a kamaz car today is more expensive than a finished truck of similar characteristics delivered from china to the russian federation once again, the metal from which we will make a kamaz cost is cheaper and more expensive than a finished truck. and why? and, because it is profitable for us, uh, to supply all raw materials abroad, but from china, uh, which is now the number two economy, until it will very soon become the number one economy, they have differentiation, if you sell raw materials, no vat square for you and we have for the fact that our oil and gas are leaving. uh, for export almost two trillion rubles are returned to oil and gas partners. what a fright . this is a huge reserve, and in this regard, when the government is negotiating that the business chipped in and 300 billion rubles. invested listen, well, it means that these 3 months will be a long time , negotiations are already underway, it is better to force them to stop in a completely different way. the issuance of

value-added tax and in general , protective barriers are needed for the export of our raw materials, we need to process them. and if we are to trade, then with goods with increased added value, including at the expense of ah intellectual labor retention very well said the president. but, when we now see that the government. the ministry of finance is preparing an order for a government decision that some companies can receive exemptions and receive subsidies to receive orders from the state and at the same time be offshore. well, come on, if you work, uh, in russia, everything should be here in russia and in our faction it should be included in the bill. and we say directly, let's give half a year, if someone does not return, uh, all e to the legal system of russia, then then, as a wireless economy , the state takes all this for itself, because with these , and gentlemen. not a secret. uh, look at

forbes data out of 111 dollar billionaires, more than half have dual citizenship. we understand, and the president has already spoken about this. it's leverage. they have companies , they have working people from these russia, and they will influence and influence and influence very strongly there, but we don’t know everything, but we can only guess, the third topic is long-suffering. indexation of pensions of working pensioners. i i won’t get tired and my party comrades have not tired of repeating unfairly for the seventh year already. and there is no indexing. ok then. there is no money needed there, in my opinion, there are 600 billion rubles. listen. well, let's, as economists calculate, there were 14 million working pensioners before the end of indexation. now about a family, where 7 million, and everyone, if the state. that's right, well then, we also

and let's figure it out. and how much if 7 million rubles. work with pensioners worked if they received indexation, how much would be taxes from the payroll by random vat rub 2.4 trillion that this money doesn’t need e , we need the budget, so at least from this point of view. i leave social justice out of the equation. probably you need to look and still returned to a fair indexation of pensions for working pensioners. uh, two words about the false victory over poverty. but why are you fooling yourself? well, why did rosstat change the methodology? eh now? well, listen, well, it doesn’t happen like that in conditions. ask we all deputies receive letters about how hard people live. yes support presidents and thank them for it supports the special, but life is very hard for 5% decreased retail sales of food people on saves on food. and what about rosstat? in

the quarter of 2022, there are 2.9 million poor, and in the fourth quarter, from only 11.6 , it has become two times less. wow. it's great how people see everything on their wallet and understand that it's completely wrong. well, one more time. uh, let's go to the graphic policy. our offers. i will not repeat myself. uh, it is necessary to solve these issues, i can not help but to say that here are our long-standing proposals for a fair basic income, now is the time. let's start, uh, with a special military operation member of their family members. here let's let them know, under any conditions. they will return, guaranteed jobs there. they will receive a basic income for their family and the necessary money, and will not receive large families in the next stage in order to really deprive the demographic problem. well, education. and the fact that u higher school is happening uh. well, that's when i'm trying everything. index of efficiency, but

listen to a student who does not have time to kick out a dunce without a hole. all of you are inefficient, so everything hits you, listen, but who will we raise then, what kind of specialists will we have. well, once again about the long-suffering unified state exam. i am grateful, but mikhail also speaks to mishustin at the meeting with the faction today, of course, you need to weigh the pros and cons. here, dear mikhalych, you said, uh, that from the most remote, uh, corners of our country, thanks to the unified state examination, they can enroll, uh, children in any universities well, let's tell the truth, well, firstly, an increase in minutes. well, first of all, not many universities have written so-called interviews practically for them. and now look, we need engineers, engineers - this is mathematics, which means, uh, in order to pass here, that e is not basic, but advanced, which means there is no school curriculum there. there are more than half of the questions there is no school curriculum, only a tutor. who can afford a tutor? who has money, and we have

