Skip to main content

tv   Cross Talk  RT  October 4, 2024 12:30pm-1:00pm EDT

12:30 pm
inspires real, the white house is reportedly realizing that it may be on the able to prevent a regional war in the middle east. meanwhile, thousands tens of thousands are being killed. why is the west so indifference to diplomacy? the cross hockey in the middle east. i'm joined by my guess. marla osmond and be rude. she's an assistant professor at the lebanese international university and a political commentator also in lebanon. we have professor soft dean. he is an associate professor and canada research chair in the history of the modern, middle east, at the university of british columbia. and in rome, we cross though ramada rivera. she is an author and managing editor of the palestine chronicle. alright, cross black roles. and in fact, that means we can jump anytime you want. ok, professor, if i go to you for the subsidy, and if i can go to you 1st here i have titled this program apocalypse may be, is that hyperbole on my part as well. given what we are seeing on the ground or the
12:31 pm
chances of a regional war and possibly a war that actually expands beyond the region is increasing. so there's definitely a reasonable assumption that if is free is not actually the restraint properly. if we don't see a change in the approach of the us administration towards is reactions of us own policy and the region given the fact that iran is also now has struck back without a fit for the attacks that is being as committed against iran. we are seeing a gradual escalation that's kind of not accelerating or quantum leaps that have happened in the past 3 weeks at the same time. so it's still not clear that we are heading there soon. so it may be an apocalypse, but maybe not, no matter what it's it seems that everybody in the region we'd like to avoid a greater conflict with the exception obviously, of israel. israel is choosing these fights with its neighbors and it's called
12:32 pm
meeting. we had that of a group of assassinations, of course, the designation of uh, as well as leadership and intrusion into lebanese of sovereignty. israel wants this, but it wouldn't be able to do this if the united states wasn't 100 percent. what did joe biden site? totally, totally, totally behind israel, without the united states. we would not be seeing this happening. go ahead. no, it wouldn't be seeing this happening either. and without also the help of the nato and special colonizers that were ones colonizers and still lower like friends, and even k as well for, and not only supporting diplomatically the scientists entity, but they are also supplying it with the needed weapons to this made gaza and now the submit button on and s for the genocide. over until 11 on i, i was reading a statement by the 11 use ministry of health. and the minister was saying that since october 8, the number of martyred civilians and even on have been more than $1600.00,
12:33 pm
including hundreds of children and hundreds of women and the number of injured has surpassed 9000. and he was during his basement. he was saying that he was actually beginning of the reports that are coming from sign is israel cleaning that now hospital was 11 on our housing weapons. this is age. a pretext for design is going to be to start also targeting hospitals in the suburbs of a within, in the south as well. so this is escalating pretty fast. they must model on you, right? you just said here is as america, what you just said is very reminiscent of what we heard about the genocide in gaza . hospitals mosque schools. this is a replay. this is a replay of what they did in gaza. they're attempting to do in lab and on, particularly and, and, um, and they route right now, do you agree with that? yeah, of course they are trying to do this. they have been doing this over the past week theater because the for a level wave of attacks that happened in decline south lovenox was so just meeting to effect to a point that it was taking out families 12 number,
12:34 pm
17 members and the st. pounds. especially those were displaced from the south to the because they were also a bond, and they're safe houses, and it was all civilians. there were no fighters there, and that's what we saw in casa and now are seeing targets in south lebanon and south the some suburbs. will fade with and usually the high other are you the spokesperson of the violence really entity keeps showing the sweets spending people to stay away 500 meters from certain areas to be stricken. but this morning, up until an hour ago, there were hits on the southern. something's a vineyard wood without any, a pre, a posts or pre tweed spite of hire today, or anyone else. which means that people were trying to get some stuff out of their houses, and they might have been either killed or injured because of these attacks without any prior for that. but that's what you're telling me what you're telling us. this is terrorism, but it's nothing short of just terrorism. it's $1.00 oh, $1.00 terrorism and it is sorry. now it's starting to decades ago. i'm not going to go there. but it started against living on, specifically 2 weeks ago with beach scandal of the tears,
12:35 pm
