Skip to main content

tv   Hardball With Chris Matthews  MSNBC  April 22, 2010 12:00am-1:00am EDT

12:00 am
for his re-election campaign out in arizona. is this constitutional? that's one the questions. and finally an odd one from nevada, a republican candidate for the senate's proposal to replace health care payments with a barter system, as in you know you bring your doctor a chicken or a sack of potatoes to pay for a treatment. i guess that's what they mean by repeal and replace. let's start with the big news out of florida. there could be a big problem for republicans down there. beth reinhart is a political reporter for "the miami herald." and jay weaver is "the herald's" investigative reporter. i want to start with the fact. i want to be joe friday, so let's start with jay. what is the hard news about the irs investigation and the justice investigation of marc rubio? what is there? >> well, pure and simple, the
12:01 am
republican party of florida for years has issued credit cards to its senior officials and to its senior politicians. and, of course, they're supposed to use these american express credit cards for political purposes only. it's a nonprofit organization. they collect millions from fat cat donors and they're supposed to use it to advance the party agenda and to advance candidates. well, as it turns out, records obtained by "the miami herald" have shown that they were using a lot of these credit cards for personal good times. you know chic hotels, jet travel, five-star restaurants. so the irs has basically been snooping around and they have opened cases against some of these senior officials including a former house speaker out of north florida, but they're also opening an inquiry into marco rubio, the former house speaker and now u.s. senate candidate in the republican column against governor charlie crist. and they basically want to know whether or not he used or personally benefited from this credit card usage? and he's not the only one in the cross hairs. >> okay. >> there are others, too. and that's where it stands. we're talking about millions of dollars here.
12:02 am
>> well, let me go right down to beth, in terms of the impact statement here. politically, does this in any way, shake rubio's position as the clear front-runner in that primary fight? >> i think it shakes a little bit, but to his credit, he's really established himself. he's so far ahead of the governor right now. and the governor's credibility with voters is really strained at this point. they don't necessarily trust him the way they used to and so when he attacks rubio on his credit card spending, these voters that i've talked to don't look at it the same way. >> are they going to blame -- will the conservative voters on the side of the republican party, are they going to blame him for having dropped the dime on rubio? beth? >> oh absolutely. they -- they, you know, they -- they try to diminish the stories that we've written by saying, you know, they're all leaked by
12:03 am
crist. i saw one blogger said something about you know the credit card statements taken by crist without his permission, which you know, i think is pretty wild speculation. >> let me go over -- let me go over to jay on this whole question now. you and i had -- reporters -- i've been a reporters for years. back when i had expense accounts as a print guy, they always told us, just keep it clean. the pros who check the cards, will know what is clean. don't worry about the little details, just be clean about it. when you looked through these did you get a smell factor, wait a minute, there's something here. this guy's not using his card right. rubio? >> well, sure, in rubio's case, to be fair, it appears that he wasn't quite as big of a spender as, say, the party chairman of the executive director. >> jim greer. >> and some these other politicians. >> yes, jim greer is the party chairman who's -- who's under scrutiny.
12:04 am
and, you know, there were others that spent a lot more money than rubio. >> okay, let me get to the quick here. when i was looking -- our producers were all going through it, we're looking at one that was particularly weird. if you go to somebody's event and your card gets side swiped or something and the guy who parked the car, this is the one that jumped out at us. do you think that was over the top for rubio or is that a standard kind of expense? if you go to an event, and your car gets side swiped when the guy parks your car, you shouldn't have to pay for that out your personal life. what do you think of that expense, as a reporter? >> well, let me use your example. look, i mean, i wouldn't have build it to "the miami herald." "the miami herald" issues credit cards at least in the olden days. their expenses that are business related are put on the credit card. >> right. >> so obviously if that had happened to my car in front a valet damaged i wouldn't have built it to the republican party or "the miami herald" in this instance, this hypothetical instance. i obviously would have billed it on my own credit card.
12:05 am
it's a personal expense. >> you think that might be -- you think it reaches the level of -- there's an irs investigation, there's also a justice investigation, a criminal investigation going on down there, is it fair, just for tonight's broadcast, to say that marco rubio is not under criminal investigation? as far as we know. >> i think it's fair to say it's not -- i think it's fair to say he's not under criminal investigation but i think what is fair to say is that they're looking to see whether the numbers are bigger than just that minivan, you know, accident that occurred in front of the valet. i think it's a situation where they have to find a lot of examples of that to show he was not reporting income that he should have or that he was falsely -- falsely putting information on his income tax returns that he shouldn't have. and he will have to account for that. if it's in the hundreds of thousands of dollars it might be an issue. if it's in the tens of thousands of dollars and he can explain it may be just more of a civil matter. >> what strikes me, beth, the political thing. that's what we cover here.
