developers making money, the developers who need affordable housing are in there to make money. we need a little bit of everything. a lot of one thing, one way or the other, is obviously not the right direction. i am going to take a position, hopefully representing most san franciscans who do believe the embarcadero has come a long way. we have much for -- we have a lot to go forward with the exploratorium and this will make the embarcadero and much more active area. president buell: i will be brief. as evidenced by 90% of the testimony, it has been directed to the planning commission. the rec and park commission has heard about 10% relating to the shadow impact on the site. what we are being asked to do is assess whether or not the

shadows created by this project create significant adverse affects on the park. i thought staff did a good job in establishing the criteria. part of it is how the shadows occur, time of day, time of year, and location. we have heard from a staff that it is a small fraction of 1%. those shadows occur in the month of june and july between 6:45- 7:00 in the morning and between 6:15-6:30 at night. we normally would not be sharing this time with the planning commission were it not for that fraction of 1%. with that, i want to let the audience know as well as our commission that that is the scope of our interest in this project. we do not weigh in on bulk, height, transit, parking. commissioner levitan: i just

wanted to echo my colleague, president buell. this has been an interesting hearing. i am truthful when i say i cannot remember the last time seven hours went by so quickly. [laughter] i go on road trips with two small children so i know what seven hours can actually feel like. it is interesting because the subject matter is interesting and the testimony has been interesting. it has been varied and diverse and well-thought out and articulate it. my temptation is to weigh in on more of the substance of the issue before us that my esteemed colleagues have far better expertise in. the extent that i am able to vote is what president buell suggested. to that end, i do think that the amount of coverage and the duration of that shadow, relative to all of the benefits of the project, really are such

that the shadows are not in the least bit of verse to the area and projects. i look forward to supporting it. commissioner lee: likewise, this has been a very educational experience for all of us. i would like to also add that that area of san francisco is changing. it is changing at the capitol committee, at the rec and park commission, we just approved the installation of a playground at the park. there are more families living there. that is why we decided to do that project and that will provide some amenities for families with kids.

we also recognize that that entire neighborhood has undergone enormous change. i remember in 1989, pre-1989, that part was under a freeway. it was covered by a freeway. today, of course, that has completely changed after the earthquake. we do live in the city. we have to balance the needs of change with the need for open space and parks. given, on balance, this particular project, the public benefit outweighs the minimal shadow impact upon the park. i would also support, along with my colleagues, this proposal.

i do have a question -- actually, with regard to tennis. we have heard a lot of testimony from the tennis club. regarding the loss of use of the club and so forth. i would like to see if we, as a department, our general manager, can reach out to some of these families. clearly, we have a very robust tennis program at golden gate park. for instance, i was there -- our capital committee approved the repaving of the tennis courts that are now in the golden gate park tennis center, with a donation from the united states tennis association. we have also undergone, through our capital division, repaving and improvement of tennis courts all over san francisco.

i would like to see if our general manager could reach out to the families of the golden gate tennis club to see if we can include some of those families in the public tennis programs we have at sanford and -- at the san francisco recreation and parks department. we do have some very committed staff that are deeply committed to promoting the sport of tennis. i believe that we can provide a public venue for the members of the golden gate tennis club. thank you. commissioner antonini: i move to certify the final environmental impact report. commissioner miguel: i would like to second that and add that i was remiss in not mentioning in my previous remarks the

letter presented by peter from will. any individual is spent 16 years as the executive director on ee has a depth of knowledge of this area of the city far more than i could ever have. for the majority of people who are in this room or have been in this room today. i think that his recommendation should be acknowledged. >> planning commissioners, there is a motion on the floor for item number one, the proposal to certify the final environmental impact report. if the motion has been seconded. on the motion to certify the final environmental impact report. commissioner antonini: aye. commissioner borden: aye. commissioner miguel: aye. commissioner sugaya: no. vice president wu: no. president fong: aye.