the talk of peters and walkie talkies and follow through with these attacks against . well maybe they only, they only i'm sorry for that. that is, that lebanon is the graveyard of these kind of expeditions, and i think there's a lot different. let me, let me, let me go to a room over a mom that it's interesting that, um uh, more way use the word colonizers. do people in the region understand that when joe biden says the g 7 says, i mean latrice, and then i mean of all what group and you could mention the former colonial powers . it's really these people, they would be there. so tone deaf, the history go ahead and room the 1st of all, there is of course, a property of representation. it says that all institutions are northbrook presented to go anybody, these g 7, he's not for preventative and preventative of what the new award order is. the same way the united states security council is not representative of what the new work is. and these is why they are allowing each while to continue with its genocide
12:36 pm
a war for one year now and with terrorist attacks. and what my, what will say about the warnings of, by these way, the army we've seen that time and again in palestine in gaza. sometimes they also trick the population to see them population. they sent messages to a certain area in a certain neighborhood. and then they at talk and target, for example, be a power level root in the same neighborhood. so they play these tricks with the cdn populations, events and not only terriers and bus routes. so as he becomes a and this is possible with the complete cd, of course, this country of the colonizing powers that she mentioned, but also with the complicity of the media. this is very important. this is will and the united states are allowed to life openly. we've, we've heard so much into rhetoric about once he gets these 512 piece. the truth is,
12:37 pm
on the ground that the opposite is true, and the media is come from well and the media is not reporting that mis routed before he was murder, and had agreed to a 21 day ceasefire. the media is not telling anybody that let me go back to the professor. it's, it's very interesting to me is, is netanyahu trying to repeat of the 67 war solving all of israel's problems simultaneously because that's what it looks like to me go ahead. i was just pointing out that before coming on your show that some people were a bit worried about a possible both 67, the feed after the string of attacks that the whole conducted against the resistance and whether or not. but as a matter of fact, in 2024, it was uh, is really airports that were gone by around and not easily and bombing, airports in egypt. so if this is as planned, it's certainly not going the way he wanted. in fact, given the last few events which included the invasions that dude mentioned, the,
12:38 pm
encourages and to live in on. you may be repeating 2006 instead of repeating 1967. so, you know, and he even changed his wardrobe. he switched from his is uh, you know, suit and tie back into his black as a means of probably also deceiving and be calling his own population and pretending to be in mourning with those who died on the, on the, on the front or killed by the resistance, so let me out is certainly trying to a, uh, what i would say is turn around the strategic defeat of october 7. he's trying to do it by expanding the war. and he started to choose that when he assassinated. i say it has something that's what i law and other um uh you know, leading members as well. but in fact it looks like up until now the impact of those attacks has not seep through to the bathroom for you. so the ability of hezbollah for controlling command has not so far been debilitated. and on top of that, the attack while you're on as further probably busy themselves busy now with future
12:39 pm
plans to uh, you know, uh, strike back. so if it's the $67.00 scenario as much as we have to be concerned about the, you know, non stop a genocide thing does uh, be, uh, you know, uh you tried to go through the military superiority and yeah, we have yet to see anything close to a not, not simply a decisive this eats an indecisive dispute as an that story, a decisive victory. for those reasons, we haven't even seen it in decisive victory, at least in model while you're, you're in be root. um, what is the morale and what is the, what is the attitude towards has blogs, we this conflict to large and gets larger and larger. it is very interesting to watch peter at 1st time when the people have lost basically everything their lives, their loved ones, and possibly their homes and their businesses. and yet they say that we would only
12:40 pm
retain return dignified when beach resistance is victorious, and they have been cheering. and the capabilities, of course, will not. and, and maybe putting an end to the infiltration towards lebanese lands. uh that started on october 1st and has been going on ever since they have been trying from different villages in your own. and i said one in a basic and they have been incurring a lot of a that's headquarters. have been taking these uh commanders and these fighters from the battlefield and they have been hit while also trying to flee, which has major issues, attempt to infiltrate. it's 11 on any responsibility at the moment, which brings out what the professor was saying about power as well. as command and control center is not affected by the assassinations of the leadership, the political leadership and the combative leadership, which means that the institution it's still valid, is still capable. it is hurting. and at the same time, the feeder we have seen also besides being fired from the oven on from the south and into enter a parts of occupying the palestine hurting the palestinian hurting the it's really