12:06 am
we're not investigative reporters. we do enjoy their work, however. let me ask you, beth, about this question. this is the first time nationally that one the tea party, well -- pinup boys or pinup girls, whatever, has gotten this scrutiny by the press. they're now in the heat of the kitchen as harry truman would say. if you don't like the heat day out of the kitchen. finally, it's not rand paul, not one of the others. it's this guy. what about the impact? are they ready to take the heat? it looks like he knows what he's door, my firsthand look at the guy. look at what he put out. he put out a statement whacking other guy. all the negative publicity regarding the way that charlie crist handpicked chairman spent money in the party. he's going after him. and the best way to deal with that as far as my spending is concerned, you know, he keeps going here. it was legitimate political purposes i spent the money. i paid for them directly to american express. i've not been contacted. i don't know anything about any potential inquiries but i welcome the chance to set record straight once and for all. so he's dealing with this frontally but all the time
12:07 am
whacking the other sigh, jim greer, who is charlie crist's guy. can he push in guilt over to crist, not only does crist get hit for dropping the dime on him but it looks like he's tainting himself in the act. >> well, you know, the -- marco rubio's credit card statements, you know we obtained them back in february and we've been writing about his spending through the credit card and also through some political committees he set up. you know, for several months. and the governor, of course, seized on that immediately and was running attack ads on television. they didn't appear to work. they -- you know he remained as far behind in the polls, if not got a little farther behind. and the governor took down the television ads. so as i was saying before you know the timing is not in the governor's favor, in that he -- his credibility is strained. and rubio has this reservoir of goodwill with, as you say, the tea party crowd. >> okay. well, thank you very much. we'll be watching this whether
12:08 am
he changes parties and goes independent or not. thank you for the investigative work and political work on this. coming up, president obama says it is time to get tough on wall street be, but how tough is this guy going to get? is he going to be teddy roosevelt or what? but first who is winning the money race right now for november, democrats or republicans? the answer to that coming up during the commercial in just one minute. ♪ ♪ [ bell rings ] ♪ [ male announcer ] at&t. the nation's fastest 3g network. this mother's day, get 50% off all messaging phones after mail-in rebate, like the pantech reveal, only from at&t. [ thunder and cracks of lightning ] whatever i did, my digestive upsets came back. but then came align with bifantis. it helps build and maintain a healthy digestive system to restore my natural digestive balance
12:09 am
....and protect against occasional digestive upsets. align brings peace to my digestive system... and the money back guarantee brings peace to me. who has more money for november, democrats or republicans? well the democratic congressional campaign committee ended march with $26 million in cash on hand, compared to just $10 million the national republican congressional committee had in the bank. during march alone the dccc had it around $1 million while the rnc down under $10. [ female announcer ] breathe right asks... [ woman ] could i ask you to strip on the street? absolutely! i have a lot of stuffiness at night. it wakes me up. i have allergies. ♪ you're right. i'm getting more air. -oh, yeah. -oh, wow! [ female announcer ] for two free samples, go to breatheright.com. so, at national, i go right past the counter...
12:10 am
and you get to choose any car in the aisle. choose any car? you cannot be serious! okay. seriously, you choose. go national. go like a pro. 0 to 60? or 60 to 0? [ tires screech ] how a car performs in a quarter-mile? [ engine revs ] or a quarter-century? is performance about the joy of driving? or the importance... of surviving. to us, performance is not about doing one thing well. it is about doing everything well. because in the end... everything matters. performance without compromise. that is what drives us.
12:11 am
welcome back to "hardball." president obama's gearing up today to press his case for wall street cleanup. tomorrow he's going up to new york, and today about 1:30 he told cnbc's chief washington correspondent, john harwood that wall street's wild gambles have to come to an end.
12:12 am
john harwood joins us now, along with savannah guthrie, who is a white house correspondent for nbc. john, you asked the president if wall street has done enough to police itself in the wake of the crash. let's listen. you give me your sense of it afterwards. here's the president. >> when you spoke in new york a few months ago to a lot of those wall street executives, you urged them -- even in the absence of a law -- to take to heart the need to change the way they do business. >> right. >> have they done that? >> not as much as i would like. i mean, look, i think that you don't want to paint with too broad a brush. each financial institution is different. i do think that there is a sense of now that the crisis is over, let's go back to business as usual. >> john, do you have a sense that he's more reflective, a little more nuanced in talking to you than he's been in some these more barn-burning statements that he's made on the air? >> reporter: i do, chris, and i
12:13 am
think that's because he senses that a deal is beginning to come together between democrats and republicans. i talked to a top staffer on the banking committee this afternoon who said we're close to make a deal with the republicans, and i think the president dialed back the rhetoric a little bit. you didn't hear all of the stuff about, you know, fat cats and obscene bonuses and all of that sort of stuff. he was trying to present a rather cool and tempered demeanor i think. >> here's what the president said when you told him doesn't think wall street reform doesn't work as well for them. i love that. let's listen. >> that's not surprising. they've made out very well under a regime in which, when things were going well, they were making huge profits. and when things didn't go well and everything crashed, taxpayers were left footing the bill. i -- and i think the vast majority of americans think it is unacceptable to have a situation in which tails you in and, heads i lose. and taxpayers have been put in the position where they had to
12:14 am
make a choice a couple of years ago, either we let the entire economy crash because of irresponsibility on wall street or alternatively, we end up having to pony up money. >> speaking of ponying up money, savannah, as everybody who covers washington, you especially know that both parties feed at the trough of wall street when it comes to raising campaign money. is this president tiptoeing now, not just against some republicans aboard, but he knows by name a lot of people on wall street and he doesn't want them giving him a hard time when he comes back for money in the next campaign. >> oh, i don't know about that because i think it's where the rubber hits the road, right? he's still going forward with his financial regulatory reform that a lot of bankers don't like. he said to john harwood in that interview i thing he dodged the question of what he would give back or whether he was embarrassed about receiving that money from wall street. but what senior aides say here
12:15 am
to that argument, or to that suggestion is, look, the classic situation is, you get money from some corporate interest and then you go and do their bidding in government and here's an example of him doing precisely the opposite. but i thought the tone in john harwood's interview was notable and i think that we'll see something along those lines tomorrow when he makes this speech at cooper union in the shadow of wall street. it's not going to be one of these barn burners. he's not going to put the screws to wall street. he's going to say, can't we all get along in one form or another, saying it's in your interest to get behind reform. don't fight us. join us. >> chris -- >> go ahead, john. >> reporter: you may remember a famous quote where some politician said if you can't take their money and date their women -- i'm editing the quote. >> you are. >> reporter: you aren't worth a darn of a -- >> yeah, that's a california phrase and i love it well. the question is, is he tough enough to keep asking for the money?
