prime minister to reason may says she's ready to establish a more productive relationship with russia despite describing the country as a threat. israeli war planes killing at least three palestinians in response to rocket fire. from gaza. just pour into the streets of paris to show that distaste for president proposed education cuts which could endanger thousands of jobs. for the latest on these stories you can head to. stay with us for cross talk to us in the conflict in yemen and french calls for

a european army and if you're watching in the u.k. political talk show renegade coming up. alone welcome to crossfire for all things are considered i'm peter lavelle is the idea of peace in yemen and also trump is insulted the europeans might defend themselves and russia gate front and center again. cross talking some real news i'm joined by my guest here in moscow mark sloboda he's an international affairs and security analyst we also have dmitri bobbitt she's a political analyst. international and we have going these and he is

a professor of the higher school of economics as well as author of the decay of western civilization and resurgence of russia all right as usual german crosstalk rules in effect that means you can jump in anytime you want and i would appreciate david let me go to you first here donald trump went to paris for the. ceremonies commemorating the end of the first world war the bringing of peace after that carnage of four wars four years and twenty million dead in twenty million casualties. he felt insulted that his host president mccrone in france proposed a real european army very insulting to really insulting peter considering he trims very dismissive attitude towards nato in a number of ways how do you respond to it well. normally what would you clear russia should be insulted because actually here's what you said faced with russia which is that our borders and has shown that it can be a threat we need

a europe which you felt itself better without just depending or there were other states in a more sordid manner and of course so what we're globalists is kind of interesting coming out of his mo who is threatened here you know if you want to build a european army against the united states no against russia he says it quite openly and i think it's a disgrace one hundred years after the war in which province and russia were on the same site in which millions of russians that he says that russia which is know it all bought us he forgets to mention why russia is at the borders of the european union it's not because russia expend it is because nato and the european union expend that not paying any attention to any concerns that russia might might graze about it only mention russia did he also wanted to you know this is a series of russia china and we all are fearing the imminent chinese invasion of europe on the other side of the world. although i know i am right you know trying

to use troops or about the disembark normandy i pretty sure but he also mentioned the united states and even the united states he said that talking about the need to defend against now this talk is simply trying to put on warhawk credentials come on france can't even pay two percent of its g.d.p. according to nato strictures and he's talking up a european union army like the sun came here i think and what i want to talk about also the reports that mcchrystal did not want putin interim glenn jumping. also said this is not a new idea though it's actually here i'll share with you here the national interest last week wrote an article that article washington smothers independent european security issues the entire history of it since one thousand nine hundred one six months after the soviet union collapsed. in germany for the petersburg task force which was the purpose was to develop military capabilities for their opinion now

they were able to strike a compromise with the united states in which they would have a clear division of labor usually nato would do the interventionist in the nations and the the e.u. would do the dishes and then to do the peacekeeping or the training so bad cop i'm going to. go to softer one but i would political leave the us military to go in there but what has happened now of course is there's been more push for a new army because trump is alienated europeans and we've come through forget that the british has been the main want to obstruct in the army and now with brics it they're pretty much out of the way and from france they've been pushing for all that to develop the security initiative outside these structures and the germans would like to bring it in so you have all the different incentives for developing the army about. i think also an important point is that the e.u. is through the struggling for its existence now their purpose the reason why people join the u.s. political. economic reasons and economical it's flopping is going from crisis to

crisis so i think there is a need now to actually get a new purpose for the u.s. it looks like that's pivoting to what is new is there any indication even that the europeans want to have their own army well it depends on which european on the eve of the agreed something about nouriel the europeans normal europeans i think see no threat from russia there sequel the wars in the middle east they don't want to europe to support these surgeons in syria they don't want europe to ball believe beer in order to kill their you know qaddafi and plunge the country into the civil war but if you look at what has been going on since one thousand nine hundred two the european union actually started more was the united states i remember how how the whole thing in libya started it was not the united states it was such a crazy and the french planes that boarded first. how did the yugoslav war began begin there was a large you can look which said some people think that the united states started

all of this no paris a lot of them asked you know they will all of the united states to go together with them in india it was like that in course of the united states was providing air support the ground operation was conducted by european troops if you look at the history of european union since one thousand nine hundred two they didn't make peace with any of you know the united states at least improved relations with cuba somewhat now trump is destroying you with that the only quarreled with russia with yugoslavia with libya with syria with iran with anyone who objects so basically and the one that called for a microwave he is saying that europe needs to be kind of for defensive against the united states only one hundred thirty i'm i mean just you know i mean is this is this something is this some kind of gambit that mccrone is playing right now because i don't i don't see there's a lot of political goodwill and certainly no political guts and there's certainly no five. for such a thing right this is largely

