around, my proposed resolution of this request is we just take some time to read what you've brought tonight and then we make a decision tonight. i would suggest that we /stke deny the request to continue this just to make sure we resolve that request unless you have anything additional regarding this request. >> to be clear on this, you do have comments you can present us tonight? >> yes. >> okay. >> we can conclude this tonight if that's what you want to do. >> i move to deny the request to continue. >> let's continue. >> i move to deny the request to say no to the request. >> well, my issue on that, i don't know what that thing looks like. i have no idea what the document that inspector lee is

going to put forth, he had one item. that's my concern. >> perhaps it be oral and we limit it, because if it's in writing then we have to take time to read and deliberate and so on and it become part of the record. if it's presented orally it's part of the written record and we can still consider it. >> we have the option of going into closed session. can we do that? >> in terms of continuance or in terms of the findings? >> well, the continuance, i'd rather talk about it -- >> let's go to closed session. >> i don't want to belabor the point, but i didn't get to quite fully answer your question. if i could add one last item. you had asked about civil service commission, their interest and in particular one of the questions they passed to the department as well, if this commission, the police commission did not sustain counts two, three, four in the

that means inspector leans claimings which he made in his defense on those three specifications that he or to be credible and of course we don't have any specific findings as to why the commission did not sustain two, three and four so some members of the civil service commission expressed and opinion that clearly it must be the case so the police -- commissioner marshall, i think we're getting -- >> the police commission is not in a dialogue with the civil service commission. we have separate responsibilities and whatever the civil service commission may or may not have asked the department is separate from what -- >> instead let's go to closed session to talk about it. >> you may have deliberations

in closed session. >> i would ask that we do that. >> i don't want to say anything more about civil service commission, 'cause you've asked me not to. >> yes. >> there is a parallel issue, it has very important brady -- >> no, sir, it's an entirely -- if there were no proceedings in that other venn you i'd still be asking that question. >> one last question before closed session. how many pages is what you prepared inspector? >> it's just two pages, but if you guys were to continuance, i'd prepare something -- >> right now you have two pages and how many copies ? >> i made more than seven so there's more than -- >> let's go into closed session please and talk about it. we'll move into closed session. clear the room, please. we're

back now in open session with a quorum. >> commissioner marshall. >> let's hear one more time

from the council please. >> john from the department. >> inspector frank lee representing myself. >> let's start with the continuance -- no continuance this evening. we will finish the merit tonight. inspector lee, we have decided to take your responses to the police commissioners and fact finding facts in the case, we decided to do it. let's just put it like that. and we have looked at taking a look at them. we've taken a look at the changes suggested by department's council and we had a discussion about the findings of fact amongst ourselves as commissioners and we have several proposed changes

to miss blitz's document, which she will now read, that i think we have reached agreement on. i'm going to ask her to read those. >> thank you commissioner marshall. so referring to inspect or lee's information you're referring to the two page written document that he brought you this eveninging. >> that's correct. >> you reviewed them before making your determination here. the edits that the commission has agreed upon to the draft findings that are dated november 11, 2013, are as follows: on page 14 in footnote 48 there is a cross reference

to footnote 47 and instead it should read it is a cross reference to footnote 46. on page 13 at paragraph number 38 after the phrase the commission finds that the following phrase will be inserted, "in sustaining this specification, it is derivative that, and then the remainder of the paragraph remains as written. on page 16 at paragraph number

55 the same phrase will be inserted. after the existed phrase the commission finds that, the phrase will be inserted, "in sustained this specification, it is derivative that,". then on page 22 part of the paragraph numbered 62 at line 12, the reference to department general order 2.01 rule 10 is changed to department general order 11.01. those are the edits as i understand them from the commission. >> for the record record --

yeah, so -- i believe that's what we discussed. did you hear any differently. >> i want to be clear, when we said we took the two pages, it's just that we read them. >> list as any work considered. >> with those amendments, i would move in /aeu adoption of the findings of fact as amended by the reading miss police just gave. >> second. >> want to take role? >> vice president terman.

