the changes are the most important, but the labor market will change, and in this regard, of course, we must think about those people who will be released from their old jobs. come on here, uh, experts of various kinds are trying. uh, very different directions and hmm at the expert level. we will be prompted by development trends in key areas. we would, of course, be grateful for your opinion in the construction of our plans, considering. uh, so your position on these trends, oh, which i i just said it because, understanding what will happen tomorrow, we need and need to build a policy today. oh about the transfer. e capitals. yes , we have such conversations . it was in the history of the russian state. e. russia, as it were

the historical mental center of russia is always associated with moscow and, in my opinion, some kind of necessity. there are problems in the development of the capital, like megapolis, and i must say that they are under the leadership of the team of the current mayor sobyanin they do much better. what was the period in many other countries of the world and in many other megacities when they grew here? well they are happy and kind of growing problems with transportation. with the development of social infrastructure and so on, but still in recent years. uh, mayor sobyanin did a lot to stop these uh threats and vice versa to create, uh, conditions for uh, so that uh, muscovites and those who come to moscow for work or guests of

moscow, uh, who come here with tourist goals felt comfortable here a lot has been done for the development of the city in the last few years. e hmm well, this is the problem of excessive centralization of all, uh, federal structures in moscow, it exists and just like in some other countries. for example, i, a supporter, did the same as in some other countries, namely to decentralize. and specific plans construction of the supreme court. well, this should be done slowly and calmly, creating from uh the judicial

community favorable conditions for uh to work , including st. petersburg, and we will do it without any haste and fuss. uh, some hmm some some uh, big companies that, let's say, actually operate in siberia and have their central government in moscow could have their headquarters there. by the way, this is what is happening. there will be e ru-rushydr, for example, well, it settles in itself, in my opinion, in krasnoyarsk they are there, in my opinion, their headquarters are justified, and they are equipping the central authorities. it could be that some of them could be targeted, concentrated, dispersed throughout the territory of the russian federation, this will only benefit both the management system itself and the region where they will appear. thank you so much ivan timofeev vladimirovich good evening ivan

timofeev valdai club i have the following question regarding russia over the past year an unprecedented number of sanctions have been introduced you mentioned freezing our reserves in europe for 300 billion. to this we can add tens of billions of freezing the property of our citizens and our organizations. by the way, they are planning to confiscate this property and are now developing appropriate mechanisms. well, in addition to this, there are many other things, including financial restrictions, bans on the supply of goods to russia, technology of our oil , gas manipulation, and so on and so on. we all know this very well. and you mentioned this in your speech. our economy was expected to will not stand. she endured. to a large extent , this happened because the economy remains a market economy, it remains flexible. it remains adaptive , the business is looking for new markets, where, perhaps, it

is looking for ways to import substitution, the government is taking a number of steps to help businesses do this , but given the extreme conditions of foreign policy and those very sanctions, it may be time to take the path further and regulation of the economy. you mentioned decentralization to reduce the number of checks, uh, reduce the regulatory burden. i would be very glad to hear your opinion, so the question uh is related. uh, this is our choice, as in such cases, they say to reduce the number of inspections and get rid of excessive regulation by the state. so, you know that scheduled inspections have been discontinued not only for small medium-sized businesses. well, for large businesses, and we will extend. if it hasn't been said yet, i will. now we will extend this regime. oh, and for 2023. so,

with regard to regulation, yes, this is the administrative guillotine hmm, as we said, she brought to the fact that over there thousands of acts have been canceled, and uh, in their place, in my opinion, somewhere less than 500 new ones have come. i hope there are 400 with something new in modern ones, huh? new acts that regulate economic activity, yes, that's why we will continue along this path. of course, uh hmm, with the exception of those types of production, uh, that are associated with known risks for consumers. well , it seems to me for everyone, i see. well, and here we will try, uh, to build the work in such a way that all these relational functions are checked. uh they uh

violence, violence point character. wouldn't interfere, would n't interfere. e work e business enterprises in general. you are absolutely right in response to all sorts of restrictions that are being imposed on russia and the economy. and you said that it was not supposed that something would collapse in our country, but the goal was set to bring down the russian economy, but it did not work. yes, it really has become, and in this frame it is much more adaptive and more flexible . it turned out that our business is already quite mature and calmly intercepts those areas of the form activities, those enterprises, and er, which are being vacated by those of our partners who have decided to leave russia easily. our our business business takes and leads further than those