a political move and we could just dismiss miss this as. you know across this version of fake news and fact i think a lot of this is simply a way of striking striking back against trump's criticisms of and demanding that european countries spend more on their defense as part of nato structures now let's remember all european countries have their own national armies right most of them you know in significant except of course for like france and the united kingdom. if you sort of turkey is not part of the e.u. of course but it's part of nato right. and they also are also part of nato structures but they still can't most of them all but five of them can't even spend two percent of their g.d.p. on the military in fact this may actually be the discussions of it may actually be a way to cut the military spending because france and the united kingdom have

previously in the last three before brags that of course been involved in cooperation where they share military resources. because they can't afford you know this global type militaries you know capable of power projection around the world and you know this is what the european union you know these countries like france are really concerned about it's not defending their own countries it's being able to project military power in africa in the middle east in age right we recently saw a united kingdom. french troops involved in the south china sea right in these military parades that you know the u.s. is putting on their saber rattling against china so i don't think we should take talk of an e.u. army seriously if anything this is just the way for him to try to hit back strong i mean let's say in an imaginary world because nato is certainly not going to go away anytime soon but in an imaginary world. if there is this rift growing rift between

the e.u. and the united states would european elites still consider russia a threat because you'd have to go through a threat analysis here and because a lot of it is driven by russia is driven by the united states mccrone can pick up on it but. i'm basically convinced the do europeans would want to actually engage russia in terms of security and not deeming it is a as an enemy i don't necessarily agree because if you look at what the european union's done in terms of economic nomic times when they looked at how to engage with the neighbors of the common neighborhood house with russia it has always used tools such as such as eastern partnership which excludes the russians when they have now reached trying to reach further into eurasia they want to mention here is an economic union so this kind of this very serious some approaches some of the europeans would like to take on the idea of being a military. competitor to russia you're telling me that no i'm saying that they

have no interest in harmonizing their interests and integration efforts with or with russia i think wants and i'm not i'm not saying that but i don't know what i'm saying is it will be deemed as the same kind of enemy ok militarily. some military power stuff becomes the reasons for a reason for the u. texas to come take another so this is a this is the defense of the european union ok it's not but move nato that is expanding to the east though by hook or crook we have to remember that the current crisis in ukraine was precipitated not by nato expansion yet right not by military move but by the e.u. graph going to mean a liberal shock therapy diktats of an e.u. association agreement and when at the last minute the ukrainian president yannick which backed down because he wasn't getting the billions in funding he expected to

be able to finance these deep deal liberal shock therapy cuts and said no not now not under these conditions and we could that is when the european countries in the us openly quite openly on the streets of kiev to crowds cheering for the overthrow of the government they actively participated in that if that's not meddling. i don't know what foreign minister chairman of the sitting in parliament this head of the european diplomacy could try next and they were cheering they were supporting then the peaceful protesters who kept the cookie sheet punishment you know what is meant and if not this and again you know this. that everyone keeps me schooled you said that basically we should be wary all the coolness of the united states that can threaten europe security one of these sports is when i'm out of a hollow trump won the election unexpectedly in two thousand and sixteen and trump

will drop me saying peace with russia what was the reaction from europe oh it's not that ok we don't want to say i got to get over the break here hold on to that thought ok we're going to go to a short break and after that short break we'll comino discussion on some real mistake with our. what politicians do you should. put themselves on the line. they get accepted or rejected. so when you want to be president should. somebody want to listen. to the right person this is what the korean people. interested in the why. question.

are good for the systems to say for. myself or sunburned. syria. rolls can you say boy understands with the must be so it looks. this is an english for. a lot of fellows a lot of help us out i'll show you i am. not . the case in that book i know and that can be

a bios look at the model and the body is comply with most of it's own for most of the shows just the fluid so almost. moon neutral and you must. move. i've been saying the numbers mean something a matter of us of the rich one trillion dollars in debt more than ten white collar crimes happen each dish. eighty five percent of global wealth you loans to the rich eight point six percent market saw thirty percent rise last year some with four hundred to five hundred trade per second per second and bitcoin rose to twenty thousand dollars. china is building a two point one billion dollar a i industrial park but don't let the numbers overwhelm. the only numbers you need to remember in one one business show you can afford to miss the one and only boom

but. it's hard to imagine the decades after the war a nazi don't it was still active and rich in the nineteen seventies current intel had as the chair of its board a man convicted of mass murder and slavery at ashwood it's a german company. gruntal developed in the denied a drug that was promoted as completely safe even during bring them to you it turned out to have terrible side effects what has happened to my baby anything. yeah she said she's just. solidified victims i have to this day received no compensation and never apologized for the suffering that not only want the money i want the revenge .

