the resort from no one saw the case went to court, meanwhile, local journalists found out about this controversial story. one of them is andrei trofimov, a reporter. filmed dozens of stories, in search of truth and i started working with witnesses with grandmothers. yes, to the grandmothers, who, as it were, identified anastasia there from photographs or somewhere in person, when they were there with the help of simple manipulations, and the investigator, yes, was literally pointed at nastya, and now the grandmother, says the judge says, this is not her. the judge is correct. she says yes, definitely not her. and so the judge speaks. and who will return the money to you, if it's not she, she says. what difference does it make, grandmother, she says represents 90 years. she says, yes, what i like, that the money will be returned to me, if this is not the right person, she will simply judge the innocent. uh, woman, let her car go. hello, tell me what you said to the judge about anastasia ivanovna, did you ask something to let her go, right? judge lilia baranova

listened to the arguments of the defense and anastasia ivanova was betrayed by the world of restraint and released home, but so that she would not actually run away on her foot an electronic bracelet, but the charge was never dropped, which the victim stated that he did not seem to be on trial. no, your position has not changed in any way, i will not comment on anything without the consent of the superior. it’s not my fault, to be honest, i waited a very long time for the last word i waited a long time, to be honest, i didn’t think that it would come to this last word, but finally, she became my hour when i can speak out. you have every proof of my innocence. lord , there is not a single proof, why am i guilty, the investigator fabricated this case

one witness. not one would not say that they took a court session, they did not say that it was javanula. she did not admit, definitively the punishment was seen, which was not particularly two years or fines and without restriction of freedom. it is clear. immediately after the verdict, anastasia ivanova , together with our film crew, went to visit the same grandmother galina timofeeva , who, according to the judges, was robbed by the girl.

and this is not the end of the story, the consequence was the husband of anastasia ivanova gasan adaev, allegedly he also deceived pensioners, and in the same sergiev posad urban district. i do not agree with our investigation, which is not carried out objectively according to the version of the investigation at the crime scene. the dna of the man was found and the operatives decided everything converged to gasan adaev. i had to do several independent examinations to prove that

his dna and the traces of the probable criminal are completely different. we cannot and are not going to challenge the verdict of the court in order to dispel all the rumors around this case. we tried to talk to judge baranova, especially since according to local journalists, investigator kryukova and judge baranova allegedly have known each other for a long time and even live in neighboring houses. that's just the dialogue did not come out. good morning. my name is sophia sofia

program investigation of eduard petrov how can you comment on the verdict, if for a new one you do not doubt the correctness of your decision? ivanova several times tried to appeal the court's decision, but the appellate instance left it unchanged.

proof of his innocence. and filing is not a sentence. ivanova was not believed here. the verdict of the sergiev posad city moscow region on december 6, 2021, the appeal ruling of the moscow regional court on march 22, 2022 in relation to ivanov and anastasia aleksandrovna , will leave unchanged the cassation complaint of the defense lawyer kondratyuk, the representatives of the injured commissioners, lawyer unikov, without satisfying the court decision. understandably condemned to you. clear judgment. the criminal case is sewn with white thread so considers the girl's lawyers.

now to seek justice for anastasia ivanova will be the supreme court of russia, the meeting is announced more more luxurious views and bold styles more energy and metropolitan pace more business opportunities and for yourself more knowledge and smart technologies more square meters and parks kilometers donstroy for those who expect more from moscow left you to remember where your card is now a button, st. petersburg it doesn’t matter where it is, and paying for purchases is not only convenient, but also beneficial without getting up sofas have never been so comfortable. pay for purchases using the sbp button at the partners of the promotion and get a withdrawal . svetlana now knows for sure that there is a park in the city center sergey vitalievich wanted a new square. playground to influence

the beautification of your city. maybe everyone choose a project and vote for its implementation on the site outside the city unlimited access. you croak, it's still that translator. let's better i will transfer it to high-quality internet, beeline's mobile internet has become twice as reliable as beeline is on your side. pay less card have credit we will be looking for 145 days without interest on all purchases.

