the man is absolutely the beginning. yes, no, it's paid, yes, i mean, you, uh, evaluate the application, you get money for each application, i see, therefore, we uh, we treat this as a professional job, and we are very tough. i mean, the fund is already here , the fund is already evaluating. as far as the expert could be biased, unbiased, but this is estimated by the totality of data that the system evaluates again, but you have to part with the experts. we had to part with experts who did not keep secrecy. these are generally very secretive people. they do not have the right under their contract to publish that they are experts of the presidential fund for cultural initiatives somewhere on the corner, that i am an expert , then it’s usually all if i speak and speak to the audience in front of the audience. here we have 1,000 experts. perhaps, someone in this room also has to immediately raise in no case, because we will have to deal with the exclusion here. and in fact, this is happening. for many reasons, i mean, this is

secrecy and so that there is no pressure on the expert, of course, and so that there is no abuses and so that, well, in the end, there are people who are offended by the fact that projects do not support this, including for security reasons, too. independence comes, of course, and your address, of course, of course, comes from the very first competition, the most a tense psychological moment for me is the first week after we announce the results of the next contest, about a week or so. this, of course, is an unusual intensity of passions. and this can be understood, in fact. we are from the very first competition it became clear that every creative project. he is like a child, that is, people are the emotions that people experience for their children and for their creative projects. they are about the same. i myself have been in this situation once, when i also worked in an organization that also applied for grants and when you lose. you, of course, well, you are so offended internally, but now you need to gather the brotherhood in

your hands to see where you made a mistake and move forward. say, here's hmm about the amounts. they vary, as i understand it, they start with very small ending very large, well, in a separate case. yes , of course, well, we have projects of 80,000 rubles. for example, a has projects worth 127 million rubles. and the spread is very large, but it's really 5,000 very different projects, where uh there are uh projects that are implemented in very small towns, and there are places that cover the whole country, so the cost, of course, they are very different, but i can say that e in each wave, for example, in the case of 10 million rubles. and about 40 projects win, that is, 40-45 projects. this is over 10 million rubles. well, up to 500, of course, this is over a hundred projects. yeah, and so on, but the most popular category is five hundred to 3 million rubles, in principle, in

principle, uh, in my opinion, most of these good strong projects can be done somewhere in the amount of somewhere around 2-2.5 mln rub. at the same time , uh, we must keep in mind that we had the first competition, uh, in the twenty-third year in which the level of co-financing was. that is, er, those resources that are invested. the people themselves are additionally 101%. that is, here we gave 2.5 million rubles. another 2.5 million rubles. have put together commands. well, that is, at the moment we have, in principle, if we are talking about 15 billion rubles, which we gave to the teams, then somewhere around 12 billion rubles. this is what people have invested. can you imagine, that is, almost 30 billion rubles that have flowed into the economy over the past 2 years. and this too. i think it's a very important indicator. here you are talking team a teams can be, one person, of course. of course, of course, but one must understand that one person alone is still not a warrior in the field. yes, on the other

side of sweden on the pipe and greece sometimes, of course, there is a creative project - they are very different, and therefore yes, indeed , there may be one professional person who does everything, but within the framework of some small project, it doesn’t matter. if you do a project, er, well, related to the organization, whatever, you still can’t cope on your own, so there are practically no such projects. we even have one recently. in general, a terrible letter addressed to me that they did not support a wonderful project. why didn't they support because a large theatrical production grandiose in one of the regions for 25 million rubles. uh, two people do it. well, well, yes, because experts draw conclusions from everything because of this. can you be trusted with public money or not? it's worth the task. uh, as i understand it, find and give, uh, the opportunity to appear young. uh,

talent leader in the arts culture of the creative industry, has not dried up. this brook will not dry up yet. uh, first of all, we have a lot of areas where we need to find these young names. young talents. uh, and where they really are and in every area where wherever we look, cinema theater computer games. eh, music, and then the music is already popular, which means that classical and so on and so forth are felt the most, and there are a lot of theater projects. and this is just, uh, on the one hand, we hear that young actors are needed, and on the other hand. yes , indeed, there are already projects that are working to ensure that in these young e. reveal we have a lot of talk about the need for new voices. here the shaman sings now the most russian hit, for example, yes, his song is one of the very popular ones from uh

fresh, just now the author wrote it one of the participants in this competition, just yes, and then this mechanism is twisted. you and i get new songs, new names of new artists, and so on. so the fund is perceived as one of the tools for integrating the new russian regions , our common civilizational cradle, er, including the cultural one, but how is the process going? the process is underway. uh, and at the moment. we have supported about 300 projects, which are directly on e. here are the territories of luhansk donetsk kherson and so on. here they are, uh, there they are now implementing this and the museum. there is a project. uh, concert projects are, uh, projects related to exhibitions. e. in lugansk, for example, recently opened in the museum a whole exposition dedicated to the formation

