he data unconvincing, however, a low bar to meet they to say they have families interested in enrolling in the school that's why we department of motor vehicles didn't have a great deal of conversations we will prevail. >> andtolysis no recourse should they show up show up with 60 kids come fall. >> that's for next year i'm talking about this year. >> there's a recourse to charge them the space for students they told us they'll have and i think correct me if i am wrong but p one they have to prove they required in district ada if not they'll owe the district additional fund their attendance

for period one. >> i want to follow that i i don't think they were able to prove at the time i've not seen anything that shows the new number and so i just don't feel like we have an obligation to offer them a space like they came after us last year annoyed me more i wanted to keep an eye on this and understand their enrollment looks like periodically and especially the start of the school year i'm not - it bugs me that's the route they took. >> commissioner walton and commissioner wynns. >> just a clarification question so if they- if we found

out they doesn't have sufficient enrollment are we able to remove them mid semester after the period or ride this thing out. >> right so the second we would look at excuse me. not look back but do a new analysis of the start of the second year and if they don't have the finish in the sufficient ada we'll have other opens but not remove students mid year and commissioner wynns. >> if i may just to be clarify that is precisely what happened a large correct we made them an offer using those what you kind of call low bar they told us to have exactly 80 students the nun

they required and they didn't we denied them the prop 39 this year we had a practice of them not meeting their obligation so - >> apparently, it worked. >> a clear we'll need to consider if clearly it only takes filing a writ this is what we're teaching people to behalf and do whatever they want. >> i'm going to play devils advocate as you recall they have a downtown prime location and moved to gloria right direction davis and many, many families abandoned the school i feel that that move hurt their enrollment

greatly and when i visited the school they did show commenting commitment to the neighborhood and showed how many students were recruited from the neighborhood when schools move there's always an impact sorry if i may respectfully dr. murase the purchase purpose of charter schools when they brought the chart schools first place they said by the way we're going to target underserved community and students noted successful in their system that's what they were supposed to do and render this downtown location and if you recall they came here and said i can't move but i us to gloria davis and i have an obligation to serve them i have

let's go sympathy for an organization they've lied to us twice at least and no evidence they're not doing it again so i understand and it is definitely not the first time we've been faced with this choice do something we think is wrong because it is alike likely it may cost us more those are hard things to swallow i appreciate commissioner mendosa-mcdonnell that he thought we were protecting ourselves so we clearly didn't figure out how to do that maybe we can do a better job in the future. >> superintendent and commissioner mendoza-mcdonnell.

>> yes. so commissioners we're in intently noting our concerns we have similar concerns it is important to understand though that the board a in the action that it took drew a clear line when it goes to the state we're limited in what we can do aside from presenting our case at the state level there are ramification at the local level so we hear the frustration loud and clear we're monitoring the enrollment but share in our frustration. >> commissioner mendosa-mcdonnell not only am i interested in the numbers by the demographics in a location that didn't serve the community in which they claim to be serving i want to keep an eye on that. >> i want to say one more

thing. >> wait a second. >> i want to raise a note of agreement with everything that the commissioners are saying so we had a lot of staff discussions along those lines and looked at it it and dubious mr. davis testified in front of the state board of education to talk about the represents he mentioned the elements and frankly took look at of heat and scolding from the members of the board we didn't take this lightly we tried to make you are case as well we could and that didn't prevail at the state

board and fundamentally it effected our positions we should take at this point. >> commissioner wynns. >> i actually had intended to go and testify but not able for some reason, i think there is an s b.a. we should consider that we ought to ourselves advocating what the state and the last thing i want to say someone south park is keeping the list of the legislative list i've brought this up and need to aggressively pursue prop 39 charts granted by the state because we may live in the most expensive city in the country

that makes it more difficult but other discussions u school districts are deal with that this is an impossible situation and no further discussion roll call vote. >> ms. fewer. >> yes. >> mr. haney ms. mendoza-mcdonnell. >> yes. except for flex academy. >> yes. >> ms. norton. >> i did not hear your vote i'm sorry. >> yes. >> mr. walton. >> ms. wynns except for flex. >> dr. murase. >> thank you

thank you very much that concludes this special order of business item m is discussion of other educational issues thankfully now and then none cds resolution removed at the previous meeting there are none item o vote on the consent calendar with the exception of one 56 on page 221 and on page 223 ms. casco roll call please. >> ms. fewer mr. haney ms. mendoza-mcdonnell ms. norton mr. walton ms. wynns dr. murase 7 i's. >> thank you very much and now under item p consent calendar resolution severed for board discussion and immediate action commissioner wynns

severed two items on page 221 and 223. >> if i may those are short i wanted to point out those are my continuing concern of large amounts of money on outdoor translation services we get an informative memo a few weeks ago from convene about the work that's being done that is good analytical work excuse me. about the relative costs for various things i want to say that i think we should continue to monitor this and particular i'm concerned when it says we have to hire outside translation services to provide us with spanish translation and chinese translation it is different i don't except us to have someone that can do russian or arabic

