f new appeals order of abatement case no. 67991235 b stanford street there was a request for continuance on this item and i believe the continuance was granted. >> so - if there's my parties that came for the item they can still speak in public comment any public comment on this item? could case 679 six the appellant and owner of record the revocable trust the attorney for

the appellant reuben, junius & rose action by appellant reverse the moratorium of the orders under the section of the san francisco building code. >> good morning john engine for the department the address for 411 marina building is a single-family dwelling and the slooegs solution for a kitchen on the ground floor director is here to meet 2013 which an order of abatement was issued no permits filed to deal with the abatement so the staff asks for the abatement order that concludes my report and is

the appellant here? good morning, commissioners john with reuben, junius & rose here on behalf of the project sponsor since we were last here we asked joe duffey to come out and talk about life safety issue there were no one we're moving forward decided to maintain our request from the board for a 10 year moratorium on enforcement of the order of abatement due to financial hardship that is the property owners mother that lives in the basement she's 0 no longer able to live diligently and can't afford to live it sth in 2, 3, 4 this neighborhood we looked at the abatement of the

unit while that's available this is a single-family home neighborhood the purpose to provide the accomodation for the elderly mother and the intent not to create a new unit to be rented this is the property owner home so it is not intending to skier to create a second unit that's why we maintain the request for the moratorium and we're here for any questions you may have >> questions for the commissioners? okay. seeing none thank you. >> does the department want a rebuttal. >> it's deservedly in your hands. >> thank you. >> question for the attorney this is we have to vote on this today; right? whether to grant the moratorium or consider it.

>> you could vote or decide to continue it and come back to the next meeting it's up to you. >> commissioner vice president melgar. >> so we ask thank you very much and i am ready to vote on this today, we considered it at the last meeting so i'll be for voting on it today. >> thank you commissioner walker. >> i have a question on the threshold for the moratorium as to financial hardship does it apply to the owner of building. >> the requester has to be the owner of the building and demonstrate the financial hardship. >> what do we require. >> it's a judgment call for

you. >> okay. thank you any other comments. >> so this situation commissioner walker trying to lead the point of view the hardship is this is the elderly motto facilitate her and for nomination in the house that's a hardship to me; right? >> i get it now just wanted to can i have another question. >> oh, commissioner walker so we consider the conditions right now but in the event that the person who's being accommodated the elderly relative if there's a passing of that person what prevents someone else from coming in to occupy this i mean, i think that

we need to look at the short term and long term in how we discuss that i think. >> the answer put a condition in the moratorium for the particular individual is no longer living to notify dbi that brings before you a recession of the moratorium for the date. >> okay. thank you. >> commissioner mar. >> so given the information i agree with commissioner vice president melgar i'm ready to move on it i make o a motion to uphold the moratorium for 10 years or if the current tenant is no longer living on the premises one or the other. >> i second the motion.

>> a couple of other decisions one to be month missouri no further modifications during the moratorium that's one you could add you might want to request a floor plan identifying the issues and not be expanded and changed and incorporate that going into the floor plan many say a tentative decision and you could require the applicant to seek documentation to seek no life safety issues and require the department to save what is needed in the documentation to be considered as well. >> okay. thank you commissioners mr. sweeney the inspection did a inspection and found no life safety done last

week. >> commissioner walker. >> can we amend this to reflect the suggestions of the attorney we require a floor plan and statement of conditions noting that it doesn't violate no health not safety issues that are imminent here and also require if the person there new months out they have to notify dbi of that. >> and to the further language stating no further notifications are allowed and i assume that's a motion. >> i think i have to start over i think. >> mia any further commissioner comments. >> seeing none, there's a motion and second for this to you uphold the order of

abatement and so someone wants to restate that motion? >> the motion was a uphold the order of abatement and grant the moratorium with the following considerations that at person occupied the moratorium is uphold until 10 years or the person motives out and no further notifications made during the abatement and documenting the condition and that the donation be submitted to the department confirming no code violations anybody take exception to that. >> okay. thank you. >> yeah. thank you, commissioners i think we're comfortable with the conditions i want to make two points in

