amount second extension is built no affordable care. >> my understanding that's the plan. >> the way for every student or parent is something that went to the school it's been awesome thank you. >> i'd like to announce the upcoming meetings the city and school districts will meet on february 27th and san francisco and sfmta ceqa there will be a curriculum committee on monday in addition to the math update a health education curriculum and kip renewable petitions on the agenda on miracle fourth the meeting of the budget committee american people the rainy day

reserve the planning and kip renewable on march 4 and march 16 is the next month to month of the building and grounds committee there will be a committee as a whole on the early budget priority recommendations on march 17 and of course our regular board meeting will be held on march 10 and 24 any other reports or announcements from my colleagues. >> ms. fewer. >> i'd like to report on thursday, february 12th commissioner vice president haney and i went to the academy their student example of learning was outstanding commissioner vice president haney may want to comment on the work of the students i was so impressed they had their work out and tashlgd in a

professional woo just how they made the mousetrap car and also combined that with an art budget i think the students i saw distance performances and chemistry experiment but this project based learning is taken hold on i s a congratulations to the students for putting on this for the community and the board it was quite quite impressive thank you very much. >> commissioner norton you have my announcements. >> i do actually, i wanted to announce a event that's happening this saturday that maybe of interest to the school community setting goals for the playground the design forum on mission playground the doors on american people 9:00 a.m. and at

9:30 you can rsvp and really the event to answer the question to gather of the input the playgrounds should give our children we want families and kids anyone that is interested in the topic in partnership with our rec and park department thank you ms. fewer i want to congratulate mr. steel. >> and the victimized on create a new family all congratulations and wish him the best and the family the best and try not to keep you late to those meetings so you can return home mr. steel we wish you the best and on behalf of the board

congratulations to you (clapping) >> thank you thank you very much i really appreciate that. >> two announcements on thursday i don't have the right date lincoln lois lane high school will be celebrating it's 21st brotherhood assembly eye i hope high colleagues will be able to participate the brother and sisterhood assembly is to show the diversity around the school it is performed or performed by students from over 15 clubs eaten on saturday march 14 the rosa parks is having their annual fund raising that concludes the announcements

next report of closed session but before we go into closed session i'd like to yes - i'd like to read the in memoriam prosecute we adjourn into closed session i'd like to ask mile colleagues in helping me adjourn tonight meeting in memory of dr. aaron earned son a great sadness the family shares the news of this unexpected death in basil switzerland he transcribed to the board in the state and advisors for the president of the mckennaly elementary school pta i want to acknowledge kimberly pta president that worked with the family and many

friends to develop that profile in connecticut he lived in the bay area and demonstrated is a lifelong work in education and master in personnel administration and a ph.d from the university of michigan and began his career at cal policy and his true passion of to and from was the intellectual am excellent instructor to the students and aspireed and fostered crafty if his students expert in behavior change and engaging rnsz how to champion change and served as an administrator with the college

he is survived by his wife and 20 two sons his parent and it's his two siblings and their families his family and friends the communities have an amazing person who was a devoted father and son his came passion and energy by his prints will be missed two memorial fund be dedication to education have been established to the memorial fund for education by sending a check to the arisen foundation with the section for obama at wwwhorizon foundation and attracts the memorial fund to support the graduate business students at

first state please contact tim accounting anderson son at e d u and memorial site here finally when steve jobs passed away and hosted posted the following quote this man made one dent in the universe i want to say thank you steve we extend everywhere send the message back thank you aaron for making a mooevenlg impact on our lives a special condolence and we'll now recess in closed session i call a recess of the regular meeting we'll have

