just because it will, you just talked about the night about russia taking a leading role there thing as a crime, which i'll see certainly we should all strive to, ah, min, him to, to, to, to contribute to some, to tackling in ellen's some huge goals. and by 2060, we do aspire to rich carbon neutrality and we're doing a lot to do that. but it looks like a cern and many times recognition that a global, our energy balance. so you can balance is more green, is greener than in many other developers. countries, 86 percent of our energy balance is atom, the unit, nuclear energy sources of which sugar has basically almost early now, early in the c o 2 emissions, we have renewable energy when we get natural gas. 86 percent of the u. s. has on as

only as 77 percent, the germany, germany, it has 64 percent more accurately in other countries. it's even less annoying that aren't we leaders already. and usually when you actually do that, i mean, we understand that's not enough. and that's not enough for russia as well. because in russia, temperatures rising even greater even higher and faster than you know, generally across the rest of the world. and for us, it will have some serious consequences, considering that vast parts of russia lie in digitally, can you see, and it is far north because it, of course we're thinking about that. you know, we're thinking about the quality of life of people. ah, we are looking, we are removing all kinds of landfills that surround pollutant poison people's lives. we are able to move. we're working to address that. you can share your thoughts if coconut no more look at our until

a program he largest industrial centers, we have an entire program which you know, and i plan to address concerns. then overall we are doing well and we have, we have achieved even more if not for the i'm a crisis of 2008 sir. and michelle's biggest, our industry. oh, was complaining that if they started to introduce all those new technologies. although green technology is in many of the companies, many of the interpreter printers, and i'll, we'll just go belly up, you know, and, but now we're going back to, to, for now implementing those plans and full scale. we have some all and go to them like a cities that are a few months, some cities that sir made c o 2 that are treated as priority to reduce c o. 2 emissions. we had them have another. oh, so it's a phil or other priorities as well known with only me as for carbon neutrality

overall, i think about 47 percent of all carbon emissions is being reabsorbed here, which is will you remember when william as though they're being reabsorbed and now she was when we will insist on her emer, that's our capabilities. our capacity to re absorb see were to our old unit overseas. our forests grows around objectively important factor is year. we also, we have huge reserves when it comes to implementing plans in the housing sector in august vision and energy savings. young assertion, a yeast in a chimp in that area. we certainly have works for that needs to be done with lemonade. but overall, 1st the menu simply shouldn't just keep her lawyer mechanically introduce and

implement measures. we need to have actual results in it observing the progression . and that's why we want to have to work her in a transparent manner to reach those results. and i would like to the fight to protect nature like you and to protect us climates good to for in climate, from changing. i want that fight not to become politicized, to become a hidden tool of political prussia that would undermine our trust. in of those are important matters will say mr. quicken lou have for some program or in case of tax o for oscar fundamental issue. well, so far we don't have any infection if you don't see any fundamental decisions, some on transparent decisions that undermine our efforts. i have spoken to some leaders of the world and they are not going to name any names, but they understand that the demands that are being made at the level of european institutions are not transparent. they are not e,

a truly fair and they're able to do. they require some rework. in some rebalancing, i held that this will be done with rushes and other sanitation interests taken into account. sasha, children with you, and you have another letter on here with us. angela from washington. angela angela, please. the floor is yours. angela brussels. it only took us no, thank you. yes, thank you very much. you're there and i'm sorry, i'm only here virtually mister president. i heard you talk about some ways in which the us and russia are working together. and i want to ask you another question about afghanistan. 20 years ago, russia and the united states, they cooperated to defeat our canada and to remove the taliban from power. 20 years later. now, in the aftermath of the american withdrawal,

do you believe that counter terrorist talk ration between russia and the united states is desirable? is it possible? do you think we would still share some of the same goals in visa, the afghanistan that we did 20 years ago? the alumini? sure, a quantity risky, said i believe that counter terrorists corporation between russia in the us as more is not only possible is not only desirable. it is necessary from the garage when neither should go at e. latasha. this has been brought up very often and i am unfortunate that socially we don't have you in our audience with us today. but it's very clear that the threat seo now talked about is becoming less of a threat 3rd today compared to 20 years ago. and he and facts, we see that the threat is expanding. it is a global in the problem and upset tackle it effectively. we need to combine our

reference hauser, lambert, i'm glad you. like us said, the form our special services are in constant contact with each other. i think that we could have a deeper and deeper ties along those lines, but we are grateful to our american counterparts. one for the information for the data they provide that allows us to prevent terrorist acts in russia was from resilience years. let me assure you that we do everything we to and we will always do everything to provide to, to our american colleagues, any information, any data that sir would be relevant to their national interests. and sir, when it comes to preventing terrorist acts, i robinson isn't. is interested in that. mr. president about of gun stomach warner . you know, taliban came to moscow, you know, was an official delegation. and sir, for how long should it be considered? 3rd transition. you are, i see. well, it's not just about a russian,

