offering jumps on to the scene in 2017 and i'm going to start with the initial coin offering that i see 0 story because this was a huge story and 2017 more than 5600000000 dollars of capital was raised in 2017 according to measure x. from token data team this compares to $1000000000.00 of traditional venture investing in block chain startups in the same time frame and in a mere 200 $40000000.00 raised by token sales in 2016. guys are this is the report i'm preparing my initial point offering of the i.c.a.o. for the new crypto sensation merchants fischer matic you know so many bankers are jumping off buildings and jumping off beers of the fia world of being crushed by crypto so of merchants fisherman dick you can fish with these dead bankers are. dead big i say you know if it will probably raise $150.00 or $250000000.00 for the station i'm giving you

a pretty icy you know coins 89 percent discount when you think why 89 percent oh i have to share some of brock and this is the deal he negotiated with so let's compare this to the traditional financial system you had i.p.o.'s which were initial public offerings those were usually the way for a venture capitalist to exit their investment in a dot com company here you were having it all in one the investors i donators to these projects were giving money to the founders and that was the founders exit here you had a situation whereby the people donating to these icy o's were giving the money to these founders before any product had been built it was just a white paper right so the time lines almost up here because usually people start companies and 8 or 9 out of 10 fail but they do have friends and family round they do some money raising and they typically look. ford 8 or 9 years down the road

before they do initial public offering and that's after they've attracted one or 2 rounds of venture capital and then the venture capital is exiting on the i.p.o. in the public market is participating in this new company and then it has a a life post i.p.o. and will it be the next microsoft or the next apple it takes 102030 years for this all the play out where is on the i.c.l. you had the formation the creation the the organization the exit and the monetization all happening with one event it's just here's the idea let's exit. on average they returned $12.00 x. the initial investment in dollar terms $7.00 x. in 8th and $4.00 point terms so they were massive successes and 2017 everybody involved all of those who were donating to the projects all those who

were hosting these projects doing the i c o's everybody 10 down shows gave birth to this concept of the x. return you know to put this into perspective during the dot com mania it was considered to be unbelievable a windfall then if you got 607080 percent pop on day one of your i.p.o. here you're talking about 10 x. that's 10 times the initial or 20 x. or 30 x. so the idea of this x. that you know an investment in these i.c.'s would generate x returns you know multiples of return and you know that is became normalized which was fascinating this is the beginning of hysteria people all over the world hear stories of south koreans just cashing in all their pensions their mortgages buying up all sorts of i.c.'s 2000 coins like there is an eruption of coins in 2017 there were 400.

35 projects. all at the end of the day it's what what's the point of this token and have all these different tokens of do different things and at the end of the day you know the value is what we all agree on most of these new tokens they're not really meant to be stories of when it was meant to be anything in fact one of them like ios it says right there on the main website this token has no value this token is not a security token does not access our website is talking is literally for us to raise funds from you and that's it right so you're referring to a paragraph in the. description that says quite plainly this what you're buying here gives you no rights no equity it's worth nothing there's no guarantee it'll ever have any value the purpose of this disclaimer is to make them exempt from all securities laws they hope so but people buy into it anyway because it's a wink and a nod they say i know you have to put that in because you're trying to bypass the existing quacks like a duck if it acts like a duck it's probably

a duck i've spent many awoken nights pondering the scientific situation of the i.c.a.o. and i've come up with what i call is the scientific word to use. fear of missing out but that's all this is is you tell your friends do you buy this token everyone's buying i have tokens that people rescue me that haven't even gone on sale yet they're still in pre-sale and they're not even transferable trading so let one sell $0.25 and then they then they pre-sell change the price to a dollar and all these people who want $0.25 are now selling it at 75 cents and what are they trading they're trading nothing how many angels can fit on the head of a pin so here you have every single element of finance the exchanges the marketeers the business people the venture people all existing in a one space that didn't exist the head of a pen and they exploded and cashed in for billions but none of those things existed they were merely a shadow of those things the shadow of actual finance existed. in an ephemeral

serial i.c.a.o. representing nothing but had an exit and there was about a 18 month period when these things were all the rage in crypto are they securities or were the tokens themselves securities or investment contracts probably mostly gifts and if you listen to what the f.c.c. has said if you would be enforcement activity in the space you reached that conclusion as well oh yes well to get around all regulations they position these initial point offerings as diffs you were giving the company and to say that they weren't securities i want to get around security laws but the people that were giving the gift of the their cash to these companies are getting us in exchange. for their surprise when the company decided that they would just accept the gift of their money and run away. so maxwell everybody's attention was diverted to these initial coin offerings and these hundreds of tokens being issued the block size civil war was still ongoing and it