terms of life safety and health issues we've had the inspection i wonder what the property owner will do if in fact, it's happened i feel we confirm that. >> the question for our attorney is it sufficient that the donation is sufficient. >> i think it is fine you should have that incorporated into the decision. >> do you have a record. >> just verbal but we can get a note. >> this dbi can provide that. >> and one other question upheld the order and the moratorium i'm hoping it didn't allow for the fees or finances to accrue during that period that's my only concern. >> does the moratorium automatically stop the fee role. >> i think you put it in one of

the provisions. >> fees to this point and not beyond. >> yeah. thank you. >> our decision. >> thank you, commissioner. >> is that okay sonya. >> any public comment on that item? seeing none, we'll do a roll call vote commissioner president clinch commissioner vice president melgar commissioner mccarthy commissioner mar commissioner lee commissioner mccray and commissioner walker the motion carries unanimously. >> okay. is there my general public comment for items not on the abatement appeals board agenda? seeing none, i have item h adjournment is there a motion to

adjourn >> so moved. >> second. >> all commissioners in favor. >> i. >> we're now adjourned it's 928 we'll recessed and come back as the building inspection at. >> hi, i'm frank jorge golden go up a utility supervisor for the distribution system i offer seizing see the personnel that install water maidens and water

carbon monoxides i've personal proud to work with city and distribution place whether a fire or main break those folks come on scene and get the job done 3450r7b9 what time they're here to take care of each other and make it so a safe and secure way i was encouraged to learn to deal with the services and breaks and i wanted to move into understanding how to do main connections one the great things that the sfpuc to move to different sections in if you're tdr in learning a different job you have the ability to move up i courage anyone to step out of their comfortable zone and work on a system as large as a our

water system we started from one end and keep on going it's a fascinating job and i'm going to stay here because i'll never learn everything to learn about this system 10:00 a.m. >> good morning today is february 18, 2015, this is the regular meeting of building inspection commission i'd like to remind everyone to please silence all electronic devices. the first item is roll call. >> commissioner president mccarthy commissioner vice president mar commissioner clinch commissioner lee commissioner mccray commissioner melgar commissioner walker we have quorum the next item is

president announcements. >> good morning, everyone and welcome to the meeting february 18, 2015, in advance if i miss prosperous any names beginning i dbi has been asked to participate in the high school internship program an 8 week program that high school students are mentored by dbi staff from june to august 7th and dbi has typically had 10 to 15 interim students that provide assistance to the staff and expect them to participate a thank you to chris with the plan review for his assistance in helping a person getting their permit so above and beyond the call of duty

congratulation to deputy city attorney ed sweeny and ron tom that got a thank you for setting up the short-term rental applications that's quite a job and controversial one we thank all our staff and director duffy and others participant in the the february 28th town hall meeting from 10:00 a.m. to noon held in a church on turk and third dbi and planning staff will provide the overview of the mission and responses to questions from the commissioners constituency director duffy as joined he mayor ed lee and the fire chief chief joanne hayes-white the day after the

deadly alarm happened and my outstanding code violations on the building and there had not been i stress not been since 2010 and made that clear dbi will look closely with the owner to stabilize the building and begin the repairs and restoration the inspector provided an outstanding service beyond the service many of the businesses effected by the fire retrooefg documents from the building and we'll hear from ben new censure out there for 10 and 12 hours left the building so thank you for your service beyond the call of duty and thank you to the engineers for they're excellent work on the

mission street fire as well as the fire scenes on stock street that occurred in the last week of january we had quite a bit of a busy week and 2014-2015 the annual report is now published and available on wwwsf dbi.org it is full of photos from the dbi staff at work and documents what a busy year dbi had to facilitate the exciting building projects underway in the city be sure to log on and once again we're asking the dbi staff and managers to nominate our quarter one january towards march employee of the quarter if you know of someone providing outstanding service please send our information to sfgov.org and

with the winner will be announced on april 15th building inspection commission meeting also obviously sonya is going to be taking time off we're commissioners in well good hands with erma who will be stepping in and thank you for coming out of retirement is it 6 weeks. >> yeah. >> and good luck with that and congratulate to the reappointment of commissioner clinch that was sworn in and that madam secretary concludes my announcements. >> my comments on the president's announcements now item 3 general public comment theic will take the comments on the items not on the

agenda. >> good morning, commissioners i'm sherryly with the clean air health 0 alliance and candle stick point stadium we live near the stadium we're the group that opposed the candle stick point stadium we want to talk about the violations that happen at candle stick point and the asbestos at the stadium we've met with lamar developers 3 times on june and february and when we took them on a toxic tour on february 11th we have tried to engage this developer in how to how to - assist us in monitoring the dust and the community and in need of the community we live 3 hundred feet from the stadium to do i not