welcome i could cross like we're all things considered i'm peter lavelle to remind you we're discussing some real news. or let me go i think going to finish up on trying being insulted in mccrone. trying to be the new sun king of europe i just want to make the point that i don't think the european union really believes that russian tanks are going to roll into poland but but my my point is that based existence on the e.u. based on military threats to the huge russian neighbor is going to be a key focus and as a comparison though i think it's worth looking at nato in the early ninety's because when the soviet union collapsed what happened to nato and nato itself said we need to either get out of the area or out of business out of the recession meant we need to start expanding intervening. if you don't do this with

a higher purpose and more in and they will fall apart my problem if the e.u. becomes dependent becomes reposition itself as a military power descension will go down the same path they will it will need and then in order to exist if that is russia if mccraw and wants to exert it to express european. solver and tea from the united states and other countries may i suggest that he starts not with the military but with political and intelligence independence from the united states i mean i certainly remember in the last couple of years revelations through wiki leaks that the cia had penetrated every single significant french political party right not worry about russian naggers about the cia and french political parties or when obama's intelligence was bugging merkel's mobile phone right where is the big reaction against that you want to start expressing some sovereignty and independence try doing it with your

intelligence and politically you know we're not going to ship it was basically recognised by the united states that they need to download reveals phone conversations over the french and the spanish so what the problem is you know when you're talking about you are being dependent on the united states you have to you have to make it more clear which united states obama and hillary they're reviewed in their in their liberal ultra liberal circles in europe ruled in circles in europe before any of these people come back to power what russia will have a united front against and you know this will be all forgotten exactly and there is a very widespread view in russia that somehow the united states is bad and the united europe may be good for russia but let me remind the russians that there were two times in history when you were terry bordello and under hitler both times the consequences for russia what prejudiced that switch gears here. i started out by

the program program saying asking the question is the idea of peace in yemen and ethical glenn i mean there was a lot of rhetoric over the last few weeks but no the demand that it be you to say should have some kind of pulse of all the hostilities in yemen have gone on deaf ear. punishment for shogi is still to be revealed. and the united states has said i don't think it's happened get that it will no longer refuel saudi planes in yemen is it was this all just p.r. it's just business as usual war in yemen yeah i think it's mostly for signaling of course with this murder in the consulate a lot of the u.s. media discovered that there's a war in yemen you know while we're not amazing we're going to be watching this program but you've been watching this program you know it all the time but you're correct it's often portrayed as a solid war against him but it's very much a u.s.

u.s. all the war against him because the united states provides the weapons the training isn't just a refueling logistics just intelligence most importantly the targeting is what lead gives to target so this is pretty much pulled the trigger and. then that's the end of it so i think. this this this idea that the united states can't do more to the saudis is false but that's because the u.s. has a stake in the outcome of this war as well so i don't i think this. congress pushing for it probably the most is pushing for the most dreadful signal that has come out is that the trump administration may designate the who the as terrorists i mean that's if that isn't mixed signals ok pompei of the war most come to an end and then the state department in the defense department may designate the big terms in this war as being terrorists i mean i. it is really i don't know and definition of terrorism they're talking to clear those who are thieves terrorists and not saudi

arabia right i mean we had a quote from the washington post this week that you are smilin theory leaders continued to see saudi arabia as a key partner in the counterterrorism fight that has dominated the pentagon operation in two thousand when they were it's only just those areas orwellian. according to the. clinton e-mails u.s. intelligence says that saudi arabia and qatar are war funding and arming isis al-qaeda. and boko haram so i mean who is also to the terrorism here now this is just dumb this is absolutely is this is just signaling this is the minimum step they can take to try to dry our degree of public perception remove they continue to provide arms see for i. am going to tell you is this as usual about iran saudi arabia is absolutely necessary with america's

