showing these names of the people or the perpetrators that were there that shot my son on that day and i am showing these in hope that somebody will recognize who these persons are and come for forth. and give me some closure. so, i keep showing these names because of that and i am not only for my son, but i am here for all of these young men that have been murdered and these are all unsolved cases and i speak for those mothers also and we are just looking for justice. for our children. but again, i want to keep showing these names of the people that were involved with my son's case, especially thomas hannibal and paris

moffett and those are the ones that i know more about. and i will keep my son's memories and this case open because it is a cold case. and i always show this picture of all that i have left of him, and my memories. is him laying in the casket and me looking at him. no mother should have to go through this. and this is something that i will have to be doing for the rest of my life. but, it is for my therapy and for my closure. and keep me going that i continue to do this. and hopeful that this case will get solved one day. and that is all thatvy to say. >> thank you miss brown. >> thank you. >> good evening, first of all i want to welcome joe garity and it has been a while buddy, i see that you have a star on

now, gave him another one, loftus is returning in june, i heard, i heard. >> i heard it. and i know how cool it is. and sorry, we are on tv. >> okay. >> and i have a good friend called me today, clyde have you heard? and i said what? president obama on the floor. and you see, and call the president and he said mr. president, my father says that you are spying on me. president said, that is not true and that is not really your father. let's talk about something more serious and you were here chief when he came to san francisco and he ran into a motorcycle cop and he turned really kind of bad and he was not in

uniform and that happened to me last wednesday. and i am walking down market street, and there are two harley davidson cops, and they stand by the car and chitchat and so i walk politely, who is watching that driver, and they said what? do you remember that case and he pulled out a gun and shot two motorcycle cops in the face and he looked at me and said get the... out of here or i will arrest you, the motorcycle cops and how you guys not all of them, and as i was talking to the deputy chief, and they are not all of them, some of them have this attitude that they are above everybody and that is the wrong attitude and honestly it is chief, you need to talk to them or their boss and i mean that it is not cool. it is not cool at all.

and i walk down the substation and i walk in and there are cops standing there and what is the choice any way? and what are you talking about? that is not it, and that is not an appropriate question and that is not an important question and i don't do drugs. and get out of here or i will arrest you. >> we are talking about the community service, or friendliness? and i mean that we have a lot of great cops and we have 1650, give or take, but we got a few bad ones, take a look at them and take care. >> next speaker. >> good evening, commissioners my name is stephan, and i want to talk about not a good hire but a great hire. and what i mean by that is eddie santos is the head of the alu and it is one of those thankless jobs that you get where there is a high volume of new applications and a high

volume of transfer application and people want the applications processed but it is a process and it takes time. and i think that he has the right temperament for the job and he has the right leadership skills for the job and it is a job that you have to have a lot of experience because you have to size people and situations up and you have to implement the conditions that are assure that the community is going to be safe and a better place. so i just want to say this, sometimes you g get it and you are just thrilled about it and i think that it has a bright future and to have eddie at the helm and i think that we also need to look at our budgets because of the high volume of work, that that unit has to take on, that he has the resources and the staff to tackle that job and there is a lot on your plate, thank you. >> thank you. >> and any further public comment? >> hearing none, public comment is closed. call line item number 4. >> reports and announcements. 4 a, chief's report, discussion

and review recent activities presentation of the 4th quarter 2013 fdrb find ands recommendations and ois investigative summary and the department's budget presentation for the physical year 2014/15. >> good evening, chief, commissioners, public and director hicks. i'm going to start my presentation again, as we do, whenever we hear miss brown's more than reasonable ask for someone to come forward on the 24 hour tip line is 575-4444, if anybody has any information with regard to this homicide, or any unsolved homicide we would really appreciate someone coming forward, and then again, miss brown. but we welcome that you come here and have this conversation, however uncomfortable and hopefully some day we will get it brought to closure, so before i go into the rest of my comments i am

going to ask john loftus, are you retiring in june? >> i am going to bring him up and he has a very well deserved presentation to make. >> chief, and good evening commissioners and director hicks. he left. >> and he could keep a secret at the hall. >> he said that he had to say and can i get the facts? >> tonight, we have invited down to the command staff of the department of public works for some well deserved recognition. you know i am sure that you folks are aware that we worked very, very closely with the department of public works and when we reach out to them and they are handling the events or incidents, the response is always the same. what do you need, when do you need it and where do you need it and they are always there for us. and i would like to ask

