nailed it. that is my nomination for the best new thing in the world today, jay smooth at illdoctrine.com. he is a genius. that was about 30 seconds of it. the whole thing is only about two minutes long and is posted at our website in its entirety, maddow blog.msnbc.com. time now for the ed show. thanks for being with us tonight. have a good one. good evening, americans. welcome to the ed show tonight from new york. dog gone it, trumpd$

successful food stamp president in american history. >> tonight, michael eric dyson and joan walsh on newt gingrich's dog whistle messaging to the republican party. paul ryan tries to polish that turd of a budget bill in chicago. john nichols is here. >> the president and first lady have made a major mistake in inviting this man to the white house. >> and the defining moment for the ginned up common controversy. john stewart versus bill o'reilly. >> this guy is in the cross hairs in a way that he shouldn't be. whether you agree with him or not. >> thanks for joining us tonight. this is the story that has me fired up first. newt gingrich is i guess you could say blowing the racist dog whistle again. in his speech down in macon, georgia on friday, the newtster took an ugly shot at president.

>> president obama is the most successful food stamp president in american history. more people are on food stamps today than at any point in american history and he is proud of it. >> how do you know, newt? have you ever asked him? let's get to the racist part of this. i think we have to put this in the context of what the culture of the south is all about. do you remember in july of 2009 when senator jim demint of south carolina made that racist comment, that old slavery slur term about president obama talking about health care? he said if we can break him, if we can break him that'll be his waterloo. you know, that is as bad as it gets but of course he said it wasn't about race. it had nothing to do with it at all. i'm sure this has nothing to do with race whatsoever. the fact of the matter is if you want to pick on the food stamp program once again newt is on,

standing on quick sand. no question about that. and of course he said it in friendly territory down in georgia playing to an old white audience. but the fact of the matter is, newt knows exactly what he's doing just getting to the water's edge. we'll talk more about it. but newt was asked about the food stamp comment on "meet the press" and immediately played the victim. >> first of all, you gave a speech in georgia with language a lot of people think could be coded rationally tense language calling the first black president a food stamp president. what did you mean? >> come on, david. that's bizarre. this kind of automatic reference to racism -- this is the president of the united states. the president of the united states has to be held accountable. now the idea -- and what i said is factually true. 47 million americans are on foodstamps. 1 of every 6 americans is on foodstamps. and to hide behind the charge of racism?

i have neverhjs

african-americans. the republican party still can't win on issues so their only chance is to play the race card again. newt desperately wants america to believe president obama is a radical black socialist. that's what i'm getting out of the code talk out there and it's just sad. for the food stamp program we should point out it is part of the farm bill and the food stamp program has been in effect since

1964. yeah, you've got the school lunch program. you've got the food stamp program. you've got the nutrition programs, price supports. i guess you could say that the food stamp program helps keep the american farmer on the land and gives them a chance. get your cell phones out. i want to know what you think. tonight's question. are newt gingrich's comments racist? text a for yes, text b for no to 622639 or go to our blog at ed.msnbc.com. i'll bring the results later on in the show. for more let's bring in michael eric dyson, professor of sociology at georgetown university and joan walsh, editor at large for salon.com. great to have both of you with us tonight. professor dyson, do you think calling president obama the food stamp president is racist? what do you think? >> well it's certainly part of a racial pattern. you don't have to have a racial intent to have a racial consequence, to communicate a racial meaning. i think that here newt gingrich is fully aware as a

sophisticated american historian or at least a putative student of american history to understand the code language there -- welfare queen, the association of foodstamps and being on the doll e of the publ with african-american people, poor latino people and for that matter poor people who are white in appalachia. here it's quite clear by calling the first black president a foodstamp president he gets to knock the ball out of the park two or three times. he gets to knock out several birds with one stone. he can appeal to the republican conservative base. he can suggest that these tax cuts he wants to put in place, 35% for corporate taxes reduced to 12%, should be in place, and then he can give corporate welfare if you will to those who are rich and then he can also suggest that he's tough on african-american people who are on the dole who don't deserve it. it is the undeserving poor that he's getting at here and we all know that circulates mostly around the bodies of poor black women and their children and newt gingrich knows better than that. >> joan walsh, how do you read

