like in the reverse the issue became political from law and the rule of law so at that jufrn it is your where we stay and whatever the state decides in 2016 will set a base i'm equally attorney to support or novelist support the consistency and the banner high or basically saying the tools we used to have are coming into a shadow of multiple expectations which don't give me clear guidance anymore. >> i'll echo a number of comments that have been made the larger land use challenge the chagrining challenge of cluster and we've been asking the board to look at legislation to increase the number of places that mcd can go so there is not

cluster what happened what the higher bar the cu we've taken outline alu the sunset out of that eviction the legislation thas has to come to the prevention i'm not sure i'll support the legislation we're under the cu day deceased can you especially the fact that the staff recommended did disapproval and the criteria that commissioner richards read around bring the measuresable boar i don't know that is met or proven i ago that the sunset will need to figure out how to deal with that in 2016. >> move to disapprove. >> second. >> second. >> there is a motion and a second to disapprove that project on that 0 motion commissioner antonini. >> commissioner hillis

commissioner johnson commissioner moore commissioner richards commissioner wu so moved, commissioners, that motion passes unanimously 6 to zero and places you on public comment no speaker card audience new general public comment seeing none meeting @p

>> we love our parks, but we love... >> and the community who is really the core of it all, came together and said what we need is a place for our teenager to play, not just play grounds for the kids and soccer fields but we need a skate park that will keep the kids home in the neighborhood so they can play where they live. >> the children in the neighborhood and it will be a major boone. and we have generations, the youth generations that will be able to use this park in different places. >> the best park in san francisco right here. >> creating place where people can be active and lead active,

healthy life styles that are going to just stay with them for life. ♪ the

meeting to order attends to interfere with the equipment in the room and we're waiting for television actually okay can we all rise for the pledge of allegiance

and to the republic for which it stands, one nation under god, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all may want environmental impact report. >> please do you ms. hermann commissioner turman commissioner marshall commissioner dejesus is no route commissioner mazzucco commissioner hwang commissioner melara we have quorum commissioner president loftus and with us is the archive executive officer and the director the office of complaints director hicks. >> well, to the wednesday, may 13, 2015 police commission to everyone watching at home we'll keep up items on the agenda first, i understand that inspector monroe we're going to take off the presentation felt certificate to mr. lamp.

>> correct and take off calendar within section 4b the ocii director's report and the ocii outreach and the ocii confer safer those are legitimate i didn't reports the ocii has spent a lot of time and there were issues we didn't have enough time to review them any issues inspector monroe. >> no. >> questions colleagues? okay inspection consent calendar received a final action important the portfolio quarterly report first convert 2015 requester to the chief it accept a donation to request a victim get the money in response to a beating >> have a letter from mr.

robert additionally issues commending the chief for his handling and feeling positive about the chief you needing noted a homeless man almost killed and wanted to provide a dpoomsz to the victim any questions for the chief financial officer. >> no, we appreciate the convenient rot. >> new questions on this colleagues do you have a motion. >> so moved and second. >> all in favor, say i. > opposed? motion passes amazing and also want to thank mr. evans for the donation and also for expressing your violative and the portfolio report any questions pop that matter inform

90 for the director okay. a motion. >> commissioner turman. >> without voigt privacy of privacy can i know the substance why the request was denied by the department? >> yes. commissioner turman and members of the commission this has to do with ociis access to p psa police service aids and in the past were provided access to them and legal opinion was issued denying us assess

wear having further conversations about that and because often complainant don't know whether they've had an interaction with a police ever the psa and in order to help them identify who it is we do photo lineup but without those photos we're not able to do that so when it is not an officer then what we would do is refer the complaint back to the police department because in internal affairs investigates the city complaints against non-sworn not only were we denied access to photos but denied access to the list of psas by station and so

we have things to work out and we don't agree with the legal opinion however, it has to be with the labor code so we're trying to work this out there's a provision of the labor code that is being applied so the opinion came from the departmentsattorney and but it also it is being concurred with - i shouldn't say it is concurred we're still looking at it with our attorney they're often in the city attorney's office, however, and that is

attributable for us it sets aside a practice that we've having had for many years and not and perhaps the labor code provision is determined but certainly makes things less transcript and it frustrates the complainants ability to have the complainants complaint heard so. >> is that an issue of first impression have we dealt with this before it is a frustrating practice in the past is it feasible. >> yes. well - new dating back to november. >> if i could the police officers picture the names are provided by the psas are not

sworn their civilians if there's a complaint that request for all psa pictures and names so the union weighed in because they're represented by a different group and that's where the conversations is. >> and curling the city attorney's office office the representatives of ocii occ and the attorneys is advising to weigh in on this. >> go ahead. >> yes. thou chief suhr. >> the police commission and the police chief shared and that attorney opined the labor code is determined there's a labor code provision and . >> sore which code provision and attorney franco in the audience maybe she can approach - with

