you're aware of is the policy of the city not to result in increased property tax so existing bops are being redeemed no net increase in property tax on the bottom of page 6 according to the information by the sfmta and dph the 20 two departments use two different numbers san francisco municipal transportation agency rates charge the capitalized projects over 50 percent and not the 1/3rd shown in the report as compared to the rates charged by dph so we've connected table 5 on the page showing the difference direct and indirect charges for the two positions 5502 project manager and 4203 assistant engineer as shown in table 5 sf is hundred and 57

thousand plus we show 34 percent is 59 percent higher and sfmta labor rates for the engineer is hundred and 33 thousand plus and again, the 35 percent should be 53.8 percent to use it new york no sense we make a recommendation to ask the controller to look at the mta's direct and indirect labor rates and make the elements prior to 9 next issuance of the transportation bonds anticipated in may 2016 we believe that is good legislation we recommend all of the two resolutions be approved. >> thank you to the mta any questions or comments on the

reserve and the recommendation of mr. rose's. >> on behalf of mta no comments. >> okay thanks very much supervisor tang. >> sorry to add on to harvey's recommendations to items 11 12 and 13 if mta can provide clarity between the difference of public works and mta is calculating. >> sure we is have the office of public finance to address you on the body as well warmed up to the rates we have third party entities that develops our cost plan as development by the state and federal fund participates it's been approved by federal and state and the cal bonds aside from the fact that the difference in the complexity

between the agencies the diversity of fund sources as well as the requirement that we have a much higher percentage of the funds that come from federal, state, and local and public works does we welcome the controller's office evaluation we can find to reduce our off head we'll certainly love to do that i focused that on when i was at the public works to be as lean as we need to be there's a lot of complexity and hoops we need to jump through to spend the requests and spend and report on the various funding streams that's part of what might be driving the difference we're thankful for the suggestion and welcome anything that the controller's office can provide in ways to improve. >> i'll look forward to following up with the controller's office and i know that director reiskin you have the unique situation you've been

in would agencies so i know you have that experience how you do things in public works now in mta but moving forward we would like to get more clarity. >> okay. colleagues any more questions or comments. >> open up for public comment any public comment on this item? items 9, 10, 11 12 or 13. >> hello, i'm with the controller's office of public financing i want to speak briefly to some of the perimeter and items number 12 and 13 and also explain briefly some administrative changes to the resolution as the budget analyst presented the anticipated debt services on the bonds is that anticipated to be $4.5 million annually and

expected $3 per hundred dollars of the assessed evaluation at the doebt ratio will increase by .03 percent as the evaluations at 6 percent well within the 3 percent legal debt limit issuance of the bonds will be consistent with the capital policy committee and not raise property taxes of point 01 cents per assessed value item 13 is the first resolution before you it authorizes the issuance of an in the amount of not to exceed consistent with the 2014 prop a that was proved on november nourth 2013 and item 12 authorizes and directs the sale of the bond within the

$500 million not to exceed $47 million plus resolution also is just want with the administrations including the official notice of sale and the intention to sell bonds and the official assessment relate to the official sale of bonds and purchasing of certificates the deadlines for the reports precedes have not been spent they're no precedes expenditures to report on and it grants the authorities to have the issuance of the sale of the bond just quickly present the text changes that were made we're submitting them they're made in collaboration with the office of the city clerk in order to address some of the concerns and their exceptions going forward for bond transportation

authority plans & programs committee transaction they're not specific only general administrative language on the item number 13 the ordinance of 5 hedge fund million dollars resolution the language changes applies to the rat rationing indication section and second 18 just insuring that the documents and the city staffs action will be consistent with the resolution in the documents presented before the board also in the resolution authorizing the directing of the sale of the bonds did changes include similar changes to the ratification section and regret or reflect the requirement to submit espoused documents once the documents are completed to the board available for public record. >> if you have any questions

i'll be happy to answer any questions i believe mta staff is here for the specific. >> thank you sorry for almost skipping you colleagues, any questions thank you, very much open up for public comment any public comment on item items 9 through 13 at all seeing none, public comment is closed so colleagues let's take those items one by one and tweaks so item number 9 we have a recommendation from the budget analyst to place certain amazes in receive as speeded any questions or comments i'd like to taper a motion to accept those and move the loma forward as amended. >> so moved with with a positive recommendation to the full board. >> motion by commissioner tang and seconded by commissioner eric mar we'll take that without objection. and item number ten if we did simply move that item

forward with a positive recommendation. >> i move item 10 forward with a positive recommendation. >> commissioner tang we'll take that without objection. >> eaten on items 11 through 13 first of all like to accept the b l a recommendation attached to item 11 to the budget analyst premths recommendation to ask mta to look at the methodology for the items if we could approve the underlying item. >> i make a motion and send it to the phone number with with a positive recommendation. >> we'll take that without objection. >> items 12 and 13 the technical amendments as prepared by the office of vaps and so our city attorney those are technical don't have to be held.