enterprises that were just a short time ago. it seemed impossible to exist without a western presence, easy in almost all areas. yes, we understand and see the difficulties. mm medium term . we understand that we cannot produce everything. but you know, uh, how i was talking to some colleagues this morning before, how do you arrive? naturally, i spoke with everyone there in the government at the central bank. uh, so in the administration, after all, our experts believe that this is the peak of the difficulty associated with hmm. and with this wave of restrictions and sanctions, it has been passed. the russian economy as a whole has adapted to the new conditions, much more needs to be done to create new supply chains and to create import-to-export chains and reduce the costs associated with this, but on the whole the russian economy has passed the difficulties

. oh, and we will continue to develop on on on more sustainable on a more sovereign platform. but the answer to all these challenges, of course, can and should be, among other things, and maybe, first of all, sorting out and, uh, the work of the business, supporting it and increasing it. ah, magnification. uh, spaces of freedom for economic activity. so uh, well, alexander andreevich will not get around you. very often foreigners ask us, but what can you offer russia to today's world, where are your nobel laureates, where are your great discoveries? uh industrial scientific discoveries my colleagues

they often answer that, well, how about the great russian culture of pushkin, rubles, icon painting one in russian architecture. they say, well, that's all, it's in the past, but today and at this moment today i listened, i didn't open up what russia can offer to today's world russia of today's world can offer a religion of justice, because this religion this feeling lies at the root of all our russian all our cultures are russian sacrifice, and today russia is making this sacrifice. she exists alone alone alone with everything else cruel western world is leading this fight for justice. this is a huge contribution to today's russia here in the context. uh, the world civilization of world culture, because even those old traditional e values ​​that we talked about are the same ruble russian icon painting and also amazing russian architecture, novgorod pskov and, uh, amazing golden silver

age. they all talked about justice ideology of the religion of justice. we have four traditional denominations. we have enough ata will be this first. this is a joke, of course, it means about doing something, you know, it means that i sit behind your work behind your creativity, when well, there is time with pleasure and i read what you write. speak of course, i know that you are such a real russian patriot in the kindest good broadest sense of the word. uh, do we need to present something specially to someone? i'm not sure about this, you know what you are now

said that we, uh, are sacrificing something in the interests. e many other peoples. i'll argue with you here. we don't sacrifice anything. we are working to strengthen our sovereignty, this is in our interests. this is u first of all, uh, the strengthening of u financial economic sovereignty, it will be the basis of the foundation for our future development of technological educational scientific what is there or not. e nobel. they say it means, uh. well, alferov made his invention, when e means after 30 years there, or how much he was given the nobel series, well, that's it, the point is the former president of the united states and further. e, means nobel in a row. well, this is an indicator of some kind of achievement with all due respect to the nobel, how much is the committee and how is

the owner? uh, so it's a wonderful nobel prize. is it only to show in this, then, uh, science is developing, we must do everything to return and here is the foundation. and from applied science was a multiple higher for our development. and we'll do it at our place today. there is a significant and noticeable renewal of scientific personnel. our science is becoming one of the youngest in the world. yes, of course, the same states. uh, meaning, uh, their uh, their competitive advantages from the point of view of a monopolist in uh, global finance. there, like a vacuum cleaner, it pulls out everything from all over the world, including scientific and creative personnel. well, okay. well, this will also end

with the loss of monopoly on this, it was cheated, like on the world currency. and this will also happen today. you see, and here's what we do it is. very attractive for many countries of the world and peoples, but our western so-called partners are doing everything to slander russia, humiliate her somehow ignore her interests. and when we fight for our interests and do. it's openly honest and uh hmm and let 's just say so manly. that in itself, this fact in itself, this example is extremely contagious and attractive to billions of people on the planet. you look in many

african countries in some countries. russian flags now in latin america the same thing is happening in asia we have a lot of friends and we don't need to impose anything on anyone just many very many people and politicians and ordinary citizens. they are tired of living under some kind of external dictator. everything is already tired. they never see an example of our struggle with this dictator, they are both internally and externally on our side. and this support will only expand. now we talked a lot about science this time. in my opinion , it was one of the most interesting sessions, just about how to develop the science

