the most powerful guy in the room knows i'm not easily expressed. with the champion kers he's tale an interest in the street and has come out on his own and made arrests of the people who are smoking in the bus stop in the shelter which is one of my pet peeves i don't care what you're smoking unless it's pot. it's really made a difference. this is the second meeting that he and i have been together because we had a community meeting with jane kim concerning the shooting on market street and jones and it was, you know, was most of the more than he was

there and chipper as usual so i get to add him to the people i enjoy working with and it's champion michael redd anyone and i was very happy to learn that champion greg is now at northern station i'm expecting to be foreman a champion group to kick byte. i happen to know where the bad guys are and hanging out human resources i want to give a shout you tell to pat whose give me me the best services in the sfpd. i want to wish you all a happy new year and save holiday and i'm done with the things here

>> thank you and have a happy holiday season. any further comment. apply lawrence before you begin to speak i want to bring to our attention this committee has rules one of which you are away of >> speak up you want to talk about rules. >> one you didn't obey at the last meeting please, please obey the rules of public comment and i know what the brown act is i can speak under any topic here as well as i don't harass anyone on the board so don't tell me what the rules are. >> i don't tell you what the rules are you obviously don't know them. >> i don't want a sermon.

>> mr. lawrence please. i speak on behalf of we the people and when i bring comments here in front of the commissioners, any questions or comments? public at larger. >> there's the opinion. >> (multiple voices). >> he don't have a basis to get involved. >> legislator your voice. >> i was speaking. >> you're not allowed to speak in a public former. >> mr. thank you, your honor man arresting you're not allowed to address me when i'm speaking. >> i don't need a sermon from you when i'm speaking either. are you done >> mr. lawrence to me. >> i appreciate it if you start

me at 3 minutes i was 2rur79d by mr. thank you, your honor man. >> your 3 minutes have not started. >> don't start insinuating me. please lower your voice the minutes have started >> you better keep your lieutenant in line here that's part of your job he has 40 no right to insult me he's under the line under the sunshine law and the brown act. for the record i'm here to speak in front of inform of this commission i've been a city receipt for 45 years mr. thank you, your honor man please direct our words to the entire commission >> i will lower my voice. >> thank you. >> i speak on behalf of people that live in the city of san

francisco i don't speak on behalf of myself. a lot of people contact me and want to know why i'm the only commuter speaker in front of of the forum and i appreciate their contacts because no one addresses issues that are directly involved if the city of san francisco. you talk here and compliment one other about the great job but the public pays for this and you don't understand that on any base whatsoever. i don't bring up things that i make up on my own. things that are never discussed in this commission. the last time i brought up on and on a newspaper article that was not discussed and now i bring to your attention out of

the paper i don't necessary favor political comments because they backed the black panthers at large but they come up with various articles that no paper will publish. decembers issue taxes in the sfpd brutalityly about a black bicyclists that was beat up. i don't make the case because i was beat up and put many a choke hold and kicked. those are issues you should discuss here. it's good to give officers plaques and a compliments for doing a great job because you have a lot of good officers but a lot of bad officers that walking about us they're part of occ compliance and they have

complaints they're never discussed and their names are not brought. when a sense at large runnings into this year i leave you the articles that should be discussed about sfpd officers beating up a sense for whatever reason. we have police but we don't live in a police state not yet anywhere and those are issues you should concern yourself with you leave you two copies of the newspaper >> thank you. next speaker. >> good evening ms. brown. >> as also i'd like to use the overhead. i'm paulette brown and i'm here

to talk about my son who was murdered and thirty rounds of bullets were pumped into him my sons case is not sofldz and i'm looking for justice for my son and the last time we were told to check on the cold cases. my son was a good boy. he graduated from went a to catholic school. i had to walk across the state to receive his diploma. he was 17 years old a baby. as i said all before the holidays are here my son loved christmas. he's not here to enjoy this

christmastime with his family. as a mother i hurt everyday not just when i come here but everyday when i'm at home when there's nothing else to do and when it's time for me to a go to sleep i'm in pain even though i have two daughters left. but i try to stay strong for them but it's hard. but they see the paper in their mother everyday. i wouldn't wish this open any parents any parents i'm not saying those people don't have problems but this is something i need to keep saying and doing. because if it i do not i'll probably laid and die.

