully i. it repeat is the fox news, donald trump has designated one of his representatives in the ongoing conversations, with the national archives, about these documents. read a statement, that mr. trump had a coat standing order during his presidency, that quote documents removed from the oval office, and taken to the residents where deemed to be classified the moment he removed them. and a quote. this sounds like the formation of a defense, or something. although none of the statutes cited about classified documents. have you heard of such a thing? to not happen? >> in theory, of course, it can happen. he's the president. while he is president, he does have the ability to de-classified documents, on a moments notice. that can be done.
5:09 am
here's the issue. when you declassify a document, that has to be recorded somehow, or no one knows that it is these classified. the document itself, we need to have some market audit. surely, it's no longer classified. -- and put the proper markings on it. more importantly, that is not the only copy of the documents in existence. there are perhaps hundreds or thousands of other computers and electronic, or printed form, and other parts of the government. almost certainly held in secure compartmentalized facilities. they're declassified, if the copy that the president has declassified, he's declassifying the content within that document. therefore, those are the documents need to be marked as well. there should be evidence of this, if it happened. in the luckiest administration i've ever seen. all kinds of things are being reported to the press, the fact
5:10 am
that this was never reported until the statement, does make respect -- skeptical. >> one we don't understand is motivation. we know this evidence, that they asked production is from trump. and they found out there were more documents, then people from the department of justice went to mar-a-lago, and ask for more documents, they got some, but found out that there were more, and then they finally get the search warrant, they go to get them. what we have not spoken to, over the course of the last few days, what were the possible motivations before having these documents? have you been able to get any thought, where are we able to shed any light on that? trying to get inside the former president's head is dangerous business. it's hard to know what motivations are there, but we do have some experience watching him in the presidency for four years and some of his time before and after. sometimes there is not a strict logic. there is not eight dimensional
5:11 am
chess going on, it is simply a win or an instinct. it could be something as simple as, this document seems special or memorable. it documents something that i found particularly interesting when i was told about it -- therefore i want to keep this. it was a memorial my presidency. maybe if all of the thoughts didn't go through someone's head, the former presidents, had someone in his staff, but that kind of motivation is not unheard of. to say this is something that struck me, this is something that is important to me, it could be so's love letters to kim jong-un, it could be 1 million other things that are classified that we don't know about. for some reason they really got their hooks into the former president with those immediately around them. the important thing to remember here is that we don't know whom these charges are targeted against. it is possible it is the former president, but it's also
5:12 am
possible to those around him. there was time and time again after the president left office that him or the people around him were being made aware that there were documents that they should not be in possession of, but yet they continued to have documents there. that's why we had the search and seizure, the serious crime. -- >> thanks for talking about this and helping us get -- he is a former cia officers, daily brief or four former fbi director robert mueller and attorney josh ashcroft. we will continue to dissect every detail in the anti-democratic story of donald trump to the story, including how the former president's response to the -- tropical golf course lead to a rise in rhetoric from the far-right. this week with the velshi banned book club is around the corner. on the agenda today is a classic, controversial classic, lord of the flies. more velshi after this. you are watching msnbc news. e watching msnbc news.
5:13 am
age is just a number. and mine's unlisted. try boost® high protein with 20 grams of protein for muscle health. versus 16 grams in ensure high protein. boost® high protein also has key nutrients for immune support. boost® high protein. meet leon the third... leon the second... and leon... the first of them all. three generations, who all bank differently with chase. leon's saving up for his first set of wheels... nice try. really? this leon's paying for his paint job on the spot... and this leon, as a chase private client, he's in the south of france, taking out cash with no atm fees. that's because this family of leons has chase. actually, it's león. ooh la la! one bank for now. for later. for life. chase. make more of what's yours. shingles. some describe it as pulsing electric shocks
5:14 am
or sharp, stabbing pains. ♪♪ this painful, blistering rash can disrupt your life for weeks. a pain so intense, you could miss out on family time. the virus that causes shingles is likely already inside of you. if you're 50 years or older, ask your doctor or pharmacist about shingles. with downy infusions, let the scent set the mood. ♪ if you're 50 years or older, feel the difference with downy. [lazer beam and sizzling sounds] ♪♪ >> tech: cracked windshield? don't wait. go to safelite.com [lazer beam and sizzling sounds] you can schedule service in just a few clicks.
