presentation on a better bart which i mean will likely schedule if not urgent but schedule that you're aware of the bart scheduled projects that they're working on. >> and also, they mentioned that the affair only covered 75 percent of their costs so in new york their central station underground lots of restaurants and shops and that yes, i did. >> a lot of revenue and mentioned in asia like the 81 pa and hong kong and underground the way station there's an underground shopping mall so asked him to consider that >> i may add one point of discussion a substantial amount

of discussion twenty-four hour in light of our hourly workforce and sort of the mitigation of where they live and the complexity of bart to be able to do that. >> i've met with tom and the s.b.a. and they plan to have classes in chinese in chinatown and the city college campus and wanted to have a mixer so in chinatown it will be sponsored by the east west bank i told her to meet with the east west bank they're a provider as well as the. >> okay. >> i'll let adam know about that. >> any other commissioner reports. >> i have a question about the come back to the economic interact analysis is bart going

to be part of the agency we'll be talking to. >> it's too far from what we're trying to do. >> i think in terms of it's not that it should be k4ri9d but in terms of what we're able to influence mostly is really around the city infrastructure project that's not to say that we couldn't use what the commission end up doing with the recommendations once bart is with the infrastructure project this is a discussion point or have the city have that as a discussion point with bart. >> okay. thank you. >> i think it was brought up that people think they should coordinate with mta so because

it is coordinating a schedule. >> okay any other reports? seeing none we'll move on to the next item north america item 9 new business we want to add scott a discussion of scott ab 12 e i didn't mean to cut him off it needs to be an agenda item a proposal for a small business tax holiday a single day it has of if passes at the the state level it has an implementation because we have an credential we'll have that discussion whether to recommend to the city and county of san francisco for them to honor that as well and there recent all kinds of logical issues for the

tax holiday many businesses have many online point of sales you can track this as a single transaction it is great but not without complications >> so may i ask one particular. >> uh-huh. >> i don't know if it's one or a couple of questions i'll jaundice it as new business i'll check with our chief confinement to make sure we have the timeline and all of that do i need me to check in with the small business community to sort of gage their level of interest as well. >> it explicit hurt to have outreach i think that i mean, however, we want to do that it is happening at the state level the primary

question whether or not san francisco will be amenable to sync emphasizing with that, i think if we can determine that by speaking to whoever it in favor of that it can be a matter of a point of order we'll support it and the city is listing to do so and the business will decide whether it wants to take advantage of the holiday and go through the extractions of managing the implementation of that. >> uh-huh. >> i wondered how will different businesses will they register it i mean it wouldn't be a tax holiday for target. >> that's to be routine by the planning commission, and may be acted upon by a single roll call vote interesting question. >> what democrats a small business. >> we could have a discussion that probably is in the fact

sheet here. >> uh-huh. >> we didn't have time 3 minutes and whatever the limited amount of time to go through the detail. >> but that's good to hear so we're dpw and to let you know the stages of what the commission can do to have a resolution there's or there's a state legislation committee within the state government and make recommendations so that as on behalf of the city whether the city supports something or not to were there can be a recommendation to support the state bill and a resolution recommending you know there could be two resolutions in providing direction to the city for the sales tax.

>> i've seen the survey asking about this i had my own issues as to how i would execute this so i think it's a worthwhile thing to put on the agenda since it's a small business tax holiday recommended are there any other commissioner ortiz-cartagena. >> i don't know if? an action or jaundice can we get rid of hard copies i don't know what the laws if i get someone to donate tablets. >> that's the discretion of the commission i know that some commission do that could be something that is taking into

account in terms of our budget is depends on - and i 1st district i know it's not in the budget but if someone demons. >> that's not to say it is not in the budget it is depending on what the tablet is and we haven't you know not to say it can't be in the budget it is really if the commission t is interested in having that. >> i'll take a look at that. >> let's take into account it, it, it great to save paper and certainly needs to be subscribed in any manner - physical decidess. >> that's not to say the direction the majority of commissioners want taebltsz i'll be happy to do that.