of the statehood of the luhansk people's republic. for example, i was there, but absolutely amazing. if you want to understand why? what happened then you have to go and see with your own eyes this exposition with you . there will be no doubt that what we do. this is correct, there are already quite a few projects that are being implemented. there together there in st. petersburg, mariupol e, novosibirsk lugansk vladivostok donetsk there and so on set. documentaries are out. uh, large exhibitions such as, for example, the museum of the victory of ordinary nazism, for example, there was a large exhibition now in the my history museum, a russian project began. azov, for example, yes, this is exactly what can help young people understand why and from what what happens, that is, these are the origins and so that a person can think with his own head and draw conclusions and not be subject to any propaganda. yes, that is, a person, when he himself

saw the artifacts, when he himself saw the facts , the conclusions, of course, it is much easier for him to navigate and we also support such projects. thank you very much for the conversation. thanks for the invitation. hello in russia, the decade of science and technology presents a program on how science will change our lives for the next 10 years. i am vladimir antokhin. i am ekaterina shugaeva. in 10 years, fiction will disappear, we'll see, because i invited the optimists,

who believe that in 10 years , fiction will really disappear. this is andrey novikov lanskoy, a writer of literature. good evening. decisions hello good evening culture. what is the probability that in 10 years fiction will really disappear about the history of the emergence of literature in the century bc? cuneiform tablets the oldest inscriptions found during excavations sumerian cuneiform writing did not appear earlier than 3,000 years before our largest library consisted of 25,000 clay documents in syriac

in the babylonian and sumerian languages, the hieroglyphs of ancient china were invented by emperor fuxi. ay , he saw them on the shells of turtles, well, about egyptian hieroglyphs and stone rosettes. i think they know all the most ancient records were household records, just like most of our birch bark letters. these are private letters, debt collection, trade, household instructions, as well as testamentary receipts and even court records, but among them there are literary and folklore works of jokes and riddles. but the epic of the gilgamesh, of course, the iliad of odysseus - this is already infusion. ancient literature as for russian ancient texts, the oldest of them is the word on law and grace written back in the 11th century, and philip you are probably a physicist rather than lyric. do you know when exactly

fiction arose, when it appeared fiction literature appears in literature appears in the 18th century bc in the 3rd century bc babylon a tale about a fairy tale the first such reliable facts in egypt e, tale-synhete e, the tale of two brothers such literary appear, and works. well, of course, we all know lade about and about homer's odysseus represent so far seven cities fighting for something, in general, where they live and where they were born and died. this e homer , who may even be, is a fictional character na in a language that no longer exists. existing battles, they are an existing city , this is the purpose of this art to start such a process, respectively. i believe that fiction appears at the moment when language appeared, when people wanted

to convey information, maybe even hide it. yes, as they say, the language was created given to man, not only in order to to say, well, to hide something, so it was a very long time ago andrey lenivich. but on the contrary, you are more of a lyric than a physicist. and which ones just now said, of course, about yes , the children of homer, yes, and which are the most famous? well, in general, the most popular works of art in general in the history of mankind. and who counted? who decided but no, well, let's do it, the prices are, first of all, both in artistry and in the chronology of occurrence. of course, the most ancient text is gilgamesh gilgamash, which, well, no one knows. what video did he get us, because a lot was lost here, no one knows how you saw there got e, or hells and odysseus because they are divided into 24 songs according to the number of letters of the ancient greek alphabet, but this does not mean anything, because it is likely odessa a

if, for example, those are formed over the course of three e centuries of three centuries, and there are eight or nine campaigns in threes. well, let's do three trips, cartridges for each century, and each campaign gives rise to its own text. here is the text e, not any. there, in short, informative or there, transmitting or communicating there previous information. no, this is a text that talks about our needs, our needs, and show themselves to the world. here to make war our task is to defend there. and some ideas that we bring to this world. our task is to earn money, because we will not earn money by collecting olives. we are heroes we are red-bearded guys who come here and besiege troy for 10 days in order to make it happen, the main miracle of this life so that the world at least spins, so that the badger who lives inside this sh-this earthly globe,

so that it really shows, in general, that love is love for the motherland, love for a woman , love for money. for whatever reason, they write about this culture really is by the way, a sign of the greatness of literature why for example dostoevsky the great and some girl who wrote there i don’t know the text on vkontakte is some kind of banal. well, no, not artistically for several reasons, but the first reason is, of course. here is what was said. this is the antiquity of sex. a the second reason is tested from the text on quoting or worshiping this texture today we are on vkontakte, these are, yes, it’s easy to find me there, or someone? yes, yes, yes, it’s impossible to lose, to forget this , i understood my colleagues. you understand, we are now talking about those things that are sincere, that people love, this is true. there is nothing more beautiful. what, for example. i do not know the most naive love poems with the most

