number one received a message at the city back, butaliev street, a trading house trading on the site of the fire has now left new footage of the continuation of vladimir putin's meeting with members of the council for the development of civil society and human rights. something else while there are two performances and allow it. uh, kargadze, something olegavich, managing partner of the gorgaz law office and partners something olegovich, please, please, dear vladimir vladimirovich dear colleagues. i want to touch on a topic that touches enough be a small number of people, but extremely unprotected. and these are people who are recognized by the court as partially capable or deprived

of legal capacity, the current legislation allows them to subsequently apply to the court for restoration of their legal capacity. but until the court they are restored to their legal capacity. they do not have the right to conclude deals, respectively, to sign an agreement with a lawyer so that he accepts the assignment and represents the interests of the deprived dees. difficulties in court they cannot and therefore this process is for them becomes extremely difficult, we held certain consultations with the ministry of labor of the russian federation and the serbsky institute and the federal chamber of lawyers of the russian federation , they all support the initiative that i now want to voice vladimir vladimirovich, this is the need for a lawyer to participate in this category of cases, including by appointment , and not e by the will of the applicant directly. that is, when a person, uh, submits

an application for the restoration of legal capacity, then his interests must be represented lawyer, including, it is possible to pay for this lawyer should be carried out at the expense of the budget, in my opinion, if you give a recommendation to the state duma to make changes to the civil procedural legislation that considers the mandatory participation of lawyers in such cases - this will make life much easier for people who are in the strength of certain diseases were limited, or deprived of legal capacity. this is what concerns this issue, but i also cannot but say, dear vladimir vladimirovich, a topic that worries any sane citizen of our country. yes, and it seems to me that not only this concerns our fellow citizens. this is besides the frantic russophobia, about which

many colleagues have already spoken today, and you also noted, but the ban on russian culture, dear colleagues. it's, uh, punishing ourselves . that is, okay. they hate everything russian and are trying to turn, and the image of a russian into the image of an enemy, but to deprive themselves of that age-old culture that russian literature has enriched world literature music art. i know that in some countries tried to ban dostoevsky recently there was a scandal at the la scala opera house when they tried to open the season with mussorgsky's opera the ukrainian ambassador to italy wrote a letter about the inadmissibility of opening the season of the opera season in italy of the russian composer's opera. i'm just talking about this. it seems to me that yes. of course, we

must protect our compatriots abroad, but we must also pay justification. i don’t quite understand how, but we must pay attention to protecting that a culture that has become part of the world culture, which is now some. in my opinion, quite stupid people are just trying to withdraw from uh, the world's treasury. well. this is, of course, the sheer stupidity that is going on, er, but somehow protect it for the sake of future generations. i think we should thank you here. olegovich, the first thing that concerns the restoration of the legal capacity of those of our citizens who were once recognized as incompetent, of course. uh, i will instruct the labor of other relevant departments to think over this enemy. e hmm think and uh

offer a solution here money is not about money. the money, for sure, is small from the budget, because how many such appeals there will be, this is the mandatory participation of lawyers both on behalf of the state and at the expense of the state. this practice is widely used and lawyers in the corresponding money. for this they receive the state, but they are obliged for feeling the interests on behalf of the state. all this can be done. we are the details that are related to this who need legal protection, what do i mean, eh, if we make any decisions in this, but, in the sense, including at the level of the law, then it is impossible to limit the possibilities of people. uh, let's say to turn to lawyers with the kind of lawyer

they themselves would like, the services that they themselves people would like to use, including, uh, a lawyer from uh, the same human rights organizations, or the wrong organizations of profile organizations. well, you just need to think about this topic, yes, this is the first second concerning. er, means parts of your question concerning. a russian russian culture, but uh, so we are talking about russian culture, but this is a pickle. will i shoot down russian culture or not at all? and? and the same gogol is a russian writer or ukrainian e. here, e, of course, this is foolishness, as our famous musician said. e valery ramych. eh, that's eh, that means eh. a. they are just fools who

impose such restrictions, but they deprive themselves of a part of world culture. i honestly don't even know if we need or somehow to oppose this why because those who do this are clearly enemies of our country, they themselves harm themselves by their actions. and is it necessary to prevent this damage that they inflict on themselves? the logic is, it seems, as sophisticated, but it seems to me that this is still logic, which, uh, which still has the right to exist. well , let's think, uh, but sane people, including those in foreign countries, of course, understand the nonsense of what they uh, they uh, they do. uh , ruling circles, uh, ruling circles. there, in some countries are doing. yes, the president of turkey, mr.