>> i now resume the regular meeting of the board and i will announce that closed session actions february 24, 2015, board by a vote of 6 i's absent with councilmember emerald within one dispublic department of transportation off one student and 7 site administers the where had by a vote of 6 votes approved 403 principled and one ms. fewer and one absent councilmember emerald a new principle wins at one absences commissioner tour-sarkissian's approved the contract the board by a vote of 6 ids with commissioner mendoza-mcdonnell

for 39 assistant pretends the vote approved the contract for 7 program mrifrts the vote for an approval of 6 i's absence councilmember emerald approved the contract for 30 executive director for did the board approved and may not renew a notice for 5 promised and absent councilmember emerald the board by a vote of 67 ids one absent a new assistant principle and read out of the closed session for february 24, 2015, a board by a vote of 6s within absent councilmember emerald with the requests of one high school student in the matter of km the

danish san francisco unified school district gives the authority of the district to pay a stipulated amount and k g l case no. 2010333 the board by a vote of 5 ids one abstinence gives the district a stipulated amount and stipulated one talented litigation matter to 68 i's one absent commissioner mendoza-mcdonnell the district releases a release and pending litigation cal one hundred et al versus the san francisco unified school district and the superior court cased that in a pending

lawsuit for the self-contained class 1 to of that i a vote of 6 i's one asbestos commissioner mendoza-mcdonnell the braid post scheduled in the daytime schedule of pe destruction for the statutory and will have a monitor to insure and document that pe instruction is being provided by itself code and the council will be updated for its third reading fees and number two wallace by the school district court case and case no. 3 lasalle versus sfusd by a vote of 6 i's one commissioner

mendoza-mcdonnell the board approved the settlement in the amount not stipulated with all possible claims that concludes items the closed session reporting item u another informational items post in the agenda and the staff report the acceptance of gifts and january 2015 meeting adjourned

>> good evening and welcome to the regular meeting of san francisco ethics commission february 23, 2015, calling the roll arrest commissioner hayon commissioner keane commissioner andrews and chair

commissioner hur has been excused item 2 on the agenda public comment on matters powering or not appearing on the agenda within the jurisdiction of the ethics commission anyone have my public comments before we move to the next item hearing none i'll turn to the third item a presentation by san francisco stanford university students regarding their campaign finance project for the 2014 election and welcome and look forward to our presentation. >> thank you. >> you can come up. >> yeah. >> steven macy the technical officer want to take a moment to

welcome christopher's and jeffrey they've been interning from the b matters of admission project at stanford university and look at the laws of the data we collect and data and visiontion software we use in the office in the past two months able to produce data visualization on the november 2014 election i don't want to take away if from their presentation but the work they've been able to do in the past two months is very expressive we we've been very lucky to have them. >> thank you. >> thank you. can you hear me, i'm christen thank you for the opportunity to suspect with about our project what we'll be showing you

tonight a data visiontion and data project that analyses campaign data from the 2014 election cycle previously you'll landmarked did do not on the website in realtime so leading up to an election you can see who the largest contributor are we wanted to do this year once the end of the year filings in the beginning of 2015 to get the full aggregate data and do or in naturals on the spending cycle we'll be showing you a productive of what will have you ever had your deposition taken about going live on the ethics commission website in a few weeks the data from san francisco's on data portal with the finance data i'm going to pass it on to jeff who will talk

about the specifics of the project. >> hello. thank you again for having us i'm jeff as christen mentioned we took the data if on san francisco on data we've used a data visualization called tabla that allows us to create a story with chapters and section that tells a story of what will happy in 2014 in the campaign finance data so when we started to look at the specific sections that encoop lasts the story we're going to try to tell in the sections they include the first total spending in 2014 it also i should note within the city and county of san francisco 2, 3, 4 addition to the assembly race there was specifically

within the kunlt jurisdiction from the alliance additionally the types of contributors and there's 15 of those who are the largest contributors and the resent of those and the lobbyist consulate data and the political parties and the pack general committee data welling we get a good sense of whooped in 2014 cycle and eventually we will be hosting all 9 story that has chapter and sections of story and i'll pass it over to christen with the productive. >> thank you viewing and i will be going back and forth the

first is total campaign spending giving me a moment i'll get this centered here we found nearly $25 million was spent by ballet data committees in particular this doesn't include the june primary election in november and the circumstances a.a. are proportional to dollars spent this is $22 million that was spent by committees an positions who is one positions that have one and instead of saying winning elections we'll say position one the expenditures that are opted o opposed those are expenditures was 22 admission and losing walking was that million dollars this doesn't include the vicinity direct spending together and all san francisco elections as well as the statewide city elections

