t's not fair to make money by throwing people into the street like dogs and stepping all over them. >> (speaking foreign language.) >> and turn and look at me, i'm very angry. >> (speaking foreign language.) >> there are 10 of you but we are the people. >> (speaking foreign language.) >> if i have to come here hundred and 2 hundred times i'll do so i'll be back until i fix this situation. >> (speaking foreign language.) >> a question for a boat to be able to sail it has to have a caption. >> (speaking foreign language.) >> where is the mayor ed lee (clapping) >> (speaking foreign language.) >> today know why he's not

here. >> (speaking foreign language.) >> you have the empty lalz halls to come here to face the problem he himself has created. >> (speaking foreign language.) >> you know what i'm going to call ed lee the corrupt he sold-out to money (clapping) >> (speaking foreign language.) >> supervisors you don't want to play fair if you want to be taken away and tomorrow. >> (speaking foreign language.) >> money isn't everything first do things right and do them well, thank you (clapping.) thank you. >> thank you. next speaker, please. >> >> supervisors richie

residential builders association i've got good news you have hundred speakers about three or four hours just kidding and i came here. >> excuse me. it's been a long meeting can you please respect and allow each member of the public to speckle for their time please so we can get through this. >> supervisors i came and emigrated from ireland i make 7 bucks u bucks an hour we worked hard an, an carpenter up the ladder and became a general contractor now i do real estate development most are hispanic and irish people come from many places and the reason i know those states where they are in mexico i'm not sure is where my

guys come from any understand the brobz have a problem and the problem is evictions a major, major problem and a major part of our eviction problem is the tics most of us worked for a long, long time in eastern neighborhoods because we played by the rules and hopefully we respect the rules we're against evictions i comb or come from a country my ann cherries our population from 8 millions to 1949 we're against evictions is the moratorium were a solution unfortunately i don't know it is a solution it is we have to stop the textiles i know the supervisors have tried is it

let's put our heads together we're working with did you mayors task force to find a exclusion it is equitable and fair and that's very, very important i'm not here to speak against any supervisor. >> thank you, sir thank you. next speaker, please. >> (clapping.) supervisors i'm kevin the fourth-generation against the housing band first of all, it any other neighborhoods can decide to derail the projects that includes affordable housing unit it effects negatively impacts the community with middle-income workers that might spend their dollars 0 into the economy this explicit displace anyone it helps to affiliate the producer i'm in agreement with 93 the band raises prices the

mission is the hottest district for young tech workers and more equivocation. >> can you pause the speakers time. >> sir can you hold on for a second. >> can you pause his time. >> absolutely i want to say as many of the tech workers for every tech jobs 4.1 jobs are created and teachers and cooks you name it i want to wrap this up and want to say. >> excuse me. excuse me. excuse me. we have at the end of the public comment and i ask that in order for us to get to the public comment peddling period i'll ask the members of the public to allow each member in line the opportunity to speak without outbursts please. i'll wrap up i know that will

mandate the affordable housing unit and that's bad policy. >> thank you. >> thank you. next speaker, please. >> >> i'm redman alliance i'm a market rate developer not a popular occupation to voluntary here tonight that's life i came in san francisco in 84 a local immigrant i lived on 23rd and full name for a few years i worked on valencia street for 4 years valencia and 17 anybody that reminders valencia that was the time on valencia street it you opened a business it last day 6 months and went out of business there was nothing to keep them in business i moved and now live in bruno heights

any children went to school we wake up one morning a year to the sound of the drumdz from cardinal an brilliant and 24th street and go down to watch the car value we feel we contributed to what the nation has to offer and feel it a great neighborhood it is great to see the passions here tonight but the passion for what as happening absence a miss directed at market rate developers i firmly building if there's a a moratorium tomorrow morning it makes absolutely no difference to evictions to ellis act or the other social issues discussed those are issues that the city at large has to deal with and we as developers do our part when we do what is provided

are that under the planning code when we provide accident onsite and offsite affordable all the fees we have to pay i hope i vote against the moratorium. >> thank you sir thank you. >> thank you. next speaker please. >> next speaker. >> hello supervisors my name is ethically moore a san francisco native a daughter of immigrants a owner of a small development company it saddened me to see this as us and them. >> excuse me. excuse me. i'm not going to troornt disruption allow the members of the public to speak so we can move forward with this meeting people have

