my plan is a plan b motion. >> i like his better. >> there's two components to the planning department there's the one gathering the existing and two the - there is the evaluated components of the conditional use necessary when the industry is compared to like industry so possess o boss those elements are tied into this legislation so. >> why not add those f to the motion as a recommendation. >> okay. >> so the recommendation would be that massage therapist be classified as other health care professionals currently that are currently in operation in san francisco that does not require

conditional use. >> perfect. >> may i start that as the certification with about correct we don't want massage therapist. >> massage thooefts that meet the certification refrigerates in the city or state of california you can get a california certification or a san francisco certification but not both right. >> i'm wondering if we need to go into that level of detail i think item number had the health department kind of the direction to supervisor tang to try to do something it eliminates having to make those distinctions so we make a distinction that provides the confidence that - >> we call them massage thooefts that's out of my recommendation i'm recommending those regarded as a massage

therapist. >> we're talking about establishments so i think i mean one could say if you have one definition it is item 4 but the direction to commissioner tang to work to create a definition that parallels ass this as a house industry progression so that then once this definition is created then it minimize the need for conditional use. >> it is kind of what i'm hearing our saying. >> i think the grrth is very clear and as far as the cu we're saying that the c should not apply to a category of practitioners as supervisor tang or as the experts will define it

shouldn't apply to everybody and if the purpose is to limit illicit activities not do that to the detriment of the legitimate and professionals in the field is that's the - and right. right so i think we're trying to get at how we say that we want this group of health care professionals mansion age therapist to be defined as health care professionals like the other health care professionals that does not require conditional use and what those others are whether their dental technicians or occupational thooefts i don't know the clarification but get help from the group so that the supervisor has a rational for

creating that class of health care professionals that meet the various needs of people whether they be physical or warehousehatever, whatever therapy is required. >> have we boiled it down. >> the recommendation is the first recommendation is that your - excuse me. the - sorry i'm trying to that how to do that in terms of taking direct action to file none 141303 is you're recommending not approval for the reasons you've stipulated in terms of the reasons around

conditional use. >> yes. >> at the same time, we're talking about planning there is a need to for the planning department we're recommending the planning department create a means to grandfather. >> correct. >> correct. >> i second that. >> okay. so with that i will say that commissioner president dwight merely made the motion (laughter) and commissioner adams seconded roll call. >> commissioner adams commissioner dooley commissioner president dwight commissioner ortiz-cartagena commissioner l. riley commissioner tour-sarkissian commissioner white all right. so then you've

unanimously approved that recommendation to be passed on to supervisor tang and to the planning commission so i think that is it for those who are here for item 4 and 5. >> thank you for your input and time it was great input. >> all right. commissioners, i shall move on to item number - yes. >> deanna. >> deanna thank you very much and diego thank you very much appreciate it, it's yours. >> all right. so commissioners we are generally this meeting does have a hard stop at four but the next meeting is detailed

so i'm going to just for item number of update on the development and preemption of the legacy program we're not going to get into a detailed discussion i'm highlighting the changes that have been made and passed out of the board of supervisors and then at our april 13th meeting we'll get into the detailed discussions of work on the program and establishing the registry program under item 6 i've already informed you that supervisor campos had taken out of the legislation the rebate incentives and that discussion is take place in terms of looking at what we can do to have more robust financial incentive i think this is going to take

awhile to look at all the various nuance and things available we'll start that because those will be recommendations the commission needs to make and it's final list for the program so that will be coming before you but a significant change that happened if you'll turn to page 2 so page 2 item b start on line 3 purpose of this section for 2a 242 legacy business needs a business that has been nominated by the board of supervisors or the mayor and the small business commission after a noticed hearing determines the following

criteria so what's been struck are suggestions of specific industry so this now i think will require if the commission to develop some stronger administration guidelines for the departmentalized to work with it requires that i meet with the board of supervisors to get an understanding as to what their determination you know what their idea of a legacy business is and in addition to the mayor and for you as well so but the other items that have remained the business operate in san francisco for thirty years without a break exposing 2 years and the business is operated and that business is laurtd in san

francisco the business has contributed to neighborhood history or neighborhoods or community the business is committed to cvs the features that define the business and that there's a fee involved and the other item initially the legislation has a june 30th date in which the commission was to develop a legacy business program and registry application criteria this is now been extended to september 30th. >> yeah. >> so because of time we will get into the timeline at the next meeting and i also want to inform you that i've been in discussion