was coming to a head in may of 2017 was consensus consensus is a conference a big conference cryptocurrency conference by that point which is very expensive to attend and it's sponsored by many big sort of corporations and at this event in may 2017 happened the new york agreement barry silbert of the digital currency group one of the very early adopters of big coin created this agreement called the big queen scaling agreement that consensus 2017 and what they decided that they would implement said it and double the block size from one megabyte to 2 megabytes so 2 x. what happened is that once this document the new york agreement and the 58 signatories was released the users of big queen they were very upset to hear that yet another agreement behind closed doors. as had happened and basically the

hackney morris erupted the hat no to x. you ask after the u.s.s.r. the user activated saw fork so this is something that occurred a few years ago as part of the scaling debate where due to frustration of how difficult it is to change the rules in bitcoin some people started looking around and trying to 5 and i would say centers of power and one of those centers of power or at least things that appears to be powerful and equate is the miners so there were various groups that were coming together trying to rally political support from mining pools and large hash rate providers and basically getting them to signal the you know they were going to change the bit corn protocol of a certain way and the threat of course being that anyone who disagreed with with

those rule changes were going to find themselves on a block chain for that essentially had no mining activity no new blocks therefore no new transactions and it was basically useless but the u.s.'s movement came about and basically said you know what we don't believe that the miners have the power that they believe they have yes they have hash power but the hash power while you can spend millions of dollars. brute forcing this cryptographic equation to create a new block and put it out on to the network. that all of that energy expenditure all of those capital resources cannot force a $10.00 raspberry pi running on the network to accept that block. that you know 5 watt a tiny little computer is running its own rules and will look at that block and say you know what you're broke. rules i reject it i don't care how much money is spent

on it and the work that miners do does not have bally you because they did the work any more than digging a hole has value just because they cost a bunch of calories to dig it you have to dig holes where people find it valuable you have to do work that people find it valuable with crypto currencies and so the user activated software merely changed what the hardware is of last resort decided to value in terms of the work that the miners were doing and so this put a huge asymmetric leverage in favor of the people running the 4 nodes and greatly decreased the the apparent power that the miners have because the miners can go mine as many blocks as they want but if nobody is going to give them a block reward that's valuable for doing that work well you just burned a bunch of electricity from that standpoint the belief was that in fact the users

in aggregate the people running these nodes they get to decide whether or not to accept the blocks from the miners in fact have more power than the miners so as a result we had a bunch of people create this us fork of bitcoin core which basically said you know what we're drawing the line in the say and on this date we're going to start activating these features and if you're blocks don't activate the features we're going to reject your blocks and you're not going to get paid any more.

there's. the. because the swarm see the blood of them so moving. to build your school local was before. much of those who heard it's a preview are mostly other movies to see him with the north we will. move the bulk move but it. will show you that look beautiful livable i mean it's going to look for a good. movie just like most of these girls will give you films for good girls. to go to shows a look but look at your simu belonging to show the story to go. to startups

to. get to meet until it was a little missed they'd say look it is it's. just testing understand statistics not it's a mash told. to stop the president and please introduce more students. as we have petitions to post this for to snap them up and do it because that is the cousin with you swear your supporters to your shoes they sure sure mr you should cook door for the one who's do you do the request for. so 2017 was the resolution of the block size war the users of

bitcoin determine the outcome of bitcoin it wasn't the powerful miners it wasn't the billionaires they introduced 148 and these are activated saw for aug 1st there was a soft fork to basically save at the same time there was also a hard for that happened on august 1st 2017 and that was to be cash or bitcoin cash and you know it's for us is a big cash because the founders of big cash don't like that word but that was the forte remember the day before everybody was hanging on the edge of the seat that this is going to be a hard fork to bitcoin cash and there's going to be these are activated off or will bit coins survive nobody knew for sure and it survived by the end of the day august 1st it was still around it was still there and then it set the stage for the 2nd half of the year and what we actually did was we issued this user activated software this ability to you with our own full nodes decide what big question is

for us because no because it is the centralized because it could be many things to many people but you the individual have the ability to decide what is for you by running the big software and enforcing the rules that you believe to be big and so that is what we did as a people as a as a community millions of people across the world we ran the user activated software which was the version of big win that we believed to be the real big and so that of course might have caused a chain split and that end up scaring some of the some of the larger corporations some of the larger mining companies they didn't want to see change split so they essentially backed off and it was a very public loss and a very public win for the for the community this really something that was what i calls completely unprecedented this was really the. you know type of battle that we saw here and at the end of the day it was the users of the was the community that once again. these large large corporations and so this was a defining moment for