of technology in these conditions, so here i am ruslan yunosov sitting in the hall. just drew a very interesting picture for us. thank you, today i represent the valdai club with seedlings, vladimir vladimirovich you really said the right words about science. we see that over the past 20 years, support for science has been serious. in russia, the mega-grant program has grown and allowed the launch of dozens, many dozens of modern laboratories in russia, we see this. however, on the other hand, what we see here, as scientists we see that most of the professors who opened these laboratories never came to live in russia and work full-time , and you can even understand why it’s hard to compete here with a 5-year mega-grant. and here you have a professorial position for life. this is really a question, but on the other hand really. we discussed it at the session yesterday and our chinese colleagues have made a truly colossal breakthrough in science over the past 20 years. and today. they occupy not just returned scientists. they returned them. they take first place in many directions. here we are dealing with quants, and

i see that i want to say that we know that the most powerful quantum computer today is in china and not in the usa the maximum number of patents is published in quants by china and not by the usa well, on the other hand, of course, in russia we also have programs that bring together many laboratories. the same quantum project. a quantum computer is a 20 scientific group of 15 universities, universities, institutes of the academy of sciences, but we have 5 years of planning. i think today we faced increased pressure. we really have a challenge to scientific and technological sovereignty and maybe this is the right time to start formulating strategic projects and make the horizon 10-20 years. thank you yes the higher the horizon the better the farther the horizon. better. this i agree with you. we need to look at the positive examples of other countries of our partner friends, including the people's republic of china, a lot has been done there in recent years. under the leadership of the chairman, he

pays great attention there not only to the development of science, but e china as a whole. china's economy is improving the welfare of the chinese people, i know this, we are in good friendly relations. that's where they get real results, of course, um. perhaps the subject of our study and implementation in our practice. as for mega-grants, they really played a good positive role. and uh, the next step that we're implementing right now is not easy. uh, research and creation of separate laboratories. this is the creation of uh scientific uh, communities of young scientists, uh, and uh in this. as a matter of fact, hmm, the future of these mega-grants. uh, i agree with those who initiated this process, we are doing it. yes? andrey alexandrovich here. well, we will continue to do so. you said that no one came,

some come and work. here, even if they are formally listed somewhere there eza. abroad hmm spends most of his time in russia, there are quite a few of them, these are our former compatriots and not only former compatriots who are somewhere on the job, but come to work with us all the time you know, and the world of science just like the world of art, it does not tolerate hmm uh artificial uh border restrictions on people should feel free and we will not lock anyone here, but we will welcome everyone who wants to work in russia on the whole, we are succeeding in this , and we will continue to follow the same path to increase the planning horizon. well , you are probably right, although we have e how many migrants for 5 years now? yes, you can, of course, extend them. these are questions. e question. uh, of course, uh related

budget financing. but it can be done. uh, anyway, for today, we can expand these horizons, although here. this is what you uh said about the fact that somewhere there a person works and occupies some kind of, uh, professorial position. and it's not for life everywhere. why? you, the scientists yourself, know that contracts were signed there for several years, the contract is over, goodbye. be healthy, that's why there, too, it's not all for life. hmm but to live, uh, in uh. hmm, in the uh space of your native language of your culture. it's for life, so uh, it's this freedom of choice that should be given to both children of culture and scientists. we must create conditions that are more attractive than, uh, those that are being created. uh, overseas. this is not an easy

process, so we are achieving results and will continue to move along it, including, you are probably right, and expanding the planning horizon. so bathroom thank you, my name is vanway. i work at the university. this is a chinese university. i visited this time in russia more 20 countries in russia and wrote a number of articles in order to showcase the real russia china many people love russia and you in particular, for sure. you are now with a lot of pressure on your shoulders with a big load. do you feel fear

or nervousness or maybe excitement? fate has created you a second question that you would like to say to the chinese people, and what could you say about the last ten years of russian-chinese relations and what are your forecasts and expectations from the future of russian-chinese interaction. thank you so much. when i work, i never think about some hmm historical accomplishments. i just proceed from what needs to be done and what cannot be done without. this is the most important thing, and in this sense, of course, the circumstances of the country in which she lives she shapes any

