tv The Reid Out MSNBC June 20, 2023 4:00pm-5:00pm PDT
4:00 pm
here's the only thing left to know on msnbc, next is an exclusive, one year post-roe, a reidout special with vice president harris, starting now. it was a moment considered unimaginable in 21st century america. the u.s. supreme court eliminating the constitutional right to abortion. the bans were immediate, along with the horror stories of shuttered clinics and women
4:01 pm
denied emergency medical care. >> i'll never forget one of the doctors just ripping off his gloves throwing them at the trash and saying i can't help you anymore. you have to geout of state. >> almost a year later, the landscape of abortion access is even worse. republicans remain focused on pushing restrictive laws that americans overwhelmingly reject. >> the body inside of the mom's body is not her body. not her body, not her choice. >> the supreme court may have empowered the states to reshape abortion law, but reproductive rights remain a national issue that the biden/harris administration and congress must respond to, to forge a road map for the work that lies ahead. tonight, from dallas, in a state considered ground zero in the national fight over abortion rights, this is one year post-roe, a reidout special with vice president kamala harris. hello, and thank you for joining me on this special edition of
4:02 pm
"the reidout." my guest for the hour is vice president kamala harris. but because it's such an important issue to so many americans, we also wanted to bring around this table people whose lives and work were directly affected by the elimination of the right to an abortion. joining me are genesis sanchez, an abortion rights advocate, amanda zaroski, lead plaintiff in the abortion access lawsuit against the state of texas, shannon brewer, executive director of the las cruces women's health center in new mexico, and dr. toddive y who is an ob/gyn in the state of texas. i want to start with you, madam vice president. we know this is a big news cycle. there's lots of news going on. but we really wanted to focus on this because this was a huge loss. i think for so many people. and i appreciate you being here for this conversation. but i would love to know first
4:03 pm
how you felt not only as the first woman vice president of the united states but also as a former prosecutor, as a momala to two lovelies, as an auntie, as a woman, as an american. to that moment, when you knew that roe was gone. >> so joy, first of all, thank you for bringing us together for this incredibly important conversation. four days before we will recognize one year since the dobbs decision came down. i was actually that day when i heard the highest court in our land took a constitutional right from the women of america, from the people of america, i was that day on my way from d.c. to illinois to do an event on maternal mortality. with lauren underwood. because you know, the irony of that moment couldn't be more clear in terms of the disconnect
4:04 pm
between those who are fighting to attack this right and deprive people of this privacy right and those who also have not been leaders on an issue like maternal mortality. but i was on my way to illinois and you know, in the litany of things that i am, including a momala and all the other things, i'm also someone who was motivated to become a lawyer because of people like thurgood marshall. one of my inspirations was rbg, and the idea that the highest court in our land just did that and rolled back rights that had been recognized was incredibly shocking. i knew it might happen. the decision had been leaked. i called my husband, i called doug immediately because he was the only one i could really just like let it out with. words not for television at this moment. but again, you know, the thing
4:05 pm
about our nation i believe one of the strengths of our nation is, yes, we are a work in progress. and the progress we have made, one of the attributes has been about our collective fight for the expansion of rights. and this was such a stark restriction of rights that had been recognized. and i immediately knew when that decision came down what it would mean for real people almost immediately in our country. who for the most part many will suffer in silence and are alone and without resources of many types. and i was extremely sad for that reason as well. when that decision came down. angry, you know, and extremely sad about what it would mean for real people. >> you know, i know that obviously there's the great inspiration of thurgood marshall and all of the great jurists
4:06 pm
that have been on the court in the past, but i also have seen an interview with your high school best friend. >> yes. >> who talked about your other inspiration for becoming a lawyer, your best friend when you were in high school suffered incest in her home and ended up living with you and your mom and your sister. because of it. and i just, you know, when you think about women who you were defending as a prosecutor that they had been abused in the state of texas and in many other states that have now trigger laws and affirmatively banned abortion, a woman who is in the position of your best friend, if they tried to obtain an abortion as a result of being pregnant in this state, there's a bounty that could be placed on them, a cash bounty on anyone who helped them, they could be committing a crime. any doctor who helped them could go to jail for life and lose their license and be fined.
