listen to me on serious x m radio monday through friday. follow me on twitter at ed show. the rich a matter show starts right now. good evening. >> > thank you for staying with us the next hour. michele bachmann was a front-runner in the race for president. michele bachmann, you may recall, stormed into iowa, won the ames, iowa, straw poll and looked like a force to be reckoned with in politics. people started googling michele bachmann which did not bode well for her presidential chances. her husband, marcus bachmann, for example, turns out to run a counseling clinic in minnesota, among itself other services, offered in the past to cure people of the gay. mr. bachmann also on record reportedly talking about gay people by saying, quote, barbarians need to be educated. that comment led to one of the more amazing protest scenes we've seen in the entire 2012

presidential election season. ♪ ♪ told me when i was young we're all superstars ♪ >> a group of protesters dressed as barbarians conducting a flash mob coordinated dance routine to lady gaga outside the clinic in minnesota. while striking as a protest technique, the barbarianf$ash mob does not have wide applicability to other politicians. we've not seen other coordinated dance routines, gay, barbarian or otherwise used against candidates this year although a girl can dream. we've had a flury of glitterings this year.

if you're a candidate who's being glittered or being in the case of -- oh, yeah -- in the case of tim pawlenty, a candidate who was being confettied. how do you -- oh, how do you handle that as a candidate? i mean, really, there's not much for the candidate to do in this circumstance. there's no real way to come out of that looking great. essentially, you should wait until it's over is probably the best advice for how to deal with that. more recently we've seen another new protest tactic gain traction across the country. that is the human mike. the human mike is an occupy wall street innovation. in the absence of a microphone, it's the means of communicating to a large group of people. >> mike check. >> mike check. >> we amplify each other's voices -- >> we amplify each other's voices. >> we amplify each other's voices. >> no matter what's said -- >> no matter what's said. >> no matter what's said. >> so we can hear one another -- >> so we can hear one another.

>> it all starts with somebody yelling, mike check. then the crowd repeats that. and then the message gets delivered by human communication. the human mike and the mike check phenomenon turns out can also be used to interrupt other people's events.lírqr and that is something that political figures this year have to be prepared for. we have seen a wide range of responses to the mike check being used as a political interruption. some of these responses are effective, some not so much.ç >> we'll take one more question. >> you know, it looks like time's running out. >> yeah. >> mike check. >> mike check. >> mike check. >> we are the 99%. >> we are the 99%. >> we will be heard. >> we will be heard. >> there are criminals on wall street. >> there are criminals on wall street. >> who walk free. >> who walk free. >> there are protesters in jail. >> there are protesters in jail. >> there's something wrong. >> there's something wrong. >> with this system. >> with this system.

>> we are the 99%. >> we are the 99%. >> do you feel better? >> do you feel better? last week george w. bush's former senior adviser, now fox news personality, karl rove, came face to face, himself, with the human mike. here's how karl rove responded. >> today it's equal to 70% of gdp. >> mike check! >> mike check! >> mike check! >> karl rove! >> karl rove! >> is the architect -- >> is the architect. >> is the architect of occupy iraq. >> the architect of occupy iraq. >> the architect of occupy afghanistan. >> the architect of occupy afghanistan. >> here's the deal. if you believe in free speech, then you have a chance to show it. if you believe in the right of the first amendment, free

speech, then you demonstrate it by shutting up and waiting until the q&a session -- >> karl rove engaging the crowd in verbal combat there. if you believe in free speech, then you ought to shut up. michele bachmann recently ç encountered the human mike during a foreign policy speech in south carolina. >> american consumers -- >> mike check! >> mike check. >> mike check. >> mike check. >> this will only take a minute. >> this will only take a minute. >> we have a message for miss bachmann. >> we have a message for miss bachmann. [ inaudible ] >> so there's a spectrum of ways to respond to the human mike interruption as a protest tactic. for ron paul, it was waiting until the end and being a little condescending. feel better? for karl rove, anger.

for michele bachmann, freezing with your eyes wide open and then running away. none of those options i think it's fair to say went all that great for the politico at the center of those human mike interruption protests. today in new hampshire the president of the united states was mike checked. when president obama chose to handle it rather differently than how the republicans have been dealing with it. >> before i came to school today, i -- >> mike check -- >> i had coffee. >> mike check! mr. president -- >> mr. president. >> over 4,000 peaceful protesters -- >> over 4,000 peaceful protesters. >> have been arrested. >> have been arrested. [ inaudible ] >> oh, that's okay. that's okay. okay. it's okay. that's all right. listen.