the permission of the chair. >> president and, of course. >> welcome ms. franco. >> occ i'm sorry may having i have the question to. >> the provision of the labor code. >> i don't have it by memory there is a labor code that identifying the employees of another department the director said do city attorney is weighing in and vesting that absorb we can be clear about what was allowed or not allowed the trick for us if if in the past we've received we had received this information so had is a slightly new situation but it is a good time as any to get st. it clarified. >> and commissioner turman if i might i mean at ms. franco it is

the interpretation of the employer what the city attorney has o pined an employer is each department of the city and so what it labor code prohibit is one employer providing another employer affirmative. >> i know the section now. >> okay it is interesting interpretation of the labor code but okay. thank you very much >> okay. do i have a motion to file the quarterly report. >> second. >> all in favor, say i. opposed? motion passes unanimously >> line item 3 public comment the public comment can address the commission not with the

agenda for today is the people shall address the commission as a whole no commissioners are to respond to the public but may i provide a comment, however they shall rerefrain from the conversations with the public limit your conversations to 3 minutes. >> unbelievable. >> welcome. >> i see the commander maddox he's no traffic and i brought it up i heard last night a interview with the director of salt lake city on traffic they have a great program wide sidewalks and two traffic lights one for the bikes and one for

the cars i licensed to that and said that is brilliant i'll make a left to right turn and the bikes go first, the cars go second i listened to them and call in to k go and told commander maddox she said i didn't think about that i said call salt lake city i hope she does on to other issues 20 homicides year to date and oakland has thirty and new york 313 and la hundred and 41 not bad commander bradenton said i'll make it 2 hundred homicides next year you go bay boy you go boy a

lot of good things are going on i know sometimes negative things go on but i'm connected to a lot of people on the social network i'll be can defended we'll text each other and talk about everything and there's a lot of things right now which ms. hicks i didn't see a breakdown of containment from the black community clyde you know you can't direct conversations to anyone. >> what. >> you can't direct our conversations. >> i haven't seen a complaint from a black or white community or latino it's been utilized to me in the victimized we're living in right now it would show i i don't think are go the black community makes a lot of

complaints. >> you can provide a brief response. >> yes. president and members of the commission in response to the commissioner mazzucco. >> commissioner president loftus and members the commission a breakdown of rates and ethnics in the appendix to the appendixes annual report it is on our the occ website and african-americans were 26 percent of occ complainant in 2014 and all matters listed under the consent agenda are considered to be routine by the members of city council were 27 percent 26 percent declined to state their race and asian-americans were 6 percent even though i can't give

my annual report tonight because of deliveries at least i can talk about this and 11 percent were latino and 2 percent were native-american islanders. >> welcome. >> okay. >> next speaker. >> any further public comment good evening jessie welcome. >> yes. i was the african-american i want to add this is my overwhelm i want the people to know 445 sf w p at.org the code is 19 61 to 2014 you can get in there and get the e-mails and see the pictures i want to thank the prosecutors

stand for that i have pledges i'll try to it to mexico brenda and jerry, jose and harry williams and others i'll take that pledge to stand up you up to all forms of hated and bigotry i'll not tolerant those with the other factors i'll work with my neighbors to create safe and more inclusive communities for all that's what the police do something i want went to you guys i want more people and citizens to get involved i saw the black goois guy was cutup at

the laundromat so a lot of things get recorded liquor when i found this noose in my room i want you to see that i didn't if i was black are gay i can't why they put it on the close it's throw out filled if the castro and my red michael jackson toy but this noose was on the tie rack in the hotel by the mason i'm political i'm always here and city hall i have to stand up for your rights i think we are political all our lives get political i don't know anyone that is not political so i want let you know it is time

we really have more community involvement policing a greater society and g l is not night indoors. >> landlord are fox you you know we have things the champions sometimes works and sometimes doesn't work and thank you. i want to be safe on my birthday. >> excuse me. is today, our birthday. >> friday may 15 and so it's your birthday coming up on behalf of this commission happen birthday. >> and next friday is other persons birthday. >> thank you juicy and welcome i'm john is there speaker cards for this commission.

>> no. >> thought i'd ask at a community meeting plea of of safe came to we were talking about parking in our neighborhood it is important i dealt with parking for a number of years and put together a study for the neighborhood to put in the parking and deal with the planning for the roads and everywhere else and muni and here comes in the last two years we've taken out parking on turk and now taking out parking on the 2 hundred block of eddy i have a problem all the surface parking lot in the tenderloin that are curling in existence right now are being utilized for parking but they also have plans to be built on and so where are all the cars

going to go we have one millions people in san francisco and most of the jobs are downtown if e you keep on taking away the parking spaces the police department has the jurisdiction over the parking lots by the way, yes, they do i know i don't know if you know that i have concerned about the displacement and here an employee of safe an entity of kind of mixed up with the police department and so on and so forth telling us how to take away our parking i don't like that and one of the things when i was in the neighborhood my visitors wouldn't come because they can't find parking this is a concern i moved out of the