4:07 pm
i just wonder how you process that as a former prosecutor. >> so you are correct. my best friend in high school, i learned that she was being molested by her stepfather. and i immediately said, well, you have to come live with us. and i called my mother and i told her. my mother was like, of course, she has to come live with us, and she did. she came to live with us. and that was one of the reasons that i wanted to become a prosecutor. to protect people who have been the subject of such abuse, and most of my career as a prosecutor was focused on crimes against women and children, crimes of violence. and so one of the issues on the topic of the dobbs decision is to your point, laws being proposed and passed that make no exception, joy, for rape and incest. and i'm going to be explicit
4:08 pm
about what that means. it means that so-called leaders are saying that after an individual has experienced such a crime of violence, a violation to their body, and surviving that, that these so-called leaders would say to that same person, and the next decision you make about your body is not yours either. that's immoral. that's immoral. to take away her ability to decide what happens to her body next. and so when i think about what is happening with these proponents of this approach, you know, i think that if -- i think one attribute of true leadership is to have some sense of
4:09 pm
empathy. and understanding. as opposed to judgment. when people have had those kinds of experiences. and these are the things that are at play. and i do want to say, because i think it's very important to say, on this issue, one does not have to abandon their faith or deeply held beliefs to agree that the government should not be telling her what to do with her body. >> yeah. and you know, sitting beside you is shannon brewer. and you know, when people talk about the end of roe, they usually say the end of roe, or they say dobbs. but the second half of that case is dobbs versus jackson women's health. and i have a picture of jackson women's health, it was the pink house. it was the last abortion clinic in mississippi, not just in jackson, mississippi, but in the
4:10 pm
state. and it was your lawsuit against the state for eliminating access to abortion that winds up being this case, dobbs v. jackson, mississippi, that triggers the end of abortion rights. and we're looking just at this image of the house that is now a consignment shop. i remember driving by it not long ago and seeing it and being sort of shocked when someone told me that was the pink house. i wonder in that moment when you heard that dobbs was gone, how you felt. >> i felt like we had gone back in time, actually. that's what i felt. and still to this day, that's what i feel. i feel we, you know, we have let women down. we have set things back so far, and it's going to take forever to get it back, if that ever happens again. it won't be in our lifetime.
4:11 pm
that's how i feel at that time. i felt that all the fighting we had done was all in vain at that moment. it was just, you have all types of feelings when that took place. from staff, friends, you know, doctors, escorts, everybody who helped with movement. it was very emotional for everybody. >> yeah. i mean, when i think of you, i think of dr. howard in mississippi who risked, you know, arrest providing abortions for women in mississippi back in the 1950s and '60s. you are an activist. you have moved to new mexico to continue to help women. >> i have. i moved to new mexico. literally jackson closed in july, and we opened in new mexico in august. we had already been preparing for it because we knew what was about to come, so we had been trying to figure out how we were
4:12 pm
going to make sure women continue to have access during this time. and now what we have been doing, we have been seeing women from all over. most of the women have been from texas, and that was one of the main reasons we wanted to open there, was to help the texas women. mississippi also, but most of -- they still had other states. so that's what we have been doing for the last year, getting clinics open. we're now working in chicago, trying to get a clinic open there. >> and you know, texas is obviously ground zero for this fight. you're a part of that story, amanda, in the sense you're suing the state. talk about why. >> it started out for me as education and advocacy because a lot of people i think didn't understand the sweeping impacts that these laws could and are having on real women, including myself. and so it was a big part of just
4:13 pm
educating people and helping them understand what is truly happening, but now, it's become much bigger than that. and what i hope now is to give a voice to all of the other women that this is happening to, that it has happened to, that it will happen to. and i hope to give some courage to other women to take similar action in their own states because we know that this is happening all over the country. and we need to fight back. and so if i can provide a little courage for others, then that's what i'll do. >> when roe fell, did you ever imagine that -- you had a wanted pregnancy. and you wound up needing the same procedure that would be an abortion because of a non-viable pregnancy. did you imagine that the end of roe v. wade could impact you? your health is forever changed because you could not get an abortion procedure. >> that's right. i did not understand, again, the sweeping impacts that we're seeing now.
4:14 pm
i was pregnant after a year and a half of trying. and grueling fertility treatment. i was outraged on behalf of all women in this country, including the baby girl that was inside of me at the time, but i didn't understand that not only had this right been taken away from us, which by the way, everyone should have access to, but we should also have access to safe health care, and i didn't realize that these laws were also going to prevent women from being able to access health care. >> i just want to -- please. >> that's the amazing thing, that a lot of people didn't realize it until after this took place. you know, we have been fighting and talking to women forever, but people don't ever think their rights can be taken. that's why nobody ever took it seriously, even when they saw it in the news, nobody took it seriously until afterwards. and then everybody was like, there's no way that's possible. i'm like, yeah. it's possible. >> there's a saying, a quote
4:15 pm
from coretta scott king. and she said the fight for civil rights, which is the right of individuals to make decisions for themselves about their own life, the fight for civil rights must be fought and won with each generation. the point being that if we are not vigilant, we might see these rights go away. so we must be vigilant every day. and this issue, joy, as you mentioned, you know, it's so fundamentally is about freedom. freedom. the freedom, the ability of an individual to make decisions about their own life. and literally their own body. and i think there's some piece of this also that underlying it all is hey, trust women. trust them to know what is in their best interest. what are we saying, that a bunch of people in a state capital in washington, d.c. are in a better position to make a decision for
4:16 pm
her than she is? in terms of what is in her best interest, the best interest of her family. especially when we consider that the majority of women who receive abortion care are mothers. and when they're making that decision about what is in their best interest, it takes into account usually so many people beyond herself. and deciding what is best. >> yeah. >> so but it truly was the decision when it came down to amanda's point, was really about the creation of a health care crisis in america. >> indeed. >> because it is not only about abortion care. it is about access to reproductive care, access to doctors, access to ob/gyns. the data shows us in a state like texas, ob/gyns are only in half the counties. they're only in half the counties. >> you're getting an amen from
4:17 pm
the doctor at the table. >> we're going to take a quick break and when we come back, we're going to ask our doctor about the state of health care in texas without roe, and we're going to ask our representative from the young generation who is essentially growing up without this right, so much more with vice president kamala harris and our wonderful guests when our reidout special one year post-roe continues.
