bay area air quality with regards to the locations of them we oversee those with regards to where they are the ordinance requests they be upwind and down wind we speak p with lamar and their contractor we agree where they're located. >> is that shift babylon depending on how they are blowing. >> at the don't move they're up wind based on previous data on charge you the winds moves as the project increases are decreases they move up and downed wind they'll move them when you receive a report once a most while they propose on brave

of lamar we receive one of those we are going to receive and discuss that with lamar so that's basically, it for that slow down this is this is the locations of where the monitors are this on candle stick and they're called p m ones for dust p m-1 through 4 or 4 they're up wind and down wind and their locations for the alice griffith again they're located upwind and down wind at the location and they also in addition to asbestos and dust and up if you

can see i don't know if you can see h-3 is by the hearts elementary school an asbestos monitor only because of the concern for sensitive receptors so i think one of the recommendations later on is that we recommend to lamar they have place a monitor dust monitor in that location. >> i actually what one question your monitors does that pickup other things other than asbestos. >> this is based on the size of 10 micro grams of meters two so if it is forebodes as it comes down through it identifies it with a reading. >> did that pickup anything

else around hazardous readings. >> no. >> we're only doing tests for asbestos. >> yes. >> yes. >> with regards to transparency of the air monitoring additional we have on this slow down public has access on the ocii website now and everything is uploaded on a weekly basis we send there it is a home website. >> so there was a concern about grinds on some of the grafts that were produced that the clean air alliance had we want to give a background in reading

the day online the public should know the motors are not a health risk is raise one or two possibility that the diet and time the asbestos were not effected so if we steady that you call lamar and they tell their contractors to think of a different way to spray the site a diet and a time when an vial event unrelated to the jobs happening at once liquor a fog or mist their may be a 10 micro gram motorpoint so again, the cleaner

alliance proposed an additional dust monitor at hearts elementary school we agree so we have discussed this with lamar and in addition we don't recommend they have a dust monitor at one of the avenues but recommend they put in asbestos monitor to address the concerns of the clean air alliance another concern was the third party was to select the third party inspector we do not recommend this because the developer is responsible and there's a liability concern who they includes their environmental community their credentialing with the dissolution and another university based didn't

necessarily have the qualification for work site monitoring worker safety we use an additional ohio. >> the last one is the dust control plan does incorporate best practices. >> for controlling future dust again based on the visible dust the inspectors see that lamar has to take care of that we've provided a letter with responses to they're specific recommendations to the off-duty control plan and now lamar will come up and tell you what changes they plan to make. >> good afternoon my name is

st. is bronson the director of the development i appreciate your time today before i go to the content on the slow down i did want to provide a little bit of background an lamar europeans history and roll on the project lamar has been active under performing construction in the community for over a decade we're familiar with the requirements and regulations on dust control and community concerns and prospective of those issues we have developed strong understanding of the expectations of the different regulatory alleges the community we've been significantly engaged for a long time i've heard mentioned our invested interest being one of money we understand

the only way to succeed on the project is by taking the cautioned necessary the cost of doing things right is a lot less than doing that wrongs so we're implemented p employment to do everything to mitigate dust on our project i said to clarify the purpose of uh our hot lion as well we hover a contractor to - the purpose of our hot lion to respond immediately, the system we have implemented actually converts the voice to text and immediately send overwhelms out to a number 6 people within our organization so that regardless if one individual is on visitation there are other people in the phone tree that can pickup and

talk to the contractor and get immediate action observing if height concerns or significant concerns besides an immediate issue the city has a number of hostile lines for community members to voice ars concerns we've also worked with the city to develop a list of that and provide that to the community that being said there are opportunity for improvement and we appreciate the communities involvement in particular dr. tompkins and shirley moore have been vocal and evaluating those are concerns we've made significant progress in addressing those are concerns and making refinement and additions to the dust control plan and asbestos

admission plans executing we're listening to the community one clear example when we applied for two different types of permit we have a number of news where the community that was clear their preference was noted implosion so ultimate we withdraw that request weren't to the communities position and other hemsz e recommendations provided by others so we're in the process of implementing some of those i'llize those we're currently additionally some of the - in the slide it shows