the -- i'm going to be talking about a whole range of things tonight, and i appreciate you guys making your point. let me go ahead and make mine, all right? and i'll listen to you$ xou listen to me. all right? young people like the ones here today, including the ones who were just chanting at me, you're the reason i ran for office in the first place. because -- [ applause ] -- it's folks like you who why i spend so much time up here in the dead of winter four years ago. there's a profound sense of frustration about the fact that the essence of the american dream, which is if you work hard, if you stick to it, that you can make it feels like that's slipping away. and that's not the way things are supposed to be. not here. not in america. >> after the president finished speaking today including a by-name reference to the occupy

movement from the president, an ap photographer named charles darapac captured this moment, a young man in the crowd handing president obama a note. a close-up shot of that note shows it's the script that the human mike interruption protesters were trying to use when they interrupted the president's speech in new hampshire today. you have this guy essentially deliver a confrontational message to the president of the united states, but look at this, this is an amazing photo. look at the look on the kid's face and look at the looks on the faces of the people around him up that close with the president. it's kind of an amazing campaign shot from that ap photographer, charles darapac. this is one of those ones that probably goes into the awards short lists. the reason president obama was in new hampshire today was to talk about a payroll tax cut that he signed into law at the end of last year. payroll tax cut giving the ç average american family about $1,500 extra they otherwise would not have.

that cut in your payroll taxes expires at the end of next month. the president today was arguing it should be extended. now, this is something that already exists. this is not a new idea. it is not a very controversial idea. on the one side of this argument, you have president obama pushing for this thing today in new hampshire, on the other side you had all of the conservative groups including the koch brothers' american for prosperity today coming out in washington and saying, yes, please, we agree with president, extend the payroll tax cut. the president is for it and the conservative groups on the right are for it. where are the republicans on it? do the republican presidential nominees support this idea? hold on. in order to answer that, you -- what month is it? the likely republican presidential nominee, mitt romney, has sort of symbolized the republican field by being all over the map on this payroll tax cut thing. first he was for it, then against it then back to being for it. mitt romney has made a hash of this issue. >> what he's advocating, at least for now, an extension of the payroll tax cut?

>> i'm all in favor of keeping taxes down and keeping burdens down in american businesses and employers. i want employers and and entrepreneurs to have every incentive to open businesses and start creating jobs. >> if the payroll tax cut is not extended, that would mean a tax increase for all americans. what would be the consequences of that? >> no one likes to see tax increases, but look, the stimulus bills the president comes out with that are supposedly going to create jobs, we've now seen this played in the theater several times. and what we're seeing hasn't worked. >> you'd be okay with seeing the payroll tax cut -- >> look, i don't like temporary little band-aids. >> would you support an ç extension of the payroll tax cut? >> i don't want to raise taxes on people in the middle of a recession. >> to clarify, you agree with president obama the payroll tax cut should be extended? >> i want to keep our taxes down. i don't want to raise any taxes

anywhere. >> mitt romney was for the payroll tax cut in august. mitt romney was against it as a temporary little band-aid in october, and then in november so far, at least, in november, he has been for it. the biggest news in d.c. politics right now is the big congressional supercommittee has failed. one of the things people hoped was going to be worked out in the negotiations was this issue of the payroll tax cut. also the extension of unemployment benefits. according to the congressional budget office, if those two things don't get extended it will have a huge negative impact on the economy. since the supercommittee failed to act on those two things, there will now be the usual level of political fighting about those things with the added spark that the combatants in the fights are going to be people running for president. here's the thing, though. the election is a really long way away. the election is a year away. and we all have to live in this country no matter what happens in this election. these fights are not just for show. they're not just about political posturing. it's about whether the economy gets better or gets worse. forget the election. today we learned the u.s. economy grew at a slower rate in

the third quarter of this year than we originally thought. instead of growing at 2.5% rate, we grew at a 2% rate. at the same time, the national unemployment rate remains stuck at around 9%. it's not all bad news, though. the economy is actually awesome right now for one specific sector of the country. today it was reported that u.s. bank earnings are at their highest level in more than four years. woo-hoo! at least there's that. the occupy movement has got the country talking about the interests of the banks not always being the same thing as the interest of the country. and the occupy wall street has got the country talking about the fact that the 1%, the very richest, them doing welí doesn't necessarily trickle down to benefit anybody else. the occupy wall street movement has changed the conversation. and it behooved politicians of all stripes, left, right and center to be able to speak to those issues and sometimes to those individual human activists when they interrupt your speech. putting your money where your mouth is means coming up with now economic policies that

