Skip to main content

tv   Cross Talk  RT  June 20, 2014 9:29am-10:00am EDT

9:29 am
well that he would do anything i. don't i know i'm tired of crying too don't. go to the try to. people are going to. want to come here. for the short changing every minute. of. the time the last oh well. my. wife. skis is going to eat lots. sometimes from nothing. this season ends and. it's not just
9:30 am
a story you'll be shocked if you see a stage eight looked to be. but not on the cell. phone or leave the room. is a. polo and welcoming all things are considered on peter a logo a genuine appeal for peace negotiations or a gambit to intensify the conflict these are only some of the questions surrounding the president's call for a cease fire and forces in the east say it's a trap options are narrowing.
9:31 am
crosstalk or schenkel so-called truce i'm joined by my guest marcus papadopoulos in london he is the editor of politics first magazine in new york we have don de bar he is an anti-war activist and host of a daily radio program and in washington we cross ivan eland he is a senior fellow and director of independent institute all right crosstalk rules in fact gentlemen that means you can jump in anytime you want and i very much encourage it marcos if i go to you first in london. does polish ngo ask for a ceasefire out of strength or out of weakness or cannot just first of all say peter it's a good thing but russian news outlets are covering the conflict in ukraine in bed because if western media had to field for themselves the world wouldn't be hearing about this terrible dreadful conflict which is incurring civilian casualties every single day but you know president poroshenko he's approaching the conflict in a very to place this man on the one hand he talks of wanting to bring peace to the region to have negotiations but on the other hand he's maintained in i'm
9:32 am
prosecuting a terrible offensive which is resulting in just awful civilian casualties so what i believe is plain a very very dangerous game here i think he's trying to lure the militiaman fighting against forces into a false sense of illusion while continuing to prosecute a military campaign using grad rockets using the air force using tanks so personally i don't think any credence should be given to anything the polishing kerry says when he claims he wants to resolve the conflict in eastern ukraine in a peaceful manner it's ludicrous you know don it's one thing that the government in kiev has been able to prove is they can kill civilians pretty well and i guess that's the it's the only thing it's been able to do because its own military is proving to be quite apt here it from a western ukraine perspective he better. start getting some results because those
9:33 am
guys on the on the my don have been monitoring him i'm talking about right sector people here he wants to he talks to words of peace but he really needs to get this resolved pretty quickly because his own power might be at stake. first i think to describe is job description i would go to what the permanent representative from russia to the u.n. tell the churkin said which is he's really a translator not a president his job is to translate instructions from english into ukrainian and he's been doing that fairly well we've had the visits from various parts of the us government to kiev right before the predecessor and this government attacked yet again the people in ukraine the people in ukraine i mean it's the eastern part of the country but if you look at an electoral map from the two thousand and ten election. the last president to the deposed president pulled about a third of the vote in kiev it's not as monolithic in the west as as it's portrayed
9:34 am
here so ukrainians are ukrainians and the ukrainian military which by the way part of the reason that it is so when that is that there have been massive desertions from the beginning when this coup government and its successor said to attack its own people this is really a proxy war by the united states being fought against the people of ukraine with a comprador group fully established by coup in kiev and then i think the opposition perhaps it will evolve and while you know some other smaller parts of the west of the very far west that are traditionally attached to poland you won't see as much but there is support for the people in the east and for their own rights in large parts of western ukraine that we haven't seen expressed yet i have anyone in washington we came across that famous telephone conversation with victoria nuland
9:35 am
you know if there's one recording there's got to be a few hundred if not a few thousand recordings of her instructions to kim how much do you think the u.s. is behind whatever strategy poroshenko has. well i think probably too to a great extent i wouldn't necessarily go as far as don but i do think the u.s. has heavily. influence. because of course they're providing the assistance and of course the e.u. is backing up with economic loans and so is the united states both financially. and militarily and. advising the ukraine certainly the us has a big role and i think the united states looks on this as a. ukraine as a real prize. and i know a friendly government in ukraine to the united states of course is better than a government that's friendly to russia and i think you know the e.u.