12:41 pm
entity industry facilities. instead of also targeting somebody use the same way that is robust doing they still refuse to target any stuff. there's at the moment, given the a, the possibility that israel might escalate it even further against different needs . that tells you a lot about these really strategy. but it's failing both at the border and in people bergman's campaigns. but what is interesting, peter, as well as seeing that the assignments entity also to speak, conducting at conducted air, strikes against the threat and multiple areas on the course of mine and, and on the inside. indeed the mask is the capital. the syrian capital also targeted the capital, and now we have our hearing reports this week that they might be targeting the border between 11 on answer it because they were saying that this warner is allowing weapons to enter into has been on the spot defective. it's a civilian border in 1000, so keep the bedding, but it's also a border where people trying to escape. so there they, they went by and make sure that there is no escape. you're all right, i'm going to jump in here with this thing. i'm going to jump in here,
12:42 pm
we're going to go to a quick break, and after that break, we'll continue our discussion on events unfolding in the middle east. stay with the russian states. never as tight as i'm one of the most sense community best. most all sense and the speed, the one else holes. question about this, even though we will fan in the european union, the kremlin machine, the state on the russians to de escalate the ortiz food neck,
12:43 pm
keeping our video agency roughly all the band on youtube tv services. for the question, did you say they requested the the, what is a part of the is it that the employee would post that isn't the defense you of us and bidding the word or is it something deeper, more complex might be present? good. let's stop without cases. let's go out of the to take a fresh look around as
12:44 pm
a life kaleidoscopic isn't just a shifted reality distortion by tell us to do vision with no real opinions. fixtures, design to simplify will confuse really once a better wills, and is it just as a chosen few fractured images presented to this, but can you see through their illusion going underground again the
12:45 pm
the welcome back to the cross walk where all things are considered. i am peter roosevelt to mind you were discussing events unfolding in the middle east. the . okay, let's go back to room room and i, i'm, i suppose all of us and many of our viewers watch some of the speeches that were made at the security council at the united nations on wednesday. and it's interesting, and some of those speeches were an impassioned that and one individual insulted the institution from beginning to end and its uh,
12:46 pm
the people in the hall itself. but it's in watching those debates. you can't escape the conclusion that international law, international humanitarian law is just absolutely collapsed and it's only because the west allowed it to happen. go ahead, enroll the absolutely. first of all, we have to say that international law, for, in the way the system worse is something that was decided from the west, from court on your powers at the or assets the, the old system was decided by them and it towards only for them. and if there is something that's, you know, the were on golf now the were on lebanon, are showing is exactly that. the international law is like an empty box in a sense, because it's not applied. and it's not a pretty good book, a to certain powers that needs to be defended. and you know, we've seen as well insulting the institution with facts of the ground. and it didn't start to yesterday. it did start on october 7, 2020 we,
12:47 pm
we've seen so many resolutions completely disregarded by, as well as throughout the years without any accountability of, for uh, televisions we've seen as well. now escalating and you know, recently you and simply tell you, tell you what, i'm telling you. terrorist was as lived as pissed. so no without having to spend a film is really territory. and, you know, do you and us books, person at the diaries was very side and saying, all of the leave another talk can you imagine if this came from china, this came from russia. it would've been over, you know, the media as the biggest scandal of our time, but everything is and out and the system wasn't able. i don't say to stop the war to bring too many tegan to to godaddy's money, $78.00 to gaza at to bring met defense, vaccinations and so on to a population to
12:48 pm
a cd there and population that is struggling with the genocide. so really be complete. you know, these institutions are completely power this. yeah, well i look forward to the secretaries. they blinking in a orange jumpsuit one day for his lying about the uh, the fact that um is real as blocking 8 in 2 guys. so let me go back to the professor, professor, you know, one of the, it's already been mentioned, mar was already into the mentioned how the media is treated of these events over the last year, particularly for the last particular few weeks, is that you know what you know, well a ceasefire is necessary, we all want to cease fire and all that and, and, you know, engaging behind the scenes with around and thinking about last april, you know, trying to calibrate a response to what these really said and attacking the consulate in damascus. and everybody seems to, you know, okay, we can do this which try to calibrate all of this and that,