>> any other business i think we have a final call. >> commissioners i don't agendize i agendize public comment at the beginning of the meeting pr. >> i wanted to make sure i didn't miss anything. >> no, no because i knew that would be approximately an hour meeting one 7, 8, 9. >> do we have a motion for adjournment. >> i move. >> second. >> and commissioners we're adjourned oh. >> yes. yes. >> all in favor, say i. >> yes. >> opposed? we're adjoined. >> can you please rise for the

pledge of allegiance? >> pledge of allegiance. >> president, i'd like to call roll. >> president loftus. >> here. >> vice president turman. >> here. >> commissioner marshall enroute. >> . >> dejes u.s. >> here. >>. >> also here with us is joyce

hicks and chief of police. >> welcome everyone to the to the march 11th police commission meeting welcome to those here in attendance and those watching at home. we haven't been here in city hall since february 4th so it's good to be back. >> please call the first line item. . >> certificate of appreciation mr. jeffrey man hierm man heimer and i understand we're going to have a presentation. >> i am lieutenant chin from the -- mr. manheimer, are you here? come on up [applause]. >> sorry sergio.

>> correct i'm lieutenant sergio chin from the investigative team. tonight we're here to president the citizen's commendation. let me give a little bit of detail. there was a robbery incident that occurred at the 1800-block of polk street the the suspect tries to leave without paying and mr. manheimer hears the ruckus and turns around and sees a big fight. a couple of things he

could do take no action or push him off the bike and he did that pushed him off the bike the suspect falls to the ground, the cop shows up and arrested and most people wouldn't take any action but mr. manheimer here risked his own safety and displayed a willingness usually reserved for police officers and fire fighters and a select few of our civilian population and mr. man heimer heimer should be commended for for his brave action and be awarded the commendation award. >> commissioner commissioner mazzucco gets very excited about this [laughter] there is

one one less rob er on the streets of san francisco due to the to the courageous actions of mr. man heimer and such an example of behave bravery is worthy of the highest esteem by the san francisco police department. [applause]. >> and for those of you watching at home who can't see, there's a large contingent of supporters for mr. man heimer. welcome. >> i just wanted to say thank you it's an honor to take this award. it wasn't something that you expect walking into work and it was good i could help out with the police and i know what you guys deal with on a day-to-day basis so it was the least i could do so thank you i appreciate it.

>> wonderful. >> [applause] somebody should take a picture. >> mr. man heimer [applause] inspect tore please call the next item. >> adoption of minutes for the meetings of january 28th, , february 4th. february february 11th and february and february and february 25th, 2015. .

>> colleagues in your packets you have the minutes prepared for these 4 meetings are there any discussion about these minutes. >> i move to approve. >> all of those in favor? those opposed? the motion passes. please call the next line item. >> heist. >> >> action. . chief there's a request here from the department to accept these 13 hyster forklifts. >> actually i'm going to let to let sergeant matthews speak to that. >> thank you. the police department are operating receiving excess and under

utilized government equipment everything from paper shred ers to storage cabinets and police boats and even at one time helicopters and at this time we've been able to locate 13 forklifts and property supply areas as well as some of our specialized units and they come to us initially at no cost from the government and after 1 1 year in our possession they are turned over to us to use as we see fit either to return to the government at no cost or penalty or reallocate or sell if we desire so a great saving estimated at 226 at $226,000 worth of forklifts that we get at no cost. >> 13 seems like a lot of forklifts just curious about the number.

>> sure. the way these are stockpiled by the government they are told to us they are available but without any real detail on the condition of the forklifts we have a short window to inspect them for use ability and so due diligence said we take them all and see which ones we need for parts to make the others whole and if they are not all in proper working order we can turn those back in. >> do you have any questions? >> vice president turman? >> sergeant matthews can we also allocate to other agencies. >> the equipment is did i differently classified for their use and for the first year they must remain in the

control of the police department for a law enforcement purpose and after that time yes, we could potentially. >> any other questions for my colleagues? okay. do i have a motion? >> accept. all those in favor. aye. motion passes. thank you, sergeant. >> thank you. >> good luck with the forklifts. >> thank you. >> please call the next line item. >> the public is now welcome to address the commission with items that are within the jurisdiction of the commission and address your remarks to the commission as a whole and not to individual commissioners and during public comment neither police or occ personnel or commissioners are required to respond to questions but may

provide a brief response and occ personnel should rerefrain however from entering into any discussions with speakers during their comment and you you can limit your comment to to 3 minutes, please. >> welcome. >> hello commissioners i've been here many times before for those of you who don't come all the time i apologize for doing ancient history in the last 3 minutes and actually you can get change done around here even if in a roundabout way i want to wish you a happy month. if you didn't see the report on channel 2 last thursday it featured the chief being interviewed talking about the lieutenant and his disgraceful exit from the department and i think if if you haven't seen it, i recommend you watch it and