person, including me, of course it is. uh, what about? that we should be afraid of someone, of course, probably, many would like to hear me say now, i’m afraid, i would be afraid, but if i was afraid of everything, i would not do anything, but i cannot be guided by considerations. e of this order in the place that i occupy, i should be guided by the interests of the russian people of the russian state and this idyl. and i will continue to do what i consider necessary for the interests of my people and my country, as far as russian-chinese relations are concerned, in recent years over the past decade. they have acquired an absolutely

unprecedented level of openness, mutual trust and efficiency. country dimension of china our largest trade economic partners we work practically, but not practically, but really in all spheres. and in the military sphere, exercises are constantly joint law in the technical sphere, and as confidentially as it can be never before in the history of our countries and have we been working in the field of culture of humanitarian interaction in and in the field of the economy, of course, well, the biggest commodity is russia's turnover - it is with china and it is growing. moreover, it is growing very quickly at a medical pace and the pace - these were dialed even before of any restrictions and distribution of our

commodity flows towards asia, including that side of china, we set certain tasks for ourselves together with hmm and my friend. he talks about me like that, i consider him a friend of mine, a citizen, and we will achieve the exact turnover at a certain level of goods, we are moving towards this at a faster pace than we even planned, as far as our relationship with china is concerned, well, we treat it like a close friend to the chinese people with great respect for their culture and their traditions uh hmm and i'm sure it's building on that solid base. we are confident that we will move forward. as for fears, professor ivan said this year, when since the spring, uh, the

nuclear factor somehow arose, and you pointed out its presence and, in general, many people zoned it a little, remembering your statements. right here, at our event 4 years ago, that we will all go to heaven . we're in no hurry, really. you thought, this is already alarming somehow, and i specifically thought that you are alarming. effect achieved thank you mohammed alexander region of iraq i am very pleased to be here mr. president. i have a direct question for you after the hegemony for

everyone, do you think that at this stage the kurds in all parts of kurdistan will achieve better security, more justice in the future, could you start in more detail on this issue. and as you said in central america in africa, the russian flag is everywhere, there are a lot of people who love russia and support it. i want to assure you that the same i can say about the middle east, there are also a lot of people who support russia or love it thanks. thank you, the final part of the speech of the euro. by the way, in countries and in the states, we also have many supporters there. um, by the way, in the united states there is a very strong part of the people who adhere to traditional values, and they are with us. we know about this as far as the kurds are concerned.

i already spoke not in relation to the kurds, but in general to all peoples. of course, we should strive for a balance of interests only if we achieve the balance of interests of the world can be sustainable, including this also applies to the fate of the kurdish people. so please go on. uh, here's mr. senior in my opinion, yes, if she made a mistake. thank you good evening konstantin old man republic of moldova i uh, hmm, i represent the parliamentary opposition of course the opposition because. well, our power. to the misfortune of our country, our people still prefer. uh, some other itinerary for my, uh, foreign trips. as a result, the lights

in chisinau almost completely went out today, but, but this is not about that. i have a question, but at the beginning of the instructions, vladimir vladimirovich spoke so well about your family that i took the risk of having two children, they are 8-10 years old. they are students of the lyceum named after pushkin in chisinau , they really asked me to say hello to you, and i cannot deny myself this father's little pleasure. so, greetings to you from alexandra and gabriel from chisinau, now the question is, and in your speech you spoke about the inevitability of the emergence of new models of interaction between countries and regions. eh, maybe in this context it has it makes sense to return to the idea that you voiced back in 2001 about a single economic humanitarian cultural space that will e stretch from vladivostok to lisbon for

us moldovans of different nationalities, such a statement of the question. it would suit me very much, because it is always very difficult for us to choose between good and good between europe and russia, and for us it would be a very promising project, and, as it were, the light at the end of the tunnel, but is it possible in the world that we are going to build in the world post the conflict is there in a world that will no longer be the hegemon of the global policeman. dominant powers thank you. is it possible to create a single space for a humanitarian economic yes and a region in terms of ensuring the security of all who live on this vast mega-continent. e from lisbon to vladivostok, of course, yes, hope dies last. uh. it 's not our idea. this is an idea hmm but then

