it, our grisha lost his temper, improvise what we have as a slave for escaping, execution, set fire, no, i won’t, okay, i myself, i want you to look me in the eyes when i put you out, soon. why am i saying this? because i am confident that they will continue to help. why are you sure? why did someone decide that they, well , we’ve been emphasizing all the time, it’s beneficial for the americans, to develop their own industry there, to lower europe a little, to keep tension all the time, russia, china, to produce, which means to fill their industry, but what has changed? since it is beneficial for them, they will do it, well, they will bargain a little there for migration, for this, for everything.

well, they will do it, i’m not even more surprised than you, many have forgotten trump, they remember him with and i, including, who was for him once here here, when you remember, they talked about the elections between him clinton, madam, i then said that he would win, but what then, then the sanctions against russia that he imposed, why are the republicans now, will he be there or will there be another, by the way, we also have this not some is taking place, which means there is a disagreement with...

russia is a country of great achievements, right now we are making a discovery in science, our children are opening the doors of modern classrooms, we are creating new cultural spaces, and of course, we are opening new routes to the point of attraction, open for yourself to achieve the achievements of our country, come to the russia forum exhibition. yes, so i continue this theme

of sabotage about the fact that you said 15, there are 30,000, so they ran, which means that ours are the same ones there, since before there they ran for copper farewell, so now, i keep asking myself a question, it’s not very convenient for me to talk about this, volodya to you, because recently this week you received a well-deserved award there, you received this tefi award, but when often people, here i am. .. i’m listening to prilepin, or karen georgievich, i’m listening, or my beloved minister, who came to the state duma last week, i just can’t understand, here we have a central bank that monitors the banks, god forbid they do something there stolen or given to the wrong place, we have rosprirodnadzor, which makes sure that the vodka is not released, that means, or there, that means, the ministry of emergency situations, which monitors the firefighters, because this is associated with a security threat, this is the information sphere. it’s not related to security

, threats, somehow it’s become unfashionable to say, yes, because youtube, the ban, that means all these things, someone noticed that twitter was banned, someone is talking about it now, he well, this bothers someone, elon musk noticed, he bought it in russia, in china without any war, they did it a long time ago, because that this is real security, it is much more dangerous, not even from the point of view of sabotage, from the point of view of brain destruction, you open and... it pulls, but in the same way ours didn’t pull, it doesn’t pull at all, it doesn’t pull at all, not businessmen when the west was here, the president spoke from the rostrum of this center of international trade, but look how quickly, he says, and rightly so, praising businessmen, as if... not to mention,

but he probably said there too, alexander mikhailovich , will remember this, oh key rate, well, now nabiulina and the minister of economy will argue here, but what confused me and what i would like to return to is the last question that kostin asked him before he left, you know, on our forums they used to be all the time foreigners means anglo-saxons, all this means bomont. what do you think, they ’re not here now, but how will they come back? they won’t come back? and the president said: they will return, the politicians are forcing them there, but they will return, i would like him to say, it would be better if they did not return, he probably meant this is probably in your head, because what has changed, well, they will come back, their

financing rate today is 4%, 5%, how will you beat them, what kind of competition is this, well, what kind of competition, they say, we are creating competition, well, what kind of competition, if we have always had it, this rate is higher than theirs... three times these businessmen, i look at them, they are still as they were, they are sitting on the gaidar forum, whatever, not because they are bad , they are like that, how history turned out, i often remember the chubais, scold them there or gaidar, but you understand how to scold, so they scold us communists, because this is not their ideology, but we scold them, they have a different ideology, but they are gifted, they are all one of yours, oh well, well, gaidar was a deputy editor-in-chief of the magazine.

no, no, because our investments have always been associated only with foreign investments, what our banks did was take out loans there, and then resell them here, and so, now there is a different bias, i praise china all the time, but now i want a little talk about something else, i see the situation today is the automotive industry, how quickly it was taken over by chinese automobiles ... but the state has tools such as government procurement, put officials on cars, the state buys these cars,

thereby helping, but if you have a localization level at avtovaz of 90%, and you fought and fought for it, and other vaz workers in kaliningrad... who, together with the koreans from bmw, were simply collecting, and today they, therefore, came to putin and also said: yes, give us recycling, which means a benefit. and the question is: a tomorrow, god forbid, this private owner, this chinese, will leave again, and again, there are no components, no factories, or anything else, we should not be mistaken in this sense, we must have these state instruments, i thought they would talk about this they will talk at this forum, i thought they would talk at this forum about the fact that we are still in the west, investments are not one and a half times behind foreign investments, our investments that need to be invested in these factories, because without this there is nowhere, we are lagging behind in terms of gdp for human development is still twice as much, that is, this education, this is medicine,

i prefer to hear about this on such forums than once again about what, and i heard again, let’s not raise taxes, what does it mean to not raise taxes again, i say 2000. all the scientists are banging on about it , 200,000 of our families in the country receive more than 5 million a month, 2000, they can, and the rest, of course, just a little, they can raise taxes, they themselves should have said how businessmen came to cruosevelt during the second world war, they said , we are ready to share, they are one time shared there 300 300 mile, that is, you are talking about a progressive scale of taxation, i am talking about a progressive scale, the tax says there is no need to raise taxes, they mean.