this? what purpose does it serve for newt to talk like this? and of course he plays the victim in all of this. your thoughts? >> well, you know, i do think that it has a racial implications, you know, there is a long history as michael says of associating welfare with black people. ronald reagan, that sunny, je genial figure used to talk about welfare queens driving cadillacs and even strapping young bucks buying steaks with foodstamps. so there is that history. there is rush limbaugh. as soon as the president got elected insisting his stimulus bill, his unemployment increases, and his health care proposals were reparations to black people for slavery, a controversial issue for sure. so, you know, you also, if it were just the foodstamp president maybe we could give him -- maybe we could give him a pass. but you only missed a couple things. he also said that this president only knows how to turn us into

detroit, make us like detroit, distressed african-american city, and he also made this crazy reference i believe in the same speech in georgia saying that this election is as important as 1860, which is when we elected abraham lincoln, which led the south to secede over slavery. i don't know what other association with 1860 anybody could have sitting in georgia. so it's a string of racial dog whistles that adds up to -- it doesn't even feel like coded racism anymore. it feels like racism. >> michael, does any republican contender have to go down this road? i mean, to solidify the base in a very sick manner? and it seems like we're the only ones that are calling them out on this. >> sure. >> i think there is a real parallel here between what jim demint said and what newt consistently says as joan

pointed out. but is this what the republicans have to do? can they any way get the nomination and move forward in the election without doing this? >> i certainly think so. but i think that they believe that this is the best way, the easiest way, the cheapest way. stereotypes after all are the lazy person's way of dealing with the other. there's always a kernel of truth, some part of the truth that can be revealed, and the ingenuity of employing this kind of wolf whistling is plausible deniability. how do you dare believe i meant that he says to brother gregory on "meet the press" and has the constant drum beat of denying he is the victimizer and plays the victim and therefore when he invokes racial passion and we call him for it he makes himself to be the victim and as a result do you mean ka duplicates his effort. he is sending signals, straight up expression of racial

sentiment on one hand and on the other hand gets to play the victim and see how these black people are beating us up, the association of detroit where i hail from has a black enclave of civil horror and governmental despair so i think all these are part and parcel of a southern strategy that unfortunately continues to be played in 2011. >> and, joan, does he have a shot at winning the nomination in your opinion? we did a story last week and documented all of his infrastructure and things he has been able to do. he's raised more money than any of the other candidates combined. that's what we reported. so what does this all mean? >> no. i wrote a piece this morning kind of jumping out ahead of the headlines, ed, saying newt gingrich will never be president than's what i believe. i don't think he needs to do this. i think that the sad percentage of people who will not vote for a black president are already in the republican column. he's not widening his appeal. and look. today let's move away from the issue of race. today he had to flip flop again

on the individual mandate. yesterday he kind of defended it. today if he doesn't like it he's in trouble with his comments over the paul ryan plan. so, you know, he's running a terrible campaign his first few days out of the get a andate an too much baggage. he is not presidential and will never be president. >> what did you think of gingrich saying he thought the ryan plan was radical? >> it's radically nonsensical but radical means to the roots and it is to the roots of conservative ideology that continues to poison the well of common sense and also civic responsibility to those who are most vulnerable. to call paul ryan's plan anything but what it is, an attempt to up the ante for those who are rich, to give tax cuts to those who don't deserve them, and then those who are rich continue to get richer and those who are poor continue to be poorer. it sounds like a cliche' but it's certainly real and i think here again i agree with joan. i think newt's personal life, the horrible choices he's made

politically, and the way in which he has been a polarizing figure and not a unifier will continue to ensure that he will not make much if you will truck in the american political system as a presidential candidate. >> all of a sudden it's getting kind of thin over there on the right. i mean, all the things they've been saying about president obama you would think he'd be easy to run against. >> seth meyers had it right. the only person who could beat obama is maybe the obama of 2008. where is that guy? other than that i don't think anybody on the right has a real chance to get at mr. obama. >> great to have you with us tonight. thanks so much. don't forget to answer our question at the bottom of the screen. paul ryan tried to sell his medicare busting plan again today with a rebranding that just doesn't work when the brand stinks. tonight is a big night here on "the ed show." psycho talk comes back. i'm loving it. last year's number one psycho talker is in the zone. stay with us. ♪

