contact me again. nastya, hello, come in, once again, i apologize for being so late, it's okay, here's all i found, a copy of the medical record and the results of the tests.

so, a colonoscopy was prescribed, anesthesia was applied with the use of morphine, nastya, this document is just a salvation for us, really, the main thing is that it helps, i 'm sure it will, okay, i'll go , it's already late, good night, thank you very much, goodbye, bye, oops, why aren't you sleeping, i was waiting for you, lie down with me, oh, "i'll change now and lie down with you for a bit, i was scared, no, it's very strange, well, what's strange, well, i don't know, i 'm kind of angry, but that's not right, he's my dad, and i love him, oh of course, kitten, he's your dad and he loves you very much, you've just never seen him in such circumstances"? i'll tell you honestly, i

don't know how i would behave in your place, so you're my little hero, by the way, he looks better in a suit, much better, you should understand that in almost all families everything sometimes turns upside down, but this is not it means that the family stops being a family, dad loves you very much. and you and gen, this is the most important thing to understand, what are you working on now, on your conscience, i mean, i have to do what i really don't want, that well, we have this thing, like what happened to our family, i promised one... that i

wouldn't let her down, but it looks like i deceived her, well maybe there is another way out? the only way to help my clients is to tell the whole truth, but if i tell the whole truth, two families will suffer, mom, i don't understand, you you are a lawyer, you must represent the interests of your clients, dad says, you either do your job. or stop doing it, so yes, that's right, you are great, you will make a good lawyer, yeah, the devil's advocate, go to bed, who are your witnesses, the head of the hr department, natalya nikolaevna marincheva.

witness natalya nikolaevna marincheva is called to testify. witness marinecheva, come in. natalya nikolaevna, what do you know about the wrecked truck? it was faulty. i protest, your honor. the technical department and the hr department are different services. the witness cannot have sufficient grounds to make such statements. accepted, natalya nikolaevna, what was your relationship with mr. ivanitsky and under what circumstances did you become aware of this information? i hope 5 million will suit you, well

, everyone, well, of course, who do you take me for, kalinin? i would have done it right away, well, yes, and the widows also need to make official apologies, gentlemen, well, you are not being impudent, you should dial ostavyev, by the way, where did your charming assistant go, she ran away, imagine, no one wants to work, with you, this is the school of life, kalinin, well, okay, you will have these written changes, i will come to an agreement with staffev, next time we will see each other when you are already replenishing, oh, well, sooner this ball is really interfering with life, it was nice to meet you, alice, all the best, yeah,

yeah, anya, nastya, victory for... hurray, i congratulate you, i did not doubt you for a minute, thank you very much, this is a very flattering opinion, of course i understand that nothing can compensate for your losses, but nevertheless the amount has now become significantly higher an official apology will follow soon, thank you, thank you, i'm very glad, alice, i'm sorry to bother you, can you have a minute, yes, i'm sorry, please, i don't know about you, but without an assistant it's a disaster, right? if you don't like our new candidate, i'll hire some pretty freshman, and i'll do it on my own. oh, i think i'll like her,

so she came after all, of course, i promised, you please forgive me, i couldn't come to your birthday party. i had a lot to do, but the kids said that everything was fine it went well, look what's here, what's here, my darling thank you, yes, everything's great, it went great, mom said that you 're doing some difficult work, yes, i just finished it, yeah. success, yes, congratulations, thank you, as new colleagues, it's not pressing, it's shining, no, we almost never cross paths, i see, that means mostly with kolenin, well of course, he's your

former classmate, he was hitting on you back then, sing, what are you getting at, i want to ask, he's... not such a cool guy as he seems, be careful, thank you, i i'll try, what does it mean, i don't want to sing, listen to gossip about kalinin, but i want to draw my own conclusions, i've lived with my eyes closed for too long, i've had a lot of time here, i thought. "i realized that i 've never loved anyone as much as you, sing, alice, i beg you, give me another chance, give our family a chance.