why can’t it even come close to china? i started comparing, looking for materials, looking, do you know why? look how china lifted 800,000 people out of poverty, at the same time. china's education level was 60% 30 years ago, now it's 99. why did apple, which moved production, try to move production almost half from china to india, suddenly discovered that there are 50% defects there, there are no defects in china, but there are there, because this is the same gdp per capita that china invested back into the population, this was, by the way, with us in the ussr, in the capitalist and

... these issues, because these are the questions why should we discuss and talk about the cornerstone ones that are associated with the development of our country, not only to award a medal and order of labor valor, but to create.

the leading position of the communist party, however, the issue of economics remains capitalist principles, by the way , let me remind you that we had approximately the same thing in the twenties and thirties, not only that , throughout the era of comrade stalin , such an element of the essentially capitalist economy as the artel worked absolutely correctly, which supplied an extremely significant percentage of the state defense 26,000 such enterprises , let’s see now, yes...

a hero of labor, so, let’s talk so seriously, this week will be constitution day, that’s why i remember your discussions, big discussions about constitution and changes to it, but you understand, that’s why they are silent on the twelfth day of the constitution, well, not really, because some kind of holiday is so strange, but this is also an opportunity for the country, let them reconsider after the presidential elections , that we could not revise, remember, print, so until now, external legislation prevails over internal legislation.

based on the understanding that today, deprived of real sources of energy resources, those traditional ones, they are imposing on the whole world artificially invented green energy , which actually takes place, but it cannot be today a replacement for everything that was, but they do not have these resources that they bought continue to buy, they want to impose on the whole world a mechanism for replacing this,

for which they they want to say that since you don’t have technology for green... energy, we will provide you with it, but you have to pay for it with the price of a traditional energy carrier, that is, they are looking for new forms of other countries through the mechanism of linking them to supposedly modern ones technologies, a childish question, why? then, in order to reduce prices, why green energy? and this is, well, this is what they came up with, moreover, i want to say that today they are laying the legal foundations for such a term as ecocyte, that is , this is about what they see today? accept the right to solve, moreover, even with the use of military force, those problems that, in their opinion, are associated with environmental violations, this is a very deep penetration into those relations that with the automobile transport appeared as environmentally friendly, because there was a disaster in new york, when horse shit flooded all the way to the first

floors and there were rats, then it was precisely new york that welcomed the advent of automobile... transport as a way to combat this disaster and they said that this is environmentally friendly and solves problems, they want to plunge us all again into an unknown place, so that later we can courageously get out of this, they want to impose their own vision and, under this vision, give themselves special powers to implement or the use of armed forces, including on the territory of those state forces, well, this is the second question, but i’m talking about the same thing, now we’ll see, maybe they won’t have any armed forces left, i mean. and colonialism , which they are trying to implement in different directions, i want to say that they continue this policy in the economic sphere, when we talk about ours there about our people, who are still adherents of liberalism, we must understand that these are also elements , unfortunately, colonial policy, financial colonialism and so on further, let’s see, let’s return again to our favorite topic, especially since the forum

showed, by the way, i don’t quite agree here, that many important things were not said, just important things would have been... said by the president, in particular that there is a strategic direction of economic development, it is correct, here are the mechanisms, yes, of course, he left the others to discuss, including with the central bank, by the way, very interesting remarks were made when we are talking about a kind of liberalism, that is, imposing on us a model that is not characteristic of today’s level or desire for economic development, we must understand that through the mouth of one of the deputies of the central bank, such a chestyukhin, he said the following words that today the banking sector does not look like it has the possibility of including the banking segment in financing the country's strategically important technological projects, why? yes, because they don’t have access to cheap resources, well, listen, we only have cheap resources there, but we don’t have our own, why then do we need a central bank, if he crosses out his present and future to himself. in fact, we have banks, and money, opportunities and competencies, so

here i categorically disagree with this formulation of the question, when we talk about what was said at this forum: the entire government is doing this, but at what cost is growing, they are looking for an opportunity to make loans by subsidizing the interest rate, which is huge. immediately the head of the central bank warns that this is a dangerous path, because if you get carried away with providing soft loans, we will

are forced to increase the discount rate again, listen, well, one hand heals, the other hurts, well, you know, i of course understand, but i would like to be involved in one process and not opposition, but at least a justification for why such a policy is not more profitable than joining forces in this direction, because let's look at the further development of what awaits us, today the economy, which received almost 5% growth in general over 9 months, has slipped to 3%, why? well because the interest rate reduced the volume financing, but we are going further with you, and if we look, if we looked at the government, not only do they have their own opinion, but thank god, apparently they listen to us, the attitude towards the income of the banking segment, we know with you that in fabulous things are expected this year. income, profit from 3, there 2 to 3.4 trillion rubles. and the government began to think that, of course, it is not a question of confiscating these funds, on the contrary, consolidating these resources and channeling them into

