later adapted it will play the performance always attracts a full house each time the actors receive a standing ovation. but it should hardly comes a surprise nearly every russian family had to endure the horrors of stalin's repressions.

pilot error and the psychological pressure of the primary causes of the plane crash that killed the polish president and most of the country's political elite as their crash investigators deliver a final verdict poland's prime minister has cut short his holiday to examine the report with an official statement expected on thursday. as the world's most notorious prison guantanamo bay enters its tenth year protests are held in the u.s.

calling on president obama to finally deliver on his promise to shut down rights campaigners claim the detention center is there to hold people indefinitely without trial more than one hundred seventy detainees remain at guantanamo. despite spending millions to fight tuberculosis abroad the number of cases in the u.k. reaches a worrying levels with fears there's no cash to treat home doctors attribute the spike to poor living conditions and of the number of immigrants coming to the country tuberculosis causes three million deaths a year worldwide. next peter lavelle it is across all guests discuss reconstruction efforts and eighty one year on thirty minutes of heated topical debate is on the air.

and you can. follow me and welcome to cross talk i'm peter lavelle one year after the catastrophic earthquake in haiti remains in ruin and prospects look bleak what has gone so wrong for this impoverished country who's to blame the west and its n.g.o.s the u.n. for the haitians themselves. can. you discuss the situation in haiti one year on i'm joined by easily done talking in new york she is the founder and president of the haitian lawyers leadership network also in new york we have nicholas at all saying he is an award winning independent filmmaker and in washington we go to stanley lucas he is the executive director for

the washington democracy project and another member of our crosstalk team on the hunger all right folks cross talk rules in effect that means you can jump anytime you want to go to you first then we have a few days ago oxfam came out with a report and it painted a very bleak picture here in the me quote two sentences from it as haitians prepare for the first anniversary of the earthquake close to one pill a million people are reportedly still displaced it goes on to say less than five percent of the rubble has been cleared only fifteen percent of the temporary housing that is needed has been built and relatively few permanent water and sanitation facilities have been constructed what is gone wrong one year later i mean there was a lot of money dedicated to. rescuing haiti from this tragedy not all the money has been sent not all the donors are sons of money you have a lot of blue helmets there you have a lot of security and you have an army of n.g.o.s and they just all getting in the way with each other i mean what is the world going wrong. thank you for

having me. if. you're quick two hundred thousand. we lost thirty billion dollars. the international community responded quite quickly we got one point four billion dollars of private donation from the world two point nine billion dollars for the united states and four hundred million dollars from the international community the . american family how is this helping people because i seen the pictures it doesn't look like a good picture going our one iran i mean it's easily if i you easily if i go to you what is gone wrong here i mean like all the ingredients for success should be there is really going on i want to go to you i mean all the ingredients should be there haiti needs not charity but justice and until has the haiti has justice there is

not going to be any structural change the needs of the and as you said as you mentioned with the oxfam report ten billion dollars was a was pledged on march tenth after the earthquake and only ten percent of that has been delivered in only by some of the small countries even part of the united united states all of the big big big countries have really not donate any of the billions of dollars they have said they would give to haiti interest for reconstruction there's no reconstructions as a mare fact there is barely any sorts of clean water as we know there's a cholera outbreak if there was clean water people would not have cholera outbreak what the fundamental problem is in that what your audience needs to understand is that when people say they're donating money to haiti it's what they're doing is taking money from their right hand and putting it into their left hand and nothing goes to haiti essentially but a trickle down but. the strategy is not one. working because we are building up

n.g.o.s in stead of building up haitian a situation you have twenty eight and you got one point four billion dollars the i am blaming thing a patchwork of programs in those programs are not answering to the needs of patients like a needs eastern soup or to haitian sensitive haitian institution the private sector of eighty civil society and the haitian government and it's not happening right now we are trying to nick names why isn't it how and why is that happening ok is this a haitian phenomenon right here it's because there are haitians or is it the international the structure of international aid i was being implemented and are this is just an ngo. money machine i mean there's so and so many n.g.o.s and they were there before the earthquake the most good morning goes where there's another or maybe i want to go to you nic nic first go ahead. well i think one part of it is

that unfortunately and it's been the case also before the earthquake but we always tended to empower the enjoys much more than the haitian authorities you know always pretexting that you know the haitian authorities are corrupt it's always the same game with the n.g.o.s meanwhile n.g.o.s are there for long term survival there are also now we call of a non for profit but n.g.o.s are there for there are there are there are actually industries there are competing with each other the other day there was an article saying how you know it's the war of logos and stickers that's one problem with the other problem also is the leadership but when you hear somebody like clinton who is the most one of the most popular voices out there very powerful you know individual saying that actually you know we need to know more what you're doing it clearly shows that the the real problem of leadership in haiti and also the problem of involving haitians the more you know believe the other day said that he wished he wished actually internationalization were working more with the the haitian authorities so there's