4:18 pm
4:19 pm
4:20 pm
when i first learned about my dupuytren's contracture, my physician referred me to a hand specialist. and i'm glad he did, because when i took the tabletop test, i couldn't lay my hand flat anymore. the first hand specialist i saw only offered surgery. so, i went to a second hand specialist who also offered nonsurgical options - which felt more right for me. so, what i'd say to other people with dupuytren's contracture is this: don't wait —find a hand specialist trained in nonsurgical options, today. i found mine at findahandspecialist.com.
4:21 pm
i'm back with the honorable kamala harris, vice president of the united states, and my panel, genesis sanchez, an abortion rights advocate. amanda zarowski, shannon brewer, executive director of the las cruces women's health organization in new mexico, and dr. todd ivy who is an ob/gyn in texas. we were beginning to chat about the consequences, and the vice president made an excellent point about when you eliminate abortion, you sometimes eliminate doctors. >> and that is absolutely true. we're seeing many effects downstream effects from this. one thing is on education of physicians in our state. what we see nationally is in states that have restrictive abortion laws, there's been a 10% decrease in medical students going into the field of
4:22 pm
obstetrics and guncology. after the passive of sb-8, there was a 19% decrease in applicants in ob/gyn programs. this is the second largest state in the nation. we have four of the top 25 largest cities in the u.s. and as madam vice president pointed out, we have about 50% of our counties that have no practicing ob/gyn. >> that is because people are afraid to go to prison, they're afraid if they have to treat their patient, they could wind up in prison. >> many people don't understand the law, and i find my own friends don't actually understand what the texas law is. and basically, what the texas law says is you can make that decision if it's a life-threatening situation. but if we don't agree with you, we're coming after you. >> joy, here's the thing. the doctor has been
4:23 pm
extraordinary in terms of the courage because also this is requiring so much courage from doctors who believe that women should not be deprived of access to reproductive health care, and the threats that so many have faced as a result of being outspoken. i admire your courage to speak so openly and publicly about it. but i have talked to -- amanda and i were in tallahassee together, and her story, like so many, is a story of going and needing emergency medical care, and being denied because of the confusion. and what we're seeing so many physicians and health care providers who are now really worried about what that does also in terms of access to all kinds of reproductive health care. in the top ten states with the worst maternal mortality, in the top ten states in the united states of america that have the worst maternal mortality, those top ten states also have bans in place. >> yeah. >> think about what that means
4:24 pm
and the hypocrisy at play when people purport to say that their position is because they care about women and children. but yet, you don't have and don't give them access to high quality and affordable care, including postpartum care, let's also talk about that. and what that means again in terms of, you know, really conflicting signals, but actually hypocrisy at play. >> i wonder, genesis, as our representative of gen z -- >> i'm a young millennial. >> very young millennial. >> i wonder, this is, i'm not going to age myself, but at least i lived most of my life with equal rights as a woman and an american. for you, it's gone like that. >> i remember a year ago when i heard the news, i was working and i was kind of, you know, in the heat of the moment, i was like, okay, that's bad. that's really bad. then a few hours later, i saw something online about how the
4:25 pm
last clinic in texas shut down, and i started to cry because i thought of all those young people who now no longer can go to that clinic because they need the full gamut and spectrum of reproductive health care. and i think to madam vice president's point, this isn't just about abortion. this is about the entire spectrum of care, and young people are now afraid to seek that care because we know that bans also disproportionately impact black and latina women, and they're the ones who are also being prosecuted for accessing pills for helping their friends, they might experience domestic violence from their partner for seeking abortion care. so we're seeing the negative ramifications. and those are just some of the stories we're hearing. they don't fully encompass what people are experiencing privately. >> i don't know about you, but i know when i was just out of college, i got all my health care at planned parenthood. it wasn't just -- i wasn't going there for abortions.
