have it legalized and take the dr and demolish the entire structure i can't give them that. >> take dr and deny. >> take dr. >> commissioner president wu kate from the city attorney's office there are a couple of options here i'm going to try to lay out and planning staff may have something to offer the commission can't take dr and approve the project or not take dr and approve that the commission couldn't force the owner or the trustee to affirmatively apply for another permit to legalize the unit what will happen is the building

permit is ultimately appeal able to the board of appeals there's not an you outstanding notice of violation on the project that this owner has come in voluntarily to try to legalize or try to get rid of the illegal unit but this commission does have the ability in disapproving the permit under section 207.3 so and as you noted this commission doesn't have authority over what happens to the tenant that is a separate matter for the rent board to you to continue it and take dr and disapprove or approve with conditions of some sort. >> can we approve the entire

structure. >> no. we're moving an illegal unit be let's get rid of it we can't do that. >> you're being subconscious. >> i recommend we take dr and not approve it. >> commissioner johnson. >> thank you very much there's lots of again to clarify the issues i definitely agree with not approving the building permit we can't force the legalize we can't force them to sell it i want to focus why i'm going to support denying the project first of all, itself think it's absurd the project sponsors has brought up things that has nothing to do with to do with the tenant where

they're a litigious or the person who owned the property was two nice that has nothing to do with why we're here i understand that the trustee needs to sell the building as part of you know his obligations to get vail and thees state it is not necessarily our purview to help you maximize that value you have the property as it exists sell it to someone that will definitely buy it and leave it that's not within our purview when we look at the building permit as a project we don't care i'm sure you'll be able to sell to somebody look at the

building paratransit there are no outstanding violations on the existing unit it's been there for decades it sounds like it's been elevated as two separate unions one legal and not not for that reason i don't see a particular reason to support the demolishing of a non-conforming structure turn it into a residential unit not a conforming structure with noted outstanding structures again, i totally understand the trustees position the hearings are in upper your schard that this obligation but not our job to get involved as a trustee and not get involved if any sort of

rent board or tenant lymph gland. >> commissioner antonini. >> i'm concerned the dr requester didn't show up which is kind of odd i'll favor a continuance because i be i'd like to at least see if we can get the dr requester to come here and perhaps the project sponsors could try to work further with the dr requester to see if there's a way to resolve her retainedcy situation and see if we want to leave the kitchen in it or not and it becomes a simpler thing i'll make a motion i'll see if i get a second.

>> i wasn't aware it was continued i'm going to probably support the motion the dr requester didn't come and i wonder how mafltd she is. >> let me just comment so this is an unusual one i'm sympathetic you're trying to live out the wishes but the dr requester is not here we have no idea of their complaint and maybe a legitimate reason they're not here so i'll support a continuance i understand that commissioner richards position on this i like our energy on it i'd rather take that energy and fight when a bigger issue and

maybe a project will come up i'm a little bit torn there is so many unusual pieces i'm not sure we have make a full judgment so in localizing that that i'll support of the continuance. >> second. >> second. >> in regards to my continuance i'd like to see what presentation she had from the previous owner was she begin i want you to answer because you didn't before i want to know was she told it was an illegal unit or her situation that has a lot of bearing how i'll vote was she told this was illegal and they were letting her stay there perhaps i don't feel so strong about protecting her presence there that's the motion to continue i think we have a month

but - anyway you'll want a date and i'm sorry for me i don't believe i'll support a continuance it doesn't change the physical land use question about commissioner johnson said we think that one illegal unit should be removed or not removed did 0 dr requester may have contacts. >> commissioner richards. >> did the tenants residency would the dr still be in effective if she moves. >> i'll support a continuance. >> commissioners, we have a motion and a second to continue 24 for one month to december 4th. >> commissioner antonini commissioner hillis commissioner johnson

