this owner has come in voluntarily to try to legalize or try to get rid of the illegal unit but this commission does have the ability in disapproving the permit under section 207.3 so and as you noted this commission doesn't have authority over what happens to the tenant that is a separate matter for the rent board to you to continue it and take dr and disapprove or approve with conditions of some sort. >> can we approve the entire structure. >> no. we're moving an illegal unit be let's get rid of it we can't do that. >> you're being subconscious.

>> i recommend we take dr and not approve it. >> commissioner johnson. >> thank you very much there's lots of again to clarify the issues i definitely agree with not approving the building permit we can't force the legalize we can't force them to sell it i want to focus why i'm going to support denying the project first of all, itself think it's absurd the project sponsors has brought up things that has nothing to do with to do with the tenant where they're a litigious or the person who owned the property was two nice that has nothing to

do with why we're here i understand that the trustee needs to sell the building as part of you know his obligations to get vail and thees state it is not necessarily our purview to help you maximize that value you have the property as it exists sell it to someone that will definitely buy it and leave it that's not within our purview when we look at the building permit as a project we don't care i'm sure you'll be able to sell to somebody look at the building paratransit there are no outstanding violations on the existing unit it's been there for decades it sounds like it's

been elevated as two separate unions one legal and not not for that reason i don't see a particular reason to support the demolishing of a non-conforming structure turn it into a residential unit not a conforming structure with noted outstanding structures again, i totally understand the trustees position the hearings are in upper your schard that this obligation but not our job to get involved as a trustee and not get involved if any sort of rent board or tenant lymph

gland. >> commissioner antonini. >> i'm concerned the dr requester didn't show up which is kind of odd i'll favor a continuance because i be i'd like to at least see if we can get the dr requester to come here and perhaps the project sponsors could try to work further with the dr requester to see if there's a way to resolve her retainedcy situation and see if we want to leave the kitchen in it or not and it becomes a simpler thing i'll make a motion i'll see if i get a second. >> i wasn't aware it was continued i'm going to probably support the motion the dr

requester didn't come and i wonder how mafltd she is. >> let me just comment so this is an unusual one i'm sympathetic you're trying to live out the wishes but the dr requester is not here we have no idea of their complaint and maybe a legitimate reason they're not here so i'll support a continuance i understand that commissioner richards position on this i like our energy on it i'd rather take that energy and fight when a bigger issue and maybe a project will come up i'm a little bit torn there is so many unusual pieces i'm not sure we have make a full judgment so

in localizing that that i'll support of the continuance. >> second. >> second. >> in regards to my continuance i'd like to see what presentation she had from the previous owner was she begin i want you to answer because you didn't before i want to know was she told it was an illegal unit or her situation that has a lot of bearing how i'll vote was she told this was illegal and they were letting her stay there perhaps i don't feel so strong about protecting her presence there that's the motion to continue i think we have a month but - anyway you'll want a date and i'm sorry for me i don't believe i'll

support a continuance it doesn't change the physical land use question about commissioner johnson said we think that one illegal unit should be removed or not removed did 0 dr requester may have contacts. >> commissioner richards. >> did the tenants residency would the dr still be in effective if she moves. >> i'll support a continuance. >> commissioners, we have a motion and a second to continue 24 for one month to december 4th. >> commissioner antonini commissioner hillis commissioner johnson no commissioner richards no commissioner fong

no arrest commissioner president wu. >> that fails there is, however, a motion to take dr and disapprove the building permit application on that motion because there wasn't an action memo with finding for disapproval the city attorney strongly recommends we reiterate those findings so if commissioner johnson could you reiterate the reason why you want to take dr that will assist me in creating finding. >> sure i am supporting taking dr and disapproving the building permit because the illegal dwelling has no what do you call actions

items gentiles it notice of violation against it it does constitute a third dwelling illegal to it might be i see no reason to discontinue it i don't believe it impacts the ability of the trustee to sell the property or make any other land use decisions at this time. >> yes. i believe i was able to grasp what commissioner richards in the case of preserving affordable housing and if any other commissioners want to add a findings of their own. >> i believe it is the mayors derivative to preserve units. >> ma'am, city attorney is that

good? all right. so bear with me just a moment so i can - and so on the motion then to take dr and disapprove the building predicament application it preserves the affordable housing and the illegal unit is without a complaint and violation the illegal unit does not prohibit the trust to sell the building it is kept with the mayors divisive >> so sell the property or take any other land use decisions if you want to do that. >> so noted.