than lie down, this is sprinkling, lay down on the ground , what are you standing there for, i'm tired of living, lay down, lay down, mortai floor, guy, drop the gun, drop the gun, police, drop it, come on, where did you get this recording? i had to work hard to find it, nastya. anzur

sharipov received a life sentence for the murder of a police officer 5 years ago, attention, this reconstruction was shown on tv for some reason. and do you think that it could have influenced the jury? it influenced the jury. firstly. he is shown at the very moment of the murder, then a close-up of the killer's face, such things have a stronger effect than words. i agree with alisa. okay, the family is demanding a review of the case, they believe that the sentence is unfair and want to achieve a reduction in the sentence. we need to rewrite the cassation appeal and transfer this there fact. i think that it is necessary to consult with vitaly, because he has to appear in court. why consult with vitaly? there is little time, we need to rewrite the complaint and send it before 5 o'clock, then it will be too late. the presidium of the regional court will only meet in a month. i think that we still need to consult with vitaly. don't worry, colleague, we will not tell anyone that you missed this fact. i'd rather wait for you here. we think that with the new information we have enough arguments to rewrite the cassation appeal. what do we have?

the reconstruction of the events was shown a week before the trial on a very popular tv show, by which time the case had already received a very wide public response. did this influence the jury's opinion? yes, it is we who need to act quickly. what do you mean? it is now 16:10, we have 50 minutes. then do not waste time , act. okay, i hope you type fast. so. any facts are needed, lists of regions, replays, reviews from the internet, anything, anything will help, i told you it was a stupid idea, half an hour left, we had to decide ourselves, but now we will not have time, nastya, go, please help my wife, can you, yes, hello, hello, there is no data on viewing rating, well, more precisely, we cannot get them now, it’s just that 5 years have passed, you came to tell me that you didn’t find anything, no, well, write down everything you find,

we’ll tell the rest at the trial, if we even get through with the complaint, what is he, anzur sharipov, yeah, 5 years ago he killed a policeman in a mini-market, he is serving a life sentence, it recently turned out that during the show they showed a detailed story about this crime, the family wants to appeal, they think that the trial was dishonest, no, well that's obvious. i am a lawyer for the company shvets granovo kalnin partners, yes, i understand, i just wanted to clarify, you received a letter from us, well

, a cassation complaint, anzur sharipov, no, that can't be, please check again, yes, yes, i'm right here at the computer, everything is gone, thank you very much, thank you, i yes, good afternoon, that's it, what would you do without me, mr. kalinin, we have familiarized ourselves with your cassation complaint and are ready for oral explanations, so, what are you not satisfied with the verdict, your honor, 5 years ago anzur sharipov was convicted of killing a police officer during...

i apologize, maybe i'm butting in where it's none of my business, but i don't think this is the place for a child. excuse me, we just really wanted to see our dad. excuse me, who are you? i'm anzur's wife, adliya, this is your daughter. delcha. i'm alisa filippova, a lawyer. nice to meet you. tell me, why wasn't anzur in court? well, this is a cassation hearing, and usually convicted people aren't invited to them, okay, we just really wanted to see him. so you're his new lawyer? well, not exactly, in general it will depend on the court's decision, how much the court will support our complaint, and why didn't you say even once that anzur is not guilty? our complaints concern procedural violations, this is not connected with the fact of guilt. listen, the fact that anzur was with

me that night, isn't that proof? otliya? now it's not them, then none of you believe me, and he was with me that night, take it, this is gulcha, she is three here, and this was the last time she saw her father, it is unlikely she will see him again. let's get out of here, they accepted the cassation complaint, great, it will be great when the client gets a shorter sentence, nastya will deal with it, and

then what do we do, and we are heading back to the office, there are a lot of things to do. his wife did not testify, she was his alibi, but she did not testify in court, and you know why, because wives lie to save their husbands, she has a criminal record, i also read alice's report, listen, it seems to me that you are biased about this, and she had a criminal record in her youth, well then it does not count, in our case 12 jurors thoughtfully made a decision.

divorce proceedings, a major client, a promising business, promising and profitable, here is father sharipov succeeded, excuse me, please, and i am about sharipov, can i take this business, and you too, where, they conspired, i don’t think, it looks like maximalism, youth, oh well, do what you want, anzur sharipov is yours. why are you looking at me like that, i don’t understand, everything is fine, forgive me, but in my opinion, there is no benefit for you here, i could be offended, yes, but you won’t be offended, because you deeply, i apologize, anyway, you shouldn’t talk like that, okay, there are things that, for example.

it looks like we've been scammed, here i've collected everything i have on the sharif case. sergey, well, you were his lawyer, maybe there's something that 's missing from this pub? listen, i have nothing to add, alisa dnitrina, or just alisa. sergey, please help us. alisa, you'd better ask your husband. he organized a special group: the best employees, the senior one there was viktor pobedonostsev. okay, tell me, why wasn't anzor's wife questioned as a witness?