erdogan, is also on the e, also drew attention to this. he remembered that only the nazis in the thirties of the last century lit books on the classics and classics in the squares and compared. e, compared these actions of the nazis with what is happening in some countries in the relations of russian culture today. and this is a valid comparison. that's when people from outside, and even more so politicians of this level. eh, they turn. uh, attention to what's going on, it even seems to me much more effective than how we're somehow going to always point the finger at this crap that, uh, is thriving in some countries. here, yes. and what happens is, of course, amazing about a surprise. it's true, well, they're hurting themselves.

we will keep in mind. that and those with what and with whom we deal. this means our assessments of their moral qualities, they are correct and this confirms the correctness of what we are actually doing. please, one more performance, it's for us. it's important for us. you decreed irina nikolaevna shishkina, a member of the presidium of the social movement free, donbass, i am a member of the presidium of the social movement free, donbass please, good afternoon, vladimir vladimirovich colleagues, and vladimir vladimirovich, i convey to you the bow of the inhabitants of the new regions of the russian federation for the opportunity to return home. we have been working towards this for many, many years. and finally, this year it happened. for us, this

is a holiday with tears in our eyes. unfortunately. as for the support by the regions , there is nothing to discuss here. our men we have been defending the territories with weapons in our hands since 2014, and the territories of the russian territories are women in the rear, forging victory, and, in general, in the sphere of daily shelling of the regions. we lose civilians every day, we lose children. we are losing starikov every inhabitant, and donbass is now a hero of the same heroine and maria pirogova i am grateful to you that you noted the state award for her contribution to the development of the russian federation and there is such a systemic issue vladimir vladimirovich april 7, 2014 was proclaimed donetsk , luhansk folk republic but for the so-called world community. edelura we remained the territories of the

state, ukraine for the period from april 2014 to september 30, 2022, when we became part of the russian federation, residents of the donetsk luhansk people's republics of the new territories were prosecuted by ukraine for especially grave crimes. these are doctors, teachers , civil servants who did not accept the coup d'état. in 2014, they disagreed with the ruling nazi regime. and these people were condemned by the negotiations. entered into force name of ukraine for such crimes as the state. treason, espionage, uh, financing of terrorism, uh, these are very, very serious articles after reunification with russia after returning home, and information from the law enforcement bases of ukraine, uh. now it means in law enforcement in the bases

of the law enforcement system of the russian federation, and thus it turns out that today 1,000 citizens of russia, residents of new regions, have a criminal record for especially serious crimes, which violates their rights guaranteed by the constitution they cannot, but we cannot be engaged in entrepreneurial activities, be guardians, be elected to be civil servants, and so on, we cannot apply to the courts of the russian federation. convicted by the courts of the russian federation, we are dealing here with the so-called. by the state of ukraine, vladimir vladimirovich, i kindly ask you to consider the issues of issuing a regulatory legal act, which uh will not recognized criminal record sentencing ukraine residents of new regions. they were convicted for political

reasons. and yet, ukraine is not shy about sentencing, uh, 8 1/2 years in prisons in captivity, uh, torturing residents of russian-speaking people just because we are russians . all the top political and military leadership were called guilty of war crimes. ukraine a. given sentences. we sent to all human rights international organizations. however, at that time we did not have an instrument for its execution, since the republics, i have already said, were not recognized. ah, since 2014 , war crimes have been recorded in the regions, it is also carried out by law enforcement agencies, then this work was picked up by the investigative committee of the russian federation and it is also carried out by a public commission, by the way, which colleagues spoke about earlier, uh, by

analogy with the commission in the soviet union vladimir vladimirovich in the summer of this year was very widely announced, and the holding of an international tribunal by the nazis, and valery alexandrovich fadeev made a proposal to create an international commission to investigate the crime of the nazis war crimes, i beg you to return to this issue people of donbass, justice is required. they demand that justice be restored. we do not ask to erase the face of the earth of the city of ukraine, we know what a pain it is. we all experience it. we ask that a tribunal be held so that it could be some kind of inoculation against nazism or this brown plague has stopped its march around the world. the consequences of the crime of the ukrainian authorities, and, if we are talking about ukrainian crimes, in fact, it is the collective west that is fighting

with us with the hands of ukraine, and in addition to the wounded and killed civilians, they also have such a consequence as damage. a public commission has been operating on the territory of the regions for many years to calculate the damage caused by the armed aggression of ukraine according to the state. we now have this amount of more than 1 trillion 321 billion russian rubles. and it's not final. sum. she grows every day. and these are not all objects. we were able to investigate. due to the fact that front-line zones are constantly shelled, there is simply no physical access there. and one of the sections of damage includes the damage caused to the homes of our citizens for 8 1/2 years, our people without a roof over their heads, because their houses were destroyed by ukraine will be with this nazism. they are