but as you will know, we were cool with the representatives of the taliban. we invite them to moscow. we are, we're working them in august. and the thing is that these decisions are made of the level of the un hender. we're expecting the people for years and the people who should watch control the situation of dentist and we expect them to proceed with what we can do to, to, to, to mozilla that we choose a or a transfer. that will be a positive one. and sir, they will achieve progress in the country, and once that happens, perhaps they are clean and then they will no longer be branded as a terrorist organization in the international community. but before that happens, or of course, military decisions, usually of culture and need to be made in such a way that we will be able to remove them from the list of terrorist organizations

the same way we added them to the laser. so soon what am i going to have for a professor or not from japan? that bundle? i could have him. yes. please. to see, but pretty damn. yeah, boise chest. the president is much such an honor for me, the grub will meet you here in so cheaply, chantelle, and later still your report was really an interesting for me. that especially about he bought a seal the article in about an acrylic, say the mustard gas and turn in the asia of but anyhow, we'll have the most antagonism was when he would like to know will be the fullest and her near without tried, gobbled to find a new peaceful agreement, but over the to use the media. we'll have 2 different her

prime ministers in japan, the earliest they me to talk. so what is your vision of bilateral relations and term, the prospects of peaceful treaty between russian japan. thank you to know, well, if indeed it was a master. claire, who lives in japan is organized in such a way that i presume changes in the political arena as very other issue of our a quick one answer come often. but the interests of the russian people of the japanese people remain the same. and those interests are also reach of fine, all the settlements between the 2 countries, including assigning a peace treaty laptop and we will work towards that goal. we don't. okay, despite oh, such a quick shifts and the political landscape in japan. oh, just recently, when i spoke to the new prime minister of japan on over the phone,

when and when did he? it is in a very experienced sir. and to vigil. it has been dealing with international affairs and diplomacy for many years. it's diplomat politically, it's a person has very, it was very close to for my medicine are there and i think that we will see continuity in japan or when it comes to japanese position with respect to rush jumpy arbor until the back a when a present harbor was still president, or will you handle a number of alter or joint projects? will you give me like he is going to really bring russia japanese relations to a new level africa. i hope that this work will be continued in the future, and the same vein, or 2 friends, lose tips will show them that is answering our questions for 2 hours trade. so

that's what i propose. she has been optimized, our work will have a bill. it's now rolls. please ask short questions here, gum without any statements. jesse short question and mr. brittany will answer them rapidly back bottles or? well, i will try to suppose the 1st question though to push alston a pulley bill timothy at that is so supportive barbarossa, rob and debbie, her question is about the bundle mc foil. i'll show you now again, the biggest for an agent in russia. i basha passes and the biggest demitra at alicia is that make live, continue socioeconomic transfer books and. and her looks at the level of worship with nations in russia is low. so what's your attitude towards mandates of explanation? you should do or illness exit in, like i said, the full mandatory vaccination thing that i can on lubin we could only have manser

vaccination if. if it is part of the vaccination calendar plaintiff's illusion of summer, lincoln birds, vaccinations go with 19 is not part of the vaccination calendar. that's why it's not mandatory that you see, but the f one. in accordance with the existing regulations and legislation, the regional authorities have the right to introduce. mandatory madsen nation are poor if there is a year or 40, drastic increase in number of cases during an epidemic. sheila, at the recommendation of the doctors and it would only take effect certain groups of people. but recently it's not just about being mandatory are not mandatory. i do not support vaccination being mandatory because any decision that's imposed on you like can be overcome or somehow avoid it. people will just buy certificates on the

black market. what would you know about? i mean, alicia, maybe i could quit zeppelin. i worked some people in the garage, at least 12 levels of have own weston, a shortening. you requested the western shore, but i've actually heard many stories about people from the west coming to russia to be vaccinated with sputnik thee. and they're over there in europe. they buy certificates that they have been vaccinated with pfizer, with the pfizer vaccine. not actual doctors from europe are telling me that there are many reports that sputnik me is more, more reliable, and a safer rank seen. but i'm not just saying that to, to promote sputnik li ah, you, we usually need. yes. and i'm saying that any decision that's imposed on you is are often being one of the mood sudle laws mandating something are often being broken. millions are always thinking about how to proceed in the other to, to,

