Skip to main content

tv   [untitled]    March 9, 2015 9:00am-9:31am PDT

9:00 am
thank you, next speaker, please >> my name is [inaudible] senior at marin catholic one of the schools effected by the after bishops changes. i drove to show support. my teachers have taught nothing but how to the love. when the archbishops actions are creating a environment of intolerance discrimination and fear for teachers and community it is our duty to support our teachers. archbishop [inaudible] used the catholic religion for haet speech. he says love and acceptance only belongs in the schools for those that are deemed worthy and that st. isn't right or just. we'll ask the arch bishal to retract the changes and ask you to support this resolution >> next speaking, please.
9:01 am
>> my name is ana [inaudible] senior at sacred heart cathedral. i'm here as a certain student and friend and a deeply troubled catholic. the language the archbishop wants to include identify the action of is evil and hateful and has no place in our catholic communities. forcing teachers to sign a document is a cont rudiction of the teacher of conscious which calls on all people to reject teachings in violation including those that discriminate those in our communities yet the archbishop continues to fight for this language. our parents and teachers do not want this and most marntly we the student do not want this. we come to school to be in a safe place to learn and ask question squz
9:02 am
explore the faith rkts we do not inxh to school to be told we are unequal in the eyes of god. should thee changes go forward, teachers will leave and parents will not longer trust the schools and we the student will suffer. thank you >> thank you, next speaker, please >> my name is michael curen [inaudible] as a frexman at sacred heartime rrb blessed with school wide diversity in interest, race, income and sexual orientation. i love how the the class mates and teepers feel accepted every day. after bishop [inaudible] wants to change that. i don't want to go to school that has teachers in fear for their jobs and forced to put down the student for being who they are. i love my school, please don't let the values of love and acceptance be tarnished >> thank you, nx speaker,
9:03 am
please >> my name is rien patterson, i'm here to make a brown act in sun shine ordinance on behalf of my clients 1067 market street llc [inaudible] based on the amendment of file number 150087 after the close of public comment. we do have comments we would like to make and we request a opportunity to do so. thank you. >> thank you very much. next speaking, please. >> good afternoon, my name is moreen hurly i'm a san francisco native and went to [inaudible] high school and usf. i have a son at archbishop readern high school and we are lurky to have the awesome teacher thaz we do. they rin fear right now for
9:04 am
their jobs and that is beneath the dignity of san francisco, that is beneath the dignity of what san francisco is all about and i know i'm probably preaching to the choir here, but these young people and all the people that had to leave, there are so many people that are thank ful supervisor ferrule for stepping up and speaking up. that you can so much, please support our teachers. it is rotten job, but they do is a great job and do it out of love >> thank you, next speakers, please >> my name is michael [inaudible] i'm a long time resident of san francisco and active precisionner at [inaudible] and most-plarnty parent of a soft more at sacred
9:05 am
heart cathedral. i must admit i was initially skeptical on the board of supervisors waying in orin the contsversey 56789 as one who deeply appreciates the separation of church and state. i question the appropriateness of government getting involved, but separate doesn't mean exempt from support or challenge, praise or criticism. just as the church should speak its mind in matters of the state it finds troubling it is the right and responsibility of the state to raise the flag and say enough is enough when the church, any church goes too far. the morality clause proposal put
9:06 am
forth by archbishop cort liowny does that it crosses the line. his initiative is hurtful to me on so many levels. as a parent, as a resident and simply as a human being. and as a catholic it pains me to see my archdiocese choose to present cath aulicism in such a judgmental way. i feel embarrassed by the proposal laser focus on hot button issues. while it appears the archbishop was rethinking his action make no mistake about his intentionsism in the diocese own words, nothing already planned to go in is being removed or retracted or with drawn. [inaudible]
9:07 am
>> thank you sir, your time is up. thank you very much. next speaker please >> my name is vlad irks mir and i'm 83 years old and homeless and wanted help from the board of supervisors and mayor lee to return me home. because i think that to keep 83 years old on the street it is the only hitler germany did it thank you. jurkss thank you very much sir. next speaker, please >> i want to cu-mind sal
9:08 am
vudoor cort lion. good for him. a men. yes and shame on all you people. shame on you. what does the bible say? paul quoted leviticus in loving your neighbors. love one another for he that loves one another fulfilled the law and for this though shall not [inaudible] if there is any other command it is briefly comp hended in this, love your neighbor as yourself. love works no ill so love is fulfilling of the law. the context of the statement is leviticus 19 where it says you are full of hate if you do not rebuke your brother when you see him do any wrong. that is what it says, you are full of hate, but this is turned around by the homosexual community and
9:09 am
those for home sexuals 180 degrees from what it means. i'm stealing rushes words, but words mean things. words mean things. you can't change god. he is the same yesterday today and forever. when the grace of god comes into a mans heart then he does good works if he is a adult rr he say that is wrong and repent. if he is a homosexual he says i won't be a homosexual anymore. we read in first corinthians chapter 6 of the sins of those that were not christians and we delineated them through the [inaudible] >> your time is up, sir.