5:15 am
it's so easy. and more customers today are relying on their cars advanced safety features, like automatic emergency breaking and lane departure warning. that's why our recalibration service is state of the art. we recalibrate your vehicle's camera, so you can still count on those safety features. all right, we're all finished. >> customer: thank you so much. >> tech: thank you. don't wait--schedule now. >> singers: ♪ safelite repair, safelite replace. ♪ millions have made the switch from the big three to xfinity mobile. that means millions are saving hundreds a year on their wireless bill. and all of those millions are on the nation's most reliable 5g network and most recommended wireless carrier. that's a whole lot of happy campers out there. and it's never too late to join them. get $450 off any new purchase of an eligible samsung device with xfinity mobile. the author solomon rushdie is or add a line to your plan today at xfinitymobile.com
5:17 am
still in hospital this morning after being violently attacked in public on friday in western new york state. his literary agent told associated press that russia has been taken off the ventilator and can now speak on his own. rusty was stabbed about a dozen time will participating in a discussion on priests beak each in america. he is best known for writing the satanic versus, the 1988 book, considered blasphemous by some government in majority muslim nations. -- also called for russians killing. iran's leader at the time ordered a falk russia, an edict, that the all to be put to death. the man accused of the stabbing is sympathetic, reportedly, to that kind of extremism. pleaded not guilty to assault and -- charges.
5:18 am
joining me now -- is in erie, pennsylvania, outside the hospital where rushdie is being treated. what more do we know about rushdie condition and his attacker? >> good to be with you, ali, signs of improvement. his agent reportedly telling the associated press, confirming that rushdie is now off a ventilator. he is now speaking and reportedly in good spirits despite suffering a remarkable dozen or so stab wounds according to the stock would county district attorney. those wounds across his body, his neck, his chest, his stomach. the accused attacker was arraigned in court yesterday on second degree attempted murder and assault charges. -- the district attorney says he called the stabbing at the lecture series a preplanned, unprovoked attack, saying that the suspect had traveled to the county by bus. he had a fake i.d. on him and
5:19 am
he purchased a ticket ahead of time in order to gain entry into rushdie a lecture. to law and foreign officials are telling nbc that the leading theory in the case right now is at the suspect had acted alone, inspired by iran -related extremism. they also say that in the search of the new jersey resident belonging to the suspect they found an iranian flag. they know that they had been combing through his social media accounts. rushdie has faced death threats for decades over extremists over his publishing of the 1988 book the satanic versus, which many mom muslims consider offensive in blasphemous. it called for his killing more than 30 years ago. we have not gotten any public comment from the iranian government, but newspapers there, some, have praised the attack. one calling it divine revenge. -- >> emily ikeda, thank you for
5:20 am
your coverage in erie, pennsylvania. playing politics with the lives of real people in the stain in american history that is the family separation policy. no heavy perfumes, and no dyes. finally, a light scent that lasts all day. downy light! i would say that to me an important aspect is too... meta portal with smart sound. helps reduce your background noise. bring that sense of calm, really... so you come through, loud and clear. meta portal. the smart video calling device that makes work from home work for you. for months now the texas open. it's a beautiful word. neighborhoods "open". businesses "open". fields "open". who doesn't love "open"? offices. homes. stages. possibilities. your world. open. and you can help keep it that way.