>> i never know. >> on that motion commissioner antonini commissioner hillis commissioner johnson commissioner richards commissioner fong no commissioner president wu so moved, commissioners, that motion passes that planning commission motion passes 5 to one with commissioner fong voting against expirations that places you on general public comment i have no speaker cards is there any general public comment? >> you may. >> when we were planning after all there were 8 houses we live in two house near the area all the houses are the same it has a living room and diagram not a bedroom and the reason i know hal la i handled her real estate

and she's had the back unit where it says all utilities will be paid by her, she knew you it was adjacent to her unit before all of this started we actually called liz to the planning department i have a voice recording that told us what to do we went into down to the planning department they said we need the report fixed the inspector looked at the property and investigated if better than to get the building cards from 891 to 1950 it states it's an adjunct space the tenant was aware when we approached her

in january and told her hal lazy wishes we'll oh, her relocation fees he her response it's expensive to move that's not going to be enough when you our talking about a tenant that be take advantage of a very kind woman who gave her housing i know you're talking about someone that housing i believe that holding it up and not letting it sell for a higher value i don't know what the people are going to do i know this is stressful on us where the city directed us to do that and the staff gave us a advise was all directed and in the

notes there were give it to you this tenants makes well over $80,000 that wants to get money from a dead woman is wrong having to allow her to continue to live there and take up that space and not go through the process that everybody else is gone through to make halos wishes it really, really wrong i'm a native which the san francisco when you talk about diversity i don't know how other than the native-american and other people that understand this she is adamant to get money from a dead woman it's wrong thank you for listening to me. >> thank you yes. >> i urge you in the spirit of

our decision but it is not what i intended this is the property is going to displace her and all we're going to do is transferring the zoning and selling it at a lower price by reducing the value of the property your reducing the tax basis of city that's pga our salary you're only displacing - i said in the spirit of keeping affordable housing that's really not what is going to happen because the structure of the property and whoever buys this is going to displace her anyways, the person that should get the value is thees state of

hoa la and thank you. >> okay additional. seeing none, public comment is closed meeting adjourned >> superintendent carranza has an announcement oh, excuse me. does anyone need translation in the room i don't think there was a call for translation anyone needing chinese seeing none, be superintendent the gay street

alliances in item d is withdrawn that will be presented in a future meeting at the board of education. >> this is approval of november 14th may have is motion and second any corrections reenforcement please mass can say could. >> mr. chin mr. haney ms. maufas menus dr. murase ms. norton thank you ms. wynns and president fewer that's 6 i's thank you. this is the superintendents report be straightjacket. >> thank you good afternoon to everyone and go giants. >> wow. and we know that being a team is changing and the status show it 75 percent of the teenagers say they've used drugs to deal with pressure at school,

however, step forward is promoting healthy lifestyles you can count the ways during an open house at the wellness center the wellness initiate was held by the wellness staff and student volunteers to explain the services as with the subject of the examiner the san francisco wellness be initiate is dedicated to help the academic successful are our 16 thousand public ask the at 19 canvases sfusd students recorded they've been reducing their alcohol use and it's no consequence that an overwhelming majority says someone cares about them so congratulation to our wellness center and staff for the good job on the students as you know this friday is halloween one of our he

elementary school is clb in granted style the teenage mutant turtles will be out at sherman elementary school hundreds of students will trestlework treat and will be celebrating looking like area the fact the school has reached it's fund railings for the year we want to wish our families a safe and orderly halloween this year i'm sad to report we've all been informed the city of san francisco recently experiences two great losses in the passing of telling ted emphatically son and the closing of the san francisco bay garden. >> he was a progressive speaker and served as the director it's our condolences that the board of education and he myself as