a social stratification in hereditary poverty and further when it is said that sending a child to a school there in moscow in st. petersburg somewhere again, if there is a family, money, a hostel, no one will give, and how the judges were to live and it turns out that someone there is money for a tutor so that they get a good higher education, and the rest. well, and most importantly, we offered an alternative alternative and say, well , let's think, why don't all large cities have universities from teachers universities do not create an independence commission here this the commission has been taking an exam in russian for a whole month, this is in mathematics. this is an applicant in physics, nobody knows who you will do. he will pass the exam, they will give him what you passed for such he will send there are alternatives and it is necessary, of course, to decide this. well, uh, finishing, i want to say, nevertheless. we have claims, as you understand , there is a certain claim to the financial and economic block to the social block of the government, but in general, we think it is necessary to recognize the work

as reprehensible and, in general, the government cope with the tasks that our country faces in our economies. thank you sergei mikhailovich new people faction aleksey gennadievich nechaev getting ready andrey mikhailovich makarov dear dream viktorovich dear vladimirovich dear government colleagues at the meeting before the government's report and today we were convinced that we were in agreement with the government. in the main , russia needs economic and technological independence. we already have a colossal backlog of the best technological platforms. large ecosystems of yandex savings vkontakte today in russia are the best internet banking in the world. thousands of modern internet companies have been created by creative and

free people, and losing such people is worse than oil revenue oil is minus $ 50 of income, but each lost professional is minus 10 years of knowledge experience. for the development of russia , the mineral industry is the sovereignty of russia today , some of our specialists have gone abroad. for various reasons. we should not put labels on them or close the way home, the government is doing the right thing not to frightens those who left the country do not tax them with extra taxes - these are decades of education and experience; it is important to return them, it is even more important not to lose those who stayed and work in the country, and they are the majority.

we need to invest in our people to develop practical education supports start-ups to train specialists from tomorrow to create such opportunities for the country that those who left would envy those who remained the west expected that sanctions would deprive us of our usual way of life, but our entrepreneurs bypassed all the fences provided the country with everything necessary to prove that they can be relied upon. let's now we are representatives of the executive branch. let's help our producers. today there were words about smart protectionism. there is a very simple logic in raising duties on consumer goods for foreign companies from unfriendly countries. let's instead of what they will pay. income taxes at home, let them pay duties. here we want to trade in russia. let our

manufacturers pay, they have long learned to make high-quality and modern goods. let's we will help them and free up space for them on the shelves of stores ; thanks to the government for sharing this approach. it gives new jobs just a salary, a new quality of goods and a quality of life. and most importantly, a sense of pride in their country. it is this approach that needs to be protected for the freedom of entrepreneurs. is promoting the new people party and is already implementing the government. you have done a great job of reforming control and oversight activities. when you make a turn from punishment to prevention of violations, inspectors

, unusually for themselves, begin to come to enterprises not to check, but to explain the mandatory requirements , it became easier for entrepreneurs to work after the introduction of a moratorium on inspections. last year, 240,000 inspections were cancelled. this allowed the business to save more than 200 billion rubles. the mechanism of obligatory before judicial appeal. now. this is done quickly and simply through public services and saves everyone time and money allows businesses to work more calmly, expand, raise wages , and there is no need to stop if the government continues to expand reforms and control over supervisory activities. we will support your legislative initiatives in this area. last year, the government forced the work of development institutions by almost 50,000 entrepreneurs in small and medium-sized businesses . last year, they attracted 800 billion rubles. through

