bit less revenue >> it's clear that the trigger for the com memento of rent is between the two proposals. >> practical speaking is that a year difference and i think it's about 18 months difference the main thank was the amount. >> so we're clear on the record t m j would be in the space working on it for 18 months before they start paying represent. >> the difference was about a year so the present value does effect bow mostly the rent. in our study it's just a review so if we precede with the resolution i believe i want to get our connoisseurs curtains there maybe some more opportunity to guide us in our

negotiation and in terms of what you see in terms of office rent and in terms of parking. i want to note that for the record and the port staff to note that we're here to optimize in the intent we have to still go through new york times >> to summarize the port staff asked us to look at the bulk head from our own theoretical base submittal and we justified the rent a little bit and looked at the whole believe you were discussing the buckle head to make it a feasible project. given the seismic and sub you structure costs that would be triggered and came up with a yes on both. you're correct the first part of the report is a good guidance in

the report we can tweak the bulk head project a little bit more. >> okay. any other comments from commissioners. >> just one. let's maybe our directory can answer this one. if negotiations with t m j falls off the cliff do we have a back up and a for the normal process if we don't concluded negotiations we go to the next bird and they welcome that if the opportunity arise so, yes we would come back and inform you. >> thank you. >> uh-huh. >> other comment your obviously hearing from the commission but we're not addressing that but in the event there could be other circumstances that keep this lease on the books for longer

the term or long-range than what we anticipated but say we go beyond 5 years we don't think it will happen but i want to suggest that as if we were to progress into the long-term phase into the lease as structured there's increases based on on the c pi we look at any other percentage rent possibilities after year 5 in the effect we don't precede with total development so we don't lock ourself ♪ the long-term for whatever reasons don't have the ability to participate from the strelth >> you're absolutely correct. >> then gov. again what was raised about the parking can you explain between the two proposals it looks like

waterfront partners include the port for parking was that revolted up into the total from t m j. and again, just reiterating my colleagues comments i think the quality of the two both submittals was extraordinarily high and it was difficult to choose but it reflects what is happening at the port we're able to attract that and i want to thank both parties in participating and hope it will be other opportunities in the future to improve our waterfront >> thank you for all the work you did. >> thank you very much. >> any further comments from commissioners

all in favor, say i. >> i. >> resolution 1351 has passed but i said to say based on awe the time 8 look at the 235eb9 so we get a sense of what's going to happen. >> great. >> one last comment that i appreciate. that the effort to bring in local businesses has not gone unnoticed. they look at bringing in the local businesses that have been in their legitimately they thought they were there before we realized the poor condition the building had been in.

but there will be an effort to bring in local businesses in terms of of bringing in food trucks and other retail establishment that are based on san francisco. i appreciate that effort >> on on the total development we want 0 very, very thorough development and proposal so i think even though there's a lot of interest we don't have the information to make a decision at this time that will require a lot of work on the portside and any interested party that wyoming want to submit as well. >> thank you. >> congratulations. >> thank you very much. >> thank you. item 8 b informational for the requests for the eco center and surrounding 6 thousand 58 square

feet looked in the intersection of jennings street and cargo way >> good afternoon. i'm carol the environmental affairs person. i'm here this knowledge with an informational update with the progress of our workshops for recall in september you authorized staff to issue a request for parole for potential he tenant to operate and to lease and operate the eco center would the ports objectives which which are promoting public access and making the most of the center for an educational resource and engaging the local community and with the educational program in the park. the rfp was used september 24th and the responses westbound were

due. we use the standard procures then used for advertising lease stunt and concluding print in region overlook newspapers and community newspapers. we posted the opportunity on the citywide database as well as the port site. we e-mailed directly to over 4 hundred homeowner associations eased community dproupdz and nonprofit is groups in the bay point area as well as to our port authority and those listed on the mailing list. we e-mailed all existing port tenants regarding the opportunity and a reached out to environmental organizations and corporate responsibility. port staff worked the existing tenant listcy for port justice

to open it for 6 days concluding the days of the weeks and the weekend to open the eco center so anyone who is interested in the building or the opportunity can visit and learn about the eco center. we have a convention in october that was very well attended considering the scale of the opportunity it was tenant by individuals representing 17 different organizations. on the due date of november 8th we received two submittals that meet the qualifications and we were forwarded to the qualification panel. one proposal was sent in by the bay foundation in partnership with the city college of san francisco and other institutions and organizations who commented