a big coin because it's set up very adversarial really the position between certain users in the minors and the minors at the end of the day seemed to relent pretty quickly and this is because the economics and the game theory basseley support the individual or the hardware to be in the minors there they actually have a very weak position in terms of the game theory big question is just a fascinating social and economic experiment in this regard. of course brings us to the scaling debate so where are we in this in this area this better breakthrough some argue it's not as clean cut as others suggest where are we on the scaling debate going charlie i'm a free market person i believe that markets are markets are efficient when we allow them to be put off of their own it's not going to be as fast as human beings we

want it to be we want instant right if we want things done now so yes the scaling debate to 2 years however how many bad solutions came and went how many how many things happened that kind of a threat why was there a need for scale scaling nay what is it because it is a big one is growing and because it is growing to a point where we need the ability to have more transactions when it's arrival the visa or master card network when it's arrival swift we need to scale the right way the other side the client says now that's not really you get to keep it as a store of value and you know you're done ok around you even the store value folks think that we need to scale but they think that it's to be scaled in a different way so here we have a market created compromise and as we saw there day it passed with over 90 percent consensus what if we seen any you know senator congress. i have been able to do something with 90 percent consensus it's almost never this took a long time yes but it takes a while to get

a perfect market solution i think this is one of the most bullish things that ever happens of course what if some bad actor came along with 500000000000 dollars and said hey i want to change pick one to suit my needs a lot of money you could influence a lot of people but as we saw a lot of people start doing that craig right all these different companies and an unlimited only they tried to influence because of their own way but the market didn't allow them to do it and the market created the protocol horizon it passed everyone got together and that's what i see here is like this was this was like a perfect governance this well is the notion is that it isn't just game theory succeeding it's game theory will always succeed in the end and it's perfect market clearly did ask equilibrium in this case was the current iteration yeah this is a little silly that's why i have always felt that if you just think this is a giant game theory experiment it'll ols work out fine that's what it is you don't need to get too deep into the tech debate as such i've said it on your show a 1000000 times big coin is one of the largest social economic experiments we've

ever had in the history of the world and this is not solidifies that argument this is if anything if peter schiff can say the corner is now no value blah blah blah but there is a huge value and begin to study one of the largest social economic experiments and the history of humankind. obituary $180.00 jamie diamond says if you're stupid enough to buy fish oil you'll pay the price well yeah $100000.00 a coin so all the headlines leading up to august 1st when we had a soft fork am a hard fork all the headlines were again that was dead because he was dying would not survive august 1st we were on the edge of our sea everybody was on the edge of the sea waiting to see what happened basically it was like y2k it all survived we survived everything was ok and from there we saw. of course from august 1st till the end of december we saw an epic parabolic move in big queen and it went up to

$19000.00 by the end of the year that is correct once released from this controversy the price started a. hyperbolic move north toward this 20000 price and i remember being quoted in the press that you know once we got past segue that this really opened the doors out to a new era scaling promise that would be coming is looks like it's going to happen and money started to flow into because of an accelerated pace cash went on its own separate way between stayed as users wanted it into this mix came basically chicago it wasn't wall street it was chicago and the options and derivatives. we are recording this quite a few hours before the futures markets opened in chicago. has become

a huge massive international story everybody's hearing about it we're getting a lot of tweets and a lot of e-mails asking how to buy it how to buy it people are panic buying and you're certainly seeing that i saw a chart of buys versus hold and it's all buy is no selling there's nobody selling so you're seeing quite a basically a melt up and then rollercoaster down in those very volatile you we're going to see a lot of volatility in back home prices as these futures markets unfold there's going to be multiple futures contracts multiple banks all these banks are getting into it it'll create a bigger pipe for more money to flow into bit klein right now the pipe is about like this is a relatively miniscule market compared to the bond futures currency futures stock futures you know 5 trillion dollars worth of forex per day is the market because in that arena. as a pipsqueak by expanding these contracts futures contracts derivatives are bringing wall street chicago into the mix you're taking that small straw which is an on ramp