4:26 pm
i was going there for everything because i didn't have health insurance. so talk a little bit, you ran a clinic. you were providing care in general for women. >> yeah. women, they have nowhere. we were providing birth control. they have nowhere to get birth control now. the reason we were doing it in jackson is because they didn't have access. so now, i don't know what those women are going to do. and that's the thing that aggravates me the most, is that they will take away so much, but they won't find an answer to, you know, to provide basic needs for these women. and that's what's really detrimental to the women, actually, in mississippi and everywhere. >> joy, you mentioned college. so my goddaughter is a senior, just graduated from high school, on her way to college. but she called me, auntie, she said, when the decision came down. and she said, do you know what's happening? my friends, whatever gender, are
4:27 pm
starting to make decisions about where they will actually go to college depending on what's happening in that state. because of course, if you look at it, i think the number is something like 23 million women of reproductive age live in states that have banned abortion. and what that is going to mean for those 23 million, for the myriad of health care issues that are at stake as we have just been discussing. it's having a real impact on all types of decisions that people are able to make. >> if my children -- they're out of college now, but i would not let them choose a red state. i wouldn't let them choose a state that banned abortion. can you talk about the very specific medical consequences that you're seeing, doctor, taking place here. >> absolutely. we fully expect an increase in maternal mortality and morbidity, an increase in those rates. now, the numbers aren't in yet, and of course, the pandemic complicates that. the last information from texas was through 2019.
4:28 pm
and we saw that the maternal mortality rate was just about stable. but now we're seeing delays in care, patients are sicker, and before they can be intervened upon. it's absolutely gut-wrenching to sit there and see a woman get so sick when you know that you could help her before that ever happens. we are seeing increased strains on families, families now have to travel, and of course, women with fewer resources are disproportionately impacted by this. so now, they take time off work, have to get child care, travel to new mexico or another state. huge financial strain. >> doctor, could you also talk a bit about, joy, if you don't mind. >> please, absolutely. >> i'm hearing countless stories of women who are in the process of miscarriage, intended to take
4:29 pm
pregnancy to term, and are in the process of miscarriage, and are having to travel from places like texas to colorado, places like texas or florida to seattle. to get care, to address their miscarriage, and the stories i have heard include women so afraid that during that plane trip she might actually miscarry, but she cannot get care in the place where she lives. and think about what that means. in terms of the emotional trauma that is re-enforced by all of these laws. she's already experiencing emotional trauma because of what is happening and then requiring her to go through tsa, get on a plane with perfect strangers, to seek help, if she can afford to actually travel. >> and it's dangerous. >> and it's dangerous. >> absolutely dangerous. you know, i have a story, i walked into work one day and
4:30 pm
there was a patient who had just had a baby about six months before. had chronic kidney disease and hypertension and could not access contraception and had a hemoglobin, was very anemic. it was about half of what ours would be. she had ruptured membranes at 17 weeks. so because the baby still had a heart beat, because the fetus still had a heart beat, we were unable to provide care until her condition takes, becomes life-threatening. >> i mean, and this is -- and i hope this is not triggering for you to have to talk about it, but there are real people. you are a real person who went through this kind of situation. >> yep. >> what does your doctor say to you in that moment? >> well, the situation you're describing is exactly what happened to me. and the laws in texas were so new, and there was so much confusion. and nobody knew what they could or couldn't do. so it just incited so much fear, not just for me but for my health care team.
4:31 pm
because they didn't know what they were allowed to do with their professional training. and so you mentioned the emotional trauma. i couldn't leave the state, and if i had, i probably would have died. so i had to just wait until i did become near death. it took three days, and the trauma of that waiting and being in terror and fear for those three days, not knowing what's going to happen while having just received this devastating news, i mean, it's cruel. it is inhumane. >> and the reality is, the people making these decisions aren't doctors. >> they're a bunch of politicians in state capitols or in washington, d.c. many of whom don't even know how a woman's body works, by the way. i might add, doctor. >> that's true. you know, i tell this story, we were at one of our elected official's offices in d.c. and we were visiting, not discussing abortion, and the
4:32 pm
assistant brought this up to us and said, you know, y'all need to stay in your lane. you don't need to be in politics. you're a medical expert. stick to medicine. now, i politely handled it, however, my knee jerk response in my mind was, if you want to keep medicine out of politics, then you keep politics out of medicine. >> amen. amen. and hallelujah. well, amanda and dr. ivey, thank you very much. we will be praying for you that whatever you want in life comes to you. and you have been through a lot, so please keep up with us on the lawsuit. thank you so much. so much more ahead with vice president kamala harris and our wonderful guests. stay right there.