it's hard i might look okay open the inside but i'm in pain the period of time interest rates are still walking the street to kill again. we all know who they are and we all know they did it. i don't want an ice for american people eye i don't want them dead i want them to go to jail to prieven and realize what they've done to themselves not only to me and my son but to themselves also. not only did they take my son but if they go to jail their mother is going to miss them. i just want justice for my child and please help me.

thank you. thank you, ms. brown >> any further public comment public comment is closed please call the next line item. >> line item 4 reports and announcements chefs report and review of recent activities as good evening, commissioners and public. i comment on a couple of public comments we spoke to the suspect on the bicycle which when encountered one of the officers who was bit. for a full version. so far as ms. brown goes as also we're lacking the witness or witnesses that could come forward and anybody who has information we'd appreciate it we have the list that ms. brown

has given me to search for the suspects one it deceased and others are in custody and others occult of custody. we'd love to give you the closure by the but we need the testimony. update open crime in san francisco. it's been reported that crime is up it's up approximately 14 percent on a largely driven property crime. property crime is up 20 percent since the inception of the a b-109 and we're grasping left leg with the consequence of not having the repeat offenders that aren't able to accept an alternative strategy of incarnation the shootings are done and homicides are down

thirty percent. and hopefully, we, carry that momentum into 2014. anybody that's shopping in san francisco we're passing out flyers we have posted off parking garage meters please keep our packages in the trunk of your car don't get so evenly tlarld with your cell you make yourself available for crime. this will make you less available as a victim and help us to get a hold on the property crimes right now. a couple of the cases there was a homicide no june victor was killed in the district sea homicide investors developed the suspect joshua who was located and placed under arrest.

the investigation is continuing and there was some press early that our save streets operation that is in concert with other law enforcement agencies and the u.s. attorney's office are targeting drug dealers all within one thousand feet of our schools and children for to the end the suspects will be charged federally and the sentence will be a long time stay from the tenderloin. every one of those suspects having had a minimum of 10 arrests for sales and analytic and more than 40 arrests in the tenderloin. make no mistake those restraining order dealers not users more than 90 percent of them don't reside in the city. on a brighter note as the

holidays go forward we continue to do a lot of things in the community thursday the wellness program received a sift with the westport tall kids we did the dreams toy drive with the sfpd champ was last saturday and the batkid and his family were back again and it ended in $137,000 to make wishes come true for kids who have medical companies. operation dream continued and it was a victory over the seahawks. the officers did a great job they had a good time with the fans. we had 23 booksing for too much

alcohol and had 43 patient we booked for alcohol and two arrested for vandalism there was a report that a person was hit with a bottle and that was from his roommate. and on saturday we'll be doing the gun buy back at the boy's club with commissioner marshall hopefully, we'll bargain to come close to 3 hundred guns and on august '89 in the mission we evident up with one hundred and 50 guns. tomorrow are will b will be the services for the lieutenant truly one of our finest >> that concludes my presentation. >> we'll be on a break here we

are going to have some new officers. >> right we'll be graduating an academy class on saturday the 27 every supervisor wants to have their cadets dpraut. it's critical if you're ever talking to anybody we stay on the schedule because every time we bump a class back we're down until 2018 >> approximately, how many officers. >> somewhere around foy. >> i want to 2k3wi6 a big thank you to the united states attorney's office for helping in the tenderloin. it has a significant impact when

those individuals are arrested they're the worst of the worse offends and there's no cycle door and the fancy deals it's federal prison learn our lessons and i want to thank the da's office and the federal government and all >> nobody knows when their next arrest you're next arrest could land you in federal custody. >> that's great. >> sxhufs. >> i have one question i know we're pushing people to go on and on online do we have a e an update. >> no longer do we have to tell people to wait until notify you, go on the sf gov. 24 hours a day