for fear into bitcoin and you're making it massively bigger futures markets are very important they were developed for commodity markets for farmers agricultural sector and they needed a way to hedge their costs because their shoots cost the planting of a field of corn and you wouldn't know for a month or not whether or not it would be hit with blight or bad weather awful stuff so you need to protect and see lock in your your profits your the costs of doing business but in terms of this futures contract it settles not in corn or wheat or bitcoin the commodity it settles in paper all derivatives even though they may be leveraged 80210021 they're still referencing an underlying commodity that's held somewhere in custody if you remove the custody layer then everything built on top of it becomes instantly worthless the big coin market you do have now the hollers of last resort as they're called they have within their abilities to do

battle with the naked short sellers in the and the futures markets in a way that would restore price integrity in and i think that going forward that would become an issue. the price suppression schemes to petition encourages collusion and a decline in protocol it's almost game theory yeah and the game theory that has defeated a lot of players to co-opt the mining industry in particular has. prevailed so these guys who are used to getting the easy collusion in the precious metals markets they might risk 10 or 15 percent of their capital if they get it wrong on this market they get they could get right that's exactly right that's exactly the point the financial industry controls the base collateral in the gold market through through. goal of all systems but they don't control the base collateral in the big one market it's the last resort who control go out early that is where you

don't risk. 15 percent it's several 100 it's losing it all right absolutely deeply into debt and it's a war it's a standoff between those a listers or yes. that's right. december 11th 2017 big queen futures begin trading on the c b o e n chicago the price of between jumped by over $1000.00 and the 1st few minutes of trading which was part of the epic bowl ran from under $2000.00 in august to nearly $20000.00 by the end of december on december 11th you have the c b o e then on december 18th you have the sea launched their futures contract now many in the world community the likes of jim rickards were saying once this big question futures happen then you're going to see the epic paper shorts you can see the crash of bitcoin and to be fair on december 18th that was the all time high of bitcoin and thus began the descent of

bitcoin from that price well as we were saying about life master she came in. at the behest of wall street to try to financial eyes because to separate the blash a from the because i'm and to try to destabilize because and because overcame that attack now we have another assault on wall street this is the futures contract that's another attempt for wall street to get in there and try to undermine bitcoin to try to financial eyes and to bring in concepts like react off occasion and other ways that water uses to control price and manipulate price and this is coincidental with the top in the market and the ability to sell contracts that were in excess of what the market was actually showing was the appetite for these orders. drove the price down one could argue you need a lot of demand to fill these paper shorts these counterfeit shorts and that demand

was being fueled in large part by a mania that was seemed to be unsustainable and was undergoing a bubble so we start 2017 bitcoin $1000.00 we have over the course of 2017 the block size war ends and the winners are the users . august 1st happens we see the user activate a saw fork and we see it the hard for to bitcoin cash the bad actors in the big space basically split off into this hard fort that sets in motion an epic run a parabolic run in the and the price of bitcoin we and 2017 with an all time high and because over 900000 hundreds of billions of dollars of market cap that sort of conversation that you and barry silbert had had when it was a mere $6000000000.00 a market cap had come true and wall street the futures markets the derivatives

market which is a quadrillions of dollars market enters this space december 27th not way out of the air pushing 840000000000 almost a trillion in market cap and common was we're having to 5 trillion will see how that works. you know to go 27 seen the german newspaper developed published an article pleading that the european union would last 30000000000 euros as a result of its very. particularly

affected eastern europe many polish film as went broke and even committed suicide. sometimes i can't account for as i was of on a good time i'm a political animal will put on the political and on the. phone does it for the young victim to have to find out why the on the whole saga going to get stuck doesn't on the kind of unknown police think it doesn't then let's see in the in the pool in this if one song the smith position log. on doesn't dance with all the folks enough has become. you know world a big part of the new lot and conspiracy it's time to wake up to dig deeper to hit the stories that mainstream media refuses to tell more than ever we

need to be smarter we need to stop slamming the door on the back and shouting past each other it's time for critical thinking it's time to fight for the middle for the troops the time is now for watching closely watching the hawks. toyota to get up off the ground to serve begin to. get your game face on the sounds of men and maybe the grown man that mislead us into the. turn. which did away from the office or the joy of his crew. they obviously did a kind of lunge for the web in one smiths and they would have been done treece one . i never saw any contact with. any kind of went back to where they were

back here again 15 feet apart at this point. among the stories that shaped the week of the russian and chinese president speak his attempt to dominate international trade they were in russia's northern cal but petersburg biggest events. taking cover and while the u.s. had spent with new sanctions a leaked recording suggests washington is feeling between you know the country's opposition against president maduro. just to keep the opposition.