[ male announcer ] in 2011, at&t is at work, building up our wireless network all across america. we're adding new cell sites... increasing network capacity, and investing billions of dollars to improve your wireless network experience. from a single phone call to the most advanced data download, we're covering more people in more places than ever before in an effort to give you the best network possible. at&t. rethink possible.

donald trump announced today he is not going to run for president. i for one am very disappointed. he decided making money was more important to him than public service. i think i called that weeks ago. his decision must be devastating to all the righty pundits out there who were just salivating over the prospect of a trump candidacy, like dick morris. here is dick just three weeks ago. >> donald trump is getting into this race and i think he is definitely going to run and i think that he'll shake up the whole race. basically there will be sort of a right wing republican primary which will have gingrich against bachmann against palin against huckabee. and then there will be a primary of the moderate republicans and independents which will be romney against trump. >> okay. a lot of predictions there. let me give you fact. three weeks later dick morris's predictions are in the toilet.

trump is out. mike huckabee also announced this weekend he's not going to run. he's making too much money. i'm a little upset about the donald bowing out so fast. i endorsed this guy last month. now i got to go find a new righty, a new horse in the race to take on president obama. my search for the next craziest republican presidential candidate is coming up. stay with us. it's true. you never forget your first subaru. time to mix it up with new philly cooking creme. it'll make your chicken creamier, dreamier, with lots of flavor. spread the love in four fabulous flavors. spoon in a little new philly cooking creme.

spread the love in four fabulous flavors. we search, browse, and shop from anywhere. we live in a social world. isn't time we had a social currency to match? membership reward points from american express. use them to get the things you love on amazom.com. welcome back to the ed show. thanks for watching tonight. my favorite story, paul ryan the architect of the plan to end medicare as we know it. well, he decided to try to do this thing over again. he gave a big speech in chicago today. he is trying to rebrand his medicare voucher plan.

you show me a voucher plan i'll show you a voucher plan. since americans, including his own constituents, just absolutely hate the idea, here is ryan giving it a go again. our budget also gets health care spending under control by empowering americans to fight back against skyrocketing costs. our budget makes no changes for those in or near retirement and it offers future generations a strengthened medicare program that they can count on with guaranteed coverage options. >> what? empowering americans? guaranteed coverage options? gosh, you know what? they must spend light years coming up with these little buzz phrases that just are so camera friendly and so appealing when it comes to speaking in front of a crowd. oh, he's so articulate, this paul ryan. he's actually going to propose a

program that is going to allow old people to get a little bit of money and go out on the free market and get a deal with insurance companies. i mean, i tell you what. that must be the empowering americans part. and the guaranteed coverage options? hey, there might be two insurance companies out there that really see that the old folks of america, the retired folks of america, they're just a brand new hell of a market. ryan said president obama's plan for medicare would lead to rationing. and he tried to make this contrast. >> our plan is to give seniors the power to deny business to inefficient providers. their plan quite to the opposite is to give the government the power to deny care to seniors. >> inefficient providers.

how could 80% of americans be so wrong on this? i mean, this ryan guy, he must be the smartest guy on the planet. inefficient providers. medicare, medicaid, they've been inefficient providers. why? because the doctors haven't cut a fat hog on the deal? so ryan says his voucher program will give the power to seniors. wrong. the gop plan will give more power to a market that will charge seniors a hell of a lot more for coverage than what they could ever possibly afford with the stinking voucher program. that's how you got to talk about this program. just give them the straight talk. right? none of this lofty empower americans, guaranteed coverage options. the protesters outside, they weren't buying this thing either. any more than the folks at any of these town halls that he went to. the protesters chanted, "hands off our medicare."