been patient we're here to listen to the members of the public of the public we could recess and not take a vote or allow the members to speak so we can move forward forward so the board can take a vote please i'm asking you nicely to please do this thank you. >> the includes the immigrants and working class and families we have people that love this city and want to city-state see it ethnic diversities we are saddened by the unfair evictions people can have different violation or visions there's a alignment stock of hours and an unlimited number of people that want to live here we can't

exclude the tech members accepting the reality of growth and dealing with is it not trickle down confirmation trickle down economics is based on the market the market can completely regulate itself and the san franciscans recognize that is noted realistic i don't speak for all developers the inclusionary affordable housing paid for by market rate developers is a necessary component to zeal with the reality of the affordable housing crisis moratorium is not a realistic way to direct the housing criticize and this means stopping the affordable housing. >> thank you. >> thank you. next speaker, please. >> good evening supervisors my name is jim i've lived and worked in san francisco since

1998 i currently run a small city-based electrical company i work mainly single-family homes and in three to four unit buildings most of the contracts come from smaller buildings their financing those themselves and don't have the bigger money i'm opposing the moratorium that puts on pressure those are the spokeswoman businesses in the last decade dealt with the eastern neighborhood followed up with a work session to now to stop the market rate housing will stop the invests and encompass that moratorium is changing the rile and something that was code compliant and followed all the

rules set by the eastern neighborhood now it non-compliant without hears and no notice when we talk about fairness and equality it proposal is not working in general we need a proposal that helped with housing for all income levels in housing creates more housing opportunity the idea that it displaces people is incorrect adding this moratorium will only add to the list of failed policies and effect the blue-collar worker it claims to protect thank you. >> thank you. next speaker, please. >> good evening supervisors i'm a samuel contractor and developer here 90 in san francisco i worked in a lot of buildings around the city

whether it is raping or putting in the foundations windows or doors a lot of them in the mission over the last 25 years i'm completely against any displacing anybody i don't feel it is right we're a smaller contractors company we financed our own promotions i think that changing the rules in this situation changing the rule of the game is not fair as when the rules are made up something creative could be done in the meantime but the fact of changing the rules i'm against it time. >> thank you. >> thank you. next speaker, please. >> you can speak at the podium

sir. >> thank you. thanks to all of you it has been a long night. >> excuse me. no signs allowed in the board can you please put our signage down at this time. >> i know that regardless. >> please. can you please remove our signs thank you just sit here and wait until iyou

do so.

>> thank you so can you continue, please. >> certainly i know that regardless of what does of the issue you're on that i'm speaking for everyone in the room we appreciate the venue to trademark our positions and thank you for listening partially i'm travis a long time resident of san francisco i was raised by a siren mom of meeftd needs in rental housing so i'm acutely aware on a perm

basis of the stories i've heard this evening and semiemphasis with the feeling and again, i'm speaking for everyone here we're looking forward for a solution i've work for the past 20 odd years with builders if a personal experience the vast majority of those men and women have built in san francisco for generations and decades ignore the entire city's history that the vast majority are also people of modest means and counting nails and borrowing against their homes and retirement to provide hours for the city's residents it any surprise people to know that, in

fact, many of the builders don't city projects the irony it costs so much to constrict in those towns to ask the vendors to build lower-income housing is not relevant i'm against the moratorium it restricts the ability of the thank you topanga for tax and finance for other needs in the housing development. >> thank you, sir. thank you. next speaker, please. >> hi, i'm born and raised in san francisco i work and live in this city and i think we all agree there is a housing shortage but i'm concerned about the moratorium condoning that crisis and marking the mraerts worse and what is currently available i come from a small family xuks an

immigrant family we do a lot of good work and important them or work in the city and a band on the mission essentially putting a band on all the contractor or contractors if you put a moratorium it is an impact a moratorium can capital improvement plan. >> can you pause the speakers time. >> excuse me. >> thank you. can you continue, please. >> sure a moratorium can cripple the low income emigrated builders i don't think stopping the construction is the right answer a more turn for 45 days will not prevent evictions and displacement that will prevent a

whole construction industry from going to work so moratorium will not help with affordability or displacement that's all i have to say. >> thank you. >> good evening supervisors tax thanks for being patient with the group you're dealing with i'm morris a san francisco resident for 28 years and member - >> excuse me. there's a member that is speaking can we please hear him speak thank you. >> i've been a san francisco resident for 28 years and member of the residential builders association been working in construction in san francisco in all neighborhoods and the mission especially the mission in the last 10 to 12 years in the 60s are 70s was amongst the