12:16 am
and that's a good question. savannah, he will not stop asking for money, is he? >> oh, i don't know about that. i think that the dnc will continue with its lavish fund-raising. ip don't think anything in this proposal that would put an end to that so i wouldn't expect that to go away any time soon, no. both parties feed at that trough as you know. >> i know that they do. take a look at what the president will say. here's what the president told you that there's no connection between his push for financial reform and the timing of the s.e.c.'s -- no, this is responding to the charge from the republicans' side in the hill especially that he sort of went into cahoots with the s.e.c. and said let's score some political points in going after goldman sachs. let's listen to his response. >> i gave a speech about financial regulatory reform in 2007 before our current crisis, in 2008 before we fully knew what this crisis was going to be. we released financial reform as a package over a year ago. and so we're not johnny come latelies to this thing. we've been pushing this hard throughout and the s.e.c. is an entirely independent agency that we have no day-to-day control over.
12:17 am
and they never discussed with us anything with respect to the charge that will be brought. so this notion that somehow there would be any attempt to interfere in an independent agency is completely false. >> okay, john harwood, help me out here. why would it look bad for any politician to say let's get tough with these bad guys to any regulatory agency? i guess i don't sew see where there's a downside to saying, let's all be dick tracys here? >> reporter: i think you have a point, chris. i think the question is was there any interference? and the president was very strong in saying, absolutely there was not. >> i see. >> reporter: and you know he's pushing back against this mistrust in the country, and one of the things that people might point to, we'll see how the s.e.c.'s case turns out but greg craig, the former white house counsel has gone to now represent goldman and, again, if you're of a mind, as a lot of people are on the right, the left, to distrust the bonus of the government you may say, wait a minute, maybe that case was set up. >> yeah, let me ask savannah about the politics. it seems like during health care we all know this that it was kind a murky situation in terms of the public reaction. it was, at best, a 50/50 proposition in terms of an immediate crowd appeal.
12:18 am
it seems like this time the president is dancing on a floor that people want to see him on, which going after the wealthy people that may have misused their power on wall street. does he have a little lighter step right now, is he a happier guy going up to wall street than he was for fighting for health care? >> reporter: yeah, i think that they've recognized the populist feeling that's going on in the country right now is with them, anti-wall street. so they're also happy because they have a good economic story to tell. unemployment, there's not a lot of good news there. this is something affirmative they can do. they can say, look, we're cracking down on the banks, we're tighting up some of the worst practices. we're shutting down the casino. so the president may use conciliatory language but bottom line, they're saying, wall street, the party is over. we really want to tighten up this regulation and they need it because it's a counter-narrative to something that's come up over the last year.
12:19 am
a lot of people started to conflate the recovery act, stimulus act, the $70 billion act with the bailouts of wall street. so in a lot of ways the president was getting lumped with that kind of mr. bailout narrative. so this is a way for him to say, i'm fighting back against wall street. i'm trying to crackdown on them. and frankly, that's why democrats were not freaking out when there were 41 republican senators signing on a letter in opposition last week. they felt like at the end of the day, republicans are going to get cold feet, a few will peel off and we're going to get our bill. >> reporter: chris, you wouldn't dream up a fight more than the white house would want this
12:20 am
fight right now. >> well, is the president going to -- you're telling me, though, he's going to go up there more carefully than i might have thought of two days ago. >> reporter: well i think the level of the rhetoric may vary according to how much resistance he's getting from the other side. when he gave that radio address over the weekend and really whacked mitch mcconnell and the republicans and the special interest lobbyists, that's when it looked like they were standing up and saying, solid wall of opposition. now you see, mitch mcconnell saying, well, we're getting more serious about this now. and richard shelby says we're 85% close to a deal. and the democrats are also saying we're close. in that environment, i think the president is more confident and doesn't feel like he needs to hit them quite as hard. >> would he rather have about a handful of republicans with him and be a real teddy roosevelt or have 15, 20 with him and look like he's a little softer? john, your assessment? what do you think they'd like to see more, 75 votes or maybe 63 and make it a little tougher? >> reporter: i think it depends on what bill the larger group would sign on to. he knows he's got the whip hand in this debate right now. he's got the strongest position.