because she had a criminal record, and it was clear that she's lying, anyway, the testimony won't do anything to her ... well, do you already regret not taking the divorce case? i don't know yet, but somehow there's little chance with sharipov, yes,

it's all strange, it feels like everything is against him, like in a textbook. hello, you called me from the bar, right? yes, hello, you're ekaterina, my name is alisa, this is my colleague evgeny. hello, we apologize that...

zini was in court, this is him, excuse me, my break is over, i have to go, i have an operation, goodbye, goodbye, and you're great, this is i see, and specifically, we need a specialist consultation, let's go, well, who wants to try? this one there will still be versions, let it be him, yes, it is him, this is how

the procedure for identifying criminals usually goes, this is a standard scheme, but the thing is that there are no criminals in these photos, after such a disgrace you have to leave the profession, well , don't worry, it's normal, you are familiar with the problem of interracial identification? all chinese people seem the same to us, don't you, i assure you that they have the same with us the problem is, they can't tell us apart, and all over the world it's hard for people of one genotype to tell people apart, oh my god, captain obvious, you want to try, i'd be happy to, great, according to your racial type, you'll probably have problems with the buryats, let's talk shit.

please, oh, well, the same trick won't work a second time, yeah, that's why there's a criminal here and... here he is, yeah, there really is a criminal here, you're all right with your logic, here's the interracial identification, no, here he is, i have a feeling that we know each other. no, well , maybe, so many people pass through here, you can't imagine, i'll definitely remember now, and you were working on the sharipov case, so

under what circumstances did you take him on, well , something like that right off the bat, about five years ago, yes, yes, and there were no cameras in that store, remember, they made a photofit from the words of that nervous nurse. the seller was taken to the hospital with a heart attack, and she was the only one involved in the case as a witness? yes, yes, yes, yes, that happened, now i remember, she then she wrote to us in great detail: height, age, complexes, all that stuff, you know what, write your email here, we 'll send you a composite sketch, so it turns out that you detained him only on the basis that his build suited him, no, why not? at the very least, he was wearing the same sweatshirt he had in the store. he couldn't even throw it away. yeah, imagine, he was just walking around the city like that, the moron. the whole thing is, they

came in droves, they came in droves, i don't know what to do with it, i don't know, okay, thank you, you're welcome, but will they ever give us that door they'll break it, wait, here... "sorry, you didn't want to do this, i changed my mind, look, in kazan the nurses made a composite sketch , they detained our guy, but the identification was done by photographs, do you see what an onza"?

smart, yes, but you can press this in court, yes, but it would be better if you talk to your husband about this, what's wrong, he was in charge of this case and might know something about the apers, what 's wrong with them, why they identified by photographs, for the safety of witnesses, it's clearly some kind of scam, your husband might know what kind. the photographs are good, but direct there is still no evidence, the nurse later identified him in person, more serious arguments are needed to overturn the sentence, there is something to do then, work, search, think, camilla will help you.

camilla, hello, hello, didn't we cross over to nat with you, we drank naborderschaft with you, well now everything is different. she will help you, hello,

sit down. what do i owe you? your wife does not want to involve you in the case. anzur sharipov, review of the sentence. she is defending the policeman's killer, but he is guilty. alisa doubts, and so do i. doubts, well, if he doesn't want to come to me, let him go to pobedonossov, he was the head of the investigation team, if i change, he 's not thrilled about the supervision either, yes, it could hurt him, i really need to know, is there something wrong with the evidence collection, camilla,

they monitor communication so closely here, but there is an exception. dirty dates, but you can't do that in a pre-trial detention center, yes, such dates are only for family members, well, since the local boss owes me something, i can help you with this case, but i can't help you personally, camilla, yes, i'm sorry i fired you, you're a good specialist. "i know, believe me, there were all sorts, problems with housing, nothing to eat at all, i

worked three jobs, but i never stole anything from anyone, ask my friends, even if i borrowed money, i always paid it back, i didn't kill, i didn't kill anyone"? calm down, i wasn't even in that store, we live on the other side of town, tell me better, and about this sweatshirt, tell me, did they make you take a picture in it, i'll take it off altogether i wanted, it was very hot in the office, that policeman told me to stay in it, which one was drazdov or zharkov, i don't remember, one of them, okay, and how did the blood stains come about? on the sweatshirt, my daughter and i were playing, she slammed the door in my face, or rather on my nose, i wiped it off like that, but there were almost no blood stains left, for i washed everything off, yes, i didn't