5:22 am
governor, greg abbott, has been bussed saying migrants and refugees from the southern border to cities in the northeast in response to the biden administration's decision to lift title 42. that was the pandemic era policy that allowed officials to deny entry into america. so far, texas has bust more than 6000 migrants to d.c. alone but recently has gone to a public battle with new york's mayor eric adams, so we have started blasting people to new york as well. >> it is a piece of political theater that neither helps refugees seeking asylum nor -- there's a total disregard for their needs, they are being
5:23 am
used as political pawns. much like america's policy towards migrants, the cruelty is the point. in the absence of congressional acts action or true reform, cruelty is a deterrence to immigration that we have seen before. five years ago as soon is assuming the presidency, donald trump and his administration started carrying one of the coolest policies against immigrants in recent history. under the policy of zero tolerance, all those who cross the southern border illegally with children were mandated to be separated from those children. more than 2000 children were separated from their parents or from other adults with whom they came. this policy was very poorly thought out and has early implemented. in many cases children and babies were taken from the parent without any possible probable explanation for it for when they would see each other again. that's because the people carrying out the policy, didn't know the answer that question. record keeping was basically nonexistent, no one kept track
5:24 am
of the kids, the family members, or where they were taken. many of those children and two overcrowded facilities where they were basically caged in with others in the same situation. it took years in some cases for them to be reunited with their families. for a long time, the administration denied the existence of this family separation policy. now it is undeniably part of donald trump's presidential legacy. joining now is caitlin dickinson. she is the author of the magazine's cover story for next month, titled we need to take away children. the secret history of the u.s. government, family separation policy. she's been the last 18 months investigating the story, conducting more than 150 interviews in the process and has reviewed thousands of pages of government reports. kaitlan, congratulations on an important story. we talk to you for years and we know how much you work on this. one of the things that comes out of the story is the degree to which -- this is trump's policy, trump's
5:25 am
legacy, but it took lots of people in lots of departments both to implemented and mess it up as much as you write out. >> that's right. as soon as the country found out about zero tolerance, found out that hundreds of separations had happened in secret and then they ramped up even more and you had thousands of additional separations. anger turned towards stephen miller, trump's steve chief immigration officer and the homeland security secretary. the reality is that those two figures were absolutely pivotal, stephen miller pushed relentlessly for this to happen and kirsten nielsen ended up being pressured and pressured until she just went along with it. there were so many other people involved and, importantly, people like tom holman who was the head -- under president trump who served under both republican and democrat presidents before, he had been an enforcement in decades, he is supposed to be an a political career expert who understands the system.
5:26 am
he, unlike stephen miller, wasn't pushing for policies from an ideological place but from, theoretically, expertise. same story with mcaleenan who is the customs and border protection. some people really trusted to provide good information to homeland security secretary about what she would do. instead, these individuals and their staff assured the homeland security secretary that this will be fine. they said things like we have done it before, which is untrue, and systems were in place to prevent these prolonged separations, which wasn't true either. stephen miller, by the way you see on tv or streaming -- he's all over the place these days. he has a comment on everything these days. >> you write the people who know miller say he believes zero dollar save lives on immigration enforcement was traditional popular complement among his base. mueller has told them that the administration laid the groundwork necessary for a future president to implement harsh enforcement even more quickly and with greater reach than under trump.
5:27 am
if anyone is likely to lead another push for a government to separate families of the stephen miller. for a year and a half i tried to reach him so i could ask him, a mug of the things, why he had lobbied so forcefully for this to occur in the first place and whether he would do so again in the future. a close friend of miller and his wife explained that ever since the couple became parents, they have been consumed by childcare care and were hard to reach. again, i will put it out there, stephen miller you are invited to come on the show and i will have caitlin back and we can have this discussion. why is he so into this? what is this thing? he has been sort of an anti-immigration guy for a while. why this? >> well i think for miller this is an ideological passion, if you will. he cares a lot about the immigration system and wants to limit immigration to the united states as much as he possibly can. your viewers know that. you have other people, importantly, again not just miller put these career enforcement officials who advised the trump administration and still believe, very strongly, in what
5:28 am
they see as the success of zero tolerance. generally, this prevention by deterrence approach. they believe very strongly and so there is no question that these policies would come back. i can tell you i did countless interviews and there was nobody who said, maybe would take a different tack or go a little bit softer or trying to work more with congress. they are ready to hit the ground running. >> one about kyrsten nielsen? you talk about her as someone who seemed, at times, resistant tillis. she's one of the senior people who spoke out against the policy but uk say she became subsumed? >> she did and i think her story is important not to absolve anyone of responsibility, she is the highest ranking law enforcement officials who signed on on this as prosecco terry. she was, at the center of this lobbying pan campaign, she had immense pressure coming on from her white house and miller who are doing things outside of the norm and government.
