to me it's the thing is, sovereignty, the certainly is meeting it is a multi dimensional thing, multi event for the thing, assuming the rotors too. but i seen him or why am i kidding? why do i keep saying that russians are so it says, well, stop existing, it's not doing solve it. and it's not only about matter. it was all the military security or other types of security. there are other components to that. so what has happened to europe, for example, many european leaders, but they've been giving in your opinion enough to slide on one to be a to use later that little but the show i'm trying to attack sound one of these or, and we get like thinking about someone and these like it was the way many europeans are saying that the europe has lost solver and to see it and the drying ford's economically driving for, as you pointed to germany. and you have a good leader to, to, to list the leading politicians. and they said that after 9 and 45, germany has never been the fully solver and country to more typically we just know

products give them. and i'm just curious, what is it leading to? what's a means in practical terms in which the united states has had provoke system and i have no doubt they were the ones that briscoe this deep cleaning appliances when they supported the coo and ukraine in 2014. it's a great interest that we're personally aware of the fact that the that was a red line for us. but now with my face deals with that, and we have what we have now. what is your workspace? what's your name? and i believe that was not an accidentally needed this conflict. so why does it mean outcome? just let me pull them as well and that you can reach us. we will see if they didn't get to you real sure. a bed last night and all of its sovereignty west, huge mar, dupage duty and silver and t. they you happy to follow? there's no a 3rd solver in their leader. they had to follow embarrassed footsteps. politically, why they had to introduce sanctions and restrictions in the bullet with russia.

when you wave, were you 1st to do that, they knew that it was a damaged, anything for them that mclaren was down to them. and now these energy, they have to buy this energy from the united states. nothing splits since the middle 30 percent more expansion. you're going to choose. so the, in for the use base restrictions on russian oil, i just looked up quickly and then you can watch the outcome. it's not as evident as with gas, but the outcome is the same. so collection in the last suppliers. now your suppliers now uh slow to naturally and they started buying each to this oil from sugar from used. but if you're a number of suppliers, they have to pay more. now as a result of that, and we are selling our oil to other states to offer account trays at a discounted price, which typically choose so you know what's happening direct these click on the competitive edge of the european economy, went down a complete and suppose and the competitive edge, you know,

some all started and you can in the main issue, i'm going to see you instead of us goes into rivalry for you speak about economy of the united states. you split them. and when top was you and sort of was of the same happened to in some other and the states, 1st of all in asia, there economy is also growing, sir. so with their own hands, because of losing far, those are a sovereignty. we have their own hands, they had to make decisions that were detrimental to them. it was actually a month, a group of why do we need such a partner? can you still need somebody as gas? well, no, they are not use line long enough. there's that here is what i would like to draw your attention to, would you guess because we are largely leaving and we sort of piece was to and that us to ship the european markets that is going down and we are increasing or the presence in the other markets we see growing markets, for example in asia. yes, we still have go. we a lot of ties movies to point to because i work in culture,

in education with your at the a size bed have christiane scale, centuries of history. and it is all based on the christian culture. but here again, your opinions and you are not including asthma within the questions during the right think now or do the yard destroying post their christian roots the are uprooting. despite in their tradition to more mercilessly means to but i'm seeing so we are not going to close any things about him. so neither a windows nor mead stores, but we are also, you will not tried to which which person impose ourselves on your you've the want of the welcome us and we will work together. we are open for that meeting discussion that i think wiggins became loosely about this topic. but as for the most important parts,

i have mentioned them as for the tax book and the color revolution and see what the some 1956. i have not read that part of the textbook we will do. and as for us, we throwing the troops as well. that's a historical facts as well. in effect, deposition, some of the big van and 1956, many western countries. i don't see any problem human cuz they medium is the fans. these guys and the blue flames. the base for the problems that existed there. it was partially the fault though, the hum, gary and authority is so those times they were training fighters abroad, then they were sending them into hungry just leaving emails with cook with it. and so to lose the floors in the but it's hard to describe, but that's what we call it a revolution because still nothing but a city there was uh, purchased, done with the some we start on the strong foundation for these protests inside the country. i think that's now been staying inside so the last 4 and 12 so you