with mike buehler from sf heritage the hell man family fund i believe we've jointly piloted through sf heritage but that is a joint partnership with sf heritage office of small business and the family fund to apply for a grant to help do some of the research analysis programming defining to help us with that so we'll see if we get it and it will you know ♪ doing so moot our timeline oh and lastly i should say i'm so sorry i did talk to the historic i made a presentation to the historic preservation commission and the historic preservation commission has a committee that is now taking a look at another cultural legacy so this does have a specific

overlap the legacy businesses with cultural legacy many of the cultural districts are cultural districts because of businesses there so there is much interest on their part and also being engaged with this process and want to have continual updates and provide feedback and if relevant at any time to do joint commission meetings as well >> thanks. >> all right. now, what do we do >> we'll move on. >> any public comment? >> okay welcome. >> hello, i'm shelly i'm staff with the planning department and

staff to the historic preservation commission and i sit here today to just let you think that the cultural heritage assets committee is a new commission they started meeting in january of this year specifically to deal with the issue of cultural heritage and how do we protect it and support it our traditionally landmarking designation are not board enough to support the uses ego businesses and so we're exploring ways the city can develop new programs to do that so their obviously really existed about the legacy heritage i'm sorry i'm going to mix terms so they're excited about the legacy business program and would like to play a part in developing that cree that this commission will use to dominate

businesses to the register and hope bmw's for the next couple of months the committee is holding hearing inviting speakers from city agencies and communities would have an interest in the cultural heritage to share ideas and to lower than better what the landscape needs are for the particular areas so i wanted to off our support if there's anything we can do in terms of research or our past experienced with the japantown or the cultural heshlg and economic strategy we could on two years ago or our work with the investment neighborhoods program we will be happy to share experience. >> are driver's license any

other cities that have done that. >> no, that's the scary part we don't have precedent to look to internationally there's been recognize of intangible heritage assets for quite a while the legislation passed about 10 years ago or more but at the national and state level we don't have programs to look for that's one of the things we strurlgd with in the japantown experience to target cultural businesses institutions nonprofits in trying to find a way to support them we had to start basically at the beginning what are the criteria to define them so we came up with a method dissolution to help the community to find what we meant by cultural heritage. >> okay thanks more later. >> okay any further public comment

seeing none, next item, please. >> item no. 7 is the director's report and i will be belief i just want to let you know we're completed one hover and for jane old position and her name is carl oil she'll be starting next monday. >> congratulations. >> also, we were our office was broechd by the sheriff's department captain extensively pulling son and chief they have a lot of programs really dealing with recidivism for men and not really many for women so they have a women's resource center for women that are coming out of jail to be able to connect into

services and so they want to create a coffee cart as a social entrepreneur program to train women to be bar status so i met with them to kind of talk them through what this may be from a business operational side and so this is kind of an exciting thing for us to be partnering with the sheriff's office to help to get a program that will support those women reentering and getting jobs in the private sector. >> workplace i'll leave my director's report there. >> great. >> so we'll move on to president report. >> i have nothing to report

next item. >> item 9 vice president report. >> on to item 10. >> commissioner reports. >> no one seeing none, move on (laughter). >> okay all right. you got lots of meetings. >> moving on to 0 new business. >> item 11 new bus and seeing none. >> and item 12 is motion a adjourn. >> i motion to adjourn. >> i second it. >> all in favor, say i. all right. the month to month is adjourned at.

>> i want to welcomed everyone today, we have a wonderful set the of speakers i'm sure everyone is incredibly that i have i didn't in their remarks you won't have be here longer a half hour and lunch break with tour 90 wonderful affordable housing for seniors and here to celebrate an unbelievable partnership are the st. anthony's foundation we've had the privilege to partner with them and this was their idea we are that lucky enough to be invited along for the ride it's been a fantastic trip we're happy with the outcome so i'm sure you're aware of the downstairs of this building has

the new st. anthony's dining room and he associate work center and the clothing room in the second-story and on top an air right we are able to build 90 ientsz of affordable housing on floors 8 through 10 all right. that was not one of my applause lines as the case so many people were involved i'm going to do my best to if i for some reason, i leaf our name out we're thrilled for the opportunity the other really special thing will the building we thank you for the opportunity to name after a wonderful champion of so many issues around teenagers and immigrants all of the things i think p make inform so special that is vera haile housing her daughter's are