12:21 am
so he can hold tough on some the controversial elements and they'll come along. if he only got five for a tough bill i think we would take that, but if the whole rest of the crew wants to sign on board and have a consensus bill, i think he'll say, i made them take it. what republicans are going to say, by the the way, chris. we stood up against bailouts. we protected the taxpayer from that. >> thank you very much, john harwood. thank you, savannah guthrie at white house. has a healing touch. there's a factory giving old industries new life. and there's a train that got a whole city moving again. somewhere in america, the toughest questions are answered every day. because somewhere in america, more than sixty thousand people spend every day answering them. siemens. answers. i'm ed whitacre, from general motors. a lot of americans didn't agree with giving gm a second chance. quite frankly, i can respect that. we want to make this a company all americans can be proud of again. that's why i'm here to announce we have repaid our government loan, in full, with interest,
12:22 am
five years ahead of the original schedule. but there's still more to do. our goal is to exceed every expectation you've set for us. we're putting people back to work, designing, building, and selling the best cars and trucks in the world. with our 100,000-mile, 5-year powertrain warranty to guarantee the quality. and the unmatched life-saving technology of onstar to help keep you safe. from new energy solutions. to the designs of tomorrow. we invite you to take a look at the new gm.
12:23 am
12:24 am
back to "hardball." now for the "sideshow." first of all, it's not a sideshow when it's your money. but let's listen. >> so now, we will attempt to figure out just what exactly is going on at goldman sachs, that the s.e.c. is now charging them with fraud and on our continuing wall street segment -- these [ bleep ] guys. >> so here are the goldman sachs excuses. number nine -- you're saying "fraud" like it's a bad thing. number eight -- number four -- hey, sport, how much to make these questions go
12:25 am
away? number three -- american needed a villain both republicans and democrats can hate. and the number one goldman sachs excuse, it's obama's fault? >> why are government employees filing a civil suit against goldman sachs? that's just going to be embarrassing in a few years when they all go back to work at goldman sachs. >> regulate these derivative markets. who can disagree with that? >> republicans aren't beating around the bush anymore. they say flat-out they will filibuster new rules for the nation's financial system. gop senators contend the legislation would lead to more bank bailouts. >> these [ bleep ] guys. >> sorry, there's nothing funny about people being out there screwing up the american economy. just ask anyone out there right now trying to get a job or trying to get a loan. next, bartering for health care. that's a proposal being offered by republicans sue lowden of nevada who is running to replace senator harry reid this election. you know, given someone a bag of potatoes for getting your broken arm fixed.
12:26 am
here she was with her idea. >> let's change the system and talk about what the possibilities are. i'm telling you that this works. you know, before we all started having health care in the olden days our grandparents, they would bring a chicken to the doctor. they would say i will paint your house. they would do -- i mean, that's the old days of what people would do to get health care with their doctors. doctors are very sympathetic people. i'm not backing down from that system. >> bring a chicken to the doctor, paint their houses, is that what the republicans mean by repeal and replace? time now for the "big number." and it spells big trouble for senator jon ensign. remember ensign admitted last year to an affair with one of his staffer's wife, well his wife is currently under investigation as to whether he broke lobbying laws to help that staffer get another job. anyway, senator ensign hasn't yet said whether he's going to
12:27 am
run for re-election in 2012 but his first quarter of fund-raising number this year gives you an idea of just how tough it would be. according to talking points memo, just one person, one, donated to ensign's re-election so far, giving this senator a grand haul of $50 in fund-raising money. the lone donor actually explained his support saying, quote, all men are dogs. that's the donor talking. $50 total donated to senator jon ensign by that guy from one person, who said he's a dog. tonight, not a very "big number." up next arizona goes after illegal immigrants, and also after president obama's birth certificate. they still want another birth certificate. ya know, i'm really glad we finally decided to see where raisin bran crunch is made. yeah, this trip is way overdue. i just can't wait to see all those crunchy flakes in action. i hope i get a chance to put two scoops!™ of raisins in some boxes. you know what will really get us in the spirit? ♪ 99 boxes of raisin bran crunch ♪ ♪ if you're nice to me i'll share some with you ♪ ♪ you take one down ( and pass it around ) ♪ ♪ 98 boxes of raisin bran crunch ♪
12:28 am
three tasty ingredients, one great combination. ♪ raisin bran crunch! from kellogg! uh... yeah? you gonna ask him this time? about what? our erectile dysfunction. shh...no...i don't want to talk about it. look, you're not alone, millions of men with ed have talked to their doctors. i don't know... we can do this. okay...