forced to live in temporary accommodation centers, rent apartments and travel to neighboring regions. this is a whole labor mining dynasty dynasty of teachers. the doctors of donbass are generally a gunsmith region, and what else i want to note, but according to the norms of international law , the state that is guilty of causing this damage, that is, the state of ukraine, since 2014 , more than 10.000 complaints to the european court of human rights for damages, where the defendant was listed as the state of ukraine represented by president poroshenko and then zelensky however, we are on our own experience saw as a so-called european court. for human rights, it is politicized, it does not fulfill the functions assigned to it by the charter and is not a fair judicial international

instance. and these claims were considered for a long time, and then they were invented on a formal basis. they were returned. ah, vladimir vladimirovich, in this regard, i kindly ask you to consider the issue of restoring the housing of the inhabitants of the region, in particular the territory, and we call it historical until february 24, 2022. these are the people who have been fighting nazism for 8 1/2 years without a roof over their heads. they want to return to their homes to work for the good of their homeland, to live simply to live and give birth to children. well, despite the fact that a very serious condition. now and the circumstances are. uh, residents of russia residents of the region. it 's the daily shelling we're working on. we forge victory in the rear , men at the front defend our homeland. and we will not let you down, the fighters asked you to tell that you can count on them, thanks to vladimir

vladimirovich, you know, first of all. u want to say that the man of your yut is very dignified simply. really and very effectively very effectively even a surprisingly strong man is real. it's true, it's the first, but it's so i couldn't help but say it. and now about the questions you raised. uh, citizens convicted of political residents of donbass, of course, all these cases need to be stopped and this state put to an end due to the absence of the corpus delicti itself and such an order, of ​​course , the prosecutor's office of the general prosecutor's office of russia will, of course, yes, but yes, i am sure that this issue will be worked out. the shortest time the shortest time and the decision will be about public tribunals.

but yes, 18 years old. you said such decisions are made by public tribunes. uh and such. so, even if something is not being implemented today, all the same, such decisions will not be superfluous, and to me its nazi regime. he must receive the action of this nuanced regime must receive his assessment. uh, the same applies to the compensation of ukraine, uh, the damage caused to the donbass residents of donbass to all these territories. i have today it will definitely not be a new territory of russia either. but uh, i agree with you to wait. uh, something is pointless on the part of ukraine and it is necessary to help people who have lost their lives, their uh, living quarters, starting on february 24 of the fourteenth year, when the tragic events began there. i

think it will be necessary to create a separate program to help the people of the housing recovery program. we are now working in those territories where hostilities took place quite recently, including, say, in mariupol, the work is going quite actively, everything must be done so that people do not end up on the streets , the government has such an instruction and the work is proceeding at a fairly fast pace. i hope that people who live in oryol pancake see this. er, this is due to federal budget forces. the federal government, but also at the expense of some regions, including at the expense of uh, st. petersburg, uh, the specialists who work in mariupol and work uh, enough eh, energetic. uh, but the support program and uh recovery, housing recovery in general

to find new territories, of course, will need to be created. we will do this without fail and will help people in various ways to stop their rights, including and above all, uh, the right to a normal human life to housing. here we will do all this calmly in working order. yes, even doubts, there can be a few words to continue the conversation, if permission is in the mouth , alexander semyonovich, and the continuation of the conversation, uh, it is worth paying regions, and such as belgorodskaya uh we also conduct kursk, bryansk region, and the monitoring went out. recently i was in the belgorod region. unfortunately, also regions. e, ha are being fired upon. e are resettling the residents. uh, hmm deep into the regions. he

should note that, nevertheless, stability and peace of mind of the population are preserved, but this also requires additional funds, and the restoration of housing for social accommodation facilities for people, but would like to draw attention to the fact that in the kursk region and the provincial duma developed a special law on border areas, which implies, and additional financial support precisely uh, the aftermath of these attacks to restore the infrastructure. and it seems to me that it would be useful at the federal level, uh, to develop a bill that would provide for additional budgetary funds, uh, specifically for the border regions bordering ukraine , uh, to support regional budgets in order to cope with the recovery, uh,

and i would like to take this opportunity to briefly touch upon transnistria, which is not recognized on the territory, which is now e v the consequence of, so to speak, the aggressive actions of ukraine and moldova turned out to be in fact under blockade, and 200,000 residents of the transnistrian moldavian republic are heard to have russian passports. they sometimes cannot leave the republic and are subjected to humiliating searches at the moldovan border; at the ukrainian border, they are simply either arrested or not allowed to pass. e pressure on producers to limit gas supplies from the side, and the moldovan republic too. it seems to me that it would be worth paying attention to our compatriots and fellow citizens living there one question. and with the question of justice, one way or another

