today the office is represented by maxine out to re so please your question. thank you maria harbor. good afternoon. good afternoon, mr. ro for lee. they multi me, then everybody is interested in many things. but unfortunately, we do not have much time. and my question is about iran, the rest continues to name iran for continuing escalation, which they believe will result to the collaborative negotiations on the the t, ron says that the engage in decent formation instead of serious negotiations . what is the russian position? what should be done to make the negotiation to success? yes, unfortunately, our wisdom bosses continue to bend the truth the like. and the answer

that i have given nature is approaching our borders. and it blames the russia for the escalation of the tensions because it has forces on the border. the same is true here. trump's administration, some level. so with 3 from through all the agreements including you and the resolution that the doctor, they disappear, i do i itself and iran is the guilty one. but actually for moving around has not taken any steps that would run counter to be a allegations and a so as soon as it became clear to me was the decision was on the big us and clear wrong. starting the look at the iran assumed responsibility on that h spillway, indifferent man,

and im cylinders, door aid to willy abuses you press. pam did of the implementation. only all the volunteer relates were bad taken obligations away with different each they saw that they launched to, ah, more woodside, technologically advanced to centrifuges at home and decided that as soon as the united states, so my returns to the on the ring, its commitments, seth iran, will follow and it is actually on the basis of negotiations are going on in vienna yoga between april and june. they will, 6 was grounds of negotiations said mm hm. and did you, this is iran and the united states. it did not, it won't get down to bonnie ocean on the table. there was a group of col. denita said you're from mom's, we go to go to the european. nicholas is telephone services from russia. moved side germany, china moved woo, upgrade britain and france. and as

a result of 6 arrived and said, well, we got labeled cockhead shirt with flat out of documents that allowed us to understand that we would come to town as finally was. and there was a, a, was melissa on duty, new government being formed in iran and our west nicole, they exactly roost were a bit hasty, used the linear, i've got multiple studies. she was the urge durante, do everything as soon as possible, but we reminded them that ron waited for more than a year for americans to versus to coming back to that understanding them with susie and then when they view to which it is new, i understood it wouldn't happen, school, they come back to will what they wanted to do. but i would like to say that to iran has a new team and there is new leadership in the realm of an day when your church pad,

they dropped a proposal. so i that to the best in the colleagues, it didn't like in 1st place, but then they understood that they outward studying. and this is their, what is being done right now. they weren't bloom just to the problems all a much rather than the problems of substance. i like her who i should be the 1st to say i have come back to the drums on ring obligations around was sure that the americans should do that because they're the you asked was the 1st to the one to withdraw from the chase of you. i in the americans, it with my believe that it was iran who had started to see the bar laid its obligations that with americans believed that the iran that should do the 1st step when you money and in russia were china. and some of our uses, wrestlers, livable colleagues, earth regional, chicago, stateful, you sign, carolie, saying, and harmonize a subset. this is what is actually being done by negotiators in vienna. ah,

they decided to have a break to unity of things in milton christmas surfaced. if it is left after that the negotiations would resume and the iran believes that leave the united states sir. highs reside in t owner, its obligation since tops and which will tell her you're threatening ways. the sanctions in line versus future with the resolution which remind 20 to 31 at united states will lorna its obligations death use little then there is a chance i use this finish the listening to through loosely blue on its head board and t. bear in mind that to the prince, all which i believe is the by says that all for negotiations is as follows. nothing is agreeable to everything is agreed upon. we need a couple more comprehensive package documents,

and i would like to remind you that we can remain live the interview with me. love all at actually we are on line with all languages that the r t i uses. and now the french thank you very much. my name is carla. mr. navarro. you could you please comment on the, the state and my by showing a flow tree on the show on the russian authorities about very serious consequences in case that russia invited crime. why do the same we have, which will you explain this did format all rights in our relations and you know, communication with colleagues. well, it's a question to them actually was didn't have any negatives to, to,

to that it's how with nicole exit, who have come home with the responses to like to play god intolerable mostly should fancy we have had the friendship targeted have made arrangements that they would have demands to russia because it's, this is actually what they are doing. and it seems that the president of russia go was, and other russian officials that have touched upon the so called escalation. because russia is threatened to be blamed they have already preparing been to powering package over sanctions in advance.