9:10 am
thank you. clearly there is a need for meantm helths services in the chamber. at this time public comment is now closed. thank you all for coming out today. i see a lot of proud parents in the audience. the student that came out today, thank you so much. you did a great job. at this time we will move forward. >> ilems 19-23 is considered for immediate adoption without reference. a single vote may [inaudible] >> okay. supervisor farrow >> [inaudible] >> supervisor mar >> 23 >> supervisor kim >> was there a amendment? >> i would like to sever item 22.
9:11 am
>> on the remaining items which i think is only probably 1 item. >> 20 and 21. on items 20 and 21. supervisor ferrule. [inaudible] >> supervisor wiener. >> 21. what item did we not sever? >> item 20 >> item 19, supervisor farrow >> thank you madam president. i want thank the people that came out to speak today for all my colleagues for cosponsors the signing with me. the topic of conversation is a rough one for a number of weeks and brings no joy to talk about it, but i continue to believe as a prathsing catholic in san francisco who was educated in
9:12 am
orcatholic school, we have a obligation to speak up and despite the recent events i continue to be a proud catholic in san francisco. proud to be educated here and part of a praths catholic family. as i mentioned the last few weeks have been the most challenging of my life in the catholic church and know tonight it was a sampling of the people that feel the same way and want to thank everyone for reaching out to my office at a time when pope frances continues to give so many hope inside and outside of the catholic church. these local events have over shadows the instration we are getting from rome. i think these actions really afront the valees we have in san francisco and that we all hold dear. their content and the way they
9:13 am
are communicated to the the community and school community and in so many ways our adherence and defense of these values define us as san francisco mpt inclusion over exclusion, tolerance ofern discrimination and commitment for respect for the individual makes us who we are as a city. in our catholic church has the right to insure the catholic faith is taught and up hp held in the schools. but for a pastor to deny young weapon the ability to serve as alter girms as example, as we celebrate womens history month completely discredits what young women have brought to had catholic church. this is the point we should look to include people and encourage people to be part of the community, not exclude them. i think most parntsly as weez heard from people tonight to require teachers to sign a
9:14 am
contract and to afirm and believe many of the practices the church discouraged is evil crosses the line. disageeing with the teachings doesn't mean i or anyone here isn't a catholic or bad catholic, but disagrees and has a caujss that tells them otherwise. plike many people talked about i don't know what to say whether they are teachers parents or student who believe in those values as well. what do we say to the teachers that are part of the lgb community or the friends who are part of the lgb community? insuch we stand up for everyone. we stand up for the community and honor and embrace those that choose to do the same. our features play such a important role for our children and families and i
9:15 am
want to thank members of the arch diseize and high sools that came out, even a wild cat, thank you for being out here, but the disconteent and uncertaintyly and confuse the stream of events caused it not only unnecessarily but avoidable and in my opinion unconsciousenable. we can not talk out of both sides of our mouth. honoring our teachers and placing restriction on employment and creating a culture of fear that has no place in our schools right now. the message is coming from pope franceing and the archdiocese cannot be more at odds in the tone and approach and this causes confusion over what the real message of the chunch is and it is what dishardens me as a catholic. it is unfortunate when there is a constant need for par
9:16 am
tisitation in everything we need here in san francisco. we need to be galvanized and notdroid in solving our issues that face us. we continue to have violence on the streets and continue to have homeless issues and have so many issues that need or attention and argue and suggest need a strong catholic community. i love pope frances quote, i prefer a church which is bruised hurtding and dirty because it has been in sth streets rather than a church that is confined and cleaned from the own security. i'll say again this week, i expect as a legislator and pray as a cath lack that events are resolved in a manner similar to the resolution we are voting on today which honors the cont butions of the
9:17 am
teachers [inaudible] my mope sh continues to be no matter what religion our faith community we qu move past these events. we have a long road to go, but ultimately rededicate ourselves to the mission of the chunchs and faiths and focus on being men and women for others here in the city of saint francis and colleagues i hope to have your support >> with that can we crawl roll >> item 19 and for the record item 19 is the urge >> student archdiocese of san francisco to [inaudible] on item 19 >> supervisor ferrule rkss aye. mar, ayeau. tang, aye.
9:18 am
supervisor wiener, aye. [inaudible] breed aye. sfr visor campus. there are 11 ayes. this resolution is adopt. >> [inaudible] problem gambling awareness month >> i called for 23 >> we are missing a member. >> different house >> i think we already approved >> no we didn't. >> we attempted to. >> same house, same call. without objection this resolution is adopted. madam clerk can you call item 21
9:19 am
>> resolution to support senate bill 277 repeal thg personal belief exemption for vaccines >> supervisor weern >> this is a resolution to put san francisco on the records supporting the elimination of the personal belief exemption forvic seens. we have one of the few states that allows anyone if they don't want their kids vaccinated. this is a significant pub public health issue. it isn't about his or her child t is about others in the community that are too young to be vaccinated or can't be vaccinated for spinge health reasons or the fact that vack seenss are not 100 percent.