tools, national warranty system operated by an sme corporation. in the twenty-second year, the industrial development fund financed production projects for 140 billion rubles. this is 2.5 times more than in 2020 or 21, but given today's challenges facing russia, even this is not enough. the industrial development fund and the sme corporation spend their limited resources carefully and wisely, but they need to at least double the amount of funds for cheap loans for business, i am sure if the government comes up with an initiative such adjustments in the budget, you will be supported by our faction and all the deputies, new production facilities are opening all over the country; domestic demand has been maintained and is growing among small and medium-sized

companies. there is a huge potential for development ; they need additional sites to expand. we need modern offices. at the same time , millions of square meters of state and municipal real estate are idle in the country. abandoned sanatoriums for children's camps in the industrial zone, first floors of municipal buildings. the time for the premises in russia to be empty has passed if you provide them entrepreneurs can solve two problems at once to increase the efficiency of the use of state property and help business. we suggest that the government get involved even more actively. with this issue on the agenda, then state property will cease to be a burden, cease to be an expense, and development will not work for the development of the country for growth. the quality of life of our citizens need not only give confidence. people with tomorrow. well,

inspire them. we often hear. uh, on tv. we have in the hall here the question is what does russia need a state ideology? national idea? yes, it is not needed. it is actually possible to find the russian dream somehow else, but these are very simple understandable values. these are people who want to be free and work with interest, when the initiative is not punishable. i think everyone has heard proverbs in russia that the initiative is punishable. let's make it stop being our proverb. this is equality of opportunity, when everyone can succeed in realizing themselves in life and this is prosperity , a prosperous life for their family for children for grandchildren. today, many politicians are in favor of no rich people in russia. we are for the fact that there were no poor. it is very important that every person in russia knows that in whatever

region and in whatever family he is born, if he studies and works hard, he will succeed, knowledge, experience and well-being will build a happy healthy family. there is always a person behind every great discovery and scientific breakthrough. those who are not afraid to dream? such people have made us leaders in space in today's digital economy. today this developments. we use every day. we must continue both in space and in science and in artificial intelligence. building on radioelectronics in medicine we need russia's leadership in the high-tech world of the future, i am sure that we will not agree to anything less. thank you thank you alexey

gennadyevich united russia faction andrey mikhailovich makarov please andrey mikhailovich your final speech then mikhail vladimirovich's closing remarks dear person dear colleagues vladimirovich colleagues let me remind you in january. in 2020, the president set the task of creating a completely new mechanism for interaction in this government, to raise, regardless of the level of power of the branches of government, the mechanism of interaction to a qualitatively new level of work on efficiency. this is the only way to solve the problems that the president has set we must solve to improve the quality of life of people, and this is the main result of the government's work over 3 years. i am specifically talking about three years now, and not just the previous

year - this is the creation of a mechanism that can effectively respond to any challenges. the main result is that those decisions are that those decisions that used to go years ago today from the idea, and its elaboration of implementation in the law of implementation. life goes on for weeks, or even days, and most importantly, a feedback mechanism that allows you to actually decide in real time what needs to be tuned. this is the new effective level of work of all branches of government. but last week, the president, speaking at the congress of the rspp, said we need to go further. we need to create a new qualitative level based on new technologies based on digital opportunities. quality the effectiveness

of the government's activities should grow and today it is very important that the government's report is not a bravura report on achievements. although really. i think everyone will agree that a lot has been done. here's just one listing showing how much has been done in all industries, there really is no cap on physical giving sentiment. there is an understanding of the tasks that we face and their complexity, and therefore a detailed development. how to solve these problems in the future, therefore, on in fact , i cannot agree with sergei mikhailovich mirovov when he says that there is no strategic thinking in the government in the government does not offer any strategic developments. we talked about this a while ago, and by the way, the government's report in the state duma is always there. it creates huge opportunities for new high-quality solutions, and we said that

in addition to reflecting on sanctions, a vision of the future is needed, but haven’t we seen it today. this is the future, as the government imagines it, what is being proposed. well, let's remember the priorities. and what if not the future fulfillment of all social obligations, regardless of sanctions, perhaps the implementation of the president's address. this is not a strategic future for our country. is the achievement of national goals. i will not now name the figures that are in all these funds that are allocated. this is not a strategic vision. in fact, the structural transformation of the economy is an emphasis on technological sovereignty. isn't that a strategy. here today. you and i have heard everything, how the government sees it. and what the main thing for this needs to be done and in what time frame it will be done, huh? isn't it strategic?

