tv [untitled] December 28, 2011 11:30am-12:00pm EST
11:30 am
here. hardly any birds squirrels you know. dirk's you are know what's going on here. on green monarchy. is our ticker when you live from moscow it's eight thirty pm moscow time my name's kevin owen and these are our top stories today one of the late north korean leaders funeral ends but hopes of change and his successor overshadowed by concerns that foreign nations might actually want to keep the status quo. a russian court decides against banning a translation of a harley krishna holy text which was suspected of being extremist. post mubarak egypt seeks to shape its international ties them in turmoil and uncertainty at home well it's out of leaders trial finally resumes. this is r.t.
11:31 am
the arab spring iran's nuclear program and the ongoing middle east turmoil are just three things that put the world in a spin during twenty eleven and indeed got tempers flaring at the un's most powerful body next than we hear how reacting to these major events is going to pan out in two thousand and twelve with a man at the heart of it all russia's ambassador to the u.n. vitaly churkin he joins us now live your best to churkin thank you for taking the time to be with us my first of all start by my pleasure about libya the u.n. security council rejected russia's proposal to investigate civilian deaths from nato strikes in libya what a members avoiding in order to simply case the ongoing conflicts and i'm more important. well you know first of all it was not rejected the fact of the matter is that a number of security council delegations including the russian delegation raise the need to have some clarity about civilian casualties as
11:32 am
a result of nato bombings because for months we're heard from made from nato that they are adopting all those measures in order to make sure that there can not possibly be any civilian casualties and then we had on december eighteenth of this a disturbing investigation published by the new york times which it showed that there were dozens at least civilian casualties so it makes sense to us and seems to be a pretty obvious thing to have this matter investigated in an impartial. and it's a political but also humanitarian case if there are people who became victims of those strikes maybe injured people or their relatives were killed then they should be given some assistance without waiting for a prolonged period of other ongoing investigations like the investigation by the human rights council or i.c.c. international criminal court which should deal with a whole range of possible. crimes transgressions which took place in libya in
11:33 am
the course of the military campaign so it's something which will continue to pursue and in fact i would think that of the matter can be clarified within weeks and not months which would otherwise be the case it was simply a lie in those other investigations and we don't see anything. in this after all nato is a partner of the united nations after all nato has been acting on the basis of a security council mandate so the security council we believe should play an active role also in having this matter clarified but also i think if you put too much emphasis on this issue you will forget that the security council is working quite harmoniously on a range of issues. of pertaining to the conflict situation in libya the u.n. mission is there supported by the security council the security council is working under the resolution which was adopted by at russia's initiative on
11:34 am
a looking into the dangers which are there in terms of spreading weapons out of libya which were left of them that in the course of of the conflict we are helping the libyans to rebuild their political and economic structures so a lot of harmonious work is going on in the in the security council of the united nations even though we continue to have some ideological and political difficult is as to whether it is a loose and nineteen seventy three was properly implemented and the issue of possible civilian casualties which again simply has to be clearly fired and set aside to the satisfaction of everybody the libyan people and to help lee in the possible victims of the bombings and bus you touched on it just i want to pick up the. aussie rules of post conflict libya how they being made secure how is the
11:35 am
u.n. stopping any of those weapons maybe ending up in syria. they may be ending up in various places and the fact of the traumatic regional effects of the libyan conflict apply not only to the possibility of the spread of weapons but also own migrant workers who were working in libya but then they had to leave the country and create all sorts of tensions in the homelands as to the you know the particular the issue of the weapons it's not just the united nations but under the aegis of the central of the united nations a lot of work is being done on that the best thing i can report of this point is that we're told that the most dangerous of those weapons in terms of terrorist use the so-called manpads man carried anti-aircraft weapons have so far not been that they're to the outside of libya so we hope that this concerted effort of the international community together with the libyan authorities can be successful in
11:36 am
the containing the danger of spread of weapons from out of that country something else i'd like to ask you said libyan militants a known to operate in syria what does that say about the nature of the syrian unrest that we've seen so far and why indeed does it appear that the u.n. members seem to be holding back from denouncing that what's happening there. you know this is a this is an issue as you know we two weeks ago the russian delegation and reduce the draft the security council resolution to the council trying to encourage the political process encourage the league of arab states money during mission which is being deployed now in syria but. we have basing our proposal proposal our new draft resolution on the presidential statement which was adopted by consensus in by the security council on august street which called on everybody to stop violence in syria and which stated that the only solution to the syrian crisis could be found
11:37 am
through a syrian led all inclusive political process had all the members of the security council had all the influential members of the international community been guided by the principles of that presidential statement i believe the conflict would have been over in the months ago but what we see is that there are some who are trying to stir up trouble and as things would usually happen when there is a crisis all sorts of extremist terrorist elements show up for instance several days ago there was a horrible terrorist attack in damascus and the day before that the minister of defense of lebanon said that they detected some al-qaeda groups are moving into syria from from lebanon so i wouldn't be surprised that the you know some terrorist elements from libya or other places have found their way through to syria in order to not to stir up trouble and to try to fan some kind of a s.
