unscrupulous entrepreneurs no, these are all inventions of some people who are engaged in control, who go with inspections, who scare the president with the fact that unscrupulous ones are flying there and yes, and we and others all do not act. don't repeat stupid things. for good, there will be no foreign enemy propaganda. this is the second, and the objects are the situation. in reality, for example, goods are running out, they need to be stretched out so that, uh, this product is enough, so it does not raise prices. this is not dishonesty. this way they need to survive they need to go jobs about it. well, how can i say, nobody thinks, so well, alexei gennadievich, of course, i'm far away. what does it matter that in all they appoint unscrupulous, but there are such entrepreneurs, there are such speculations. unfortunately, we know this very well in the markets, but we will not argue about it now, absolutely, and you are absolutely right. and now, by the way, we will also talk about this, because vladimir putin spoke about the fact that under the sanctions. and we will be saved by the freedom of enterprise,

and we talk about it quite a lot, but is it freedom now and what needs to be done to make it appear if it is not enough. well, firstly, there is more freedom for entrepreneurship. it 's true. thanks to these, so to speak, it would have been misfortune, there would have been no happiness, two parts helped. now we have introduced a moratorium on inspection, and it continues to operate in a protective degree, unfortunately, the motor will run out. in six months, the question is. and what will happen next? yes, we will hope that this motor will continue, for example, they removed bankruptcy. now the tax office cannot bankrupt enterprises. but the truth is, she can, for example, put up money for collection and also the entrepreneur of the enterprise is left without money, so there are some moments, but still it got a little better. and so the pressure has decreased, fewer checks come here. hmm but of course, this is not the freedom that is needed in the conditions of such an economic war that the west is waging with us . and here is what is missing. specifically, the inspector did not come at all. well it's

going to be some kind of mess you know how many demands there are to the enterprises of ur rospotrebnadzor recently , i don’t know, 5.000 5.000. yes, you can read at least remember, but of course, since the ministry of emergencies do you think the requirements of the firefighters? guess well , probably too. i thought thousands of tonsils were tall. how many requirements do you think there are for enterprises? well guess too. well, also, probably, several thousand people 100,000 hmm, of which there are 20 thousand for all industries and further tracking. this is what you can keep in mind. at least keep in mind not what to perform to perform and it was not done in order to perform the point is that there was someone who will take the contract and write a piece of paper that everything is in order, well, the inspectors will take fines. this is why it is possible to reduce regulation much further than thresholds since the eleventh year thresholds have not been raised, for example, there are millions of rubles, there are one and a half million rubles under many administrative criminal articles. was more than one hundred percent

a million in the eleventh year and twenty-second times a million. we bring the bill tonight in that let's raise these bars in order to a criminal offense will also not be a carrot. well, after all, these are different things, so a lot needs to be done, both our party and the parliament as a whole are doing this. there is one more topic that concerns, of course, freedom of enterprise in general, and so on. and today andrei klishets said that, well, a tough statement. he said that import substitution has completely failed. this is his opinion, however, valentina matvienko once also said the day before that there are big problems and plans need to be changed. and what is your opinion on this matter. thank you very much. it's a very good question that er and enlightenment is not in the volume that we all expected, it's true, but i would not say that it failed. there is, one might say, so that it is a failure. we can say that the first stage has passed. import substitution improtrusion 1:0, and we move on to stage two. you know how zelensky can say that they

are surrendering. and can you say you're evacuating ? yes, the question of assessing this or that son , i am a question of reality. for example, there i once yes, companies literally just recently there a year ago faberlic and, for example, cook uh, hmm products. yes, you can even make components there, but to go into chemistry, you have to make ingredients in order to have a big market. here we have made one such approach, for example, there is a lot of rose oils and essences there, and it turned out that our entire russian industry consumes. uh, there is a quarter of what we can do in the fields, there are pink uh, there in the krasnodar territory in khadyzhensk. answer quarter. where to put the second the price of what we would do would be eight times the price of the essence in fran and 6 times the price of the essence in egypt, this is not a competitive price. why such a difference in market size? it is clear that the larger the volume, the lower the market, the lower the price, this is understandable, therefore, earlier it was easier to