here we'll hear from them this building is nominated after her that's an applause line all right. (clapping) so again there are a lot of speakers here today, i'm going to start thinning people was we go so i won't tire no one out first st. anthony's (calling names) i hope i didn't screw up too much psa necessary okay. i screwed up but any event this is an opportunity that st. anthony's extended to mercy we got a tremendous relationship in fact we share a board member her somewhere and her husband bryan helped to cement this

relationship and the outlet incredible partnership anyone of this magnitude it is because of partnership are of the public sector you know in san francisco we have a city government that really knows how to get things done narns you'll the complaints when it comes down to affordable housing you can't member of the government like the housing and others i can't see her i want to oh there you are probably the first it champion in this city i think that is a little bit and inspiring when your elected officials are vongz for the housing pea she's an incredible champion and pushing this issue since before she was a supervisor and huge champion and

i give you our champion jane kim (clapping) >> doug failed to mention i come out of the school of doug schumaker i've been well trained well before i came into office to represent this district those are the best days the day's when we get to do the ribbon cutting inform a much needed affordable housing in san francisco i want to give a big round of applause for the mayor faulconer's mercy and st. anthony's for making that possible today (clapping) they have been a lot of events on the site when i started my office it was really great to come to the groundbreaking when barry invited all of us to the st. anthony's new dining room and their services and spaces

but the 90 units of affordable housing here for seniors that was named air force vourgz but we for the buildings to come up that's a lot of impatience i walked up and down the block and couldn't wait for the day it was phenomenal that building is really a part of the changing the future of tenderloin it is anchored with 11 taylor we have the bonding first church and one of the most come 35k9 churches that help people with their sleeping quarters and soon be able to go to the ribbon cutting that is one of the problematic liquids for those of you who wouk up and down the street it

is now closed (laughter) (clapping). >> thank our tenderloin expand it was part of that and it is on valencia with an the problematic liquor store is going to turn into a youth riding i writing program for young people in the neighborhood with dave (clapping) but we're here to talk about vourgz and the housing that is here i have to say a couple of things about vieira i was fortunate to come into office as vieira continued her 20i678 there are many people in that the room that by vieira vieira was that fierce person she came in your office and never situated for the low income and seniors for everyone that needed

a voice she was tireless when i got the news of her passersby i thought i saw vieira advocating yesterday we've had that experience on her last day fighting for the community and she really summed in an interview she did with gary in 2009 it was part of the story core project in the scombuf you get a sense of her spirit and drive for change she said when they talked in her interview why canned things change it's a simple statement but an important one to carry everyday many of us get stuck in reality was is possible and not but vieira was pushing the boulders and in that sentence why can't change it is a question she held

everyday and fought to make sure the answer was yes so i want to congratulate again, the folks that make that possibly doug schumacher and shaurn and barbara were here everyday the project was a reality so thank you (clapping) of course, to barry for the vision with the st. anthony's foundation and board and staff to enlighten more than a dining hall but a place to find employment and access to tech and clothes and nutrition and housing a really full wrap up approach to how to make this neighborhood healthier and stronger and safer (clapping) and i'm sure doug will thank

everyone there is so many folks that made this possible ultimately from the mayor's office of housing i see joyce crumb from human services and dph preponderance of the evidence e helped and mary go thank you to make sure that is a capacity today and i look forward to seeing the units and the residents who is going lives will be transformed on golden state (clapping). >> so it's true there are an unbelievable number of people from the city side marge go and wolfgang are partners not only here by on many projects are huk huge humane partners from the mayor's office of housing i've got a long list ann and olsen

lee and georgia martin and others from the urban housing and i'm sure there are many others thank you for everything you did to make that possible (clapping) so we're officially 10 percent through the program in case you keep a chart at home the 09 great partner for us is the hud as long as hud for many, many years they've been the key partner for producing housing particularly for seniors in some ways a sad waterfront momentum this is the last hud 202 projects in california for

whatever reason they've chopped did funding that provided the subsidies for this beautiful spot so hopefully that will change some day in not we're here to celebrate and we couldn't have done it without you from the team from hud to say more is larry ferguson the production chief our kids go to state and federal school together and a champion of housing. >> (clapping.) thank you doug before i get going i want to say on a perm note i'm very honored and humbled thanks again doug. >> home is where the heart is home is where the heart is iemth going to talk about hud's $13 million in section