9:36 am
has behaved. really started this crisis by saying it's all or nothing for ukraine and i think you know ukraine really has to nestle between the two blocks and it also has to have autonomy in the east simply because of the political situation there whether we'll get to that point i don't know but certainly there is a tug of war there to try to. ukraine from the russian influence you know markets it's very interesting i've been said something that i think is absolutely right is that you know the european union is uncompromising this government in kiev is uncompromising no negotiations in this is this is insanity here and this is what's causing all of these deaths you know pushing all mention decentralization federalization that's been talked about for months now all of a sudden he talks about it is effectively his own idea absolutely because for the
9:37 am
united states government and the european union it's a matter of it's our way or the highway there's no compromise and the way in which she crying has been treated by the e.u. and the united states is disgraceful ukraine should have been allowed to choose to extend the critically elected leader the president and the coefficient whether he wanted to push economic relations with russia or with the european union and president had a mandate however that didn't fit into the agenda of those in washington and those in process it was a very warm. see to see ukraine come away from russia and finally entrenched itself in the west point joining the european union and eventually join in when we hear western politicians talking about we have to sit down and talk in a reasonable manner about ukraine that's just that's just empty talk that's empty rhetoric the reality is that there is no compromise and we just we need to do is
9:38 am
look in the east of the country we've got a ukrainian military that is and that has proven itself to be a net and yet it's still fighting this bloody war and of course if pushing to wasn't being backed politically economically and also undoubtedly militarily by people in washington and in brussels would really be still prosecuting this war when the ukrainian military is not achieving any progress you know done that there's further this goes on the more of a identity issue arises in the east of ukraine because before all this nonsense this invented crisis i really want to stress that invented crisis public opinion polls in the east of the country people didn't want to join russia well every day that passes more deaths people are going to rethink that and then we're going to even have a bigger problem here because we're going to have a self partition this is and then washington being uncompromising wants everything this is a catastrophe well i mean some people are alluding to this as being
9:39 am
a replay of the fifteenth century or something and i guess if you wanted to go back that far which is you know. in this hemisphere you could but i think the context of block politics that was referenced earlier although what applies in fact i don't think is a necessary precondition to the current situation is rather something that's been created by the west i don't know how much russia has to do to show that it would like to be in. grated into the rest of the world politically socially and economically it dismantled the soviet union it dismantled the socialist economy it did everything that was asked of it and then some from one nine hundred ninety one until the last few months really and yet it is the one that separated from the g eight in fact the g eight becomes the g. seven and you know it's oster size so the creation itself of blocks and
9:40 am
a block tension is this is a creature of the west and it serves a particular purpose the purpose is to serve the interests of the elite here that do not want to see competing centers of power economic political social whatever anywhere in the world but rather vassals to whatever state organization they have control of at the moment is the united states military is the european political construct they had hoped although that now they're turning on china to use china's economic power also as a part of this construct and this is almost like looking at you know molotov ribbentrop in poland back in yeah one nine hundred thirty nine in terms of the break in the real estate between the two blocs if i were doing strategic planning for the russian military i'd have to be looking at it that way and looking you know at this basically as the beginning of an invasion of russia for it physically i
9:41 am
mean how many military assets do you have to deploy to the theater before people on the other side start thinking that way well that that's exactly how they're thinking about it in this country where i live i mean even i mean how would how far do you think russia is i'm sorry washington is going to go to get the prize called ukraine mine is crimea well i think. you know it has to be several hasn't they have to be somewhat subtle in their approach because the ukraine is a little different than some of the other countries and i do agree with don i think this is a western imposed block system because. as i think if you recall. george bush the first verbal he promised mikhail gorbachev that north nato wouldn't expand well of course nato has repeatedly expanded right up to russia's borders and so it's create that's created the reality what should have been done after the cold war is if you want to keep nato as a talk shop invite russia to join as
9:42 am
a full member and not have blocks but that's the root of the problem ok all right gentlemen i'm going to jump in here we're going to go to a short break and after that short break we'll continue our discussion on ukraine stay with r.t. . this is the media leave us so we leave the media. motions to. play your part of the physical. issues that no one is asking with to get that you deserve answers from. politics only on our team.
9:43 am
her. on marriage in the financial world. talked to goldman's cannot stop because it only takes the demands of credit . and life there and then.