unfortunately i want to point out it's 5 years and over a million dollars too late. imagine the pension he's going to get because you promoted him after a crime and that teaches other officers that the way to get a promotion is by breaking the law. 5 years ago the castro was operated under the aegis of a corrupt supervisor and police officer and extortionist jane warn er and those are the 3 leading lights of law enforcement in the castro five very very long years ago. there has been an improvement but it hasn't been fast enough and it hasn't been nearly enough. okay. the shooting

that happened about 2 weeks ago -- of the poor mr. perez lopez and covering for one of their inform ants who were criminals. they had 3 officers went to the federal pen because they were dealing with criminals and went to the pen because they were dealing with criminals and became criminals. we all know the mission station is the most corrupt station in the city and we all know the undercover cop program there has been given a hard look by these feds and they are still look ing. have you notified the feds. i've got a lot more i'll come next week or the week after. thank you. >> any further public comment?

>> hello. my name is paulette brown. i'd like to use the overhead. i'm here concerning my son and his friends called him cheddar and he was measured by a semi caucasian by a semi automatic gun and to this day still no justice. his case is a cold case. i have the name of all the perpetrators that murder and that was there and involved with my son being murdered. anthony hunter and one of these is deceased. these are the names that i got

and these are the true names of the perpetrators that murdered my son they are still walking the street one of them is thomas hannabal and he has a comedy show somewhere and he's living his life as though he never done anything. and my son , his body, his birthday is next month, april 6th and this is what i have to celebrate. this is the life that i have to celebrate. no life. i can't stop this. this is my therapy to come here and keep my son's memory alive. this is not easy

for me, but i will continue to do it again, these guys names are on my son's file is the perpetrators that were going to shoot another young man. see these names, look them up, get them off the street. i'm afraid for my children that i have left. who is to know if these guys might be looking at me. they might see what i'm doing every month or every week and i don't care you took everything from me. you took my son. he was my only son and i grief every day and i don't care if it's been 8 years. i i need justice for my child. there are so many unsolved

homicides out there. my son is one. these cases need to be solved. these men need to be off the street not to murder again. >> thank you miss brown and again there's a 250 there's a $250,000 reward into the investigation into into the murder and chief correct me if i'm wrong i think the anonymous tip line is there and please come forward to tip line is anonymous. thank you miss brown. >> further public comment? >> good evening commissioners, chief, everybody out there my name is jacki bryson and i'm very happy to see you back at city hall. i was one of the

uninformed and i did come last week and that's okay i got to look at the door. in any event, i want to thank you again for coming to the tenderloin and south of market and commissioner commissioner hwang got to see -- 6th street which is where i have to walk. wasn't it kind of scary cautioning up there. i want to talk a little bit about 6th street today because i'm hoping the police will do something to make it less scary. on the corners of 6th street and howard we have a lot of vehicular bicycles and cars bad behavior where if the police were stationed there they might be able to struck might be able to instruct people via ticket that this is the wrong thing to do. sometimes that's the only way to get the point

across to people that's very educational to have a ticket that you have to pay and yesterday i was speaking with a motorcycle police officer who has a lot more patience than i do there was a jerk on a bike riding against traffic and he nicely but firmly said you are going the wrong way and the guy continues to ride and we're talking about he's in the left turn only lane going the wrong way on howard street and turns and says to the officer -- thanks girl if that had been me i probably would have shot him and that's one of the reasons i don't have your job and he didn't do anything and he didn't swear at him and anything and yeah this is the kind of guy we want working in the police department and the person eventually got onto the sidewalk and drove about 20 feet more and back only the the street and so whoever officer was thank you so much for keeping your cool other officers who kept their cool

were those at project homeless connect today and a lady was determined that she was going to get her california picture id even though the best we could do because the d.m.v. cancelled without telling anyone was to give her a voucher to go get this and she raised such a ruckus and the officer was his usual cool calm and collected self and i'm keen on pj and she got hustled again the second time and i said officer pg is this the second or third strike for her? i don't know the end of that that story but nobody lost their cool and i think that speaks very well of the san francisco police department. >> thank you miss bryson further public comment? welcome. >> hello. my name is larry and i like to be called edmund juicy and i'm very tired i want

to thank -- i mean gascone chief he said he's going to be doing a lot more work with sro hotels and black woman's sons who have been shot in the city and i thank god he knows something that's going on in our hotels and i'm also here to say i'm really looking forward for our police officers in san francisco to get the cameras i hope we're going to be a city that will have cameras very soon and i'd like to see the police walking up market street and it says one of these weekends it's saint patrick's weekend and new year's and i'm tired and i just really want you all to have cameras and i want more