well, we were to buy something in advance or a national shop or in a foot still. and this is what it seems they are doing now. land, we have verbs on numerous occasions. the last quarter americans with brick units are where you're most like canadians. i doing any crane our with equipment a, with a military aircraft right on the border with russia in the baltic states. so why are there some more shapes in the black sea which is violating the nomes of the material convention? and in response, we did not tear any adequate with reply, only threats which are below and instead over a new loss during like that, our colleagues would draw the ideal with the responsibilities france and germany

should encourage kfc warner obligations under the men's agreements. that rather than uses, take all the attention and we'll try to do, spoke me rosa, and it was a sigh that her russia void. the invade done by, sir. are you crying? she the entire craig? this is quite obvious, sir, like 3 sailor's quay. and the, his regime of suit has been with the renewable water bill talking about 2 of them every now and then all the time. and we will, that means google's, it seemed some years ago that kia for would be able to honor the midst agreements. and this is actually what mr. zalinski promised when you had your in the electoral campaign. and it turned out that it seems he won't do that to do, to how to radical zoning, an artist. and in order to take of the attention of all those as

a true because it seems to be able to fulfill its obligations support. it was the result clear, the crime in platform and its just wasting right on this topic. all of us can call the excel so playing this game, but they should take a serious approach to trying to demand that ascii. that resolution would be $22.00 o 2 should be implemented, it adopted them in agreement. this resolution size clearly who should do what and in what consequence you i'm talking about if don't and lou on sco including amnesty with special status elections for the gloves on the miss the key. you then yes, good school on the conditions. the agree the by gave donates, can look on kind of the ages of oversee and then what's the level in your control,

the, the restoration of control over the do deal with numbers and now they're doing the country on us. okay, so, so do us a little step of decide with the border and then we will understand what's going on . so we'll see what the regime will be like. this is the draft glow that the president has mentioned to rest and micron and chancellor americans in yesterday mentioned to chancellor show the draft law on the transitionary period that the government of ukraine has introduced to their home at rada and that benz ukrainian officials from a hearing to the means agreements instead of embassy, they have lustration, in spite of a special status, the military and the military ministration. and no elections are mentioned in this draft law, the linear gun total,

just restoring the control over the occupied territories as they put it in francois . despite the promises off the germans and the french to talk zalinski out of promoting this law. good me pluses. ukraine is introducing and adding this since law inter there, the just let her and the council of europe said that everything is okay. there are some of the comments on de lee go us. i certainly go aspects, but nothing was said with regards to eat contradicting their un security council resolution and the venetian commission decision. so i have a request to my good friend, johnny flood rianne and my german colleagues. i met on an n better book on their margins of they always see ministerial meeting and she said that she wants to at here at to the minsk agreement. she supports minsk agreements . so you school, perhaps

a solution that's what they should do instead of being concerned by the so called occupation and escalations is there now to the 2nd round of questions, daniel from our english office a little that sip of your school. i would like to proceed with the agenda, though to my friend, your colleague, touched upon the western media continues to escalate tensions with regards to the cranium crisis. the c. c 9 has been talking about thousands of russian soldiers at the ukrainian border. you have mentioned several times that such escalation is it that such escalation of tension to special operations in november, russia took an unprecedented step and published diplomatic exchange with germany and france. and back then, it was said that the middle of miss actually was published. so that russia's position on ukraine would not be distorted. woo bonus. so did you achieve your goal?

no, you're getting stu. a law. well, i'm convinced that lexie below that because this escalation was to come up with the new boot deliberate. and i'm not trying to shame any one to which is just you more to try to make them come forward to well, we are diplomats was so just as one of my colleagues put it, we need some rational cynicism. and in terms of freshman or cynicism, i believe that the exchange you mentioned is quite poignant. and as it, because of those kind of contradicts you level to normal school from the statement that russia blocks the work within the norman deformity. because it is not true, which in 3 will and we are very much concerned by the fact that the mean sc

agreements is what shows are being distorted by kia scovella. i have already mentioned that in my response to the previous question, yes, sir. and the french and the germans, as sir co authors of this document and as full fledged participants off for the normandy, formative law student can continue to side at 100 percent with the cranium regina before. and they used to tell us that that was not that there is no alternative to the means agreements that everyone should adhere to them. but now you can just treat or i don't remember the exact date, i guess it's an on october 12th, there was the ukraine, e u summit. laws are yelled in the school and at the summit floor, it was said that russia will abuse. frushell whipple has its way doesn't to meet a number of demand. cent keefe is doing well, and they are performing their duties of the goes to the normandy form and the polio