banal. e, reef, and i mean, i say, but a citation index in subsequent generations, that is, in other words, and those model, but model structures that are present in the texts. and one way or another they are replicated in the consciousness of the subsequent one , you understand this citation, where in this case, not just i don’t know there, but an appeal to a. here here communication with the precedent here the perception of the previous text. as part of not only communication, not only figurative artistic comprehension of the world. and how parts of your past is in the order of things? when we , for example, perceive the word about igor's campaign , or the zadonshchina, or the iliad, or, i don't know, any other ancient epic, we perceive it as part of his biography, but national ah. you see, trying on this long chronology and long-term involvement of us , each of us is not a private man in the street, who has

a very small history and a very doubtful prospect. yes, and the past. i don't know you won't tell anyone, only blushing with shame. you understand, no, we are proud that we are drawn to this grandiose beauty of the universe. when someone goes camping a sad hike. this is our past, we grieve no less than from the loss. i don't know there to worry in the end or health there or when i don’t know there, but a thousand something but ships, er, there they moor to the coast of troy when the guys are there. there is a task, there is a task. she's a little romanticized. but this will be done later, because antiquity treated this very, very pragmatically, then it will be necessary to romanticize, but give us our helen there, not helena proper. e was the cause, the whole whole thing. it's but you always need to come up with some kind of pretext for any village fight.

you understand, it’s beautiful there, it’s stormy, the sun is in a state, or vice versa, there is a full moon or on the rim, a frail moon, you always need to justify any fight. and here, as you can see, we must have a long history. each of us each of us has a, which this story of which this story turns from an inhabitant into a representative. i don't know one of those people who are sitting at the imaginary long table of humanity, and they are all men and next to them are women and next to them 10 and next to them the sheep are grazing like a goat. i don't i know who haven’t gone to the barbecue yet, but who well, these are our children and so on , you understand, and uh in this, and we read these texts and it becomes pleasant for us, at least, i don’t know these pisets that are there, because because that, for example, they took the epithet long-read from homer, and we understand that it is long-valued, which means it is not alive. it's not owned by

dogs or, uh, dust, or by the sea, for example. we are looking at the sea. we are looking. indeed it is the most senseless thing one can think of, but it is not senseless, because she is a ship-breaking fish , you understand, he teaches us at least some things that formulate our ideas about the world and you know. what kind of idea is this private when, for example, i don't know there, but the priest departs from the tomb. oh, fu, here is the bed of a dying old woman with the feeling that he will never again believe in the driven goat shyness. there are no goats. here you understand, here it always sounds, then the steamy theme, passing through the walls and silence and cries and groans, is the theme of the triumph of man. and it makes sense to each of us in general, epite the length of the dark, and the advertisement is a short advertisement on ntv love, all

ages are submissive, lay me down, not much old, but i’m young, whether tatyana vasilyeva decides to go to the registry office for the third time and sex is another matter. you agree absolutely financial position matters and that's it. why on alexander astashonko, pushes him into bed with young girls, hug her. so take it. so kiss your husband, my mistress was a year and a half, as the sisters and the zaitsevs divide one husband into two, the husband said quickly. take off your panties, she flew in and says, tanya, he confused me with himself , it happens that she is very much.

ntv i'm flying away, swimming down the mountain, moving out, and open the zone and relax. book profitable tickets, hotels, tours on ozon is a great way to teach your child financial literacy free tinkoff junior card get a free tinkoff juniors card and we will help your child with the first financial issues. it contains the highest dosage of the substance from the pain of inflammation pentalgin against pain and inflammation in the muscles and joints. in the application

yandex travel and get up to ten percent cashback yandex travel booking. hmm, then we were the first to launch sms, we were the first to connect the connection in the subway and rose above all so that you communicate not only with words, but

also with pictures, stickers, circles of rice. and if you need words again, say them looking into your eyes. meet megafon 3:0 with high-speed 3g which is now available to all subscribers. switch to megafon new fun from ruslan at any time in the stoloto application, everything is seething and diarrhea filtrum thank millions micropore filter absorbs bacteria, toxins, helping to eliminate the unpleasant symptoms of filtrum to put things in order in the stomach is a great way to teach a child financial literacy. free maps. tinkoff junio. the child will learn how to manage money right in the tinkov app. and it will be convenient for parents to keep track of his spending. get a free tinkoff

junior card and we will help your child with the first financial issues up to fifty percent discount. real discoveries of a large selection of hotels and get cashback up to 10%, yandex travel booking is a great way to teach your child financial literacy free tinkoff jungle map.

