Skip to main content

tv   [untitled]    July 20, 2014 2:30pm-3:01pm PDT

2:30 pm
contract contract for convenience and to authorize the final payment in the amount of 95 thousand dollars plus incurred on the project and >> item? seen none, public comment is closed. . commissioner low. so what happened at the board of permanent appeals does the project need to be redesigned >> the department is looking at for the renovation we're looking at withdrawing the permit and the item go back to the appeal board and the renovation plan will going cuckoo. >> and have to be rebid.
2:31 pm
>> we're looking at different vehicles for the construction i mean one avenue could be a form of contract and another a j oc that's think exceeded way of completing that, yes there has to be a rebid to the scope. >> so some of those termination costs that lowers the bids on the new scope of the work. >> that's correct the interior part of the work we'll do on this rams that's buffoon done not an added cost to the rams. >> so the new scope of work we k can still stay on budget. >> that's correct. >> seeing no other questions is
2:32 pm
there a motion? >> so moved. >> moved and seconded in favor so moved. >> we're on item 11 port smith renovation project and. >> it the locked in chinatown and near walter alley it's a living room of chinatown residents next to some time. the restroom was built in 1990 and quickly became the most uses restroom in our public parks. in under the 2008 bond the restroom task force evaluated the restroom and recommended to increase the capacity. through community meetings we went through a planning process
2:33 pm
and recommended replacement of the restrooms in order to increase the capacity. on the overhead okay. our images of that restroom building that was designed and approved by this commission and the arts commission that is the modern interpretation of chinese architecture it is increasing the men's room from 4 to 6 and the women's from 2 to 6 and recreational use. the estimated cost of the project at the time of the commission approval of the time was $800,000 plus we put the project out to bid twice. the first time was in may of 2014 we received bids four bids
2:34 pm
the bids expedite our project and the average was $1.47 million the high costs for the architecture metal work and the c m u this is what the building is comprised of we looked at creating all of the elements in the project identified 8 possible all of the elements and looked at it modifying the details we simply switched in aluminum to a steel material that brought down the price and did a perform specification so there's no unknowns requiring the contractor to do a mac markup of
2:35 pm
the construction. the overlay project was increased to $1.265 million. in the 3 bids we received 5 and of those the contractor who submitted the lowest bid is changing construction in the amount of $1 million plus the r and l.b. contractor that performed on a couple of not more city projects including the one south van ness project in 2009 the value was $5.7 million and they did the renovation of the clubhouse for $2.7 million and the projects were completed to the satisfaction of the city.
2:36 pm
if approved the changing construction the total budget will be $2 million $37 plus therefore the staff recommendation to say award the contract go to the chang construction. additional a reallocation of $1.68 million from the 2008 from the parks contingency fund to the project. >> any public comment on that item? please come forward richard. go ahead >> good morning, commissioners i've been listening tour your
2:37 pm
package this project has been detailed over different times this project should then be considered whether there's a 20th century 20, 17 or renovation of the entire park area i don't know how that 2012 fits with this project you have this project from the 28 funding enough said i have a question in my mind how that type of money it moving at&t park when you look at the other issues on this park practical kind of stuff such there's a lot of pissing often the side of the building and part of my crew were saying things with the hour closes it we make the round i wonder if you, put some gravel around it
2:38 pm
the structure doesn't afford very much sanitation but he look at that particular part of the park when you have to tear the place down where are the people going to be using the restroom i recommend you put if temporary units and opening up get someone to deal with the square recreation center that's been closed a lot of people need those area for their daily activities thank you. >> next speaker >> hi, i'm speaking that on boost of the chinatown development center. chinatown as two popular public
2:39 pm
boomers at the chinese hospital which is increase in door and public square is the other one it's - if you ask the residents which is one thing in chinatown that's best and the square bathroom also comes up and if i ask the residents most critical things in chinatown this comes up there's no option the neighborhood has so we're looking forward to this new design we have many meetings in the last few years it took more time people involved in the chinese rec center the design before you is not the first one
2:40 pm