, it was touched upon here. i know that tatyana nikolaevna moskalkova, as experts, is developing e provisions for its creation of a new international court, given that russia has withdrawn from the council of europe and now russians can not use the mechanism of the european court of human rights, but complaints against russian justice . unfortunately, a lot, and he himself was recently in one of the regions of the box office. we were present in court, which means that lawyers watched the process. they filed, well, about 20 complaints. they drew attention to gross violations in the course of proceedings at the first and appeal instances. and unfortunately, the court did not

react to this in any way, and the verdict was upheld. and there were such rude things as well, for example, er. as a translator of the text, a doctor was connected, yes, to a regional hospital in one of the russian regions, that is, an absolutely person without experience without confirming his qualifications. this is just one of the examples, so i would like to know your position on the new international court here and, uh, the question is whether the supreme court should have more contact with our council. and, with expert human rights organizations, it is precisely to discuss those appeals, those proposals for improving russian justice and the last question, and starting from the eighteenth year, and thanks. uh, you got the institute of public observation in the russian elections. it

has proven itself very well and is growing. trust in elections and in the electoral system is growing competitiveness, but it seems to me that it is worth thinking about further development, but of this institution. in particular, i propose that we expand the system of public monitoring of public control. in particular, the function of public control. it would be possible to transfer e to the human rights ombudsmen, the constituent entities and the similar council, and in the regions, the human rights council in the constituent entities of the russian federation well, i think that public control in elections should be extended not only to the day or days of voting, since now voting is used multi-day, but also at all stages

the electoral process, starting from registration , there is also a very problematic moment when someone does not agree to eat, it would be worth it, to hear the opinion of the public, as well as for the period of the campaign. i think public oversight. hmm would increase transparency. uh, elections and trust in them. thanks uh-huh well, i'll start with that very finished, in general, of course, public control at all stages of the electoral process. it seems to me in why not make will make e election process? as you said more transparent, which means will enjoy the result will enjoy the great confidence of our citizens. and what, in turn, will increase? uh, authority, uh, any level of power that has gone through an election. i agree with you. i need to ask for a job. i will ask

the governments and the presidential administration to think about your proposal and make their proposals. so, with regard to the improvement of the justice system. well, of course, we are constantly working to improve the justice system. hmm, and in this regard. eh means e. wanted what to pay attention to? yes, yes, the international court of human rights. there, uh, this is a structure in which indeed many have applied, but we have constitutionality with us. uh is not limited to only uh, that means one system. uh, we have a single justice, though the system of justice is, of course, well, the constitutional court. it exists separately, you can apply to the citizen of the year to apply to the constitutional court. here imagine the constitutional court during menstruation i was recently told. oh, how many requests. uh, moreover, on even very specific issues, he

goes to the constitutional court for the protection of his rights from the citizens of the russian federation well, this does not mean at all that we cannot think about some other institutions, uh, that protect the rights of citizens, of course, think there, you can please , formulate your proposals mine, mine and in the administration. uh, let's look at the relevant assignments there as well. e to other departments that are directly related to the work, and the justice system e about citizens and their rights transnistria citizens of the russian federation well proceeding from above actions, proceeding from reality. we have always turned. attention, all our partners and colleagues, to the need to comply with the citizens of the russian federation living in this territory on the territory of e. as for the socio-economic situation, it is not simple, including the supply of energy resources. uh, we have actually been supplying gas there for free for many years.

free of charge, but lately, since the gas goes through the territory of moldova, problems arise there, everything in moldova has its own difficulties and we see the difficulties are great in economic and sociality, they are blocking blocking gas stands, in transnistria well, not exactly they are not completely blocking, because if they block, then part of ukraine will not receive gas from the power plant, so it's not that they are blocking the thing is, they don't have enough. true, in these conditions they are incomprehensible. why do they store part of the gas, as they say, of their moldovan gas received from us in the buried territory on the territory of ukraine, it’s just necessary with this sort it out, and i'll ask myself a millionaire to look at it to understand. we'll definitely consider the rest of your suggestions. thank you for bringing this to our attention. we've been here for almost 3 hours. thank you so much.