really do help the 99%. that don't just empathize, that really do help. joining us no is "washington post" columnist and msnbc policy analyst ezra klein. ezra, nice to see you. thanks for being here. >> good evening. >> when mitt romney was against extending the payroll tax cut thing, he derided it as a little band-aid. is it a little band-aid? would it have a notable effect? >> it is littler than it could be. it's funny, because mitt romney's argument makes you think he'd like a much larger stimulus. the payroll tax cut, $120 billion a year. economic forecasters think that would be enough for 1% to 2% in growth next year but not a ton either. it would be great to have more, to have infrastructure investment, to have an extension of unemployment insurance. if you think it's too little of a band-aid, the idea is to make it bigger. obviously that has not been the tact mitt romney has taken with it. >> in terms of what happened this week in washington, ezra, i mean, obviously people are headlining the fact this was supposed to be a deficit reduction supercommittee and didn't come up with deficit

reduction plans and so now some automatic deficit reduction plans, some automatic big cuts are due to go into effect. that's the headline here. is it possible, did you expect, did other people in washington expect the supercommittee thing would have been able to come up with some ways to help the economy, not just to cut the deficit but actually help the way things are now? >> absolutely. almost every deal seriously considered in the supercommittee included uy and the payroll cutç unemployment insurance and the payroll cut. that was a big deal. though the supercommittee fell apart, the republicans much more so than mitt romney did, said, we're not so sure about the payroll cut or not so sure about ui anymore. you were going to get $1.2 trillion in deficit reduction one way or another, the trigger or the supercommittee. you were saying at the beginning of the segment here that there are policies here that help the 1% and policies here that help the 99%. what's funny, this is one that helps both. the banks do not recover. finance does not recover. corporations cannot recover. not in the long run, unless the rest of the country recovers, too.

so the market died yesterday. if you read the financial press, "bloomberg news" or jp morgan, what they sent out, everybody said it was for the same reason. not because they were worried about the deficit. that wasn't going to change from what they thought it would be. but they're worried we would go into fiscal contraction next year and the economy would be worse and if the 99% aren't buying things, it's hard for the 1% to make money. >> we saw in the news today banks are having their biggest quarter in four years. i feel like this is obvious now. we've had record corporate earnings, we've had wall street broadly speaking doing great. we've got direct evidence that banks as well as other big companies are doing great. how is it that these guys are having such a great year? they're having such a great time of it? and it doesn't ever translate to everybody else doing better? >> there's a lot of why they're not spending the money. we'll take the corporate and bank profits just that they're sitting on for a moment. is that they don't see a reason to spend it. they don't see a way to spend it profitably. a corporation would build

another factory or hire more people if it had customers to sell the goods to and customers who go and need a new store clerk. the banks would give out more loans, hand out more investments if they thought they were going to make them back profitably. they weren't worried the economç is going to crack over europe next year. there are two big impediments for them to get the money into the economy and and help the economy recover. demand, infrastructure investment, and the other is uncertainty about whether or not we're going to have a major recession due to something like europe. that's helped by investors. if europe goes badly, if we're doing some fiscal stimulus and have economic supports, if congress and the federal reserve are committed to standing behind the economy, then at least, you know, it's not going to get all that bad. at least you know our political system will respond in a way to mitigate the damage. >> "washington post" columnist, msnbc policy analyst, ezra klein.

ezra, thank you, my friend. nice to see you. >> thank you. a big unexpected and principled political move out of the pacific northwest tonight. a governor has had a crisis of conscience and made a surprise move tonight that really nobody saw coming. that's just ahead. [ woman ] my boyfriend and i were going on vacation, so i used my citi thank you card to pick up some accessories. a new belt. some nylons. and what girl wouldn't need new shoes? we talked about getting a diamond. but with all the thank you points i've been earning...

♪ ...i flew us to the rock i really had in mind. ♪ [ male announcer ] the citi thank you card. earn points you can use for travel on any airline, with no blackout dates.

i wanted support for my heart... and now i get it from centrum specialist heart. new centrum specialist vision... helps keep my eyes healthy. centrum specialist energy... helps me keep up with them. centrum specialist prenatal...