the 13ru7b9 our condolences to his family and friends a major loss to the contingent the memorial services for him will be at mission school in our auditorium only sunday november 16th from 2:00 to 4:00 p.m. linked at 18th street and easy access to public transportation and it has limited street parking i mention the city lost a great institution that the san francisco bay garden has closed down with the staff after 40 years we thank the bay garden for the service in gufsz another voice for the people (clapping) on thursday, november 6th is the fourth annual 4r6b9 dinner fall into pride so the theme for the sf c s did welcome the 4r67b9

families the dinner is at ldda atkins middle school we want to thank the principle for offering his school once again and all the board of education commissioners all that have been attending all are welcome and can make their revisions by going to wwwdot fall into pride dot event bright.org or call eric mar is 2422 615 posters will be distributed to all ask the the first is lvntd district wide and the third will focus on bullying preservation welcome to the meeting and guarantee go giants. >> thank you superintendent item c recommendations of

awards. >> we have several recognizes for our dedicated staff the first, i'd like to call on the doctor to present the distinguished ward to our john burke (clapping.) good evening, everyone it is a big honor and uppermost pleasure to be giving this award to john burke i can't that have a more deserving candidate being in the assessment department i think it is only fair i back up with this data the person most mentioned in the satisfaction by the administrators was john burke some of the remarks high marks to john burke very responsible active we love john burke he

rocks john burke you are always assessable and john is also grateful operator with many departments signatures c and i and public relations john is a rescue ship in a sea of data. (laughter) we frequently ask john for help to make sense of the results and he's responsive and tremendously supportive in our shed work of communications john within the department john is also up for a challenge his can do spirit is infectious he lives up to our school first if a principle or school calls he's got that as a priority he is significant in problem solving

we appreciate his creativity and sense of humor i have worked closely with john for more than a decade and have been impressed with his 13wrig9 and hard work and commitment to the schools he's on outstanding leader completely committed to equality in a positive manner john has a an encouraging manner and skilled we had a great time of translation and growth in the assessment as we prepare for challenges and opportunity of the new computer based smarter assessment i know that john is the right person to navigate our ship through the sea of data let's here it a round of applause for john

(clapping) >> congratulations. >> thank you. >> i don't know if i can say much after that thank you very much and really i can't accept this for myself it really is the whole office thank you very much (clapping). >> thank you congratulations. >> president fewer we have this

evening a special service award to christen and here to present it is principle andrew. >> i don't see him is christen here hi christine well, chris teen do you want to come on up this award is presented to christina special education teacher the nomination spoke of her unwavering teaching and access to the pe requirements and a supportive environment upper donated by our peers would you

mind meeting us at the lectern we'll present you with your certifica certificate. >> just wanted to say thank you for the recognition i appreciate it. >> (clapping) >> thank you. >> and we have one more award

this is recognition of inclusive schools week. >> i think i need a motion and second to introduce this. >> 70. >> thank you very much i think we need dr. b.a. long could to read this. >> dr. elizabeth please come forward to read into the record the schools week. >> ms. blanking can please sit here please. >> good evening and we do have our community advisory committee here this evening they're

responsible for the celebration forward to the board of education mrs. webb and deborah our chairs and many of the people in the district are working towards the resolution so thank you for approving that this evening whereas the inclusive schools network schools around the word have dedicated the week as school week with the inclusive education one community and whereas the santa fe san francisco unified school district is commit to providing an education for schools and classrooms that are welcoming and capable of educating outline children and whereas the educators of san francisco recognition that each child is unique and learns delve and worked better in the teaching is stlald to their interests whereas the families of sfusd

have been working to insure your classrooms are inclusive and high professionalism whereas by their efforts to make our schools and classrooms inclusive the educators and families of step forward have contributed significantly to building stronger and more inclusive community and whereas educators and teachers deserve to celebrate and might further improve so we're asking you for the resolution thereby be it resolved by the board of education and the district join with the network and the societies schools and district and community around the world in declaring the week of december 3rd, there 5 and engages the classrooms to sponsor appropriate learning and activities buildings in his