3 hundred and 65 days a year and sign up for the test within 6 weeks take the test our list will be a living list on and on we're encouraged so far but the folks we're debiting every color of the ribbon and squall orientation we'll end up with a really, really good quality pool we're not going to lose folks everywhere. we ask folks inform sign up and take the test they're in the process >> thank you commissioner kingsley. >> chief it's good to hear the gun buy back is happening what's the compensation. >> you know i believe its $100

for the handguns and 2 hundred there's for any assault rifle i believe. anything for the cohesive. call line item 4 d or b >> occ director's report and review of recent activities and the comprehensive statistical report for january one through january emphasizing and the mediation of complaint and adjudication of sustained complaints in 2013. >> good evening director hicks and good evening, members of the audience. you have the reports in your paycheck but in fwreef through november 2013, the okay occ

received cases through 2012 when the occ received 6 hundred and unnecessary cases but closed 5 hundred and 32. we sustained 48 cases as of november 30th of this year we had pending case down as of the same time period in 2012 >> moving to cases that were mediated in november of 2013 the occ mediated 3 cases and that compares to 4 that were mediated in november nevada. between january 2012 and

january 20, 1354, cases were mediated down if 58. move to adjudication of sustained complaint. chief suhr a.d. juktd occ cases where i determined sustainable allegation and encompassed discipline as follows:. one case was for a neglected doubt involved a traffic stop for failure to have license plate the officer wrong flu searched the trunk and failed to collect traffic data and received a republic manned >> the officer was the passenger in a marked

impractical patrol vehicle go who yelled at a cyclist and used harsh and pronounce language there was a witness unrelated to the cyclist who was an attorney for the justification and collaborated the incident. the partner didn't see what happened but saw the officer push the cyclist. discipline was imposed. there was sustained duty will the officer failed to give a report as required by the general order and that this was because the officer was trart a female and the officer was

admonished. another case where we standard unwarranted action in in relation of duty altercation and the officer inlawfullyly seized property address reviewed to give the owner a property receipt and co- that milking the property with the co- complainants property the officer was admonished. another case a sustained doubt obligation the officer was admonished. in the case of discredit an officer was aggressive and demeaning to a man having a non-psych emergency and that's where the insufficient everyday

the officer was admonished. another case resolving the officer reviewed to collect traffic data and the office was retrained. and an officer gave the landlord wrong voices and the officer was admonished and any trained he said after giving that advise did go back and said it was incorrect advise. that concludes my report >> on the bicyclist case i asked for a followup interview and was wanting more clarity so i didn't have a choice but to find insufficient evidence.

>> the occ rules prevented the follow-up interview. >> probably more appropriately be discussed in closed session should the commission wish to do so but the occ provided the officer with a preliminary finding and this was an incidents where the follow-up spoof was not about the evidence before the cohesive it was about whether or not the officer was lying. and so there was a suggestion by internal faifrz description of to bring up a altercation that the officer was lying and bring the officer back in and ask the

officer whether or not he had a different thought about his denial. so - >> commissioner commissioner chan. >> thank you. i've noticed in the previous reports the majority reports theirs admonishment and not a suspension. i'm wondering in the progressive policy and practices are those cases and other cases getting any specifics is it the first time offense >> yes. the first time offense our for all. >> so the second time. >> that's a republic manned.

>> for instance, there was a case that was a first offense started with a republic manned. >> thank you. >> commissioner loftus. >> well director hicks it seems i was left unclear if there's follow-up especially talking about an officer lying is there vocation into that i wonder if there's follow-up for something we can besides better about the process to make sure it didn't get dropped. >> commissioner loftus nothing was dropped nicole this was a endearment over the sufficiency of the evidence that was presented and in this instance the officer had been asked whether or not that officer said those words to the clairvoyant

the officer denied. it was our determination that probation officer to bring him back in and say where you lying was not going to resolve additional evidence except he would deny. he was saying that in his original interview and now, when you ask is there an opportunity to do additional interviewing or gather additional evidence once we've made a determination jefferson once we've made a determination that's takes into account the determination, however, there are instances where the officer or the

complainant asked for a hearing and indicates there's additional evidence we will reopen the investigation >> okay. but not nicole. >> we determined in this case it wouldn't be fruitful and we didn't agree. >> thank you. >> all right. call like that item 4 c as commissioners report. >> i want to report that both commissioner caan and i meet r with commissioner mahoney and went over the lack of compliance with the officers and we moot with officer brown and went over our interim rules. we're down to very, very if you