buy many things, we used the west as our raw material inflow, which is our position, therefore, and now we will need to do it ourselves, it needs to be redone and so on many industries. you can't compete with global concerns that have a different price, so say, another practice, and now we will compete. and stronger than nevertheless you need to compete, because these concerns do not want to work with us for far-fetched political reasons. damage in themselves. many of them, uh, cry, well, they leave because they are forced to. and this question, by the way, is also very interesting. eh, because how can we be here. here we are this morning from the studio discussed the issue. e, which will now be considered in the state duma. it's a question of what do you do with the assets of western companies that we have, well, in particular the tag, there and so on. here is the composition of your party on a, because our western former partners. they just take everything from us. well, we do not want to become like some citizens. we need

to do something to protect our interests. yes, as i understand it, that is, yes from several aspects. the first e, you know, do not confuse pr and reality. more than 600 companies have said that they are leaving russia; in fact , less than 100 have left. that is, they know less steel, and the pain is not going to go away, for example, now russian companies are looking for components in asia around the world. there for these 3 months. still very few deliveries went to really new western companies, they supply everything seryoga from europe that they need without any problems, moreover, they have their factories in poland, the same poland that now has taken away all the property from fifty russian companies. this soil, they are bringing their factories to the same finished products in russia. yeah, so no, western companies are not going anywhere. they know how they say goodbye in that joke. they leave. that's why here you have to say goodbye before leaving, finally, if they leave, nothing terrible will happen. yes, there are complex industries there, yes, mechanical engineering and such technological ones, there are also the same

computers, but nothing terrible will happen in consumer goods. over the years of the market economy, we have grown a lot of players who, in terms of quality and cost of goods. no worse somewhere, even better than western ones, so don't worry, but some used to not have the opportunity to stand on the shelf in stores, there was no money for advertising, and so on. here, uh, without goods, we will not stay. wow well, here you are as a manufacturer, er, a representative of this class of entrepreneurs, because production is much more difficult, so i am raised by entrepreneurs who are engaged in trade. it's just that there is a huge difference, two big ones, as they say in odessa. moreover, there was a large laboratory there. great remains, and i just mean that uh, uh, the departure of western companies. he really really helps. to our companies. and develop, uh, than if they were present here, and we would develop more actively the same market was very dense. uh, global companies spend, there are multibillion-dollar advertising budgets, at least huge huge benefits, have

huge benefits and such leverage on the trading network. they are in the best places. in trade networks. they have a distribution system for retail chains. now. if they really leave, of course, the demand for the national capital of the national producer will be much higher. it will be a little less dense, there will be a little room in the market for internal expansion, but alekseevich, and yet, nevertheless now there are sharp disputes colleagues other programs on television. we watch them all beautifully and, uh, we understand that there are a lot of such extreme positions, someone says, let's revive the state planning commission. and someone says it will kill the economy, and so on. it is clear that truth, as usual, is somewhere in the middle. here is the appearance of some kind, let's say not the state plan, of course, someone coordinating body at the government level, which would direct the activities of

entrepreneurial enterprises more actively. how do you think, it needs to be done. i think yes, moreover, it should be some kind of inter-party such, perhaps even inter-industry. uh, rooting center. what are here uh? are there any advantages? yes, we see that, uh, of course, there is no state alloy, firstly, it is impossible. secondly, it is not needed, because price regulation will lead. it was from tsarist russia on the eve of the revolution, it was in the soviet union the regulation of prices, the regulation of production volumes. it 's simple, well, so to speak, it's a modification. this is the black market. this is a trade from under the floor. this is no there is no recipe for this, so there is no need to choose between the middle if you need to choose a market economy, but market does not mean spontaneous does not mean there is some kind of invisible hand of the market. no, market - this means that people compete , the company competes, but there is support. such healthy protectionism, for example, the ministry of trade, the idea of ​​protectionism in relation to the national capital of social companies, the manufacturer

supports further now the question is industry councils at ministries, but so far this is, of course, scattered management. you need something like this, like during the war, there was the gkos defense committee. where all the information was collected and a quick decision-making now, such a body is also needed, but at the same time, i see that the government. unfortunately, nonetheless. i hope that this is just a crisis, just a temporary situation, and this situation is very long. this is a long economic war. russia that this touched on a very big topic. it's a pity. we have so much time, but a little more eat. why because? well, let's be honest part uh, quite frankly. or rather, we are all the time, to be honest, but to be frank, after all, part or this part of the business, including those that you represent, your party represents in the state duma, but hopefully. well, we’ll sit out a little , keep silent, do nothing special, we won’t depict a burd of people’s activities.