they talked about it up to the urals. in my opinion, i transformed this idea of ​​our french e, colleagues and former french leaders into vladivostok why because people of the same culture also live in the urals? this is the most important thing for this reason. eh, today. yes , these complex, difficult tragic events are happening today, uh, but uh? but in general, why not? in general, it is possible to imagine such a thing, but it seems to me that one way or another it will happen. i spoke about eurasia as a whole in my speech. i spoke about eurasia as a whole, including this european part , you know, it’s just very important. it’s very important that i really want to return to my speech, so that this e european part will regain the right to subjectivity. but that's it.

well, how to talk, er, with this or that world, if it does not decide anything and on every occasion has to call the washington regional committee and ask what can be done? and what not? well, this is how it happens in real life. i remember very uh such here difficult events around syria when they started, well, one of the leaders arrived. so i meet with him and agreed what we are going to do, how are we going to do it? specifically, this is made from us from moscow flew. returned to washington to paris everything is forgotten, as if there were no agreements. well, how to talk about what? and there were direct agreements right up to where the fleet will move there, what we will do, how we agree, we are against, or we agreed. deal. well, how does he

talk? well then, talking to them, she is very direct to call. what are you, is that all? i'm saying now, i'm not imagining anything. you understand, of course, europe defends its interests there, especially in the economy. and even then it didn’t blow up very much. uh, gas pipeline systems. it's not ours. they are common european. there in e. nord stream has one of five bright companies represented. as if it were necessary. there is still enough impudence to show it there. or maybe it was russia that blew itself up, it blew itself up, russia went completely crazy. no, they still do. in my opinion, gazprom published this even pictures of 2016, when under the gas pipeline system lies an american,

in my opinion, explosive device device. they said that they lost during the exercise and lost. so right under e under the gas pipeline. uh, so this grain device came in, which, in my opinion, was intended to destroy underwater mines. listen, well, there are no photographs right now, because the world's media do not even broadcast. nobody repeats this. all of this is dying in the bud. no, neither on the internet nor not, there is nothing in the regions of the screens. this is also the use of the uh media monopoly in order to promote the desired information and kill everything that interferes with them, but it's there. well, everyone is silent, that's why, of course, you need to hmm, you need to create. this is a single space in every sense from lisbon to vladivostok but can this be done only with those who have the right to vote? i don't want to provoke

anything, to offend anyone, but this is such a practice. this is the real reality of today's life here, uh, but it is nonetheless. in my opinion, from a historical perspective. it's possible i've already mentioned this. now i’ll say it again, i once had a horse helmut kohl said that hmm but the states will take care of hmm sometime their own affairs, including there in latin america asia will develop powerfully in its own way, if, uh, european civilization, you want to be preserved as the center of some world center. then, of course, you need to be with russia well, such was the position of hermet kohl, the current leadership of the federal republic apparently adheres to other views. but this is the choice of uh european countries. but i'd like to go back to where you started, you said the lights went out, there it's in the gut, it's unclear. why did he go out. we definitely

have nothing to do with this. well, yes, you know why i am talking about this, because russia is always blamed for everything, somewhere the lights went out, somewhere. uh, the toilet isn't working. sorry, somewhere else , something else is to blame for everything about russia, you know, remember this one in the famous film, and this technique there is some kind of chapel there 12, which century we also destroyed, but thank god. no means, but uh, i want to inform you. and that's what i'll say. what is called pure truth, but when they led negotiations with representatives of the government of moldova on gas supplies about gas prices gazprom took absolutely pragmatic? a market

position for on under a contract with e. moldova on the supply of natural gas gas, which means that the moldovan side did not agree with, uh, the position of gazprom and insisted on price preferences. gazprom rested, so then mr. miller came out to me and stated his position and said that he believes, so his point of view is correct. i asked him. to meet halfway the moldovan side, i mean economic the opportunities and financial capabilities of the moldovan state are something valuable, although fair and from a market point of view, well, not uplifting for moldova if you could not pay in this sense. he