no commissioner richards no commissioner fong no arrest commissioner president wu. >> that fails there is, however, a motion to take dr and disapprove the building permit application on that motion because there wasn't an action memo with finding for disapproval the city attorney strongly recommends we reiterate those findings so if commissioner johnson could you reiterate the reason why you want to take dr that will assist me in creating finding. >> sure i am supporting taking dr and

disapproving the building permit because the illegal dwelling has no what do you call actions items gentiles it notice of violation against it it does constitute a third dwelling illegal to it might be i see no reason to discontinue it i don't believe it impacts the ability of the trustee to sell the property or make any other land use decisions at this time. >> yes. i believe i was able to grasp what commissioner richards in the case of preserving affordable housing and if any other commissioners want to add a findings of their own. >> i believe it is the mayors

derivative to preserve units. >> ma'am, city attorney is that good? all right. so bear with me just a moment so i can - and so on the motion then to take dr and disapprove the building predicament application it preserves the affordable housing and the illegal unit is without a complaint and violation the illegal unit does not prohibit the trust to sell the building it is kept with the mayors divisive >> so sell the property or take

any other land use decisions if you want to do that. >> so noted. >> i never know. >> on that motion commissioner antonini commissioner hillis commissioner johnson commissioner richards commissioner fong no commissioner president wu so moved, commissioners, that motion passes that planning commission motion passes 5 to one with commissioner fong voting against expirations that places you on general public comment i have no speaker cards is there any general public comment? >> you may. >> when we were planning after all there were 8 houses we live in two house near the area all the houses are the same it has a

living room and diagram not a bedroom and the reason i know hal la i handled her real estate and she's had the back unit where it says all utilities will be paid by her, she knew you it was adjacent to her unit before all of this started we actually called liz to the planning department i have a voice recording that told us what to do we went into down to the planning department they said we need the report fixed the inspector looked at the property and investigated if better than to get the building cards from 891 to 1950 it states

it's an adjunct space the tenant was aware when we approached her in january and told her hal lazy wishes we'll oh, her relocation fees he her response it's expensive to move that's not going to be enough when you our talking about a tenant that be take advantage of a very kind woman who gave her housing i know you're talking about someone that housing i believe that holding it up and not letting it sell for a higher value i don't know what the people are going to do i know this is stressful on us where the city directed us to do that

and the staff gave us a advise was all directed and in the notes there were give it to you this tenants makes well over $80,000 that wants to get money from a dead woman is wrong having to allow her to continue to live there and take up that space and not go through the process that everybody else is gone through to make halos wishes it really, really wrong i'm a native which the san francisco when you talk about diversity i don't know how other than the native-american and other people that understand this she is adamant to get money from a dead woman it's wrong

thank you for listening to me. >> thank you yes. >> i urge you in the spirit of our decision but it is not what i intended this is the property is going to displace her and all we're going to do is transferring the zoning and selling it at a lower price by reducing the value of the property your reducing the tax basis of city that's pga our salary you're only displacing - i said in the spirit of keeping affordable housing that's really not what is going to happen because the structure of the property and whoever buys this is going to displace her

anyways, the person that should get the value is thees state of hoa la and thank you. >> okay additional. seeing none, public comment is closed meeting adjourned.

>> it only takes a tiny this great big world to find a place that you love my home upon the hill i find i love you still i been away but now i'm back to tell i san francisco open your public gates you turn no strarn away outside your door san francisco here that the wandering one planned to wander no more had a place only makes me love

you best with the heart of golden west san francisco welcome me home again, i'm coming home to go wondering no more san francisco open our golden gate a you're not thank you for the opportunity a stranger away outside our to door san francisco heres our wandering one planned inform wonder no more only places only make me love you best tell me you're the heart of golden west san francisco welcome me home again i'm coming home to go rome no more ♪ ♪ ♪