9:44 am
welcome back to cross talk we're all things are considered i'm peter lavelle remind you we're discussing the recent developments in ukraine. ok i'd like to go back to marcus in london the person known as yeah he'll be remembered as yeah it's because of victoria nuland he said he wrote on a website in the united states for the ukrainian embassy and referred to russians is sub human but nobody seemed to pick up that in western media we did of course and i'm going to talk about it what do you think about that the last time i heard
9:45 am
a term like that in europe was in the one nine hundred forty s. . what one of the realities stemming from present yannick over it's been over for him was that neo nazis and anti fascist in ukraine are now playing a role in deciding ukraine's future however there are other groups and i would refer to them simply as unk hoof individuals uncouth individuals who hold positions of power within ukrainian government referring to individuals prefer into russians as subhumans a so-called foreign minister and i use that term in a very loosely way referring to president putin and russia in a derogatory way is this really what twenty first century europe is all about is this was a country. crane it's supposed to be in the modern civilized era where individuals are referring to russians as subhumans and as she said the last time the russians
9:46 am
were referred to subhumans that was back in the 1940's nazi ideology and that was so today in the in the next in the deaths in the awful deaths of thirty million russians and yet there's no condemnation by the west why because the west has a history of working with odious groups when it's its interests you know i don't want to divert the way from ukraine but look every year in the in the boat expects of latvia and estonia that all what they are waffen s.s. veteran parades who in washington or brussels has ever condemned those parades what would happen if it happened in london or berlin there'd be outcry and rightly so and in ukraine you have people in the ukrainian government referring to russians as subhumans that's completely unacceptable it's appalling and yet there's no condemnation because these people in kiev making these comments are the tools of the west they're the tools of the west to bring ukraine away from russia and thereby weaken russian influence in europe and in the world automatically you know
9:47 am
john i don't know if you saw a gent sakis comments about those comments and i was just left completely speech was i maybe you don't have a comment and you were left speak with the speech was as well go ahead. i actually spoke to the monitor when i saw it. at the daily news i think you did thank you delivering a press conference. yeah and you know so she said it was inhuman instead of subhuman now it was originally and somehow that's different and i think of course i mean if you go to the song about jen psaki that's been circulating the internet perhaps she meant inhumane but in context it's clear and also she said and also the translation now is inhuman which is the same as subhuman only worse subhuman is
9:48 am
below human any human is this not human at all and so that was her explanation but you know the larger context is this happened the same week that you have a riot and attack on the russian embassy in kiev and the tali churkin at the u.n. cannot get anyone at the united nations security council to deal with it you have and finally finally. after you know much negotiation if they have at least had discussions about it in addition to that what this situation is live beyond skin and the other places that are under siege in east ukraine at the security council the united nations of the united states you know through its proxy one of the baltic states acting as proxy refusing to allow a discussion or in any event a resolution to come forward looking for relief for humanitarian relief for the people there saying that there's no precedent cause in other words there is nothing going on in eastern ukraine that would require humanitarian relief now it doesn't
9:49 am
make sense looking at the facts on the ground where you have refuse you know tens of thousands of refugees water supplies disrupted all these other things but if you don't consider the people there human if there are any human suddenly humanitarian relief is of course not appropriate because that's for humans that's exactly it's not even subtext that's what's being spoken. and in the capitals and all of the you know norms for embassies all these other things are being completely abrogated in plain view without the united nations or any other structures dealing with it whatsoever it's a pretty frightening profit is frightening and ivan eland if i go back to you in washington it's all because it's really has very little to do with ukraine it has everything to do with russia doesn't it yes i think it is it's. trying to get as much of the near abroad away from russia as it can and i think some of your other participants here have touched on something i think is you know this is rhetoric
9:50 am
we're talking about now but as long as the conflict goes along it's going to become more bitter like the syrian civil war is you know more bitter and i think you going to see radicalization the other comment i would make is that the double standard is not just in. covers rhetoric it also covers actions i mean putin was heavily criticized in the west for going into crimea about we see no equal criticism in the united states of the kurds for grabbing or oil rich kirk cook so even as such actions have a double standard here in the west russia russia gets very. amazing least slanted media coverage here in the united states and that's why i keep doing this topic ok marcus you what you were nodding your head what what what what element of what i meant is that you agree with their well i think it's important to clarify that in
9:51 am
the one nine hundred ninety s. the west was happy to see russia integrated with the rest of the world while it was a happy with in the ninety nineties simply because of russia at that point was on its knees it was on its knees politically economically militarily it was totally dependent on the west on my feelings just to try and stabilize the one. a commie so the west was happy then however today in two thousand and fourteen it's a very different russia russia is standing on its feet it's not dependent on the west anymore and then we lie it's the problem for the west that the west doesn't have that sort of dominance that it once had in the one nine hundred ninety s. so it has to look around the world to countries which control and we can russia's influence and ukraine it's a huge area it's a huge piece of the jigsaw but if you crane was to come into the e.u. and nato russia on its western borders effectively would be inclusive and it would