did not really agree with me, but listened to my opinion. gazprom went forward. the government of moldova and concluded a contract for the supply of gas on moldovan terms on the terms of the moldovan side of the moldovan government there are many details. i just don't want to bore the audience, because it 's not for anyone but you. she's not interested, well, there. associated with debts associated with current payments. yes , with a certain prepayment, but in general, in terms of price parameters, they fully met the moldovan side, but you have to pay, of course, on its own. it seems obvious to me why it was brought to the point that there is no light, but this is already sorry, this is not our problem, we remembered, uh, two years ago there was

such an interesting or even less interesting episode when it turned out that when you were not long before the outbreak of hostilities, they talked with president macron, and journalists and all this was broadcast over the speakerphone. they recorded it all. well, such a somewhat unusual form, but okay. you to such things this is not the first time. how do you feel about things like this. negatively, i believe that there are certain formats. uh, communication between, uh, heads of state and they must be observed, otherwise , trust in what the partner does as a whole is nothing reprehensible here. if then, and what are we talking about, what are we talking about, if our assessments reach the representatives of the media , well, just then this is necessary warn. that's it, no warning. well, of course not. yes, on the contrary. uh, when uh, there are telephone conversations, including through closed

communication channels, and we always proceed from the fact that these are confidential negotiations and they are not subject to publicity, or something is subject to agreement by the parties, if this is done unilaterally. come on, it's not nice, of course. and now, when the macron calls, you ask who he has next to him? no? and why would it just be worth it, because now i'm getting out of that someone is listening is understandable. so uh, please, here is a guest in the front row from indonesia. thank you mr president. i really liked your speech. i think she brought us spirit. we can build together build stronger sounds like the motto for the g20. we hope that you will

come next month on the internet, ask you about the heading today security for all mr. tsuna in the fifty-fifth year already said that all security alliances for the world security. can you uh handle getting rid of from natalia together perhaps? everyone loves you very much. in indonesia, everyone is always screaming. hooray uh, and i want to ask if i can take a photo with you later with pleasure, such a beautiful woman with pleasure, so uh. we have had very good relations with indonesia throughout. eh, practically. well, all recent history and hmm uh

, president fedot when he calls me, he addresses me with the words, brother, i tell him the same thing, uh, and hmm we value the relationship that we have developed in this indonesia i am grateful leadership and the president for inviting us to the top twenty. uh, let's think about how we'll do it russia will definitely be represented there at a high level, maybe i'll go. while i'm thinking, uh hmm as far as the creation of new blocks in er. in asia, in my opinion. this is an attempt to transfer to asia the failed system of bloc thinking from the atlantic region and without any doubt. this is a harmful undertaking , this is again, uh, an attempt. uh be friends with someone against

someone in this case be friends. uh, against china hmm, we, uh, don't just not support. here, uh, this is an attempt to revive this or recreate now in the asia-pacific region what happened in the atlantic, but uh, we believe that this is a very harmful and dangerous undertaking. well, i must say, i must say that this has adverse consequences not for the participants or for the allies, er, in the same united states that, as we know, they are being taken away from there. uh, contracts for the supply of submarines, there's something else. uh, it's just that nothing has been done yet, and the negative consequences, including for the allies of the states are advancing. and if this

practice continues, the number of these mistakes and problems will only increase. we, of course, uh, have opposed and continue to oppose this kind of policy. so general sharma, i know i wanted to ask you, right? it's just mr. president's bike. and india has traveled a colossal path of development from an english colony to its current state of almost 1.5 billion people, uh, and the noticeable results of development, uh, cause universal

admiration and respect for india, uh, from everything the world has done a lot in recent years under the leadership of prime minister fashion. uh, he is certainly a patriot of his side. and this is, uh, his uh, thesis, uh body, and in india it matters both economically and morally. india has made huge strides in its development. and, of course, she has a great future. eh, india is not only in the right of the border in that it is the largest democracy in the good sense of the word, but also proud of the pace of its development. e. this is an extremely important base on which india is developing with india a special relationship created or built on the foundation of very close allied relationships

over many many decades. we never had any today. i want to emphasize this never and no difficult questions. we have always supported each other. this is what is happening now, and it will continue to be so in the future. now the pace of economic interaction is growing, eh, prime minister. e fashion asked me to increase. well, for example, as an example. uh, well, first of all, the turnover in generally uh, but as an example uh, prime minister. the fashion asked me to increase the supply of fertilizers, which is very important for indian agriculture, and we did it. what do you think, by how much and sixtieth times the supply of fertilizers in india has been increased by some percentage, and all of us six-tenths of the time, this means that the trade turnover in the sphere has almost doubled. uh, purchase and sale of