>> john gibner, deputy city attorney that's right pass them out today. >> let's take a motion. >> and i move with a positive recommendation as amended. >> okay. perfect we have that motion pie commissioner vice president mar open items 12 and 13 1ekd by commissioner tang and we'll with a positive recommendation item 14 is a special order for 514 to hear the budget priorities for the next two fiscal years we'll do for about an hour and a half >> okay. good afternoon everyone welcome back to out of recess from our regularly scheduled budget & finance committee for wednesday, may 20, 2015, madam clerk call item 14 hearing on the youth priorities

for fiscal years 2014 and 2016-2017 and requesting the youth commission to report. >> okay. thank you madam clerk this is a tradition we have at the budget committee to hear from the youth commission i want to thank the commissions to literally i didn't this is my appointee and thank you lilly for your harry reid hard work and looking forward to hearing our priorities and work with the- whoever wants to come on and start the examination all right. thank you for having us here this good afternoon good afternoon. i'm micro leigh mayoral appointees on the second year on the commission i'm a seminar the lowell high school this is a productive year we've worked on the methods from

writing resolutions to writing and hosting public hearing for the media and after much hard work the residents and meetings and conducting emphatic research we've got priorities committee and commission wide we believe implementation of those 13 priorities particularly is important for the equality and access for the youth san francisco is unique and a diverse place we used to grew up and live in and we hope to continue with the stablth we thank you thank you for your time and consideration in establishing san francisco as a leader for social economic and democratic opportunities without further ado i'd like to welcome commissioner cardenas that will be starting us off.

>> that's correct i'm josh thank you for choosing me good afternoon supervisors. thank you for inviting us yesterday and i'm the representative for the youth commission and begin with the first priority lauren san francisco for age in san francisco we believe that robust broader unfortunately united states has terrible rates and choose san francisco last year was our worst voter turnout and in california tennis world war ii we have protecting families as economics and the challenges that require young people's leadership to solve the city's problems that is crucial we have

all hands on deck to have the youth develop their leadership and january of 2015 the youth commission urges the extension of voting rights this is central in those school elections built upon on previous resolutions by the board of supervisors and 2005 the board of supervisors supported the legislation 92 to allow each county to decide whether to lower the voting angle to 16 also supervisors march 2015 introduced a charter amendment to the legal voting since the lower age to 16 sponsored by supervisor avalos and supervisor kim and supervisor mar and supervisor campos were co-sponsors we often know this issue

triggers great skepticism and because of that adopted as viewed as a second look issue because of our research we found that it make sense and there is a compelling justification to lower the voting age and found this is a great investment so voting habitual and suggests that someone casts they're first vote the more they'll become a lifelong voter and to cast the first vote young folks are looking to go to college it is not a priority to vote but their stationary and allows them to cast their first vote we know that when young people are given the chance to vote oftentimes a

high number of voters for 18 and older and young people are able to engage in the local process to make responsible voting decisions and understand politics from - we found it 44 percent of young people voted differently from their parents so we do know that we can cast independent and informed votes and also know that central voting increases the turnout as well as the parents and 16 and older and at age 16 they hold significance in society when adults have responsibilities working hours they pay taxes and allowed to drive and take cola's in civics and government and

currently central voting this underway in asa trail germany united kingdom and chicago primers we absolutely know that i don't know sfonz san franciscan are ready to demonstrate their leadership san francisco has a rich history of youth tell him as has been crucial to policymaking we also know from the current elections this is cost effective and with the current allocations of capacity they could prepare special ballets for 16-year-old voters and this is also sparked a national statewide conversation currently our state representative senator mark leno introduced an amendment to lower

the angle for elections we know that san francisco has the opportunity to build on innovation and for the voter turnout by being the first major city to lower the voting age to 16 we urge this afternoon that the board of supervisors lower the voting age for municipal and school district elections to age 16 and also i'd like to note that the other priorities will not tag as long as that one i'm introducing joyce for the second priority. >> hello supervisors i'm joyce sue the district 7 precedent i sit on the immigration committee i'm going to talk about amendment number 2 for the san francisco dock recipients in san francisco there are thirty

thousand undocumented cabinet 5 thousand between 18 and 24 in 2013 president obama mentioned the child docking a in 2014 obama expanded docking a for preferred action under the new plan the recipients will renew their status every 3 years instead of 2 and immigrants that entered the u.s. between january 2010 that has one child that is a citizen or has a green card can stay in the united states although those two programs are not - the needs to have the costs open the immigrant is is placing a significant barrier on docket immigrants 35 percent of under hundred percent of the

poverty level those barriers were made clear at a meeting we held with supervisor breed's office we encourage the board one to support the additional fund and grant to sf dock a mranlts two expand the number of seats on the dream sf fellowship program and pass the mayors $10 million total fund over two years to sf dock a community we commend mayor ed lee and are particularly excited about the peace in which he's provided fund for the resolution for the youth commission passed in january while the new and expanded docket and depositing a programs are temporarily held up in state court we looking forward to