rich based in san francisco we too get moved on and i'm sure we have 10 thousand people a year moving to san francisco everything changes and time passes by i respect the views of the people that are here tonight that support of moratorium but i think it is not the fix in our situation i think the ellis act and displacement from tic is the basis of the hub there's a lot of the empty sites in the mission district and no one is being displaced not the way to move forward thank you, again, for this evening. >> thank you very much. >> thank you. next speaker, please. >> madam president and supervisors john with the residential brltdz first of all i'd like to say we're also opted to local evictions and if it is

true there is 40 percent of the admission for airbnb building something needs to be done with that it is very important i wag all the speakers we need to create for affordable housing but i disagree with the way to accomplish it and i think by placing a moratorium on in the mission area we're going to pit more pressure on the exist hours i'd like to reflect back a little bit on the eastern neighborhoods plan that was a property process that was took 10 years to put in place everybody got a chance to participate from the time the eir was introduced in april of 2008 to december of 2008 i can talk about the public hearings they were held in commission presentation was at ludicrously

on monday then land use committee was president 3 folks we had infrastructure analysis and financial feasibility analysis and this area plan was voted on by then supervisor ma gold rick and supervisors chris daily was not able to vote but supervisor mark at the end of the day, we need the project in the pipeline that followed the rules submitted their plans they need to be allowed to move forward we do need to build affordable housing - >> thank you very much. >> thank you. next speaker, please. >> good afternoon expirations or

commissioners i'm with the residential builder association i worked my way up the ladder since 19984 i you know we came out of a recession as builders and so went through a hard time some of us didn't make it threw we're back and following the rules to reiterate what happens in the eastern neighborhood they were done for 5 to 6 to seven years we're following the rules we don't of the you to change the rules in the middle of the game you can't do that when we went through extensive studies our we're not for evictions we just want to see our immigrants as itch as everybody else in this room have a place to stay in san francisco and have a pa

place to work >> thank you very much>> thank you. next speaker, please. >> (clapping.) >> all right. so my name is carmen a hoours activist a member of the democrat the harvey milk club lgbt democrat club i was here for the first leg of the hearing it was just impressed i heard it is of was city going on and so i'm expected to condense anyone but i want to say to borrow a concept from a friend we're in a crisis right now so what do you no idea a crisis you just stop and i feel like this moratorium is an ask of the brown and black

folks have to and the exultance that are being pushed out of san francisco take a pause and re-evaluate i'm tired and emotional it is not the best argument but asking the board what if not this let's take a pause and talk about housing in san francisco. >> thank you. next speaker. (clapping) and good evening thanks for hanging in david steiner beggar with benjamin a reasonable degree of medical probability i've bin design architect in san francisco for 35 years i've developed a lot of the multiplied unit around the city all cities change and neighborhoods change to study the history of any neighborhood in san francisco they chunk eastern neighborhoods as people

have said has vetted there was a great effort to do innertion in the transportation corridor and in exchange la large fees were paid to the city to help with all the aspects of the city so to paraphrase san francisco chronicle editorial in the 30th of may entitled no way to ease a how's crisis the halt everything plan is counter productive a short time solution in construction shall not displace the existing units that it may displace commercial new contradiction jaltsdz a minimum of 12 percent onsite or number two, fees for fees existing housing shall be higher priced

because of the pressure there's a number of solutions already in the pipeline mayor lee's 2 henry adams and $50 million for the 2 hundred units and tdr can generate as many as 50 units this moratorium is unfunded and not the right solution there are bug problems this is not the solution. >> next speaker if you're in line to speak again, you'll not be allowed the opportunity to speak and i disagree sprong with the moratorium but agree with most of the speakers we have a crisis and as a a how's leader and you

guys as elected officials you'll have us in position of leadership we have guilt on our hands raising rents, displacements evictions the anxiety you sense in this room is not just in this room it is in the just in the mission it is each one of our districts we have a problem energy, the passion here tonight it needs to be channeled we need to get groups and focus on raising more money more affordable housing do you guys realize the number of the cost of affordable housing there's nothing affordable about it anymore we need to focus on how mandatory development affordable housing fees from products in

the mission needs to stay in the we need to find creative was in the mission get to go to people in the mission we need new and creative ways to do more productive with our goals to produce offsite housing there's a new oifbt goal that protects the people in the community i didn't hear about the ellis acting we sniped a little bit on tics i didn't hear about changing the building code to make the standards of tic comparable to a condominium disincentivizing. >> thank you sir thank you (clapping.) i'm sorry but you've had an opportunity to speak. >> i haven't spoken. >> yes. you