ago, joining supervisor avalos in the [inaudible] protests and being part of asians for black lives as a solitary and i like. i feel that resolutions like this, that are symbolic are important but our actions that we do in personal lives our political lives and building organizations and those movements is even more important. want to really appreciate supervisor's come in and read for sharing so much of themselves and giving input into this. i was a big part of this process from the beginning and i know that is a process that we all have to go forward in the future. it's an awkward decision because i'm hearing from growing movements and learn every day by being active in them we are to follow the lead of young people with her was on saturday with the

millions much more with other actions or follow read of african-americans but i'm still going to be supportive of the original motion supervisor autos has brought in a really appreciate the comments and the insights and the wisdom that have spoken from the community. ideal following the lead of african-americans is really really important to me but i do feel that supervisor comments suggestions have logic behind them, my political sense is it's watering down and it's taking away the real heart of the alex -- movement and how san francisco is connected. so, we are making connections with other types of violence and other issues. i feel like the avalos resolution is really focused on institutionalized racism within the justice system and the police system

and it's about a full systems change and cultural change. there are other issues out there also but i think that's the focus. so all be supportive of the supervisors avalos's original motion with appreciation for the amendments but i'll still be supportive. i think supervisors kim's suggestion to compromise by still mentioning alex -- is a good one and i be supportive of that if the original motion doesn't go forward in supervisor:'s moments are successful. to me the most important things are the result as others have said and putting this on record in support of the ferguson action. the ferguson action movement statements and the structural changes that are proposed in them to me are the most important things. i know that the heart that went into the drafting of this from germany and pollock two supervisor although wilson's office, and the community efforts to get the language the strong as possible is something him and

said supportive >> supervisor autos >> thing. i like to start moving on voting for amendments and probably will have some process questions. i have an amendment as a whole. i believe that supervisor: amendments are religious amendment of the hole that i have here today. so, i believe that this amendment as a whole is actually more complete document than the work in progress that submitted last week. so i would propose that we accept this amendment as a whole and we have a vote on the [inaudible] that are being proposed by supervisor:. i am willing to go forward if we cannot approve the amendments, if we do not approve the minutes that supervisor: is accepting, that we move forward that we don't pass this ordinance but we have on the

books the ordinance that i submitted today that i think is a much broader than the one that i submitted last week it was just a work in progress. that's my proposal. is that we accept the amendment as a whole. and then we have a vote on the amendment that are being offered by supervisor: and then we vote on the underlined ordinance. i do believe we need to pass this ordinance we would need, you both mdm. clerk >> this item is on second appearance. it would require a goes to weave the reference to committee and its expose on the item itself. >> so at this time i think that supervisor autos stated we can take the amendments that been offered in the order they have been received. so, mdm. clerk let's call well on the mimicked the whole offered by supervisor autos >> the messrs. further discussion >> point of information supervisor autos has made a motion to amend. [inaudible] motion to motion to extend the

motion which might be unanimous and then we would proceed on whether to adopt that amendment. >> there to amendments as a whole ending before sereno so there's one set by supervisor autos and one by supervisor:. then we will proceed to the underlying item divorce. item 52. >> this is a six vote threshold. >> all be supporting just amending it so we can consider that amended. >> that is correct the motions were taken right now have to do with just the moment as all permits submitted by the two supervisors. any other further questions, seeing none mdm. clerk >> supervisor autos the moment bearing a new title supervisor winner aye supervisor autos aye supervisor breed aye supervisor

campos aye supervisor: aye supervisor federal aye supervisor kim aye supervisor mark aye supervisor chang aye there are nine aye >> that amendment has been adopted. now, we have the second amendment does offer by supervisor:. so this amendment might be amendment of the holder supervisor: submitted actually is overlaid on top of the minutes that have not been adopted just out by the board. so mdm. clerk if you could take a local boat on the mimicked offered by supervisor: >> supervisor winner aye supervisor avalos no supervisor breed aye supervisor campos aye noto supervisor: aye supervisor federal aye supervisor kim know supervisor mark note supervisor

chang aye there are five aye and for nose >> seen as this amendment it needed six those to be adopted this amendment fails. now colleagues, before us is the underlying item 52,, and first other to call supervisor breed >> personal i like to duplicate the file and secondly i will not be supporting the resolution today. thank you >> supervisor breed has made a singular motion to duplicate the file. i just like to clarify that wanted duplicated file which would you like to see good one is contained supervisor autos is amendments >> for clarity, it would be based on the recently amended item that supervisor avalos has submitted to the board that we approved >> thank you. supervisor:

>> i was seconding the duplication >> thank you very much. so now mdm. clerk if we can vote on one of the files in >> after we vote on this matter president then will tend to the duplicate items >> yes >> does the duplicated file require about >> no it does not >> on item 52 as amended supervisor winner note supervisor avalos >> this is the underlined ordinance >> aye >> supervisor breed note supervisor compost aye supervisor:, note supervisor fell, note supervisor came, aye supervisor mark aye supervisor chang, no. there are four aye

and five no spirit >> this resolution is not adopted. now for the dupe. file. >> just for clarity i want to duplicate the file and send it to committee. >> all right. for the duplicated file mdm. clerk if we can take a roll call vote for sending this to committee. >> supervisor winner aye supervisor avalos, note supervisor breed, aye supervisor compost, note supervisor:, aye supervisor federal aye supervisor kim, no supervisor mark, note supervisor chang aye there are five aye and for nose. >> this just for

clarification, this motioned to send to committee required five votes because it is a parliamentary motion. it required majority vote of the members present here today so that motion to send committee passes. now mdm. clerk, if you could read in memoriam >> today's meeting will be adjourned in memory of the following beloved individuals. on behalf of supervisor: the late mr. lewis jesse armstrong senior. on behalf of supervisor jim for the late ms. liana [inaudible] on behalf of supervisor more for the late ms. laura joan by. mr. choi [inaudible] >> thank you. before we adjourn i just want to wish our colleague supervisor leo: a very happy birthday today and wish everyone a very happy holidays. mdm. clerk is there any further business >> that was our business for

today and the legislative session >> thank you. the meeting is now adjourned. thanks for watch happy holidays nona with the businesses worthy events and this week enjoy the happiest time of the year in our great city this is the weekly buzz this tuesday make union square b will unveil air tha 30th anniversary with windows featuring adaptively dogs the proceeds will help the spca find a new home head on over and then on saturday enjoy the free yoga

in golden gate park free melting into the ground and join the group ann at 11 for mediation for mind, body, and spirit on saturday night the city party with the telephone scope taco in the views and with the awe tronlz astronomies join the amateur and enjoy a short lurk and the sky is the limit and that's the weekly buzz for more information on those vents journalist us others sfgovtv an. >> call the meeting of the historic preservation commission to order good afternoon. welcome and welcome to the to the san francisco historic preservation commission regular meeting for

december 17, 2014, please be aware that the commission that the commission does not tolerate disruptions of any kind mr. lambert (laughter) president hasz commissioner wolfram commissioner hyland commissioner johnck commissioner johns commissioner matsuda commissioner pearlman first on our agenda commissioner it general public comment i have to, no speaker cards anyone wish to speak on tomes not on this agenda seeing none. >> director's report. >> commissioners tim frye department staff don't believe there's a director's report headings. >> seeing no questions move on. >> item 2 past events staff

reports and announcements. >> tim frye department staff just a couple of items make you aware of our advanced calendar and the memo in our packets regarding the departments budget will start discussions with you i believe in late january and then part of february on the next fiscal year budget so, please forward any comments or ideas in the meementd meantime to prepare for those hearings give you a he heads up on february 9th the national alliance will be hosting a commissioner training in san francisco at the ferry building this is something the department set up with the generous funding from the historic preservation commission and from the venue and the amount of funding we were able to open up to all

northern bay area commission so we hope to have a robust attendance and discussion about a variety of different commission matters and design review meaning policies and procedures and thank you for the hearing room it is a great hearing room where a view we'll give you more information on the training again on monday february 9th it will be an all day training you'll receive the safe your day will be going out in our e-mail next week that concludes my comments. >> seeing none, no questions or comments move on. >> commissioners that place you in commissioners matter presidents report and announcements. >> no reporting or

announcements. >> considerations of the draft minutes for the historic preservation commission december 3rd, 2014, hearing and the draft minutes for the hemorrhaging for december 3rd, 2014. >> commissioners any corrtions or alleges seeing none, any members of the public wish to add or correct my minutes. >> commissions. >> i have a question i was present for the cultural meeting and the minutes looked good but does the whole commission vote on those minutes or having is that the members that of committee that vote on those minutes? >> traditionally like ar c we'll all vote on it. >> yeah. >> so. >> i move to adapt the minutes. >> second.

>> thank you, commissioners on that motion commissioner hyland commissioner johnck commissioner johns commissioner matsuda commissioner pearlman commissioner wolfram and president hasz so moved, commissioners, that motion passes unanimously 7 to zero and places you on item 5 commissions comments and questions. >> i have one of the bat we're pushing the metro landmark theatre to get a do you believe but over and over or a park let out in front of the marquee trucks are backing both it so the castro theatre had the same issue any other disclosures or announcements or anything seeing none, we'll move on that is the historic preservation hearing schedule your consideration for adaptation you should have in our packet a draft or proposed

hearing schedule the only thing i'll note it is soon is january 7th you have no items on your advanced calendar. >> and are we likely to get items between now and january 7th. >> very unlikely. >> i ask we cancel that hearing. >> anything else we see on here? july one maybe later but we need to see what is coming so for now - do we take a motion on this >> we do move to adapt the hearing schedule what i was creating it i didn't notice it coinciding with a major holiday actually exception july 4th but that is several days prior to see. >> i see april 15th on here so.