they actually showed up and said that outside in chicago. yesterday presidential candidate newt gingrich, well actually he wasn't buying it either. nbc's david gregory asked gingrich what he thought of ryan's voucher program. >> i don't think right wing social engineering is any more desirable than left wing social engineering. >> left wing social engineering? that's what medicare is when 80% of the american people want it? ryan hit back saying with allies like that who needs the left? then newt's spokesman, well he tripped all over himself trying to explain that newt actually supports something close to ryan's plan. let's bring in washington correspondent of "the nation" john nichols. this is almost a comedy hour when it comes to news. to follow these people going back and forth on this. let me ask you. what is the empowering americans part of his speech today, which

part do you think it was? >> well, the empowering americans line is the most orwellian line in the speech. he is saying that he is going to give people in their 80s and 90s the ability to work on lowering health care costs by going through the bids or the offers of dozens of insurance companies and picking the one that's the cheapest. the fact of the matter is there is no empowerment here. what this does is make the lives of working americans dramatically more difficult, dramatically more complicated, and ultimately what he's talking about if you translate it is setting up a situation where they will move money out of a very functional federal program, medicare, into the accounts of private insurance companies that will begin by taking off their high profits. >> and so he is so damaged on this he can't do a do over, can he?

>> no, he can't. in fact, this was a disastrous day for paul ryan. imagine you start out -- you're going to give the speech that's going to win everybody back. it's going to undo all the damage done by those town hall meetings but instead of having the platform, having the podium, you've got to deal with donald trump quitting his presidential race. >> yeah. >> then newt gingrich calling your plan right wing social engineering. >> let's talk about wisconsin politics. herb kohl not going to run. is paul ryan going to jump in? >> no. he will not make this run. i know he is sort of hinting about it for a couple days. i think it's part of trying to rehabilitate himself, make himself look like somebody people wouldonsider for the senate but i understand that this evening congressman ryan and his staff were making calls to republicans in the state sending out signals that he almost certainly will not run. >> okay. let's talk about new york's 26 special election that of course is coming up, big time

referendum on ryan's medicare plan. this really is the first election out there that we're going to be able to see the tea leaves a little bit or maybe the sea change that's out there if it is as many have predicted. you've been out there. what are you finding out? >> i think the new york 26th race is the most important race, certainly, of this part of the year. maybe the whole year. now, remember, this is a district that voted for john mccain for president. >> yeah. >> in new york state. it's as conservative as you get. it should not elect a democrat to congress. and yet the democratic candidate up there has come from way behind to a position where she now leads in some polls with barely a week to go. this is an incredible race, ed, and it's shifted entirely on the medicare issue. the democratic candidate embraced a support of medicare and wrapped the ryan bill around her republican opponent's neck and that's what's changed this

race. >> john nichols, washington correspondent of "the nation" always great to have you with us here on the ed show. always great insight. i appreciate it. we'll be on this next week. we didn't get osama bin laden from torturing detainees. senator john mccain said that. he got his information from cia director leon panetta. and now the panetta letter. it has been revealed. it has been revealed. so mr. rumsfeld, speak up. this is stacy. who runs circles around asthma. and dan. he never lets high cholesterol get him too low. and amy with her arthritis well in hand. they go to walgreens... where their pharmacist not only refills prescriptions but gives advice... immunizations... and health tests. staying on top of your health starts right in your neighborhood. walgreens. there's a way to stay well. with listerine® whitening plus restoring rinse. it's the only listerine® that gets teeth two shades whiter and makes tooth enamel two times stronger.