a special development fund in order to be able to subsidize the interest rate rate or at least develop industry and so on. i have a question: what is the structure of this profit? we have already talked about this, this is the recalculation of foreign currency earnings, these are fabulous incomes on federal loan bonds, which is actually a state guarantee, and they pay for it... there is more than 10%, and this is all the banking sector, and then subsidizing the interest rate , after all , interest rate subsidies come from the budget, this budget is paid to someone, the banking sector, well , naturally such profits, but maybe we let’s stop pumping from one to another , maybe we’ll just immediately decide on a certain level that will allow our industry to develop, so i literally asked the united arab emirates what their situation was, 40 years ago, 40 years ago, 40 years ago they weren’t was. on the map , in almost 40 years, gdp has grown 290 times three, oh, sorry, 190 times, 200, 200 times gdp has grown, today they have a population of 10 million, and

indigenous people of 1.5 million, gdp is 500 billion dollars, you you know, this is when look, i wanted, maybe they have a different rate there, 3, 3.5, maybe the inflation is different, 3.9, well, maybe they have something going on that we shouldn’t take, there’s no such thing, here... the international monetary fund published data just the day before, it analyzed what monetary policy is in the countries of central asia and the caucasus , it said, well, let’s not go there, the main thing is that it said, you know, to increase or improve the efficiency of monetary -credit policy in these countries, these countries need to work more on independence central bank. well, maybe we will think about why this kind of recommendations are imposed by such a state, but...

the central bank, independence , when we sometimes even often touch on a single program, i want to say that the central bank, isn’t comrade moses, has been scolded, it’s time for you it's time to act, i just can't understand where this idea of ​​holiness comes from. here are the theses about the independence of the central bank, here’s where it came from, we’ve been there so many times, yes, we ’ve passed a whole law amending the constitution

russian federation, where many korin georgievich took a direct part in this work, but why is the central bank perceived, this is what, this is where it all came from, where this nonsense came from, well , i think this requires special analysis, but although we have already come to... to the decision that even if there is no question of revising the constitution, then at least it is possible to solve the issue of reassigning the central bank to the government through organizational means, do you think this is the whole point mihalovich, not only this, here is the president said at this forum, he said emphatically , what’s the matter, there is a ministry of finance, and in the government, that means there is a central bank, he’s like stalin, he meets with them, talks, thinks that she herself ran to raise this rate, there are approaches different, she ran to raise this rate herself.

there should be centralism, well, there should be , yes, it won’t work, the principle is democratic , but here it is not, because there is no discussion of power, there cannot be dual power, in the economy there cannot be two powers, so that’s when i literally have one remark related to that , what we shouldn’t imagine sometimes when the central bank is criticized, they say , you know, they live there according to imf manuals, well , it feels like they open it there in the morning and read what they need to do, no, unfortunately this was formed over many years years, this topic of liberalism in economics, it’s precisely about the fact that people just... live with this ideology, they don’t see it differently, today there is an understanding that the imf is for such countries, including including ours, determined that we can fill our economy money that is equal to gold and foreign exchange reserves, but this is absurd, absurd in a country that has enormous competencies, projects, opportunities to issue money ourselves, we must be tied to gold reserves, but unfortunately, today the central bank, well, follows these recommendations and we today we get everything with you, these 350 there are 300 billion...

frozen, frozen and the central bank and there and many enterprises, today the government managed to take them into account and it is necessary to issue emissions for them, fill the economy money supply, here it was faced , the central bank was faced with the fact that somehow this does not correspond to the understanding that gold and foreign exchange reserves must correspond to the money supply, it turns out that today they have turned on a mechanism for withdrawing what they think are excess funds, and today the economy began to dry up, and today we are faced with the fact that even subsidies from the budget.

no, no, it plays the role of the federal reserve system, wait a minute, it doesn’t do anything, it’s a completely different branch, which every reserve system in general somewhat about something else, this is what she is talking about, this is a community, this is a community of private banks that are interested in a certain set of activities, the central bank has a different functionality, no, the central bank, of course, has a different functionality, so this is by no means, this is by no means

synonymous . a macaque can also play the role of anyone, if in the ukrainian government jerome powell is in charge, and we are all listening, so finish and shoot, yes , but he’s not talking about the central bank, i leonid would like to continue the thought here a little, related to what, what are we when we are talking about the development of everything that is happening today and the correct development trend, then we must see that the world is changing with this, look at the president.

terrorist attacks and those terrorist attacks that, unfortunately, were associated with the death of people, this is a former deputy of the kiev rada, well , to be honest, it seems to me that this is still very relevant when a country that is waging a difficult struggle against those individuals carry out terrorist attacks, the moratorium on the death penalty would be abolished. i don’t really understand at all how this all fits together us, and these conversations about how the death penalty doesn’t matter, but it doesn’t matter, yes, when a man saw his wife with his mistress, he killed either his mistress, or his wife, or both, or himself with an ax, this is understandable emotion, and where people consciously make a decision, and often with material interest, they are very...