4:33 pm
as someone living with type 2 diabetes, i want to keep it real and talk about some risks. with type 2 diabetes you have up to 4 times greater risk of stroke, heart attack, or death. even at your a1c goal, you're still at risk ...which if ignored could bring you here... ...may put you in one of those... ...or even worse. too much? that's the point. get real about your risks and do something about it. talk to your health care provider about ways to lower your risk of stroke, heart attack, or death. learn more at getrealaboutdiabetes.com
4:34 pm
when i was diagnosed with h-i-v, i didn't know who i would be. but here i am... being me. keep being you... and ask your healthcare provider about the number one prescribed h-i-v treatment, biktarvy. biktarvy is a complete, one-pill, once-a-day treatment used for h-i-v in many people whether you're 18 or 80. with one small pill, biktarvy fights h-i-v to help you get to undetectable—and stay there whether you're just starting or replacing your current treatment. research shows that taking h-i-v treatment as prescribed and getting to and staying undetectable prevents transmitting h-i-v through sex. serious side effects can occur, including kidney problems and kidney failure. rare, life-threatening side effects include a buildup of lactic acid and liver problems. do not take biktarvy if you take dofetilide or rifampin. tell your healthcare provider about all the medicines and supplements you take, if you are pregnant or breastfeeding, or if you have kidney or liver problems, including hepatitis. if you have hepatitis b do not stop taking biktarvy without talking to your healthcare provider. common side effects were diarrhea, nausea, and headache. no matter where life takes you, biktarvy can go with you. talk to your healthcare provider today.
4:35 pm
what do we always say, son? liberty mutual customizes your car insurance... so you only pay for what you need. that's my boy. ♪ stay off the freeways! only pay for what you need. ♪ liberty. liberty. liberty. liberty. ♪ nexium 24hr prevents heartburn acid for twice as long as pepcid. get all-day and all-night heartburn acid prevention with just one pill a day. choose acid prevention. choose nexium.
4:36 pm
narrator: it's called, “shared leadership.” driven by each community in a groundbreaking setting: california's community schools. where parents and families, students and educators, make decisions as one. creating the school and shaping futures - together. based on the needs of their students... ...steeped in local culture. curriculum from cyber security to gardening. and assisting families with their needs: wellness centers, food pantries, and parental education. california's community schools: reimagining public education. i am back with vice president kamala harris, genesis
4:37 pm
sanchez, and shannon brewer are still with me. and joining the conversation is annie runo, associate editor at upworthy, and rachel sweet, former campaign manager for kansans for constitutional freedom. i want to start with you, madam vice president. you were headed to north carolina, which recently overrode the veto of the governor who attempted to stop an abortion ban. that's locked the entire south in. why north carolina, and what are you hoping to achieve there? >> so, i'll be there for the one-year mark of the dobbs decision, which is this saturday, in four days. to again, discuss and to be right there at a ground zero. why this is an issue that all americans should care about. independent of the choices they would personally make for themselves. this is fundamentally about freedom. the right to make decisions about your own life and your own
4:38 pm
body. and this is a foundational principle for our country. we were founded on the notion that government should at some point stay out of people's business. >> yeah. >> to say it in an academic way. >> legal. >> a legal matter. and when we think about this and connect this with so many other issues, i think we all have to stand up and say that, you know, we as a nation stand for the principle of freedom. if i may, i'll share with you another way to think of this. i have now as vice president me. presidents, prime ministers, chancellors, and kings. when we as the united states of america walk in those rooms, we walk in with the authority to talk about the importance of democracy, of individual rights, human rights, rule of law.
