lose you lose could you could shoot that to the lower the, with the injecting pressure to inoculate against it. government and companies around the globe are showing controversial ads that claim vaccines the key to re gaining freedoms. but put it aside, down the middle debate, the issue you're going to create a society. they just choose not to have it. they're creating their own apartheid needs. should be happy to say it, but if solely that it is not working, if there is 11 work that can explain it. great. meanwhile, the world health organization slams wealthy states for the global vaccine disparity in our producers to increase supplies to developing nation. it comes if you regulate to still hasn't recruit the asters and show that they're made in india,

and us approvals for oil and gas drilling on to joe biden skyrocket to the highest . who's george w bush was in office, despite the current president pledge to go green. ah, good evening. just gone 10 here in moscow. you watching archie international, ludicrous. that's how a british rule maker has slammed an advertisement by a top big company. that suggests vaccination is the only way to get life back to normal. although there's been a low uptake of shots by values on the 30 politicians to warn that heineken commercial gives the wrong message. the

heineken really ought to consider whether discriminating in loyal customers who may be, cannot be vaccinated for medical or other reasons. there are lots of people who can't be vaccinated and it's quite wrong that they should not be able to go into a pub and have a drink, ludicrous. i'm surprised to not making recommendations and other countries given their levels of vaccine hesitancy. while the ad does come after british ministers reportedly drew up plans for mander free vaccine passports to enter pubs or restaurants from the autumn, a mass despite what is presented, is a hugely successful inoculation program with almost 35000000 already having received a shot in the u k, but britain is far from the only country where pro vaccine pressure is in full force and some have apparently gone too far.

but what you just saw there was no stray leon add. that has been criticized for scare tactics and for using an act through an age group that is not yet eligible for the vaccine. on top of that, the pace of inoculation is in the country is slow in part due to shortages of doses, something that critics things say makes these campaigns even less appropriate. we put the issue up for debate. real worry for me about this is you're going to create i to take society that will be those people who call to have a vaccine for medical reasons or maybe for their own reasons, or maybe because they younger and they haven't seen invite yet. there is therefore going to be a to, to is this is say it is no going to create to, to the system. that's absolute. poppycock, people who can't have it for medical reasons can have a medical exemption. but if they just choose not to have it, they are creating their own apartheid. they have a duty, particularly young people now to do their bids for the rest of society.

those who need the backseat and so you should be label are generally around the room numbers for population who have been medically advised. actually she doesn't actually work, they don't stall transmission. i'm just putting that blurry. i suggest you check the world war on very i suggest you stop spreading misinformation and face new jersey. you get behind this. there is a very big question over whether young people should have this vaccine at all. and the reason for that is actually most young people will get cobit that recover, they'll be no long time sequentially. and this is about personal choice. and responsibility wants to do all these 3 things. they could go over and have a reprimand that young people have a duty. they should get vaccination as well. no one's talking about coercion. no

one's talking about monday, treat jobs, but young people want to have fallen out to life. it's coming anyway. actually, we should be encouraging those people certainly over 40 to make sure they have a vaccine. i would like younger people to have it as well. but i do believe in personal choice and liberty, we don't believe in compulsory vaccination, but what we do need to do is get brittany back on track. meanwhile, across franz, there have been protests against anti co, with restrictions with riot police foreign t gas at the steel de rallies in paris. the flooding on the street, on the national day celebration rises hole stones officers not of rubbish, containers nor among fire cities across the country of also seen similar marches too. from next month, the facts in powerful will be required to enter a restaurant, shopping malls, trains, and plains in france,

and it will be obligatory for all citizens over 12 years old. meanwhile, health work is have been wont to that they may not get paid if they don't get in ok lated business own is to let in those that passes the face fines and the year in jail. and with regard to vaccines, rich countries are acting in pure greed, the warning from the world health organization. as it ask, maxine produces to ramp up supplies to developing states, many of which have still to receive a single dose. the more contagious delta variant tightens its grip. sorry to say it, but if solely that it is not working, if there is 11 word that can explain it, it's great. what we like is, and we have said it many times from w jo. the global leadership do like what, as far as any guys doing astrazeneca started in europe, has production in india. and if all the vaccines could do that,

