i went to the pre-trial detention center and got my things. they returned the things that lay here in winter.

i have books here literature civil code we have no right to discuss the verdict handed down by judge boris raikis, and there is no doubt about the professionalism of this person for more than 30 years, he has been the chairman of the council of judges of the tver region, an honorary lawyer of the region of the legendary human justice system in 2019 received a prestigious judge of the year award. of the noisy verdict, boris gave the only interview to the local tv channel tverskoy avenue. i think that all

the evidence in the case that was collected and examined during the trial would have allowed the other composition of the court to come to the same conclusion that we have come to. the village of mikhailovskaya and the justification of alexander zabenkov were perceived differently. some consider the young man a hero and protector of the family , others a cold-blooded killer. the correspondents of our program met with many participants in that story and that's how it was. first of all, we will send a doe, borisovna fedyaeva in her yard a ferocious dog barks, not ceasing, despite the fact that he is on a chain, the dog appears after the pensioner was attacked by an unknown person

, it happened six months before the murder of her son, there was a knock on the door at 6 pm. it was already dark, november 10 is police day, yes. i went out to say, who well, the door did not open, something like some kind of semi-childish voices. i thought, someone came, probably, well, maybe a pill like a doctor, maybe a child who got sick? yes , of course, so i opened the door, they immediately grabbed me and began to close my mouth. just don't scream armpits. i didn't even turn on the light. there was no light here either. well, in the mouth there were wounds all around , so they clamped their mouths when they began to wrap their heads with tape. and and. i think, well, that's it, now i'll wind everything up. i and i will die on the pilot , we searched fedyaeva’s house, but we

didn’t find anything of value, and before we left, we untied her hands. after this incident, the children were very alert. they were very scared for me. eh, vasya said, mom, i'll buy you. when i have money, i will install a video camera. i 'll get you a video camera. well, that's it, really vasily petrov never put a camera in his mother's house. and in general, lately he has not often visited a loved one. svetlana borisovna recalls the last telephone conversation with her son and the events that preceded it, how a neighbor's dog attacked her cosmos. and i'm on a bicycle, because my leg is sore. i blocked it with a bicycle and started talking to him, doing something, for some reason you let him out, which means that the dog drove away here and he wow and she came back, she just started digging a bed. well, it's been 15 minutes. here after this case. after this conversation

, the dog runs again and drove. i'm on these braids. driven drove, bye. i jumped out the gate. i don’t look at the braid, i can’t see it, i can’t see the dog. in general, dispersed everyone then. i went oh the fence. here is one time. they say there, just such a ringing was the whole fence. something didn't break. she knocked on the gate once. you are noisy. vasily of course. well, of course, i dialed from my phone. i got my son, i say. vasya talk to misha nosiev, so that he does not poison the goats, the dog does not let the cat save, dispersed all the braids. well, talk to him. tell him to let him go. they will give me goats that it poisons their dogs so much. and the phone was on speakerphone. well, i give it to her, mishustin vasily and i only heard on

the speakerphone. as i told you. vasya, my son, that misha got to the bottom of what you needed at home and he dived behind the gate with this phone and went into the yard. what childhood friends vasily petrov and mikhail vasilyev were talking about, of course, we will never know. but the end of the story is well known. a year and a half later, svetlana borisovna fedyaeva talks about what happened without saline, but listen to her, i’m talking very hard. and where is my son, where is the car? we approached the car. i look on the ground there are two people. my son and another guy i don't

know. well, i have a lot of hands-on experience. there you can already see the face covered with all this loss of blood is great. and the wide one approached the same. the same story. i don’t understand, he was so full of strength , full of life, the grief of a mother who lost her son is impossible to put into words, but it’s just as impossible to blame a person who defended his family, his wife and little daughter from the armed raiders. we are going to visit. yes, his

houses are less than 100 meters away. with daughter veronica what is victory day is a pure holiday a person thinks the sky is heard there right here

well done well , how can such a person be a murderer. 2020 played out that is, you were lucky, here is this metal structure, that is, it was hit, if it weren’t for this structure 100% i would not have gone anywhere further from this place, and what happened if they put a girl, i i evade let her

go, but she ran towards the bathhouse. why did i run here? because the child ran here? i broke through them and ran to the table, ran to the table with the child to beat. i just don't know how to convey it now to speak. i’m starting to shake inside, i grabbed a knife, so we all happened, as we already said. that's about two minutes. that is, it is so scary . all sorts of emotions will show clearly that such explanations for men have become familiar , you can’t say anything. and i’m running, like this, and i