behind this sign is the real shirinskaya school and really interesting classes, where real fifth graders are passionate about their first discoveries of more than 14,000 points of growth in small towns throughout russia , a national education project that matters here and now. and you can in six months 180 days without interest? only in alfa bank, 20% cashback for purchases in supermarkets with a free

alfa bank credit card. order a card today and we we will instantly deliver it to any point in russia alpha-bank is the best mobile bank.

the beauty licks you, thinks such an idyll could not have been a career as a lawyer, the story of drugs almost crossed out. 13 years ago, he was accused of possession and sale of a prohibited substance, the error of the investigation and the court cost arthur dearly, he spent 3 years in a strict regime colony. in november 2010 , at the entrance to the city of lyubertsy near moscow, at the traffic police post, the car of the lawyer artur hi was stopped.

i felt that they were breaking me from both sides hands, that is, they wring their hands, put them behind their backs, shackle them in handcuffs and drag them by force, two men dressed in civilian clothes, dragged me across the road. uh, they put it in the bushes near the lamppost. near this traffic police post opposite the traffic police post at this very moment, when there were no witnesses yet, but just these two employees. as it turned out, after that they were employees of the economic security service. i saw one of them put me the outer pocket of my overcoat, rolled up into balls of

some sort of polyethylene material. i tried to get up somehow. uh, well, it's very uncomfortable to get up when you're lying with your legs spread; worse with attesting witnesses during a search of a lawyer, they found the same bag in it was amphetamine. the young man was taken to the department. they began to offer me to write a sincere confession that i was engaged in the systematic sale of narcotic drugs, that supposedly everyone knew everything about me, that i was a malicious huckster and an odious drug dealer. well, i never considered it unacceptable for myself to admit to something that i did not do, therefore, at least i was beaten in that moment, uh, burned my hand with a red-hot knife, despite the threat of torture. arthur prel did not

break down and continued to insist on his innocence. all. this time, the relatives bit by bit collected information about the likely customers of the case against the lawyers of the luberetsky district, according to which there were fake documents for the land plot. he unearthed the whole thing at that time there he went to court. and the court had to just substitute these documents. here, uh, and this situation happened. arthur, he defended the interests of ordinary citizens, and on land lyubertsy region. uh, there were his clashes, well, not physical, but purely documentary with the administration of the lyubertsy district and , uh, with a number nearby, but of entrepreneurs who had millivites for these land plots, a, and who planned to build residential buildings there, or there, uh, some then more buildings.

ah, but they were hindered by these people, to whom these lands were allocated plots and who were not going to part with them , they were really tired of seven structures that had views of these lands , employees were connected, and those who worked in the state nart control. but then these were only assumptions themis was interested in dry facts. case materials and in 2011, the judge of the lyubertsy city court mikhail milushev found guilty the horror of fear that day was my birthday, just the day before my birth we declared my son 8 years in a strict regime colony, of course, it was very scary, but my husband said, so we cry one day. today we cry. and tomorrow we start working. arthur april was sent

to a colony in the city of bezhetsk, tver region, but even there the lawyer was not at a loss on the day of the devil mittens, and in the evenings he taught english to convicts, played the guitar and even organized a kvn team. here is a fragment of the performance. meanwhile, the relatives of the convicted lawyer continued to look for evidence of his innocence; they wrote to all government agencies and reached the well-known journalist,

boris reznik, who at that time was a deputy of the state duma of russia. unfortunately, boris lvovich died in 2018, but his assistant remembers these events well, but it was an ordinary day, he fell out to receive deputies. well, that is, boris ivanovich became interested in this story. at first, she

was somehow skeptical about her, because, well, it can’t be that a man was sent to jail for 8 years for no reason at all. well, i decided to make requests like this to check how true this is. i got acquainted with the materials of the criminal case, it turned out. the only evidence of an allegedly violent drug trade is a bag of a banned substance found in his pocket, and the detention protocol clearly states that this is amphetamine even before the conclusion official expertise. further more in the case, there is no explanation of how law enforcement officers learned about arthur's criminal activities.

