region for example was not very successful and i guess this kind of victim blaming or trying to find some kind of external enemy is not very effective because that's a real tragedy i really want to pursue that angle of crisis communication a little bit later but let me ask you one question about which and specifically because i think the most difficult thing about this particular tragedy to process is that it was totally man made and putting himself said that this children died not because of terrorist attack not because of a gas explosion but because of a formalism corruption negligence and all of those things they have become archetypical trait of the russian state the state that he himself helped to create do you think is it fair to describe that tragedy as his own personal moment of reckoning i can tell you that unfortunately there is no. complete insurance

for cases like this unfortunately i guess that yes that was a tragic mistake but i don't see a reason to blame him personally. i don't see that someone has to bring condolence historian of putin not to the thermal as well as they govern there that the sheer not only he not only him a few of them and actually i guess that's a great mistake and. you can doesn't mean it my point was not that which it was to blame but whether you think the russian state is to blame because it's true in a fire it can happen everywhere but the response to the fire which was absolutely horrendous the observance of fire protection standards which was nonexistent and many many other factors whether we can indeed as all russians and we are all going through a very painful period that we can recognize that this is ultimately the mistakes

and the the consequences of what our state is like. who don't see the world state maybe they have to blame some specific minister is in charge of sponsible order in this fear or local and regional level but i don't see a reason to blame the state is itself well i have my impression was that putin himself was doing that because he actually said that what is to blame for this tragedy is the lack of. good performance on the part of the state and i think that was that he was the perhaps the only official among all the very large group officials who actually communicated that clearly. because he feels people's emotions and they actually see sure of that so you know. it was a smiting that in a few shows some of the. dalt to things i would see

inappropriate like victim blaming in and talking about so or not those people on the street is. not. someone from hue of the some kind of israel's over or emergency to see or see as as a broader source so i guess that's a shame and the saw that putin filled himself a different way i guess that maybe the have a lick of direct elections competitive elections and maybe if those officials. could have an experience of competitive elections maybe they could be more flexible moral maybe it would not have ever heard it ascended to such power after all because if you have to go through a competitive election for complaining in a year or sensually you're putting yourself objecting yourself to a lot of scrutiny and it seems from at least the camera experience that these

people are extremely uncomfortable office even facing their own people supposedly for whom they they work can i ask you a question about reforming the russians they because this was explicit complain promised by putin himself he said that the goal for the next six years is just make it to the logical breakthrough but also to make the russian governance more effective more humane more responsive what does the camera tragedy here say at or tell us about this corp of that challenge. you know there is some kind of contradiction because putin said that they have a bet on a young don't know krauts actually mostly there are a few shells leach did walk in executive branches power actually most of them. never had any experience of public politics day

in never been elected in a few exceptions but to most of the new governors they never had any experience of capet at a competitive politics and i see that they needed actually they have a few very serious problems like. and when a mental issue or such a tragedy is like d.c. it could happen and fortunately. those new people those new persons in a power they need to have those stew and scheme use to communicate to the people directly and also in such an uncomfortable circumstances like it happened in camera and before it happened and most poor region and so on and i'm afraid it's most of them are not ready let's talk about camera specifically

because. to me if this person a dad was a manger a sort of highlight of this tragedy apart of course from the huge death of the fact that that many officials at the local and federal level totally incapable of doing any kind of communication there was one of the most outrageous examples of a local official blaming a father who lost five family members for trying to score p.r. points on that tragedy. do you think that is is that just emotional death deafness the lack of empathy or is that indeed the lack of skill can something like that be correct ideas the lack of skill unfortunately and of course this. deputy governor who say to the father who lost all his have family that you're just trying to score the p.r. for and he didn't realize who stays with him and after of course the soul that

this lieutenant governor day he understood that he did rule and he kneeled. the fully grown but look here was not the only one for example there was another meeting which here already referenced during which they had of the investigative committee and very very close put in confident alexander but stricken practically accused parents of food leaving their children on attended in this anymore or at the playground because they wanted to do some shopping and he said that you know in our times it wasn't like that parents were supposedly more responsible that said his leviton it wanted to. visit it seen him on the law video to loot though the doubt it burns so he's lying and there's no injury there were in no more that time but in any case it's an extremely insensitive thing to say and thankfully put in actually cut him short but he also said mr stricken said that. you know in our times it was like that do you think that's

a generational thing do you think that will change as younger officials come to the reins of power. is not always better and this is a matter that maybe they're more emotional at you and i know. i'm not quite sure of course if they are talking about the health of business to get a committee does not need to be very empathetic actually he needs to find a fifty really who are really has to be blamed so who is a response of you found already to parents who have their children in the cinemas i guess it's could be some kind of emotional reaction and so it was room by descent. have about one hundred investigators in kemmerer region who has to find out who really is responsible for this tragedy is so i guess it's true but it's not all the truth about investigative committee. but at the same time of

