does keep track of the discipline imposed by the chief but not in the same in our case not in the same manner that chief suhr would he has a greater database confusing internal violations we only have the occ that is in compliance. >> okay commissioner turman. >> my question is probably more to the chief chief i keep seeing inover and over the need not of the duty for the traffic status i understand we're not seeing repeat of those one the first time and the astonishment and

retrain i'm not taking issue what was the last time we sent out the quarter in saying how important this data is it is done. >> so every bulletin is put out every two years i'm happy if you want me to put a bulletin out. >> i think because the keeps seeing themselves reoccur on the broader i think a adjourn reminder and i have to put it in prospective we wrote hundred and 29 thousand tickets last year so you've heard the tickets where we didn't do the 5 data it was not hundred and 29 astonishment you probably i mean the exception rather than the rule director hicks will agree we've

gone through thirty this progressive mode the data is far less than it used to be that's correct i applauded u applaud the department but it is it is the one you need it didn't report on just to see we've done the things to do to everyone i'm going saying i'll faulting the department. >> ib9 to put out a reminder. >> and one more director to follow up on that. >> yes. commissioner turman open that thought hundreds of thousands of citations the occ is only investigating a very small universe event last year, we only received 7 hundred complaints and so we had the

numbers off the top of my head but a smaller universe was where we found this neglect of the duties for the traffic data so we depends on what happens with the other hundred thousand citations. >> we just without violating the privacy right can you give us a little bit more information on the officer engaged in inappropriate language can you tell us about that. >> i don't have that information at this time. >> thank you. >> one follow-up on the 2425 data my understanding is that the way we find out if an officer didn't collect the e 585 day on the race data for traffic

stop a complaint went to appendixes is there something the department can do a pro-active approach for the data. >> the supervisors are responsible to make sure the e 85 data is entered that's why we're working in this year's budget to get the e citations it takes the officers imputing the data it will be automatically uploaded so again, i want to put the reminder out i can ask the supervisors to do. >> like an audit. >> random audit. >> sure and give us a sense of that data proactively. >> any other questions for director hicks anything further director hicks. >> no commissioner president loftus not this evening. >> thank you, thank you, very

much. >> line item 4 c the commission report and president's report. >> colleagues, i will cover what's been covered we had an incredible first cip ceremony i wish all the commissioners that started dr. joe when you initially went to the cip resolution this was a moment the commissioner mazzucco was there and commissioner hwang and commissioner melara that was great to lift up those 9 heros they've got families there and you know there was not a dry eye in the place the idea those are stories that are happening everyday and don't get told that often i think that was extraordinary that was reward

and allocated funds for beautiful plaques for the officers tument the mental health and communicated partners this is not a law enforcement program it a community program and the level of respect and partnership that went both that font event it was an incredible moment for me as a commissioner to watch it unfold and see how much people care about this community and watch them partner to make things safer it was awesome to use a word i don't often use poor may i ask something about that. >> of course, >> i wasn't there and just going into the format for the lack of someone that read citations so you know,

i think something that happens to be good, i got permission and tom knows about someone some of this is activated i hope we can get this activated especially, if we want to showcase the cip. >> that is a very good idea. >> that will be great. >> do you think that someone can get on your shoulders. >> sure that's a great idea i know that commissioner mazzucco and commissioner hwang we'll bring that idea back i want to point out we were trained i went with the new retired deputy the national train and one of the things that is of the place a last pinnacle you have a have an awards ceremony and one of the things what is critical to the

cip program nurturing by leadership tremendous gratitude to the chief and the commander and lieutenant melena he's so well respected by the cops and the community he's such a good guy and been an credible choice the fact the program has done well, the nurturing by the lip reads leaders of this department i'll say the academy class to be they're getting younger but an impressive group their credentials and background they get awards and i was very impressed we have high expectations for them the president of the class was a young woman who talked about the they're the rejection generation of the 21st century policing and

