of course, it is also true that any country , by the way, russia, when we talk about labor migrants, it wants, and this is a legal requirement, that people living on its territory respect, as i said at the beginning of our meeting, to traditions, to culture, including language, of the host country, but when we talk about the category that you just mentioned, of course, these are first of all... people who lived in these territories even under the soviet union, and often due to different circumstances of living in the same general country, they ended up where they live, of course, outside the legal regime of almost all civilized countries, such a situation for people who are not citizens is generally strange. the invention of those

who claim to be considered democratic countries, it is certainly ugly and is now acquiring new qualities and a new scope, we see all this in the modern world, a person has the right to independently choose the country where he wants to live, if it is, if it is his choice, if this did not happen, due to objective circumstances of living once on the territory of the soviet union, in one or another part of it, well, in general, if, if a person decides to live somewhere in another country, this is his choice, but what you said, then what we are facing, of course, requires us to be attentive to these processes, requires our adjustments in relations with these countries in which things of this kind are happening, and requires

our attentive attitude towards people who want to return to their historical you're right, valerievich, we need to we will definitely think about this, we will formulate our approaches to this process accordingly, but if people don’t want to go anywhere and they are expelled, well, we can’t do anything either, but nevertheless we need to create conditions for them too. people, of course, need to come together, let us together , together, think about how to react to what is happening, but i don’t think that happiness will come to the home of those who pursue such a policy, well, i don’t know how long now , but in latvia, in my opinion, 40% were russian-speaking population, probably not a small number now, if they will pursue such a policy in relation to people who wanted to live in this

or that country, in the end they themselves will face such disgusting within their countries, please, the next speaker, smorda, commissioner for children's rights in the ulyanovsk region, hello , dear, you always pay attention to the children's issue, the children 's main value of the school is the people working in it, the teachers, and the quality of education of our future generation depends on the well-being of the teachers today. today the system is, one might say, in stress, although she tries not to show it too much, the shortage of teachers in schools is 250,000 and this is calculated only in vacancies, the outflow is colossal, for example, i visited

those in which the teacher who teaches geography also teaches biology , a foreign language and even music, in populated areas, sometimes entire institutions are closed due to staff shortages, which subsequently causes death, almost the death of the populated area itself, because it is a socio-cultural center; unfortunately, children go to pedagogical universities very few, despite the fact that we are told that this year there are twice as many applicants. submitted their applications, in fact, they did not get to other specialties, graduates did not reach schools, dear vladimir vladimirovich, unfortunately only 10% did not make it. they go to work with managers in marketplaces. young teachers also cannot cope in the first year, and this is primarily due to the highest, colossal workload that school teachers face today. this year it has increased multiple times, this is primarily due to the ongoing

reform, the transition to federal, new state educational standards, a new federal educational program, and digitalization with the creation of a unified educational space. and the lack of textbooks and corresponding programs is a huge problem, modern requirements for lessons are very high and require very high-quality preparation, teachers preparing for classes are sometimes forced to resort to ten sources, and this takes up to 6 hours a day, this is a fact, and teacher pay is carried out only during scheduled hours, and this is unfair, it is extremely important that today there are textbooks for school, and today there is a fear that due to the fact that the development of textbooks for new government programs and programs is a long, labor-intensive and financially expensive process , there will be a complete transition to electronic versions, but textbooks

are, first of all, books that should not be taken away from our children under any circumstances, the workload on the class teacher has gone beyond the working day so much that they simply do not have time for their own family, teachers are responsible for each child , for each family, moreover, teachers are threatened with a reprimand or immediate dismissal, therefore , class teachers, dear vladimir vladimirovich, very much ask that their activities be regulated in order to outline the circle and area of ​​their responsibility, plus today teachers are overloaded preparation for conducting numerous dictations, olympiads, organizing the participation of children in various... projects, events, the holding of which has intensified significantly in the last year. teachers receive countless assignments collect information, provide reports instead of teaching. at the same time, sometimes tasks flying from above seem absurd , but they threaten dismissal, for example,

making three phone calls using a new digital platform, and it doesn’t matter to whom these calls will be made, while teachers, this is exactly what happens... to this digital system, sit down at operational meetings and make calls to each other, or, for example, force parents to maintain pages on our children’s social networks, and strictly monitor how the feed, how a child’s digital profile is maintained, and supposedly teachers should know what children do outside of school hours, how the whole family lives, but i would also like to note that our enemies, who also very carefully monitor all accounts, social profiles on social networks, they love how they live, what they do, with whom the future defenders of the fatherland communicate. it is enough to take a photo of the day, the class teacher, the teacher, in order to understand the volume and load that they are experiencing now, and that’s all you need

streamline and take decisive measures, and most importantly, appreciate the justice of this enormous daily work, in addition, dear vladimir vladimirovich, the burden on history teachers is mainly from neighboring countries, who, as a rule, immediately become citizens of the russian federation and live according to our laws. according to our all-russian monitoring, which we conducted this year, from 20 to 50% of children of different ages, including those already in adolescence, do not speak at all or speak russian at a very, very low level. teachers are forced to use cards in lessons. to explain the meaning of russian words, and this infringes on the rights, including those children who study in classes in their native russian language, initially, teachers do not have the competence to teach russian as a foreign language, there are no teaching aids, and according to the one approved this year

