let me go to you because i know your political stripes pretty well and reflect upon what i had to see in the introduction to mean if you don't agree you face in sold surround and violence representatives beliefs about what it means to be on the receiving end of violence it seems to me and i don't want to overdramatize things but over the last few weeks it seems to me that part of the political spectrum wants to normalize political violence in terms of speech at least go ahead gene in west palm beach you know it's discouraging because i think that my whole political life my thing has been that sometimes i'm wrong and i hold myself out to the fact that i may be wrong but i enjoy the civil discourse as some of my favorite things to do have always been shows like yours where you can have a conversation and a civil dialogue without ridiculing the other person without calling them names without accusing them of some form of bigotry but the left has taken a tack you call it a civil war i'm calling it an uncivil war as

a massive step away from the civility and then they tend to want to do this blame game and blame the whole thing on the fact that the president is somebody who hits back just because conservatives traditionally have never hit back and so i think that it puts conservatives like me in a in a really discouraging place and that we've always wanted somebody who would hit back the bully on the playground right i think that's a good thing because bullies in politics they shut down civil discourse but in this particular case i think the left has taken it far too far steve case one but there are a lot of other cases here that we're seeing almost every day now and the political environment you know. i used to remember is that ok i can understand you know the liberals used to be the ones that were taller and in want to dialogue and wanting to engage people and now we have a president which who can be quite vulgar at times i think everybody on the pay.

and all and our viewers would agree many times he's of but he's a bit rough ok but why does the left now have to emulate that i mean aren't they supposed to be better they've always presented themselves as being the better part of the political spectrum it seems to me they want to get in the mud. and fight it out that way which is not really part of the left's tradition at least my reading of it go ahead robert. well there is an old expression that you don't get into a peeing match with a skunk and i think it's been a huge error on the part of democrats but i'm going to make it clear donald trump has set the stage for all of this and if there were sixty thousand people in yankee stadium and everybody cheered for him except one person he'd be tweeting about that one person that doesn't like him but i don't think that the democrats are doing the right thing my fellow democrats and in the attacks that they make against trump against his allies just in general i think maxine waters is is the biggest enemy to

the democratic party is look like an idiot saying the things that she says and does and i i find it repugnant i've been attacked because i'll speak and i'll say well as a democrat and then i get blasted on twitter from people saying you can't say that you're not a real democrat you're a phony you're you're you're a plant you're a bob and so it's like oh i can't have any kind of dissenting opinion i have to just have an automaton o'clock response and you know all the drama will be you know i mean we're obligated look at me and with all due respect what do you expect from identity politics ok if that's exactly where it goes you're not fitting the mold you know then you're an enemy that's what identity politics does let me go to ron ron what does the left hope to achieve by this strategy i mean you know you don't have the leadership speaking out against that schumer said something and then he got attacked for it again identity politics comes into play it's

a losing proposition i don't know what the democrats hope to achieve by going down this path go ahead ron but you know i don't want to split hairs on optics here but i think when you're in the in the topic of this conversation when you say the laughed what you're really. furring to is the democratic establishment good in the corporate media and i would argue just for optics sake that's not the left one could argue that something like m.s.m. b.c. and the democratic establishment that is in fact the liberal establishment but when your say liberal you should be using it in the field loek sense they were sent to the left in the best of times and was sent to the right on it affects them a dirty fair the question that's actually and all wrong there's nothing actually progressive i agree with that ok but in the end the questions that i set out to everyone here i said stablish minute left so procreation and ok but let's but my

question is what does the establishment left want to achieve by taking on this strategy all it does is increase but you know it just increases the volume in the temperature of political discourse when we have no to the point where we don't have any ok go ahead ron. oh i agree with you and i think they really thrive on creating this am i caught of me of a we're not trump and trump's awful and we're not that when it comes time to talk to policy they really don't have any ideas you know we live more than ever before we live in a two party system lewis black said it best the republicans have bad ideas the democrats have no ideas so when you have a absolutely no ideas and when you have this president that's kind of a knee jerk reactionary you know that says you know some outrageous things sometimes what else can you do but then get in get into the match yourself and

gauge in the hyper partisan click bait culture that were a part of and try to run with it and hope that maybe you beat a republican or two and twenty the third priority of the democratic party is winning their first priority making sure progressive policies don't happen their second priority which those two things kind of go hand in hand is pleasing their donors their third priority maybe beating a republican or two by engaging in just partisan bickering you're getting all three of those things accomplished what you get in those top two things accomplished any ads at third one maybe maybe not so rep a recipe for disaster ok. reflect upon the fact that recently over the last week or so it's been conservative women particularly that have been attacked in public we don't have to go through all the names there's so many of them out i mean i thought the democratic party loved women and respected women go ahead gina. yeah we