what matters is the annexation of the regions, the defense capability of our country , the care for the families of those who are there today, because in fact, no matter how hard it is, it is still the hardest thing to wait there. and this is caring about people. isn't that strategic thinking. today we heard about all this for united russia, which was very important throughout the previous year. this is the fulfillment of the people's program with which the party went to the polls. just because the people's program and the day of russia are not only the message of the president. this is another 2 million wishes of the people that they said are the needs of the people. and look at how this was resolved, because it is very difficult to say today, because all this year we have been working on the implementation of this program together with the government. well, look at the cost of materials. so, reduce the number of school buses. no, the government finds money, adds funds and we increase the number of buses. i can name the figures that we have made in the twenty- in the twenty-second year. well, i can call

the number that we are increasing the number of school buses, 23 the same. faster than schools to repair schools to build new schools. colleagues, this is the result of the work of the government. the main result is that despite the real blow that was inflicted on our country, the masks have been thrown off. if we've been told it's not against the people, no, it's against the people. here, the main thing is that we were able to protect people from this blow and continue to do so. i think this is an assessment of the work that the velo government really wanted to pay attention to last year, but i would not like to dwell on the fact that everything is fine. look, parliamentary control parliamentary control is a necessary element. here is the effectiveness of this mechanism. this is feedback. here is a simple

example, remember, when the budget was going on, all the committees considered each state program in detail, and now, before the report of the government, the minister, the vice-premiers, they worked everything out in their committees, then there is a norm of the budget code that by april 4 all state programs must be changed and must be adopted, everything is fine. everything is fine, but there is only one more law, the law on parliamentary control, that these programs , before they are approved , must be sent to the state duma so that the same committees can see how the results of their work are put into practice, the government has done a brilliant job . it has shortened the time frame. it says before april 1, everything is done to you before january 1 in electronic form only in the state duma of forty-five programs received only seven. i, you know, for interest called several ministries, they asked, they almost sent something. you know, the answer is amazing. what was needed? so colleagues. let's

come to an agreement, and as far as i know, the leadership of the government directs all employees towards this. this is not only a minister, because in fact the government in a broad sense is not only ministers. i am the deputy prime minister. this is everyone who is doing this work, they should all understand that parliamentary control is not a stone, who wants to get around, and this is a tool that improves their performance, the next question for us. it is very important, these are regions, in fact. i think that, together with the government, throughout the year i was implementing the most important instructions of the president. how to reduce at that time, remember commercial loans; practically today, commercial loans at these huge interest rates to zero, we have practically replaced them with budget loans, but the main mechanisms created are real mechanisms. support. remember how the funds were allocated, but the rise in the price of metal. e, in order to support the facilities that are being built in the region and these funds went to the regions went to support, moreover

, a mechanism was created that, if the regions were not called restructuring. here is the restructuring of the most important situation, mikhail vladimirovich said that they were released in the twentieth year, in general, they created a mechanism from payment at the same time that if you direct the funds that you have left for the implementation of the construction of these facilities in this case, they are written off from your main debt. that is, we essentially gave the opportunity to use these funds for the regions so that they could fulfill their social tasks and build their own facilities. it is definitely very. by the way, remember we talked here. two years ago we talked about the need to give more from the financial possibilities of the regions to give more freedom. here mikhail vladimirovich supported this proposal then. we then introduced these norms on a temporary basis. e, not in some kind of budget, but the law on the features of execution last year, having analyzed all this together with the government. we have seen what