pathological obsession with iran where. there are no obsession with iran i don't think the united states itself as a country is interested in all of this mass but let's look at the process let's look at the peace makers from the united states which is to force to stop all of this cruel things from happening there is a report from reuters that cia director general hospital that the audio recording solve his death you know when she visited the stumble i can imagine her reaction so what after all the prisons that they. ran in you were up in other places was she really impressed by what you don't at least when you're under pressure or with the first thing that went into her leg was damage control that's with literally running from mike to the peril of my company or you know you want him to save yemen when he says about iraq you saw that this week iraq's leadership to make a decision whether they want their people to eat and of course well that's

a step up from you know act like a normal country i think that was the quote before i think this is wonderful from pompeo because he's actually admitting white u.s. motivations with sanctions on any country and so he always been right he speaks out the other side of his mouth of supporting the i. people against the whole us at the same time he says that the iranian leaders had better get in line with us foreign policy if they want their people to eat i mean this is the same time thing we saw with north korea when t. rex rex tillerson was saying that with the advent of ghost ships with north korea that we were starting to see some real the same sions were starting to have an effect which is because the north koreans were sending fishing ships out without even a nuffield to get back home they were so desperate to provide food right and we saw the same thing all the way back with madeleine albright and iraq when she said it

was worth it right however real you know we can debate you know the numbers that were involved in the question also is she a five hundred dollars half a million she as the question was phrased she accepted the premise and said it was worth it to kill to starve a billion children happens they think and for me is is it and maybe it won't make a difference because the news cycle is so short in the attention span of people in so short that i mean for the first time during this horrific war actually got some coverage i mean even in the mainstream media here. with this more public awareness here and i know that there are members of congress i don't know how high on the list after the midterms but i mean yemen is part of the conversation now like it has never been before but that also applies to shape the narrative but i do agree that i can congress to push for doing much more than scaling back support with much more than simply the refuelling to see that the narrative is shifting as

well that's why you know this week the saudis to started saying you know we stand with the people of yemen because i'm not sure how that works but i know if i don't i saw that i didn't. think i said something rather snide on facebook i'm going to do not a states pushing to this i know. that they're a terrorist group and. of course we're pushing for a ceasefire so i think because tens of thousands of people were killed in the war and about the millions of children. are in the risk of starvation so they freeze if you go into this huge catastrophe i think this time and the media's focusing on that now i think there is they really need to hopefully to another incident have some kind of momentum or i mention the three topics in my introduction i want to get to the third one oh russia gate where are you big welcome back here mark. i mean we have that now we're going to have a shift in congress where they will go into the g.o.p.'s hand and

investigations into the democrats and the investigations and the d.o.j. and the f.b.i. will probably go away. yeah i mean certainly with the house control what were investigations that were there as far as i'm concerned paul ryan never put enough force behind you know as a counterreaction to you know the political nature of the way you know with the mueller investigation going after metaphor it's back taxes really i mean that's that's what you come up with it's just silly but now you know the democrats will launch you will see a flood of subpoenas they will put as many republicans and figures in the trump administration as possible under oath in the provoke of questions just hoping they say something stupid and law i write however inconsequentially about something you know that has nothing to do with actual russia gate collusion or anything like that you know they'll go into their own personal histories and taxes

and everything like this because this is all about you know the house version of mark raking so subpoenas hearings investigations into trump's sexual peccadilloes however far in the past into his taxes into giving jerry security clearance and a position. the miller investigation was small but i think a blood sport out there if you look at public opinion polls before the midterms russia gate doesn't rate as seeing very important with the public it is with the democrats of course and with the liberal media it didn't pay the many divisions i think in the election they're still going to do it. no but now you're correct they are going to push it part of the response to democrats through haven't really come up with a clear political message in terms of what's wrong with the country and how do we move forward so instead they go yeah well they say that trump is narcissistic and all the talk about himself but the democrats they will do the same do only talk

about trump so that they really get going and so when do they took the house was the first message is a came out always should get trump's tax hasn't we should. we shouldn't teach trump like all of this is offensive because it will go through the republican controlled senate but nonetheless if you think the job in the race goes by so fast gentlemen we're running out of time many thanks to my guest here in moscow this is the end of our broadcast segment stay with us for the extended version on our you tube channel see you next time and remember.

that all russian gay hoax never got any tracked. then no prob but it's great troll bait and i think trump is pleased that he increased seats in the senate and he'll get barking mad nancy pelosi hitting the russia gate hoax button every single day which will drive ratings for rachel maddow but it will do nothing to help them win twenty four. join me every thursday on the alex sullivan show and i'll be speaking to guest of the world of politics this i'm show business i'll see you then.