(inaudible) to come on up for a moment. this award is way overdue. but, a few years back, we dealt with occupy sf, and we were extremely successful in our operations with occupy sf, thanks in large part to our critical partners and the aid they gave us. we cleaned out justin herm an plaza in one evening and it was a terrific job and it was only because of the prior planning and the help for dpw and all of the equipment to come in and clean that up and about a year or a year and a half later, we dealt with an issue out at fellow laguna where there is a large park and the people had and camped in the trees a similar situation occurred, and they were up in the trees for 600 days and it cost the city over a million dollars and we reached out to dpw and provided us the equipment and they trained with the tactical units

for two days prior to the operation and we were able to take three people out of trees. no one was injured and it was a successful operation and so i want to thank them and provide them with this plaque and i need my glasses. and this is from the san francisco police department and it was a certificate of merit and appreciation, it is awarded to nahamid who could not make it tonight, and stringer and the gang at dpw, in the deepist gratitude for your exceptional service for the take down of the encampment and the plaza on 2011, and the assault on the occupy and the form that fell on the streets on june 13th, 2013 and for your unwavering support of the san francisco police department during the

occupy sf movement presented this the 5th day of february, 2014. thank you very much. >> on behalf of the commission we want to thank you and i know that a lot of times you are called on to do the thankless work of cleaning up the mess and often times i hear on raet from dpw can come out and you are always out there taking care of hazards and helping the police officers, and so thank you very much, it is greatly appreciated so thank you. >> and chief, before we move into the report. >> we have one more. >> we got one more. >> what is his rank now? >> one star. >> okay. and i would come on and any more often and i put on the tie on and the old spice. and i will do that more often. and yeah. isn't that true. >> okay. >> and with the dpw we do a lot of work as the chief mentioned and along with that, this year,

we had the and it was late night hoop, and pea soups or the midnight double for, and a lot of times, we present, or we forget that the people around us, and only the people around you and we asked dpw for the things that we present for the plaques to learn from the barnyard for the parker and the people that crn numbers and also with the plaques and most importantly for us, we have a lot of challenges with the staff being and so to elevate the security base line and we had an idea of putting the extra portable lights on by joe lee and just to elevate that a little bit around the center so that the people would be hanging out and we have it on the joe lee during the basketball game and during the game and with that we called dar and he had tim come up and put the lights up for all of the games and was effective and was ad good idea and we had the ins and outs and effecting the security good and i think that it was important, and for that, we have a certificate of appreciation, for timothy hines with the department of public

works and the deepist gratitude that led to an overwhelming success of the 2013 late night pea soup and skills forum. and awarded by chief of police. >> chief? >> thank you very much. >> >> thank you. >> thank you very much. >> thanks. >> i forgot to mention at the very beginning of our agenda here tonight. we always not always, but we adjourn in the memory of former police officers, and current police officers and we are going to adjourn in the memory tonight, beginning here, but when we do adjourn, in the memory of sergeant michael jfrnlts hutcin, from company northern station who lost his battle to cancer, he served the san francisco police department since june of 1990, he

graduated in 178th recruit class and he leaves behind his sister who is a san francisco police officer, and his father who was a san francisco police officer and his wife, joyce and three children, michael junior, britney, and malik. and we will adjourn in his memory and his honor tonight. thank you. >> chief? >> thank you, commissioner. >> some recent updates and i know that we have two presentation and so i will be brief. >> we did suffer our second homicide of the year and but more importantly, one more significantly it was our first homicide at the hands of an intimate parter over 43 months going back to may tenth although the relationship was only two weeks old, it was still an intimate relationship, and although, 43 months was something significant, we wear it around here that we now start again and hopefully we

will get to way past 43 months, but we did suffer our second homicide in late january. and again, unfortunately yesterday, we suffered our first pedestrian fatality, since our meetings and our commitment to zero fatalities for the year, and it occurred on sunset boulevard at yorva and, the driver of the vehicle was at fault, and it has been charged with the vehicular manslaughter. and the efforts of the officers that i have to say has been significant. and citations are up, since that meeting, 43 percent. across the city. and they are going to go up more, so again, our i implore the public to slow down, bicyclists and motorists for the sake of our cap able friends over at the occ, and we don't want more occ complaints and we take no pleasure in