11:38 am
neko or religious conflict there this is what the terrorists are all about that about starting conflict but we believe that they're all of the international community in a crisis situation like wait we find in syria should be a do to help the people of that country to find a peaceful political solution to the crisis and that has been the line of the russian federation all along and that has been our guiding principle in the security council as well so with everything you've just said in mind how much more leeway would you like to see the syrian government given to sort out this from within. well we we don't give any leeway to anybody we believe that the syrian government should be extremely prudent and should refrain from excessive use of force we believe that there has been there are been some extremely troubling reports coming out of syria about excessive use of force by those or it is we urge the syrian government to cooperate to face fully with the when it ordering
11:39 am
mission of the arab league but also telling that the everybody must put pressure on on the destructive elements of the of the opposition or various destructive elements which may have found their way into syria that there are violent acts are not going to be condoned by the international community and this is a this is a key to finding a peaceful way out of the situation there and this is one of the discussions we're having when we talk with all colleagues in the security council about all draft resolution i'm talking about the armed groups out into the problems within syria is it difficult for the u.n. members to put sanctions on to syria because of the previous broken promises about non implemented reforms to now scale back a deal. well you cannot really talk about broken promises because some reforms were announced. some of them were pretty far reaching like changing the
11:40 am
constitution and getting rid of the political monopoly of one party but of course are to expect that those real reforms can be implemented in a situation when the the crisis is sort of teetering on the brink of civil war even under normal circumstances in any country or reforms of such magnitude on all these reimplement but i mean the point i'm trying to make is that the sooner the crisis the military clashes stop in a better position the international community will be to demand that the syrian authorities move along the reform track as quickly as possible towards forming the constitution doors conducting democratic open elections but all that in a situation when there is an armed conflict being encouraged from various quarters one would see weapons being moved. illegally into syria all that of course becomes a separate conversation and bussard like to broaden this out next and focus in
11:41 am
about what might be ahead in two thousand and twelve more generally in the region islamist parties have made inroads in the countries whose governments were overthrown in twenty eleven what additional risks does it bring to the middle east and north africa or indeed what action do you think that will require from the u.n. into twenty two. well it's hard for me to speculate about the possible role of the united nations but of course. some of the domestic political developments are pointing to the fact that this democratic process of some of those revolutions is not necessarily something which which is going to happen easily or at all what impact is it going to have on the regional situation remains to be seen but let me say that i believe that the greatest. danger in terms of this debilitation in the next year if i make my if i may make that prediction might come from the very disturbing growing confrontation between the west and iran this is
11:42 am
a very dangerous scenario russia has been working very hard in order to prevent the scenario from playing out but we do believe that the peaceful solution can still get the upper hand that we do believe that iran can start talks with the international atomic energy agency on those unanswered questions about their alleged former military activity in the in the military programs in the nuclear field with do believe that there is still a possibility on the basis of that he's and russians russian initiatives to restart the talks between iran and the group of the six of which russia is a member so i think that the the great focus of those who don't want to to see a very dramatic escalation of tensions and conflict in that whole area would be to make sure the. peaceful track the negotiating track in relations with with iran
11:43 am
prevails in two thousand and twelve to be clear the u.s. senate israel most notably the people that are worried about iran are any of their fears justified in your view. well there are concerns which were certain the shia concerns about the possibility of around developing a nuclear weapon and that's why we have been working so hard in the format of the six and in the security council that's why away a vote on the for sanctions resolution resolutions in the security council target the iranian nuclear and missile programs a but we also do not accept the proposition that the best way to prevent the war is to stop the war and certainly any military move against iran on this at this point or it could in any in any kind of scenario i could possibly imagine would have a dramatic consequences which would in no way improve the security of the region