>> i. >> commissioner chan. >> i. >> commissioner kingsly. >> i. >> commissioner marshall. >> i. >> motion passes unanimously. >> that concludes this matter. the findings are adopted. thank you very much. >> next item mr. secretary. >> that will be a closed session item mr. vice president, next, 6b. >> commissioners, as there are not really any matters and we have already engaged in some closed session activity, i would say that we put this one off until the next meeting. is that okay? >> yes. >> i'm fine with that, sir. >> vote -- the next item please. >> item seven, vote to elect whether to disclose any or all discussion on item six held in

code session . >> move on non disclosure. >> second. >> can we do that or need role call? all in favor? >> i. >> we don't need role call. >> closed. the next item please. >> item eight adjournment. >> so moved. >> second. >> we're adjourned. thank you.

>> (clapping) great that's correct. as i was saying i'm the chair of the yerba buena community and the neighborhood that's home to the highest concentration of that's right we don't think there's a better place. we're here it stretches to harrison and fifth street on the west and we that it's really a place that welcomes people to the city the culture institutions and we see the living zone as a welcome mat. the neighborhood is known for its insdunt and this is a fun way to combine the science and arts.

the yerba buena benefit district is dedicated to improving the life of folks. ? how the district is working with the city in partnership on the yerba buena street life plan. it's a plan and violation road map for large projects. this is one of the larger projects. we've done artful bike racks their cool and creative. we're going to have a bike core wall relay. our plans will have a cleaner air doc station. for free were going to improve the alleys and adding after the ethics sidewalks. the goal of those projects is to facilitate action and promote pedestrian life and ultimately

community pride. the yerba buena is proud to work with the city and the composure to your memory to design and implement this important project. on behalf of the yerba buena and the property owners that fund it i want to thank mayor ed lee and supervisor kim and their amazing support for the yerba buena work to help improve the quality of life. i want to thank spur this gentleman has been an amazing companion and deserves the credit for the violation and implementation of those projects. i want to competence my appreciation to the staff our director of neighborhoods projects that do heavy lifting to fte get those projects implemented. the amount of work you can't imagine.

i want to thank our friends at the mrorp tomorrow. one of the skeptic things we've worked with this gentleman shawn. didn't if you will please welcome shawn (clapping.) thank you we've been out here for three or four days on market street. i want to remind everyone what an amazing place this is. this looks like a design but it's about people and creating a zone where it's a circumstances. it's a circumstances because the things are get people out of their shells. we joked this is kind of a a lot to do it get people to hold hands but here on market street

it seemed like somehow we've boxed ourselves in this is a place for people to be themselves. and when you talk about innovation it's about a mindset and a way of seeing of world. i think about this as a tradition of innovation. those dishes were developed 30 or 35 years ago and they were a brilliant idea and all this light we've been repreponderance of the evidence in a unique way of evenly lightning market street. the tinkering beverage was an experiment 3 started with in the lab but if i could touch one and touch each other i'll have more fun. and so we want to bring the

spirit of that kind of cremation into the world. i think of neil and i were talking about this he's been a big proponent of this project that is in the greater market street project this innovation is important. we were thinking about a time when libraries had closed. if you wanted something from the library maybe you got a book may not not but now you can walk into a library and pick up a book. the goal for this is to make this the new normal how you interact with each other maybe is that a before were locked up. i want to thank my team we work

in a studio model we have four or five people to the engineers to the designers to josh back there he's spent missouri most of his design work say volunteer. we have those amazing volunteers that help us turn the corner on projects. i want to thank dennis for an green lighting this. this is an estimation of what we've done an innovation and it requires champions. they trust their people so i want to thank dennis specifically. and on this note i'll introduce the director of the x platform >> wow. look at all the energy in people

here in a zone that's already - i'm so exfoliated to be here. when we moved the "x" tomorrow down to pier 15 it was never meant to stop it here. the opportunity of moving into the urban environmentalists into the neighborhood was part of our community illness when we got started ease move forward into pier 15 pr i want to thank shawn to be the head he thought spear to start building those x tomorrow ideas. it's been our belief also the "x" tomorrow isn't just a place but a way to see the world and to be part of it. it brings, you know, part of those experiences ease grab someone on the side of the street and enjoy it.