disappear, really, there's just a lot of work now, come on, choose. that's all for the day, i'll go with you wherever you want, yeah, come on, come on, yeah, we need to talk, the meeting is in 5 minutes, remember, i was talking about visiting your husband, yes, you know, i can't talk about anything now, especially about my husband, peter knows something and can tell you, but at the preliminary meeting, wait, how do you know, have we seen each other? have you seen each other? yes, were you in the pre-trial detention center with my husband? could you at least consult with me? listen, while you wait, i told you, i had to solve

the problems myself, don't dare go to my husband, then you go, if you want to help anzur, go talk to him. well, let's begin, you gathered us, mr. kalinin with purpose, what is your purpose? we will direct the exclusion of anzur sharipov's identification materials from the case. the reason is that the investigation is biased, your honor, i protest , your honor, unfounded. the protest is rejected, we are here to sort it out, since we have been assembled in such a large composition. who is your witness? detective fyodor drozdov, your honor. witness fyodor drozdov is invited into the courtroom. zhenya has been preparing. just like

you, come on. hello, good afternoon, good afternoon, the fact is that the accusation was built only on the fact that the defendant caught in a zenit sweatshirt, i protest your honor, the protest is rejected, the accusation, you will let me hear what you are getting at, he was photographed in this sweatshirt, fyodor mikhailovich, this is that sweatshirt. exactly, yeah, but doesn't it seem inappropriate to you to present for identification only one person in a zenit sweatshirt? i already said, he came in this sweatshirt, he was photographed in it, and what do you order me

to dress them all the same, well, it seems to me that yes, for the purity of the experiment it was necessary to do exactly that. tell me, were there blood stains on the sweatshirt? stains, yes, they tried unsuccessfully. and where were the stains? here on the back of the forearm. the defendant once explained where they came from. he said that he was injured while playing. as a child, playing with a child, well, yes, was it the victim's blood? and we don't know, the lab couldn't do a dna test, the blood was almost washed off, almost washed off, that is, the forensic scientists, who are capable of performing miracles based on a single molecule , failed, well, it happens, well, it happens, but imagine, well, suddenly, if god forbid, you... if your nose started bleeding now, what

would you do, how would you wipe it off? i, i would wipe it off with a handkerchief. but imagine that you don't have a handkerchief with you now, what would you do? i object, your honor. and what does that have to do with the case? the objection is accepted. lawyer, what are you getting at? is it true that you? people, since zenit is the pride of our

city, it is the pride of our country, i want to remind you that in may of 2012 zenit became the champion of russia, so its symbols were everywhere, so tell me, are you sure that you arrested that person, is that impressive? ms. filippova, is that all? yes, thank you. your honor, as you can see, there are enough arguments to exclude the material knowledge from the case. there may be enough arguments to show the stupidity of the apologists who work, it is not clear how. but their stupidity does not mean that the evidence is inadmissible,

denied, thank you, thank you. that's why you did not let your wife speak, he was preparing, there was no opportunity, no, listen, we agreed with you, we wait 3 months, then we decide, who is better, and you are always patronizing and pushing your filippova, agree, it is an unequal fight, and you are trying to slip your protzh a more profitable divorce to burkov, why such an honor alisa. scares the acorn of light, he is afraid that

she knows more than us put together, after all, her husband, his former boss, you never know what he shared with his wife, i like that he loses his presence of mind next to her, yes, maybe he has his own goal, and what is it, to take revenge on the victory for her husband, here i am a woman, i understand her perfectly, i am sure. yes, it is he, and you look again carefully, this man robbed you 5 years ago, well, he seems similar, well, i don’t know, they all look the same, he was screaming like crazy, everyone with their faces to the floor, with their faces to the floor, who is everyone, i’m alone here in the store, okay, thank you, please. in my opinion, this hero

doesn’t look like our vanzura at all, we need to find someone who does, there were three more reports of armed robbery in the summer of last year. oh, and i also need to know, do you have anyone, don’t even try, we have too little in common, well, opposites attract? listen, i have a suggestion, come on, come on. you'll find proof that it wasn't sharipov, then i promise to have coffee with you and tell you everything you want? "i'm already on my way, then look, it was him , yes, it seems similar, well, it's hard to say, i saw him briefly, he immediately put us all on the floor, yes, but maybe you remember something

special, i don't know, but something that caught your attention, no, it seems like nothing special, but he came in, took out a gun, started yelling at everyone. with his face on the floor, i didn't argue, i did as he said, but he took all the money from the cash register and left, you said face down on the floor, yeah, that's it, that's not enough for you, he had to do something else, no, sorry, of course not, and the robbery itself, it turns out, was in august, well yes, they found him, they even paid me the money, i understand, thank you very much, you helped us a lot, thank you, well, if you discredit the testimony of the operatives, then everything will fall apart for them. i understand, but how can you do that? fel drozdov has repeatedly fallen into the hands of