it takes years to get where we are and the community we spend a lot of time in translation to the committee input moving forward the square life will continue to we're looking forward to working with the construction company and it will be the summer so we're looking forward to the chinese neuroin february of next year we want to open it with a new restroom and i want to say to you the commissioner low and staff all you it took many years to open the bathroom and a we love the
2:41 pm
areas all space parks in the selma we are absolutely thrilled with the new bathroom so thank you >> anyone else who wants make any public comment on that item? seeing none, public comment is closed. >> commissioner low. >> having participated in many community meetings and several commission hearings on this matter i was surprised how much immense public input there was on a public bathroom and recognize the heavy usage of this bathroom and the huge idealizing delays i wanted to commend the chinatown community center for their outreach and as well as the staff folks don and marvin vin and those for
2:42 pm
patients in dealing with the community he meetings so i'd like to move this matter for approval. >> i have one question before e a second in the recollection we have in front of us it is the resolution we award the contract to the chang c m construction for a maxillomillion 928 or m h construction. >> so at the end he said the recommendation was to chang c m construction. >> only only it was put in here at the time they didn't know which one. >> moved and seconded all in favor, say i. so moved. >> we're on the memoranda of
2:43 pm
understanding. >> i'll have to reduce myself our law firm hnltz that. >> is there a motion and a second to reduce commissioner low moved and seconded your reduced. >> recuses. >> good morning holly from the capital division the matter before i is the possible mou between rec and park and the mayor's office of public finance for the van ness property you're familiar with the property that is a site on the waffling adjacent to our islander and to
2:44 pm
brief i i'm sure you're aware of the proposal for the real estate diversifies to purchase that and hold it up for 24 months it will undergo community outreach at the last meeting i approved the resolution in support of the acquisition and the future use of the fund and the board of supervisors passed the proposed acquisition onto the full board and made the approval contingent on the memorandum of understanding so, so the full board will vote on tuesday the 22nd. so rec and park staff has worked with the director of real estate to prepare a memorandum of understanding that governors the purchasing and maintenance of the property as well as real estate services to assist us
2:45 pm
what with potential third party sale of the property just a brief term of memorandum of understanding the office of of his opinion will use commercial paper to finance the purchase and they'll have maintenance standards. any physical changes to the site during the real estate division hold it will require the content of the department and during the time it is in real estate jurisdiction rec and park staff will work to establish the potential for the alternative uses and potential third party sale of the site for a portion of the seven hundred that's owned by build inc. the stechtd
2:46 pm
cost of all adjustment that may not be associated with the third party sale that's the cost of the real estate dwefs is 895 thousand dollars and those costs can be paid for by the open acquisition fund. the memorandum of understanding further states more than two years schedule for august 1st our pd will repay the 95 thousand and 2 percent interest this totals one million plus minus the acquisition fund and that jurisdiction transferred to rec and park upon payment and that's it if you have any questions, i'll be happy to answer them
2:47 pm
>> thank you. >> any public comment on that item? seeing none, public comment is clos closed. >> commissioners entertain a motion. moved and seconded all in favor, say i. so moved >> thank you very much it's a big day. >> give me one moment. this is the same as recuseed. involvements >> welcome back so -
2:48 pm
>> okay. so we're on item 13 general public comment continued if you spoke on item you can't speak doesn't but if you if you can i have 3 cards - 4 cards i'm going to go ahead and read off the names (calling names) thank you. as a reminder you'll each have to minutes (calling names) okay come on up
2:49 pm
>> good morning, everyone. >> that good morning. >> good afternoon. i'm a community organizer and i'm here to speak on behalf of the western edition technology center i've been working with for the past few months now and i know there has been comments earlier but wanted to raise my own concern and support for the center i've cabin working with concerned community workers that continue to build support for the center to kind of give a brief history of how that space came into being that was established by a lot of organizations including the
2:50 pm
presbyterian church and luther ran church we went through a process in which we identified technology as something that was in need for access with folks in that community so through that test we able able to establish that stacey space and now having an mou its important we be able to maintain that space so for funding it's a huge concern for the people that are utilizing the center we want to understand the plans for the park and understand where the information it available and also, we look forward it work with rec and park to understand that process