date we tried to determine where the dust marshes were placed they provided us with a power point presentation but not able to locate the monitors we found two one on other side of the stadium on the north side and southeast side there's not a monitor one near the elementary school there're a childcare center monitor and the old monitor at alice griffith housing development but tomorrow they're planning on starting the excavation of the candle stick stadium so that will create the dust from this mechanic demolition which will cause even more dust we're asking we wrote

inspector laura letter to shut them down nail until they're in compliance and we've done our best to try and develop a good relationship with the developers they only show us power point presentations and referred us to the cac the advisors to get our answers so i'm asking you if you could intervention on our on behalf and the on behalf of the community to safeguard the children and contingent from the dust that will come out of this project once necessary start the stadium. >> i'm sorry can you tell me your name and group. >> i'm shirley moore the clean air health alliance i'm with the belview and in charge the candle

stick committee thank you. >> hello i'm julia with at clean air health alliance i live next to candle stick park and as shirley said we've stopped the inclusion and there's extremely high rates of religious picture rates the reason we don't want an implosion the work needs to be done we're not convinced as a community that lamar is doing the work and letting north not letting us in we've had a number of the violations and after the conference we'll bring those to education they're not working there are dust piles u.s. bancorp covered for weeks i look

out my window they've done nothing about it they know we're concerned and see it on the 1131 they gave us a map i'm going to put this here can we bring it up great those are the four locations their dust monitors i've searched and searched and i mean i are went back four or five of times i couldn't believe it myself here we are in the the location that is close it to the elementary school by the gillman playground this year's there's supposed to be a duster monitor inside the ground it's not there i've searched from every angle and from griffith i couldn't get a photograph but i can is with

the sexually assaulted and there's nothing from my side i thought they were hidden behind the dust pile but if you climb up on the rocks there's nothing there we've got too far away from where the daycare centers are no way there's that issue we need more dust monitor not insides the perimeter they're not listening we're in the obstructionist we are concerned we're really concerned about the health of the residents as shirley said thees evacuates is going to start tomorrow without the proper water that will throw a lot of dust and that matter will exacerbate the ass mass and

the religious picture issues we need to make sure that is done well, we're asking for your help thank you. >> good morning. i'm dr. tompkins also a member of the health alliance i'm associated with other organizations within this i've participated in science for 45 years as a sophomore and done work in uc berkley and with the department of chemistry and have that two offices in vietnam i come before you as my previous colleagues said we're not wanting to

industry but when there's a misrepresentation of the facts of the corporation it has to be stopped protect the health i did research in the 80s and north side of the breast cancer and hospitalization 4 times hyper the state average when the doctor and i did the k340u7bd studies and the dr. did the analysis on the space station we used the same equipment it measures the part per trillion i stand behind what we found in this picture pagers and similar sound-producing electronic devices are prohibited at this meeting. please make a no television station sorry our printer was not work please notice the craft between the two piles of dirt to give you the illusion that water

is being placed on the piles anytime i put water on the dust it is a light sandy color this is thinking there is water when you look out it i've taken courses in geology no water no water they turned around at the edge of the fence where shirley and julia said where the public is walking we see the gorillas knot they put a thin coat it's already cracked and no water to get the consistency to hold the water down not only does this cause asthma it according cot

health department that heartaches and strokes they get get the highest rate of heartaches of folks in san francisco we're asking for a klein breath of air they've not come employed with the regulations we did an analysis and did the recommendation to them as well in terms of the department and the city and i'll submit this for consideration as well as by the commission please do not permit them until they get in compliance with the dust regulations we took them out last thursday with the city with the air district and the health department they deliberating misrepresented the facts i don't know what the punishment of fines they will sit up here and lie to you your

ore representatives we want the development not at expense of our lives it's a human right as a citizen of san francisco and this nation our buddies died in vietnam i can't can't we have a clean breath of air my father's generation died in the shipyard we're still trying to clean up i was in the research center those bombs that were dropped on japan were shipped from health department sadly in some of the research life expectancycy for african-americans males if 66 to 62 the average life sentence for others is 68 this is r6g9d in african-american