writing tickets, we would rather everybody's money to stay in their pocket books, if everybody would slow down and pay attention and again, to folks that are not in the cars, i get that sometimes the cars are aggressive, but sometimes you can be right and some of these instances or killed, and i am not siding with the cars i am just asking for the people to be smart and protect themselves until we can get a handle on this thing. so with that, i am going to give it over to sergeant krudo and he is going to make the presentation on the firearm discharge review board findings and recommendations. for the 4th quarter of 2013. >> thank you, chief. >> president mazzucco, vice president turman? >> chief, and officer involved shooting investigators team and

i am here to present as the chief said, the fdr finding from the third quarter, as well as the open officer shooting investigation. >> the fourth quarter, firearm discharge vehicle convened on january 14th, 2014. and at that when it convened, there were four cases that were considered and four investigations. one was an officer involved

discharge 008-13. and the shootings, and all from 2011, 11-110, 005, and 006. i will summarize those cases briefly, and define it. and the fdrb was composed of the following members chin was the chair and chief loftus and comprised the rest of the voting members and vice president turman was present and marin represented the occ, in addition, badrini was there and also of the sf pd range and also chief chin included captain david lazar of the training division as a non-voting advisory member, and that is a new addition to the fdrb. the first case that was considered was the officer involved discharge, 008-13. which occurred on october 17,

2013, and this was a case involving two biting dogs in this case, the officers were following up on a cold burglary report and two dogs came out of the door and attacked the officers. and one officer fired defensive and the two officers present. that was found in policy. the officer involved shootings that were reviewed were case 11.003, this case occurred on june 29th, 2011, and on the golf street between eddie and ellis and in this particular instance, two officers were following up on an investigation involving an armed suspect at large. they responded to this area, and were immediately confronted with the armed suspect who was going to be in the leading area, the suspect pointed a hand gun at the officers and the officers returned fire and the suspect attempted to flee and the officers fired again at the fleeing final and so on.

and the suspect was struck twice and taken into custody.. and that is ongoing at this time. this case was found to be in policy. 11.005, this occurred on the broad way corridor in 2011 and 2:00 a.m., uni formed officers from the central station were in the area when they noticed a suspect matching a fugitive description. when the officers attempted to obtain the subject he began to run from the officers and during the course of the pursuit pulled a tech nine pistol from his waste band and one of the officers fired and the suspect was taken into custody and he was not struck. and that was found in the policy. ois, 11-006 occurred on november third, 2011, this was

on the 600 block of tungston street and in this particular case, the officers responded to a residence regarding a report of a stabbing. and the officers were confronted with a victim out in front of the residence that reported that his son had attacked him inside and there were other residents inside. and the officers went inside and found a second mortally injured victim who happened to be the suspect's mother and as they were trying to provide emergency evacuation and attend to the victim, the suspect confronted the officers, and ignored the commands and one officer fired twice in defense of all present. and the suspect was mortally struck. this was found to be in policy. >> and then i will give you an update on the status of the officers, those were the four cases considered. i will give you an update on the open officer-involved shooting investigations. and what it is a different

format and i will point out that says that i believe that you have the hand out and that says 20 open cases as of yesterday's 21. so, three of the cases, it was, the cases were 11-003, and 005 and 006 were presented to the commission. and one case that we have received the charge and decisioning from the da. and that is at homicide. and they are finalizing the criminal investigation and that will be forwarded to us. and ied. and in the cases are with the district attorney office and those, and they are either reviewing the case files or preparing summary letters, they do, i have a better understanding of their process, but they do, they get the case file and they review it and prepare a summary report and it is reviewed and they prepare a summary letter and which is forwarded to our department to

the homicide and then that closes the homicide investigation. 8 cases and 8 of the ioses are in that charge with the da. and three of the cases have been opened since the last time that i was here before you, 13008, 009 and 14001 i will add four cases obviously as of yesterday, 14002. and then finally the cases are ongoing active, and iad and or homicide investigation. >> just to address the specific cases i mentioned that i am not going to repeat, but i mentioned the three ois from 2011 and those are for all purposes closed and actually since this was prepared you should have received the summary reports from and those are finished. and in the new cases that have started and you will not see

14-002 yet, that is like i said, just yesterday. but, 13-008, 009 and 14-001 are new cases, that have gone at least as far as the return of the presentation and those are new since the last fdrb. and excuse me, since the last quarterly presentation. and then, this is just a summary of the investigations by year. >> and so 113, 5, and 6, have been found in policy, and those cases will be closed and you received the summary letters. and opposite of the district attorney is drafting the letter on 11-007 and they are preparing the final charging decision on 11-008 and the oldest case. and 12-001. homicide is awaiting the final charging decision for that. and homicides, awaiting the final charging decision on 002.