had the whole when they go low we'll go high thing it looks like when someone goes low they're going to go lower the whole war on women thing they've turned that into a war on any woman who disagrees with their politics i would really like to get back to a time where we can have a conversation a little bit like we're having right now frankly where probably the three of us wouldn't agree on policy matters much at all but we can definitely agree that civility and conversation are much more intelligent way to go about establishing policy that works for america and slinging insults and especially as you point out to peter it's the identity politics i would argue not the president the identity politics that have brought the democrats to where they are in what is amounted to a truly uncivil war that is really among the left in this i mean the right we're getting along pretty well not perfectly but pretty well i remember a few years ago when i thought the republican party was imploding but at this point

i really think that identity politics is imploding the left that they have got to get some issues to stand on and to work together frankly because even if the three of us four of us sat down and discussed policy we could agree on we could find something that all of us are passionate about and we could fight together on that but rather than that the american people and especially the traditional democrats out there they're watching this lunacy go on the left and thinking i don't know but i know that's not what i want and they'll lose in the midterms because of it i feel quite sure at least at this point if something doesn't change fast you know why can't the establishment democrats rein these people in are they afraid or do or they're worried to be their bases drifting to more progressive socialist we could look at what happened in new york i mean what it won't what's the lack of reaction because it seems like the lack of reaction shows the huge splits within the party go ahead. it's a completely fragmented party right now there is no leadership who can you say is

the leader of the democratic party since you seem really sensitive booker. maxine so you know and here is that here's my proclamation for the democrats that they better that they have to get the sky is always blue water is always wet and donald trump is always going to be donald trump so stop complaining about what he says and what he does because he's always going to do that why do you throw some policy at us and tell us what you were going to do democrats to get rid of them or if why should we vote them out what what is your plan as a democrat i can't speak to any policy i've heard other than donald trump is a creep and a jerk ok i agree so what are we going to do. ron you're agreeing there now that my point is this it's ever been ever since the campaign not even the election is that the more you go after this guy the mainstream media the more you push him up and it's free advertising what it and so much you know you have seen him go out on the

road i mean all he does is attack these people and they love it ok they were giving him all his material ron yeah you're absolutely right and i'm sorry guys i missed a little bit i was going to take issue on my end it's called it's got it in for us i thought it was like why was it something i said i don't know i don't have a good discussion but but everything just kind of went out on me very second so i'm not totally caught up i apologize but yeah i think rob you bring out her and you're going to they don't have any policy ideas i don't think that's an accident though and that's why again i'm very disenfranchised by the two party system right now because i don't feel that there's anybody with power in politics with the exception to bernie sanders that represents any of the policies of iraq going to jump in here i'm going to jump in here we're going to go to a short break and after that short break we'll continue our discussion on political stability stay with r.t.

. rather they have to as he should be. one of the people so if you be in love because . that's me what i mean i well me and nothing. but the same. one i was was a. double move. in school the. only

industrial jungle in the prison instead of instead of a watchman a rug from a christmas. winter with a mint oh is that and there have none removed can you hear me shall i. diminish cancer most i'm. remembering pretty brags that it was all about the british my to

bring back five hundred factories are going to export our way back into a g.d.p. rocket ship and take on the world cool britannia go brittania well it turns out they're all going to be picking fruit out there and can bury shyer. originally thought is drastic to us it has taken care of our cars just the same as me you could find most of them from a completely different car to i would just. as the. problem is that we kind of how they stayed within the state they call a nice this non part of sweden. and i don't know some people who have money. no no but ok so what's the stop stop stop stop

here koku. my culture is christian country and we don't do things like that and we reach out to you if you do then we hate you and somebody hopefully you can do something about this stuff. we can not be naive about this to not attract more gangsters rapists and these it's actually that are tearing down this city we want sweden to be a swedish country and we want to know the people who live here and now to go back. welcome back across like we're all things are considered i'm peter remind you we're discussing. civility.