with the visualization you can interact with the data we'll drill down and look at how much was spent specifically by candidate committees over $7 million was spent by candidate committees to oppose them the green kshlgz recognize the size with opposing campaigns for positions that one you can click on the circles and get a pop up table below that shows you specific details of the expenditures so in this case those were expenditures expenditures to oppose commitments those were two committees that opposed david chiu and one that opposed jane

kim this is how to manipulate the finding and the money on those committees the sail visual lay out what's important most of the money was spent i guess kev you can say on elections that had the intended outcomes and 3 times more money was spent on ballot measures than on committees which is interesting so you can also click on those and look at that more closely on 7 details about how the money was spent so you get o could look at specific measures to either support or oppose them and the expenditures made that's a snapshot i'm going to pass it on to jeff now. >> thank you so with this section ms. package

has been looking at the total contributions for the contributor type and chops sorry about that we're connected to the. internet right now so this is in realtime sorry about that arrest those are infrastructure previews this is showing you can see the top is a bar that shows the total spending in 2014 and the different colors represent the types of contributor and you'll notice other generally includes corporations and, llc types and the yellow or orange indicates individuals blue is committees and then red which you can't see

it is so small our small contributor committees both is interesting one can basically look at this and see you'll see the bubbles change each bubble representatives a contributor and scan over and see information about 3 and to go back if the initial section which kind of electricities to why this is a contributor to the information there are out layers for example other others we see f c, llc american beverage association it contributed about $9 million and see see individuals and so what's kind of exciting you can dive into the cat those are bar charts on

the right and that's individuals - the bar chart on the right can show the recipients but those are ballet measures we see a pretty clear trend of what is the being spent that i contributor workplaceith that. >> we look at the expenditures on consultant and we found over $12 million of the $25 million i mentioned was spent on consultants either to support or oppose specific ballet measures or candidate so looking at the first visual the large circle

represents measures and 88 percent of the expenditures on candidates was 12 percentage here being to support the candidates in fact all of the candidates were in support whereas the ballet measures what is what to support or oppose we'll see a further visualization and the activity dratted the activity if you click on the bubbles you'll look at the bar gravel here and what i did i aligned the location outcome similar to what i showed in the did the expenditures have the desired effect did it matter to spend money on consultants we see the layering e by and large

the measure e if you look at it closely the rest of the story i'm not going to show the other measures when you look at candidates, however, it was really 50/50 in terms of whether it was consultant spending that helped said candidates and quickly to show you some more of those this is a list of consultants and click on them with information on a pop up table which candidates give the money and what that money is spent for i'm going to turn it over to jeff he'll talk about lobbyists. >> so, yeah so this is one of the sections in the chapter about lobbying and we've seen here a word cloud in i minimal

you're familiar with the word cloud essentially each words hepatitis e represents how often a contact from a lobbyist made an association it becomes clear to the user which people are being lobbied so if you choose one for example, housing and property and tax on the left hand the official news cannot the lobbyist firm and in fact, the lobbyists clients we'll see a independent picture in the blue that says whether or not it was effective lobbyist contact or when a wasn't in the outcome we start you know it is constructing an interesting picture when is happening and effective. >> okay. we analyzed did activity of the political action

committees i'm not to show you a few fidelities if we get it online there is more we are showing you this is information who gave to political action committees and what they gave at the top we have timeline from january to december and what was interesting you see in may a peak in contributions before the june primaries and one in october before the general election this timeline is interact active you can click on it by clicking on it you'll activate the bubble graft down below that shows you everyone that gave during that month that you clicked in the boo timeline

while click on the names in the bubble graft and so more information about who gave for example local 2 is a union so you have individual names those are union if you look at something like that committee for a bright future you see a variety of corporate donors this is for political activities over time and drill down into the specific individuals is having given to them there's information in the analysis about what those political action committees are do go with the fund they representative interests information about contributions to committees so those are further detailed if you click on a bar gravel they've see the action committee how much so