♪ ♪ in rome no more. >> (clapping.) ♪ ♪ ♪ ♪ ♪ (clapping.) thank you beach blanket babylonian and big city i'm michael perishing the board of the directors on the sthoilg

foundation on behalf of the board i'd like to welcome you to the grand opening of the new st. anthony's dining room before i start, i want to remind everything this is a non-smoking event st. anthony's has been in san francisco for 64 years it bodies the openness and generosity of the city of san francisco without the generosity st. anthony's 0 would not have been able to serve 40 years and without the generosity of our community we'll not be serving meals on this corner in a place that was what converted automobile shop we provided the critical will basic services to many, many people i'd like to make i'd like to

thank even that made the day possible our volunteers (clapping.) many, many volunteers our employees (clapping) >> yeah. >> (clapping) >> our donors thank you, very much. our sponsored there's a list of them right here in particular i'd like to say to thank our lead sponsor making kevin corporation thank you very much (clapping) i have the great how shall of welcoming the board of trust father john harden fathered john many of you know is form director of st. anthony's she was the one that get the ball

rowell open little new dining rumor in 2004 to raise the money when they said it was going to be define father john took the leap of faith and sunshine said full speed ahead god will provide and good idea has provided father john, please came forward and offer our blessing to our folks this morning. >> who's taking bets how long it's going to take before i start crying. (laughter) grass us he loving god we also give you thanks for the guest gift of life especially on this day for st. anthony's our model

and guide bless all here present and those unable to be with us who have transcribed of their time, their latent and the treasure to the creation of this new dining room and norman in order to condition the miracle of jones street as we follow our instruction to feed the hungry give clothing to the naked, constantly remind us that all that enter here are our brothers and sisters and also to be treated with dignity and respect grateful for 64 years of service we ask that you send down upon this new building our spirit to make it a place of living stones it came passion

marked by the love of father alfred and father floyd and many other friers who have walked with those in need (clapping) amen >> amen. >> thank you father john that player and all you do to bring us to this day thank you (clapping.) i would like to bring to the pronounced berry stinger our executive director as executive director berry had the task of completed the characteristic campaign he did extremely well, we're thankful for that but we're very, very lucky to have him as executive director his

knowledge and wisdom his kindness are a benefit to our entire community with that, i'd like to welcome berry to the stage (clapping.) good morning and welcome to all of you for being here on this great day seems like my responsibility to get you ready to enter the new dining i'm going to be practical all you take our hands and put our fingers on and temples and look at it a little bit and go oh. >> oh. >> okay look this way and go avenue so are you ready my work is done here no, today st. anthony's foundation is taking a bold step into the future today, we're

opening the doors to so much more we're opening the doors to more meals, more help for those in need, and more hope and that hope that hope is not a gownless hope no navigate we've been standing solidly on this granddaughter u ground for 64 years of history see 64 years ago today, the old dining room was dedicated at had very to the navigate the line of hungry people queuing up along golden gate has been going on for more than one hundred years the earthquake the friers have remained true to is it fair to say the patron of the city those friers os in they're poor they're on brothers and sisters and remained true to all of you

who are struggling true to you who a share this journey towards the community for which we've all been create it, it's vision this xrirtd alfred back in 189 informative 50 people would have a dining tables in which to share the meal we were hoping today that one of the friers in a rest home no oakland brother anthony that helped to district food we hear that said to father alfred the old garage we could make into the dierpg you want so badly he helped him back o make the

sandwiches and acquire that building brother anthony and all the freezer they knew nothing they were called to fill more than empty stomachs he e they knew nothing we should be creating created a community to catch a glistens of ourselves as brothers and sisters radiated if god's image today, i'm remind of a couple of things that father alfred and i hope the press is linking he'd get very upset when a number person said this was a soup kitchen he said this is not a soup kitchen but a dining (clapping) when you enter that when you

enter the building today, you'll know exactly what was he was talking about look at the ceiling and the bringing chairs and the natural light coming into the windows this is not a couple u soup kitchen but a dining room you'll enter that dining room and realize that is a beautiful place that was built for you you'll see the supervisor tang new kitchen i realize you diver more than the scraps from spokesman tables when someone services serves you or fry on a brand new set of clothing i hope you realize your better than what living on the streets sometimes makes