>> -- this was before i submitted my appellant brief. this past sunday i noticed how to drawing of the top of the page showing the relative height of the buildings conveniently shows the three stories left on west side of the building. plus i noticed this yesterday when they wanted to add another wind ori for the interior and i already have no privacy and because i need to keep the curtains open. my point is to illustrate how deceptive these documents are.

i think most people would not have noticed the discrepancy. after all i caught them by chance at the very last minute and six months after receiving the document. i greatly appreciate the time and diligent effort that the board has conducted in approving my appellant brief and i look forward to the judgment in my neighbor to revoke this permit especially the extensions on the roof and the rear. thank you. >> thank you commissioners. i'm here on behalf of the permit holder. the appellant has received significant notice throughout the process. this is the plan on the wall. even from

the photo it's very clear there is a person standing. that was last march. miss pres sta did send the application to the pell appellant as well. what the department of planning asked to minimize the amount of paper go out, they request that you take the drawings and shrink them so they fit on a certain number of pages. this is where it looked a little odd at certain times because that's what the planning department requires you to do. that's exactly what's happened. since the dr filing period elapsed the construction drawings drafted, both the planning department and the dbi have received them and found

them to be compliant with the code. i want to mention there is no window proposed for that wall along the appellants property. it's not permitted by the code because it's on the property line. so in the end the appellant waited 2 days prior to the appeal and responded to all the of the modifications that he requested. because he didn't file a dr request she found comfortable to plan the drawings and was surprised when she got the appeal two days before the appeal period. she was willing to listen to concerns. one of the things that miss pres sta did want to propose was it was create twog

creating two walls and she was still willing to incorporate that into the design. in the end this process is going to create a new family size dwelling unit. the recently adopted housing element of the general plan has a clear policy to develop new housing and encourage the remodel of the new housing. new multi-bedroom is expensive and that creates a more affordable family housing. it's three units with open dedicated buildings. >> thank you. mr. sanchez, nothing further. the matter is

submitted. >> a lot of things were brought up, but i think the primary issue with the appellant has to deal with the stair to the roof and the stair penthouse. looking at the orientation i would have guess that the blockage of the sun occurs relatively late in the afternoon. given that the penthouse is almost directly due west of the appellant's property. which means the southern sun is what provides most of the light and sunlight into rear yard and will continue as it tracks across

the sky somewhere late afternoon where the penthouse will have any impact on the supplement. -- sunlight. at that time the sunlight is very low on the horizon and as was stated by a number of people, i find the impact here is modest and minimal. i think the appellant should accept the offer of the permit hold er to put glass in the stair and enhances their stairs and will add a little bit of transparentcy and light through that wall. >> i agree. i don't have anything else to add. >> me neither. i think the only thing i was concerned about was the light as well the

technicality and any concern about clarification can be questions on the plans, at this point should have been resolved. the light issue, i don't think is of great concern. i think that i would move to deny the appeal and uphold the permit on the basis that it's code compliant. >> do you want us to condition the lazying in the stairwell? >> the appellant doesn't care. you have to come to the microphone, sorry. >> the only issue is that it would require additional time to be spent on the construction drawings. >> as far as the revision. >> exactly. >> unless it's done tonight. i

don't think the appellant cares. i saw you shaking your head. so, again you need to speak in through the microphone, sorry. >> the shade expert that the permit holder hired showed with the glass it would cover the shade would be two or three hours per day. that's what we went over on may 3rd meeting with both architects. in fact, the architect asked him when they saw that i wasn't very happy with the shade because it was more than i was originally expecting. my guess was like an hour of shade with the penthouse there which is you know the sun is due west so it creates towards their shade area two or three hours and the architect requested to add

glass instead and i said that is the glass, 2-3 hours per day. >> the question is should we condition the permit to have the glass be part of the stairwell, the penthouse? >> if it's a choice between glass or solid, i will have a choice between the house? then it's glass. but i would prefer none. >> okay. thank you. >> yes. >> i just want to point out, i'm not sure if that construction in the last wall of the property line if it would require the wall for fire rated. >> it's an excess of 3 1/2 feet. it's a double run on the stair there. >> so, do you want to --

>> let's proceed. >> no amendment to my motion. okay, denial the appeal and uphold the permit as code compliant. >> okay, we have a motion from the president to deny this appeal and uphold the permit on the basis that it's code compliant. on that motion, commissioner fung? aye, hurtado? >> aye. commissioner honda? aye. the motion is approved. the permit is upheld on that basis. >> we are adjourned. thank you.

future >> thank you everybody i'm daniel the chairman for the san francisco super bowl bid committee (clapping) we are thrilled and excited to announce today we've raised $30 million to bring super bowl 50 or 51 to the san francisco bay area. not only do we have the dollars but the companies that have stepped forward have come on board and we're announcing that

$25 for every dollar we raise is going back into our community in the bay area. so with have is a program to get to but before i get started i need to thank a bunch of people. i'm going to start with the 49ers in the boston group hewitt packard and gibson dunn, virgin america and a bunch of companies in the back have contributed. we just gave the passage to the