that motion passes 4-2. may i call item 2a? the proposal to adopt the environmental quality act. is there a motion? commissioner antonini: i moved to adopt the findings. >> second. >> it is for adoption of the findings of the california environmental quality act. commissioner antonini: aye. commissioner borden: aye. commissioner miguel: aye. commissioner sugaya: no. vice president wu: no. president fong: aye. >> the motion passes 4-2. i will turn over item 2b to you. item 2b is the ferry park

request to consider jointly with the rec and park commission to establish a cumulative shadow. i will call the roll if there is a motion. commissioner miguel: i moved to adopt the item. >> second. >> there is a motion for adoption. the establishment of a cumulative shadow limit. comm aye. commissioner borden: aye. commissioner miguel: aye. commissioner sugaya: no. vice president wu: no. president fong: aye. that motion passes.

>> we are still on item 2b and we need a motion from the rec and park commission to establish the cumulative shadow limit for the park and to adopt the findings under the ceqa. do we have a motion? commissioner levitan: i would move that my colleagues adopt this resolution, including a statement of overriding consideration and mitigation of monitoring and reporting the program and establishing a cumulative shall limit for sue berman park. i move that we adopt the resolution. >> second. vice president harrison: aye. commissioner bonilla: aye. commissioner lee: aye. commissioner levitan: aye. president buell: aye.

>> we are on item 2c. do we have a motion? >> yes. i would move to recollect -- a resolution recommending the planning commission finds eight net new shadow cast by the proposed project at eight washington street will not be adverse. >> second. vice president harrison: aye. commissioner bonilla: aye. commissioner lee: aye. commissioner levitan: aye. president buell: aye. >> with that, the recreation and parks commission will adjourn if we have a motion to adjourn. >> so moved. >>

>> good afternoon. welcome to the cleantech ecosity. i am vice-president of defense that they cleantech group. when have a very special award. i would like to introduce the ceo of the cleantech group. >> thank you, everybody. thank you for being out here. it is my great, great honor to be the guy who gets to give an

award to make your end lee -- to make your -- mayor ed lee. the cleantech tracks a lot of data, and that points to the imprints of california and the importance of san francisco as the epicenter. for that reason, we choose to hold our annual lecture conference right here in san francisco each year. it is happening right behind you. to give you two hints as to what went into the data, 208 clean tech companies retract as top ones in our debt of us are here. of the cleantech 100 list, our top list of companies, 11, more than 10%, are located here in san francisco, more than any other city. we also are well-aware of all the different programs, from green buildings to the climate program to everything else, so we are as honored as can be to

say congratulations, and please join me at the podium, mayor ed lee. congratulations on this award. >> thank you. thank you very much, everyone coming out. it is my pleasure and enthusiastic banks -- thanks to this wonderful organization that has now been here for 10 years, helping us think through and plan and inc. lot more partners. i want to also recognize ford, there sustainability program that mike is here to talk through. i just sat in one of your cars be as enthusiastic. i have already told your cells per cent to talk to our fleet manager to make sure we get a few of those -- i tell your sales person to talk to our fleet manager to maturity of those on our fleet. i think it is up for me to come back and visit the whole group, because every three months they are extending in our great city.

i would like to see the next product that they have up there. but autodesk and ford are great partners today on this clean tech innovation we have in our city. to have so many companies gathering and then to announce this great award, the clean debt capital north america. this is a wonderful award for our city. it is not just the award we are enthusiastic about. i am in it is a bad -- enthusiastic about all the efforts in getting that award. there are so many people who put faith in our city. and i call it investor confidence, because that is what we really need to build, a new industry of investor confidence in the city that is really centered around our a very human thought here, and that is something that i think keeps the city so alive. that is that we want to leave this world, no matter what we are in. i am in government right now.