ok let's go back to ron in in l.a. on skype are you ready for the into the wreck you want to finish up a point please go ahead yeah i mean i was just getting at you know rob brings up that ease not seeing any policy ideas from the democrats he's absolutely right i think this is by design i think that really the united states is ready to go in a more populist direction if the four of us you know the four of us sat down and dr gene it was saying if the four of us sat down and really talk policy we wouldn't agree on everything we seemed to kind of be all over the spectrum we have different points of views on different things however there would be some really big paler that i think we would all have in common i think we would all want to end the wars and invest that money back home i think we would all want to see a populous where unemployment is in better shape we might have some different ideas on how to get there but it's something that we would all want to see happen there

would be some big crucial for instances where we would be on the same page who does that not benefit that doesn't benefit the establishment that's right ron let me go to gene and you know why all four of us can have a civil conversation because we don't have to worry about donors really that's reason why ok yeah it becomes more of a temporary election that's right that's right you know geno one of the things that really ball there is nobody knows a little more or. one of the things that really bothers me about what's going on here is that my first incarnation professionally i was an academic historian and i taught courses at the university of california and i really really hate it when people start using the term nazi and calling someone hitler because i know the history of the twentieth century in europe extremely well and the people on the left. during those terms around or so abjectly. incorrect in without

knowledge they don't know what they're actually saying it's a very terrible those are terrible terms and you have to used very sparingly go ahead gina because this is what gets on my nerves well that is discouraging to me too for exactly the reasons that ron cited when i believe that there are productive things we could do if we would actually work together and for all the criticism of this president he has been someone who is willing to work with his political enemies and he's willing to sit down with democrats and he's willing to ask their opinion and that's one of the things i like best about him it's even willing to call himself off once he's really decided somebody is a bad person and to stop and listen and if we had a little more of that particular element in our society i think we'd be better the democrats have themselves in a real position and here's why their money is coming from the far extreme left those in hollywood and the progressives in general but their votes come from places like the rust belt the unions where the jobs are drying up because of illegal

immigration and other sorts of policies that the democrats have passed so the democrats can't figure out how to get both the money and the votes and that's their delimit they're going to have to start to develop if they're going to survive in a two party system as ron referred to they're going to have to develop some sort of policy that can appeal to a broader base and pull from republicans not that i'm here to advise the democrats although that's not like that's just what i did but i kind of watched some of these problems happen within the republican party not all that long ago and i honestly and you may not believe me as i am on the right and i don't deny that but i've landed here honestly and i'm willing to admit when i'm wrong i honestly crave a government where we have a strong opponent that comes up with good idea yeah so that that makes my side yet or i do think that polish is all of us when we're all more good. that's a very smart observation and i think that's really good and that may and that makes

the political debate brings it up to a higher level here rob one and i want to go back to this historical thing because i think it's i think it's really important here i mean when we have people you know there's like the n.t. for people that you know that's really the fringe people that are saying that you know. making comparisons to nazi germany well i would say that there is a historical analogy and i would volume are germany where germany was collapsing in the one nine hundred twenty s. for a whole wide variety of issues but there was during that time there was the lack of respect in the breakdown of public discourse that's one of the reasons why the nazis was able to come to they were able to come to power and i think that this is a critical moment that that's a history lesson is if you continue down this path yes you could create a very very disturbing future but we're not there yet and i think people need to step back and and all of us here a bit like mine policy policy and more policy i'm tired of the emotions go ahead rob. well first of all as

a jew i don't like the word nazi thrown around so arbitrarily and easily i think i'll make it clear i think he's despicable i don't like him he demonizes immigrants but that's not the same thing as what took place in nazi germany and i agree with you peter we have to look at things historically it's it's like what happened in iran with the ayatollah khomeini and we were so upset about that as americans well why did that happen who did we support we support of the shah of iran what republicans used to complain so much vociferous lee when when fidel castro took power but we had multinational corporations in cuba paying workers two cents a day there some course there was a revolution so i we have to look at what leads up to things and things donald trump didn't just pop out of nowhere and invent himself and just get elected by magic there were things that upset infuriated people and he had

a you know voters that came in and elected him and so we have to look at the why instead of again complaining about donald trump oh he's this he's that he's terrible he's a jerk. and tom landry had a great sign when he was coach of the dallas cowboys that said what if there is no what if. so let's let's deal with reality and what's happening right now and again going back to policy policy policy you know ron we had a supreme court justice kennedy announced he's stepping down i'm really worried and i mean if we think the political atmosphere is bad now wait until his successor is announced and before he goes or she goes before congress i mean this is going to be one hell of a storm ahead of this here because it's already started i mean the ink wasn't even dry in the document and the. war really started flaring out i'm really worried.