gave a remarkable speaking speech that's my report. >> commissioner mazzucco. >> thank you commissioner president loftus and other commissioners from the cip when this started several years ago it was concept was brought to us that hopefully save lives and people have to warmup up to a lot of the police officers were doing it and had train actuality we heard about 9 lives that were saved 9 lives not extraordinarily been saved if they involved another path the officers were to produce i want to thank katie tang we serve on the commission to try to make things better i heard 9 lives saved that's an accomplishment

for the police officers thank you all and commissioner katie tang and again, it is incredible and the academy class do they have driver's license but it was incredibly diverse and well educated class and so we welcome them into the path of the members of the san francisco finest and commissioner loftus thank you for knowing one of them since they're a baby san francisco has to be proud we need more on the streets it was a great ceremony. >> any other commissioner reports. >> okay hearing inspector call the next line item. >> commissioner announcements and identification for consideration and further commissioner meetings action. >> there's one item colleagues i found a resolution from

january 2011 that laid out the priorities for this commission in the 3 tiered system color coded with interesting but not current so i think we need to revisit that resolution and give you the number we can revisit is it some of the things we've made a lot of progress but some other areas are lacking we need to address i want to calendar that and commissioner melara. >> remind us to (inaudible) domestic violence approach for i said to make sure (inaudible). >> uh-huh. >> and the other was (inaudible). >> uh-huh. >> to complete the racial

profile data. >> i have that we tried to research a request on residents and non-residents and that data is not available our computers is unvariables to or available to get that but now i've mating made it a point to get the information. >> commissioner turman. >> i'd like to calendar for the next available meeting a discussion and action item to consider ca a change to the commissions monthly schedule. >> okay. we can take that up in june great anything further commissioner and we're going to have a report back on the department of appendixes on the departments sort of performance or compliance with the 21st century leasing report. >> yes. that's on the docket

only a matter of scheduling. >> okay hearing nothing further let's get to public comment. well. >> hello sf i sit here and here hear you talk about the crip and this is a mthd by sometimes i don't don't know if you're black or gay why people hate you there's no help for us because one over rules to leave you out but i was 54 and martin luther

king and malcolm x died and 39 we've enjoyed on the i want to say last year, he fell and broke at 4 and howard street but it made it better i can carry many pie pocket the bold head i understand this year there's a republican president candidates between 5th and 6th and howard that's a good thing on howard but mainly as i age that is my last year of living here i'm very concerned about how that myself you're not protected in this city you know, i look at how my gay rights protected my black rights not a criminal or a

drug advocate a marijuana advocate n 15 years ago when bush was the president we have 25 states i hear you talk about the k ti i know that has to do with mental health and officers we know that this is our buildings in san francisco this tenderloin neighborhood why i feel that people pushing and you become part of the sxhoir scenario you try to be positive it not enough given to those persons that show up at the commissions you know around in the city creating havoc but we have to be killed by someone i think about the little boy this was killed someone the world is no the good place what can i do i read the last chapter of the bicycle howe i biblical we have

a time when i think it is time to take the people that don't throw things and put them on the other hand, up not in our town or schools not in our cities i know i'm a person that show have been through enough and shouldn't die thank you. >> any further. >> oh, here. >> any further comment. >> no i mean, i'll get it leave it. >> hearing that being said inspectors north next line item. >> as a reminder before the commissioners next wednesday will be dark no meeting next wednesday. >> dark no meeting thank you inspector. >> line item 5 election of commission officers action. >> colleagues this is a

requirement of our the commission we do american people election of officers in may for a number of scheduling issues we've had challenges meeting this deadline we didn't elect officers in september but this is the charge in may so i note there are a couple of folks president to be recognized commissioner melara. >> i'd like to nominate commissioner president loftus for president. >> of the commission. >> okay i second that. >> okay and there's a second and i see commissioner dejesus. >> i'd like to nominate vice president commissioner turman and i'll second that. >> inspector monroe do we have a two motions need to take them