003, is still waiting the eme and the medical examiner report and so that is father along. and the other cases from 2012 are with the da and they are among the 8 cases that i mentioned in the charging decision. >> 13-001, 002, are in the same condition as the cases from 2012. and the remaining cases are active and ongoing investigations 13-3 through 13-7 were active the last time that i spoke to you and receipt maining cases 13-008, and 009, and 14-001, and 002 are new cases since the last time that we appeared. >> in the investigations. and 14-002 is we have a calendar to the return to duty

next. great. >> well, thank you, sergeant. and so, so, we have some cases from 2011 still sitting in the district attorney's office and we have one case at this point. and we are back on it. >> sure. >> 007. >> and 13-007, homicide has received the letter and 13-008 are drafting the decision letter and they are working on the letter now. >> they have made the changes in the process and i have been talking to the folks over there and one of the things that they have been doing was holding until the criminal case had been adjudicated. and so they have changed that process and also spread the work instead of going through one person to work on the letter of parallel now and so you are taking the steps to access rate the process. >> that has been my concern and i know that they are cautious

and take it seriously and i am glad that they are signing the cases to the other assist an das and it is good to know that they are waiting for the public to know for example, if there is an officer involved shooting, and the suspect also was being charged with an unrelated offense and with an assault on the officers, it takes times for those case to conclude in the criminal courts, before the issue their final decision and so it is good to know that now, so thanks for the clarification. commissioner loftus? >> thank you, for every quarter i feel like it is helping understand and see things moving. and so, i note, that the eight cases, i think that have transitioned since the last time, you came to see us, and it seems as though your one charging decision that we got from the last caughter from the district attorney office on your list. >> the letters that we presented we received all of those charging decisions. those, once we get the charging decision, it is a fairly quick process to close it. so the three that were

presented, the three oises, 11, 3, and 5 and 6 presented at the last quarterly fdrb, when i spoke last time we did not have the letters. >> so those that we finished all of the last parts. >> but we and okay. and we closed out since receiving the letters >> so this is another and, this is why this is helpful for me to understand that these are cases from 2011 and going to the firearm discharge review board and just for the point of clarification for me to understand that time line and that process and i had an understanding that those were reviewed close ner time to the incident and if you could get me and remind me that the colleagues might already know this what the factors are that made it ready to go. >> the firearm discharge review board is summarizing both the criminal and the administrative

investigations and so, all of the piece haves to be closed. there are. and the, the administrative investigation by the internal affairs is depending on the criminal investigation and so that has to be concluded, obviously, if there was a criminal issue that was determined, you know, out there and the criminal kulpability that would have to be concluded on the criminal investigation side, and in addition to the district attorney's review and process. which is outside of our control. there are other dependencies that may include the medical examiner's officers and criminal and the crime lab issues and the other factors that play into that, but once the criminal investigation by our department, these investigations are conducted by homicide and, our homicide division, and once those are concluded then they are presented to the da for review

and then the da as you know is conducting the own concur ant investigation, and they are a process is internal and but they put their both investigations together, and they make a determination and review the case files and it is my understanding and then they prepare a report for the final charges decision. >> and then, after they get that, then, they write their charging decision letter. and so that triggers all of those things would trigger a presentation before the firearms discharge. >> right and then it is ready and then we can speak to the review board about what the findings of the two investigations were and that is really the purpose to present it to the command letter for the executive review and to the chief and and so we are able to and we cannot present the closed investigation until they are closed. right. >> and so i just woman to echo

what president mazzucco said and you have been hearing from us about how much we want these to and how important it is that the investigation is thorough but this investigation is justice delayed and denied. and you better age them and if there was cultbility found and it would cause it, and i am glad that you are working with the da's office to identify the area the areas that we can work with the board and those three cases were presented and on top of that you got the letter on the fourth case and i wish that i could say that it was something that i did and these things have been in process and i, got a better et indication and kienld of what the process is on their side and it is invisible >> you are the guy that comes before us and we ask you to make magic to happen and you have little control over it