there are big changes at school now the pointer is not to break the grades not to fake the diary not to forget the parents at home can be collected in one message, and the learning formats have become more flexible and technologically indispensable, only teachers have remained indispensable, thanks to him, children have responsibility, perseverance and self-confidence become teacher. choose your university to be a teacher.rf. a teacher is forever a program about how science will change our lives, in the next 10 years, in 10 years , fiction, who and what our expert professor kapustin thinks

will tell. difference. no no. no russia enters the construction of the most reading countries 60% of russians read a book. at least once a week. more than we read only china and spain well, we are competing with the usa england and germany the higher the income of a person, the more often he can be seen with a book in his hands, illiterates in the world 15% gender differences are most pronounced in holland among bookworms in 50% of men and only 30% of women literacy in the world the need for a book is growing too and interestingly, over the past year , demand has grown by 30% for romance novels, 40% for science fiction and more than 50% for fantasy. well, percentage is good, but

it seems to me that sometimes statistics pick up. it seems to me that now they read less, but we are talking about literature, they are about mathematics oleg konstantinovich so today it belongs to the genre of fiction. well, i think that you don’t expect me to define what fiction is from wikipedia either. i can only say what i myself attribute to this genre, and what i do not attribute, and my criteria are very simple. he is inside. i still, well, adhere to the point of view that man is a creator, as the image and likeness of god and if in this text in this work, i see the soul of the one who wrote it, i feel it, and even the spirit, probably rather than a soul. that's it, i'm that it's a work of art. if not, then no, and in this sense, as they rightly said , it can also be scientific pop, behind which i see and

feel the one who wrote it. and in this sense, this is fiction, maybe, uh, formally classified by the genre of lipovis novels, which can not see anyone and have nowhere to go. even if literature from my point of view. so here is my definition. well, probably, everyone has their own here is what to say so, what they write in general, how to say general words there. the images there are fictitious fictional situations. well, well, well, that's wrong. well, what 's up with that? i loved you love still be. maybe he really loved, but is that something fictional, therefore, where is the creator behind the work felt yes, and where not? now there may already be a suspicion that it is artificial. andrey anatolyevich is sitting there, and any people have fiction, but it’s not

translated, but it’s their own, or there are peoples without literature. well, of course there is moreover their absolute majority. ok big one it is a rarity if a people has, first of all, its own written language, we do not realize how few peoples actually have their own written language. i'm not talking about my alphabet of such in general, well, a few units. you can say yes, but your alphabet, your writing. yes, even literature. yes , even a large corpus of some history of literature. this people is a very great rarity . there are very few such peoples, and even the peoples who created the great literature are, again, a few of them. well, look at the world. well let's say so about 5,000 languages. and writing is a must. yes, writing is far from all in writing, a prerequisite for the appearance of literature. am. there must be authorship. here they said that it is difficult to find the criteria

for fiction. well, probably really difficult, probably, there are a lot of such borderline moments. and where everything is very shaky, but in fact, there is still a science of literature of literature, where all the terms are, of course, spelled out. yes, that is no need to think that what is all this at all. maybe unsteady after all, there really should be writing. there must be authorship, this is necessarily the difference from folklore, where we do not know the author or, let's say, the author is collective, there are intermediate forms. the epic is no longer folklore, but not yet literature, but someone believes that it is literature. that is, when we speak a question of terms. it is very shaky, but the content of the terms changes a lot. well, a question. actually , the question was not about this, it was about whether there is and if if all peoples have literature, well, no, of course, a huge number of languages. ah, africa, south america, there, polynesia, australia , a huge number of languages ​​without writing , without literature. there must be some mythology there, of course, there is

some kind of folklore, without it there is no literature. that is, we, but let's say the russian and other peoples on the territory of our country. everyone , in general, has its own written language and its own literary history, but they are very happy in this sense, historical civilizational, that we do not just have literature, but great literature. here i am talking like this unit, if it is translated. for example, if africans translate pushkin, he becomes their literature. well, of course, but this is our literature new information. pushkin how are you, as pushkin’s studies are now becoming clear, yes, what does it matter that he is not from ethiopia, but that the arab of peter the great hannibal is from a child, but it’s not so far from ethiopia, but it’s just such a detail, he fights. it's nice . yes, fighting in africa, our guns. everything. we won't give it up, but the translated pushkin will always be a fact of russian literature. no matter what the language was not translated. it's nicely

philiped. but fiction, does it affect society, if it does, then how well, and the mkhomsky scientist says that language is a method of thinking, it is impossible to separate those departments in the brain that are responsible. in general, yes, some are responsible for the language for verbs , others for adjectives, so the child masters adjectives later than verbs. and the formation of the proposal yes and that's what colleagues say, just the same, this is the base. uh, literary writing, fine motor skills - it's all invested in us. and we think. so look at at at all at e, just the beauty of our language three words. i love you allows us to confess our love in eleven different forms, where you can find a language in which you can do it, for example i love you is one single