5:29 am
bridging people throughout the agency with the manson arguments, doing much as he could to force people into agreeing with him, but then members of the bureaucracy really turned on her because they saw an opportunity for their own career advancement if they sort of saddled up to what the white house was pushing for. what happened to her, eight reflexive breakdown of these lines that should exist to prevent bad policies from ever reaching the desk of the cabinet secretary in the first place for a decision. the policy were no planning at taking place should never be presented to someone like nielsen, in this case it was. >> what happens now? we still, i've had you for years talking but how this real solution so this where we have to deal with immigration in a real matter. you can't have nobody coming into america, we would be short of workers and we have that sort of situation. but we have got to solving congress, which means it will still fall in the hands of
5:30 am
administrations and -- >> that's right. i know we sound a little bit bit like a broken record, saying congress, hey congress, you haven't done anything. i do think we show very clearly in the story that the absence of congressional action has left the border patrol to figure this out on their own. it is not law enforcement officials to figure out what is humanitarian policy, economic policy, international relations. all these things are left to a police force effectively that has one tool at its disposal which is punishment. that is why you continue to see border control turning back, again and again, to the same approaches. they don't work, there is no evidence they were, but when congress doesn't intervene it is basically like there's no choice but to use the tools they have. >> remarkable story. i'm glad you took the time and space and the atlantic took the time and space to tell this. it sort of keeps falling off the radar. it is not only solvable, it can be solved in a good way.
5:31 am
let's thank you for keeping the tournament for all of us. caitlin dickinson is a staff writer at the atlantic. it is been one year since kabul fell to afghanistan ten taliban forces, where things stand today in afghanistan. 12 days after nancy pelosi visited taiwan, a group of five american lawmakers are expected to land today in the taiwanese capital of taipei. the congressional delegation is led by the democratic senator and her of massachusetts. includes three democrats and a republican member of the house. they are there today and tomorrow, they are scheduled to meet with senior taiwanese leaders to discuss relations between those two countries and regional security among other issues. on the days after speaker pelosi's visit 12 years ago, china response to the show of force, setting missiles, warships, and more planes to lord over taiwan. lord over taiwan it's a storm that crashes, and consumes, replacing thought with worry. but one thing can calm uncertainty.
5:32 am
an answer. uncovered through exploration, teamwork, and innovation. an answer that leads to even more answers. mayo clinic. you know where to go. i'd like to thank our sponsor liberty mutual. they customize your car insurance, so you only pay for what you need. contestants ready? go! only pay for what you need. jingle: liberty. liberty. liberty. liberty. ♪♪ my relationship with my credit cards wasn't good. i got into debt in college and, no matter how much i paid, it followed me everywhere. between the high interest, the fees... i felt trapped. debt, debt, debt. so i broke up with my credit card debt and consolidated it into a low-rate personal loan from sofi. i finally feel like a grown-up. break up with bad credit card debt. get a personal loan with no fees, low fixed rates, and borrow up to $100k. go to sofi.com to view your rate.
5:33 am
sofi. get your money right. ♪♪ ♪ ♪ this is the moment. for a treatment for moderate-to-severe eczema. cibinqo — fda approved. 100% steroid free. not an injection, cibinqo is a once-daily pill for adults who didn't respond to previous treatments. and cibinqo helps provide clearer skin and less itch. cibinqo can lower your ability to fight infections, including tb. before and during treatment, your doctor should check for infections and do blood tests. tell your doctor if you've had hepatitis b or c, have flu-like symptoms, or are prone to infections. do not take with medicines that prevent blood clots. serious, sometimes fatal infections, lymphoma, lung, skin and other cancers, serious heart-related events, and blood clots can happen. people 50 and older with heart disease risk factors have an increased risk of serious heart-related events or death with jak inhibitors. this is the moment. but we've only just begun. speak with your doctor about cibinqo today.
