or in noah valley that have commercial buildings and the question is that appropriate is the are they appropriate we get more again thirty percent affordable housing we can debate over the level but to me that is not adding to gentrification or displacement that is helping by providing thirty percent affordable housing at times when the boards is debating 25 percent inclusion it is worth continuing the discussion and having for debate this has been constructive i haven't my left side of e-mails and public testimony the only developer that calls me was bridge housing an affordable housing developer that encouraged us to pass the program and again, this - continue the dialogue i support

of continuance. >> wow. i don't know if i want to sit through another one mr. welch he appreciate your beliefs he sat here and used the words economic he cleansing i residential design it when i think of ethnic cleansing i think of things when i saw people lined up and getting shot because of a different religion i get where how coming from it could go create pressure thank you for your thoughts i think ethic cleans was not something i would have used but appreciate what you brought to the discussion i go back to the december 3rd

hearing with supervisor wiener pr and we joked about it today he was saying basically it us dear completely do something do something stop continuing it i don't want a continuance why wait get it up to the language we voted, 3, 3. >> the land use got it to push it forward basically none of the things we've mentions i put myself back to tonight going you know, i think there are so many issues some of them political to be honest i'll pin the boards for this one for the protection of legal loss to be honest the staff has done an amazing job absolutely no questions asked

the work yonl i don't believe will not be lost but to get this thing over the line i'll pin the board with rental enforcement so the production production production talk and some protection protection protection is great but the legally loss short-term rentals i've been on the board i sat through the hearing the first hearing i was wheemgsed the 10 thousand vacant units what are we are doing to pin them into the market to i'm peg the boards coming up with a comprehensive solution to put this under the protection piece

so i'd like to get it to the board as fast as possible don't support a continuance. >> commissioner moore honestly the pile is high enough the discussions have been endless the department has given it the best and so has the public i think we've provided a phenomenal amount of data and phenomenal insight it is wide open i'm ready to let it move on to those who are in charge i'll prepared to let it go i have to say the saturday morning request request for continues was continuance was a - i've worked on this package two weeks ago hard and you're looking as if

you're raising your forehead we were asked in in a compassionate tone to consider the continuance this was not the rights time the work was done you've given me a huge pile of studies and my work was done so i'm prepared to support the continuance to support the to not support the continuance and move on and lets it go. >> commissioner antonini. >> we'll i'm in favor of the continuance it is absence unfair to groups in greater numbers not thoughts that was being continued because that was what a lot of people called me i said it will get continued and after the commissioners came up come

up what a laundry list there are a lot of things to make that legislation and we should do that here set the tone for the supervisors the supervisors tend to be more political then than we can and look at this and try tee build something that could you mean they'll make the decisions but we're sort of passing it to them with unfinished parts as the speakers awe tests it is a good piece of legislation i want to see more communicated meetings and by april make great strides and in april that will be even more and a lot nor supports i'm voting in favor of the continuance. >> commissioner vice president richards i want to remind everybody we

forwarded the list he did that tonight staff i know between now and the time the boards picks up we'll a work on the list and down 0 on paper i look at between now and april another 2 thousand residents move into san francisco that we don't have homes for i hear that when i go to sleep it is kaikz issues i want the boards to act on that. >> commissioner hillis. >> i mean, i'm supportive of the continuance the fact it came saturday not been shy to continue the items commissioner moore by any stretch is i don't think so it as problem but a

disservice to the public that we've not talked about and o that i understand think short-term rentals what we did was glow the list i'm happy to do that and lands think remedies of what we want to do so i don't think it is doing justice to the people that came out and talked about add you be to us and when you look at the videos that are hundreds of them they punts open that's not my duties i'm pointed out to make good policy it is a cop-out so you know i'm willing to go quickly and scheduled to an earlier meeting and agree to disagree but not giving a good debates not comfortable of

moving and commissioner antonini. >> this is something i do this is actually a relief when you know that okay your familiar with everything has it stands now and knowing a week ago it will be modified and will be another date to make your decision is a relief so, i mean we worked under the circumstances by not continuing it i probably would have you know been a little bit more forceful about the clanks i was suggesting changes to the staff i want to see a product that we hopefully, will agree on owe forwards it to the boards in that way i'm voting for the continuance it could be sooner but not make a decision tonight. >> commissioner vice president richards that i have i guess staff you've done work and answered all the questions

online i got the answers and maps and things put together and comments >> just to be clear to cleaver the language we felt we have been having an sledder pace of community meetings we forwarded these we knew a lot of things for maybe continue to a donates when we can digest so we can do something in 3 week. >> if we push this to the board you feel confront you know what the issues are

i don't know it is the same as having for dialogue if we'll come back with responses but that's up to you we can come back sooner april 7th if that makes a difference and director rahaim i was going to do say what bill said in front of is a number of issues you've raised a number of issues that the communities has raised it would be our normal practice to not when there are those many issues not to move forward so see the next phase of work this is normally what you'll do nicole certainly take our issues to the board but normally you'll want to see the issues reluctance. >> commissioner antonini. >> i could move for probably

three weeks will be february 18th if i'm calendaring that. >> the 18 a cancelled hearing unless you time to reissue it. >> probably a lot of commissioners let's going to the next week february 25th okay. >> i think that will be as quick as we can do it hearing what staff says next week is the fourth i'll change my motion about the seconder to february 25th for final action. >> yeah. i'll second. >> commissioners, if there's nothing further shall i call the question? on the motion to continue. >> sorry i'd like to make a request in that week we'll take

an action and make recommendations to the full board we kind of go through 0 those issues like rent control and small business and lot mergers and ami kwha where the supplies and cu approval or not and you know make recommendations like we did did during the airbnb debate and forward it i'd like to see more communities we've heard a lot of people not able to digest their questions i'm not sure that three weeks gives us the ability to side that level of communities engagements i'd like to see that we'll see where we are in three weeks but more diagonal. >> commissioner wu. >> so i i do want to read this list we can talk about them tonight or not so the way we

calculate the will the mergers out loud and not allowed rent-controlled unit or no demolition and 3 small business with the focus an legacy business and is 4 it is decision making 5 is something i'll call liveability guidelines and 6 the density equality and 7 is how this program adjusts inclusion go baseline changes and the ccii process and 10 exemption to the program. >> could you share that with staff later. >> thank you ask commissioner wu for clarification i think that the program of - applies but some areas are dense

so it impactss areas definitely commissioner vice president richards. >> i'm looking forward to get to the finish line action on the 25 when we do this next. >> commissioner antonini and i'd like to add it a have good list by commissioner wu the other thing the displacement of business interests in buildings where they might take advantage of the sites i brought up the right of first refusal and i'd like to see if staff works that that was one of the biggest concerns and the realistic concerns brought up by the speakers. >> if i can take the opportunities to talk about commissioner wu thank you for listing those if mean we'll act on all of them selectly but