supports my child's growth and development. new centrum specialist is a complete multivitamin that gives me all the benefits of centrum. plus additional support... [ all ] for what's important to me. [ male announcer ] new centrum specialist helps make nutrition possible. an accident doesn't have to slow you down. with better car replacement available only with liberty mutual auto insurance, if your car's totaled, we give you the money for a car one model year newer. to learn more, visit us today. responsibility. what's your policy? one suggestion for winning in iowa and new hampshire this year, do not campaign there. do not kiss babies. keep a low profile. politico.com noting this week the candidates at the top of the

polls in the republican primaries are the ones who spent the least amount of time meeting with voters in the early states. look at who's ahead. newt gingrich and herman cain in the early states, noted by politico, quote, ride high in early state polls, spending time promoting their own interests and book projects than on the trial in iowa and new hampshire. rick santorum meanwhile has been camping out in iowa making a point of visiting every single one of that state's 99 counties. yet, mr. santorum still polling at roughly 4% there. also jon huntsman focusing his entire campaign on new hampshire, only polling at 9% there and can't get a bounce to save his life. don't forget poor tim pawlenty who ran really, really hard in iowa and dropped out after the ames straw poll. for whatever reason, early state campaigning does not translate into doing well and isn't cutting it for republican candidates. what does seem to be having an impact for the candidates in the

polls is the debates. tons of people watching the debates and there have been a ton of debates. the republican candidates have completed ten of them. along with two forums and one sort of fakey super friendly two-person nondebate between newt gingrich and herman cain for which the tickets were really expensive. there's apparently going to be three more debates between now and christmas. these things have been the greatest show on earth. at the very first debate, we were reminded why it was so great ron paul is always around at these things. >> senator, are you suggesting that heroin and prostitution are an exercise of liberty? >> up until this past century, for over 100 years they were legal. what you're referring is, you know what, if we legalize heroin tomorrow, everybody's going to use heroin. how many people here would use heroin if it was legal? i bet nobody would put the -- oh, yeah, i need the government to take care of me, i don't want to use heroin so i need these laws. >> i never thought heroin would get applause here in south carolina. >> that was the first republican

debate back in may when ron paul says, essentially, we should legalize heroin and the audience goes nuts. then at the first debate in iowa in august, rick santorum, who famously compared being gay to doing something that he described as man on dog, he made what appeared to be what sounded like a bit of unsolicited -- >> now they're under a murlocracy that tramples the rights of women, gays, tramples the rights of people all ç throughout society. >> rick santorum stands up for the rights of gay people in iran. he doesn't appear to change his opposition to gay rights in this country. thanks to the republican debate show, weird stuff happens. rick santorum speaking up for gay iranians is now a thing that exists in the world. i love this show. at the next debate in september, we learned another new thing about republican debate audiences. nobody expected legalizing heroin to be an applause line in

the first place. at the nbc debate at the reagan library, presiding over a record number of executions became an applause line. >> your state has executed 234 death row inmates. more than any other governor in modern times. have you -- [ applause ] have you struggled to sleep at night with the idea that any one of those might have been innocent? >> in the state of texas, if you come into our state and you kill one of our children, you kill a police officer, you're involved with another crime and you kill one of our citizens, you will face the ultimate justice in the state of texas. and that is you will be executed. >> what do you make of -- [ applause ] what do you make of that dynamic just happened here, the mention of the execution of 234 people drew applause? >> i think americans understand

justice. >> then at the next debate just a couple of days later, the republican debate audience made itself famous again. >> let me ask you this hypothetical question. a healthy 30-year-old young man has a good job, makes a good living, but decides, you know what, i'm not going to spend $200 or $300 a month for health insurance because i'm healthy, i don't need it, but, you know, something terrible happens.ç all of a sudden he needs it. >> my advice to him would have a major medical policy -- >> he doesn't have that. he doesn't have it. he needs intensive care for six months. who pays? >> that's what freedom is all about. taking your own risk. this whole idea that you have to prepare and take care of everybody -- [ applause ] >> but congressman, are you saying the society should just let him die? >> no. >> yeah! the debate crowd, yeah! saying if somebody doesn't have insurance gets sick, yeah, let them die! then the next debate is when it became clear why it is rick

perry is the last kid on the bench when it comes to choosing up sides in debate club. >> i think americans just don't know sometimes which mitt romney they're dealing with. is it the mitt romney that was on the side of -- against the second amendment before he was for the second amendment? was it before he was before the social programs from the standpoint of he was for standing up for roe v. wade, before he was against roe v. wade. yesterday we found out through admiral mullen that haqqani has been involved with, and that's the terrorist group directly associated with the pakistani countries. and that's exactly what i'm going to bring to washington when i go there in november, or excuse me, in january of 2013. >> that's what they call foreshadowing. at the next debate, we're now into october, we really started to see that the rick perry/mitt

romney bickering we've all come to know and love about the republican debate show, that that was not only going to be exciting, it was going to be funny. >> i'll tell you this, though. we have the lowest number of ç kids, as a percentage, uninsured of any state in america. you have the highest. i'm still speaking. i'm still speaking. i'm still speaking. we have less than 1% of our kids that are uninsured. you have a million kids uninsured in texas. a million kids. under president bush the percentage of uninsured went down. under your leadership, it's gone up. >> i'm still speaking. that was just the -- i'm still -- i'm still -- you can do this even fighting with yourself. anyway. that was just the warmup for the following debate a week later where the romney/perry story line peaked. the october 18th episode of the republican debate show is the one where mitt romney laid hands on rick perry. >> mitt, you lose all of your standing from my perspective because you hired illegals in