5:34 am
an innovation from pfizer. ever notice how stiff clothes speak with your doctor about cibinqo today. can feel rough on your skin? for softer clothes that are gentle on your skin, try downy free & gentle downy will soften your clothes without dyes or perfumes. the towel washed with downy is softer, and gentler on your skin. try downy free & gentle. there are not many images that have stuck with me quite like this one. hundreds of afghans sprinting after an american military aircraft, willing it to stop, literally. some clinging to the side as it gains speed on the tarmac. a level of desperation that most of us could and hopefully we'll never have to imagine. on these defining images, they have a yard out, when it became clear that the afghan government had collapsed and the taliban was taking its claim in kabul. it happened, fast faster than
5:35 am
predicted because the taliban faced a little to no resistance as it swept across afghanistan taking province after province until it provided kabul, the capital, to kind of scheduled. here we go, today. -- afghan allies who helped the american military and many afghan civilians this possible. by august 30th, two weeks later, the u.s. has officially completed its withdrawal of afghanistan on schedule. over those two weeks, about 123,000 people were airlifted by afghanistan by the united states and its coalition partners. the u.s. side evacuated about 80,000 civilians, about 73,000 were afghans or other foreign nationals. president biden vowed to help as many people as possible, but he made a special promise to the afghans and their families who lift the wrist alive to help american troops during that 20-year war. that included translators, interpreters, drivers, and
5:36 am
others. there was afghan allies who are eligible for the s iv program. the special immigrant visa which opened a pathway to the united states for anyone who worked for the u.s. government. the wartime allies conducted a survey in february that showed an estimated 81,000 applicants with visa applications pending as of august 15th 2021, they stay or go, the day kabul fell, of those 78,000 remain left behind. that is the harsh reality. so many afghan civilians and allies to the u.s. government not ever got there to get out of afghanistan. even those who did face and determine the future. zain alex talk-y, zach for short, was 20 years old when he started working for the u.s. government as an interpreter. his zach and his family qualified for the program but last year he was stuck in afghanistan, held up by a
5:37 am
bureaucratic technicality. all the while he and his family were engraved danger. zak was being threatened by the taliban over his work with the united states. they called him an infidel and a traitor. i spoke to zach last year. his face, his identity, veiled. he told me about the threats that he faced from the taliban as he was trying to get out of afghanistan. >> the taliban -- are house because they are looking for the people who has worked, people who have done the work with the u.s. forces and they are looking for them to be targeted and killed them. >> zak told me later that he thought that interview that he did with me might be his last. during his time as an interpreter, zach made a lifelong friend of marine lieutenant tom schuman. the two were signed to an area helmand province, one of the most dangerous areas of all of afghanistan. they literally walked in each other's footsteps to avoid
5:38 am
stepping on improvised explosive devices. zach wrist his life for tom and schuman, now a marine major, was determined to pay him back for service. major schuman wrote letters to the white house, appealed on social media, and took days and intense effort while being incurred sourcing the attack in his family out of afghanistan. major schuman spoke to rachel maddow last year when he found out that all of this hard work paid off. >> we pulled every letter, poked everywhere, it was just this series of hail mary's. there are so many close calls and so many moments where i thought, maybe we contacted the right person, maybe we had the right solution to this. it was a series of tragic events. >> it wasn't easy, but back in his family are now in the united states and have been here for almost a year. i had the honor of speaking with dak and major schuman last week. zak explain the moment he
5:39 am
realized he was going to be rescued. >> i saw some people that there was -- i had been with the military and knew who they were, i saw that they were seal team guys and and i feel happy. i saw the guy, i think they've come for me. i shake my hand and my son was on my shoulders. they saw me from the roof top and said, sack, we see -- he sees my son he says he's wearing the blue t-shirt. i say yes or, i'm him. i jumped out and grab our bank and saw them just go bow down to the occasion open the gate. they get us in. and that, at that time i just feel pristine me. >> i wish i could say zach's turning it over, it's not. zach's most recent visa
5:40 am
application was rejected. even after all he's done for this country, all he is not to get here, all major schuman did, stay in the united states is still not guaranteed. still, he is grateful to be on u.s. soil. this was known as the forever war for america and other western age nations. forever didn't last, we are out. for people of afghanistan americas withdrawal was part of a new generation of anguish. what you are hearing, not that much much has changed. much has changed. or an unbearable itch. this painful, blistering rash can disrupt your life for weeks. it could make your workday feel impossible. the virus that causes shingles is likely already inside of you. if you're 50 years or older, ask your doctor or pharmacist about shingles. [peaceful music plays]
5:41 am
[soft cymbal crash] are you tired of clean clothes that just don't smell clean? downy unstopables in-wash scent boosters keep your laundry smelling fresh waaaay longer than detergent alone. if you want laundry to smell fresh for weeks, make sure you have downy unstopables in-wash scent boosters. age is just a number. and mine's unlisted. try boost® high protein with 20 grams of protein for muscle health. versus 16 grams in ensure high protein. boost® high protein also has key nutrients for immune support. boost® high protein. panera chefs have crafted a masterpiece... boost® high protein also succulent, seared chicken... a secret aioli... clean ingredients... in a buttery brioche roll. made fresh, to leave you... speechless. panera's new chef's chicken sandwiches. $1 delivery fee on our app. kids, one year they want all dinosaurs stuff the next, camels. - llamas. - llamas.