get dual-action listerine® whitening rinse. building whiter, stronger teeth. each day was fueled by thorough preparation for events to come. well somewhere along the way, emily went right on living. but you see, with the help of her raymond james financial advisor, she had planned for every eventuality. which meant she continued to have the means to live on... even at the ripe old age of 187. life well planned. see what a raymond james advisor can do for you. so he chose a university where the faculty average over 14 years of experience in their fields to help him turn a thesis into a business plan and accelerate the path between ideas... and actions. my name is myron sullivan, i'm developing a robotic system to clean oil spills,

and i am a phoenix. [ male announcer ] learn more about the school of business at phoenix.edu. long before a cummins diesel engine powered a ram truck.. it roared to life out here. and proved itself here, here, and here. and it's now delivering best-in-class towing, here. and unsurpassed torque, here. the ram 5 year 100,000 mile warranty covers you everywhere. ram.

welcome back to the ed show. remember a couple weeks ago when the righties were out talking about this? torture? if we hadn't tortured anybody we wouldn't have gotten osama bin laden? senator john mccain gave a huge smackdown to the bushies who said torture led to the death of osama bin laden. and today the letter from cia director leon panetta to senator mccain was revealed by gary sergeant of "the washington post." panetta said that multiple streams of intelligence led to bin laden's compound. he said that some of the detainees who provided useful information had been subjected to enhanced interrogation techniques but their information was not the key. and here's the main point of leon panetta's letter. let me further point out that we first learned from the courier from a detainee not in custody in 2002. so the bushies are wrong when they say or imply that we

wouldn't have gotten bin laden without waterboarding. >> i think the fact that you clearly have the current cia director saying that part of the intelligence came from enhanced interrogation, these are techniques that we know work. that debate is over. >> but it wouldn't be surprising if in fact that program produced results that ultimately contributed to the success of this venture. >> well, in my view we very likely would not have captured or killed osama bin laden had we not had the intelligence information we had. so i think that it's clear that that -- those techniques that the cia used worked. >> dick cheney said it wouldn't be surprising so he really didn't know, did he? but he's out there planting the seed with a lot of americans, if it hadn't been for them we wouldn't have got him. another smackdown of the bushies

came from former terrorism adviser richard clarke. >> robin asked richard clarke how much credit does president bush deserve for finding bin laden. this was some controversy last week. >> zero. i don't know why that's controversy. the man did nothing about bin laden until 9/11 and after 9/11 kind of did for a few months, sent troops to afghanistan but didn't tell them to get bin laden. >> those are the facts. president obama told his people to go out and get bin laden and that's exactly what they did. think the fox news controversy over common is finished? think again. jon stewart debates bill o'reilly. we've got the highlights and donald trump dog gone it again he chose money over america. so now i'm put in an untenable position. i have to go out and find another whacko republican candidate to endorse. fortunately i do have some options i'm really starting to like.

rather than admit 17 black students who had been assigned by the norfolk school board governor jay lindsay almond jr. seized norfolk's all white junior high schools and ordered them closed. a fierce legal battle ensued that included a strategy called massive resistance. they remained closed until february 2nd, 1959, when they reopened with the 17 black students in attendance after rulings by the virginia supreme court and the u.s. district court in norfolk. these are the kinds of things that america has been through that we've been able to overcome. i came in to maury high school on the heels of this integration. i've seen this country. i've seen where i come from go through change and make it happen. we're still america. we can do it.

well we knew it was coming sooner or later but certainly devastating to this talker. i have some bad news to report tonight. donald trump i'm sure many of you know by now is not going to be running for president. i, for one, heart broken over the decision. i endorsed this guy last month. the one candidate that i want to see break away from the pack and secure the party's nomination for the 2012 republican presidential nomination? i am endorsing -- sorry, dude. you only get one balloon. he had two balloons! remember, i did that twice on this program. and now less than a month after i gave trump my endorsement, the donald is out of the running?