your home and you knew about it for a year and the idea that you stand here before us and talk about that you're strong on immigration is on its face the height of hypocrisy. governor romney? >> rick, i don't think i've ever hired an illegal in my life. i'm looking forward to finding your facts on that. >> i'll tell you what the facts are. >> rick, again -- rick, i'm speaking. >> the newspaper -- >> i'm speaking. are you going to keep talking or let me finish with what i have to say? look, rick -- >> i thought republicans followeded rules. >> this has been a tough couple debates for rick. i understand that. so you're going to get -- you're going to get testy. we hired a lawn company to mow our lawn, and they had illegal immigrants that were working there. when that was pointed out to us, we let them go and we went to them -- just -- you have a problem with allowing someone to finish speaking.

i suggest that if you want to ç become president of the united states, you got to let both people speak. first, let me speak. so we went to the company and we said, look, you can't have any illegals works on our property. i'm running for office, for pete's sake, i can't have illegals. >> i'm running for office, for pete's sake, i'm speaking, i'm speaking. that performance -- speaking -- followed a few weeks later by the oops debate. >> i will tell you, it's three agencies of government when i get there that are gone. commerce, education and the -- what's the third one there? let's see. >> you need five. >> oh, five. >> commerce, education and the -- >> epa? >> epa. there you go. no. >> seriously? is epa the one you were talking about? >> no, sir. we were talking about the -- agencies of government -- epa

needs to be rebuilt. >> you can't -- you can't name the third one? >> the third agency of government, i would to away with the education, the -- >> commerce. >> commerce. and let's see -- i can't. the third one. i can't. sorry. oops. >> what did he have written down that he was looking at that didn't help? a few days later we got a clarifying moment -- i'm speaking -- about republican debate audiences. >> mr. cain, you're familiar with the long running debate whether waterboarding constitutes torture or is an enhanced interrogation technique. in the last campaign, john mccain and barack obama agreed it was torture and should not be allowed and the army field manual should be the methodology used to interrogate enemy combatants. do you agree or disagree, sir? >> i agree it was an enhanced ç interrogation technique. >> and then you would support it

as president? you would return to that policy? >> i would return to that policy. i don't see it as torture. i see it as an enhanced interrogation technique. >> congresswoman bachmann, your opinion on this question that our e-mailer asked? >> if i were president, i would be willing to use waterboarding. i think it was very effective. it gained information for our country. >> woo! i love the hooter. it's the clapping then the hoot. woo! applauding torture. just to be clear that that's what they're doing, they applaud it twice. woo! waterboarding. over this past weekend there was another one of the forums, this most notable for the fact that three of the six candidates in attendance cried during the event. perhaps maybe a tribute to house speaker john boehner who cries a lot, who cried last week? i always find it charming? in any case, the republican debate show is not stopping any time soon. ten debates, one forum, already in the can. there are set to be 13 more. 13 more through mid-march. and that's even before we get to

the real presidential debates during the general election. i know it is inevitable, but i'm going to be so sad when this show gets canceled. ♪ let's go ♪ ♪ ♪ come with me, let's go ♪ ♪ come with me, let's go ♪ ♪ cruise like a norwegian ♪ ♪ and just let me be [ male announcer ] this is your moment. ♪ your ticket home ♪ [ male announcer ] this is zales, the diamond store.

turn right up ahead. you never update me. so, now i just have to wing it. i meant turn left up ahead. recalculating. turn right now! [ horn honks, tires screech ] [ laughs ] [ crash! ] and your fifteen-minute insurance might not pay for all this. so get allstate. you could save money and be better protected from mayhem like me. recalculating. [ dennis ] dollar for dollar nobody protects you from mayhem like allstate. tle dennis ] dollar for dollar nobody protects you from mayhem emotional hetlretl?tl aren't you getting a little industrial? okay, there's enough energy right here in america. yeah, over 100 years worth. okay, so you mean you just ignore the environment. actually, it's cleaner. and, it provides jobs. and it helps our economy. okay, i'm listening. [announcer] at conoco phillips we're helping power america's economy with cleaner affordable natural gas... more jobs, less emissions, a good answer for everyone.

so, by reducing the impact of production... and protecting our land and water... i might get a job once we graduate.

on friday on this show, the best new thing in the world made me fall apart on camera. and my cousin athletes foot. yeah, a man named mr. butt having to enforce pakistan's new censorship of that word, i can't even make it -- best new thing in the world today. good-bye.

prison, go. i'm sorry. i'm very sorry i was not able to hold it together. however, there is an important update to the story that constitutes the best new thing in the world told. i have an agreement with my inner 12-year-old i'll deliver this like a grown-up. i don't trust my inner 12-year-old, but that deal is in place. that's coming up.