12:29 am
(announcer) talking to your doctor about ed may be the last thing you want to do, but it's definitely a conversation worth having. twenty million men have had their viagra talk. when you're ready for yours... you'll find helpful tips on talking to your doctor at viagra.com ask your doctor if your heart is healthy enough for sex. don't take viagra if you take nitrates for chest pain as it may cause an unsafe drop in blood pressure. side effects may include headache, flushing, upset stomach, and abnormal vision. to avoid long-term injury, seek immediate medical help for an erection lasting more than four hours. stop taking viagra and call your doctor right away if you experience a sudden decrease or loss in vision or hearing. talk to your doctor today... and ask if viagra is right for you.
12:30 am
i'm lynn berry. here's what's happening. the coast guard has released the
12:31 am
first video of the oil platform burning off of the coast of louisiana. a company spokesofficial says there's no signs of any trouble before the explosion that left 17 workers hurt and 11 missing. workers mnlged to escape aboard a supply boat. on track to lose more than $2 billion after a volcano grounded thousands of flights next week. flight schedules are slowly turning to normal. the house has slowly released a bill for families caring for severely wounded veterans. and an ethics committee go -- a federal lawsuit is being filed in milwaukee and the top vatican officials of covering up hundreds of cases of sexual abuse in a school for boys. now back to "hardball."
quote
12:32 am
welcome back to "hardball." there's a big fight unfolding in the state of arizona over an immigration bill that would allow local law enforcement officials, police officers, to stop a person, they suspect, is an illegal immigrant. here's illinois congressman louis gutierrez. luis gutierrez reacting to the bill yesterday in washington. let's listen. >> the governor of arizona should veto the bill and if she doesn't, the president of the united states barack obama should assert federal government's preeminent role in regulating and enforcing our nation's immigration laws. the lunacy of rounding up people because they look a certain way are suspected of being in violation of immigration statutes can only lead to one thing, violations of people's basic fundamental civil rights. >> democratic congresswoman loretta sanchez from california sits on the homeland security
12:33 am
committee. and republican congressman brian bilbray of california is a member of the house immigration reform caucus. i want to get to this issue of birthing, or birthers because there's part of this legislation out there that are basically going to say future presidential candidates, they have to have birth certificates. let's start with this general issue. congresswoman sanchez, what's wrong with the state trying to enforce the law, the federal government never seems around to enforcing? they have half a million illegal immigrants in arizona. the federal government has dropped the ball. why shouldn't the state of arizona pick it up and do the job? >> well, actually the federal government has put more resources. many of the law enforcement agencies in arizona are under 287-g but what we find is they're not very well trained about what the rights are of people. so the problem with the law like this is that, for example, i'm hispanic. so if i go to arizona, does that mean i have to carry a copy of my birth certificate? and an affidavit and 14 signatures of witnesses to say
12:34 am
that i'm an american citizen? how do you suspect someone looks like something? that is the problem with the law like that. >> well, what is the law -- what would be a way that we could avoid all this and stop illegal immigration? do you support the idea of a biometric i.d. card that's actually checkable or not have a checkable i.d. card? do you want a checkable i.d. card? >> well, i actually am one of those people that like the freedoms of being in the united states and one of the things that we have always argued for was that we wouldn't have a national i.d. card, but again i'm also a person who lives under an i.d. card here in the congress, i live under a driver's license that's under the biometric i.d. for the future for california. so i mean, i'm already using that if i want to drive, i'm already using that if i want to come into the capitol. so personally i don't have a problem with it but there are a lot of conservatives who do.