9:52 am
be dramatically weakened but then you have to have a look in syria the americans have to have helped cause a conflict episodes in the deaths of one hundred thousand people well it's no coincidence that syrian russia traditionally have close relations and if the syrian government was to fall and extremists were to come to power russia would lose its influence in the middle east so it's a game of chess the americans a plane you know done is one of the things that's not really reported very i mean the story gets so bad bad coverage in the west but there's another story here that it is very interesting is that the russian people are getting very very frustrated with the situation going on in east ukraine because you know what they're the same people and watching it and we will see all the feeds i mean it's all sanitized in the west we see everything here and it's really really disgusting and it really is beginning to bother people here because something must be done and putin has been very strong in saying no we're not going to go in there we can't fix a problem that the west started in the first place but you know there's that other
9:53 am
element here there's a lot of pressure on putin at home yeah i mean i'm seeing it with commentators for example. because i won't go into names but you know people that are on the show that are stressed over are putin not going in and i understand that sentiment to a degree i do to the. you know that you have to look at the reality i'm sorry if you look at the reality of the situation you first of all have. people in western ukraine that are you know working class people that are sort of like klan members in the south they are easy to mobile you know this situation is uncomfortable for them they don't understand what's going on around them they feel disempowered some hotshot points that the people in the east that the russians you know those people do not like you it's their fault and that's who they direct their hate at and that mobilizes a core group so you can fill up for example them i don but then there are people on top of them who are actually organized in this kind of stuff who look at say the
9:54 am
mines or the factories in the east want to be oligarchs who are present all the guards who would like to be sitting on top of that to the west of them you have people in the e.u. looking over the shoulder of those people with the west saying if we let these guys in kiev take that stuff over we'll just take them over and then further than that you have the u.s. that's kind of how you construct this sort of thing but the real key here is that the prize is not ukraine the prize is russia ukraine is the doormat into russia that the u.s. has been looking for since the beginning of the cold war and even earlier if you go back to the period right after the revolution you will see that there was a proxy war fought in kiev more or less along i mean in ukraine more or less over the same fracture lines geographically and socially as now with the west using anti soviet anti russian proxies in western ukraine to fight that ultimately led to ukraine being brought into the u.s.s.r.
9:55 am
but immediately towards the end of the u.s.s.r. it was the whole chain of people in the early one nine hundred ninety from kiev to laval but i think that were some of the early inside the u.s.s.r. proponents of dissolving it and of course i'm sorry i don't think that was spontaneously organize. it wasn't him i know john let me let me go and i've been diligent so let me get let me get ivan give him the last word here on the program do you think that washington wants russia to invade eastern ukraine. well they say they don't but of course you never know i think that they probably would prefer not to because i think they like a friendly government in ukraine and i think that's very important but they've got to find some way to pacify the eastern regions and so you know they may eventually come to some sort of autonomy. situation and if they could get that that's probably what they would want i don't think they they really want to i think they would like
9:56 am
to dampen the conflict there but of course they would they definitely want the ukraine in the western camp ok gentlemen fascinating discussion we've run out of time many thanks to my guests in london new york and in washington and thanks to our viewers for watching us here r.t. see you next time and remember crosstalk. is a. huge news but eugenics vulgarize ation of darwin science punishment for an on committed crime i was never supposed to learn to believe in eighty feebleminded still today for the few i don't know why. but i still don't know why genetic improvement
9:57 am
through forced sterilization the basis for nazi ideology don't stop at just sterilizing yet again and now go to the point of deaths. for years rarely discussed . until now i'd really rather not talk about that right. some people say they want to support the war in time but not a very nice one the curtain falls down. and it's some point in i could no longer stand it i decided to kill myself. even i was scared of what i'd done i punched her but i didn't understand where i didn't want a man raising his head and the woman should. run from him. everyone who sees this video to also speak to the children's father.
9:58 am
my has then became a controllable people that he can do anything. while you're crying don't cry i know i'm tired of crying too don't cry a bad. series to get the basic right to kill its. own people are going to. want to be a fire alarm if you're treating everybody to. the to the last the well. why the hell. was the stick there's so many. cases for each one still.
9:59 am
sometimes from nothing to. disorient and it's still it's still just all still can still be just if you see a stage into it look easy to see what's the other selling. len. will come to the. show thirty four countries spend over billion euros she says should be one hundred fifty million degrees with. little to sell from st petersburg to france such as the sun. the future average.
10:00 am
for civilians a five year old boy among them are killed by army shelling in eastern ukraine even as the president prepares a peace plan promising a ceasefire. iraqi forces are on the brink of losing control of the country's biggest oil refinery to islamist radicals that have reportedly already taken over an airport on baghdad. a group set up to fight semitism a dumps militant tactics in france threatening to kill those who don't share their point of view. the eco activists are left to wonder exactly what plants are being used. after the head of the public but this conspiracies about plots again.

31 Views

info Stream Only

Uploaded by TV Archive on