form. you won't even be able to reassemble it any other way, that's why we think in this way, that's why we are so creative, that's why we are so creative. yes, we can talk without verbs, yes, if only with verbs, yes, like a scientist, like a person in general, associated with technological technological revolution technological. eh, developmentally i understand that this is a core competence. now it will allow us to enter a new technological order, therefore, yes, our society is based on this language on this cultural code. well, this is a little exaggerated. i agree with colleagues. uh, unfortunately, uh with all colleagues from skeptics and optimists. well, but here we have exaggerated the influence of fiction on society in general. you know, this question has not yet been investigated, and every sociologist in general and, uh, historian of literature or literature. vet, i don't know a philosopher. well, not that everyone, but in any case, and he would like to find those subtle instruments of weighing the impact of society

on the impact of literature on society. and when, for example, i was small, uh, i studied from textbooks, which each chapter of which ended in the next lenin from tolstoy, that is, with other words , metallostroy influenced lenin or not, spoke out several times, so the question is here a genius, or rather lenin turgen and so on. i mean, it was all extraordinary. i'm great i opened, for example, a textbook, not a textbook, but a two-volume new year's book, and, read that tons of sailors, before going to the front to defend, and the october revolution, they went to look at the taigung foyn. and after that, they all shouted in avihun fonts and beat, there were white guards and so on. this is the most vulgar topic imaginable, we don't have all the weights, er, by which we can verify the accuracy of our our examination of this matter when we talk to you about those cultures that do not have fiction. there generally the nurse is a tradition is a myth. well,

let's just say we are not the inventors of coca-cola. do you understand, this is what hurts our soul? not at all. i don't know, after all. i first time coca-cola. yes, that's right , coca-cola. i've already tried it, after reading almost all of dostoevsky, do you understand what's the matter? the same thing, i don't know how polynesia is here for which for example i don't know life according to myth or under the gods. it is as natural as it is for us. presence dostoevsky in our life we ​​walk. every day i walk past the bolshoi theater. you see, but this does not mean that i visit the bolshoi theater every day, you understand? here is the same, here, fiction, literature. good numbers were sounded here, in general , we think they are some optimistic ones, but we forgot about one more circulation. we don’t have small ones, but we have a small assortment, you understand, and what place does any love story take in all this, a love story, in general , hardly belongs to fiction. there is some kind of ersatz. there is some kind of extract, outgoing literature, and on this

extract, by prop or even without trying, and some according to the model of secondary tertiary, and hollywood, and hollywood scenario , the whole concept of this artistic pseudo- fiction is built. this is not fiction. we read rubbish, but to rubbish, which refers to or a love story. and this is science pop or something else better. which i don't know. bye. roman well, today is the best love story of all time. this is no better than a love story, because this novel is not understandable. now you understand, we make students or uh or student, there students read this fragrance. they physically cannot read. this is when you think, give for the reason that a that their ability to read long constructions, and they have it is limited, because they are used to one second. now a thought will sound in

favor of thinking, or even not against clip thinking; they are brought up in the aesthetics of a limited fragmentary, but mental act and when everywhere advertising teaches them that's how the thought. after that, we give them anna karenina and say. come on, i don't know, let's read it. this is a seven-line sentence. they forget on the third line, of course, they are not able. physiologically, they are not able. read and then they take the culture, they take the love novel written. i don't know these cute ones. i don’t know optimistic aunts, but the truth is written, and everything is clear there, because the sentence ends on the same line. that's what really, what will become of our society. i don’t know, so you suffer from the fact that they stopped reading karina. yes, i envy you, you know , some kind of worldwide pain that has settled in general. this is a beautiful outfit, honestly

. let's just take a little while. let's get burned. katya will wait for the arrival of the train advertising. they lived a difficult life, they died, my beloved , i don’t need real grief, but in their souls they kept their youth and did not forget how to dream. 80 3 years impossible inside mixed energy and a farm girl haven't seen you for 5 years. thank you for these feelings of moms and super 60+ new

season. this is a program about amazing people with very different stories on sunday at 22:20 on ntv military police premiere from monday at 20:00 on ntv pentalgin in it is the highest dosage of a substance for pain and inflammation in the muscles. and i also want to relax my joints. book cheap tickets. the service for buying cheap

air tickets was offended. there is a great way to teach your child financial literacy free tinkoff junior card get a free tinkoff junior card and we will help your child to first financial questions. he is so alone. tell me, when you see a summer juicy sale on yandex market, buy a coffee split system for only 2290 rubles. at the beginning there was a word, then we were the first to launch sms, we were the first to connect the connection in the subway and rose above all so that you communicate not only with words, but also take pictures. and if you need a word again, say them looking into your eyes. go to megafon discomfort and stir up filtrum thanks to

millions of micropores filtrum absorbs bacteria toxins, helping to eliminate the unpleasant symptoms of filtrum, so that in according to legend, the quality of non-alcoholic canvas was checked by german knights, if drunk was equal to the width of the ball, then it was cooked according to the classic soap recipe from the halal valley, so the knight on non-alcoholic canvas is a symbol of the qualities of non-alcoholic quality in german for real discoveries it takes time and a place among a large selection of hotels in the yandex travel app and get up to 10% cashback. yandex travel hotel booking. tickets