the volume could increase. meanwhile, despite mass production of the asters and nica shot, the vaccine has still not being given the green light and the you with the blocks regulators. they're still not approving supplies of the job that were made in india . peter oliver has more than the story. you may think that all vaccines that have been given the green light by the world health organization and all the major bodies would be treated the same around europe. however, if you will, getting an astrazeneca vaccine, it may be worth while checking where it was manufactured. because if it was one of those that is being produced in india, it may not comb with the benefits you think it does know some european states including france and so they say they won't accept travelers who have been vaccinated with astrazeneca doses manufactured in india as it stands, it depends on the way you want to go in year if whether or not your indian manufactured vaccine will be accepted for entry here in germany,

along with 14 other countries in europe. you're good to go anywhere else, including france, italy, denmark, at a rust of all the human to states. you face being turned away. that's despite the job being backed by the w. a joke, and the vaccination given as part of the un kovacs program. you have to remember that during different demik, our challenges was to persuade the nation to accept that we are all in this together. those recent policies could negatively impact these campaign. people who are already suspicious of vaccines who become even more suspicious. they could also lose trusting public health messages from the government and be less willing to comply with corporate rules by not accepting vaccinations approved by the world health organization. the un health authority says these nations may well be putting global vaccination programs at risk. such moves are already on the mining confidence in life saving vaccines that have already been shown to be safe and

effective. effective uptake of factors and potentially putting billions of people at risk health expert struggling to find the logic in some countries, refusal to accept jobs made in india. you can just cut off countries from the rest of the world indefinitely to exclude some people from certain countries because of the vaccine they received is wholly inconsistent. because we know that these approved vaccines are extremely protective. cloth presented care of said that they've now submitted the paperwork to the european medicine's agency for their production facility in india. but one 4th coming on why taking so long. as it stands, it falls to individual countries, which vaccines. they will accept for entry in which ones they want, but how people meant to know which ones will be accepted, where and whether the job they got thinking it would bring them a little more freedom will do just that. the difference in the book senior accepted by the members state were great confusion amongst travelers. confusion leads to

decision paralysis, not traveling to summer, which might adversely affect the travel and tourism industry. confusion is also unpleasant. emotional experience. our publishers messaging should be precise to the point. instead, what we have is the biggest situation where even though the 2 astrazeneca vaccines are exactly the same, the one producing india must being peter people in for, they should actually not even mention the difference between the vaccines. and i say the evidence that the vaccines producing other countries inferior, which i doubt exists the situation would undermine vaccine confidence by appearing to label some shots substandard european union should not create a 2nd rate countries. and 2nd rate travelers, which is really dangerous to watch kelly. but also politically there's been another crim discovery in canada. her further $160.00 unmarked graves have been

found at a former school for indigenous children after over a 1000 were discovered in recent months. it is reminder of adult chapter in canada is passed when native people were forcibly integrated into society and according to an indigenous rights activist. this is just the tip of the iceberg. of course, this is devastating. there's a tremendous amount of grief in our communities already. and they're going to be more we have there's definitely going to be more down here in the space as well. the residential schools were all over canada all over the space. so are people are going through a lot right now. it's still heartbreaking. and i feel like i'm coming to where i'm just now right now, like i'm just now, i'm not since a group of unmarked graves were discovered in may, there has been

a rage across the country. catholic church is have been attacked and several of a human being burned to the ground. moreover, on canada day in early july statues, victoria and clean elizabeth, kansas topples lie cried. chancing no pride in genocide, canada's prime minister is committed to fighting discrimination. and racism is difficult in moments like these to fully comprehend the decisions of the past that led to these tragedies and atrocities. but it is necessary to absorb them and understand them to be able to move forward or residential schools were tasked with forcibly assimilating native children into white culture. they were made to abandon their language and also traditions. and many were