a lot of arrogance but that this is been going on for more than twenty years the way. so this is. an international. right stanley go ahead jump in. this structure put in place by do international community community do. mission control in reaching the haitian government have no control haitian private sector even ourself into just four we have been pulled aside if you look at this speech two weeks ago of the haitian members of the reconstruction commission they are very frustrated because contract. given to people without their knowledge and the haitians are completely put aside all of the we're construction process and we need a haitian with a new treaty and we part of the process as you know when you talk about international aid you cannot replace the client and to international community we are trying to play station we are very grateful for the money do they have given to us but we don't have control over. easily i mean i don't know how anything would

happen so quickly in the program so we already got to the blame game ok everybody seems to be blaming everybody else well how do we break out of this well for me to leave and i'm going to go in first please go ahead sorry how do we break out of it we have and since today is your broadcasting this because it's the first year anniversary. i want to first say that we lost so much we haitians lost so much three hundred thousand people dead in thirty three seconds and so there has to be a time where this is about flesh and blood this is not about cost effectiveness it's not about n.-g. o. profits it's not about us export led economy i mean the real problem the basic problem is that we have a world system where it's we're in haiti as it's applied it's dead dependency domination and this does sort of unfair us policy or even today when we have all of

this devastation in haiti with. this. applicable lipstick just unfathomable injury and i've been doing remember and says all we can and i can tell you the grief the trauma to haitians i mean none of that is being translated everyone wants to talk about why are there over a million people on the streets in haiti at the moment well you know there was help in haiti supposedly before two thousand before the january twelfth the problem the real problem is that we have a system where the united states in the international financial institutions have decided what is development for haiti and they're using right now what we call this interim haiti we construction commission to bring forth policies they hadn't been able to do for a long time right now this interim reconstruction commission has basically taken

over recovery this haiti interim recovery commission has taken over it's it's it's forget about these elections we're talking about president clinton has so much titles in haiti right now do you can even tell what what he's about because he has . for five different titles he's part of this commission where supposedly the united states it's in the united states and the blame he has has to go to the international community because they're the ones that got rid of haiti's. democratically elected government we can the government and then put on haiti this sort of export led economy this economy where they say you know haiti has a population of eighty percent seventy percent peasants in the united states says you know what we're going to do is move the peasants into assembly plants and give you this sort of export. interest interest. when the interest of the

consumers abroad is more important than the domestic national production in food sovereignty of haitians this is what you get you get salmon you get earthquakes where people are dying because there are too many of them came into the cities looking for jobs that united states had pushed them off of when you have policies where these americans come in and destroy the livestock of the of well the haitian as you know. all of this when you have when you have all of this happening then you have to look at does haiti need charity or just you know. the saying is if you see what this is a different way and they. talk quite a bit about outside interference i mean there is a long history of american interference in haitian affairs going over sixty years now i mean is it is it because these are the structural problems here is that. governments and government governance is just simply ineffective because there is so much outside interference well. if you look i

mean since the beginning since he became independent everything we've talked about the major powers here that are involved france and the us i mean there's just been despicable since actually haiti became independent from the the. ration that he had to pay to france which is now in our money to twenty three billion dollars to the first occupation in the one nine hundred twenty s. to the embargo the many embargoes the different. we've actually meddled in and we've been supporting these two leaders could it our. it is clear evidence of interference here so yeah it's not helping you know he has not held haiti to develop a normal you know when its own pace. always does meddling and meddling and meddling and and this is this is been going on now for a while or i'm going to jump in here i'm going to let you finish out your break after a short break we'll continue our discussion on haiti stableyard. and

. feel. the it is easy to you. if you shoot easy.

to keep. such. hungry for the full stop and we've got it first hand the biggest issues get a human voice face to face with the news makers on the t.v. . which brightened. about someone from the funniest impression inside. the start atif dot com.

if. you want to. welcome back to france sometime beautiful to remind you we're talking about haiti one year after the earthquake.

but before let's see what russians think about helping this country on the first anniversary of the earthquake that struck haiti people pray and call to offer more help one year ago haiti earthquake claimed the lives of over two hundred thousand people and left more than one point three million homeless menace to living in tents it is a year ago the letter sent to ask russians if they would donate to help haitians forty five percent of the respondents said they would and that the forty three percent would not there was no unanimous this since the aid delivered to haiti by the entire world is now called aid industry and public fears it would not reach the recipients back to peter. ok stanley one of the one of the greatest criticisms

of the whole aid effort towards haiti after the horrific or earthquake but in the way the west deals with aid in general and it's called a culture of dependency in haiti seems to be the quintessential example of creating a culture of dependence ok and how do you break out of that because i think usually brings up a very good point you know i think maybe the haitians deserve respect not charity. i agree with you. of it we five dollars by the international community we control only two cents we don't need more aid we need better aid but we need to fix our own hours. we have witnessed the failure of governance in haiti as you know the past three or four president to do value left we six hundred million dollars of our money we could not get it back president aristide saw stalled two hundred fifty million dollars we didn't get it back i think we need better governance and also we

need the import of the haitian just for our eyes you know are going to the world bank it is two percent of competent haitians are overseas. we are four million people living in twenty countries so you need the input of the human resources haitian human resources that are overseas to strengthen the capacity of the state if we can address that the country can move better forward ok what do you think about that i mean just blame it on the corruption of past presidents do you agree with that yes. no i do. your are your your audience should know that i was a representative as a lawyer for president chavez. and mr lucas has. cannot prove what he's saying he's just saying it president aristide was the first democratically elected president of haiti and the reason why he was deported to south africa by the international community bush jr administration was because he