departmental order, which is advisory in nature for schools, teaching russian to non-speaking children, everything is left to the school and organized within the framework extracurricular de. the federal state educational program does not provide for teaching russian as a foreign language at all. thus, the entire burden and problems of organizing social, cultural and, above all, linguistic adaptation rest with school teachers. the quality of education in such educational organizations is significantly reduced. schools are losing positions in departmental rankings and losing their funding even more. this is a paradox. average today. it is imperative to streamline this process, first of all to recognize the legislative level, by amending our federal law on education in the russian federation 273, that this group of children are students with special educational needs who need to create

special conditions, these are benefits, special training for teachers, programs, it is necessary to ensure the creation of special adaptation classes for such children, for intensive and gradual study of the russian language, that is, the integration of such children into the educational process in already formed classes and, of course, further adjustments are needed in state education programs and, of course, methodological support. the feeling of leading school teams during the certification of teachers. the new system was introduced this year, but it further demonstrates a subjective approach to the certified teacher, since certification commissions are created in the educational organization itself. there is no procedure for appealing the results. there is no appeal authority. evaluation criteria for failures at. there is no category either, everything is left to the school management, but

local appeal commissions, where any teacher who does not agree with the unfair decision of the certification commission at the level of an educational organization can appeal, they should be created at least at the level of municipal education authorities, and even better at the level of relevant regional ministries, about the patient, who today he can calmly pour out anything... on any teacher, on social networks, in the media, post it, and discredit the actions of any teacher, this makes them feel insecure, sometimes you read comments, even what would seem to be a decent publication, we have not teachers, but monsters and not people with their own personal lives, and teachers do not believe that the initiative that is being heard today to create conflict commissions at the school level will work, our parents are demanding, which... relates to education, which can solve the whole issue, for this

the directors of the teachers suffer, respectively, and are fired. in our opinion, the real protection of the teacher can be the establishment of liability for the dissemination of information discrediting the status of the teacher, for posting online stories, comments discrediting the dignity of a teacher , by analogy with establishing responsibility for fakes and discrediting the actions of the army, volunteer formations, organizations and persons who with... with the service provider, it should become a title, have its own value and weight . our society must remember that the work of a school teacher is the selfless work of highly educated people who pass on knowledge, help shape worldviews, and pass on values ​​to our children, our growing up. generation, they are the ones who help educate our future defenders of the fatherland, and this is their great contribution to i have finished, thank you very much

for your attention, dear vladimir vladimirovich, since i represent the institute of ombudsmen for children’s rights, as part of our daily service, we constantly communicate, and i personally constantly communicate with a very large civil community, representing parents, representing charities, various organizations. this situation, we want to go together with you to further victories, thank you, thank you very much, i don’t even know what to react to, because everything you said, everything is school, teaching, textbooks, remuneration, prestige, teachers, class management and its regulation, i have definitely noted it

for myself, we will definitely look closely at the relevant ministry there instructions and the presidential administration will look at it, it’s unexpected for me that you said about the restructuring of the teacher’s work, which was aimed at relieving the teacher’s workload. his work, you say, forced informatization, this very strange, to be honest, even unexpected for me, this is such a formal approach to informatization, we also need to talk about this, let’s return again to the same sensitive topic, i think children, migrant workers, a simple topic, everything you said, that's all, i just wrote it down almost verbatim, we need

, of course, to think about resolving all these issues, uh, children should study, but this process should not be accompanied by a deterioration in the conditions at school - children, our citizens, this is a separate issue, and you can't pretend that this problem does not exist, of course, too... i will give the appropriate instructions, prepare a proposal, i hope you will take part in the development of these decisions, here we can do a separate group, well, here a lot of things can and should be done, but pretend that you can’t just do one thing, pretend that there are no problems here , they do exist, it’s true, you are absolutely right, now regarding all sorts of options for discrediting teachers, educators, teachers, this is a very subtle, certainly very important, very subtle area that is subject to,

conditionally regulated by modern methods , especially, i mean that we live in conditions, in the modern information space, nothing can be solved here with shouts or prohibitions, i don’t even want to go into details now, maybe this is one of the most difficult topics, which you touched upon, but definitely absolutely, we need to protect teachers from unlawful interference in their lives. and from unlawful pressure on them in the information space, and i repeat, we need to think about this, think about it and take the appropriate solutions that will change the situation for the better from the point of view of protecting the rights of teachers in this case, please, let 's move on, fair help, dr. lisa,

dear vladimir vladimirovich, you have repeatedly emphasized that increasing life expectancy and improving the quality of life of citizens of the russian federation, this is one of the primary tasks facing the country's leadership. due to the large volume of tasks facing the implementation of the rights of citizens of the russian federation to health protection, this year, the year in the hrc a working group on public health care was created, the goals of this group are fully aimed at protecting the rights of the citizens of our country, our group, of course, we are paying attention to the organization of health care in new