49ers and it's all due to silver stein and they got in their hands. just to give you a quick timetable of what's happening we traffic to bovtd our committee will be there in full force and we have 15 minutes to tell folks y why san francisco will be the best place to host the super bowl. so it gives me great honor to call up mayor ed lee (clapping) >> thank you, danielle i know you mean that in jest for

raising $30.25 percent is going to the youth that's an incredible message. i want to thank former mayor willie brown and board president chiu and i want to add my thanks to the entire committee. when we take a worldwide event a sport we all love we're been celebrating for many, many years and going after the super bowl 51 or 51 with the committees leadership has been respectful and reflexive of our valuables. i want to thank the corporations

that h have helped. i know the nfl owners are going to do be thankful. we know that what we put together with the cooperation of mayor matthews and the whole region and the reason we're here today at the foot of market street is this is where the nfl starts happening and it works its way to moscone center with the it will be host. i celebrated with my daughters being in town i bought them

ipads. this is the technology in the city but we women this whole effort to use the sports games and technology calculation that's going on and we want to make sure that our hospitality leads the hotel and every restaurants between here and san jose that we know the excitement will be here. that's such an incredible history in the industry we know we're take care of issues of transportation and public safety i know the chiefs here with our corporate community. it's a signal that the flipping

e floif groups will be here. i did not anticipate this so face but when people get excited whether it's the giant or the w49 we have so much to celebrate every tiger woods came out to celebrate. it inspires us to have our cooperate citizens to enjoy this event. thank you for all the corporate communities putting this together and the the entities working together to host the

best super bowl we'll ever have. that he when he break the opening this super bowl they'll be more happening. so thank you very much. appreciate your leadership. >> the next speaker needs no introduction so i'm going to introduce pat our development chair. joe has been incredible. john amazing that were chris kelly, jim wonder man from the bay area. mary murphy from gibson dunn and

neil thank you. charlotte the first people i went and spoke to. and robert anderson is here. now, one of our biggest cheerleaders mayor willie brown >> i am delighted to be part of the effort to make sure that san francisco is selected for either 50 or 51 preferably 50. nothing impressed me more when young mr. murphy recruited said 25 percent of all that's been raised from the gallagher and the rest of you will remain in

the community for people who are in need. that 25 percent on-ramps into $8 million. obviously greatly in need based on all the numbers we see. and to have that happen around an font around the super bowl will be the mayor said it's just the threshold we will expand on a cooperative basis. i would guess there's no other region in this nation that can change so many minds and souls in terms of resources and in terms of talent and in terms of location and obviously as my i

late friend herb came in said if you can't make heaven san francisco is our preference and clearly the rest of the world sees it that way >> so i congratulate you mayor you've loud all of us to be a part of a mission to improve the area including super bowl 50 or 51. we're going to have a ball. there's no way this passage is not going to be approved by the owners in boston believe me i've spoken to a couple of my friends (clapping) >> i asked him not to raise expectations. we have some of the best

companies in the world behind this bid and one is hewitt packard. tom bradley is the vice president and he's here he representing all those companies that came together to represent us. so thank you for your commitment. >> thanks, danielle. i'm not sure what could be a larger challenge in following the mayor to speak. the documents of the first - they called out the need to make a contribution what our employees and workers live and work. and to they funded 75

years ago has made a great number of commitments and frankly a great commitment of money and passion to this community. we had the opportunity to bring the super bowl back to the area after a thirty year hiatus but but clearly we're not alone. we have folks in silicon valley who share this opportunity google and yahoo and all companies who's on history is woven into the fabric of argue country. the super bowl stands for the

ultimate in competition and it's the most watched game in the world. and the city embodied all about this great event. it's a platform that reaches millions of people and can lift people up and give them the opportunity. and to this end we're proud to make super 50 the most charitable. we'll give children the opportunity to stand on their own feet to compete and win. so i thank my colleagues to

bring it back to a this area and in doing so we can provided a certainty home advantage i'm happy with that too. thank you very much (clapping) so i left one person off jeff has been an incredible committee members too. so when we talked to marry lee we also knew we needed an ally on the committee. so mark thank you very much. thanks, danielle. i have to tell you as a kid who group watching the giants you'd

never convince me i would be standing here. it's amazing how far the super bowl has - but the fact we're here, here having raised $30 million committing so much to the impoverished folks in our area. it speaks well of mayor ed lee and daniel thank you. and from my prospective on the board of supervisors this bid speaks to two things in particular one our continued commitment to those who are less fortunate. this is historic in the terms of where future money will go to but it speaks to our changing

relationship to the it community we're together now partners going forward. businesses that are employees and put our folks to work in san francisco. as the mayor said we're one of the lowest unemployment places in california. and so we're grateful to our corporate sponsors as well. and i look forward to the board of supervisors looking to make sure this is one of the best events the super bowl has seen >> and the president of the board of supervisors david chiu. (clapping). >> good afternoon i apologize for being late it was yu rushi from the airport because

4:00 a.m. this morning, i was in boston to wish my mother happy mother's day. i want to make sure that we make the right decision san francisco and the san francisco bay area we're experiencing a season of supporters magic. over the past we're we're hosting the america's cup. we were just in the super bowl ourselves. i see a couple of folks who were in the super bowl. but we're in a magic moment and it's appropriate we've come

together. thank you to daniel and our mayor and thank you to all of you. we are the city that knows how to throw on a great sporting event we know how to entertain millionaires in the world and i welcome all to party with the diverse san francisco. >> i want to thank martha cowen and e 2, k and the gold rush girls from the 49ers. i know that p j have been incredible thank you for doing all of this.

i want to let everybody, you know, though grateful we are we're going to do boston we're going to put our best foot forward and bring back super bowl 50 or 51 and we're proud to represent this region and thank you and have a great day