9:20 am
meseals are 95 percent effective. it is important we increase vaccination rates for measles and other diseases in california and i want to cu-mind senator pan for introducing sb 277 to firmly move us in that direction so and for your support >> thank you supervisor wiener. same house and same call. without ubjuckz this is adopted unanimously jrfxz rk >> item 22 is [inaudible] to consider without reference and amendment to board rule 3.31 to the extend the term of the joint set city and school district through nob nab >> supervisor kim >> i want to make a minor amendment to the motion
9:21 am
suspended board rule 3.261. it is a typo, we have met on the 4th thursday. >> can we take that amendment without objection? >> second by supervisor campose >> without objection the amendment pass said. on the underlying item. item number 22 can key take that same house and call >> as amendmented. >> without objection the motion is approve. item 23. >> urge the golden gate bridge board of drecktders to remove >> supervisor mar >> i move that we continue this item for one week
9:22 am
>> okay, supervisor mar has moved to continue item number 23 to next week. seconded by supervisor campus. without objection item 23 is continued to next week. march 10, 2015 . madam clerk are there any other memoriams? >> and no memoriams today. >> this bringstuse the end of the ajunda. is there any business before us >> that conclude the business for today >> with that our meeting is adjourned. thank you.
9:23 am
test. >> planning commission regular hearing for hearing for march 5, 2015, i'd like to remind the members of the audience that the commission does not tolerate disruptions of any kind. devices. and and when speaking before the commission, if you care to, do state your name for the record. i'd like to take roll commissioner president fong commissioner hillis commissioner moore. >> i don't have a screen. >> it's not on. >> i'm not on. >> we have new proposes we'll fix that in a second. >> commissioner moore. >> commissioner richards we do expect commissioner wu and commissioner johnson and commissioner antonini to are
9:24 am
absent commissioners first on your agenda items proposed for continuance excuse me. at townsend street the go conditional use authorization for continuance march 2015 case t c a amending the resolution of the short-term rental and the administrative code is proposed until april 2nd, 2015, and item 3 at 276 hartford street a discretionary review until april no other items proposed for continuance i'll just check. >> any public comment on item the items proposed for
9:25 am
continuance seeing none, public comment is closed arrest commissioner richards. >> move to continue. >> second. >> on that motion to continue all matters as proposed commissioner hillis one that 0 acceptance. >> i'm showing up as commissioner richards i'm commissioner moore i'd like to ask for continuance on items a-10 a and b the discussion requires a full commission we're trying to amended the bopped bay area special use district on the particular proposal a amends those boundary side folks spent a lot of time working with the supervisor for adding parcels in this case and that discussion should be brought forward before
9:26 am
a rezoning of the particular property. >> commissioner moore we should take up the item when it is called under the regular calendar ms. the initiation. >> okay. we'll take it up commissioner president fong. >> as the time is it r is scheduled just to be clear 10 ab or 11. >> i'm sorry 11 i misread the number it is okay. >> commissioners on that motion to continue commissioner hillis commissioner moore commissioner richards and commissioner president fong momentous unanimously 4 to zero. >> commissioners that places you under your consent calendar
9:27 am
- 04 at 1401 howard street this is a conditional use authorization any public comment on item the one attorney at law the consent calendar? seeing none, public comment is closed closed. >> move to continue. >> this is for approval. >> sorry sorry move to approve. >> thank you commissioner hillis on that mission commissioner hillis commissioner moore commissioner richards and commissioner president fong smooement unanimously item 5 consideration of the draft minutes for the rules committee for february 12th as you recall this was not included in your packet. >> commissioner moore. >> move to approve. >> second.
9:28 am
>> on that motion to adopt the minutes for the rules committee oar commissioner hillis commissioner moore commissioner richards and commissioner president fong snoementd unanimously 4 to zero and places you on commissioner questions or comments. >> yeah. that's me and commissioner moore. >> i read on interesting article that talks about the world cities based on accident quality of living and it was very interesting san francisco ranked 27 and vienna and places you under your regular calendar try one and new zealand 3 and fran for the record geneva corp.
9:29 am
haeg filed the first 10 i was surprised with the benchmarking of new york that san francisco was 27. >> number 6 commissioner richards. >> couple of things the first one is in this week's chronicle an article on the airbnb people were blaming the process i guess my comment if there are 8 thousand rentals and 7 homicide calls not that many people called to say there's something wrong with the process i think we need 0 have more calls and if there's a process issue we'll fourth but 10 are percent of the people have listing not good enough for me that's my comment on that i move to see how this
9:30 am
shapes i in the future a couple of things not a day goes by i pick up a paper about affordable housing and we should put a moratorium on the mission i sit here i can we've talked about did mayor's office of housing work streams when is that going come before us and the emergencies dial we've been hearing about it anyone knows when that is going to come before us. >> okay. you thank you. >> commissioners, if there's nothing further we'll move that on 0 department matter item 7 directors announcements. >> the director's report in our packet. >> awhile i've got the mike i'll introduce