regions, now it’s like this: it’s wrong to say in the donbass in novorossiya in the returned territories, and it’s necessary to say that a number of your instructions that were given to integrate the healthcare of these regions are carried out by children with severe, including orphan diseases, those children who are supported not only by fair assistance dr. lisa, but also the circle of good foundation, it’s the children who demand... the first child from the luhansk people’s republic with spinal muscular atrophy, an 11-year-old girl, whom our organization has been helping since 2015, was the first child of donbass to receive help from the circle of good. i want to say a few words about this

girl, her name is ksyusha kirdan, she is from the luhansk republic, she is one year old, she is disabled, a wheelchair user, but she draws very well, she really asked me, i can’t refuse, a drawing for you, please look, vladimir vladimirov, she i drew and named this drawing moscow , the kremlin, putin, i will pass it on to you through the protocol service, i couldn’t refuse her this request, ksyusha, give me my best wishes, let her get better, thank you very much for this gift. thank you, vladimir vladimovich, i will definitely tell her, i think she will see , to say separately that medical workers of the donetsk and lugansk republics, zaporozhye and kherson regions are actively involved in the system of providing care according to the protocols

of clinical recommendations of the russian federations, we try to provide them with comprehensive assistance. assistance in this, in particular , together with the russian association of nurses, we now regularly hold large seminars, they are conducted by specialist doctors, in order to integrate nurses into modern methods of providing care for patients, and from doctors, the public, who continue to work under fire, yesterday they were injured again, two children, fortunately, have already received the necessary help, one child is heavy, but everything has been done for him, he will... live and will not be disabled from the doctors of donetsk, i want to give you this book, it is called the hospital that

was not, this is a book about how in the donetsk people's republic, since 2014 , first aid was organized for the defenders of the young republic. and to those instructions of yours that were given in 2020 to 2022 to the instructions that directly relate to the organization of social and medical assistance to people without a fixed place of residence, i have already addressed you with these questions, but some points require elaboration, you instructed, including through the system of public services at the place and actual location, to realize their right to a pension, to health care, to... the human rights council, like government agencies, works on these instructions and there is some progress, in

particular in the organization of social services , new centers for social adaptation are being created, with the help of grantral, socially oriented ngos, providing serious assistance to citizens without a fixed place of residence, socializing them, giving them documents, although they are not always successful due to those obstacles that sometimes are caused to us locally by mfc employees, but we are working with it, socialization is a very difficult job, but we succeed, such as, in particular, in the fair assistance of dr. lisa, the green light homeless assistance center, where people can not only wash themselves, change into clean clothes, get help from a psychologist, get help from a narcologist, work, get a referral to a hostel, but as for the problems with providing medical care to these citizens,

serious gaps remain, despite the fact that help, and this is being done, planned medical care, regular and long-term care is practically unavailable to these people, this applies to citizens with cancer, cardiovascular diseases, diabetes, chronic infections, including socially significant ones, such as kitsch, tuberculosis, hepatitis c, this applies to people after amputations, fractures, after abdominal operations, who need nursing, but they are discharged from hospitals to virtually nowhere and turn to charitable organizations, which in the overwhelming majority do not have a medical license, because this is specialized assistance that we cannot provide to charitable organizations, we have isolated precedents when homeless veterans of the northern military district sought help, including

after injuries and amputations. we consider each such case separately; they deserve special attention. it is necessary to create care, rehabilitation, and palliative care beds for such people; these beds are almost nowhere to be found. homeless disabled people, at best, are accommodated in... russia, even without documents, in fact, this is real, we have positive experience, the experience of the tyumen region, where the charitable organization mercy is a non-profit organization, but it interacts with government agencies and the orthodox church, received. allowed absolutely all homeless people in the tyumen region who need medical care to receive this help at all stages, i ask you to give

instructions to study and disseminate the tyumen experience in organizing medical care for homeless people. not a single citizen of our country should find himself in a situation where he is deprived necessary medical care. our working group will study such cases and look for solutions. problems and keep you informed about how your health is progressing. and i would like to take this opportunity to express to you the support of my colleagues, in greater russia, as they say, in the donbass, in novorussia, in zaporozhye, we are the medical community for you. thank you very much, but i think that colleagues here have already made reservations that novorossiya and donbass are part of it. greater russia, uh, and, the topic that you raised is very sensitive, people who, by virtue of various circumstances, now i will, i won’t

even say, due to... nothing, but they found themselves on the street, without a place of permanent residence, often without work, of course, they need special attention from society, because, probably, that what happened to each person , a significant share, is their fault, but also society as a whole and society as a whole, that means, that means, those who allow such people to appear, that’s what the whole point is, and if this happened, then we all should think about how to improve the situation as much as possible this is possible, let's think together about what and how can be applied and replicated throughout the country, thank you very much for raising this issue, i ask you to further work with your colleagues from the government from... from

the administration, to work on this topic, convey to them everything that you consider necessary, use it in order to make appropriate adjustments in the direction, here is eva mikhailovna merkacheva, the next speaker, a columnist for the moscow komsomolets newspaper.