about how this process is going to work go ahead ron oh i mean you know i'm also worried about a hyper conservative supreme court i understand i understand that and i understand i understand but what i'm saying but what i'm saying is is that i'm more worried right now is the process because what it does is it taints the entire process it taints the court and now you have people on the left the extreme left doubting the constitution itself now there's a lot of things that need to be done but if we don't have the same playing field in the same laws then then we can even further away from communication there is going to be a come from ation process and now the democrats who get their act together and ask good questions and said destroying their arms up in the air ok that's not going to help anyone go ahead ron. and we'll see what they do i mean when it came to no gorsuch they certainly just kind of threw their arms up in the air and in i think that one of the things that this does for the democrats is it really kind of

strengthens their argument of blue no matter who hey look what happened look at the supreme court for all you people that want to actually change within the party for all you people that wanted to run as progressive straw you people that went to joel stein this is your fault it's not the fault of barack obama who just kind of let his pick go and didn't do anything about it it's not the fault of the democratic establishment who propped up a flawed candidate in arguably the only candidate donald trump was can capable of beating it's not the fault of our political lack of any type of hardball whatsoever and just rolling over to the republicans because a lot of the democrats just go along with the republicans anyway it's your fault the whole supreme court thing just kind of strengthens their blue no matter who argument meanwhile you know we're facing a potential hyper partisan hyper conservative supreme court for years and years to come and i respond to something gina said i don't think the problem with the. the

democratic money is necessarily hollywood now this is coming from somebody who the president of show business still will not take my phone call maybe there's a little bit. but i think it's you know they're bought and sold by the same people you know their donors are the pharmaceutical industries their donors are big oil so of course they're not going to come out against fracking because big oil gives them a lot of money of course they're not going to come out. of wall street thank you so it's like when you have two parties that are just kind of bought and sold by the same people one party is allowed to represent those people want to apologize because they were on the right this is what we do the other party is just a little more subtle about it ok gina you know i really like. film sees a great actor i think he made a complete fool out of himself by making a spectacle lot of themselves and one of these award gatherings here i mean will it's really time for hollywood to kind of simmer down and you know we give you

a few ball actually a lot of bucks to watch your films but i don't need to hear your political opinions to be honest ok because i don't see how anyone really in hollywood except maybe clint eastwood i can show my prejudice but i don't see that they're particularly well informed and i don't know why they should try to get involved in the political process go ahead yes for example when they're saying you know destroy ice it's only existed for fifteen years that's not true it's just called a different name before so when hollywood comes out on these some of these issues they sort of they make some mistakes because they don't have the historic knowledge that you're talking about and and that doesn't look at either but i think that ron illustrates a really keen point here that should be punctuated and that is when when both parties were both listening to the same tune right at the wall street you know whoever came up whoever had the big money because they needed it to be.

reelected that right there is what i think that people like me who like civility who like you know i am a conservative bona fide as best i can tell again i keep an open mind but i think i am but that's what i liked about donald trump and that's why i elected and worked hard to elect a donald trump it wasn't because he was like me it was because he didn't need or seemed to want or even seem to have a lot of regard for those same groups that had always controlled you know in particular big pharma particular wall street some of those groups he didn't have a need for them he didn't seem to care or give them much regard or even respect and i wanted somebody who would answer to me and i think that the average democrat out there right now they want the same thing they want to politician who's not bought and sold who will answer to them and they can't find that in the democrat party like now and that's the conflict i'm going to jump in here i think the political established left needs to calm down and i would give the same advice to the

president of the united states out all the time we know many thanks to my guests in new york los angeles and west palm beach and thanks to our viewers for watching us here see you next time and remember crosstalk rules. twenty eight team coverage we've signed one of the greatest goalkeepers of all suck but there was one more question and by the way who's going to be our coach. you guys i know you are nervous he's a huge star and the huge amount of fresh camera you have to be the center of the beach. and we'll show you all the great the great you are the rock at the back nobody gets past you we need you to get going let's go.

alone. and i'm really happy to join for the two thousand and thirteen world cup in russia meet this special one. meets just at the reno beyond the team's latest addition to make up a big. book. is very valuable and very competitive so so far we go to do something to be competitive as a footballer and therefore we know from when we come back to the. roots of this knowledge and and we can perform it. in twenty forty you know bloody revolution to tikrit the demonstrations going from being relatively peaceful political protests to be increasingly violent revolution is always spontaneous or is it you know here i mean your list put video and the

belief is that i knew scrolling needed a lot of the former ukrainian president recalls the events of twenty forty. those who took. invested over five billion dollars to assist ukraine in these and other goals that will ensure a secure and prosperous and democratic. camera . roughly once they showed some new play you for the. future uncool videos during the world cup and someone with. more. really don't t.v. . for the world and so architects visionary largest international congress on the development of july seventeenth through twenty second business.

forum dot com. nine of ten. have reached an agreement on the crisis including the setting up of special migrants and the speeding up of the extradition process. a prominent us. nobel peace prize nominee has been arrested by the f.b.i. about allegations of paedophilia. tries to foster a nation of patriotic european smacking it compulsory primary school children on both the country's national anthem and the e.u. ode to joy. the group stage of the twenty eighteen world cup in russia is over only sixteen teams now remain in.