course it was a mistake what you said. this all actually pushes the reactions of guys don't don't this is the laying out there yes absolutely and actually what is in the reality that's an empathy to the people you know you mentioned the this is victim blaming factor and i think it was also very prominent in another recent example of botched communication in their lower house of the russian parliament. they do which involved allegations of sexual harassment the deputy who was accused of that he was cleared of all the allegations but i wonder if you think it's a end of the story a. few aspects. first of all there is no proof well this was a tape yes. yes it was a transcript there was no tape they didn't bring the tape and also it was no any

group or expertise and also i would say that they do my commission. does not have right to arrange this expertise so i guess discussed right move would be to go to police they didn't do this and of course what was strange and what members of parliament and this commission note is that it happened just. in just before the election and dismay and they're trying to suggest a p.r. point think as a senior saying yes but i would say that that's a problem and i would say sometimes it's a gear between the dinner a sense because the people from that older generation they think that some things

are normal and to people from younger generation they think no they are not isolated here that there is a value or a gap obviously taking place within the deputies and. you know that voters but i think what they reach mania is not only the harassment story itself but the reaction of the deputies and they said gesture by the ethics committee that for example women have have to trust more modestly not in a row. that's wrong yes absolutely i mean i think we would all agree that it's wrong but do you think there is any chance of bringing to those people that that value shift has already occurred or do you think it will only. get registered once the new generation of politicians come. i guess that they just need more time bought some time i guess that's the problem is if your guru in to blame some you need to bring in some proofs so that i

do understand them they felt it like some. if you can also avoid saying stupid things like for example women dressed modestly i mean else i absolutely i do understand and also to say that i have been much more beauty a than those girls in one. caress yeah yes this is where one of the deputy there's rad that's right it was a mistake as well and i guess that's the see. dissin problems. delay cause of communication skills dellec of empathy and the lack of accountability i guess tears as. she said that was a thirteen i was going to say about the same time. not everything is to bat in russian power there are some people in them party

so for example i did like. a behavior of governor led nikitin who in the days. and the days of condolences he just came as a simple citizen just brought to. the flower. state quietly get out well and it was a it wasn't. just. the you are not a big. cheese then the you are just hit them when you share they condolences it's a different. disguise much more young yes well mr minchin kerry have to take a short break but we'll be back in just a few moments they chant. the

most expensive fish in the will of each one selling for the tens of thousands of euros it continues to grow its entire life if it was thirty years old you might have a two ton fish out there and yet they don't get that big today because we're way too good at catching. it's only whims of a much larger mission was once there was much more widely distributed we have politicians that are in office for a few years they have to get reelected everything is very very short term our system is not suited and is not geared toward long term survival and that's why we have because this is a. new when you don't know what the gallic to what did it put in. to what to do not through

only ten space it. may. lead to no kill said. cement. no term it is messy that. if you speak french. yes. that's the. case too. welcome back to well the part where you begin to russian political consultant mr

minchin came before the break we were talking about the. deficiencies of the russian political elite but obviously the president himself promised a new style of governance over the next six years there are lots of discussions in russian and russia about putin four point zero he has been talking a very passionately about the need for a technological breakthrough but his critics would say that for that he lacks that knowledge and he lacks the fact financing i feel like lacks the people. what do you thing of course there's a dissident or a difficult task and of course if you're talking about technological breakthrough or the question is why they didn't do this before the special live in the heard of such good. prices conductor but i dissent. or bruce lee have

a. very good positions for example in militarist sector and you know how the conversation of the some people. prominent expert in militarists and ask them is it true all those things which i'm told in his state of the union and say yes one new theme in many put in speeches is we the people the safety of civil engagement of both personal and shared responsibility do you see that as populism as paying lip service to democratic institutions or is there something more to it i think that he's a genuine. this is thing. to name the actual it's true because people who now march more involved. in. serial activity in some volunteer remove and so on

so i guess it could last a few decades people in russia because more friendly more empathetic more open and i think they've also started to demand more from that public officials and they obviously into less than part one is a good example of that because. i cannot imagine they harass men scandal like we had and they don't let's say five years ago people it would just register but apparently. this value a shift is indeed happening just the changes that chile just that's right people demand more from officials at the same time especially use in some kind of internet platforms. officials begin because it would have people so for example. in more schools we have this internet blog from like it if citizen i

live not for far from the place we have an interview right now now and it was. it was a hole in the road. and just sent a photo for a disservice and it was fixed in a few days so the lesson for everybody if not always as efficient and at the end of the day what we would expect from the government is not patching some holes but actually allaying good growth in the first place i know that in one of your articles you said that put in is an experienced populist you actually said that he became a trunkless long before the political emergence of trump himself and trump with a divider you can. never imagining him as an actual consensus candidate whereas put in the whatever you think about him politically is a unifier and the latest election show that he not only preserve his core base he actually cheap voters away from you know marginal and oppositional parties are they