11:44 am
which will in no way improve in the long term the security of israel and which could really have very tragic consequences so. we have been saying that for a long time and this is our consistent. stand if you will so again our effort is going to be a target at the doing whatever we can in order to prevent the scenario of a regional catastrophe being carried out in two thousand and twelve just looking at the news the last couple of days as a potential flashpoint could be the strait of hormuz how worried are you about the potential for conflict there. well those reports seem to be extremely troubling yes and this is not the way to go about it but over the past few weeks we have seen . the build up of various accusations and counter-accusations and this is quite troubling could we now talk where the relationship next between israel and the
11:45 am
palestinians as we head into the new year the peace talks appear hamstrung on one side by israel going forward or more settlements on the other the palestinian statehood bid already of course getting that unesco recognition do you expect any breakthroughs in twenty twelve might that manifest itself. well i sure hope so that if not breakthrough with us that at least some progress is going to be made but at this point in time i'm not extremely optimistic incidentally you mentioned the palestinian unesco bit and of course they also submitted their application for the full membership in the united nations we don't see at all oh it can hurt the israeli palestinian negotiations because of the palestinians have very wisely stated from the outset that they did not see their membership in the united nations as an alternative to negotiations with israel is that they accept that yes in the final analysis the problem will have to be settled in their direct talks
11:46 am
with israel is but also they believe that there must be certain parameters within which they will be talking to the israelis and one of the elements of those parameters is that the settlement activity on the west bank and is jerusalem will have to stop because now we see a situation where the west bank almost entirely covered by israeli settlements and outposts so it's logical for the palestinians it would seem to ask what kind of two state solution two state solution there can be if there is no land for us essentially on the west bank for some pockets of territory which are populated by the palestinians and the rest of it that is has been basically taken over by the israelis also they want to be to be sure that i want to talk about borders this is something which will be resembling the borders of one thousand nine hundred sixty seven this has been the key a kill amount of the international approach to the negotiations between the
11:47 am
israelis and the palestinians for a long time supported by that of peace initiative by numerous resolutions of the security council and numerous documents of the of the court it unfortunately in the year two thousand and eleven was sore at the end and see to to try. depart from those parameters that particular parameter of the settlement which of course makes it even more difficult to restart the negotiations but the court is still active if there is a room in the security council to do something and let me tell you that there is a lot of frustration among members of the security council about the fact that the security council has not been doing anything on the palestinian issue and a number of members of the security council are not talking about the russian delegation a number of members of the security council say when you have to have a resolution which will reconfirm those parameters well we tried to have a resolution on the on the settlement some time ago but it was vetoed by the united
11:48 am
states so a lot of frustration is there but hopefully both sides exercise restraint and. i should say that we have seen some positive movement from hamas politically in terms of the sort of palestinian reification bit when the from us on the abbas and also their moderating their political stand we believe and we have sort of moving trying to move them in that direction coming to the need to recognize the existence of israel within one thousand nine hundred sixty seven borders and fortunately even though there are still some rocket attacks by some extreme elements in gaza overall this calm is being maintained between the palestinians in these rallies president abbas very courageously announced the use of force in dealing with the issues of of their relations with israel of course we're all in the security
11:49 am