and low instance languages listed on the second page the second page is low incidents of arresting bic we saidabic we said a huge i have a problems are hire outdoor transparency for spanish and chinese. >> keeping in mind those translation services in spanish and chinese given the population of chinese and spanish speakers a limited number of transparence

later in house we understand that and that's part of the analysis that is but point well-taken. >> i don't know when i look at this i thought that the special interpretation is 70 percent at best by special education it is to technical our trans later may not be up on - >> if we're spending a lot of money on trans later but translations of the i p and others documents it is specialized in a major language like spanish we should have our

own technical specialists that can do those translations those that is the kind of issues. >> no further comment. >> ms. casco. >> ms. fewer mr. haney ms. mendoza-mcdonnell ms. norton mr. walton ms. wynns dr. murase 7 i's and superintendent proposes for first reading two items i need a motion and second for suspension of the rules to hear the first proposal at first reading on restriction to board bylaws and two closed session for the business and agenda and closed session for action and reports and second. >> thank you very much ms. casco roll call vote on

suspension of the rules. >> ms. fewer planning ms. mendoza-mcdonnell ms. norton mr. walton ms. wynns and dr. murase. >> 7 i's. >> we need a motion and second for the proposal itself. >> may i have a motion and second and mr. superintendent a december person to read. >> our general council to do the honors. >> so the first requested the bylaws 9321 and the other the

requested action the board of education the san francisco unified school district revised board bylaws 21 he .1 in the provided attached document. >> thank you. any questions or comments regarding that. >> seeing none roll call please. thank you. >> ms. fewer mr. haney mr. haney ms. mendoza-mcdonnell ms. norton mr. walton ms. wynns and dr. murase 7 i's. >> thank you very much we need a motion and second for suspension the rules to hear the next board policy business and non-structural operation for the district may i have a motion and second to suspend the rules

second. >> thank you very much roll call vote on suspension of the rules. >> ms. fewer mr. haney ms. mendoza-mcdonnell ms. norton mr. walton ms. wynns and dr. murase 7 i's and thank you very much i need a motion and second for the restriction to the board policy itself. >> so moved. >> thank you very much mr. superintendent a designee to sustain the action and madam president general council to do do honors the restriction to policy business and non-structural claims and actions against 9 district the board of education of the san francisco unified school district adopt board policy claims and actions against the district as provided in the attached document. >> thank you in public speakers any comments or questions from

my colleagues seeing none, miss ms. casco roll call. >> ms. fewer mraefrn ms. mendoza-mcdonnell plaintiff attorney mr. walton ms. wynns and dr. murase 7 i's. >> thank you very much we're on item r board proposals first reading none item s the board members outstanding committees or organization and all others questions we have already heard from the mr. haney from the report from the committee as a whole and let's see we heard a portion of the ground services commissioner mendoza-mcdonnell would like to rectify the additional discussion. >> we have interesting it possible items the first the update on the hunters point this is in the shipyard and the

quality before public sites are available we've been in discussion with the city and the office of investment & infrastructure to determine whether or not san francisco unified school district is interested in developing a site out that way and we had updates we're out a little bit by continue with the discussion the others was the summer bond a great presentation by staff members on all the construction through the bond initiative and some individual projects happening to the type of over $19 million and just exciting to see all the work happening over the summer the kids get to come back to a brand new school and commended the staff for the work and they're

anticipating summer to go smoothly and opening on time and on budget and the last a form park 2 hundred middle point park that has facilities around that ever used by cv o are the abandoned and it is quite an eye sore and mr. golden state golden gate an update if he wanted to tear down the site and consider more we're looking at $200,000 and commissioner walton and i will be getting a smaller team to start think about the investments in revitalizing that park in the process and likely to do fund-raising to engaging rec and park for the san

francisco unified. >> z i'm interested and would like to be part of any small group that you and commissioner walton are doing and my day job might be helpful. >> i was going to call you open that. >> very good all of the committees will be in recess in july thankfully and any other reports by my colleagues? seeing none, we'll move on to item t report of closed session items none u other informational items posted in the agenda are acceptance the gift for the may have month and clarified personal translations tonight colleagues i'd like to adjourn in memory the labor leader king

the farther of our dear friend and deluge mia short ecology a contrasting he died of natural causes he's the father of the carn listen born in fresno after serving in the army in world war ii worked with the looshl union and being one of the first african-americans to take care of in leadership and got married and the interracial comes up were forced to move 9 times ones their landlords find out that mr. king was black and his wife was white he helped with the housing development is opened in

the of him neighborhood n.y. to rosa parks elementary school that was a racially integrated foundation and he lived there from the time it opened to he died he's survived by two daughters and one son, 5 grandchildren and 9 grandchildren and his pga p is following his wife that died in 2000 i ask condolence to carolyn king and i believe chef vice president wants to say something >> yes. thank you i'd like tocy thank you on behalf of the family he was my uncle and his wife my uncle's sister so thank

you very much. >> we'll let carolyn know. >> meeting px

>> here we go. good afternoon aerobic wn. i would like to call this meeting to order. this is the reg yaerm scheduled meeting of #4r57bd use and transportation meeting. to the my left is kim and supervisor cohen [inaudible] our clerk is mrs. andro[inaudible] i also want to recognize jessie washington and