i know so many people in business and others, and we want to leave this city in the next generation better than what it is today. that is a goal. that is a goal that should hit every single industry in the city, from tourism to the medical field to all the clean tech industries we are inviting in. that if we can say to our generation and to my kids that i am going to use my time to make sure that every aspect of the city, whether it is waste, a compost recovery, or energy efficiency, or solar or business in itself, that we measure our self by how we have improved. and that takes a lot of effort. you know, when we're setting a goal that we want to be 80% below our 1990 levels by 2015 and today we're already at 12%, that means a lot of great effort. that means that when i get in my car every morning, even though

it is a 7 volt now, right, at least i can say the first 35 miles are without a drop of oil. i am proud of that. i am proud of being part of that culture. the next step is to get to 100%. and it is my job as part of the investor confidence to make sure that we set the groundwork for the 100% electric vehicles so that we do not use a drop of oil. because, ultimately, that is going to save our planet, going to save our city. then we get into all the other industries, whether it is solar, energy efficiency, just the myriad of things we're doing with our utilities, and registering in every industry that we want to be the lead. so this award is earned every step of the way. and i will tell you, as a former public works director, i sat around the table with our architects and engineers, and years ago i felt the enthusiasm they had when they said i am

going back to school, a director. i am going back to school to earn a degree as an architect, as an engineer. i want to be a part of this great wonder, this direction we're heading in. that is why today we celebrate 35 million square feet of office space that is under some kind of lead certification in our city. that is a tremendous accomplishment for our city. that is also why i spend a lot of time saying that, not only am i enthusiastic about electric vehicles, but our whole public transit system operates from clean energy. that is why i will always say that those voices that suggest that we tear down hetch hetchy, they're not talking about where the cleanest hydroelectric power is derived from. it would not only the energizer for our public transit system, which it is, and our public spaces like city hall is, but again power of electric vehicles

that will be the next generation, even power up bicycles that have energy to get at those steep hills. that is going to be coming and forthcoming. we have a lot to celebrate about. as he said earlier, to, this award reflects and follows other awards we have. and the world council on green buildings gives us an award, gave us an award last year for being part of the greenest city buildings and greenest city building policy that we have in north america. that is well-deserved. we are the greenest city, according to siemens as well. that is another part of a great effort here today on this conference to see what next we can build in our economy that is part of the grain economy. 208 clan tech and investor firms in our city is a wonderful accomplishment, one that supports our efforts here. we're going to do more on that. we're going to expand on our

solar companies that are already here. and that is a great topic while we have the umbrellas out. our solar companies. because when we fill up the reservoir and at hetch hetchy power, we're going to also make sure that we're going to continue on this very wonderful theme we have about attracting some of the best-seller companies around the world to be here. with our own efforts, and china sf, we're going global. we have got five of the largest seller manufacturing companies located in san francisco. that is another accomplishment. they're coming here for a purpose. the one to be part of that culture. so i know that there is a lot of companies that have already established here in san francisco, and if you are thinking about whether you should locate here, let me offer you this other enticement. you know, there is a great culture being here. there is talent. but there's also entrepreneurial

and innovative in system -- ecosystems that we are creating here in san francisco. that is a great attraction to locate here in san francisco. you want to be part of the culture. foremost on my agenda as well. no company ever wants to be located in san francisco simply to be a san francisco company. they want to be here because there is a global and a bit of ever going on here, that when you launch a company here, you're going to be a budget access to global market that we want to develop here. that is why it is so enticing to be the mayor of san francisco at this time, because i want to create a global economy for all of our energy efficiency, our solar companies, our clean debt companies, all their investors. we're working as 18. we suggest to you to locate here because it will be part of a global economy because we wanted continue establishing here. on behalf of the city and county of san francisco, not only for the enthusiast them cover the

very foundation we are creating, we have more to go, more to work with and put together. thank you for locating this wonderful conference here. [applause] >> thank you so much, and congratulations mayor lee. we have an award to give you. i have to get my apologies to joe and mike. in the excitement of mayor lee and the award, wanted to ask two important partners to make some remarks. joe is with autodesk, the most important design companies that are leading the charge in bringing designed to cleantech, an important partner bringing investment and incredibly important software to cleantech. a couple words from you. >> thank you. how about a hand of applause for our great mayor ed lee again? [applause] thank you for standing in the rain and braving the weather to be with us today.