wouldn't use and i don't think that you're familiar of keeping an eye sheets we for so you know, personally, we should use the modern wording. modern phrases to describe the situation from the mid 20th century, as for, as for, with growing troops, because i'm convinced that it makes no sense to use troops. but though we had to suppress method, he'd been been see it friends that are some pro inside. when we do a country with this junior difference, the way the people to achieve the goals that they believe it's like i said, so is there a priority in west virginia and that is true for the european countries and the we're eastern european countries and made no sense to you see the troops, they're just and that'll be the peoples of these count. trace activities did not want to see them in their countries nor a good crack. it's a priest,

but you how it happened at the cubicle? slowly on what conditions at all happened timor, buzz them in. what ways it all happens? well, unless there is a lot of questions found that because our troops, they have to withdraw into an open field. a lot of people, they don't know about, that they just read through, into an open field with their families. is that a normal thing to keep up with a new bullet? uh does that is, could you see? and i think it with, as for any kind of publications or any kind of legal consequences and it's all based with throw, it was not put in paper and neither by the solve you heads up in the authorities, nor by russian authorities western part, personally you don't have not assumed any obligations, union city and nothing the most of them will issue additional has the problem is not been large and they to go to the east, our american partners, they are denying that early and then you have to you, they promise things. and then they ask a, so where's the paper?

there is no paper. well, one thing maybe some promises were made, but it's not worth anything just doing. and we know that they do not care about this paper. they can throw it out. but at least that labor would have something on it. and when the troops were we throwing, we could have agreed on something. for example, we could have spoken about the security in europe, ensuring security in europe. we could have achieved see some kind of new construct for security in your, in your architecture for security these and was putting the bar in about mr. atkins, bar, german, social democrat. he had suggestions about establishing new security, a system in europe that would have included russia english to the united states and canada. but it wouldn't be nato, but it would include everyone altogether in eastern and central europe issue. you probably me see when you're and i think it would have result, a lot of issues that we face today. he was a smart guy. he says the right thing,

because otherwise you will see 1st and it will happen again. but then it will be closer to russia. it was a german politician with an experienced smart when you say it's good to go with, well versed in person. now listen to him. neither solve your leadership nor the united states want stronger audio. so now we can remember what he has said, big fan, we would, you know, we've done so with throwing troops and it made no sense to keep them there. we would, but the conditions now he'd throw, that was something that should have been discussed. so then you think we should to one secret and we should have it achieved the situation back then. if you would, that would have prevented the current events and the current cries is such an issue? well, i guess this is a to have, i answered your questions and just to ensure that roll a 5 day 5 or something you, we're going to follow up. thank you. it seems we're still can all jump in their stuff from food in the center of the route. i'm from germany,

from the state, so you'll have it. and i'd like to connect to to what you just said to the special miller to appreciation. and ukraine is often justified with anti fascist motives. he said you have to, we have to free ukraine, people from the nazis. we have to drive them out, we have to liberate the country. so before this background, it must seem somewhat confusing that you own a high government level in contact with the right wing parties, such as those are some of the more know soon i or the i've d. i've done that to you in an of the dodge fund parties, which i deeply rooted in a racist environment. and they don't have any sympathy for the russian people will. one come in the one consume and to they don't have any idea or sympathy for the idea of russia as being a multi ethnic people. would you just stressed in your speech? so i would like to know. what do you hope for what do you,

what does your government hold full from such contexts? and what are the criteria for having a context? both parties like that. and can you understand the anti fascist and west and you see that as a sort of contradict some politics of your pull that takes this is an inch but it also cut you off the list of price. i'm sorry, i would ask you to be more precise here. could you specify exactly what you, when you talk about the fastest time they enter fashion, pontus and their attitudes to russians and so on? could you be more because specific ships otherwise we will be house on the quino co paula and had a contact on the official meeting with for a move to the 2nd level for in 2020. this was a sort of an official meeting and part of the the of the view on hooker for instance, is deeply rooted in the socialist movement in germany. you went to demonstrations

with nazi. so this is really confusing to enter fascists and germany. and if it's a contradiction to their policy, we sort of recognize that the as the policy of jeff truman of true nature. so what exactly confirms what you see that they're based in certain fascist values. all professions, the why is a, if the, based in the freshest ideas exactly. specifically, what is this about web soon? hucker for example, is he's linked up with a specialist who demonstrates interesting regularly and is it so doing that the, any of those 3 of the light bombing together was with passions tend to link up with them. and so this is one of the reasons why of the drum secret interior of secret service up to us, the spot to boot and saying they are writing. it's funny,