physically and even sexually abused over all more than $4000.00 or 9 to have died while confined to such institutions rally williams again says it is wrong to actually call these places schools. what's been going on right now? you know, when they're calling and residential schools, i really don't like the terms falls because the education wasn't they were educating us there. they were when trying to form, i sent a white people. and i have so many examples of how genocide is still happening to us to the may you know, the governments, how these policy plays, that don't work with us. even with the recommendations from all these inquiry, there are so many wires that have happened. none of them, none of the recommendations are taken seriously or are implemented back to work

with us that can help us. and then you know, when the media, the media is slowly coming on board with us. but, you know, like for everything a murder, indigenous women and girls, they label us in the media as sex workers, drug addicts, runaways drunks. you know, so that doesn't help us as well. so there's a lot of things to get done with the police, not taking reports seriously. and predators know that they could target us. and people in general know that they could target us. and so the janice not is still happening. you're watching out international. we're going to take a quick break. we'll be back with more stories fee in 2 minutes. the ah

ah ah, i use remember the great 964 bill dr. strange love. you remember the subtitle of the film was how i learned to stop worrying and love the bomb. well, i have a 2021 updated subtitle. when it comes to the surveillance state, how i learned to stop worrying and love be in. tell community folks today or not

feared their doors ah, so come back he without international my race. his trolls will be banned from football. my cheese, the british prime minister, has warned to offer a wave of online abuse of black england plays taurus jones and nodded to take joints must face big fines to to the condemn. and of all the races that horace that we saw on sunday night, there is a chance not to hold these internet companies to account and to make sure that they face fines running to 10 percent of their global income. if they fail to take hate and racism, accept all 3 black football and we're head for the garage of rice, his comments on social media after missing penalties in the year 2020 final on

sunday, which is the one now position politicians to say that johnson himself has failed to protect the place. the prime minister has previously done no more than turn a blind eye to racism against our players were words and gigantic england. flags are no substitute for using the power he has to make it stop. okay, well we can talk about this further. i would nice panel joining us. we have bill new technology expert and privacy activist alongside him at his cash more. he was a so she did you professor at aston university and then also there on the far right market gassett. she was an international affairs commentator and you are all very welcome as usual, marco, if i could start with you the government, they're saying look, it's going to hand that stadium bands and also fine tech companies. what do you make of the government responds to what happened to the england players?

well, i think it's being pushed into this response by the strength of the response to the response as it were basically the government has to cover itself. but the real question is, what perhaps should be done in this situation, perhaps where over again the putting here because we have a situation where yesterday's heroes in the following sense, are at least temporarily being criticizes. today's zeros, but not necessarily even by majority of people. if i buy minority people, certainly in this country, possibly some of the majority of over coal is abroad. so the question is whether these kind of measures are appropriate at all in terms of u. k. legislation given the implications of such measures in terms of restricting all the aspects of freedom of speech, which we would rather like to protect. so this could be the fin until the wage where we find some issue where we all agree, where we all hate races and so on. and we say right, let's allow bands to take place before we know it bands become normal and bands

become extended. and we really want to see the, the principal who wishes count country was founded of freedom of speech, just jettisoned that way and so easily. and if that's bring you in here, you feel is been an overreaction by the government because, you know, surely they have to do something. you've got england plays, they've been racially abused online. it's very clear the emoji. the banana is among case everything that should be unacceptable. the government surely has to do something. well, it's an opportunity for the government. johnson in particular, to win some favor, because it can now be justifiably seen, is doing something. however few to all that may be, i don't think you'll get very far with the likes of facebook and twitter. but it's a gesture and you have to make that kind of gesture at a moment. at this point, i'd like to make go, andrew, is that we're all talking of the past 48 hours about football, racism. we don't know who these people are. her spreading this racist stuff