including additional monitor and rising our dial inspection about the self-righteous at the bottom as well as the things like whether something is directly witnesses or verified directly we're working directly with dpw and our consultants to make sure all our inspections and monitoring reporting is to their satisfaction. >> thank you for that presentation. >> thank you. >> is there any additional public comment no more presentations madam president. >> is there a public comment on the item. >> 3 minutes each for public

comment. >> dr. thompson to him kins i which is prepared to give you 3 minutes i appreciate if you would respect that i'd greatly appreciate that. >> one is mrs. moore stated earlier we want to thank the board to stand up and having staff work with the contingency another institutions in the city has not done this they're missing in action ocii we view them as nothing more than it was novice to learn they're in journalist venture with lamar research working in the interest of the citizens that pay their salaries we don't reap the benefits we want to point out we

want the permit pulled this is a wait of our time we - you have a nice presentation you have wonderful slides the fact is that we've wasted three weeks their tearing that stadium down at the top level right now this morning as i drove in i inspected it myself the fact they've only had we'll talked repeatedly over dust controls i'm not an engineer one gentleman on a crane on the cherry picker spraying over there prior to that before the rain two individuals with a hose and water coming out mrs. moore and other residents on the hill have dust in their house i've driver's license there and their within glasses are coded with one - you have to

look at relatives not another rhetoric lab and i submitted into you earlier a file of their work and somehow or another they were able to get around the combhpt and adding in under four minutes or less 5 or less no where in the reports was it shown improper installation of monitor we had k pi news really looking at this is not crazy old doctors looking at it i'm not senile we asked in the last meeting and one of our officers from the alliance asked the signs we put. you up in chinese characters so

everyone can read that the problem is this is thin if you're driving but we asked that that can put in spanish and the website in an easy read work format for accomodation by the general public comment that didn't have a scientific background i was told this was impossible and argued and holder 59 thank you representatives from health department i taught a class teaching middle rate students audience i respect the fact you have a lot to is and 3 minutes is national enough but i appreciate the note we have other people up to speak thank you doctor. >> i hope you understood we want a pole to enter into a

serious discussion to get those problems revolved. >> thank you>> thank you. next speaker, please. >> 3 minutes. >> i heard you thank you very much this is so important that 3 minutes won't do the job i have material here i brought because this is ongoing and it is for you're reading so you'll understand and know what we have gone through and it hurts me that fact you've given u.s.s. 3 minutes ocii i asked for the minutes when all of this occurred they couldn't give me notes when we were talking about agent orange number one alice griffith was built in 1960 it

was built on landfill the groups have not been tested people have liquidated and dying over there and mothers having stillborn babies the dust and wind when it blows it don't blow one way or two what did you say i live on ingels the only reason they stopped the work i called a friend of mine i don't know if you read his blogs it is francisco all that dust coming into my house i live 3 blocks away interest where they are i go after let me say this to you there is no state and federal compliance officer in the entire

city of san francisco other than the unified school district her guidelines section 3 are not being approved we don't hear anything the hunt that material you have as you can see what occurred back in 2011 between the health department and the other department in co-hostile together is all about money not about our lives out there at bayview hunters point i've been in bishop since 1948 i know the community my mom came in here in 19423 i was 10 yvendz i'm 82 now they don't know the area every time i go to a meeting i brought to you do you think they read it no they

don't care i hope you listen this needs to stop, in fact, the rigor act needs to be enforced in san francisco thank you for your comments. >> yolanda louis again san francisco is become known as as city i can see the eric garden symptom on a daily basis we can't breathe when we say we can't brothel our complaints go ignored when we sigh we can't breathe we're the culture many this city to continue the human rights violations killing the black community and i asked you a question can we breath when this was stated they started doing the mechanic

after the community complained the community asked it was not allowable they tried to sneak one that dr. espanola jackson provided the doctor has experience for decades in this community is not qualified is a joke over the decade we don't see anything around our people dying if you had a dog to send to a boarding place for 90 days would you give them the same conditions you put the black people at hunters point under knowing you had to leave our dog there 90 days with the daily dust inspection report is being monitored mostly and they're looking at previous data to this where the put the monitoring dpiedz but not the one they have