2:51 pm
and make sure the community is included in that space. thank you for listening he wish you all a great day >> thank you. >> next speaker >> hi, i'm a resident in the portal district i'm in support of keeping glen eagles open it has two fairways, you know, clean greens and sclaer car path you see the tree limbs are falling down and the infrastructure needs no be replaced. i don't know. i've made a phone call inform rec and park a few times whether or not they're trying to taxiing take it away from the lease holder the
2:52 pm
repurposing of the call would be a crime it's a great golf course and made similar to another golf course that should be as singular space and take advantage of making it similar to the harding golf course >> thank you. thank you >> next speaker. >> good morning, commissioners and uncle phil. >> we've talked about glen eagles as a reservation area i want to emphasize that the current manager has welcomed the community to use hits facility last year, we held a ma clarion park meeting and this last sunday he opened up the park to
2:53 pm
have a fundraiser and he reached out to the community be so he's not only in it for the money as they say in rhine a golf course he's there to become a part of the community and support many of the groups in the ma cleaner work area if i taking into consideration weather difficulties can be resolved and have more activity at ma cleaner park. >> thank you. >> >> thank you. next speaker, please. >> hi, i'm chris i'm here to support glen eagles i'm a public school teacher in the city it's
2:54 pm
great glen eagles offers a on an affordable program and it's important inform the seniors the second thing i want to echo things about the community of players there it's diverse both men and women and both the people insides the city and out it's really something unique like i would i play a lot in the summer it should be preserved and lastly i want to speak to the community involvement. i teach at the international academy city hall's under bayview and hunters point they were open to supporting the
2:55 pm
people around glen eagles. >> >> next speaker. >> hello, i'm tony i'm here to speak on the issue regarding glen eagles just to express many of you have played that there's unique and has all the topographic and the great people i've made great friends and consider it a tradition to play golf but the current ownership is very, very hands on i've played at all the courses that the city has golden gate park and lincoln and harding their lovely as well but the one difference i've been a member of the golf eagles club their hands on asking how to improve the
2:56 pm
experience and play and offering us the chance to get involved to improving our own golf course so i'm here to encourage the commission to support the current group to maintain the high quality golf experience so we don't have to feel like we are joining a country club obviously playing golf as a part of the disposal income it's great it have a playing place to go to where people want to make our next experience better and they know who you're sons are you like that that's mire point i want to make. >> nancy. >> hi, i'm nancy i'm an 11
2:57 pm
year resident of the lower fillmore in the arms that is a section 8 senior building maintained by the african-american chapter of the daughters of the eastern star. i feel it's terribly important to continue this the western edition technology center as everyone knows san francisco other speakers have mentioned everything is changing the skyline and the lower fillmore is changing i have the tourist bus that can't go in front of the painted lady and the st. john church we have one of the top restaurant in the country it's changing but two things are not changing there are a lot of
2:58 pm
housing for low income seniors and low income people in general. especially for the youth it is still gang territory that's not going to change the center is an oasis it truly is the sun is also shining and the park across the street it's giving youth that have a harder time getting a foot in the door which things thought western edition is providing them a foot in the door so to not support it seems like unthinkable i'm here to strongly advocate that that be continued and supported more. >> thank you. >> is there anyone else that want to make general public comment those are all the cards
2:59 pm
i have we're now closed in general public comment and will be going to item 14 which is closed session. anyone who wants to make public comment on closed session? seeing none, public comment is closed commissioners we need a motion and second to go into closed session >> oh, sorry commissioner harrison and i'd like to - >> i want to comment on the glen eagles i worked with tom he's doing an excellent job and a resolution to this i hope i feel this is an important gem out there folks put a lot into
3:00 pm
that and tom and hopefully, a mutual mutual mutually agreeable manner. >> thank you commissioner bonilla. >> i would like to ditto commissioner harrisons remarks i don't want to reinvent the wheel especially, since we've leefrnd how popular this course is and and strong the community support so i want to do everything in our power to keep this golf course open. >> thank you, commissioners seeing no other comments we can go into closed