agricultural products. uh, we have an ongoing relationship in the field of military technical cooperation and the prime minister. e mod that a person is one of those people in the world who are able to pursue an independent foreign policy in the interests of their people, despite any attempts to restrain something or limit something. you know how, like an icebreaker, it moves calmly in the direction necessary for the indian state. e. i think that behind such countries as india a.c. e. not only a great future, but also an unquestionably growing role in international affairs. we are talking about distribution, i immediately remembered something about brazil, here is igor gilov, where he is sitting there. here, somewhere in brazil, by the way, we agreed on the supply of fertilizer. e,

they will increase, but, unfortunately, it has slightly decreased. i don’t know why, maybe because of the logistics, we have, in my opinion, reduced the supply of fertilizer by a few percent. so well, we have left somewhere. nevermind. eh, then i'll actually ask. what do i know, he wanted to ask, but here they have elections. literally one of these days, we will probably be back. you are on good terms with him, we are on good terms and ignite lulu and my good relationship. uh, with the lord, we will not interfere, uh, in uh, internal political processes. and this is the most important thing, we know that in india, despite the acute political internal political processes, there is a consensus on cooperation with russia, a consensus on our interaction within the framework of the brix for us, this is of fundamental importance. we proceed from this. we also have, uh, consensus on. interaction with uh brazil we consider it uh brazil to be our most important partner in latin

america this is how it is and we will do everything to ensure that these relations develop in the future . we went to briks. there was an initiative just a week and a half ago that saudi arabia wants to join its support. yes , we support this requires a consensus of all brix countries, but saudi arabia is a rapidly developing country and this is connected not only with the fact that it is a leader in the production of hydrocarbons and oil production. uh, this is due to the fact that the crown prince has saudi arabia's government has very big plans, which is very important to diversify the economy. there's a whole national development plan. e is laid out, therefore the direction. this i am sure they will. i mean the energy and creativity of the crown prince, i am sure that

these plans will be realized, therefore, of course, saudi arabia is worthy to be, uh, a member of large international organizations such as the brix and such as the sco quite recently. uh determined saudi arabia's status in the sco and we will develop relations with this country both bilaterally and on multilateral platforms. and now in the west they write that there are a lot of people saying that venza alman is a hamid american because of you. this is not true. so, ben salmanka is a young man, uh, resolute with character. eh, those are the obvious facts. eh, he does not need to be rude and then in response you will not hear harsh assessments from his side. that's all, we must respect both the crown prince and sadovsky arabia itself. eh, and they will answer. the same will answer the same to those who are rude to them like that

mohammed jared yes, and as for us, this is it. excuse me, please. uh, that's bullshit, because uh, the crown prince and all, and the saudi leadership, they uh, are guided by their own emotional interests. when it comes to reducing or increasing production. i know the crown prince already well, personally. eh, so i know what he is guided by. so he is guided, of course, by national interests and the interests of balancing energy markets. in this sense, his position. i'm talking now no kidding, she is absolutely balanced, it is aimed at e, with e at the balance of interests, both producers and consumers. indeed, in the energy markets, it is not even the price that matters. ultimately, this is not what is important, it is the current

economic or political situation for international energy markets that is important predictability. stability is what is important. here is the hereditary principle, which is exactly what it strives for and, on the whole, achieves what it wants. well, that is, you can’t sit on his neck either. no, definitely not. so good mr. president, i convey love and respect due to brokenness. thank you for your emphatic and complete analysis of what is happening. we question is related to the history before the second world war. far away he demonized

everything light of the usa and western europe, then a monstrous holocaust happened, now there is a hate syndrome that is being created around e russians talked about the donbass, how people were treated in the scandinavian countries, neo-nazism is on the rise there. i specifically worked on a project that is related to valuation. numborning a few vices, for example, and before world war ii. secondly, everyone is trying to level it. this means that there is a