how could he do that? when he didn't quit without one last display of total, complete arrogance? he said this. i maintain the strong conviction that if i were to run, i would be able to win the primary and ultimately the general election. ultimately, however, business is my greatest passion and i am not ready to leave the private sector. spoken like a true ego maniac who happens to have a primetime show. it's not surprising. trump is no public servant. he's never been a public ser venlt. he's never been an advocate for anybody other than himself. of course trump never had a chance anyway. did he? especially after president obama ripped him at the white house correspondents dinner and then ordered the raid to take out osama bin laden. that really removed the fear card didn't it? not to mention the fact that the president had already destroyed the cornerstone of trump's campaign by releasing his birth certificate. there goes another bullet point. by the way, donald, we're

still -- now this is the part of the story that is huge that no one is focusing on but i'm focused, i am laser focused on this. we're still waiting to hear from those investigators that he sent to hawaii. well, he did interviews with people saying you wouldn't believe what they're coming up with. but now that guy i guess i endorse has chosen reality television over the reality of facing the country trying to do something to help people out. so now i got to go out and get another pick. it's going to be tough. so help me evaluate the field. will you? i'll bring in my friend lee papa the author of "the rude pundit" blog as well as "the rude pundit's almanac." you got something now. >> just rip that page out. >> trump is just saying that, well, he would have won the primary and won the presidency. do you think he would have won a state? no. i can say, you know what? i'm going to train and win a

marathon and i'm not going to do it but, man, if i could, i would be so far ahead of the pack. >> so who is left out there? michele bachmann? i have to endorse somebody. >> yeah, i don't know. michele bachmann. she is like every guy's first wife. you know? she's like -- she's like, you know, you sit there and you go i knew you were crazy but i didn't realize you were that crazy. >> sarah palin chose the money over the public service. >> yeah. and that's been the way it has been for her entire career. people forget also she quit a a job in 2003. she was on an oil board. she was appointed to it. she quit that, too. so there is no way she's running. >> i can't -- i can't go for a quitter. >> no. no. >> i just can't do that. herman kaine. i don't know much about this dude. tell me about him. >> herman kaine is really responsible for all of us being fat. he was an executive at coca-cola. he was an executive at pillsbury. he ran burger kings and

godfather pizza. really if you think about it he is responsible for more deaths than osama bin laden. >> and rick santorum? this guy is really a social conservative. he is way over the top. >> he's a jerk and he's creepy. you know, i don't know if your viewers know the story. >> a jerk and he's creepy? >> he is. first of all we know about his, how virulently antigay he is but then there is that creepy story from 1995 about when his, one of his sons was born prematurely at 20 weeks, died after two hours outside of the womb, sad story but then the santorum took the premature baby home, had his children hold it, cuddle it, and sing to the premature baby. >> newt gingrich. we talked about him earlier in the program. is he really the inside track right now? >> if you want a bloated

egotistical reminder of everything wrong with american politics sure. >> you haven't given me much to work with tonight. >> i know. if i was going to go down crazy road i might go ron paul although i think ron paul gave me a cart at walmart the other day. >> ron paul is going to help president obama get to the white house again probably more than anybody because he will take off the crazies. i really do -- he'll peel more people away from the traditional republican party than anybody ever did on the left. >> sure. >> that's what i think. i mean, i think this is a big ticket for president obama to get back. he'll split the republican vote. >> sure, sure. he'll draw in the republican stoners who like his drug policy and the gold standard people who are 90 years old. >> lee papa the rude pundit good to have you with us. thank you so much. psycho talk is back on "the ed show" and not a moment too soon. glenn beck is spending $5 million to restore courage in jerusalem? and he wants you to buy a plane

ticket to join him. well, i'm going to give him a one way ticket into the zone. stay with us. morning flight to london starts with arthritis pain... and a choice. take tylenol now, and maybe up to 8 in a day. or...choose aleve and 2 pills for a day free of pain. enjoy the flight. and here's what we did today in homes all across america: we created the electricity that powered the alarm clocks and brewed the coffee. we heated the bathwater and gave kelly a cleaner ride to school. cooked the cube steaks and steamed the veggies. entertained dad, and mom, and a neighbor or two. kept watch on the house when they slept. and tomorrow we could do even more. we're cleaner, domestic, abundant and ready now. we're america's natural gas.