to overcome those things that are, impose on them and they always win because there are millions of them look to lots of we should always convinced try to convince people that vaccinating is better than going through the disease, it's not just about raw shades concerns, other nations as well. there are 2 scenarios going forward for any individual, either you have the disease or your vaccinate, those yeah. and rescheduled, no, this is she cannot avoid sick. they will be grossman. either you have to choose one scenario. no, it's, you shouldn't be so distrustful of the government of the state and the state on its part as to show by example that it's, it is worthy of being trusted. and i hope that will be successful with that. dispensers ruffled mister such a poor. thank you mister president. my question relates to life when his

son, how you see the and then he can defeat any withdrawal from up on his son in a broader research seek sense, would it change us global positioning? and what would impact on the dairy line, mental forces that you talk about. thank you. be addressed. i just got it. and the 1st thing i want to say is that the president of the united states made the right decision. good was right. and with drawing forces from the, from of gaston on. and when you mom, i think he understood how come he said, maybe he didn't know the details of how that would happen. but he realised that domestically this would be one of the ways one of the lines on the to which she will be attacked domestically. but he took the chance and he still did it. maybe it could have been done better can years men could have been handled their turn. but

no matter it happens and it's still brittany. it's now a fact. so the trust towards the united states, from countries that liked to see the u. s. as an ally to him, if you 222, if you can give me a base their own behavior on the behavior of the us. but this one, i don't think this will lead to any ah critical change. i think that it will not affect the u. s relations with its neighbors. and any critical way, i mean a countries are, can attractiveness to others does not depend solely on that. it's all also always comes down to military might. oh, it's under please. with mr. patina, was she with her william in this statement? 3rd, together with mister sheldon and the 1st and peter book form, you said that her, russian, german relations are excellent. and now it's

a 2nd clear ratings and 3rd choice, or is it possible to get her to ready made there is her book catalog with next? her counselor is there? well, you know, it's not just up to us. if think it is germany, it becomes interested and that we will work along those lines. the st. petersburg dialogue still exists. still there of them we could have contacts between the i community is between the sales side of the countries or it could be and we just need to iron out some, some differences. some problems get a minute, let me share it in. but the upcoming political coalition party coalition in germany is going to be a complicated one. and the various powers comprising the new, the new potential new coalition. i going to be very different, sometimes opposed to each other. but we are ready to, to,

to work towards that. so the next question. thank you mr. president for coming and little leaving from the couldn't see institute responsible state craft. china and other countries have made a move to electric cars. a key part of their action against climate change, water rushes plans in this regard. thank you. was in his ears. couldn't login of nature do i think i've, can you spoken on about that many times. so when the cars move gains in my cities, they are one of the greatest, one of the major polluters households. industries, of course, are also part of the voyage of also polluters. but in globally, let's remind ourselves where does electricity come from to lieu of the booty? let's not delude ourselves. electric cars are

a good thing atmosphere and what about sir, polluting the atmosphere when producing electricity? news? that's not a good thing about you are generating coal, a general electricity using coal in the european countries. when we just heard about germany, it's 2 times as much. it's used to times as much compared to russia, but it's, i think it's 30 percent of something of german germans. energy comes from coal in russia. it's 15 or 16 percent are not brief between usually the threshold. now over all of course electric cars are a good thing, at least on to a country like russia. however, where we have more global reserves, large scale reserves of natural gas, we could actually invest ian fil a gas driven natural gas or driven cause. we need to overall ship the agenda toward greenish, and then we'll have

a results you know, me to put in heavy dra electric car. is there any difference to the well, in novel grove, i used to, i tried to the right i using those cars. i haven't felt much difference that those are good. so effective taurus? yes. you have laura from aggressive of the next question please. mister within the computer system during them and the number of them are from searching and place to the nice to remind you. my question is about history and memory. so we've talked a lot about so the times both soviet countries true. but you might have on the 2nd november it will be 300 years the russian children

and just celebrate religion. 800 years anniversary. look for on the earth. and it made a good the impression on people by through guns to talk about the anniversary of the empire and the truth. if i were shy of this, what we shouldn't be because it's a big part of our history of from them, from the soviet union because russian federation, even though they don't agree in something. and we've addressed you with a letter and we hope that you will take a look at it and maybe it won't be on the 2nd of november, but we will remember that, well, i agree with you, then continue to history some important thing to understand where we're going, i agree with you completely with flea not, not doing enough for me,

and i'm sorry, next event will be associated with your name. you can yourself can please when you're to silver, bruce will be stored. my question is also about history of the year. make his yard her herd of the russian state for many years. and so i suppose you think about your role or russian history examining what are your main achievements and the main a failures as a head of state was that you sent me loom. wow. well, i do not think about my role in history once you start thinking about that, you should stop being positive because it starts interfering with your decisions. i'm be absolutely fit with frank here. a think about thinking, if you start about thinking, well, what would happen if i did that?