. and just recently there was a meeting on the margins are the summit and brussels of mister zalinski way, the representative of france and germany. and the outcome of this meeting was for support for keith with regards to their fulfillment of the means. agreements, nashika gills facility still sir, and we spoke, well either our colleagues have proved that they are unable to insure the implementation of free men, so they have helped to create or they are deliberately trying to undermine them in favor of the key of regime. well, i'm not sure how the situation is going to unfold going forward. but to us, i believe that your school full, we are going to continue from the to support full implementation off the means agreements 1st a sufficient of hostilities,

then withdrawal or heavy weaponry. and then the restoration of economic ties and this has not been the case, we'll recommend you actually vice versa. transport and economic located is continuing of those. so certain areas of the don't yet can and the guns regions, you know, cuz i just know that i get together and people ob, basically starving there. and so that they would not die. we are providing them with russian passports and we are providing benefits for that company so that they could actually enter the russian market and provide revenue for their workers. we are being accused of undermining the means agreements as for citizenship and russian passports. well, that's ridiculous. poland and hungary, they provide passports to their own aft, nick and people off of their ethnic origins who leave in those territories. and

then also they are trying to accuse and attack russia and not on the right echoes from kia, but also the west and the west. supports them and supports their claims, and i find it regrettable. she also knew the counselor should really and now our american corey colleagues unicode. so starting in june at the geneva, some ed between president put in a president biden back then for the president biden said that without undermining the norman deformity, he wants to use the capabilities of the united states to help fulfill the means agreements. and he has reiterated that he understands very well that the means agreements ah little half in there in them the provision off a special status was good. and when the deputy secretary of state victorious newland came here and tells them,

might em don't free to came to russia. they also took plot in the discussions on ukraine and they all highlighted. they need to define the special status for dawn bus in accordance with the means agreements and the same thing much you need to go to yesterday. i heard from that state secretary, entity blinkin at they always see ministerial as you in the, in early december. so let's hope that the united states, how this understanding that they need to put an end to this sabotage. and those are outrageous activities on the part of the ukrainian authorities. and if they do understand that, then we'll be glad to that it is. so those new and perhaps political pundits and political experts might say that that would be a kind of a political agreement or political exchange. lehman's agreements can be fulfilled, then some restrain a restraint measures can be decided upon. insecurity guarantees including

law, the banner nie dosage eastward expansion, or the deployment of any kind of weapons. what she from a neighboring country is said, those weapons that can be afraid to russia for the little girl. i'm not going to comment on any was such commentaries and we want to have both. we want to have the full adherence to the means agreements. them global demand will to ensure the rights of national minorities to ukraine because this is actually possibly ukrainian constitution. and this is also included into various lists of borders, treaties and agreements that ukraine is spotty too. and we also want to have a broader security guarantees and to have predictability in our relations with nato . if you would allow me to gather a bro, mrs. a glover of atmosphere. do you believe that the situation might escalate into

an armed conflict and how will your ministry respond in such a case? the law. oh, hello sophie for yourself is well known and has long been established home. it is enshrined to school in the famous song when you do russians want war inputs. in the book, we do not want war. president putin has, once again said that we do not want to have any conflicts, and we hope that no one else will interested in any armed escalation. would you, we dispute you as well supposed to ensure our security through the means that we deem necessary and weaken it worn any hot heads and lists. there are such hot heads in ukraine and in the west. certain boom, the little the politicians suitable for you. but beaut, the little girl, tried to fuel their aggressive sentiment and ukraine. and the,

what they want to achieve is that the more irritants and aggressors we have on our border. then the more hope they have to create an imbalance in russia. so that russia would not stand in their way from a conquering, huge political territory. a sent president put in sad yesterday at the graduate meetings was at the ministry of defense that we have all the capacities in place in order to ensure appropriate military and technical response to any kind of publications that might enrolled around us. and i would like to say once again, that we would not want to choose the path of confrontation, much actually the choice is up to our partners or global signals. and the fact that the u. s. authority is some have been quite expedition is with regards to their organizational component of our future context pool, sushi sly,

i do believe i spoke with that it's a positive sign, regardless of the substantial work ahead. and it's a good step before the new year. reminds askin over to you, mr. lovegrove, you have mentioned that germany has changed its dance on the means, ke agreements. and in recent years, we have seen and get a minute that the blood relations between russia and germany have grown worse. and berlin is accusing russia of that and blaming russia for it. so what is the reason for such israel deteriorating relationship? what do you think it's you? i have already touched upon this topic, if you to so good mister about one that you don't want. you can hear what the minister of defense of germany said, that it is still not good whether you want or sort of funded. elaine said back when she worked in the new c, german government and to what she's now saying on behalf of the european commission that is, so will they say, norman, should they was,