working with you guys and the mayors once the recreations are settled with that said i'll pass it on to sxhurgs chin. >> i'm the appointed district youth commissioner thank you for having us priority new 3 is to really have an open space cadet analysis on the park space this issue was brought up to the youth commission buying due to the playground of incident that happened many community members came out and go spoke about the issue of admission playground during the recreation parks recession meeting people were concerned on field recession and improvement no language and

better lighting the commission was able to get those improvements because the general manager heard the compliments we want to see the improvements in all the parks in san francisco not only mission playground not only for the meeting in the service hearing on the chancellors bill of rights the youth commissioners and many youth came out and spoke about the concerns of the parks in the city and the need for paperwork safety like extending lighting hours and many more which is why we recommend the mayor and the board of supervisors to urge the creation of american people open space cadet analysis things this should included safety and staffing needs and ability for youth to assess the park and numbers of youth in needs of

skouch and people of color and protecting famed and in responding english speaking recipe and residents we urge the board of supervisors to consider the children's bill of rights hearing 3 includes park safety and keen access and extended lighting housing thank you for listening i'd like to have commissioner to talk about priority number 4. >> thank you commissioner chin number 4 is make sure to the police officers are trained to deal with young people that is over the past 5 years and you commissioners have worked with the police department to improve the joint- in march envelope

this year we saw the approval the sfpd memorandum of understanding that understands and clarifies the role of police officers on campuses we continue to work with the police department to work on a competitive train this is knows and have a deems scheduled with chief suhr on may 29th next week our recommendations are the following we call upon the mayor and the board of supervisors to implement this now new hearing with the train for that 0 a priority for sergeants and police officers for the police tactics unique to juvenile it should offer the best practices awhile working with youth grounded in the psychiatrist and tops that should be included have 'coz active development and

recognizing and tracking the traumatized youth with the color and the training should include the strategies for a asserting authority with youth and incorporates scenarios of real life training and components and offer offers an opportunity to practice the new skills thank you. i'll introduce vice chair for the fifth priority. >> hello supervisors i'm certifying have a vice chair of the youth commission and on the commission justice commission i'll be present an analysis of the outcomes of the renewable for the child services after the domestic violence advocates the police commission passed a all that calls for domestic violence calls there was one component

for families and children situations and this section was highlighted as a concern to the youth commission and concerns stems from whether this is the best system of care for youths imposed to trauma and effects on the families of color with that background i'd like to move into the recommendations first of all, urge the board of supervisors and the mayor memorandum of understanding for the police departments to assess the pd refers including age and rates he can, and, secondly recommend to so how the policy is effectively youth and families and lastly recommendation the collaboration for the referrals and lastly i'd like to thank the police commission for scheduling did review since october when this legislation was passed

now i'd like to ta pass to an to commissioner lee for priority number 6. >> good afternoon again. >> priority number 6 revolves around prop c with a timely implementation of the children and family oversight committee and our children and families throughout 2014 the youth commission faflthd community conversation including folks groups and stakeholders meeting and reauthorizations of the children's fund some conversations we heard were the inclusion of pay and the there in the funded and better corporation between schools and provider and increasing the voices those asks were incorporated into prop c that passed with 73 percent of the vote this charter amendment called for the

establishment of 2 oversight the children our funds citywide that's the c y committee and also the o act the ssi that oversees dcwf the board of supervisors passed the o act with 3 seats and two will be recommended to the mayor and awning update our outreach application are sole practitioner 80 is closed we've received 5 strong applications and will be preceding soon the council legislation passed with 3 of the 4 seats that were recommend thou for your voices on those governor jerry brown bodies as for recommendation we want to urge the inclusion and look forward to supporting the youth serving and we urge the knowledge appointment of those

seats to we can begin the operations on the government body and thank you for your time and consideration and i'd like to pass it back to vice chair. >> hello, again so i'm present priority 7 to promote and maintain family unit thank you in 2010 that was calculated 7 by 7 thousand plus children's that had parents courtyard in san francisco last year the youth justice committee worked with the organization for children of incarcerated parents and throughout last year we put together the needs that of heard no june of 2014 and the board of supervisors neighborhood services and safety committee in fall of this year the police commission released the training video for rest of the praept that involves the process that was a great step forward and we

worked with the chair on the postal service that aid and maintain the children while the parents are in jail the commission are recommending and urging the sheriff's that he lower the age in county jail awhile maintaining contact the sheriff has committed to this policy and will present a draft at our first meeting, and, secondly, an online location our currently, the state prison system has locate oversees and lastly to look at ways to provide better consumption for incarcerated parent to present to their parent in state prison i'd like to pass it on to commissioner wu for number 8. >> hello