released are similar i would not say this because i guess at putin is more cautious more empathetic. less extravagant so i would say that putin in reality he's a politician of compromise much more than donald trump and i would explain it not only by a personal history. i would say that. those angry white men. are much more numerous in russia in the u.s. so debase is much worried about some of the various they have very similar that's where for example for example. national industry national in their interests above anything. now some kind

of the values of traditional society much more them to beliefs of the new globalist to world like so traditional family. religion. chums family is far from traditional i mean it's tradition by composition vs ti's electoral his electorate you know i just finished my book my new book about donald trump and i can tell you that. interesting theme. that. why the religious the women voted for the law trump even after this scandal that something so on now i know that immediately after trump's victory you were modestly optimistic about the possibility of the relationship between our countries improving but if you just had the largest expulsion of russian diplomats from the west and what's interesting is

that the united states has some doubt even more diplomats than great britain. what's what's your sense of where a relationship is going right now. new called. new cold war and the so are illiterate what do you mean by that i mean that. relationship between our countries so i would say more be true between russia and this will be worsening in. in a few years that's my brokenness is would like to mistake to make a mistake but. fortunately to strategy of the collective best these two i salute to russia. and to. shows to describe it is a real state so as

a pariah he made a point earlier that if you believe that this decision this idea to marginalize putin and by extension russia predates the conflict in ukraine it was made before that immediately after his putin's election in put an election in two thousand and twelve what is it about that irritates he's haters in the west so my so much and is that person no or is it more russia related ideas the main problem. putin. he's the most professed politician in russian history for the last century. and demain problem is that he is a disappointed brewster and political because his idea when he just became russian president in two thousand was to make russia is a part of

a big west. and unfortunately he didn't succeed if russia can be a part of the big west russia is going to be the real best. based on the various the church helped to historical west to prosper and to develop of self. and those those elections are told about religious. traditional family and nation as a center so i guess that's putin's ideology. he's a deal he can construct you. a term and to poor of power in the world of course is quite uncomfortable for the or only superpower in the world and

finally i want to ask you as a political consultant one of the strategies that the west employs a lot worse as russia is the strategy of shaming and. staining its reputation and i think it was very. well demonstrated in the united kingdom the descript all case because erin the british government is very. apparently shifting from concrete evidence the chemical evidence towards the larger debate about you know russia has such an awful reputation but that means it did it as a political technologist how would you manage. that issue from the point of view of maintaining as good of a reputation as possible ideas the most important is to the call because russia might be in my opinion. in the last year is too emotional in the response of all those accusations so.

hard a situation they call me you have to be self confidence respect to the corner and even if the corn and is rule you just have to be calm and bring your resolve as the british like to say keep calm and carry on is there mention going to have to live in there i really appreciate your time with us today and terrorists please keep the conversation going in our social media pages as for me hope to see you again same place same time here and all the party.

how does it feel to be a sheriff the greatest job in the world it's as close to being a king as any job there is what business model helps to run a prison now we just do or don't like is there nobody over the case and i don't no one comes anymore we don't have to serve them anymore it's cost effective that's what they want to do that at the moment they don't give a damn if you do good for the money there are actually paying enough to put it back into the louisiana incarceration rate is twice as high as the u.s.n. breach what she could is behind such success. you understand how big it's just put two charts overlay them one is the us dollar what is the big prize as the us dollar has moments of strength in the otherwise

long multi decade bear market to oblivion you say pressure on bitcoin as the dollar were still just bear market and its new all time lows on the dollar index below seventy you'll see it going hitting new all time highs but the dollar is the devil's currency the dollar is different currency that supports the establishment that supports the charlatans and you know it does have a strong days but the trend is does era. then what i mean that he will go on. for years will pull you out of the. good obit in the mouth and that would have it and i didn't if it was but the good is it off the. shelf. on income if you. keep it or don't or don't let you

come up. could you prove. that about the how i live and i'm mad at them and them on the numbers i'm. not bad with the internet but oh november native i said i was of them that i don't know what about nanami. and it is about. you know. what. it's going to really. know. about the subject look at some of the troops not me but they're absolutely full. of.

sources close to wiki leaks tell me that the ecuadorian embassy his genius on his internet access to stop him tweeting about cathal an issue is his friend british design a baby in westwood told this it is essential that he gets back on line. really important that he's got i access to the world but all the exposed shows the t.v. money just to do both sides of come the russian foreign ministry says e.u. states have been pressured by the u.k. to take action against russia austria has also confirmed british pressure over this could have piled case and netflix users reckoned to boycott the online entertainment giant as it appoints former president obama's national security adviser to its board of directors.