they want to have normal relations with russia? but 1st, russia has to change its behavior. what the tools problem unbearable i met anna, lena bear, balkans, talk home today. and we had a good chart and it was a short meeting with you to a number of reasons. and i invited her to visit russia and she will miss a treasure check submitted today. invitation. and i saw that then the collision agreement of the new german government. there is a provision on div and diverse russian german, ty sent longer. yes. do they also have a provision that reflects receive authority, our relations, but there are also different approaches to relations between russia and germany. and i don't want even want to quote to them. they're saying that the civil society is shrinking in russia,

and they try to make us stop lister blazing situation in the crane, et cetera, et cetera. the traditions of german democracy dictated that they needed to combine coalitions in different ways. and it's not always said those coalitions are homogeneous. while this is life and we accepted as a fact of life. their coalition is headed by the social democratic party of germany, lead europe, as the previous bills. and the leaders of this party even have been most productive in what use when it comes to good corporation, end to mutually beneficial corporation between moscow and berlin. the orders. and we hold that to the bottom of the social democratic party in the coalition would be greater attention to how we can advance our positive agenda most much. but the approach custom that they have that but other than one side is doing everything

perfectly. and the other side should change its behavior altogether. well, you understand that that can not happen. yeah. person that issues will work. so i have been asked to do the floor to jackson. well, to leave us please, if you are you a smoker? no. going back to the middle east, i would like to ask a question about syria. the presence of american troops is to a considerable strapped to the territorial integrity of the syria and russia. how's the original modifications to withdraw the troops, but they are still there. i do believe thursday, so i will go on for a long what to would prompt the united states to withdraw the troops and what are the true reasons of that? actually the true reasons, the objectives that over the americans are clear and the americans have never

hidden them with became clear when they have been controlled over the i'm so scary it has so few oil fuels that are agricultural, lots of lands. i mean the euphrates origin and they have started to encourage the carter separatist meant the terror. theresa that argue that to see these developments say ah, the lions where arab tribes, i would leave for many years and peace. i would not 2 of 30 to the americans make the situation. they are better under the american strategic form trooper will sure you have her taken that until you county them little so. oh, susan loose, suppose you'd suit and given the difficulty relations between the cards and the arabs, adults because of the situation with turkey, i took it all right, but if you could answer the relations leave the kurdish party of like you certainly

. and the working party of kurdistan, ah, it's quite difficult. so you do what you should be cd and there are, there party is a syrian bonds, a who should they define where they stand? and i, you probably remember that to donald trump or sad that to the american civil, to withdraw the american supposed to have no need to, to continue a staying there. and a dialogue with damascus should be established. and then the donald trump was disavowed. and someone in pant again, a sad that the american civil wouldn't leave undone as no. the post cards are not interesting. it was interested in the dollar good. and it became clear that the americans it would go away. there are many problems including burg, bonnie camper and a large here's what i zone around at town for the moment the dispute shoes where

they try to restore order, but in fact they could not to maintain order. they're either romanian bounded sir and teresa among the refugees. who so good friends? i am convinced that the card says should nobles of him, you will take a principal position and they will visit to russia. mister med high sir visited moscow that she was the representative of the country democratic forces and what we tried to explain to our colleagues that till we would not to ship land or any stabilisation doable when we would like to ensure that the territorial integrity and sovereignty of celia and take into account the interests so vast inc. minorities, this is one of the conditions, the key conditions and it seems to me that americans understand that too high. they

are not to feeling comfortable there, but they are still there. there's a still, we have a dialogue away, the american, i'm really treat to prevent 2 incidents. sim was books needed to live and we have also quite trust based consultations on the exchange of views on the political process. say sound a prospect sold with whole feeling humana see a resolution standard golf and so once again in a while we are alive them and they're not level pro, so yeah, no, no old. the are 2 languages. we have a couple of questions. do i so who is going to ask them the question? simple example global. yes, thank you. maria is a harbor there are a couple of questions left with vianza to stop. well as an awesome, and this is one of them. you know, the us presidents, national security adviser just recently. so i did quite all that li, either do not have sites, has actively tried to transform the existent world order by building new allowances, partnerships and institutions design.