to participate in an eco center advise committee. the aquarium bay is an consisting tenant that he port on pier 48 and conditional has provided educate program there are as a subcontractor to the listcy for environmental justice. the other proposal was submitted but the a randall institute. apr i is a bay view nonprofit who's mission to promote education and employment and other opportunity for protecting community. earlier this year apr i helped us to get the word out about green ageers is 9 and 10 and

other graders who operate in partnership with the rec and park department. last year was the. was the first year and we had 12 green ageers who participate in this program due to their interest in community service and environmental issues. this year with the help of apr u 6 of the ageers learned of the opportunity through apr i. additionally as proofed by the port commission in august apr i is a intaushth to the youth employment contract. both proposalser will be presenting their highlight. i want to sigh this is for the commission and a publics information only.

it's not part of the elevation process. the port condone a panel of 4 individuals with expertise in environmental program funding and recreational and accessible facilitates at large and mlthd and community engagement and social organism in the area. port real estate and finance staff are sprail looking at the materials submitted by each proposaler. with that, i invite apr i and then the bay institute to come to the podium each one has 5 minutes to present. amy is going to be our timekeeper so you presenters will hear a tune that signals 5 minutes have pasture and wrap up. so api

>> thank you. >> thank you. >> good afternoon, commissioners my name is is jake i didn't undermining i'm the executive director of the randolph association. i have presented a slide we have the program that carol mentions

about the green ageers here are 5 of the 64th of july in the program. and that's actually taken in front of the of the park. and i include one more comment that, you know, we are apr i we vest in our cities future and this is one of the examples of our potential. the next slide is really, truly drooivenlg in preserving our history. outdoor a randolph was a civil rights legion and we mentioned nelson mandela earlier in line with our mission we continue to fight for jobs and freedom for our community. what we have pictured at the top where i have the youth r and people's 3 at the bottom future at the tape is me in 1992 i was

at the ground breaking memorial it's its second latter to martin luther king junior and i was inspired to serve and i continue to do that day. although i started in 1992 i account to uc davis i worked in the lab before i decided to serve at the a randolph institute and they recruit me for several years i fought them hey, i wanted to go into the science i want to be a doctor one day but nov now i raised 4 kids and i refer other kids as my own >> what we do now is workforce

development for the families in the bay hunters point we do programs. the picture at the top is the hazard met training and our training is required for the academy we recruit for and at the bottom corner interests a workforce of folks that are cleric of community workers and carpenterers and construction workers routing right you outside of the hunter power plant we helped folks to bring that power plant down. it's adjacent to the location. we want to see our resident really live in san francisco and seeks sustainable ability splo through those programs. pictured if the top corner are folks we've he pardoned with in the past. i want to mention that luminal k

is one of the women owned solar businesses. we partnered around policy advocate around the higher organization and they hires local >> we're here to inspire our youth and prepare for the greener initiative and beyond. this city we haven't done a lot of development. we want to see real opportunity in construction in the green industry and introduce those concepts to our community. we can be very innovative with solar and technologies we're seen that were i want to introduce that to our young folks and invest in their future. we want to see a local billed

out of solar and conservatism in san francisco. we've attempted to bridge the gap between community and even though eco center. we see this as an opportunity to connect the environmental where the conversation is generally absent. we bring observe youth to places like city hall and i've got to std speed through. this is an example of last summer you remember we recruited for the academy and there's just one photo up there from a design competition they do an internship where they bring >> may i interrupt you the 5 minutes has republic out can we

oh, her another 2 minutes. >> it's up to you arrest i'm going to ask for the 2 manipulates because we have 2 hours of public comment coming. >> so i think we need to speed long here. >> i will definitely wrap up. this next photo is an example of the potential that we have. we completed this program this year those are the 6 portraits 5 of the of the instructor is the one with the orange hat this is an example of what we want that exhibit in the eco center and want to inspire you to draw outside the lines and dream with correspond. that's one worker or example of the potential.