the smarter power today. learn more at anga.us. beer and wine, and cupcakes. i was doing the corporate grind, like everyone else. but to be successful, i knew i had to be different. ink, ink, ink, ink, ink... i mean i love that card. it does things differently too. great customer service, going above and beyond to help me out as a small business. it's accepted in twice as many places around the world as american express, and if i ever need to give my employees ink cards, they're free. announcer: make your mark with ink. chase what matters. go to chase.com/ink. and you know it's one thing for republican lawmakers across the country to try to balance their state budgets on the backs of middle classers in this country. it's a whole other thing when their attack dogs spit in their face as they do it. this is rush limbaugh talking about public sector union

employees today. >> would you prefer to be unionized? >> no, sir. >> okay. so you don't want to rape fellow citizens? >> no. i just want to work for a fair day's work for a fair day's pay. >> yeah. me too. >> try and take that in for just a moment. rush limbaugh says public sector employees, firefighters, police officers, sanitation workers, teachers are raping their fellow citizens in this country? with talk like that, is there any wonder why republicans are losing this debate? up next, glenn beck cashing in on holy land and jon stewart dukes it out with bill o'reilly over the manufactured common controversy. ♪

[ male announcer ] in 2011, at&t is at work, building up our wireless network all across america. we're adding new cell sites... increasing network capacity, and investing billions of dollars to improve your wireless network experience. from a single phone call to the most advanced data download, we're covering more people in more places than ever before in an effort to give you the best network possible. at&t. rethink possible.

and in psycho talk tonight i'm personally celebrating its return. we celebrate the return of the biggest offender of 2010 and that would be glenn beck. his fox news show may be coming

to an end soon but his ego is going global. it all started last august with his restoring honor rally in washington, d.c. on the anniversary of martin luther king "i have a dream" speech. well now beck is trying. he is going to take his show on the road to jerusalem. >> i believe i've been asked to stand in jerusalem. this august join me for an event i have named restoring courage. when i first had this idea, what i saw in my head was a global shock wave. it will ripple across the earth. >> restoring courage. the arrogance just drips off this guy. beck thinks it's his job to restore courage. think about this.

in a country that has spent almost its entire existence surrounded by enemies. beck says this rally will be such a life changing experience people should fork over thousands of dollars to

. >> ( rooster crows ) >> by 2020, 50 billion network devices will roam the earth. that's seven devices per person. this will change how we work in ways we've never

before imagined. what do you need to secure your people, their devices, and your business? a network that can evolve and grow to protect your human network. [ thinking ] oh, gourmet deliciousness... i want you tonight! [ female announcer ] wish granted. lean cuisine has a fresh new bag. lean cuisine market creations steam meals. like new chicken poblano with tender white meat chicken, crisp veggies, in a savory cheddar sauce. new from lean cuisine.

professional driver on a closed course. ♪ do not attempt at home. always wear your seat belt. ♪ and please drive responsibly. [ male announcer ] it's the most fun you can legally have. see your authorized mercedes-benz dealer for exceptional offers on the c-class. with olay challenge that and give drastic measures a rest. regenerist night elixir gently resurfaces for the smooth skin of a light chemical peel. sleep tight. regenerist, from olay. sir, can you hear me? just hold the bag. we need a portable x-ray, please! [ nurse ] i'm a nurse.