all around through means of various conduit, social media for all we know they might hate football, they have no interest in sport whatsoever. but the using football. ready ready as a convenient platform for the expression of their vile views. so we shouldn't make the assumption, 1st of all, this is a football phenomenon. they using football. now, how johnson will attack that, i don't know. he like everybody else is assuming that the people are doing it a football fan and he's going to the likes of facebook and saying, the buck stops with you. you have to do something about it. i can't seem practical terms. what they actually can do. this is a question of killing the messenger, so to speak, but i'm sure you're going to hear some answers about what impractical terms they could possibly do. okay, well let's get that on them cuz i can see bill readying himself that bill. what exactly can these tech companies do in terms of, you know,

launching algorithms to stop racist abuse? is it really that easy for an algorithm to pick up something that is racist? i mean, the human can read it and understand, perhaps the tone of the comments and what it actually means. but could have a computer actually do that? well, we have talking about social media fell cells on the accuracy of their toll. the thing of for the, the clients that they have, if they couldn't detect racism, were they even a fraction of this procedure accuracy. then it should be very easy to identify the vast majority of those who are talking racial abuse. it's not being potentially subtle in the way that they do it. many of them are being really quite blatant for talking about bands, as we've seen with the president and the president of the united states would be one step in that direction. but many of the social channels you read the rules and

should be enforcing them. it's also the case being racist, jeering and behavior football matches and online throughout the season. it's not just in the last week or 2 with the penalty shoots out in the england of the euros that this has started. and again, there are sanctions that couldn't being adopted all the way through the season. i think mr. johnson is somewhat reacting on the put to a lot of pressure and having done the voicemail before that. yeah, just to point out, it's made he saying that we still don't know who these people are as well. that have made these comments. i mean, it's not something that tech john should be able to find it easily. or is it actually very easy to setup an account? it's anonymous and nobody would ever know whether it's you this tweeted it or not. well, we can identify exactly which account cities that are doing with them bonding,

those accounts, even on a temporary basis. it's relatively straightforward. and there are already rules in place with most of the social media networks to do exactly this. i would question the degree to which they are enforcing their own rules. however, when it comes to watch the identifying the ways behind these this is i didn't try to go situation. i mean, what we face is a level of abuse bouldering on a terminology and also troy criminal ransomware and other things across the internet which will in a pull position to police because it's very difficult to track the criminal. okay, yeah, marco, do you think that the british government has a credibility issue here given what the british prime minister has said about muslims in the past comparing them to let both sees comments? we've heard from the, from the home secretary to about just the politics in, in sport, when plays, we're taking them they, there's been

a huge backlash against the government. a lot of people saying, look, you know, look at your own records, do you feel? do you think they're suffering here from the past factions? while they got boring, the journalist and boris of prime minister journalists exercise journalistic license to produce compelling images for the time in which they write the world who owns in the rotors. and so he's in a different job with different responsibilities. and he's showing that he wants to be equal to the new talks. he's got as full, pretty patel of you on the taking the the, i mean this really gets the novel, the massa taking the, the means different things to different people. so some of the many, perhaps the most, it's a sign of the battle against racism for equality and to be commended for others perhaps, might notice that the original, well the press, the kickstart in 2016, but american fool who said he couldn't really stand for the flag on nation,

the oppressed, black people. so in a sense the flag sort of being the focus of unity becomes the focus of the vision in that moments. and perhaps there are other ways of expressing positions or racism . perhaps that could be another symbol. perhaps they could be all the way to doing it in the middle of a long battle against a centuries or thousands if my linear old enemy, and it's not gonna be one in a day success rate, the battle or the challenge of the baffle against racism. and try and speed run the risk of grades, the accidents why we see the other day. because i seriously wonder if gary southgate felt compelled to have this agenda when he chose his penalty takers. and so he chose, they put people on in the last minute, were not played the game at all and hadn't experienced a dren linda. the whole thing was to them just suddenly experience. and he added to the challenge of winning a trophy after half