4:39 pm
and in that way, we are a role model. we have held ourselves out to be a role model. but when you're a role model, everybody here at this table knows, people watch what you do to see if it matches up to what you say. people around the world are watching what's happening here. my greatest fear is women fighting for basic rights in various countries, that their so-called leaders, autocrats, dictators will look at them and say you want to hold up the united states as an example? look what they're doing. you be quiet. this issue, in addition to affecting real people every day as we have discussed, also calls into play our commitment to a foundational concept which is that of freedom. >> and you know, annie, we have a fundamental principle here that is also separation of church and state. and we know that for people who oppose abortion, for a lot of them, it is a deeply held
4:40 pm
religious issue. and i think for a lot of people they find it hard to separate from what they want done in law. >> yes. >> i would love for you to talk a little bit about that. >> sure. so i'm a political independent, which is the largest voting bloc in the nation. and i have zero interest in the partisan conflict about this issue. and i think most americans are kind of there in this sort of messy middle of trying to figure out where they stand morally, where they stand legally on this issue. part of the problem is there's been this conflation of the moral and legal. so i consider myself morally pro-life in that i'm 48 years old, i have three children who are almost grown and flown at this point. if i found out i was pregnant tomorrow, that would be a huge upheaval in my life, that would be an unwanted pregnancy, i don't want to get pregnant at this point, but if i did, i would not choose to have an abortion because of my personal
4:41 pm
religious moral beliefs about when life begins, the nature of the human soul and what not, but i also don't think that my personal moral religious convictions should be applied to everybody legally, like that doesn't make any sense. i wouldn't want anybody else's religious beliefs to dictate the laws that dictate my choices about how i live my life. i don't think that we should expect anybody to want that, especially as americans. it's right there in our first amendment. we don't establish religion. regardless of how strongly i feel about the fact i would not choose to have an abortion and there are religious and moral reasons for that, and we can have those moral debates all day long, that's a different debate than whether it should be legal for people to make that choice. >> rachel, you dealt with this, i'm sure, in kansas. kansas is a conservative state. the people there are very conservative. and yet. >> and yet. >> you led the fight to enshrine the right to an abortion or to stop them from taking away abortion rights in kansas. you're doing now the same in
4:42 pm
kentucky and in other states. it is a powerful political issue even when people have a moral opposition. >> yeah, it absolutely is. i think the 2022 campaigns really taught us that we as americans are far more unified on this issue than we are divided. a lot of prominent conservatives when the dobbs decision came down, remember, were saying, you know, this is about returning the issue to the states. we need to let the states decide. guess what, the states are starting to speak. when you give voters the opportunity to vote directly on this issue, they will vote to protect reproductive freedom every time. and especially in states like kansas and kentucky. that doesn't just mean democratic voters. that means republican voters. that means independent voters. and i think it's really powerful just to see that whether it's -- if it's a partisan issue in the halls of congress, a partisan issue in our state legislatures but in people's everyday lives it's a health care issue, a privacy issue, it's a fundamental personal liberty and
4:43 pm
freedom issue. and that is how we dealt with this issue in kansas, because yeah, we had to talk to a lot of people that may not agree with us on everything, but when you really get down to what should the government's role be in this decision, kansans, kentuckians, michiganders, every state where this issue was at the forefront have said that no, we need to keep the government out of our business and we need to protect the legal right to abortion. >> is it an issue? i wonder if it's an issue. i think there's a presumption for latinas, for people who are hispanic, it's a moral issue and that they will not vote on it. and that it will not move and it will not change. but i think there are a lot of republicans who assume this is actually going to be helpful to them to ban abortion in states like texas. is that true? >> i don't think so. i think to rachel's point, we have seen that the majority of americans support abortion and the access to abortion. and so that runs the gamut of people. that includes immigrant women,
4:44 pm
it includes people in red states, right? but because abortion bans target red states, those are also states where a lot of red lining happens, where people don't have access to the vote in ways that other people do. so they may want to vote for a pro-abortion candidate, but they don't have access to that, they can't. so i think it's more that, you know, i think there's an idea that we are maybe more conservative or we lean into those catholic ideals, but the reality is that just as rachel said, what we're living day to day is very different from what we want politicians to do and how we want them to vote. i think that's why it's so important. we need to keep politics off our bodies. >> hello red state, mississippi. >> i think she's right. i think a big part of the problem is that number one, we're not voting. you know, the big portion that
4:45 pm
should be voting is not voting. and they are making it harder and harder, passing -- constantly passing different laws in each state to make it harder for certain people to vote. which are the people who are being affected by this the most. so we need to be fighting in these states for your voting rights. that's important. people didn't think that was important before. i think they're starting to realize it. as i speak to people now, they seem to realize that it starts on the state level. that's how it becomes so big. and you have got to tackle it while it's on that state level. >> you know, i couldn't agree with you more. and actually, if you do just a quick analysis of which states, from which states you're seeing attacks on the freedom to make decisions about your own body, the freedom to have access to the ballot box, the freedom to love and marry who you love and be open about that, you will see