12:35 am
>> well, that's their problem. the fact is you and i have to get on airplanes and show an honest i.d. card and if it's not an honest i.d. card, it's fraud. okay. and if we go to the bank and try to get money out and if it's not us, it's fraud. if we try to check into a hotel and use a phony name it's fraud. go the other congressman. what about arizona? why does states try to get into the business the federal government is into? which is protecting us from illegal immigration? >> well, i think the same reason they're involved in the drug war, too, chris, is that this is a community problem. it's not just a washington,
12:36 am
d.c., concern or just a border problem. this is something across the board. you can imagine how successful we'd number fighting the -- of drug dealers if we just said well, local government's not going to be involved, we will not allow the counties and cities involved, we'll do this all, just the federal government and you know it has to be a coordinated community effort across the board, and any kind of enforcement effort. this is the basis of community enforcements. >> yeah, okay. let me ask you a problem. suppose you have a second-generation mexican-american or from colombia or somewhere, you have a hispanic look, complex, whatever you, may have something about you that indicates you from that part of the country or that part of the world originally, your parents were. and a cop stops you and says, well you have a mustache, or something that makes me think that you're mexican-american or something and he starts bothering you. don't you think we'll have a problem here with cops bothering people just because they seem to be hispanic even though they're citizens or they have a green card? he chris, that's why we have -- we have the policies that there are things that you indicate that even go beyond the color of your skin, the hair, the looks of the fact of the way that you dress. my mother is an emigrant. i'm second generation on that. she speaks a little funny. but the fact is that the law enforcement is trained in this law, it specifically says you will have a pattern of activity or a pattern of indications that give you a justification to think there's reasonable doubt. not just the fact of somebody's ethnicity. so this one has in there, it's
12:37 am
something that the federal government does with local government right now. we have programs so that they are using these systems right now. the difference is the people of arizona are doing this across the board rather than piecemeal in their state and that's why it's being implemented and it isn't that big of a leap and it shouldn't be. >> let me go to the -- go ahead, congresswoman. >> that's just not true, in fact one of the sheriffs there in arizona is under fbi investigation because he hasn't followed the rules and his deputies have not followed the rules. they haven't gotten the type of training that we get -- give to our i.c.e. or our federal agencies -- agents that do this immigration issue. so there are quite a few, in fact, the border chairwoman for over four years, one of the things that i saw was, you know discussion after discussion from law enforcement officers about how this wasn't followed, about how people were being pulled over without, you know -- and the law, the language that could be signed into law by this arizona government says, you suspect them of being an illegal. what does that mean? you suspect them of being an illegal? >> chris, look, someone born and raised on the border i have seen this my entire life. there is indications between legal residents and those who can be identified as being highly susceptible. >> like what? give me a non-ethnic aspect that
12:38 am
would tell you to look at somebody. >> they will look at the kind of dress you wear. are there different types of attire. there are different type -- right down the shoes, right down to the clothes, but mostly by behavior. it's mostly behavior just as the law enforcement people here in washington, d.c., does it based on certain criminal activity. there's behavior things professionals are trained in across the board and this group shouldn't be exempt from those observations as much as anybody else. >> here's john mccain, a new look. he was mr. immigration. here he is on "bill o'reilly." he has a different look right now. here he is. let's listen to john mccain. >> the state of arizona is acting and doing what they feel they need to do in light of the fact that the federal government is not fulfilling its fundamental responsibility to secure our borders. >> what about the racial profiling?
12:39 am
you know that's going to happen. it has to happen. >> i hope -- i would be very sorry that if some of that happens and i -- i regret it. >> okay, congresswoman, what do you think of john mccain, the new john mccain? >> well, i think -- he's obviously trying to win a primary where he's got a very conservative, you know, person who's very, very -- got some very strange ideas. i know i have served with that person here in the congress. i hope that john does beat him and then john comes back as a senator and gets back to the issue of -- of really being middle of the road here in helping us to push real and good immigration reform because that's what we need. we don't need to be profiling people. we don't need to be going after people. we don't need to have local agencies deciding to take people off of the street for whatever reason because they look like a suspect. we need good immigration reform here from the capitol.
12:40 am
>> i love the way you give john mccain a ride. you figure he's just faking it so you don't mind. let's take a look, just so he beats j.d. hayworth, that's all you care. let me two to congressman bilbray first. you're a republican. what do you make of the state of arizona saying you have to have a birth certificate to get on the ticket next time? do you think this is ad hominem. is this a bill of retainer as we used to say in the constitution classes. is this aimed directly at the president of the united states, himself, barack obama? >> no, chris, actually this is arizona. this is really aimed at mccain, because mccain was -- there's been an issue with the fact that he wasn't born in the united states. now it's interesting the fact that he's qualified to be citizen -- a president. you don't have to be born in the united states but a lot of people look at that but because he was born in panama and the panama canal is not -- was not u.s. territory, it was u.s. area to be treated as if it's territory by treaty with panama, so mccain's actually went through a lot of same thing in arizona -- >> but they're doing it now. >> -- when a question was raised about his presidency.
12:41 am
>> but doing it now. john mccain is not running for president. he doesn't have to be native born anymore. he's an american, obviously. the question is why are they aiming it at the president of the united states now? do you think it's personal? one more try. >> no. i don't think it's personal. i think it's a way to avoid -- i think all of us, chris, everybody in elected office should be showing that we are a citizen and the problem with this bill is it should be universal to all elected officials. i don't know if mccain is running again. remember, he's been running every election since i've -- i've been a child. so i'm not so sure you can say he's not running. >> well, i can't either but i tell you this, barack obama has shown his birth certificate to the world, he has shown documentation of his birth twice now from two different newspaper accounts which were only written with the authorities participating in those announcements. they weren't just somebody putting out christmas cards. announce wants of somebody being born. we have all of the records available from anybody who comes out of hawaii, he has shown the
12:42 am
record and the birthers are crazy and they keep raising this crazy issue. now the assembly of arizona has joined the birther wagon and are behaving just as zanily as the birthers. thank you congresswoman sanchez and congressman bilbray. up next, i'm in pennsylvania tonight where the senate primary race is getting a little nasty. arlen specter is getting a little nasty. joe sestak is going to talk to us about the latest arlen ad against him. it says he was relieved of duty. we're going to see what he thinks about that when he was a naval admiral. the district of columbia never had a voting member of congress. will it have one now? we're going to tell you. the verdict's in, at least for now. take things as they come? ♪ i've got an idea. or improvise? ♪ maxwell house custom-roasts each bean... for a full-flavored cup of coffee. so you can be good to the last drop. i think we need more cups, mom.