[ knock on door ] cool. you found it. wow. nice place. yeah. [ chuckles ] the family thinks i'm out shipping these. smooth move. you used priority mail flat rate boxes. if it fits, it ships for a low, flat rate. paid for postage online and arranged a free pickup. and i'm gonna track them online, too. nice. between those boxes and this place, i'm totally staying sane this year. do i smell snickerdoodles? maybe. [ timer dings ] got to go. priority mail flat rate shipping at usps.com. a simpler way to ship. they sound awesome tonight. and when i do find it, i share it with the world. you landed the u.s. tour ? done. this is fantastic ! music is my life and i want to make the most of it without missing a beat.

fly without putting your life on pause. be yourself nonstop. american airlines. that is better than today. since 1894, ameriprise financial has been working hard for their clients' futures. never taking a bailout. helping generations achieve dreams. buy homes. put their kids through college. retire how they want to. ameriprise. the strength of america's largest financial planning company. the heart of 10,000 advisors working with you, one-to-one. together, for your future. ♪

about 100 years ago a man named wilbur scoville worked pharmaceutical company. he thought he could rate the spiciness of things by measuring how the spicy things reacted with chemicals in a lab setting but was unpredictable and unprecise. more predictable and more precise turns out was this. mr. scoville found out the human tongue was sensitive enough to detect the substance that gives us spiciness at concentrations way below any test you could cook up in a lab. the thing that gives us the spicy sensation is called capsaicin and dissolved in alcohol. wilbur scoville soaked spicy things in alcohol overnight to draw the capsaicin out of them so the spiciness would be in thç alcohol solution. to that he'd add sweetened

water. the amount of water it make it undetectable by the human tongue, the amount to dilute it to make it not spicy at all, that gave you the amount of how much capsaicin was in thing you're measuring. excuse me, this is not a gag about spiciness. it's just me cat coughing on live tv. excuse me. the measure of spiciness because of this method that scoville came up for measuring it became forever known as the scoville unit. it's named for wilbur scoville. we have more precise ways to measure spiciness now, but essentially when people talk about heat and the human pain caused by spiciness, we still think in terms of scoville units. this is the scoville scale. down there at zero scoville heat units is the sweet bell pepper. you can eat those puppies like apples. you might find it disgusting. i personally hate bell peppers. it's not a spicy experience.

a chili stuffed with cheese and deep fried, is delicious. those peppers a quarter way up the toville. jalapeno pepper, imaginejalapeno pepper, measures 3,000 to 8,000 scoville units. cayenne pepper, we use that in powder form, the cayenne is about ten times as spicy as the jalapeno. moving on up to the i'm going to need a fire extinguisher territory is the habanero pepper. to basco says their own very ho original tobasco sauce is here ç on the scale. their habanero sauce is the one above it in terms of heat. original tobasco sauce, tea light to tiki torch.

it's very hot. the habanaro which dwarfs everything else, the habanaro chili is child's play when it comes to this. certified at the hottest pepper in the world by the guinness book of world records. there's a world of amateur video out there of people showing themselves, taping themselves eating a ghost pepper and then, forgive the word, but barfing or getting visibly and horribly sick for a very long time. on the scoville scale, the highest pepper rating there is before pure unadulterated undiluted capsaicin, the spiciest pepper is the ghost pepper on the pain inducing scale before you get to raw capsaicin at 15,000 scoville units.

there's one more thing hotter than the ghost pepper. that's pepper spray. the kind sold and used legally in the united states. on the scoville scale, the u.s. grade pepper spray is rated two to five times more intensely hot and therefore painful for humans than the ghost pepper is. that's pepper spray.ç for the occupy wall street movement, seeing the police use disproportionate force on nonviolent protesters has been a galvanizing thing and to a great extent it has not been the generic use of force we've seen by police that's caused observers to have a visceral reaction. to a great extent, it's been the use of this particular chemical weapon. joining us, deborah blum, author of "the poisoner's handbook." she's been writing about pepper spray. thanks very much for joining us tonight. >> thanks.