need. how do you speak from the russian side of the russian language survey of the russian language of russia is also the need to create a counter plan. this is a serious threat and the last component of the various regions. with conventional armies, so i 'd be interested to hear your analysis, it's very serious europe is facing the rise of non- nazis. thank you. what is one of these serious

fundamental problems? those who allegedly care about the future of ukraine, uh, the so-called ukrainian nationalists. it lies in the fact that even the nationalist movement and not its fascist movement are merging. after all, they rely on those, uh, who, uh, can not be attributed, uh, collaborators and nazis can never be attributed to those who, as i have already said on behalf of the nazi authorities , destroyed the polish jewish russian population occupied during during the second world war of the territory, and uh, it is impossible to separate today's so-called hooray patriots and nationalists from bandera. actually one and

the same here in this, in my opinion. their such. uh, big problem really, and that's why, uh, when i say hmm to our uh, western so -called partners. look at what is happening on the streets in kiev, there are other large cities, when thousands of people with a swastika walk the streets with a torch, there with torches and so on. uh. yes, neo-nazism is also possible in all countries, it is tenacious, such an infection is tenacious, but we are fighting this, and there they support it at the state level. and that, of course, is her problem. hushed up, but it exists and there is no getting away from it, because it is. and well, and today's hurray patriots themselves. uh, ukraine drives them. it’s not even the interests of hmm hmm don’t go and nationalism is becoming more primitive and the

economic interests are hampered by the desire to keep in western banks the billions of dollars that they stole from the ukrainian people stole and hid in western banks and in order to ensure the safety of their capital, do everything that they are ordered to the west, and wrapping it in a nationalist wrapper and, uh, presenting to their own people, as a struggle for the interests of the ukrainian people. that's what is happening in reality, they do not regret and fight with russia until the last ukrainian loses places there. you know , we have this, i talk about it with hmm well, unfortunately, there are losses, sometimes one in ten and one in eight , lately almost always one in seven one in eight. people are not spared, absolutely true patriots of their country can allow this. they are going straight down

this path calmly and don’t even think about it without looking back, of course, not their national interests are felt here, but uh, but this infection of nationalism is tenacious. and they try or prefer not to notice that it is tied to neo-nazism. and this, of course, is a huge problem both for the current ukrainian regime itself and for those who unconditionally support them and, well, we cannot but pay attention to this and will always point to it, including as one of root causes of today's crisis. so mr. kim, here from south korea, i came to the altai club for the second time. i learned a lot. thank you very much for the opportunity hear a lot of ugliness, china and the us may be

contrary to russian interests. thank you. i'll start with the last transition to carbon neutrality does not contradict russian interests, because we have the opportunity to develop alternative species. e energy, including hydrogen, including pure hydrogen, and here we have, e, serious competitive advantages, including the

ability to use gas, well, there are many opportunities. it doesn't scare us. absolutely, on the contrary, they create for us, threw off for development, but and as a transitional energy source, primary gas is the best e, energy historians. eh, you can. if we talk about deep oil refining , then here we are to a large extent. mm. uh, we have those advantages, about which i just said on our interests. this does not contradict our interesting in any way, only the bacchanalia contradicts. the energy industry, uh, getting ahead of itself, uh hmm , in addressing energy security issues related to providing e green energy, well, as it was possible during for many, many years, it is not time to finance to discourage investment in traditional

energy without preparing for this transition to everything related to e, energy green. well , how could this be done? this, to a large extent, is precisely what underlies today's energy crisis. after all, uh, western politicians just talk their tongues in order to win over to their side. uh, voters are first scared of ordinary citizens by possible climate change. then, on the basis of this fear, they begin to promise what to promise. uh, what can't be done receives the votes voters come to power, and then he and what is happening now the return of coal generation? to heating oil so what? we chatted , but the results are not in russia, and we are ready to supply gas. we are ready to supply oil, whatever you refuse. here we have left after the explosion of the

northern streams. one pipe runs 27.5 billion cubic meters. we can pump, but they do n't want to. we don't want to be here. no need. so, with regard to green energy, i repeat. eh, everything should be prepared in due time. here systemic measures that limit the development of traditional species have led to this serious e-crisis. well, finance banks don't give loans. not only uh, it means that the same thing is happening there in europe and in the states. why are there limited?