the internal security service for abuse of power. and in 2014. he forgot the main case, the gun was planted as a bike to the accused, and that turned away, the accused died unexpectedly in the cell from heart failure, the case is closed, and the winner sanctioned this whole thing, i was not in the city then, i only found out later, even so, i talked, on the detection rate, to put it mildly, his methods are not very traditional, i'll leave you deliciously, how i missed all this, this is a kitten with grandma, baked, yes, the atmosphere here, wow,

i never thought that such a person could drive by with me, forgive us, everything is fine, pet', everything is fine, it turns out that this guy continued to rob, he committed the last three armed robberies when anzur was already in prison, yes, in all cases he shouted the same phrase, face floor, well, since the seller said that the robber was caught? we need to find out who he is, what he is and where he is, and drink coffee, it's too late for coffee, see you tomorrow, hey,

what are you doing, what are you doing, it's cold there, nothing, i 'll take another pillow from you, well stop it immediately, what are you doing? remember a year before genka was born we went to him we went, you were then pinched by the bush, i remember, by the way, you set him on me, i didn't poison him, i pushed you into the pond, and the guest

is a free bird, sing, well, stop it, please, well, you 'll freeze, you'll get sick, come here, you've got a grip, well, you remember, she was all wet then, yeah. didn't lose, and you carried me home in your arms, yeah, in your arms, can't stop home, home, you forgot, forgot, but it's not right on your arms, to the barn,

okay, petya, it's late, let's go to bed. what did you manage to find out? drosdovova has already been accused of abuse of power, but the case hasn't reached trial got it. it might work, but we found

the real robber. please, ruze radzhabov, in the summer of that year he committed three more armed robberies, and during the last one he was caught red-handed, got 4 years. great, where is he now? a year ago, he died in a prison fight. oh, my, wait, we can try something else. ekaterina, good afternoon, thank you very much for coming, hello, but i just have very little time, yes, yes, yes, we understand, do i understand correctly that this is the photofit that was made according to your description, i would like it never to see again, you know, it looks like we found the real killer, look, it's ruzi radzhabov, no, no, it's not him, sharipov was in that store. here he is, yes, yes, it's him, of course, it's him, it's sharipov, excuse me,

but this is an eyewitness, ekaterina, i'm very ashamed to admit this, but the thing is that we swapped the faces in the photographs, this is anzur sharipov, and this is ruzi radzhabov, is this , is this a joke now, no. it's hard to admit, but i have to do it, it's your duty as a witness, forgive me. i am convinced that the person, who killed that

policeman in front of my eyes, it is, it is not anzor sharipov, similar, but not him, excuse me, your honor, and can i... turn to kanzur, if you please, anzor, i, i beg you to forgive me, i am very, very guilty before you, your family. i ruined 5 years of your life, i

don’t know what else to say in such cases, forgive me, please, forgive me! "forgive me, and this is another blatant case of the unfair corruption policy of the previous prosecutor filippov, when a weak person should be punished only because he is weak, by nationality, and by his position in society, simply because he is not rich, and he himself was on his team, forgive me, i did not think. simply because someone has to serve time for a crime, even if he is not guilty, justice prevailed after years, 5 years, the family

was separated, just imagine! sharipov could have never left prison because of the mistake of filippov and his team. i do not want to listen to this anymore. well, that's right, such tactics fall on the predecessor. forget it. i already forgot. you're great. you too. alisa, can i have a minute with you, i'll go, bye, thank you, anzur will be released now, i'm happy,

i'm very happy for you, i recognized you right away, back then. "i know that your husband is also innocent, i feel it, you have to believe in his innocence, believe and fight, anzur and i had no chance at all, i couldn't even help him, only because i was the only witness, and i loved and love him very much, yana didn't even think about retreating, he was innocent, you can't put up with injustice.

camilla, i wanted to talk to you, go ahead, today everyone wants something from me, why did my husband fire you, you need to ask your employer about such things, i didn't ask to be fired, but still i know peter well and i understand that he wouldn't let a good employee go. it sounds like a compliment, that's a fact, well, it's a long story, you had an affair with him, listen, sometimes it happens, people just can't work together, that's how it was with your husband.

hello, yes, kitten, hi, i'll be there soon, yes, kiss you, bye.