was immediately thrown away by everyone with sticks, these burs. yes, even so. well, i already had twilight pushed away and that's it, two ran to sasha and beat him, despite the fact that the child is in his arms. i was holding my baby at the time. i picked her up and ran here. here misha is covered in blood. i got up. well, in such a way that in the middle he was between my legs and i say that you are doing to stop. i have a child in my arms, and they still continued to beat him. what could mikhail vasiliev say on the phone to his childhood friend vasily petrov than offend him? after all, it was after this phone in a conversation during a bloody tragedy broke out in the courtyard of the zabinkov family. we go to visit vasiliev he lives at the other end of the village. in recent years , mikhail vasilyev has been working as a truck driver and lives with his wife

ekaterina in this house. now the spouses are doing repairs. mikhail is an avid hunter, and this is his faithful friend, a dog of the jagdterrier breed named. wasp it was he who drove the goats of svetlana borisovna fedyaeva. looks quite friendly. mikhail shows us the injuries received during the fight. you don't have to be a medic to understand that damage is he was extremely serious to speak to the camera vasiliev did not have such an agreement with his lawyer, but he explained that in that fight he did not touch anyone with his finger, and in fact he was the victim. and here is mikhail's wife ekaterina pirogova after all, it was she who saved her husband when uninvited guests beat him mercilessly, when they began to beat two of mikhail. and at some point, uh, i ran up and grabbed

this stick, because it was impossible to look at it. and what a normal person will do a fragile woman. what should i to do when he came out bloody, what could i lie and what could i do what should i have done? naturally? without realizing it, i quickly ran up so that he would stop knocking him down that that fateful evening alexander zabenkov made the only right decision and ekaterina pirogova has no doubts about a normal man. that's how it would have done. i think he did the right thing. and if it weren’t for him, then there would be four aggressive ones, they fly in and beat them up and they still had children, they stood quickly, they were doesn't matter. well, get out the gate. if you want to figure it out, go out and behind the gate. well , why did it have to be done in front of children with women and attack like this, uh, four with a stick,

i think that this is generally a horror. just like ekaterina pirogova thinks half of the village of mikhailovskoye, and here's a confirmation of this, we just walked the streets and talked with the locals. we've heard a lot about this situation here. people came to the man in the house, of course, he is protecting. l all right, well, it happened like this. hmm this can't be allowed we need to protect ourselves, who else to protect us. we have children of the family , people with weapons cannot come to the house. there with shovels shot down. i don’t know that alexander is right, we all believe that the entire settlement is considered to be alexander pavlovna barkova, a pensioner in the village

who has been living in the village for almost 40 years, knows everything and her house is located between the plots. we saw him on the first day, as marina brought him, a whole bunch of people, familiar girlfriends, gathered here , everyone hugs him all and says, thank god that he will return. well, of course, of course, we were waiting good guy. yes, it always helps. oh you know the words. no, even such a snotty girl in the spring. but dandelions will appear first. she will see me in the garden, she will pluck and run to me. well, unless such children will be bad parents on the weekend, he doesn’t know everything

he has to do, like a young, old man. everything he has something, that he does something, that he needs something here there, then here everything is a normal guy family, good. here on central street we meet father alexander zybenkov on the one hand. he, of course person interested. here uh. this is your son. if e you were in the same position. how is your son? what would you do? i would do the same thing, i did the same thing, i don’t even doubt anything, because. well, okay, there somewhere, yes on the road or not. they broke into the area. so you think it's true? . if he

didn't. hands how can you say to defend the honor of the mother? he didn't have any other reason. he came to protect his home there, i don't know any relatives. but i got into this the situation fell into a trap. he didn't go to kill. he didn't have a gun, he didn't have a weapon, he didn't have a knife. he just cut. he didn't even kill. he just cut people no matter how bad they were good, he just

cut. i have no other option. well , probably, most likely, i can’t compress you to tell you that he is a killer. well, yes, we do not judge, we cannot. what brand? well, he cut it - it's a fact, and there's no getting away from it, neither to the right nor to the left. he just cut, and not he had to decide whether to cut them or not, despite the fact that the verdict has already been passed. residents of the village of mikhailovskoye do not stop arguing and continue to oppose, and the lawyers of the parties , the defense initially, convinced both the investigating authorities and the prosecutor's office, turning to them with repeated requests to stop the criminal case. because in his actions. we believed that the necessary defense had taken place, and he did. uh,