one at a point any discussion by commissioner melara? okay. and ma'am city attorney we need to take public comment before we vote >> yes. that's correct. >> calls for the other nominations. >> oh, yes let's do that i have two on the floor give me your advice how to do that extinguishing one motion at a point or public comment and go to public comment. >> probably take public comment and provide the neemgsz are complete. >> any other nominations there nominations in the nomination are closed now public comment on line item number 45 well. >> jew i didn't. >> hi, i'm larry my birthday i

nominee i staples to pledge for the nomination of that president of the commission and vice president both president and vice president you've been around for a while i think the first was the police commission in the midst we were talking about t n d c and the violence i've been here for a willie awhile but i'll share a good police story i do karaoke i saw a plo policeman and in the song that is called loving you is wrong i don't want to be right. >> right. >> that's my first acceptance of a police besides military was it the military but it was a policeman in 1970 to the idea he

give me and my sister it was a father that made me appreciate policemen i know who you are and where your service and what i responsibility to the world and the community so i definitely want to nominate the president who is here and the vice president as the commissioners and vice chair of the san francisco police commission thank you and i even met the guy in oakland that is in baltimore i met him in oakland that officer so i get around. >> thank you jew i didn't so any other public comment public comment is closed. so let's go to the first motion

by sandra let's take a vote inspector monroe. >> the first nominated by commissioner president loftus and second by commissioner dejesus a roll call vote commissioner turman commissioner marshall commissioner dejesus commissioner mazzucco commissioner hwang commissioner melara that motion passes unanimously. >> okay. so let's take the second motion.

>> second motion was made by commissioner dejesus and nominated commissioner turman for the re-election and seconded by the commissioner melara. >> any discussion before we go into the vote. >> commissioner president loftus commissioner marshall i'm glad you a modest that back in time to vote on that it would be hard to vote if you weren't here (laughter) commissioner dejesus commissioner mazzucco commissioner hwang. >> commissioner melara that motion also passed

unanimously (clapping) i will thank you all for that kind support i will say i'm got tremendous reporter phenomenon the commission and each the colleagues that means a lot to have your support it is an important time for the department of we've working hard and much more ahead for us i'm grateful to work with each of you thank you for your support. >> well, man of many words thank you so much. >> i'm glad to be back on the commission we've got a lot of hard work and i'm ready to keep business i hope you are inspection next

public comment all matters pertaining to in the closed session including the voting on 8 in closed session. >> ladies and gentlemen, we're going to go into closed session on matters that happen outside of the public is there any public comment on matters property owner i'm sorry, i need a vote. >> no. >> second. >> it is public comment. >> oh, sorry city attorney i got excited. >> hi, i'm larry edmond i like to be called juicy and type in jew i didn't from the dating date we elected obama. >> our climb maybe steep

america has not been more hopefully, we'll get there i promise i as a people we'll get there by we can't having a thrilling wall street awhile main street suffers of those americans those support i may have north yet to earn he need our help you will be your president too we prove that the true strength of our nation comes not from a might of arms are scale of wealth but from the unadmires i disturbance of poverty we came together as democrats. >> if you have anything to share about the- >> i have 3 minutes so it is regarding changes. >> you've got to tie it into

closed session. >> we're going to tie it to closed session because as president he wrapped up united states up by the right hand that's ta that don't thing about living in america our job to be the beacon and send around the world what is going on with the black man getting killed in america. >> this has nothing to do with inform closed session. >> i'll be they bay area i know that the officers bay to bay breakers my birthday celebration he hope you get ready for million dollars. >> thank you juicy and happy birthday on friday public comment is closed. intersection. >> line item 7 vote

on whether to hold the closed session on the administration section action. >> do have i have motion to go both into closed session. >> all in favor, say i. >> motion passes we're in closed session