that's not the first time we've done this. the project represents one of the x particulars of a new kind of relationship in working with our hometown with the mayor's office and the living innovations idea with the make our own market street idea. this is a vibrant vision that is recreating the capital here and it makes it exciting. i have a number of people to thank. just to say the x tomorrow is proud to be a part of the city. it's an experiment we want to see how it resonates were but this wouldn't have been possible without the mayor's office or the city planning department a go up we've gotten to know the architecture the urban benefit

district the transportation ultimately alternatives but the greatest thanks goes to a man i've gotten to know and have the deepest respect for its our mayor edwin lee who's can do spirit and this new ways of evenly lightning the city that we couldn't be more proud to be a part of it and our champion is mayor ed lee (clapping.) well dennis thank you for that wonderful introduction and to you and the "x" tomorrow and a shawn thank you for your leadership here and

for sponsoring this wonderful effort to demonstrate the connection between innovation and one of our most precious streets in san francisco. you know, i was with supervisor kim a couple of weeks ago in soul korea we were celebrating how wonderful american people innovative capital of san francisco. he was looking at our city and wondering how could we be engaged in the activities and what ideas we could come out with. this innovation was another great attempt that will be successful. where else could you sit here and engage in chips dishes i did that with people in between you

could hear people whisper or educate a song and connect and create a song yourself or for probably the next week have your image carved into a pumpkin. but this is what we wanted to do in the living innovation zone. i want to thank planning and public works with other agencies to connect up with the yerba buena community district to bring out the spirit. and think about those experiments being the first of many to bring out the innovative spirits in all corridors. market street is a wonderful beginning because we want to signal how important this street is to our city.

this is an international street. i know when john have the conventions all people will come down and experiment with all our local people. but if you can imagine when we started this with an accelerator with green start we signaled a year ago we wanted to bring this innovative spirit out to pause and suggest that maybe clean tech companies or solar companies or university or a sister city can actually demonstrate this on third street or maybe a corridor on howard street or carr developing value and bring this innovative spirit right to the local spreadsheet. you can have ideas whether it's a university or another klein

company to bring it and excite people and have all kinds of good spirits. this is why we have an innovation spirit. this should be a great openness to this idea. i want to thank all the entities for bringing this spirit out for reflecting what we can do what we don't create boundary but invite more people into this. we did this a months ago when i had some san francisco students help me to create something on added 3/printer. they were saying this was a time when it's kind of like all a draft or report for them we're able to make some mistakes but create some things along the way

so this spirit can thrive in our city. this is an experiment as dennis and a shawn said and we're allowed to make mistakes but allowed to created things at the same time. it's kind of like government in the private sector this is a pro to type. so that creativity can be reflected in everything we do. we're allowed to do that when we come together in the public and private sector we should suggest to your science partners and all that this creativity can be reflected in so many parts of our city bringing out people to open their minds to other ideas. this is i think the gift that san francisco has with all our partners. i want to thank you for all the

participates in producing this diversity so we can produce other equivalence for the rest of the corridors and the rest of the neighborhoods thank you and congratulations (clapping.) we're ready and a okay. here's to liz. 3, 2, 1,

>> yeah. >> good evening, everyone. my name is syria i'm the executive director of artists ease cultural center it's my pleasure to ask the honorable mayor ed lee to come to the stage and say a couple of words

(clapping.). well, thank you syria and also thank you for your our leadership and arab cultural center. i wanted to be here tonight i don't have enough time to watch the american stories i understand it's about community and community believe and it themes isulnar valuable i know you'll have a wonderful panel discussion afterwards but i want to signal my american heritage month in the city and stress to you the importance of building bridges to utilize our city to the vandal. i want to make sure our city government as well as the things we do