12:49 pm
and then you just turn around and then it just israel that says no ceasefire whatsoever. i mean, i can't, it's, it's hard for me to compare how shameful to bite into ministration is acting. they get, they've, they're turned into false left, right, and center. go ahead professor. well, let me 1st clarify a few things for further viewers. i think because smart today is a word that's almost like democracy or freedom or international law, good for everybody. and that'd be by the story. and people can get confused. they can say, oh, you know what everyone wants to see as far. so let's 1st clarify that both time us and has molar from the very beginning. i've been calling for a permanent ceasefire. they've been calling for an end to all of us teletubbies. and this is the kind of ceasefire in addition to an exchange of prisoners. in addition to the withdrawal of israeli troops from occupied era, blan, all of these demands are within international law. so none of these demands are
12:50 pm
radical. none of them are extreme. and at the same time, it's not the only history of that. i'd refuse the ceasefire. it's, as you mentioned, the united states as consistently i would call, you know, use its media and public presence to actually not just water down to confuse and mislead. yes public. so they constantly blame the other side for refusing as these far so, and this brings me to resolution 17 o one. i think we have to talk a little bit about that because we may expect this to become the primary a band or under which a potential diplomatic solution takes place. so let me just say, if anyone has read 17 o one, they will know that this resolution, in fact, demands the people of lebanon and those powers that resists it's very occupation withdrawn to the north of the latania river. it makes all sorts of demands on loving on. it almost makes no demand on this region. at the same time,
12:51 pm
even even though that is the case is lebanese officials have consistently said they are willing to actually accept 1701. it's easily and that's been violated. thing 1701 through thousands of aerospace violations. why don't before october so then there are no demands in 17. 0 one's for is realtor actually you know this arm itself. so what i'm trying to say is even what the international consensus is, 17 o one, which is extremely unfair to 11 on. it's still being refused by is reading and only, and until there is a clear, bare handed approach that we're going to see possibly some pressure being applied with professors. but i, you know, i, i, it's my job to be contrary and, you know, consensus, how do we get there? i mean, you know, we, we've had resolutions in the united nations. yeah. and then the united states just says no and, and, and how, how do we get
12:52 pm
a consensus there is we would have to experience some kind of strategic defeat to have the consensus. don't you agree? well, that's a good point. yes. generally speaking, as we would have to experience some major defeat, although under the current administration in this room, it looks like the they don't are, they don't seem to have a long term strategy. they're really just arguing um, an attempt to destroy every single round. they have to preserve themselves, so that might be actually suicide them. but also let me, uh, maybe we can, you know, bring the discussion into a place of potential disagreement. i do think that the other power. so let's, let's put the veto point aside. because ultimately, the things that happen to the security council on happened after the powerful states kind of come to some understanding amongst themselves or lack of such an understanding. i am personally a little bit disappointed with, for example, in china's position that it's not actually exerting enough diplomatic of about
12:53 pm
a force or diplomatic pressure. let's say as much as i appreciate some of the bricks positions. they generally continue to somehow try to play a balance rolled so they're always, you know, conducting is really but always condemning fat experience for under this. so it's, i don't see, i see some, some level of, of course of action and in the congressional criminal court. but not enough in my view i, i wish somebody pressure and i absolutely agree with you. give me 11, go ahead point. go ahead. i don't sound like on keeping the out of one away is actually out of government and out of states that the bare minimum, whether it's jordan or egypt, which actually have both orders for instance. there is no reason under international otherwise for egypt not to open itself. i thought that this is a border between pa, the spot in egypt because it has nothing to do with it. i mean, there may be some consequences in the short run. definitely, surely, the diction army is more likely to be presumably able to resist the needs or the
12:54 pm