council elsewhere a saying that there can be no resort to terrorist tactics there so there is a lot of the there is a lot of pressure from various quarters to move the parties in the positive direction but whether or not the one can expect a major. progress in two thousand and twelve well as you know some analysts are pointing out that it's going to be our of elections presidential elections in the united states and they usually this is not the best time for the u.s. leadership to exercise some leverage in the area of palestinian israeli relations so it remains to be seen one hopes for progress but how much can be attained in two thousand and twelve it remains to be seen a bus that we've already had the pleasure of a company for over twenty minutes now while we've got you in the studio and like to ask you just one of two briefly other questions while while we've still got a bit of time the u.n. so far hasn't taken any action on the council units report about human organ
11:50 am
trafficking in kosovo that accuses calls for the liberation army of those atrocities why is it taking so long to start a u.n. investigation to date what exactly the this is this is a very young. well you know all this this is very disturbing to us we don't understand why our western colleagues in the security council refused to make sure that the current ulick's investigation in kosovo is really a credible investigation and that everything indeed is being done to make sure that the perpetrators should be found so the serbian delegation together with our delegation produced produced a very simple draft resolution which simply calls for the creation of office of special representative of the secretary general which will mourn it or the work of ulick's and make sure that the the witnesses are well protected we believe that the unix mechanism is not sufficient for proper investigation for witness protection and forty put into the security council we are concerned that what we'll
11:51 am
see is a result of unix work is that of the fever in five or six years of. the secretive active it is they will announce that they have not been able to discover anything and that the witnesses either died or were killed in the process and that will be it so we don't want this particular. gregarious crime to be swept under the carpet but the somebody isn't as i say there is a resistance to us of to that from to this investigation done properly in the full fledged manner from our western colleagues but i expect that there will continue that work with the serbian delegation in two thousand and twelve and i hope that resolution eventually is going to be adopted to make sure that this crime is not going to be forgotten again because you will recall that once already. the international tribunal and former yugoslavia somehow missed it i mean they stumbled
11:52 am
in the un to the problem but then walked away from a real investigation and the international community cannot repeat this shall i call it mistake again so a painful issue would believe that proper things could have been done easily. without much additional expenditure by that resolution of the security council but one of those situations when we find inexplicable resistance from some of our colleagues in the security council which will keep trying to overcome a bust or as we're looking ahead to the new year there are several dormant conflict zone all over the world where there's a worry that it may break trouble may break out if neglected thinking about cyprus and turkey india and pakistan and a few others too whereas the un security council focus on conflicts going to be twenty twelve is going to be solving current ones or averting new ones maybe as well. well we would try to do both preventive diplomacy is a very big concept for the security council and for the united nations but the
11:53 am
world so try to encourage. their work which is going on on some longstanding conflicts cyprus is certainly one of those situations which is being monitored by the security council but again this is a place and problem where reporters themselves should reach agreement one troubling again aspect but it was quite similar i should say in my view to the situation in the palestinian israeli negotiations that even though the context is completely different there have been for years and number of principles recorded in security council resolutions for an eventual cyprus settlement and basically the it says that it should remain one country so i think in my own understanding at least that in in the in the u.s. will solve and eleven it was sore some efforts to depart from that principle and the come up with proposals which would essentially in every practical or in many
11:54 am
practical ways and political ways split the country into two so i think that as created additional. problem for the prospect of the talks about the the two sides are talking. there is support from the united nations good offices of the secretary general the security council is watching so it should be possible we believe to move ahead on that issue. between the two parties in two thousand and twelve metallik chuckin russia's ambassador to the u.n. seasonal greetings to you wish you all the best with twenty twelve thank you for being on our all the best all the best to you thank you. ok hope you can stay with this programs continue it's now coming up to five minutes to nine moscow time i'll be back with the news in full five minutes from now.
11:55 am
11:56 am
50 Views
Uploaded by TV Archive on