5:42 am
so save money shopping back to school on amazon. you sure that's not a camel? yeah. whatever you say. i typed in my dad's name... and i found his childhood home. he's been wondering about the address for seventy years... (chuckle) and i found it in five minutes. travel back in time in no time with the 1950 census on ancestry. as i just noted, one year ago today the taliban took over kabul, the afghanistan capital was zero resistance. two weeks before american troops will officially withdrew from the country. like americas withdrawal, taliban takeover was riddled with chaos. the day began with panic and confusion as local criminal gangs dressed office as trump taliban, they looted abandoned
5:43 am
police posts. city posts, like military post across the country had left the weapons behind simply walking away believing that the taliban takeover wasn't navigable. mass rumors and mask panic reach all the way to the presidential palace where president ashraf ghani boarded the plane and fled to the united arab emirates, leading to a power bed, leading to the complete collapse of the government. -- the fall of saigon. american helicopters outside the u.s. embassy taking off the last remaining diplomatic staff. this, as frightening crowds of afghan civilians filled up at the airports filling onto the tarmac, desperate to be evacuated. covering the collapse of kabul from here, a year ago, one of the people they are on whom i relied that morning with matthew akins who has been covering the country for more than a decade. that is a pulitzer prize-winning journalist for the new york times magazine and
5:44 am
wrote this week's cover story titled the taliban's dangerous collision course with the west. he's also the author of the naked don't feel the water, an underground journey with afghan refugees. good to see you. thank you for being with us. one year later, what's going through your mind? >> well it is surreal to imagine that everything that we have been working on for 20 years just fell apart and crumbled in the blink of an eye. i was there on the streets that day, outside the wire, and wanting the taliban into the city at the end of the day. the next day we woke up to find taliban in charge of kabul, in charge of the capitol. i went back and make for the first time since the evacuation last fall. i went back for the new york times magazine for a story, i don't really try to ask the question of what is happened in this last year? how have the taliban ruling in their first year of power. one of the key issues this year than everyone is talking about
5:45 am
is afghan schoolgirls. why aren't they allowed high school girls backing classes and all those provinces? it was really interesting to find a lot of taliban officials for spoke to in kabul were actually in favor of allowing the girls to go back and very stretched frustrated by this decision but it had been made by sort of the shadow governments of the taliban which is the supreme leader and leadership council in kandahar in the south. >> so, the bottom line though, one way or the other, women have been the collateral damage of this thing in the pre taliban afghanistan there was education for women, women had positions of importance. during taliban rule afghanistan war there, prior, women had no rights. we are back to a place where women's rights are nowhere close to where they would have been. there's no particular intention with the taliban are doing with this. >> not to go back to the way it was under the last 20 years, where you had women, for
5:46 am
example, in high positions of authority. i don't predicting then afghanistan anytime soon. the fact of the matter is that when you make afghan girls the poster children for your military operation there is a risk they become collateral damage if the war fails. >> one of the things you're right about is not the u.s. failed to understand the dynamics of the political players within the country and understanding these dynamics could better inform how we approach of the crisis. i don't know whether this discussion of how girls will go back to school is part of that internal dynamic between the more conservative kandahar based, more religious fat shadow government, and the actual government. tell me more about what you mean here? there are some people who don't think we need to be engaging the taliban and all, except there are a whole bunch of afghans who are troubling and suffering under them as the west disengages. >> the fact of the matter is, the taliban are firmly in control of the country. it is complete moral and political collapse of the