>> not all of it (laughter). >> labor day. >> i move to sdaupt but the cancelation of the january 7th hearing. >> thank you thank you then on that motion to adapt the scheduled for 2015 canceling our first hearing on january 7th commissioner hyland commissioner johnck commissioner johns commissioner matsuda commissioner pearlman commissioner wolfram and president hasz so moved, commissioners, that passes unanimously 7 to zero and places you and places you under your regular calendar your continuance calendar item 7 at 3751 to 53, 20th street proposed to january 31st and item 8 for the case at 2168 market street

is proposed for continuance until march 4, 2015 we've received a continuance at 25 al at that street proposed for january 31st, 2015, my understanding the project sponsor has an request for an agreement on that date. >> commissioner pearlman. >> i have a question mr. fry about the swedish american got to far out. >> sure tim frye department staff we're meeting with the swedish society hopefully in january to go over the designation report society just wanted to thank you for the opportunity to meet you us face to face we have one meeting with the tenant just to give us more time to work with

the swedish society and have them understand when is requirement are under the landmark designation they had several corrections to the report they wanted to us address before this commission. >> no other comments or questions. >> any members of the public wish to speak. >> continuance on item 3. >> second. >> thank you. >> on that motion to continue 7, 8 and 9 marry commissioner hyland commissioner johnck pr commissioner johns commissioner matsuda commissioner pearlman commissioner wolfram and president hasz so moved, commissioners, that motion passes unanimously 7 to zero and places you an item 10 for case at 182 golf street the

landmark designation. >> good afternoon commissioner jonathan planning department preservation staff. >> as mentioned by the gentleman in the item before you the consideration to remedy the landmark designation from the golf street as the goldberg building commission heard the item on november 19th we passed a resolution since this hearing they've communicated to prepare the landmark report the report was revised to show the building

was eligible for the architecture expression through goldberg and the defining features were removed if the report and finally at the direction from commissioner matsuda is prepared list of owners and occupants to identify writers or musicians or another artists that live in the building as appendix a with the report. >> another important change to the designation report defining the features i included those changes in a cover memo just to brief recap far for the paneled ceilings we were added as well as the rear tile exits and the hip roof skylight that illuminates the store entire on golf street for the commercial

entry we added a paneled socket in the delay area and we opened the - the awning box above the store fronts and wood sashed windows and at least we specified the reasons with our goldberg building those changes were invading made to the character of the final features the ordinance had to be changed we did that with the st. unfortunately, the revised draft was not ready when the packet was print i believe the copy was e-mailed to you i have copies of the designation ordinance with me again, the only changes are the characters of the defined features i've discussed i want to add the department received

one e-mail from someone living in the neighborhood expressing their option and only from the haiflz association and the owner has state his preference the building not be landmarked should we choose to vote in favor the item be forwarded to the board of supervisors by the services development committee that concludes my presentation. i'm happy to answer any questions you may have. >> one quick question. >> commiserates. >> the letter in opposition was there a statement why they're opposed and they read in an article talking about the ellis act eviction associated with the building i can't speak for the person i think part of it they felt it was improper for a resident of the building to

propose landmark designation. >> thanks. >> seeing no other questions at this time we'll opening it up for public comment to members of the public any public comment on this item? >> hi thank you, again it's an exciting day we're well aware in no way does landmarking effect the affairs we've received a letter from the grandchildren copies for you i want to read a couple of exerts from it quickly this is from jeffrey glen eagle my father remembered visiting max as max took over the front

of the apartment after he married erma in 19236 he kept the drawing table in the corner of the living room that was where the light was best to work awhile visiting my father said he not only lives there but worked there and when he saw the photographs of the living room after seeing the photos he remembered one trip out west glen eagle that's jennifer's father he got a spanking i found that charmg i just want to thank you, again for your consideration of landmarking our building we've been proud to live there and as beverlyly so emotionally spoke of last night

when beverlyly glen eagle did her research that was the only building left standing that had anything to do with they are grandfather and we know he kept it to pass it on to his grandchildren and carved his name into the side of the building and i hope you vote yes to laboring this building. >> good afternoon i'll sneak into jackie's minutes we have lost another member of ruth gold beggars family we think it is very, very important another uncle i believe passed away we're happy to find ruth's grandson to collaborate this as has an been amazing process we feel good about preserving a piece of san francisco's history

whether or not we get to live there. >> seeing none, public comment is closed. >> back to you, commissioners. >> commissioners. >> i move to adapt this resolution and to move forward to the board. >> second. >> thank you. >> commissioners, if there's nothing further on that motion to adapt a recommendation. >> commissioner hyland commissioner johnck commissioner johns commissioner matsuda commissioner pearlman commissioner wolfram. >> president hasz so moved, commissioners, that motion passes unanimously 7 to zero and i have nothing for you for 2014. >> this meeting is adjourned (laughter) under 22 minutes.

>> yes. thanks for watching happy holidays nona with the businesses worthy events and this week enjoy the happiest time of the year in our great city this is the weekly buzz this tuesday make union square b will unveil air tha 30th anniversary with windows featuring adaptively dogs the proceeds will help the spca find a new home head on over and then on saturday enjoy the free yoga in golden gate park free melting into the ground and join the group ann at 11 for mediation for