i wish it the smart way too much. it is. all right, i see the discount that was ukraine 1st and you asked if it was fair for us to publicly say that with aspiring to denounce if i the ukrainian political system we have just been discussing the situation in the canadian parliament. when did the president of ukraine was it floating and not see who was killing jews? russians and coals. isn't that a sign of the fact us ukraine is currently living in a system that we can rightfully call a pro nazi system. a state leader was applauding and nazi. i'm just an ordinary folder of nazi ideas. an actual nazi. i'm a former soldier of ss, isn't that assign? often that's a vacation of ukraine. doesn't that give us

a reason to talk about the notification to me onset. yes, that's the head of state, but that's not the whole country. what i can tell you is that you mentioned those who come out to, to rallies together with that pro, fascist elements about these that's the whole pot to that's joins these rallies and meetings. i don't think so. all things professions done from nazi condemned by us if there are no signs of such open ended fashions. if someone is willing to establish contacts, this can be supportive. as far as i know, there has been an attempt, an assassination attempt against one of the leaders of the f. c. c in germany, drive to town during the election campaign. what

does this mean? this means that the representatives of these spots here using the non 6 methods or how these knots and methods being used against them themselves. that's an open question. that is yet to be research. and you can follow up on that too. sure. and the wide audience, so i'm jim and he can discuss that to speaking of the anti fascist forces. we've always been with them and we're aware of their attitude towards rush and we're thankful to them for the positions. i think that every same that there's a man's soul of the restoration of relations between us should be supported and naturally this could be the light at the end of the tunnel. i'll follow to base relations. thank you. talk,

say go roach. please. thank you for the opportunity to ask this question. it's a question of a research and nature. we've been working on the latest development in the natural gas area and beat over a year ago. we all witnessed the unbelievable the unprecedented act of international terrorism committed against the critical infrastructure, european transport, the critical infrastructure, namely the explosion. so in the north stream pipeline, you have made numerous comments on this topics. and you have emphasized the lack of effort by the european prosecute as investigators and politicians. and we see which was the lack of

a specific reaction or lack of condemnation. so my z as or it is for an example by a chancellor show. so presidents, my problem, even though the, these, these countries company is directly suffered from such actions since they are to shareholders and the cool investors of these projects at the same time, recent police, they have been numerous leaks that directly or indirectly, trying to assign the blame supposedly the investigation believes that these acts are backed by ukrainians. therefore i have 2 questions for you. the 1st of them has there been any reaction by your european counterparts showing your direct contacts rather than in their official opens peaches?

or have there been any direction to the point method channels? and the 2nd question is, what, how is it possible consequences, if the so called to repeating, investigate, to see the investigates or something you are being congress assume or assign any blame for these terrorist acts on ukraine? here's the 1st point i would like to mention. ready long before these explosions, the us presidents publicly sat that the us would do every thing to make sure the russian supplies of energy resources through these pipelines can be stopped. and he gave a meaningful smile. he didn't say exactly how they would do that. but said they would do that and there was the 1st point. now. secondly,

the destruction of these infrastructure is an act of international terrorist search point. we're not allowed to join the investigation this find our office. and just by telling numerous calls to do that in an accident point, there are no results of the investigation, and most likely there will be no results. and finally, answering the question on who is to blame? should always onto the question who was interested, who had this taken? that of course, is the us surprise of andrew resources to the can you repeat in month in the americans have been wishing to do that for a long time and they have achieved that doesn't matter how exactly they did attend with whose hands there's also in other parts of the whole problem. sure.

if some day they find out who did that they shouldn't be held responsible. this is an act of international terrorism. about the same time there was to one line or no string to pipeline. it's not damaged and then can be used to shapes 27500000000 cubic meters of natural gas to here it is only one decision of germany away from happening. there is nothing else make required and a single decision can make us turn to valves and release the natural gas, but they're not doing that with a non doing that, because the washington's part is superior. so as we call them, do not allow that for the sake of their own interest. in this,

we continued to supply natural gas to europe using the total kitchen screen. and the ukranian terrace groups are supposedly targeting of that as well. always ships protecting the pipeline systems on the bottom of the black sea trying to attack them constantly using drones. you avi's, which are prepared and which are talking targeted with the help of the western specialist. they using some simple and fee costs and they have english speaking instructors to this is a fact for us you control your own conclusions and see who does that successfully. the surprise still continue,