it is a great event. i want to thank you for selling bringing it with us today. also to recognize all the great work being done by our mirror for his strong support of the double-byte our mayor for his strong support of the clean tech industry. rain or shine, this is a beautiful city. i think you all have to agree. i am is our you're standing under umbrellas. first, i would like to thank the cleantech forum for the opportunity and the privileged to share the stage here with the honorable mayor lee because many of you know, autodesk is a leader in 3d design, engineering entertainment software. our customers use our software to design, visualize, and simulate the ideas before they are ever built are created. autodesk is also a very strong supporter of the innovation and the environmental advancement of clean technology pioneers. we provide them with world-class

software so that these companies can help stimulate their ideas for the digital models and further tests. we have several cleantech partners with us here today you are participating in the ecocity. they include pine nobility, electron volt, springboard, by a diesel, and green light motors. our program supports clean tech companies worldwide throughout europe, north america, japan, and singapore. today, almost 50% of those companies are located in california, and over 50% of those companies are located right here in the san francisco bay area. it is clean tech innovators like these two are going to solve our greatest problems and who are going to great innovations that we're going to need to solve our most complex environmental

challenges. so we are deeply grateful to the great city of san francisco, and under the leadership of mayor lee, we're delivering the platform for the company's that thrive and also to continue with their innovation. so it is with a tremendous source of pride, not only personally but also on behalf of the 600 employees who work in san francisco and who call this great city their home, that i want to thank you, mayor lee, and also want to co-presented to you the cleantech award here in san francisco. [applause] >> mike, please come on up. >> thank you very much. i am the director of the gulf electrification infrastructure at ford. first of all, thank you for having us. thank you, mayor lee, as well. >> thank you for your support. >> this a few brief words.

first and foremost, the 35 miles or so, i know my goal is to make at 100 miles in terms of electric. hopefully that will be your next project. >> ford is available, right? exactly, there are drives available in the focus elector brighter their pickup we're happy to be here in the city of san francisco. happy for the award you are receiving today. the theme of today is global -- empower global partnerships. that especially rings true for ford. because we believe that partnerships are our way of getting the electrification and vehicle electrification to be successful. just a couple of examples. you may have heard of a company that is our partner for public infrastructure but in fact, many of our customers and cities receive free charging stations through the program we have with that partner. in fact, the units that are in front of city san francisco, in

front of city hall, are actually those units. the second partnership by wanted to mention is one i will be talking more about tomorrow. it is with sun power. this is a really need a partnership. not only can you drive 100% on electricity with our focus electric, but for a reasonable amount of money, you can actually put solar on your roof that has been sized for that big goal and can provide you with essentially frequent electricity for the next 25 years. essentially that is the warranty on the system. we're happy with the partnership. we think that the blend of sun power and solar and focus electorate can be a powerful combination. we have also partnered with other companies as well. and these companies are not just companies. their electric utilities, municipalities, and they are ngo's as well, including cities like san francisco.

i wanted to personally take this moment to applaud the city of san francisco for leading the way in electrification under mayor lee's leadership. and really, the last example i want to share is whenever i travel around the country, i use examples that i get from the city of san francisco as some of the ways they want to understand how they can become electrify -- what do they do? how do they do it? i use many examples from this great city. i wanted to applaud you again for that. we do have the focus electric. if you do have extensive empty water bottles, we take them over there. with a partnership, we recycle those. and the cloth seats in the focus electric are made out of that material. if you get a chance, come over and see that. and we had our gatecrashers -- we have our mobile app. thank you. [applause] >> we do have an award. congratulations, mayor lee and

the city of san francisco. [applause]