a century on behalf of england. he added the challenge of solving the problem of racism in society and the pull of 2 massive shoulders. also the show seen year old boy and a 21 year old. okay. history. i said solve it from. maybe we went through that thought process and the couple minutes of the had certainly set your point the people that earlier. ok, alice, just from your point of, you know, your case for fun. do you think spool can do any more to help itself in solving these problems? racism because we here we hear politicians talk about it, have friends talk about it, your company should be mobile. what about support itself will support itself in the, in the generic sense that as it has a problem of racism, we say to expressions here and there, but not so much in football. you know, it's cleaned up to act in the main. the real problem. i think lies in eastern european hungary, in russia, in ukraine. this is where the stadiums are filling up with phones who feel that

they can get away with anything with impunity. and you isn't ready clamping down on those on those areas. i think in western europe in north america, asia and africa, i think that football doesn't have a problem of racism, which is not to say by the way that got my head stuck in the sand and i'm pretending racism doesn't exist. it does exist in british society, no question about that, but a don't thing. it's particularly prevalent in sports as it seems to be, because this is the media constructive narrative. and a couple just just on that, i mean place to very strongly they have to play every weight. they claim they are getting a job. that's why they're taking the knee. but where they get the abuse from big the needs of social media, not from the cry. press on the coast anyway. yeah. okay. but certainly to your point, just lastly bill coming to you cuz we've only got a couple of minutes left. i just wondered from your position, gee feel is our tech joins the whipping boys often for so can be convenient with

the boys. but that also costs you to blame because they're not enforcing the code of conduct. if they were, there will be a number of people who would be banned, but you can't just point the finger at john vocal in the u. k has football binding orders which it's not using and it's not involving particularly boy you or your wife or could be enforcing rules against some of the, the vocal associations in your which they're not doing. and they're on the white number of different functions that do exist in different situations, very to the sanctions are being used. liquid enforcement. and that was going to be little john. so there's going to want to, okay, the up until we got a couple of minutes left. so let's go back g, mark. i mean from what you've heard there. if the government could do one thing, let's just suggest and you could suggest it to them. what would it be? i think it would be not to throw the baby out with the bath wall. so yes,

tech companies could use a i to police the internet as it were about to produce legislation binding. freedom of speech, i would say the thin and the wages were one thing i wouldn't do. i think it has to stay calm here. this is one moment why we have no reason as any sense, a big this story out. most people are opposed to race is diatribes on the internet . most people don't indulge in them and therefore we should make this problem to something bigger than it is in order to generate media inches less, less will stay calm. congratulate that same on a brilliant performance. soccer played brilliantly rush, but only came up for a while sanction, but they're all good. they're all success story. they're role models that keep them that way and less mexico congratulate the team rather than demonized the country. and it's a difficult situation because we do have very high profile plays to attract a lot of attention, a lot of racial abuse. it's, we've seen that demand action. the question is what action would be prefer? interrupting me, a friend because we're saying there is

a lot of racial abuse we. we don't know full time so they have received well let me, let me qualify. i want to just say because it is a hell of a statement. i know it could be for all we know, a dozen kids who come from the kinds of backgrounds where the bread to be racist told to be racist. encourage to be so. so they grow up with these thoughts in their head, and they want to spend that bile as far as i know, why did they possibly can. so they choose this convenient method of going on. social media suddenly goes borrow and it appears to be a problem of monstrous proportions. it might not be, we simply don't have evidence to prove one way or another. the scale of this problem. what we do know is that in a everyday society, grace has been diminishing. okay, look on that point, we're going to have to wrap it up, but my thank you will

a great discussion. that was bill me, that a technology expert at his cash.