an act that resulted in the death of three people, but these acts are not legally a crime because. he protected himself, his family, his friends who were with him on the territory of his own house. of course, we believe that it was a murder, for some reasons. by what criteria do we consider that this is murder and in this case the court in our opinion. uh, made a miscarriage of justice. eh, deciding such an acquittal. we believe that in this part the court misinterpreted the actions of the protein, incorrectly assessed all the events that occurred hmm a number of circumstances, generally remained without an assessment of the court without analyzing the judicial e we believe that this is still an essential point, just as i don’t have sentences and referrals of the case for new judicial consideration. now

the relatives of those killed and the state prosecution have filed an appeal in the case, meanwhile, the village of mikhailovskoye continues its measured and unhurried life, and only neighbors alexander zybenkov and svetlana borisovna fedyaeva live like a cat with a dog. e, zabinkov , he came to you asking for your forgiveness there, well, as a human being, he almost came in there. he may be, yes, he may not even be aware of what he's done. i then i think we met on the street. so by chance i saw him, but we did not talk. ah, if yours comes in let the forest go can you simplify? i know all the facts of the case. i

can't understand how it all happened. why did he take up the knife in farewell svetlana borisovna treats us to her own goat cheese .

or maybe now, maybe, now we need to spit on everything and just make peace and live in peace, or maybe, as so many people think. and why alexander doesn’t go, he won’t miss forgiveness for what to ask for forgiveness for the death of my son for the fact that i died that day for the fact that i was not killed my child was not killed because of this ask for forgiveness. well then, excuse me. probably to make my child my family more dead for it apologize. i don’t know, my tongue doesn’t rise to ask for an apology , while alexander shows us a letter that they recently received, unrealistic

children’s handwriting of threats to voice, which we cannot, for ethical reasons, look at it for yourself. heated discussions are the unambiguity of the concept the necessary defenses have been going on for many years. after each high-profile case, rather than flare up with renewed vigor, a proposal to legislate the principle of my house is my fortress comes in an enviable frequency, and the established judicial practice. we talked to well-known russian lawyers. i would like

to say bravo to the court, because there really were practically no such acquittals, god forbid you would be in a similar situation. as our tver hero, what would you do? i probably also i defended myself to the last, because after all, this is the principle, my home, my fortress, this principle should work. it doesn't matter what the attacker had, a stick, an object like a gun, a knife, it doesn't matter. if i perceived a real threat. i have the right to use anything to repel an attack up to the decision of his life, if there was a fatal outcome. uh, hmm and someone killed someone. you see, the one who killed someone is the one who is killed. he will not testify in court, therefore, the person who

survived. well, let's say the owner of the house, yes who was attacked, he will tell his version. if you keep, if he can convince with his lawyer. it was like that then, yes. zabinkov's body reminded us again, and not the unambiguity of legislation in such a delicate legal area as self-defense, on the one hand, in the criminal code, such situations are clearly spelled out in three articles. this is a necessary defense causing severe or moderate harm to health when the limits of necessary defense are exceeded. and, of course, the murder committed when the limits of necessary defense are exceeded. the latter punishable by corrective or forced labor for up to 2 years, or imprisonment. for up to five years

of pedaling, that the very concept of self-defense should include. both self-defense and helping others, and in the broadest context near the castles. ka, by the way, had every chance to go to jail for a long time. that's just the trial of him, despite the initial charge of murder, was perceived by society. how are things with clear signs of self-defense? this is how we saw the story of alexander zybenkov, who, defending his family, killed the attacker.

it was our investigation from the village of mikhailovskoye, tver region, the conclusions of the cases are only for you. see you on russia 24 tv channel

. there are differences between a man and a woman. i noticed then that my husband and my cat are the most intelligent beings of orientalism. this is conditionally some kind of parallel agenda , continuation of conversations on new releases of our

podcasts, so as not to miss anything. subscribe listen and watch the video.

ukrainian militants attacked the settlements of donbass most of the shelling of the last hours fell on donetsk six times they fired 24 large-caliber shells from nato barreled guns with the same weapon, the militants fired at yakovlevka and yesenovataya, and they hit ilovaisk from american multiple launch systems. fire highmars. seven rocket explosions were counted in the city, the average destruction and possible victims are specified in the lugansk people's republic in these minutes, doctors are fighting for the life and health of the wounded during the saturday shelling of a hospital in a new gift, 24 people were injured 14 people were killed the russian ministry of defense called it a grave war crime those involved in it will be found and held accountable by the first deputy permanent representative of russia to the un dmitry polyansky stressed that the us was directly involved in the strike