this is us walk from the office over to the park. the two at the bottom you can see the growth. we want to connect our youth to boarder issues in the world so each year we try to bring youth to our conventions and last year, it was in d.c. we had the opportunity to walk in the washington. we can't do this alone we have a lot of supporters we have folks here today, i want to ask them to stand and i'm sure they'll provide some comments as well but thank you for the time to be here to speak and thank you monique for the two center

minutes to speak >> thank you. >> thank you. >> carol are you going to introduce the next. >> excuse me. we have the bay foundation. >> good afternoon, commissioners. my name is see caring write chin i'm the director at the bay view foundation. i want to share about our vision for the proposal we've put forth for the eco center. this is a unique stunt it's not

just a green building. it is within the watershed that drains through 9 neighborhoods. we're interested in creating a collaborative opportunity where the bay mission will work with the city college it's been there since 2012 doing literacy. we want to take the building blocks and there the programming forethe viral education focusing on that community. first and a for mothering most we know it's important to engage the community to get involved with the eco center. first off the staff we plan on hiring are representatives of south east san francisco. they're from district then 10 so

staff will be representative of that town. we're bam began to build a community member organization they'll help us to make the decisions. we want the community to be very involved in the decision making. we've also engaged any community presenters to be involved with future programming at the site and a future use of the eco center and finally, we'll be recruiting allocates person to have community representative e recommendation within our organization. i want to talk about the different programs we plan to provide at the eco center and

talk about the diversity of audience we want to reach. we want to talk about the casual visitor. there are programs that are already existing tours and the eco center is open we want to continue to build and we'll be developing a mobile website so you'll be able to access information about the organization about the green believe specifics and about the park and we'll be able to change it seasonally. we'll be open to the public 4 days a week and adding this interpret programs where we're focusing on the wetland and the different green building features and many of those will utilize the portions are showing in the low going. we'll be working with

volunteers. there are existing programming both weekly and monthly that the college is funning and we'll be expanding those opportunity. we want to have a shoreline cheap program and providing other opportunity for ongoing volunteers as well as one time volunteers at the site. we also want to work on programs for working professionals. in a way that's the the advisors committee gets involved but we want to create different types of programming that want to tour and lower than about the site. we want to work on be teacher development both the moratorium and city college have agreed to have stylists. we want to focus on public

school students and teachers. all the programs that are happening there reaching over one thousand students a year is free of charge. so he wanted to expand this down to san francisco and make sure that group is engaged. we have a couple of of program advisory representatives already >> and then the citizens of san francisco and getting the community involved again, we want to citizens 80 realize the gem of this organization. >> could we oh, her the same two manipulates. >> i'll rush throw things. starting day one we are going to be opened to the public and we're starting with what

conditional began and building on that. we have the port objectives we've demonstrated how we've begun to engage with the community. we're going to maximize the center and adding best practices like integration with science standards and am appropriate programming and levels. the port wants someone to operate and maintain the surrounding landscape. the staff we're going to hire from city college has been going that and the standard operating progresses is the same to maintain the landscaping. the port wants to engage the local community. again we've started to engage the community in a variety of different ways i've that shown and to coordinate with the staff

and we have a long history. in closing, i want to stress this an amazing site and the aquarium foundation and city college welcomes the opportunity to have that. i know first off, i want to thank you for your time i know we have loot supporter in the audience and i want to notify you guys to stand and sigh it up for supporting us. thank you >> okay. all right. >> here we go. okay. thank you very much to both of our proposers for gracio graciously vrpt our timeline. i plan to come back to you with

a recommendation at the january 14th meeting and that that concludes my presentation >> thank you. thank you. we do have expensive public comment and as you know we're loltd 3 minutes per speaker we have about 40 speakers lined if you can do it within two minutes we'll appreciate it. but anyway, having said that i appreciate our consideration in making your comments as brief as you can. the first off is dr. espanol >> good afternoon. doctor espanol jackson. i would just like to -

>> go ahead. >> i would like to state that may be one or two of you commissioners know this is a toxic site. in fact, they were trying to make it a park i was opposed to it by an e.r. no child and i call all the children at bay point my children no way should they be allowed to go there. and i'm glad you're not making a decision tonight because when i heard the speaker talking about green that building is not green that's toxic and i'd ask that you go on the internet and get the er that was done by the department and