lebanese, or the kind of thing is. so the lack of enough out of government pressure because i say it is because ultimately the united states is interested in prolonging the war if it can re consolidate this position in the region. so it wants to have, it's taken you that it doesn't want a large dig, landlord, you're absolutely right. i mean, it, we bought it reminds me of me, but a mile away. you know, kind of, lisa rice. so famously said, you know, this is the birth pangs of a new middle east. and as movie you know, a rabbani said on this program earlier this week of that turn it into it turns into a messy abortion. but the professor is absolutely right. this is so solving all problem simultaneously, the bush administration thought that was doing that and it failed. and now we have the kind of a hollowed out a bite, the ministration attempting the same thing. and it will fail to go ahead moment. yeah, imagine and imagine peter, it and feeling,
12:55 pm
but at this time also you have more players being engaging in this war like yemen and iraq and syria and lebanon was probably syria. it's, it's, you're a decides to open the golan heights front. and best rule is a set to back a years, not only months in the way that it strategy has been failing in the region. i mean, we have seen how the iron don't was not working out. the spring shot was not working. we also have the $200.00 plus listed inside square lending everywhere as sirens from the river to the sea, it was the 1st time was the sirens, sounding and occupied, found a sign rep, seen also the capable of using new ballistic themselves in them. and some people still bigger stick massage to a lot of basically putting it out of service and iraq, also sending drones and what, what the professor was saying concerning the mintern efforts that was not enough by the arab states. there's also the defensive efforts. i mean, they weren't allowed at iran to defend itself by throwing the massages because we saw edge jordan frontage reset some of them, it sounds what they allow is real to use their space to box syria, to go from
12:56 pm
a certain areas also in iraq and they also allow the 10th based on the board of between syria and jordan to operate specified that is an occupation. so there's also this that the, the peoples of the region have also responsibility. now to hold their origins responsible for the genocide that it's spinning right now over into 11 on. so we've seen a lot of changes in strategy, but we will also see a lot of changes in politics because i don't think that the people's work will accept this kind of in the buying status and facing vista and assigned the entity in at the same time i think that the nicest americans very busy with its upcoming elections and they don't want to see anymore as putting over a force in the region that might potentially go into a full blown world porch. but at the same time, this has to end. it cannot continue into more generations of bloodshed, whether 11 on dollar sign, serial or elsewhere and sinus israel has been, according to the international law, recognized as a supplemental in apartheid regime. and this needs to end. and the only way,
12:57 pm
apparently this is going to end is with the involvement of more f funds from the axes of resistance to make israel bowels sub. okay, let me, let me give the last word to romano of 40 seconds. what is the state of the resistance right now? as we speak? i think that's for 4 or 5 days is what we felt that each had a re concord we gained determined over the region honestly from and who did point of view that was a silly and they and now this is you do not re gain determined by assessing aging, a leader or a leadership you did not redeem, determines with the cyber tear at talk, targeting the civilian population of the country. a bunch d. what's happened in the last few days really showed that as well. not only did not regained that determines get lost, clearly on october 7th, but it is, you know, much more see, okay, and i know there we have run out of time. we have to go here. i want to thank my
12:58 pm
guess in lebanon and in rome. and of course, i want to thank our viewers for watching us here at r t c. and next time, remember across the the the quietest west 3, i'm in the throne. i mean, i was trying to meet you was how your ship was traveling since the mid, obviously a hair dresser, a bus driver, a sales person, anyone could become
12:59 pm
a victim. that's how private negotiators fast appeared. looking for the desk, still pretty much. what am i look forward to see we started this week and someone else in the us as a team. and the reason why you're going to be up by the name on that, on those over those. i mean is you won't be feasible. move soon on from the yes to the studies boys took over the serious me this is easier news in the middle that this request was in the window. this includes the
1:00 pm
our enemies, however, have a command room that is centralized. they receive orders from one place of thousands, also radians, gather to move. the kid angles has full of chief maya as well around supreme need to says the middle east tons, one common enemy, which is taking orders from low to see the u. k. green lights home rule for the long, dissipated chunk off to ireland painting returned to marisa, positive diplomatic butler things, but the best theories claiming they want to go to the negotiation process, which is left to us, minute treat a station that website. this is the absolute implants ability of the claim that a group of out of.

6 Views

info Stream Only

Uploaded by TV Archive on