it's great to be here. >> is the scoville scale a useful and accurate way to understand what pepper spray is like as a weapon? i mean, it is on the scale with food. is that misleading in any way? >> it is in that, you know, people say pepper and they think, oh, something from the kitchen, something kind of domestic, but it's a really useful scale in that it gives us a point of reference we all know. everyone has occasionally made salsa or chopped up a pepper and gotten it in their eyes and felt that burn and knows how much it hurts. so what the scoville scale tells us is that pepper spray, commercial grade pepper spray, is off the charts from that experience. a habanero is about 350,000 on the scoville. police grade pepper spray is about 5.3 million. and that gives you a point of reference against your everyday

life. in terms of just saying, whoa, that's way beyond what i realize, the scoville scale is incredibly useful, i think. >> in terms of trying to understand the effect of pepperç tray on human beings, nationwide we've all seen pepper spray shot into protesters' faces over the last few weeks at occupy wall street events around the country. how much of a difference does it make in terms of the human experience? how it is actually applied, the quantity, the distance from which it's shot at you. it affects the overall dosage. >> that's a great question. there's a saying in toxicology that the dose makes the poison. one of the things the scoville scale tells us is this is a very high dose. we know capcaisins do two things. they bond to our nervousystem and trigger the pain response and they're a little corrosive. they cause a chemical burn. so when you're talking about the kind of levels that you're talking about with commercial grade pepper spray or people

call it o.c. spray, you're talking about a very intense dose. and that's why you actually see these incredible responses. you can see it on video. people fall over. people are screaming. people are rolling on the ground. that's another way of measuring how high this dose is. and the higher the dose, the more poisonous the effect. >> what are the potential long-term effects or even medium term health effects of being exposed to this in the kind of quantities that we've seen these protesters exposed to? >> you know, that's a really good question, because most of our experience is the short-term blast in the face effect, but studies that have been done looking at people who work with peppers or animal studies say this. they say that you can have sort of long-term effects on breathing. people -- it's an inflammatory effect, right? it effects your nervous system and causes it to kind of blow up in some interesting ways.

so it can make your allergic ç system worse. it makes asthma worse. it has long term sort of burn effects in the respiratory system. i mean, a really good example of it is actually we know that one blast in the face damages your eyes in a temporary sense. it disrupts the cells in the outer layer of the cornea. there's lots of studies that show that if this happens multiple times, you get permanent effects in the cornea, you get a long term permanent blurring of vision and that tells us in particular that if you're sprayed multiple times, you could be looking at some fairly serious long-term effects. >> deborah blum is a pulitzer prize winning science writer, author of "poisoner's handbook." a guest writer for "scientific american." i've found your writing on this to be helpful for understanding. >> thank you. thank you for having me on. we recently reported a new list of words that pakistan's government is not going to let its citizens send by text message anymore.

words like monkey crotch and headlights. i was a little bit out of control when we reported this on friday night. now the story has moved in the direction that madeby lay down on the floor and cover my face when i heard about it today. there's a hint in that last sentence. best new thing in the world is coming up.eryo their new blackberry from at&t? it's 4g, so you can do more faster. so, kathryn, post more youtube videos of your baby acting adorable. baby. on it. matt, ignore me and keep updating your fantasy team. huh? jeff, play a game. turbo-boosting now, sir. dennis, check in everywhere you go on foursquare. that's mayor dennis... of the water cooler. you're the best. liz, rock out to pandora. oh, no i'm an only child. and nick, you shouldn't even be here, you can do everything from the golf course. good? good. [ male announcer ] on at&t, blackberry® torch moves at the speed of 4g. ♪ nurse...! [ female announcer ] dawn power clean can give you the power of an overnight soak in just 5 minutes. [ sponge ] it's a scientific miracle! [ female announcer ] dawn does more.

[ sponge ] so it's not a chore. [ female announcer ] dawn does more. ♪ ♪ ♪ when the things that you need ♪ ♪ come at just the right speed, that's logistics. ♪ ♪ medicine that can't wait legal briefs there by eight, ♪ ♪ that's logistics. ♪ ♪ freight for you, box for me box that keeps you healthy, ♪ ♪ that's logistics. ♪ ♪ saving time, cutting stress, when you use ups ♪ ♪ that's logistics. ♪ like a ramen noodle- every-night budget. she thought allstate car insurance was out of her reach. until she heard about the value plan. shop less. get more. make one call to an allstate agent.