12:43 am
washington, d.c., never had a voting member of congress. it's not like they will have one soon. the long-anticipated d.c. voting rights bill was scuttled by a controversy over a republican provision that would have stripped the district of columbia of its strict gun control laws.
12:44 am
many democrats say they can no longer support bill now and so taxation without representation continues for washington 600,000 residents. smart...you're staying at this resort for free? how? welcomerewards from hotels.com. see when i accumulate 10 nights, i get one free. and...they let me choose where to use them. the loyalty program he signed us up for has all these restrictions, blackout dates, a crazy point system... and we couldn't stay here. so what am i getting for free? my undying love? [ yelps ] wendy. hole-in-one. [ male announcer ] accumulate 10 nights. and get a night free. welcomerewards from hotels.com. smart. so smart. ♪ could open a world of wonder ? ♪
12:45 am
♪ so sensory ♪ so satisfying ♪ the discovery ♪ never seems to stop ♪ ♪ it's the magic friskies ♪ ♪ makes happen ♪ every day ♪ in so many ways ♪ friskies ♪ feed the senses wondering about your retirement plan? who isn't? retirement planning is all questions... how long? how much? how soon? what if? welcome to answer city... td ameritrade's retirement center. i get planning tools, like wealth ruler. strategies. and investment ideas. and retirement experts, on the phone, when i need them. for a little help. or a lot. whether retirement is way off. or way close. time for fresh thinking. time for td ameritrade.
12:46 am
we're back. the democratic primary up here in philadelphia and pennsylvania pits the incumbent, senator arlen specter who was a republican for 30 years, he's now a democrat against joe sestak, who's always been a democrat. this week specter went negative, it wasn't a surprise but it's pretty tough stuff. let's watch this ad. pay attention. here's the ad. >> joe sestak relieved of duty in the navy for creating a poor command climate. joe sestak, the worst attendance of any pennsylvania congressman and near the bottom of the
12:47 am
entire congress. last year alone, sestak missed 127 votes. sestak says the missed votes weren't important. he went campaigning instead. let's say no to no-show joe. >> i don't know why they find those creepy announcers but that's a pretty creepy ad. that's congressman joe sestak. i have to congratulate you, sir, for keeping your sanity during this race. you must have known going up arlen specter, you have four weeks. is this going to come? he's done it to jim hoeffel. anyone that's run against him he has destroyed. he doesn't just run against, he prosecutes you. he makes you the bad guy. you are evil at the end of these races. you must have known this was coming. what's your reaction? >> well, i'm going to find it hard to believe that the leaders of my democratic party aren't already on the phone to arlen specter.
12:48 am
i mean remember what joe biden said. i support barack obama because he doesn't try to perfect the politics of swift voting. he seeks to end them. and i think that everybody's pretty obvious that what arlen specter has done is reverted to old republican-style politics but now he's in a democratic party. let me give you a quote. so remember when barack obama as a candidate said i love this country too much to let them steal another election by lies like this one, outrageous, phony assertions, swift voting. you know, they did this to max cleeland who lost his limbs in vietnam. they did it to john kerry. they aren't going to stand for this false assertion he's made. you don't get to be a three-star admiral, lead the navy's anti-terrorism unit, command an
12:49 am
aircraft carrier battle group without having an distinguished career. arlen specter. it is time without a question for the change in politics. i don't think my party leadership -- >> you're optimistic. let me ask you this. do you think people watching the ad we just watched thinks you're section 8? you had a problem? you were relieved of duty for some personal reason? that's what they're saying, you had a problem. what does relieved of duty mean to you? to me it means you couldn't finish the job. you had a problem, mental, emotional, whatever, you couldn't do the job so they took it away from you. >> i think it's pretty obvious right now that the verdict on arlen specter is he's not fit to be the united states senator. that's why he's going to be relieved of command. look, arlen specter's verdict has already been made. you know it. you've seen the rasmussen poll. we're in a dead heat. you've seen other polls where many, many are undecided. which of these stories will you be talking about tomorrow? president obama says no more business as usual for wall street, and that's a good thing. even for banks. >> people will have confidence that when they're dealing with banks and these institutions that they, in fact, are playing it straight. >> this as a senate committee
12:50 am
passes strict new measures governing derivatives and another group of senators moves to make sure big banks get broken up to avoid the need for more bailouts. the calm before the supreme storm. >> i'm confident that we can come up with a nominee who will gain the confidence of the senate and the confidence of the country. >> with the white house gearing up for a confirmation battle and republicans ready to fight whoever the president nominates, are the chances getting better he will choose a real liberal? colonel sanders, move over, it's dr. sanders to the rescue. >> in the olden days our grandparents, they were bringing chicken to the doctor. >> chickens for your co-pay? how is she beating harry reid in the polls? and fox news swats at the in negativity.