appears to be. these are the norms of the budget code that liberates simply. e, removed from the regions confused. for this, it turns out that the region is carefully used, no one is a hooligan. nothing terrible happened with the government either. we are with you last year these norms. already included in the budget code on an ongoing basis, and the program to support ten regions, individual programs. after all, this is what actually was the initiative of vyacheslavich, supported by mikhail vladimirovich and in the most difficult time the government has found 50 billion to support this region, as the study of the counting tents shows, by the way, the development of these regions. here are those that are being carried out at a rate higher than the regions, which means that the program was a success, but 2 years remain in the forgive program. here is another one. let's think about what makes the next situation change. if this mechanism is good, let's extend it to other regions. by the way a. you know that the ministry of economic development supports this proposal with pleasure, but there is one more thing.

colleagues. we have exhausted the possibilities of supporting regions only through customization. e budgetary legislation. today , we should talk about targeted support for the regions , specifically financial support. and, of course, what is very important should be the predictability of the region. after all , in order to support the business of someone else, we give various benefits from the federal level. and these are falling incomes of the regions. let's still work through the issue that if we decide something for the region from the federal level, let's compensate for this with the region completely 100% colleagues really can not say. you know, here you were talking about business, because there is a lot of work on control activities. e in order to help businesses do. well, you know now i wanted to say about accountants, and accountants are insulting accountants, because no one will remember anyone except the ministry of finance and the budget committee. meanwhile, as an accountant, we have more than three million in our country. and in the 1990s, in the 1990s, it was decided

that our reporting is built around but no one is against it. some people really need ifrs for those who work for export, deal with external relations , and so on, but today , by the way, we are bad at these standards, translating them into russian from english, we are already dragging them into our standards and extending them to budgetary institutions. we distribute them to non-profit organizations and you will laugh at the latest solutions. add more minutes. we are killed by the political parties of a colleague. well, why is it, why? i understand perfectly well that the authors hope that when everything will be fixed? but these chickpeas will not change and will not return, so let's not at least torture accountants. here is my proposal. i offered to work it out anyway. nobody, i repeat, proposes to kill what has already been done. well, finally.

you know the last thing i would like to say is actually very difficult. yes, uh evaluate the work in which we all took part. well, now i would like to say once again united russia is ready to continue joint activities, joint work with the government with the government, aimed at to solve the problems of our people, but to improve the quality of their lives, moreover, we are ready not just to work together. we are ready to be jointly responsible for the results of this activity and responsibility to our citizens. thank you andrey mikhailovich dear colleagues speech of political factions took place the floor is given to the chairman of the government of the russian federation mekhov vladimirovich mishustin to answer questions raised during the speech of representatives of political factions

enough. dear vyacheslavvich, dear colleagues, first of all, i would like to. to apologize to the deputies who did not have time to ask their question and where the person told me now they gave me a list of lord kharitonov koshelev aksakov plyakin right barahoy in kalashnikov lugovoi anan hot and isaev i invite you to the government, where we can talk here to ask our questions. i promise that i will answer them, because it's, well, somehow inconvenient. and now we have advised the vyacheslavovichs here. colleagues, i thank you for the informative constructive assessment of our work for criticism. we have said a lot of thanks here, we understand that everything

that we want is not always achieved here, but we are trying to achieve the national development goals set by the president in a balanced and systematic way, and i will briefly comment on each speech, well, on the speech of gennady andreevich zyuganov, the communist party of the russian federation has consistently advocated the strengthening of russia's technological sovereignty for many initiatives. together, i believe, we are working on such important areas, as support, and for our agro-industrial complex, the development of agricultural territory has many, many technological issues. sovereign this for the development of industry and various sectors of the economy in this regard. everything is clear, of course, but i want more. we also remember what happened in the soviet union and everything is correct, but today hmm it seems to me that it is also important to understand how to do it, because there are a lot of questions from what was lost.