with a credit card 120 everything and cancels interest on everything for one, two, three 120 for everything in rosbank is issued everywhere without interest. take cash for every glass. cashback, get 120 days without interest. buy, rosbank credit card 120 for everything without interest, the real possibilities pentalgin is a remedy for various types of pain pentalgin acts against pain, wherever it is , regardless of the reasons for its occurrence. pentalgin do without pain welcome to the changing world. this is what shopping together looks like, where not? nothing permanent. no, that is, the cure comes and goes today one thing and another tomorrow. and my favorite burger

is called. what difference does it make what it's called? and how to figure it all out, the yandex train, everything changes, everything is a fan card - this is a digital service for safe and comfortable attendance at football matches, the card number is needed to buy tickets and subscriptions to the games of the russian premier league and the final of the russian football cup apply for registration is possible at public services or in the application of public services fan card service is valid at the stadiums of all clubs in twelve cities get a fan card and play football in the stadium. on the air is a science program and a program about how science will change our lives in the next 10 years in 10 years of fiction and, by the way , our expert professor believes in this. kapustin fiction - this is an art form that uses only words most

often written on paper. once again, literature is what reads, and every day we read less and less, we began to read less, not only in quantity, but we try to read short texts and we super-fast texts began to appear, idiot, 11 minutes, heart of a dog 10 master and says, in general, 5 minutes is enough. to be honest, i don’t understand why these brief brevities are needed at all, so that later the cities can be said? i've read all of tolstoy. ah honestly not understand word literature soon. and fiction will disappear first. oleg konstantinovich well, i know from myself, sometimes you even know, you read a book and after the twentieth line you already fall asleep, but on the other hand. here is some kind of novel

got carried away and during the night just that's the whole book, what is called swallowed, and did anyone conduct research? what is the general effect on the human body, it turns out, reading some kind of biochemistry there, something else arises. biochemistry certainly arises. let me draw. i'm the thought that andrey leonidovich began to continue a little clip clip, culture, our our our axis of time. yes, it means that one writes a letter there is a girl of her young man. so she had him how much she had him there? he writes for a week, it goes for 2 weeks. yes, it's six eight pages. yes, yes next, what did we invent the telegraph? yes, the telegram is already one page. well, they will bring a few hours there. yes, there is a phone for two hours. phone is fast it 5 minutes

called. how much do we talk here. well, how much do we talk? yes, we say for 10-15 minutes that we could talk. i remember this from my childhood. yes, there 1 hour is good here we have a messenger, right? so, here we already have it instantly. so is the thought, here is a very short thought is one, moreover, these very ones than in every message. there is one thought, but their purity is monstrous, yes, that is, it is there. 10 in one minute, correctly, we all begin already, and now further we are still at this point, we can still be saved. i am now looking at my children, my daughter sends her boyfriend more than 10 in one minute. she sends two characters. yes, a heart and such a little thing and that's it. this is

from a letter of 6-8 pages. we've come down to two emoticons. arrived very quickly. in fact , this one, these gaps, they become shorter every time, in short, yes, here there 50 years have passed there, or 150. yes, it's already been here for 10 years, here you already understand everything in 2 years. yes, now your emoticons are here, redraw. well, look further. i can still save myself from this thinker to put in the phone. no one will get me there, but they can't save us. let's have a chip, it's time to not be the same, as if the americans are already, in fact, these experiments are being conducted. a chip, if i have it in my head, i can’t escape from it anywhere. yes, just a tinfoil hat. yes, we know how to make tinfoil hats. here it is too instantly, yes, that's all. this is already a live broadcast, as it were, that's even nothing to write. no need for my thoughts in the brain. ask my ass. here is the letter received. yes, i read it. here it came to me for 2 weeks, i went to it. then i read it for a long time, re-read it, then write

an answer for another 2 weeks and wait a month for it to arrive, because they sit back and forth. yes, i still probably think a little bit before i start talking on the phone to the messenger. i don't think at all, and here it's even hard to say what's really going on, that is, no way for me a thought act to understand. that's honestly, honestly, not required. that's why ah, not just shortening, but the path, and we stop thinking, of course. you think a lot about before you write messages to read it. well, mostly emotions. yes, that's what they're called, that's all. although and now a man has a monstrous feeling, the contradiction says, well , why did they turn me into a cyborg? i take the most. well, for i take fox joyce and read, all the phones started and so on then you feel like a man, i read at night. yes, here. how

it's scary to live andrey leonidovich well, i know, now it will become even scarier from you, don't tune in to the world hospital. yes , today i have already confessed to you my worldwide pain that they do not read, but in fact, well, my children let's recognize now. of course, they don't read much. i can force and sometimes they may like some kind of romance novel. but, in principle, of course, they like it when i read to them, but i can't read all the time. they read little and people like my children. i think a lot, that is sometimes in fine fiction. just the reader will disappear, and in general fiction will then be able to exist without readers. i certainly don't. it is his first. really. the word communication was used here, it must be. i don't know the two participants in this act. it's like in love. it's like i don't know in fishing, like in barbecue.