was trying to include the masses into the politics of haiti trying to not deal with the monopolies what we have in haiti is five point five percent. of the population the haiti league arche that own ninety percent of the wealth and that in that act as a overseer for the for the imperialist imperialists so you have these these small families this small tiny group of haitians the light skinned haitians mostly from arab or syrian background who were folks that haiti gave asylum to who are now the ones who are sort of the overseers the ones who are now working if any kind of activity going to try to now you could be sure that contract was giving not to haitian small tiny businesses but these are these families who have very very

strong. connections to the clintons to the bush who really run u.s. policy and so you have a situation where a lot of people focus on who's at the top whether it's eric steed or preval or do you say but we really need to also look at who is the economic force in haiti and what are they doing and how they are can i gree the. america all right sam we're going to jump and then we're going to go ahead stanley go ahead ok i agree with doug that we need more market economy and bridou monopolies but also we need the support of the international community. to fight corruption as an example of that our high administration of court have established our ward procedure in brazil to aristide's our money in the case of. where are we have to move. bunch of

money do you as the help we can period that money for example if you we can set an example we board president and president aristide is on the docket all fishel documents of the are going to be showing that. is the right. nine hundred million dollars of that going to be if we can get that money back. you will know that begin to do that anymore if i can go to you i mean it is go ahead easily go ahead real quick go ahead i was going to say we've already established that there's a difference between who is a dictator who is not a dictator and i've said that with regards to do the president aristide but i just want to make the point with respect to something that mr ducasse just said about corruption the difficulty here is that the corruption in haiti comes from the very very top it comes from the fact that united states would unseat a democratically elected government it comes from the fact right now what we're dealing with which is

a fraudulent election that the united states would bring in the always and caricom in all of these international institution to try to solidify. an election that was clearly this how easily did it is. because you bring up a community bring up a very good mix please i don't want to i want to remember you're on the program here i mean is really brings up a very interesting point here is that because of the lack of perception of legitimacy of the political system in haiti because of the outside manipulation and interference what i'm getting at to try to go along circle here that's what's really one of the biggest problems in reconstruction is because you don't have institutions that have a whole lot of legitimacy in the eyes of the people well. it's a vicious circle exactly as the problem is like in washington you had you have a right wing lobby that has been for the last fifty years trying to play the divide game whether it's in haiti. or believe believe any time they didn't like

somebody has been elected they always came played a divide game use people sorry for mr lucas use people like look at us actually to destabilize any government had been a like that of course aristide was not perfect but he knows that b. he was elected by the majority of people he's party still being prevented from running and so yeah you have a situation right now we're going to still have aid not going actually flowing in you know most of this which was pledged as not being disbursed yet and i think the reason of that is like most leaders in the world and most institutions know perfectly well or actually are scared now that any future you know president will be that there is going to be some efforts from countries like the us or france to destabilize them and it's going to be another could it is going to be other people like like lucas and others who are going to try to do everything to destabilize them it's a problem in haiti it's a problem in other countries and then the problem is only one of them i know is i'm sure. it's not slowing in now and i know i know but everybody everybody knows you

know you work for the. full five years before i was sure i would respond spirit you to that this is all over the news yes no no it's not really it's we describe it as going to make and i'm not a. government that's a fact ok if you are if you know how you grew up in that's not a dictator it's important that the public knows how you were involved in playing the devide game and how you were involved in use by well you know white supremacist if you are if you are not aligned you see too many similar to one government why do you do or do you think that how do we have ok finally i'm understanding reply here stanley going to listen listen. to your. if you honest eyes was on it was a result of you through which you are known as a deep and very deep tissue one thing that you will see you will see that year was not the country for the interest of the people that was addicted to sheep you store

six hundred million dollars of the country that was a comma government did you value dictatorship if you are not ised a democratically elected president when he came to power he was a poor priest nine years later or in two hundred fifty million dollars of the people's money and he was killing political opponents killing journalists killing civil society leaders we demand story many elections so that's why i think if we want to move forward the are two things that need to be don't we need to end free and see and change the political culture of the country make sure that you have democrats in power respects who will offer on the constitution and ensuring the international community is regretfully and whom easily and i do well knew that mechanical sadly as country easily should i have stanley there's reason to ask of those who actually help take ok this is coming from

a man talking about democracy mr lucas has absolutely no legitimacy to talk about democracy and need this man to help. takedown and i don't have to say it you can just go to the new york times and read makes six signals where where where where where they talk about what mr lucas is and what what not just forget about mr lucas ok mr lucas is just an employee just like all of the others that are that are employees of usa idea or international republican institute these are folks haitians that are used to be the face of imperialism in haiti and mr lucas was was part of that back in two thousand and four i want to focus here. on trees have room but eyes and ideological problem because he has problem not ideological going to solve them is a failure you should tell him as you should you know the answer the world you have show you need.