5:47 am
u.s.-backed republic has left them with no serious challengers. over the past years we have seen a normalization of the taliban's relationships, especially with the regional countries. about the, with china, and also with the u.s. in the story i reported on. greece's secret -- recent secret meetings with the u.s. and taliban chiefs. they went in secret to kabul, thomas west meant the afghan defense minister in secret in july, and so you see this pragmatic engagement with the taliban. i do think it's very important to understand where the real power lies. i think sometimes meeting with the wrong people, because the power works in a hidden way within the movement. it is very secretive partly upon of being of uncertainty for so long. we have seen this pragmatic engagement with the taliban which, of course, what did we see very recently? the leader of al-qaeda being struck by a drone in downtown
5:48 am
kabul, somewhere he used to jog. so that is sort of the x-factor. if afghanistan again becomes a threat to its neighbors, the world, because of terrorist groups there would be intervention and maybe war. >> that was the starting point of this when the west believed that the afghanistan were harboring al-qaeda, -- have said they are unaware that the -- was in kabul. >> [inaudible] that the u.s. intelligence believe that most of the taliban leadership was actually unaware of alice who already being there and he was hosted by a faction connected to -- >> good to see you, thank you for my friend for your remarkable coverage of this. he is a pad sin prize writer and new york times writer. also the author of the naked over the water, undisputed journey with afghanistan --
5:49 am
>> alabama mediately affected by the decision to overturn roe v. wade. i had the chance to tour one of the states clinics which was for us to stop providing abortions the day of the ruling. that clinic is still committed to providing other types of prenatal care, but i learned about the vast network of anti-abortion forces seeking to deliberately mislead pregnant americans. an americans. ♪♪ meta portal go. look professional. ♪♪ even if you don't feel it. meta portal. the smart video calling device... - right on time! - of course. that makes work from home work for you. so, shall we get started? meet leon the third... leon the second... and leon... the first of them all. three generations, who all bank differently with chase. leon's saving up for his first set of wheels... nice try. really? this leon's paying for his paint job on the spot...
5:50 am
and this leon, as a chase private client, he's in the south of france, taking out cash with no atm fees. that's because this family of leons has chase. actually, it's león. ooh la la! one bank for now. for later. for life. chase. make more of what's yours. ♪♪ one bank for now. for later. for life. add downy to your wash for all the freshness and softness of home. even when you're not at home. feel the difference with downy. age is just a number. and mine's unlisted. try boost® high protein with 20 grams of protein for muscle health. versus 16 grams in ensure high protein. boost® high protein also has key nutrients for immune support. boost® high protein. (vo) at viking, we are proud to have been named the world's number one for both rivers and oceans boost® high protein also has key nutrients by travel and leisure, as well as condé nast traveler. but it is now time for us to work even harder,
5:51 am
5:53 am
court overturned roe v. wade abortion became illegal in a handful of states, almost immediately including in alabama. while the decision was a major blow, abortions rights advocates in alabama had been sleeping over hurdles and red tape to provide core care for years before the fall of roe. last week, you know, i visited alabama women center in tuscaloosa that can no longer provide abortion or even advise patients about how to get one or where to get one. the facility still provides crucial services for the community, prenatal care, contraceptive care, annual exams, and other things. when i arrived at the clinic i was caught off guard. something that turned me around and i came to realize that the confusion was manufactured deliberately. >> we all arrange that we would meet here and so i pulled off, i put in my gps and pull up, and i pulled up in front of a place with a different name. >> women's choice. >> women's choice, yeah that's where i pulled up in front of.