and why, in fact, they were waiting for him at the traffic police post in lyubertsy, near moscow, and the information that prel regularly sells drugs is not supported by anything in the papers, only a reference to operational force number 13 is contained in anyone, but, as the deputy found out, the prisoner of this case simply never did not have. now the investigation is underway, about ten people have already been arrested. this proboscis in uniform who planted drugs. he is the leader of this gang, who did not steal cars and plant drugs. we are talking about an officer of the moscow region police, ilya yukhman, and the son of the ex-head of the central internal affairs directorate of the moscow region, yuri yukhman. at one time, the general was a very influential and authoritative policeman, the suburbs once fucked my youngest, he served as chief of police , first in the city of lyubertsy and then noginsk

came under investigation, he was charged with falsifying criminal cases and concealing a crime. not only that, go to court, let's go, ilya's subordinate who, according to the investigation , just planted prohibited substances on citizens. in march 2014, the supreme court overturned arthur prel's sentence due to numerous violations. and after themis found the lawyer innocent, he was granted the right to rehabilitation.

as for ilya yukhman, the investigation found out that he was absolutely innocent and, of course, became a victim of a slander. now the officer holds the post of head of the regional department of the ministry of internal affairs of russia, pavel posadsky, all in the same moscow region. we tried meet and talk with ilya but the younger south, he is very careful and it is not easy to catch him. the opposition or the beretsky judge mikhail milushev, the very one who passed the guilty verdict on arthur, and this is what came of it,

the lyubertsy always held on to the group and did not give up their own. the family of general yukhmann is still in authority. nevin, convicted moscow lawyer artur prel proudly recalls past years. i am sure all my life i worked according to the law and conscience. i asked myself a lot. where exactly did you come from? here is this the problem? come on, just like some young lawyer kid, but they don’t order it. sorry, anyway, a provocation of this level, at least it costs money, when i represented the interests of the disabled, veterans of pensioners whom i defended in civil cases, where

, as a result of a positive decision, we discussed 16 hectares and canceled very large transactions for very large companies. norboev how many convicts are not the fault of our country, of course, no one knows, the stories that we told in this program prove that such cases occur, some citizens become victims of dishonest operatives of researchers, others are judicial, mistakes, unjust sentence should be envied justice, if the judge, for example, received a bribe and convicted the innocent or released the guilty tom is subject to criminal liability. but if the judge was conscientiously mistaken, then no punishment is provided for him,

therefore human feelings should always be the judge of this fool with a lever, and she will chop off her head. and if the judge has become a machine. such cases happened, of course, in my practice, but again, it seems to me that you need to understand that you are all, uh, criminal cases. they are different, there are no identical criminal cases if a criminal case has been initiated against a citizen, and he believes that he considers himself innocent. he does not believe he did not commit this crime. so, he has, respectively, the current russian legislation. it is possible to appeal against the actions of the interrogating investigator. uh, either directly to the body where it leads to the building, or pre-naturalness, or he appeals to the prosecutor's office further to the court. we

have, by law, the madmen of innocence. the person himself does not have to prove that he is not guilty crazies of innocence, but i advise people e not to expect that the investigator who is conducting your case, that he will do so, if not guilty, that there will be nothing like that, that is, actively position should be to collect evidence that indicates that the citizen. condemned khabibula profit duty part such we saw the stories of people who became victims of investigative and judicial errors. it

was our investigation from different regions of the country that conclusions were drawn only to you. see you on russia 24 tv channel

. we will take up this matter. it will be the honest

detective.

about the main events of this minute in our news release, orthodox believers are preparing for the main christian holiday in some regions of russia . easter has already been the first to be met by a resident of chukotka. in vladivostok, the main service was held at the intercession cathedral, despite heavy rain at the service of several hundred garages, well, earlier in jerusalem, the holy fire descended in the church of the holy sepulcher. on great saturday on the eve of orthodox easter , they prayed today in the church of the holy sepulcher.