12:51 am
chris, we know it's tough in politics. think about the seven or eight people who thought they'd get in to run against them and never did, for the very reason they knew this is what arlen did. i got in this race despite all of that because i do believe it's time for a change that people can trust somebody. here he is giving rick santorum his vote -- >> let me ask you -- saying i'll support george bush's nominees for the supreme court justice if rick santorum will give his endorsement. what a shame. >> do you think pennsylvanians would have a really nasty customer like that ad shows arlen to be. you think they don't want a real tough customer like arlen. the fact is there he is. you're saying nice things about him. you won't say nice things about you. you know the ichb nature of this battle? >> when i was on the fwround in
12:52 am
afghanistan, with my aircraft carrier command and we were doing retaliatory strikes, there's no one that's not going to call me tough. are my results oriented? have i increased the small district contracts in my district threefold in three years? do we take care of people moving money through -- absolutely. the results is pennsylvania's job creation is -- >> we've got to go. >> toughness, no, yes. but results, also, chris. results. >> senator specter, come on and defend this charge that this fellow is relieved of command, the words he used. it does imply a real problem but the evidence doesn't support it. you want to blast the guy personally, not just through a paid ad. >> appreciate it, senator. >> that was an accident. when we return -- must be the rasmussen poll in my head. we'll have you back. we'll talk in a minute about
12:53 am
teddy roosevelt, the republican on mt. rushmore by cleaning up the bad guys in wall street. we'll be right back. (laughing through computer) good night, buddy. good morning, dad. (announcer) oreo. milk's favorite cookie. boon motorcycle insurance, rv,at geiccamper, boat insurance. nice work, everyone. exec: well, it's easy for him. he's a cute little lizard. gecko: ah, gecko, actually - exec: with all due respect, if i was tiny and green and had a british accent i'd have more folks paying attention to me too... i mean - (faux english accent) "save money! pip pip cheerio!" exec 2: british? i thought you were australian. gecko: well, it's funny you should ask. 'cause actually, i'm from - anncr: geico. fifteen minutes could save you fifteen percent or more on car insurance. somewhere in america... there's a home by the sea powered by the wind on the plains. there's a hospital where technology has a healing touch. there's a factory giving old industries new life.
12:54 am
and there's a train that got a whole city moving again. somewhere in america, the toughest questions are answered every day. because somewhere in america, more than sixty thousand people spend every day answering them. siemens. answers. 0 to 60? or 60 to 0? [ tires screech ] how a car performs in a quarter-mile? [ engine revs ] or a quarter-century? is performance about the joy of driving? or the importance... of surviving. to us, performance is not about doing one thing well. it is about doing everything well. because in the end... everything matters. performance without compromise. that is what drives us. performance without compromise. ♪ (announcer) right now, all over the country, discover card customers are getting five percent cashback bonus at home improvement stores. it pays to get more,
12:55 am
it pays to discover. because with national, i roll past the counter... and choose any car in the aisle. choosing your own car? now that's a good call. go national. go like a pro.
12:56 am
let me finish tonight with a word about the party of teddy roosevelt. within months, president mckinley was shot in buffalo and we found ourselves as a rooten tooten reformer as president. he turned out to be the most
12:57 am
popular of all time up there on mt. rushmore with george, abe. talk about independent. talk about the business of his day, quote, we demand big business give a square deal. we insist anyone engaged in big business doing right he show himself to be given a square deal. a great article in "the washington post," roosevelt had his version of goldman sachs to deal with. a railroad monopoly. j.p. morgan tried to slip out of a mess he got himself in to. quote, if we've done anything wrong, send your man to my man and they can fix it up. teddy roosevelt told j.p. forget this your man and my man business. quote, we don't want to fix it up, we want to stop the dirty deals period. maybe president obama is getting tough with wall street. maybe a loud cheering session if he did. a few out there have a picture of teddy roosevelt up on their
12:58 am
wall. that's "hardball" for now. "countdown" with keith olbermann starts right now. which of these stories will you be talking about tomorrow? president obama says no more business as usual for wall street, that's a good thing, even for banks. >> people have confidence if they're dealing with banks, they're dealing with these institutions that they, in fact, are playing it straight. >> this as a senate committee passes strict new measures governing derivatives and another group of senators moves to make sure big banks get broken up to avoid the need for more bailouts. the calm before the supreme storm. >> i'm confident that we can come up with a nominee who will gain the confidence of the senate and the confidence of the country. >> with the white house gearing up for a confirmation battle and republicans ready to fight whoever the president nominates,
12:59 am
are the chances getting better he will choose a real liberal? colonel sander, move over. dr. sanders to the rescue. >> our grandparents -- they were bringing chicken to the doctor. >> chickens for your co-pay? how is she beating harry reid in the polls? and fox news swats at the hornet's nest by going after jon stewart again. >> you want to be a social commentator more than a comedian, if you want to be a good one, you better have some guts. >> no doubt, stewart has the killer response. >> fox news, you're the loopest of news. >> all that and more now on "countdown." >> i'm not fair. i'm not balanced. good evening from los angeles, i'm lawrence o'donnell in for keith olbermann. democrats in the senate are