to find they're in progress trying to identify where to put the signages we're almost at the end of the project they're talking about identifying it 31 they have a plan they've been doing planning for that a long time but friends would you let our dog be monitored once a month and knew what was in the air killing other dogs and those dogs were getting asthma and other aunts and uncles dying would you leave our dog there i wouldn't but i see that people are loefg the black people in those inhumane conditions that my parents ran from it and my father lived in a rat invested area in bayview dr. espanola

jackson is 82-year-old she's been fighting for almost three-quarters of a century i'm asking you to please consider us higher than the dogs i pray you do that thank you. >> thank you is there any additional public comment on that item. >> nope no further public comment we'll go to item 7 director's report 7 a. >> right now we've discussed that so we'll after the discussion we can't take action i want to acknowledge that commissioner melgar as stepped up to the plate away. >> commissioner walker please. thank you for coming and presenting about the program thank you to the public for coming and hoping that we hear

you i hear you question that we all need to ask who are given the responsibility of doing those projects needs to think of how we would feel if we lived next door to those projects we don't point taken health issues in blighting especially in hunters point around this sis they occur at a higher rate than any work or where in the city this is not just you know blowing smoke this is real so i feel like even though we're not going to be doing i guess

necessities agendized to take action is it the report? i feel like what i would like to say we need to hear the community and be responsive to the community we need to do more than we that is necessary for the people living around this project i feel like listening to the fact there is dust obviously there is dust everywhere in the city i live havlz street the dust that comes in conveyance questionable materials that's the reign we're out there monitoring the air doing it more frequently than required and more locations than is required i would rather see us doing more

than we need to research less so i appreciate that we've respond by adding asbestos monitor at alice griffith i believe that was what you said i feel like we need to really on a daily based look at this material and look at the way the wind is blowing and to be on top of that this effects people that are living there and i you know this is has this is a huge issue with the whole hunters point shipyard project and now they're tearing down something subsequent there is a lot of parcels in the air we need to do overkill if i can use a phrase rather than what is required so - >> commissioner mar please.

yeah. when this issue came before us a couple ofometers back a lot of us similar to other city departments had to run from it the gut level relaxed because it was very easy to say hey dust go to the hunt or go to you know the air quality control we didn't do that because we understood that this was very big project this was a very controversial project as i recall that had to guess before the board of supervisors everybody jumped in so we felt that with that, i want to say that we were not willing to say pass that on to someone else so i want to thank our staff frail for going out there everyday and camping out there

you know i know deputy lourey we've been camping out there everyday we don't have staff either sorry we don't have enough stand-off to camp out everyday i feel like because that is such a big project and political project because this is take place in an under served community that has taken lots of hits in the past not served well by the city in the past we can't just is we're doing everything we're supposed to do with a construction project it is awkward to deal with it here actually, i feel liquor it should be up at the board of supervisors everyone in this city took a position the

contractor doing it so we don't get off the hock now to say they agreed to all those are things when they got the job the air monitoring you know, i could mention other things liquor local hiring they agreed to a lot of things now it is up to the city to say yes. you can do this thing to make sure they can do it i feel like dbi can do our thing but this is a bigger again, it is a city problem because you know our local government low love of us feel liquor gee do we have to you know why does dbi have to be the enforceers here everyone else said they can deal with

that sorry you don't have enough staff deal with that anyway i feel like a big project the contractors agreed to a lot of things now you have to do the work, yes maybe there's a lot of people watching this project that's what you signed up for this is a big project so you've got to make sure those monitors you can't send in inu unsigned report or partial reports you can't send in - meetings where you don't know where you are this goes to all departments not just dbi all departments in the city are responsible the contractors are responsible we're all responsibly so i think we have to step it up a little bit i i know we can't take action today but i know the community

has been waiting a long time for someone to deal with this we can't keep on psa it not someone else i'm very concerned about that i wanted to say that. >> commissioner please. as i've listened to the reports i want to thank you all for coming in we had it in the packet who this is where the community is bringing to us who's going to take responsibility? for doing what we said we are going to do we're in a situation today by all of us being here that clearly indicates something is not being done right everyone is saying we don't have enough staff but the sister is sayi