the shooting supplies to return true. if you create a still have trends, it's true you crate that are we paying them the money for the transit? by the way, i've been talking about the tax previous list. they keep saying that we're aggressive that where the bad guys but money has no smell. they still get the money for the transit, the fall of natural gas. there's no problem with that. they just take it so we're being opened a here with parents. we're ready to corporate. if they don't want that. all right, then we will keep increasing the production and supply of allen g. we will work with all the markets full, it was new, find science,

new markets that tom open to all the products. this would be absolutely competitive and even increase the competitiveness of the countries that we will receive the russian energy resources. as far as the investigation we will even see in the end of the day, you cannot hide the facts and indians truce will reveal itself. you have mentioned transits in ukraine yourself on top of the russians have like one that's why we are doing so that's why we're paying the ukrainians for the transit of freshman gas. we're paying them because their contracts concepts we're supplying gas transits through ukraine because we comply with our contract the contracts with our process in europe. but it doesn't face to strengthen our

adversary. well, this also strengthens our financial position, so we get the money to all right, thank you. i'm on the really i'm owners and it's great opportunity for us to hear from you direct them said put in time gain to through patient to, to me the least bit in the state of a crane and international justice and international system. i'm coming from the rack and shortly there'll be a visit, but iraqi prime minister 2 months ago. and so i think you're going to meet to, to meet him personally. antuna. now there are a lot of problems between a, b and k or g. and do, at the same time, you have gross love guys a problem. they invested huge amount of money in your rack in general and include the stand offering. do think there is a tones that you can to hell both side to negotiate more peacefully,

to sort out the dispute between both sides and to be helpful more because the other part is in the area. they wants to put more oil on the conflict to make it more comfortable, more complicated off paint. and the other issue i want to highlight it for you is now we are about to by the end of 2023. you don't think it's the correct time for your personal help for all parties in serious, including the government's side, the care of the side regional powers at an old regional powers there to make an end for that conflict because thousands of syrians been away human lated in other parts of the worlds, and there is no a peaceful solution and no vision. and i think no one except you. because most

part there's something complex, they respect russia, respect, present, put them. i do have very good relation with them. all think so correct on to not intervene to mediate between or a multiple of them. thank you so much. again, it was just because it is done this, there's still in the conflict of the conflict sites and so many of the least and countries, including in syria respect us, treat us with respect. i can tell you that is because we always house respects to everyone else. and speaking of syria, we are a part of the peace process. and we do that under the aegis of the united nations. we cannot replace the sites themselves. we can only create the conditions and to a certain point, if it's acceptable for everyone,

we can act as guarantors for these agreements, including with the involvement of our partners in these process, i mean a wrong answer key spots of the asked and a process. we've been doing this and this had a positive effect and now everything that's been achieved and much has been achieved. keeping in mind the cessation of this a fire and we have created the conditions for the peace process. we owe the debt and our partners, deed sat with the goodwill of the searing lead the ship and of course, much as yet to be done. and i think that these external interference, dania tends to create because estates formations in syria, which leads to nothing good. the replacement of the arrow types that

have been traditional living on certain territories and all that to create these causes states is a complicated story that's can only leads to the prolong conflict. nevertheless, we are ready to contribute to of the, to the as the increase of trust to build trust between the central authorities of syria and the kurds, leaving the east of the country. this is a complicated process to know, i'm trying to be very careful here because every war matters as the 1st point. now secondly, speaking of the rock, we have very good relations with iraq. and we welcome to visit of the prime minister for the rock to russia. it is true that there are many questions of mutual interest. first of all, in the area of energy thoughts. there is also nothing important aspect in the can

only carry logistics. i will not go too deep into the details, but we know that there are several options for the development of logistics and transpose chains and routes through iraq. they're all suitable for us, but we only need to choose the most optimal projects. and we are ready to be involved in these projects. the prime minister will come and i will have the pleasure of discussing all of these matters with him, including the mathis of regional security and the security within the rock itself. for many decades, we have been supporting the closest trusting relations with iraq. we have many friends there and we really aspire to stability in the country based on disability the economy can develop as well as the social sphere. we're expecting the visits of the prime minister,

and i'm sure that this visit would be very productive, and this is very timely. she will face. okay, thank you. take care dear. hey, tyson drew the floor is yours. the especially the thank you. ties go to the phone, the piece, jessica, your party and champions media. that those last time i was given the opportunity to ask a question. it was to me, that's what it was in 2018, is that 5 years ago or poster? and i try to work in and out for the we're a new crane started sort of a jet then joined sanctions, a she against russia last year i'll be there in russia declared that it's going to all the country. and if you remember me the boat and hold the go .