4:46 pm
a significant overlap. and i couldn't agree with you more. that what kansas and your leadership and the leadership of so many people showed us is that when you remind people that they have power through their vote to weigh in on this issue, they do it. from kansas to california. red states, blue states. we saw whenever it was on the ballot in the midterms, people voted in favor of the freedom of the american people to make decisions about their own body. and i think that should give us the momentum that we need to know that we have to encourage people to use their vote, because ultimately, this is an issue that will be resolved by federal legislation that codifies, which means puts into law the protections of roe. but i also will remind people, let's not overlook local and state elections. because if you live in a state
4:47 pm
that has criminalized health care providers and provides for jail time, pay attention to who your prosecutor is. pay attention to who your state legislator is. if your state is passing laws to either protect the right or attack the right, pay attention to who your attorney general is. who your governor is. but ultimately, the united states congress can put back in place what the united states supreme court took. the united states supreme court took a constitutional right. the united states congress has the power to put in place a protection of that individual privacy right that all americans should be entitled to. >> that is a perfect place for us to take a quick break because when i come back, i want to ask you all about this national landscape. first what the administration can do, what congress might do, but also what some judges might do. we are awaiting a ruling on mifepristone, on whether or not we can have an effective national abortion ban or maybe
4:48 pm
even a legislative national abortion ban. senator lindsey graham and others have talked about it. we're going to get into that and talk about what we do next. stay with us as our discussion continues with vice president kamala harris and on our "the reidout" special one year post-roe. love you. have a good day, behave yourself. like she goes to work at three in the afternoon and sometimes gets off at midnight. she works a lot, a whole lot. we don't get to eat in the early morning. we just wait till we get to the school. so, yeah. right now here in america, millions of kids like victoria and andre live with hunger, and the need to help them has never been greater. when you join your friends, neighbors and me to support no kid hungry, you'll help hungry kids get the food they need. if we want to take care of our children, then we have to feed them. your gift of just $0.63 a day, only $19 a month
4:49 pm
at helpnokidhungry.org right now will help provide healthy meals and hope. we want our children to grow and thrive and to just not have to worry and face themselves with the struggles that we endure. nobody wants that for their children. like if these programs didn't exist me and aj, we wouldn't probably get lunch at all. please call or go online right now with your gift of just $19 a month. and when you use your credit card, you'll receive this limited edition t-shirt to show you're part of the team that's helping feed kids and change lives. if you're coming in hungry, there's no way you can listen to me teach, do this activity, work with this group. so starting their day with breakfast and ending their day with this big, beautiful snack is pretty incredible. whether kids are learning at school or at home, your support will ensure they get the healthy meals they need to thrive. because when you help feed kids,
4:50 pm
you feed their hopes, their dreams, and futures. kids need you now more than ever. so please call this number right now to join me in helping hungry kids or go online to helpnokidhungry.org and help feed hungry kids today. trelegy for copd. ♪birds flyin' high, you know how i feel.♪ ♪breeze driftin' on by...♪ ♪...you know how i feel.♪ you don't have to take... [coughing] ...copd sitting down. ♪it's a new dawn,...♪ ♪...it's a new day,♪ it's time to make a stand. ♪and i'm feelin' good.♪ start a new day with trelegy. no once-daily copd... ...medicine has the power to treat copd... ...in as many ways as trelegy. with three medicines in one inhaler,... ...trelegy makes breathing easier for a full 24 hours, improves lung function, and helps prevent future flare-ups. trelegy won't replace a rescue inhaler... ...for sudden breathing problems. tell your doctor if you have a heart condition or high blood pressure before taking it. do not take trelegy more than prescribed.
4:51 pm
trelegy may increase your risk of thrush, pneumonia, and osteoporosis. call your doctor if worsened breathing, chest pain, mouth or tongue swelling, problems urinating,... ...vision changes, or eye pain occur. >> i am back, with vice take a stand, and start a new day with trelegy. ask your doctor about once-daily trelegy... ...and save at trelegy.com.
4:52 pm
president kamala harris, and our wonderful panel. we want to talk about what happens next. we are awaiting a ruling on the idea of whether mifepristone can be banned. there is a texas federal judge who has said it should be banned. what are the implications if that band stands up to supreme court scrutiny? >> joy, the implications are profound. let's step back and understand. essentially, what this lawsuit is doing, is attacking the ability of the fda to determine what is safe and healthy for
4:53 pm
the american people to use, as has been prescribed by a doctor. now, conjecturally, understand the fda has been doing this for 80 plus years. and their process is, it is his medically reviewed scientists, peer reviewed -- and they take a very seriously. and when they make a decision something safe and effective, it is because it is actually safe and effective. >> right. >> mifepristone they, made that decision about that medication 20 years ago. >> right. >> and it has been proven to be safe and effective for its first drive use for those 20 years. these folks, who are politicians, are now encouraging lawyers to encourage a judge -- not a medical doctor -- to decide, and put in place their judgment over the judgment of the fda. i ask people, if you understand what this means, you should understand that you ought to go and look in your medicine cabinet, and look at your drugs -- the medications that you may have there could be anything
4:54 pm