so what would happen if i do that, sir? what would the asian write about me in history books once you start thinking that way it's over. you're now longer product if i were to, you know, long, efficient as for me, on a ship that you to what we were able to achieve. we've had, we had 40000000 people living under the poets ally and below the poverty line. now it's just 19000000. it's still a lot, but it's not for to 1000000 the economy as been restructured and sir reinvigorated. much defense industries. issuer, chablis, me, much will push, we leave you with many new canada, we're able to have been restored production chains made. and sir, these schools though, that so try and specialists have also been restored. they were on the verge of collapsing before, but now are there better than ever?

in each part of russia, you really futile. the still charters of it from sleep purchased it from public to a set of russia. and it was to have 9 yellow completely to script and he writes to, to do everything, even print their own money. but they will never said that, written down to be part of the russian federation. now they are, we have overcome all of that. we become more united, we like fight, shall come to rational terrorism. human. let me say something that i often think about. let me say this, quite frankly. yes, we have overcome this very difficult period in the history of our country, especially when it comes to fighting terrorism. look at it in miami, and it's not just some thanks to my of her slot at all. it's just still thanks to the patience and set her valor is of kept an sir, but mostly, and the hard work of the russian beetle. i have seen what russian families,

what suffering they went through, but russia to the, to overcome all of that. there is actually spirituality, this passion or is still my beating heart with the in the russian society. wondering if you had an important part of our society this. this is our spine, the spine of the russian society. ross is still a strong to renew critique. if you don't want to talk about the role in history, let's try another way to shoot it over. everybody's trying to find the image of a future get through until they club is not an exception. and sir, who have some discipline, sir, who tried to find the image of the future when we sampled. i personally thing that we cannot yet when you find you find this image because the world is a terminal to lee. so group, but they have the limits of for future of rush and the world to you would likely to

see what, what are your successors to see muslim nominated should go out a lot for this service actually last year and with regard to that subjects and i i think i have responded to that sir. specific question and various ways across the across the years. i wouldn't want to repeat myself, but her glowing with peter. she wouldn't let me go back to the, the, the main topic, the focus of today's sir discussion club. for instead of the global shake up fan, it was just more than that values and human need you to make music for me, nights on another bus. and the human life. yes, we need to remember that mostly the gland that's is the critical thing. i recalled a garage, i have a home when you, when you're sick is yours was known to were occur, papoulias warren and he has many work sir,

which are still popular not put in his me poke hurry, military nuclear about sir, would you talk to them? brianna? talk with her about the middle ages, spoke a road sir about freedom. i wrote about many things and he always said that at the heart of development, there should always be human human life. that people are always should always be at the center, not government 0. it people and i hope that in the future all the interests of each state will be concentrated on ensuring better life for old people. just how effective we are in establishing such a system is difficult to say at the moment, but it is a grand goal to achieve, to, to work for. let's just a cover some, a few more questions let you know, plus 12, and 3. a thorough which is i think, is this a young person holding a hand overtures pursuing?

thank you very much mr. brittany. my name is sir, is crystal from the high school of economics. you've mentioned to the, the, the not only there with her, the international and terms national come with discrepancies, are causing even worse to the end. was in the chair clear, but they were the see an active wars until you knew i would like to ask, you know, oh well, we don't see in the world because we're health. okay, that's why we're gonna have deb house of that marathon event in saki at the val di discussion club, plenty of the fine minds of elder to be able to chew over there. that certainly a couple of times a year that president putin has. he's kind of open floor opportunities for people, but when they do, boy, is he in for the long haul. started speaking around 10 to 6, and it's now approaching 9 o'clock. so over 3 hours of discussion on various subjects raging from individual flash points around the world to the big global

crises that we're all facing right now. namely, a cove it and of course, the climates and all those came up in various guises during various questions from the assembled floor, various expert politicians, and also industry leaders that are gathered there at the val di discussion club, which is a, a forum of meeting thinkers it's got a prestigious group here in russia, in terms of climate change and controlling the problems there caught it's very difficult for russia as a major oil and gas exporter. but on that president, putin was quite adamant that climate change is so evident. it cannot be denied, but on top of that fossil fuel extraction does need to continue the world gotta be powered somehow, but answering a question about that it was about the arctic, but said that we should be listening to the scientists and the science behind using fossil fuels going forward, but that her at the moment it's western politicians who are making those decisions instead and with the cop 26 climate psycho.