in the last 49 years, in

oregon, the state of oregon has executed two of its prisoners. both of those executions were when john kitsaver was governor in the 1990s, who was personally opposed to the death penalty but said he let the executions be carried out under his watch because it was the law in his state. he is now the governor of oregon again. and today, faced with the prospect of overseeing the killing of another oregon prisoner, this time the governor said no. he wouldn't do it.ç in a statement tonight, the governor said the death penalty as practiced in oregon is neither fair nor just and it is not swift or certain. it is not appied equally to all. he described the last two executions he presided over in the 1990, as, quote, the most difficult and agonizing decisions i made at governor. i don't believe the executions made us safer or nobler as a society. 14 years ago, he says, i struggled with the decision to allow an execution to proceed. over the years i thought if faced with the same set of circumstances, i would make a

different decision. that time has come. the one oregon prisoner scheduled to be killed in two weeks' time has been given a reprieve from execution for the duration of governor kitzhaber's term. this is a temporary retrieve so the prisoner could still be executed under another governor. governor kitzhaber noted today he could have commuted all the citizens of all the prisoners on death row and converted them to life sentences instead, but he didn't. saying, quote, the policy of this state on capital punishment is not mine alone to decide. it's a matter for all oregonians to decide and my hope, indeed, my intention that my action today will bring about a long overdue reevaluation of our current policy. in other words, the governor wants the state to consider changing its policies about killing prisoners, but unless and until the state does change the policy, governor john kitzhaber will refuse to see anymore prisoners killed on liz watch. a dramatic and unexpected statement of principle from oregon's governor tonight. we posted his whole statement

which is intense and worth reading at our blog today at maddowblog.com. ♪ you, you ain't alone ♪ and just let me be [ male announcer ] this is your moment. ♪ your ticket home ♪ [ male announcer ] this is zales, the diamond store.

tdd# 1-800-345-2550 there are atm fees. tdd# 1-800-345-2550 account service fees. tdd# 1-800-345-2550 and the most dreaded fees of all, hidden fees. tdd# 1-800-345-2550 at charles schwab, you won't pay fees on top of fees. tdd# 1-800-345-2550 no monthly account service fees. tdd# 1-800-345-2550 no hidden fees. tdd# 1-800-345-2550 and we rebate every atm fee. tdd# 1-800-345-2550 so talk to chuck tdd# 1-800-345-2550 because when it comes to talking, there is no fee. what is this shorty? uh, tissues sir, i'm sick. you don't cough, you don't show defeat. give me your war face! raaah! [ male announcer ] halls. a pep talk in every drop. the pioneers. the aviators. building superhighways in an unknown sky. their safety systems built of brain and heart,

transforming strange names from tall tales into pictures on postcards home. and the ones who followed them, who skimmed the edge of space, the edge of heaven, the edge of dreams. and we follow them up there to live by an unbreakable promise, stitched into every uniform of every captain who takes their command: to fly. to serve. ♪ let's go ♪ ♪

♪ come with me, let's go ♪ ♪ come with me, let's go ♪ ♪ cruise like a norwegian ♪ okay. best new thing in the world. we reported on this showon friday night that the government of pakistan was about to ban certain words from text messages. starting this week, starting yesterday, in fact, the plan was to block any text message in pakistan that contained one of roughly 11,000 english words and phrases. among the words pakistan planned to block you from texting in the country were the words flatulence, tongue, fairy, gonorrehea, if you spelled it this one incorrect way, also headlights, fingerfood, love pistol, deposit and what the english speaking press, me

included, reported at monkey crotch. pakistanis tell us today it's ç actually crotch monkey, not monkey crotch and i believe them. also on the banned text message word list as you expect, dozens of phrases that include the "f" word including phrases i've never heard of. i consider myself a scholar on these things. also 22 phrases that use the word butt, on the banned word list though it's the last name of a telecom person in pakistan. mr. butt being told to enforce making his own name illegal to text. i spent the entire weekend trying to live down my inability to deliver this news on friday night with a straight face. i live in a small town. there's not much else to talk about. i couldn't get away from people making fun of me about that. now the day pakistan was supposed to block out the crotch monkey and turn off the athletes foot and the tongue and the headlights and the fairy, now we get news the government of

pakistan is maybe backing off. "voice of america" reporting since someone leaked the list of banned words and phrases, quote, social media services like twitter exploded with ridicule from pakistanis. "voice of america" saying the frequently ridiculed example is the one about the monkey. can't imagine why. the pakistani government said they were going a test run to see if they could block words in texts if they wanted to. they say they will release a final, much shorter list of banned words later after they consult with the phone companies again. phone companies whose executives include one mr. butt which is not that uncommon a name in pakistan. one hopes mr. butt will get the one word cleared on the final shorter banned text message list of words, if ever there is a new list. in any case, for now, i'm happy to say that you can still text butt and athletes foot and a million "f" words in pakistan. for now you still can. it's a small reprieve for foul mouthed liber(ue