from insulin to what you need from for blood pressure, chemotherapy drugs -- are arguably up to attack. this is so wide sweeping and wide ranging in terms of the implications. and it is also another example of how we are in the midst of a health care crisis, where we are literally at a place where politicians are urging lawyers -- by the way, they form shopped in finding that judge. >> correct. >> -- are trying to replace the decisions of medical professionals, about a medication that is prescribed and is safe and effective for its use. >> if the implications -- there frightening. so, we are fighting this, at the moment, state by state. it could soon we'll be national. but let's start with it by state, rachel sweet. you are headed to ohio. how do we do this -- >> i'm really honored to be
4:55 pm
working at the team for ohioans for pre-freedom, that's ohioans- forreproductivefreedom.org -- we know that if the american people are given the opportunity to vote on this issue, they will stand united and protect the right to abortion. the problem is, our opposition also knows that. and, so instead of just attacking abortion rights, they are also waging war on direct democracy, on the initiative petition process, on the ability of states to even put this issue to a vote in 2023 and 2024. ohio is a really great example. in august, voters will have the opportunity to vote on issue one, which is a constitutional amendment that would make it so that all future ballot measures must pass with a 60% majority instead of a simple majority. and that was placed on the ballot specifically to make things harder for the reproductive freedom measure in november of 2023. so, it's just a good reminder for all of us that there is so much intersection with these
4:56 pm
issues, with voting rights -- >> absolutely. >> -- with direct democracy. and we have to use every single tool in our tool box to make -- >> and any, how do we have a conversation with these people who have a moral objection? >> i think the key is keeping it in that realm of the right medical privacy, which is really what roe is really back to begin with. my daughter had a ruptured appendix a couple of months ago and had a surgery, and had an abscess come back a couple weeks later, and had a second surgery. and in that process we were in the hospital room talking with her surgeon, talking with her doctors about the different choices that they were going to make in her care, where we had choices in her care -- i cannot even imagine the ludicrousness of having politicians in that room with us -- dictating what choices we can make about that. and that is not anything as consequential as pregnancy and childbirth and all of that. so, yeah, just keeping it in the realm of medical privacy. >> it keeps it fair and symbol. >> yeah. >> and genesis sanchez, how do we make sure people understand
4:57 pm
this nexus between the right to vote, between their need for medical privacy? >> yeah, i will speak to what you said. roe v. wade was about the right to privacy. and when you start to talk about, here are all the things that could go away, you are all the things that are coming down, i think that motivates people to either vote or to mobilize in their communities. and something that we know to be true, generations before us know, and we know now, is that you cannot ban abortion. you can only than safe abortions. >> that's right. >> and so people are still go to safe care. it's only going to get more and more dangerous. i encourage people to donate to their local abortion funds, so that we can fly texans to new mexico and get that care that they need. >> and you are going to keep fighting? >> yeah, we are just doing to keep opening clinics. every time we closed them down we are -- >> them closed -- >> we have open three in a year's time. we are just determined that women are going to have access, no matter what. >> a man. freedom is very hard to take away from people, vice
4:58 pm
president kamala harris. it makes people focused, they are focused. how is the administration going to respond to this moment? >> well, on the mifepristone issue, for example, we are fighting in the, courts we are going to keep fighting. because we also know that the majority of folks who receive this kind of care receive it through mifepristone. and so we are dealing with that. we are fighting on the -- also, the point that is a fundamental point. no one, regardless of their gender or condition, should be denied access to emergency health care. >> right. >> so, in our previous panel, for example, we talked with amanda. no one should be denied -- as amanda said, but also, we are fighting on patient privacy. this is absolutely about a private decisions that individual should be able to make, in consultation with their health care professional, and not worry about that information becoming public or being used, for example, by law enforcement. >> right.
4:59 pm
>> it's one of the things we are doing is fighting against law enforcement having access to this private information, for the sake of criminalizing someone who just, essentially, once health care. but i will say, joy, the bottom line is this. we have got to understand the connection between this issue and elections. elections matter. we have seen that in the work that has been done in the various states. we need a united states congress who understands and appreciates the exact point that has been made at this table. it is the individual, right the privacy right, of people, to make this decision, not having the government make this decision for them. >> yeah. and let me tell you something. our president, joe biden, when that legislation gets passed, to codify and put in place the protections of roe v. wade, joe biden will sign it. >> all right. >> so, let's make sure, everybody that you know is register to vote, like you were talking about. let's make sure that people
5:00 pm
understand the power of their voice on this. because we have seen how it has an impact. and so much of this discussion that you have brought us together for is about really fully appreciating that this is not some conceptual issue. >> that's right, that's right. >> it's about real people, every day, who, for the most part, are silently suffering. and we as a society that should care, should care enough to vote. >> amen! and while -- you can get a amen, even though it is not sunday. >> i appreciate that. >> tell your neighbor! amen. i want to thank the honorable kamala harris for, making the, time vice president of the whole united states, he came and said at this wonderful table, and all our incredible guests tonight for this very enlightening discussion. that is tonight's reidout. from dallas, texas, thank y'all for tuning in. for tuning in. >>
107 Views
IN COLLECTIONS
MSNBC West Television Archive Television Archive News Search ServiceUploaded by TV Archive on