i believe in the power of science and medicine. but i'm also human. and i believe in stacking the deck. when i realized that weight watchers online is for guys. all the guys, they think, "do some crunches. that'll just make you thin right away." that just doesn't work. so with weight watchers online, it teaches you about doing the right things when you're eating. there's something called a digital cooler. grab some beer, maybe some chips, and you can stay on plan. i lost 57 pounds. i pick up a 55-pound weight and i cannot believe that used to be right here. [ male announcer ] hurry, join for free today. weight watchers online for men. finally, losing weight clicks. finally tonight on the ed show as you know last week folks over at fox had a bit of a

problem on their hands. they didn't want to give president obama an ounce of credit for his courageous and gutsy decision to take out osama bin laden, so they made up a controversy. they went after the president by attacking a rapper named common. common attended a white house poetry reading. the folks at fox argued that he should not have been invited because of the lyrics of one of his songs even though fox news previously praised this guy, common, as a positive role model for kids. now, i went after this blatant hypocrisy. so did jon stewart. that prompted a response from bill o'reilly. he invited mr. stewart to come on the program. here's some of the fireworks from earlier this evening. >> when a president invites someone in this case the first lady the resume has to be put in front of them and they have to select people who are almost unimpeachable. >> bob dylan wrote a song about a convicted killer named

hurricane carter. he's been to the white house. why are you drawing the line at common? there is a selective outrage machine here at fox that petty-fogs only when it suits the narrative that suits them. this guy is in the cross hairs in a way that he shouldn't be. whether you agree with him or not, you may think he is ignorant in believing that shakur is ignorant but guess what? then bono can't go to the white house. springsteen can't go to the white house. bob dylan can't go to the white house. you got a lot of people that aren't allowed to sit in the white house because they have written songs about people convicted of murder. >> time now to call in media senior fellow eric bowler. great to have you with us tonight. i've never heard o'reilly so quiet. >> that was a long stretch. >> let's go back to the controversy. did they really manufacture a story that would be negative for president obama when it was such a huge story that the country's

military was able to take out osama bin laden? >> absolutely. i think the right wing media the last couple weeks have been a bit of a disaster. we had the birther story fall apart, the bin laden killing, last week an ap poll that had the president at 6 o%. they were sort of desperate and grasping at straws. >> who won the debate tonight? >> i think stewart made all the valid points. you know, common inches not celebrating a cop killer. he was saying he thought a couple people were innocent. that is not celebrating. >> it is interesting how o'reilly was talking about how the white house has to look at resumes and check people out yet they didn't check out who had been at the white house before. they just went ahead and attacked the president for having common there. >> as jon stewart said if i am the president of the united states going over the list for the poetry i'm not doing my job. that is for other people to do. sort of silly. >> let me get your reaction. here is stewart calling out the fox news apparatus. >> and you get the entire apparatus here, the infection

machine that is the overreaction -- >> you mean the diverse opinions we have here? >> no. >> from your network? >> you have not a diversity of opinions. >> oh, stop it. >> you bring in people you can beat around the head with pillows. >> he has no defense mechanism here? he is a smart guy. >> what do you make of that? >> i think jon is right. there is no diversity and the controversy was silly. as you pointed out fox a year ago praised common as being a conscientious, positive rapper, a legend. i mean, the guy is just not controversial. he went to college on a scholarship, studied business. he was in a gap ad dancing in front of a gigantic peace sign. he's not a controversial person. >> he's done a lot in public education, too, trying to keep kids in school and what not. o'reilly likes to bring in a body language person. >> right. >> we going to get one of those on this one? >> probably true. tomorrow night we'll see how jon stewart was really being very defensive the whole night. >> another facet of the story that i find so interesting as i

mentioned a moment ago, why wouldn't they research who's been at the white house before? is fox so agenda driven that facts don't matter at all? when the country is going to be paying attention to something like this? >> everything is short term within like a 24-hour cycle so they don't care who has been there in the past. they're not going to do any research. fox, i mean, it pushes all this kind of hateful rhetoric itself and for them to be picking on commons is -- >> and there was no diversity of opinion about common being at the white house from the network. it was in the morning, the midday, in the afternoon. they all had the same opinion. great to have you with us. i appreciate it so much. also tonight our survey. i asked you, newt gingrich comments, are they racist? 87% of you said yes. 13% of you said no. that's the ed show. i'm ed schultz. and the last word with lawrence o'donnell starts right now. of course you can hear my radio show on xm sirius channel 127 noon to