you understand, here, uh, hmm, the words are needed in order to be more precise , someone needs the words, the words are looking for it , it is in the order of things, because fiction, among other things, what would they say, as the ring said, it's uh, the most beautiful words in the only correct sequence here. and you see some person will wave his hand, and then suddenly stomp on some line of homer and pushkin there evgeny evgeny evgeny in order to make sure that someone felt it for him, of course, this the wave of the hand will be accompanied by some quote defined there , and where this quote will come from will be much more valuable than the wave of the hand of andrey anatolyevich well, if the barbecue disappears, i’m sure i will note. and what will happen to the world if fiction disappears, we will notice it somehow. well, if everything happens slowly and gradually or even

quickly, but gradually, then, of course, but hmm, we may not notice. so, i would like to say that a person, of course, has a need for such verbal creativity. it will always be because the language is inherent in man, inherent in man to man. but we are not we will always always be with the language there is nothing to be done to write, so there will be no reader. you are exactly like would anticipate your thought. a hmm here they will always try to write literature. but what they will write will not be necessary for anyone in this, damn it, and moreover, i can even isha, so to speak, by the way, in russian food. well, my karenina, i will think that no one will read my karenina, so i will lay there in advance, some kind of props, some mechanisms that will make it easier for the future director- producer. ah, a computer scientist and so on and so forth. yes, that is, those who will

issue before, my semi-finished product before what will be really demanded in the market or in the culture repeated not to do so, but on the contrary, to force people to read back. well, maybe it would be good to do that, but , to be honest, culture develops according to its own laws . read the pleasure radio, really, yes, it’s going on there, another life, or what? i have changed, well, how it happened the people are the same, but somehow everything is different. now, if you knew the answers to your questions, life would really be somehow more interesting. let's take a break advertising on ntv in the city park by businessmen, a this is how they remove thin vein-like objects at the base of the skull. listen,

again, the work is easier, dude, the former work in three is seriously closed . free work does not kill people money. attention, the object is borscht. the final is tomorrow at 20:00 on ntv military police premiere from monday at 20:00 on ntv i also want to relax. relax book profitable tickets hotels tours to ozon what do they allow you to do? whatever?

rosbank changes the rules of the game with a credit card 120 for everything and cancels interest on everything for one-two-three 120 for everything in rosbank everywhere without interest. withdraw cash. get cashback for every cup. buy for 120 days without interest, rosbank credit card 120 for all interest-free real

opportunities and get a cashback of up to 10 percent yandex travel booking. smirnov, i do not gossip that they allow you. yes, anything yandex.market without

overpayments chair for 1 1.500 rubles. now the rest later. makes sense, but there are cheap flights you have changed a lot at first career, and the taste of your favorite burgers no more than 200 checks in the production of cutlets to the quality has not changed over the years and the point

is that my children are among the large selection of hotels in the yandex travel application and get a cashback of up to 10%. yandex travel hotel booking. forest fires are caused by humans. stop and defeat the fire. a strong vocation, the forest firefighters of the rosleskhoz protection air force, 90 years on guard of the forests of russia on the air, a program taught by a program about how science will change our lives in the next 10 years, in 10 years , fiction will disappear. okay then. i have a simple question for our guests optimist from skeptic.

what do you think, in the next 10 years, then new pushkins , dostoevsky asimov’s novikov lanskys will appear, or the era of great writers has already left and will not return then, like, maybe to replace them, then artificial intelligence will already come. come on, i'll try to answer , look, well, artificial intelligence. first, you need to understand that this is a toolkit. he is on his own. naturally, he does not give birth to anything. and even those texts that say, i wrote this gpt, this was written by the person who asks this gpt- and he answered him, if a man he writes, as if only what was laid down in his fashion. artificial intelligence as a help to me. yes , i have a creative mind. i know what i want, but some technical work. he will do it for me. this is the first, and the second is absolute. i agree that e and literature. it will become like this e yes exclusive like that.