5:54 am
i thought to myself that knowing that you knew i was coming here, you wouldn't give me the wrong name for where we were going to go. >> me that was near place. >> that was not. >> it's not this clinic, it's right next door to you. >> it is. this choice is one of many so-called crisis pregnancy centers. they are organizations that pretend to be legitimate medical centers. they often locate themselves right in front of our across the street from places that provide abortion. they specifically do that as a means of trying to get people who are going to abortion clinics to go into their place instead. this is something that happens not just an alabama, it happens in every state, every city. we find that patients will often get stuck there. they won't be told immediately that they are in the wrong place. we have had patients who would often tell us that they were late because they went to the
5:55 am
wrong clinic and then the woman's pregnancy center would tell them they didn't know where our clinic was. we share a building. we are right next to each other, to be clear. they would say they did not know where we were. we had an incident with a person who came to us from texas. she had called the wrong place, she called their center instead of our center and she drove from houston to ours in order to get here and came into their clinic at about 2:00 in the afternoon and only then did she find out the nobody there provided abortion. they did not tell her that when they set up her appointment and they also did not tell her that in alabama person has to have a in an issue appointment with an ultrasound, counseling, then they need to leave for 48 hours. only then can they come back, after that 48 hours has passed and have the procedure. so this person had traveled all
5:56 am
day to get to an appointment that was meaningless, only to find out that she was going to have to make another appointment with us and then go home. drive back ten hours, go and spend another couple of days back home with when she could return and have her abortion. that was three trips for her. all because they did not tell her on the phone but they did not provide abortions. i reached out to the crisis pregnancy center after abortion was made illegal, so i could find out if they had doctors that they could recommend. our doctor is very skilled and able to do everything except for actual delivery because she is not able to get hospital privileges in this city. we wanted to do prenatal care and we were looking for a doctor that we could have work with us who would deliver. here, we are going to get the people who are pregnant and don't want to be. they couldn't give me any doctors. they could tell me that they were able to give a list of
5:57 am
doctors who except medicaid. that's with the gift of pregnant people who come in, but they don't have anyone who is actually going to say, you are pregnant, i will deliver your baby, you have nowhere else to go. >> what we'll see. >> prior to road being overturned we had a spaced in our parking lot the the four -- and people who are going to hold events. it was a space that takes up parking, right across from an insurance firm on one side and then a pediatric clinic on the other side. there were people there, almost every day, with signs who would shout at our patients as they were coming in for care regardless of what type of care was. i think the thing that drew me away the most was that there was an organization that was show up, that would come with or signs that said babies are murdered here. they were standing right next to the pediatric clinic. they had preachers who would
5:58 am
get right on the back door and yell into the clinic, knowing that they were close to where the prosecutors room were. very close to the rooms, small clinic, close to the recovery rooms. they would yell hellfire, brimstone, tell them that they were all going to go to hell and that god was willing to save them if they just walk out of the clinic. that was nothing we would deal with every day here. we had one person who would tell one of our nurses we had to file something because he would yell at her that god was coming for her. i think that obviously, to us, that sounds like a threat. this is alabama, this is a place where providers have been shot, clinics have been firebombed. this is not a safe place for people to work in abortion. we knew that and it is one of the reasons why it was so difficult for so many clinics in the gulf to get doctors, especially within their communities and we were very lucky to have one willing to
5:59 am
take that risk. we had an off-duty police officer who came in and within the parking lot for a couple of hours every morning. i didn't like that because it was very expensive, i would rather spend that on patient care, but b, we know a lot of people come in here where from highly surveilled, marginalized community, and having to walk back passed a police officer carson all fleeing to have to do for them. the irony is that in the days that followed the decision and right before the decision, he was the crisis pregnancy center that actually got in -- the police officer and had cops kind of thriving around because they were afraid, they said they were afraid, of some sort of action against them and so they had thrown more protection and our patients never really
6:00 am
felt protected by the police. those of you who watch a show, no i brought you a lot of robin and west alabama abortion center, more than i typically would. we take these long interviews and we headed down and show you the portion of it. i found at every moment i spoke with her, it's so important. a lot to be as watches that conversation as i could. i want to thank her, and everyone at the west alabama wins center, for the incredible work and making f is a possibility. in the wake of the overturning of roe, it is important to shed light on abortion access and the impediment to a woman's right to choose, with program commit to network, and plan to keep banging that drum, when it comes to abortion rights in this country. because it is one of the most pivotal and important topics of our time. straight, ahead we have the latest details on the classified documents that donald trump kept at mar-a-lago. i will convene another banned book club, what is the inherent nature of
78 Views
IN COLLECTIONS
MSNBC West Television Archive Television Archive News Search ServiceUploaded by TV Archive on