uh, how to say copyrighted such a product, when can i buy in a factory- made plate? yes already there. uh, so to speak , no longer in ikea well, somewhere i can yes, but my favorite cup - it's still the one that made my there er, familiar gonchar and now i just want to drink from it. yes, i will pay dearly for it. here, but i'm pleased with this. uh, the same corpus of texts is written by their disc intellect. he will take his place. it will take its place in these romance novels, because everything is according to the scheme perfectly, so it will be cheap accessible literature, by the way, you don't have to pay anyone anything, huh? there is also such a sector. here it will be mass, where it is needed, and fiction. she will stay really for that she can't help but stay a man with a new creative need. he can't take her anywhere. eh, and in this sense, probably, the need to read. it is too. in what sense is co-creation with the one who wrote it, and therefore she, too, cannot go anywhere else. if this is inherent, we

will cease to be people, but will new creators appear. that is why in the 19th century there did not know in 50-70 years. here, yes, they all just condensed from pushkin dostoevsky saltykov-shchedrin leo tolstoy here they all condensed directly in these few decades there, and then what, and then we have this gpt chat, yes , literature depends on a huge number of factors. well, for example, i don't know, after all from fashion. this is a return to the beginning of our conversation. where is the ideology? and a few figures the union of writers, conditional in its writer or 19th century, totaled, and 10,000 e people, that is, actively. e, they wrote in the 19th century, and from a distance 10,000 people published one novel or several stories or short stories, and the union of writers of the soviet union numbered 10,000 people. here, now imagine, so, then i will answer your questions. and now there are much more verses ru, there are about 2 million already,

probably, that is, there is every writers' union there. now they don't give anything at all. they just don't give anything. come in no there, there, it's really modest there. i don't know, in the end there to show the girls somewhere. i don't know, well, in the darkness of the cinema hall. here's your membership card, and the union to write or that's all, and then, i don't know, there to keep her at least this, because they run away from such uh. here. and what happened? what's happened for these here answers this question. what happened there with this bouquet of names, of which you speak, drove a language arose a new language of a new secular auto culture. who was pushkin's genius genius you understand, that's it and a by inertia. more precisely, due to such a powerful philosophical such an existential inertia of the language, these, but grandiose figures immediately appeared. and if we look, for example, at the history of culture so

retrospectively, then the history of culture had a huge number of branches that for some reason went to a dead end, while others came to us main routes. you understand what’s the matter, that is, you don’t want fiction to come in, yes, don’t grab one of your knees. well, to be honest. come on, it won't answer any questions. i feel strange about you and that's it. here , your love is surprising, because you know we are on the side of anna kalina when she threw herself under the train. we should applaud with you. it's just that we should celebrate it all, i don't know there. i don’t know everything, there, but a bottle of kefir should be celebrated. why because klikon punished evil punished, and you and i. look what tolstoy does, he will definitely discredit the korenin, his ears are collapsed. he and his age , you feel they don’t like them, and we read with you. here i am, for example, with rounded ears.

i don’t know there, a little bit even much older than karenin, i read and say, as i actually do, like any other reader that anna change him, you understand, but here e is not a wrong reading or wrong message, which her writers are not a writer. and we have a, which reads this or that book, and therefore summing up, that is, uh, of course, of course, new writers will appear. it's just impossible. you understand there will be a new cultural pattern there will be a new sex emoji. they are new civilizational models and, accordingly , this. it is also impossible for a cultural model to appear that will appear before. i do not know, because the crisis illuminates and is felt in civilized civilizational paradigms. just as in cultural paradigms , there is nowhere to go further. this gold mine of the 19th century is no longer there.

possibilities, it is worked out completely and which will be a new model. we will then show up new writers. and then we don't know at all what we'll be cleaning as a tradition. is anna karenina tolstoy? or i don't know, there bianchi there is fluffy, suppose. you understand what's the matter, that is, the tradition will change. we ourselves will rewrite this story or a new culture in fluffy. good fluffy. let's do it anyway. outcome and and here is in your opinion. what is the probability that fiction will disappear in 10 years? andrey anatolyevich do you have a forecast with a fairly high probability? well, let's say so with some reservations, firstly, of course, there will be a classic, but it is already old and old. here are some reservations for now, the old poetry will remain, but this is a question. is the poetry of literature? this is generally a separate conversation, but it will remain. so what will not remain, unfortunately, will not remain. eh, such a serious role of the book and the writer

in the socius, now this will not happen anymore and quite quickly the likelihood that it will fiction will disappear more than fifty percent 60 60%. thanks a lot. but i believe that this will tend towards zero extinction probability. e fiction, on the contrary, now in the era of transition to a new technological order , these crises arise, conflicts and literature will describe them; now such a broth of new subcultures of new artists, new e- writers is being formed. we just might not see it. we are waiting for them. it's in the books, it's going to show up in other genres. maybe in some rappers appear in music, who will write not about everyday art, but about new art about some new challenges, so it will also be artistic.

yes, it might be different. it's just that we're used to the fact that this is a book, and it will be in other formats, therefore , i think the probability tends to zero. so let's round it up to zero. thanks a lot. 10 years old, of course. well, a little too much time. yes, i would say that well, although it is accelerating very quickly. now all technological progress therefore, i said that i give 60% for this, but for the fact that there will be a paradigm shift, which leonidovich said in 30 years. i will give 95%. well, let's still 10-60%. thanks a lot. if we take a separate such small modest function of literature or fiction, about which